Professional Documents
Culture Documents
All Fire Detectors Application Guideline
All Fire Detectors Application Guideline
All Fire Detectors Application Guideline
Application guideline
Building Technologies
CPS Fire Safety
Liefermöglichkeiten und technische Änderungen vorbehalten.
Data and design subject to change without notice. / Supply subject to availability.
Sous réserve de modifications techniques et de la disponibilité.
© 2017 Copyright by
Siemens Switzerland Ltd
Wir behalten uns alle Rechte an diesem Dokument und an dem in ihm dargestellten Gegenstand vor. Der Empfänger anerkennt diese
Rechte und wird dieses Dokument nicht ohne unsere vorgängige schriftliche Ermächtigung ganz oder teilweise Dritten zugänglich machen
oder außerhalb des Zweckes verwenden, zu dem es ihm übergeben worden ist.
We reserve all rights in this document and in the subject thereof. By acceptance of the document the recipient acknowledges these rights
and undertakes not to publish the document nor the subject thereof in full or in part, nor to make them available to any third party without our
prior express written authorization, nor to use it for any purpose other than for which it was delivered to him.
Nous nous réservons tous les droits sur ce document, ainsi que sur l'objet y figurant. La partie recevant ce document reconnaît ces droits et
elle s'engage à ne pas le rendre accessible à des tiers, même partiellement, sans notre autorisation écrite préalable et à ne pas l'employer
à des fins autres que celles pour lesquelles il lui a été remis.
1 Introduction..........................................................................................5
2 General .................................................................................................6
2.1 Fire detection systems ...........................................................................6
2.2 Consider national directives and regulations ..........................................6
8 Appendix ............................................................................................ 35
8.1 Basics ................................................................................................. 35
8.1.1 General ............................................................................................... 35
8.1.2 Propagation of the fire phenomena ...................................................... 35
8.1.3 Optical smoke detector sensitivity ........................................................ 36
8.2 Arrangement of point smoke detectors ................................................. 40
8.2.1 Placement ........................................................................................... 40
8.2.2 Coverage area ..................................................................................... 40
8.3 Arrangement of point heat detectors .................................................... 41
8.3.1 Placement ........................................................................................... 41
8.3.2 Coverage area ..................................................................................... 41
8.4 Arrangement of Linear smoke detectors............................................... 42
8.4.1 Placement ........................................................................................... 42
8.5 Arrangement of flame detectors ........................................................... 43
8.6 European standard EN54..................................................................... 44
8.6.1 General ............................................................................................... 44
8.6.2 Test fires per EN54 .............................................................................. 44
8.6.3 Heat detectors and EN54-5.................................................................. 45
8.6.4 Smoke detectors and EN54-7 .............................................................. 45
8.6.5 Flame detectors and EN54-10 ............................................................. 46
8.6.6 Linear smoke detectors and EN54-12 .................................................. 46
8.6.7 Aspirating smoke detectors and EN54-20 ............................................ 46
1 Introduction
Cerberus PRO allows you to build highly technical, risk-adjusted fire detection
installations that nevertheless protect against false alarms. This application
guideline is intended to assist you in selecting the suitable fire detector and to
select the proper settings.
The recommendations described in this document are based on more than a half
century of global experience in building fire detection installations as well as a deep
knowledge of Cerberus PRO fire detectors. It is important to pay attention to
ambient conditions such as room sizes, deceptive phenomena or air exchange:
You select the fire detectors, assign and configure them accordingly. For special
projects, the selection and settings for the fire detectors are only possible after
conducting tests. A general guideline for all possible applications is simply not
possible.
We need your help to ensure that this guideline is kept up-to-date with the latest
findings and experiences. We therefore request that you let us know about your
experiences (both positive and negative) using Cerberus PRO fire detectors for
system engineering.
Contact address: Siemens Schweiz Ltd.
Building Technologies Division
International Headquarters
CPS Fire Safety
CH-6301 Zug
2 General
2.1 Fire detection systems
Cerberus PRO fire detectors allow you to engineer an installation that reliably
detects a fire during the initial phase, while also providing one-of-a-kind immunity
against interference.
Experience indicates that forces intervening seldom are alarmed too late to a real
fire, but rather in many cases, the fire department is required to unnecessarily
deploy in response to deception of the automated detectors, improper system
operation, mischief, technical failures, etc. This fact must be considered carefully
when selecting and setting the detector.
Operating modes:
The OOH740 can be easily adapted to changing conditions thanks for selectable
modes.
· Mode 0 (OOH): Neural fire detector with homogenous response behavior to all
types of fires
· Mode 1 (H): Heat detector to detect open fires
· Mode 2 (OO): Optical smoke detector with homogenous response behavior
to light and dark aerosols
Operating modes:
Same as the OOH740, the OOHC740 can be used as a neural fire detector, as a
heat detector or as an optical smoke detector (Mode 0, 1 or 2).
Parameter set
Algorithms
Danger level
Diagnostic level
Default values
Calculation and
Detector Sensor signals Signal splitting comparison Result
with default
values
The sensor acquires the fire phenomena, breaks it down into mathematic compo-
nents and sends it to the programmed algorithms. Neural fire detectors further
analyze smoke and heat signals and undertake to weigh the information accor-
dingly. You can influence the algorithms by selecting the DA parameter set and in
this manner set the detectors to anticipated fire phenomena and environmental
influences.
10
3.5.2 ASAtechnology
ASAtechnologyä (ASA = Advanced Signal Analysis) represents the continued
development of algorithm technology developed by Siemens.
Algorithms
Danger level
Diagnostic level
Default values
Calculation and
Detector Sensor signals Signal splitting comparison with Result
default values
The sensor acquires the fire phenomena, breaks it down into mathematic compo-
nents and sends it to the programmed algorithms. Neural fire detectors further
analyze smoke and heat signals and undertake to weigh the information accor-
dingly. You can influence the algorithms by selecting the ASA parameter set and in
this manner set the detectors to anticipated fire phenomena and environmental
influen-ces. In contrast to the detection algorithms, selected parameters are not
fixed using ASAtechnology. Real-time interpretation of the situation has a dynamic
impact on the selected ASA parameter set. This results in an adjustment to the
optimum effective range of the detector allowing it to be more sensitive to fires, yet
more robust against deception. We achieve in this manner a unique degree of
detection reliability while maintaining a very high immunity to deception.
11
12
l Response time: Minimum time required by the detector to alarm, even when the smoke
concentration is well beyond the value required for alarming. For the neuronal fire
detectors, this time can vary strongly up or down depending on dynamic influence.
This time will be reduced for the multi-criteria and the neuronal fire detectors,
depending on the temperature rise at the detector position.
l S-fire: Minimum smoke concentration (signal of forward scatter) is required to trigger an
alarm of a smoldering fire (see in chapter 8.1.3).
This value will be lower for the multi-criteria and the neuronal fire detectors,
depending on the temperature rise at the detector position.
l O-fire: Minimum smoke concentration (signal of forward scatter) is required to trigger an
alarm of an open fire (see in chapter 8.1.3).
This value will be lower for the multi-criteria and the neuronal fire detectors,
depending on the temperature rise at the detector position.
l Min: Alarm only possible after reaching this temperature.
l Max: An alarm is triggered when this temperature is breached, no matter how strong the
temperature rise.
l Diff: An alarm is triggered when this temperature increase and the Min are breached.
In case of low temperature increase between 1 K/min and 10 K/min, this value
increases by a few degrees (detector compensates 1K/min.)
13
l Response threshold: Reduction of the signal (gla) compared to compensation value (NFW) to trigger
an alarm. Without smoke, signal (gla) and compensation (NFW) are about the
same size (signal gla 100% compensation NFW).
Comment:
Sensitivity for linear smoke detectors is highly dependent on the distance from
detector to reflector as the light obscuration is established over these lengths. At
an equal smoke distribution in a room, an FDL241 at a detection distance of 20 m
and a parameter set "Very sensitive with open line" is identical to an FDL241 with a
detection distance of 43 m and the parameter set "Standard with open line"
(20/30x65 = 43).
3 Universal fast normal 2–3 medium Fast alarming for medium sized fire
5 Sensitive fast sensitive 2–3 medium Fast alarming for small fire
7 Motor test bed sensitive 7 – 13 hot bodies Extremely robust against radiation from hot bodies
2
l Sensitivity: At a normal sensitivity, the FDF, for example, detects a 0.5m large ethyl
alcohol fire up to a distance of 19 meters. This type of fire can be
detected at a distance of up to 38 meters with a more sensitive setting.
l Response time: Time that the detector "analyzes" the fire before triggering an alarm.
l Deception resistance: Resistance to deceptions such as hot bodies, sunlight or electric arcs.
14
Comment:
The values given in the table represents the sensitivity measured in the smoke
channel. More detail information regarding the sensitivities can be found in chapter
8.1.3.
15
In addition to these criteria, you should also consider existing risk, desired flexibility
and costs.
16
17
4.4.4 Dirt
Dirt such as flying strands or dust particles within textile production or the smallest
particles at a coal-fired power plant impact the reliability of fire detectors. At best
this results in shortened maintenance intervals; at worst, your fire detection
installation may no longer operate reliably. You must always take a dirty
environment into consideration when selecting the fire detector.
Often, operators forgo point type smoke detectors in such environments in favor of
closed detectors (flame detectors or linear smoke detectors) only. ASD systems
with automated flushing are also suitable for some of these applications.
4.4.5 Humidity
Fire detectors selected for use in humid or even wet environments must have the
necessary IP protective class (IP = International Protection). If the planned point
detector does not have the protective class required for this room, you may have to
check whether an appropriate supplemental base can achieve the results you
need.
18
19
20
These types of areas do not have an increased risk. No large deceptive phenol-
me-na occur and ambient conditions are non-critical and relatively constant.
Furthermore, if there is no pending change in use in the rooms, the performance
of the OP720 and the OH720 are sufficient for such rooms up to a ceiling height
of 7 m.
21
Parameter sets
for standard applications
2 / Sensitive
2 / Sensitive
1 / Standard
1 / Robust
Ambient conditions Room height
< 2,5 m
No deceptive phenomena exists
- Clean environment > 2,5 m
- No smoking > 5,0 m
- No vapor development
> 7,5 m
< 2,5 m
Minimum deceptive phenomena exists
- Smoking allowed > 2,5 m
- Low vapor development possible > 5,0 m
- Low process-related dust development
> 7,5 m
22
In these types of areas there is an increased, or to some extent, even high risk to
life and limb or assets. Fast alarming of incipient fires while simultaneously avoi-
ding false alarms is required.
23
11 Super Sensitive
9 / High Sens. Fast
6 / Fast Response
Detectors and parameter set
Parameter sets
for applications
4 / Balanced
2 / Sensitive
1 / Standard
with increased risk
2 / Robust
Room
Use / Application
height
Hospital rooms / high risk to life and limb
- Not or only partially able to save selves -
- No deceptive phenomena
< 5,0 m
Event room / increased risk to life and limb
- Able to save selves > 5,0 m
- Deceptive phenomena
> 7,5 m
< 2,5 m
Museum / high asset risk
- Able to save selves > 2,5 m
- No deceptive phenomena
> 5,0 m
Computer room / high damage from loss of data –
high "asset risk"
-
- Able to save selves
- No deceptive phenomena
< 2,5 m
Storage of highly flammable materials / increased
> 2,5 m
fire risk
- Able to save selves without problem > 5,0 m
- Low deceptive phenomena
> 7,5 m
Production hall for electronic components / high
costs from interruption to operations
-
- Able to save selves without problem
- No deceptive phenomena
l well suited suited
Tab. 6 Detectors and setting for applications with increased risk
24
There is little room to maneuver when selecting suitable point detectors for areas
with large and extreme deceptive phenomena. If the intent is to prevent the risk of
false alarms, you must use the detector with the highest immunity against
deceptions – the OOH740 with ASAtechnologyä and the specially developed
parameter sets. And if the OOH740 may result in false alarms, select the HI720.
The maximum occurring temperature is decisive for selecting the parameter set.
The OOH740 fire detector allow for time or process-controlled changeover of
parameter sets. The parameter sets recommended in the table below refer to
settings where deceptions occur. At other times, the detectors may be operated at
a more sensitive parameter set.
25
/ Hihg Suppression
Detector and parameter set
5 / Suppression
for applications
Parameter sets
with large deceptive phenomena
4 / Balanced
2 / Robust
2 / A2R
1 / A2S
1)
8
Use / Application Room
height
< 2,5 m
Production areas with smoke development > 2,5 m
- Able to save selves without problem
- Large deceptive phenomena > 5,0 m
> 7,5 m
< 2,5 m
Large kitchens with massive vapor development
- Able to save selves > 2,5 m
- Large deceptive phenomena
> 5,0 m
< 2,5 m
Event rooms with fog machine > 2,5 m
- Able to save selves
- Large to extreme deceptive phenomena > 5,0 m
> 7,5 m
< 2,5 m
Recycling plants with lots of dust emissions > 2,5 m
- Able to save selves without problem
- Large deceptive phenomena > 5,0 m
> 7,5 m
1)
Parameter set 8 does not meet EN54-7! l well suited suited
Tab. 7 Detectors and settings for applications with large deceptive phenomena
Comment:
Under very special circumstances, additional measures may be required such as
protecting against deceptive phenomena using diaphragms or establishing multi-
detector zones.
In most cases, it may be better to consider using special detectors for difficult
applications, detectors that have higher immunity to deceptions or whether a
combination of point and special detectors provides the best possible solution.
26
27
28
Comment:
In the event that a linear smoke detector requires response behavior comparable
to a smoke detector with a response sensitivity of 1.6%/m, select, on the FDL241
under the conditions:
– that the smoke is distributed evenly within the room under the ceiling and
– the distance between the detector and reflector is 20 meters
the parameter set 1 or 2 (1.6 x 2 x 20 = 64). Parameter set 5 or 6 achieve
sensitivity comparable to point detectors of 0.75%/m.
The example illustrates how linear smoke detectors react with greater sensitivity
than most point detectors even at a medium distance. However, this also means
that linear smoke detectors are generally more susceptible to deceptions such as
smoke, vapors or dust. You must consider this when selecting and setting the fire
detector.
Chemical production facilities, oil refineries, gas storage facilities, pumping stations
or battery rooms are also typical applications for the use of flame detectors.
However, for such applications, only one flame detector in one design is employed
in areas at risk of explosions.
29
30
31
32
Setting:
Note the following when determining required sensitivity:
– When a fire occurs in a room, the smoke rising from the thermals are acquired
by the extract air openings and led to the smoke detector via the piping system.
– The ASD system provides an alarm as soon as the average smoke
concentration from all the extract air opening exceeds the alarm threshold in the
employed detector.
– It does not matter whether this value is achieved by very high smoke
concentration at one extract air opening or by lower smoke concentration at
multiple extract air openings.
If the fire is to be detected as early as possible, the ASD system must trigger the
alarm as soon as the smoke is located at one extract air point. Such systems
normally require a very high ASD sensitivity.
For room monitoring one often accepts alarming, when the smoke spread is
already so large that the smoke is extracted from more than one extract air point. If
the smoke reaches two or three extract air points, the ASD will detect double or
even triple the amount of smoke. This effect is called the collection effect or smoke
accumulation. You can select an ASD with lower sensitivity when alarming at a
greater smoke spread is acceptable.
The required ASD sensitivity is calculated based on the following formula:
SDP
SARM = x NDPS
NDP
33
Comment:
If the parameter set 1 or 7 is selected, the 'Technical CO Alarm' is triggered,
provided that the required CO concentration is exceeded over a predefined period
of time.
With the parameter set 1, the 'Technical CO Alarm' is triggered, if:
– the CO concentration exceeds 33ppm for more than 120 min.;
– the CO concentration exceeds 55ppm for more than 90 min
– etc.
With the parameter sets 4, 5, and 6, a 'Technical CO Alarm' is triggered as soon as
the respective CO concentration is exceeded.
7.3 Positioning
The density of carbon monoxide is comparable to that of air (1.25 kg/m 3 vs. 1.29
3
kg/m ). For this reason, carbon monoxide is equally distributed in the room at
constant ambient temperature.
If the OOHC740 shall be primarily used to detect the CO concentration in the event
of a fire, the detector must be positioned like a smoke detector, as the CO rises to
the ceiling together with the fire aerosols when sufficient heat is generated.
If the OOHC740 shall be primarily used to monitor CO concentrations (e.g. leaka-
ges in gas cylinders or an excess gas concentration in heating facilities), wall
mounting (at head level) is preferably recommended.
34
8 Appendix
8.1 Basics
8.1.1 General
The rule that fire phenomena (smoke, heat, radiation, gas) must reach the
detectors applies as well to the Cerberus PRO system. Fire phenomena generated
by a fire propagate in different ways. You must consider this when engineering and
building fire detection installation. Accordingly, the arrangement and number of
required detectors (or the coverage area per detector) is largely determined by the
propagation characteristics of the corresponding fire phenomena.
COMPLY WITH The number and placement of fire detectors is often proscribed by
DIRECTIVES! domestic directives. They must have priority under all circumstances.
Heat
(convection)
Smoke
Room height h1
Radiation
Fire seat
35
Heat
The rising hot air flow from an open fire quickly cools off as the distance increases.
As a result, the use of heat detectors are subject to tight limits as the height of a
room increases.
Radiation
Although radiation energy reduces quadratically to the distance from the location of
the fire to the detector, flame detectors can still be used in very high rooms thanks
to their high response sensitivity.
36
In a fire (or test fire) this moment can vary significantly for different smoke detec-
tors with the same nominal sensitivity. The aerosols generated by the fire, the
detection principle, how the smoke particles enter the measurement chamber and
the signal processing itself can all play a significant role in this variation.
FDL241 sensitivity
The linear smoke detector FDL241 and the extinction meter, both utilize the light
absorption principle. This implies that the FDL241 should theoretically have the
same response behavior (sensitivity) as the extinction meter. In practice however,
this is not the case as smoke does not spread out uniformly in a room and each
system measures the average smoke concentration over different distances.
37
r=3m
Extinction meter
FDL241
Fig. 4 Smoke dispersion and device positioning in an EN54 fire test room
If we compare the sensitivity of the FDL241 with that of an extinction meter in an
EN54 fire test room, then we see the following:
· The FDL241 with a response threshold of -65 % triggers an alarm at an average
smoke concentration of 3 %/m (65 / 2x11).
· At the same moment, the extinction meter (mounted at a radius of 3 m) indicates
approx.7 %/m.
· The results show that (in this particular) configuration, there is a factor of 2.3 between
the average smoke concentration measured by the extinction meter and that
measured by the FDL241. This result is valid for both a smoldering fire and an open
fire (same measurement principle for both devices).
Moving either the extinction meter or the FDL to a different position in the room would
automatically change this factor, according to the average smoke concentration in the
corresponding areas.
FDA221/241 sensitivity
The extinction meter utilizes the principle of light absorption, whereas the
aspirating smoke detectors FDA221 and FDA241 are based on the light scattering
principle with two different light sources (infra-red and blue). To be able to compare
the sensitivity of an FDA device with that of an extinction meter, not only the
aerosol type, but also the transportation time and the dilution (produced by the
system itself) must be taken into account.
38
The following comparison between the extinction meter (reference) and the FDA is
based on tests carried out in a smoke channel (calibration) and in an EN54 fire test
room.
The FDA figures shown below reflect the corrected values (for the corresponding
transportation time and dilution), at the moment the extinction meter displays a
value of 1 %/m.
Aerosol / Environment Ratio bl/ir Extinction meter FDA
Paraffin / Smoke channel ca. 2 1.0 %/m 1.0 %/m
TF2a / EN54 test room ca. 2 1.0 %/m 1.0 %/m
TF5a / EN54 test room ca. 3 1.0 %/m 0.3 %/m
Tab. 12 Light obscuration module (@ 1 %/m, measured by the extinction meter)
The table shows the following:
· The FDA and the extinction meter exhibit the same sensitivity in the smoke channel
(the detector is aligned accordingly in the smoke channel)
· For a smoldering fire (FT2a), where the aerosols are similar to those present in the
smoke channel (ratio of bl/ir 2) the FDA and the extinction meter demonstrate
comparable sensitivities.
· For an open fire (TF5a) the extinction meter is considerably more sensitive than the
FDA system (by a factor of approx. 3).
Summary
The sensitivities of various optical smoke detectors can only be compared with one
another in a very limited manner and then only under consideration of a number of
different factors.
Table 15 provides a general summary, showing the sensitivities of the various fire
detector types in comparison with the extinction meter (factor 2 implies half as
sensitive).
39
Room height
Area 1 with minor hazard potential should only be selected when the following
conditions are fulfilled:
– any danger to human life can be ruled out
– neither valuable property nor irreplaceable goods are stored in the area
– the fire risk is very low
– other fire protecting measures prevent possible fire propagation
– no hazard can be caused in adjacent areas, for example by corrosive
decomposition products
40
41
Detectors Reflectors
42
a d=aÖ3
45°
a
a
45°
43
44
Detectors from class index S are particularly well suited for applications with high
rate of temperature rise over longer periods of time, e.g. in boiler rooms or
kitchens. Class index R detectors are suited for use in unheated buildings where
the ambient temperature can vary strongly, high rate of rise, but only for short
periods.
Cerberus heat detectors fulfill standard EN54-5 for the following classes based on
the selected parameter set:
45
46
47