Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Emotional Blackmail
Emotional Blackmail
When in a dysfunctional cycle of emotional blackmail, the victim may be inclined to:
apologize, plead, change plans to meet the others’ needs, cry, use logic, give in, or challenge.
Typically, they will find it difficult to stand up for themselves, directly address the issue, set
boundaries, and communicate with the blackmailer that the behavior is inappropriate. They
do not consistently set clear boundaries indicating what is acceptable for them.
Forward and Frazier recognize four types of blackmailing, each with varying manipulation
tactics.
1. Punishers – Punishers operate with a need to get their way, regardless of the feelings or
needs of the other person. Their motto is “my way or the highway.” Punishers will insist
upon pushing for control and getting what they want with threats to inflict damage or
harm.
2. Self-punishers – Individuals can make threats of self-harm if the partner does not comply
with what they want.
3. Sufferers – this is the voice of a victim conveying guilt on the partner if they do not do
what is demanded. If they don’t comply, there is a suggestion that their suffering will be
the others’ fault. “After all that I’ve done for you, you are going to let me suffer…?”
4. Tantalizers – This can be the most subtle and confusing form of manipulation. There is a
promise of what will be better if they comply. It sparks hope yet is still connecting a
threat to the demand.
In some situations, there may seem to be a fine line between indirect communication
and manipulation. Emotional blackmail and indirect communication can both have passive
aggressive undertones. The communication becomes manipulation and blackmail when it is
used consistently to control another individual or coerce them into doing what the requestor
demands. The victim will typically feel resistance to comply, yet does it even at the cost of
their own well-being.
There is also a distinction between setting healthy boundaries and emotional blackmail.
In setting boundaries, the individual is asserting themselves and communicating what their
needs are. Emotional blackmail involves conveying threats that will result in a punishment of
the victim does not meet the request.
Someone engaging in emotional blackmail will demonstrate any or all of the following:
Telling you that you are crazy for questioning them
Controlling what you do
Ignoring your concerns and pushback
Avoiding taking accountability
Constantly placing blame on others for their behaviors
Providing empty apologies
Using fear, obligation, threats, and guilt to get their way
Unwilling to compromise
Seemingly unconcerned about your needs
Rationalizing their unreasonable behaviors and requests
Intimidate you until you do what they want
Blame you for something that you didn’t do so that you feel you have to earn their
affection
Accuse you of doing something you didn’t do
Threaten to harm either you or themselves
The Victim
Victims of emotional blackmail typically feel insecure, unvalued, and unworthy. They often
struggle with low self-esteem and doubt their own needs. Victims can demonstrate the
following characteristics:
Approval seeking, people pleasing
Extreme compassion and empathy
Tendency to take blame
Tendency to feel pity for others
Try to avoid conflict
Peacekeeping habits
Strong sense of responsibility and doing the “right thing”
Fears of abandonment
Sensitivity, inclination to personalize things Fear of anger
Self-doubt, low self-esteem
The Impact
The stress of being in a relationship involving emotional blackmail can take a toll emotionally
and physically on the victim. It compromises the victim’s sense of integrity and self-esteem.
It causes victims to question their own sense of reality. It leads to negative and distorted
thinking about themselves and their relationship. Victims of emotional blackmail often end
up being isolated, experiencing extreme loneliness. It impacts an overall sense of well-being
and contributes to anxiety and depression.
The Blackmailer
Forward notes in the book that an important takeaway for the victim is that the
behavior of an emotional blackmailer feels like it is about you but for the most part it is not.
It often comes from deep insecurities inside of the blackmailer. Fear and anxiety can come
out as rage and blame toward the victim. These tendencies often have to do with what has
happened in the past rather than the reality of the current situation.
There is no exact prototype of emotional blackmailers, yet they can demonstrate the
following characteristics:
Narcissistic tendencies
Self-centered
Intense anger
Deep panic, fear, depression, or rage
Fear of abandonment
Emotionally immature
Not in touch with feelings
Lack of accountability
Hate to lose
Some of these traits may be close to the surface and observable, such as anger.
However, much of the insecurities, emotional pain and fears lie deep within the
psychological makeup of the blackmailer.
The scientific research on emotional blackmail, in particular, is limited. In one public
health study, researchers explored personality correlates of emotional blackmail in
relationships (Mazur et. al).
They utilized the five-factor personality model to assess risk factors for potential victims
and individuals at risk for engaging in emotional blackmail. They discovered that neuroticism
and agreeableness were risk factors for taking on the role of the victim. The factors
protecting against the use of emotional blackmail in close relationships were agreeableness
and conscientiousness.
Neuroticism is a key risk factor for taking on the perpetrator of emotional blackmail.
Social adaptation and assertiveness can act as protective factors against being a victim of
emotional blackmail. Data was gathered to inform preventive programs developed to
support people in building healthy relationships. There is room for additional research to be
gathered and leveraged to help with prevention of emotional abuse and blackmail.
Emotional blackmailers commonly attempt to make the victim feel responsible for
their (negative) actions.
It was your fault that I was late for work.
If you wouldn’t cook in an unhealthy way, I wouldn’t be overweight.
I would have gotten ahead in my career if you had done more at home.
Emotional blackmail may also occur in situations where one person is an addict. They
may threaten to take the car if the victim does not pick them up from the bar.
Emotional blackmail can take place in family relationships as well. A needy mother may
attempt to give her child a guilt trip for not spending enough time with her. She may make
comments referencing what “good daughters” do.
Emotional blackmail can occur in friendships. A friend may ask for money and threaten
to end the friendship if they do not comply.
A punishing type of blackmail can occur. For example, if a couple is going through a
difficult divorce, the emotional blackmailer may threaten that if their partner files for
divorce, they will keep the money or never let them see the kids. Such behavior can leave
the victim feeling rage at the attempt of being controlled and not knowing how to properly
respond.
Another type of emotional blackmail that is even more insidious is when we use fear,
obligation, and guilt to hold ourselves hostage. We can inflict our own FOG which can control
our behavior, even if it is not coming from external sources. “If I were a good son, I would
visit my mother more frequently.”
There can be different levels of emotional blackmail, ranging from threats with little
consequence to threats that can impact major life decisions or can be dangerous.
Here are some additional brief and damaging examples of threats associated with
emotional blackmail:
If you don’t take care of me, I’ll wind up in the hospital/on the street/unable to
work.
You’ll never see your kids again.
I’ll make you suffer.
You’ll destroy this family.
You’re not my child anymore.
You’ll be sorry.
I’m cutting you out of my will.
I’ll get sick.
I can’t make it without you.
In Forward’s book, there is a chapter called “It Takes Two.” She encourages
the victims of emotional blackmail to take responsibility for their behavior and
their previous compliance with the blackmail process.
The blackmail process does not work effectively without both parties actively
participating. Forward offers this perspective not as a way for victims to beat
themselves up or to place blame. Rather, she provides this point of view as an
empowering approach for victims to recognize what they can change and can
control. In the introduction, she states:
“Change is the scariest word in the English language. No one likes it, almost
everyone is terrified of it, and most people, including me, will become exquisitely
creative to avoid it. Our actions may be making us miserable, but the idea of doing
anything differently is worse. Yet if there’s one thing I know with absolute
certainty, both personally and professionally, it is this: Nothing will change in our
lives until we change our own behavior.”
In order to best handle emotional blackmail, the victim must bring a new
mindset and approach the situation in a different way. This will require gaining
insight into what is going on in the blackmail dynamics and learning to detach from
their intense emotions.
It can be useful for victims to explore what demands are making them feel
uncomfortable. In doing so, they can recognize what boundaries need to be put in
place. They must decide what is ok and not ok with them in a relationship.
Understanding the abusive impact of emotional blackmail is also important.
Appreciating how emotional abuse wears victims down can validate their
experience of feeling hopeless and lacking in confidence.
Change is scary, but doing something different is the only way to get a
different result. Otherwise, victims are at risk of letting their fears run and
potentially ruin their lives. Awareness, insight, and educating ourselves is
important, but change only comes from taking a course of different actions over a
prolonged period of time. Susan Forward asserts that we all have choices about
how to engage in a relationship:
We can accept things as they are.
We can negotiate for a healthier relationship.
Or, we can end the relationship.
contract
A contract lists a number of promises you would make to yourself. The
contract identifies the basic ground rules for you to follow. Take time every day to
read the contract out loud.
Example of a Contract with Myself:
I, ____________, recognize myself as an adult with options and choices, and I
commit myself to the process of actively getting emotional blackmail out of my
relationships and out of my life. In order to reach that goal, I make the following
promises:
I promise myself that I am no longer willing to let fear, obligation, and guilt
control my decisions.
I promise myself that I will learn the strategies in this book and that I will put
them into practice in my life.
I promise myself that if I regress, fail, or fall into old patterns, I will not use
slips as an excuse to stop trying. I recognize that failure is not failure if you use it as
a way to learn.
I promise to take good care of myself during this process.
I promise that I will acknowledge myself for taking positive steps, no matter
how small they are.
____________________ Signature
____________________ Date
Power Statement
Another way to deal with emotional blackmail is to create your own power
statement. Repeating a power statement can ground you when the pressure is
turned up by the manipulator. For example, “I’m not doing this.” “I won’t do this.”
This power statement is succinct and impactful. It works because it directly
counters the belief that moves us into compliance – that we can’t stand the
pressure. Short, impactful sentences like this are intended to challenge doubts and
limiting beliefs.
If you begin to think “I can’t stand it”…that you can’t stand to hurt his
feelings, hurt him, deal with your guilt or anxiety, etc. Change the mantra from “I
can’t stand it” to “it’s hard but I can do it.” This involves a subtle shift to getting
comfortable with being uncomfortable. Changing to “I can stand it” will build your
emotional strength so that you do not need to immediately back down.
Self-affirming Phrases
By backing down and giving in, you may feel: guilt, hurt, shameful,
embarrassed, anxious, angry, weak, resentful, powerless, helpless, fearful, scared,
trapped, disappointed, stuck. In order to change these emotions, it is important to
start with changing your thoughts. Develop some self-affirming thought patterns
to retrieve and repeat, especially when your negative thinking kicks in.
Consider asking yourself if a demand is making you uncomfortable. Why?
What part of the demand is ok and what is not? Is the other person threatening
me? Is the other person considering my feelings? If I comply, what is in it for me?
There are several levels of demands:
Not a big deal, minimal impact
Important issues including your integrity is at stake
A major issue involving important life decisions and/or could be
damaging
Request that the blackmailer get psychological help to learn new strategies.
Blackmailers can learn skills to learn how to negotiate, communicate, and own
their own behavior. First, they must take responsibility for their action for any
change to occur. An unwillingness to own and put it on the other person is a sign
of immaturity and lack of wellbeing and health. Once blackmailers own the
behavior, they can take the next steps to learn the techniques.
If they are truly taking responsibility, they will demonstrate the courage to sit
down with the victim and have a conversation about it. In doing so, this will create
a safer environment in the relationship. Safety is the primary element of defining a
healthy or not healthy relationship. Manipulators who take accountability and are
willing to be vulnerable show hope for learning and change.
What can that sound like in the blackmailer?
Can you help me?
Tell me how I can express this to you in a way that doesn’t make you feel
bad.
I am willing to get help.
I don’t want my behaviors to make you feel so bad
What is another way I can say this to you?
What can I do that will help you feel safe?
Where can I learn to better deal with conflict?
I want to improve how I communicate with you.
Don’t need to wait until you feel strong to show strength. Do it, then the
feelings will catch up. People often wait until they feel the courage, and that
time doesn’t come. Do it, then you will feel better. You can’t wait until you
feel better.
Forward suggests additional techniques to help stop emotional
blackmail.
Establish an SOS before responding to a demand:
STOP – I need time to think about it.
OBSERVE – one’s own reactions, thoughts, emotions, triggers.
STRATEGIZE- analyze the demands and the potential impact of
complying. Consider what you need and explore alternative options.
It is essential to reinforce that victims cannot change their partner only their reaction.
The emotional blackmailer has a foundation in deep layers of their insecurities. The victim’s
job is to put their welfare and health first. Their energy is best utilized to change themselves
and their approach. In addition to changing the behavior patterns during these exchanges,
victims can do their own psychological healing outside the relationship.
For example, developing skills to self-regulate, build confidence, and increase
assertiveness can be beneficial. Victims can explore the following ideas:
Learn to become a detached observer. Healthy detachment is a good coping
mechanism when dealing with conflict or highly charged emotional situations. It involves
taking a step back and becoming an observer of what is going on the current situation,
without being taken away by the emotions at hand. This will allow some self-refraction and
questioning in order to make sensible connections between your beliefs, behaviors, and
actions.
Creating some space between you and the situation can allow you to make healthier
decisions.
Forward identifies the need to let go of pleasing behaviors. People who have a
tendency to comply, may give in because they do not want the other person to be mad at
them. They need to rid themselves of the undeserved guilt, which is what occurs in
emotional blackmail.
Expand strategies to deal with your own emotional discomfort. Find ways to deal with
your fear, guilt, and sense of obligation. Embrace the discomfort of the guilt, fear, or anxiety
that can come with saying no or establishing a new boundary.
Continue to develop the thought stopping techniques in order to disconnect from fear
and obligation. Challenge your assumptions of what obligations and expectations are real
and what proof is provided for these claims.
Review what part you play in the dysfunctional cycle of emotional blackmail. In order to
be fully empowered and able to make a change, it is important to look at your own
responsibility in the situation. This is not suggesting that you are to blame for the behavior
of the other person; rather, to find areas and behaviors that you can control to help yourself
navigate through such circumstances.
Take inventory. Self-reflect on how you may justify your compliance. Here are some
examples of negative self-talk that can reinforce the pattern of giving in.
It’s not worth it to deal with his/her anger
His/her needs matter more than mine
It’s no big deal to give in
What I want isn’t important enough
I’ll just do it to get him/her to calm down
I would rather give in than hurt his/her feelings
I’m afraid if I say no
Practice pausing before giving into demands in lower stakes situations. Practice saying
no even when the threats are not evident. Be firm and stand your ground on limits set. Do
not immediately give in to what the blackmailer wants, especially if you are being
threatened.
Seek professional help through counseling, therapy, coaching, or a support group to
help navigate through recovery from emotional abuse. In the end, it is critical for victims to
remember that abuse is not their fault. All people deserve to be treated with respect.
EB After a Break-Up
A break-up or relationship separation can fuel the fire for emotional blackmailers. The
potential for them to act out, even more, rises during crisis situations, especially involving a
break-up. During this time, victims could be at risk or in danger, as blackmailers can escalate
their behaviors. Since they are focused on what they want when they want it, they show
limited concern or empathy for the pain of others. They can become so absorbed in their
own rage, that they could show signs of panic in their desperation.
If emotional blackmail was used during the relationship and there is a break-up, there is
no longer a direct method for such manipulation tactics. This can cause an emotionally
unstable person to act out even more if their means for control are taken away.
Manipulator’s behaviors may increase in intensity and in a frequency. More severe threats of
self-harm and inducing guilt would be common in a breakup situation.
They also may resort to stalking or other types of unwanted behaviors in pursuit in an
attempt to reconnect the relationship. While uncommon, taken to an extreme, the ex may
show obsessive tendencies and could be at risk for bringing the violence to another level.
It is important for the victim to remember that they are not responsible for their ex’s
needs and feelings. It is important to seek protection if the victim is feeling unsafe. This may
require getting professional help to understand how to establish these healthy boundaries. It
may involve setting clear physical boundaries to ensure there is no contact with the ex-
partner.
Finding a support system can be helpful for individuals who have been in relationships
involving emotional blackmail and abuse. The focus post-break-up is best placed on victims
learning how to engage in self-care and identify their own personal needs.