Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tai Kwun Teacher's Handbook
Tai Kwun Teacher's Handbook
TEACHER’S
RESOURCE
HANDBOOK
前言 PREFACE 1
第 一 章 CHAPTER 1
大 館— 教 育 空 間 TAI KWUN AS EDUCATIONAL SPACE 3
建 議 學 習活 動 SUGGESTED LEARNING ACTIVITIES 7
第二章 CHAPTER 2
大 館— 中 區 警 署 建 築 群 活 化 計 劃 9
前言 PREFACE
TAI KWUN : THE CENTRAL POLICE STATION REVITALISATION PROJECT
大 館 歷 史 時 間 表 TAI KWUN HISTORICAL TIMELINE 13
本手冊旨在讓小學及中學教師了解大館 This handbook is designed to acquaint
之歷史、它與香港發展的關係,以及大 primary and secondary school teachers
館活化項目如何作為香港文物保育和管 with the history of Tai Kwun, its relationship 第三章 CHAPTER 3
理的成功例子。本手冊亦提供額外的教 with the development of Hong Kong, 大館的歷史與香港發展 HISTORY OF TAI KWUN AND HONG KONG DEVELOPMENT 17
學活動建議,加強學生對香港保育政策 and how the revitalisation of Tai Kwun
的認識,並了解平衡保育與城市可持續 demonstrates best practice for Hong Kong’s 第四章 CHAPTER 4
發展的重要。 heritage conservation and management. 大 館— 保 育 TAI KWUN - CONSERVATION 29
This handbook also suggests extended 課 堂 活 動 CLASS ACTIVITY 35
learning activities to deepen students’
如欲索取更多資訊,請與大館― 香港 understanding of Hong Kong’s conservation
第五章 CHAPTER 5
古蹟及藝術館文物事務部教育團隊聯絡。 policies, as well as the importance of a
大 館— 活 化 再 用 TAI KWUN - ADAPTIVE REUSE 39
heritage.edu@taikwun.hk balance between heritage conservation and
sustainable urban development.
第六章 CHAPTER 6
筆記 NOTES 55
1 2
第一章 CHAPTER 1
大館—教育空間 TAI KWUN AS
EDUCATIONAL 適 用 於 中學 生 For secondary school students
• 掌握城市發展、活化再用和古蹟活 ·· Grasp key concepts of urban
SPACE 化的關鍵概念。 development, adaptive reuse and built
• 以大館為例,認識活化再用在香 heritage revitalisation.
港城市可持續發展下的角色及功 ·· Understand the role of adaptive reuse
預 計 學 習成果 EXPECTED LEARNING OUTCOMES 用 。 in sustainable urban development
大館是欣賞藝術和消閒的理想場所, Tai Kwun is an ideal venue for art in Hong Kong, with Tai Kwun as an
同時也是培養學生全人發展的教育空 appreciation and leisure. It is also an example.
間。教師可安排學生參觀大館及進行 educational space to foster students’
相 關 的 教育活動。 whole-person development. Teachers are 大 館 與 其他 學 習 經 歷 TAI KWUN FOR OTHER LEARNING
strongly encouraged to organise visits to 其他學習經歷是新高中課程的重要部 EXPERIENCES
學 生 在 大館完成教育活動後,能夠: Tai Kwun and other related educational 分,有助學生達至全人發展。它建基 Other learning experiences (OLE) is an
activities. 於基礎教育(小一至中三)的基本學 essential component in the New Senior
適 用 於 中、小學生 習經歷,包括德育及公民教育、社會 Secondary Curriculum for students’
• 認識香港的法律、司法及刑罰制度 Upon completion of the activities at Tai 服務、與工作有關的經驗、藝術發展 whole-person development. Building on
的 發展 。 Kwun, students will be able to: 等範疇。 the foundation of the Essential Learning
• 認 識香 港的重要歷史發展。 Experiences in the Basic Education
• 反思保育對香港城市發展的重要 For primary and secondary school students 為了達成其他學習經歷的學習目標, (Primary 1 - Secondary 3), areas of
性。 ·· Understand the development of legal, 教育局建議學校舉辦相關的活動,而 OLE include Moral and Civic Education,
judicial and penal systems in Hong 這些活動約佔總上課時數10-15%,或 Community Service, Career-related
Kong. 相 當 於 2 70 -4 50 小 時 。 Experiences and Aesthetic Development.
·· Develop an understanding of the
major historical development of Hong In order to achieve the learning objectives
Kong. of OLE, the Education Bureau suggests
·· Reflect on the importance of schools to organise activities which
conservation to urban development in account for 10-15% of the total lesson
Hong Kong. time, or equivalent to 270-450 hours.
3 4
透過參觀大館或參與相關學習活動, Students can fulfill the following OLE
學生能完成下列的其他學習經歷要 requirements by visiting Tai Kwun or
求: participating in other related learning
activities:
其他學習經歷/大館可提供
OTHER LEARNING EXPERIENCES /
WHAT TAI KWUN CAN PROVIDE
5 6
建議學習活動 SUGGESTED LEARNING
ACTIVITIES
7 8
第二章 CHAPTER 2
2011 年 的 中 區 警 署 建 築 群 鳥 瞰 圖 。
大館— TAI KWUN : The aerial view of the Central Police Station
compound in 2011. (photo/ Purcell Architects)
中區警署建築群活化 THE CENTRAL
計劃 POLICE STATION
REVITALISATION The CPS compound ceased operation
in 2006. In April 2007, the Hong Kong
PROJECT Jockey Club (HKJC) submitted a
conceptual proposal of revitalising the
中區警署建築群於2006年正式結 compound to the HKSAR Government. It
中區警署建築群(建築群)由前中區 The Central Police Station (CPS) 役。2007年4月,香港賽馬會(馬 proposed a donation through the HKJC’s
警署、中央裁判司署及域多利監獄這 compound comprises three groups of 會)向香港特別行政區政府呈交活化 Charities Trust to bear the capital cost
三組建築物所組成。建築群早在十九 buildings, namely the former Central 建築群的建議書,提出由香港賽馬會 for renovation and development of the
世紀開始落成,於1995年根據《古物 Police Station, the Central Magistracy and 慈善信託基金(基金)承擔復修與建 compound, as well as the recurrent
及古蹟條例》(香港法例第53章)被 the Victoria Prison. Built from the 19th 設建築群所需的成本開支,以及初期 deficit for the initial years of operation.
列 為 法定古蹟。 Century onwards, they were declared as 營 運 的 經 常 性 虧 損 。 2 0 0 7-2 0 0 8 年 度 The Government’s acceptance in
monuments under the Antiquities and 的《施政報告》公布政府原則上接納 principle of the proposal was announced
2003年,時任香港特別行政區行政 Monuments Ordinance (Cap. 53) in 1995. 馬會的建議書,馬會隨即展開為期六 in the 2007-2008 Policy Address, and
長官董建華在《施政報告》中,首次 個月的公眾諮詢。2008年7月,政府 HKJC launched a six-month public
提出保育中區警署建築群的可行性, The discussion on conservation of the 與馬會訂立夥伴合作關係,一同開展 consultation subsequently. In July 2008,
包括遷移建築群內辦公的政府部門, CPS compound first began in 2003, 建築群的活化計劃。 the Government formed a partnership
及將建築群活化再用,由私營機構營 when the former Chief Executive Tung with the HKJC to kick off the revitalisation
運 , 以作 零售、飲食及文娛用途。 Chee-hwa mentioned in the Policy project.
Address about the possible relocation of
government departments which occupied
the compound, and the adaptive reuse
of the site to a retail, dining, cultural and 關鍵詞 KEYWORD
entertainment complex operated by the
大 館 Tai Kwun
private sector.
「 大 館 」 是 昔 日 警 務 人 員 和 公 眾 對 前 警 察 總 部 大 樓 以 至 整 個 中 區 警署 建 築 群
的 簡 稱。
The name “Tai Kwun” (大館) in Chinese means “big station”, the colloquial name used
by police officers and the public alike to refer to the former Police Headquarters Block
and the CPS compound.
9 10
which 37% is designated for heritage
and contemporary art, 36% for public
circulation and buildings facilities and
當代藝術推廣,36%為公眾通道及屋 27% for commercial use such as retail
中區警署建築群活化項目,涵蓋建築 The CPS Revitalisation Project includes 宇裝備,其餘約27%則用作零售及餐 and food and beverage facilities. The
群內16座歷史建築物及數個戶外開放 the conservation and adaptive reuse 飲設施等商業用途。復修後的監獄操 restored Prison Yard and Parade Ground
空間的保育及活化工程,涉及面積共 of 16 historic buildings and several 場和檢閱廣場,以及其他新增設的空 as well as other additional open spaces on
1 3 ,6 0 0 平 方 米 。 兩 座 由 瑞 士 赫 佐 格 和 open spaces on the site measuring 間,提供額外3,700平方米的開放空 the site also provide another 3,700 square
德默隆建築師事務所設計的新建築物 approximately 13,600 square metres. Two 間,讓所有使用者能在四通八達的中 metres of accessible tranquil space in the
「賽馬會藝方」和「賽馬會立方」, new buildings namely “JC Contemporary” 環心臟地帶休憩享受。 heart of Central for all to enjoy.
分別提供了國際級的美術展覽空間, and “JC Cube”, designed by Herzog & de
以及設有200個座位、供教育與其他 Meuron from Switzerland, have been 香港賽馬會轄下慈善信託基金成立 The Jockey Club CPS Limited (JCCPS),
活動使用的場館。這些新增建設為香 added to the site to house a world- 非牟利的「賽馬會文物保育有限公 a not-for-profit company, is set up by
港提供具國際標準的場地,促進本地 class art gallery space and a 200-seat 司」,負責營運中區警署建築群 HKJC’s Charities Trust to undertake
的 藝 術及 文娛發展。 auditorium for educational activities (「大館」)的活化項目,包括維修 the operation of the revitalised CPS
and other events. These new additions 和管理「大館」、提供文物探知活 compound, namely Tai Kwun. It is
此 項 活 化 計 劃 的 總 建 築 面 積 達 2 7, 9 0 0 offer international standard venues to 動,以及協調本地與海外的項目持份 responsible for the management and
平方米,其中約37%用作文物欣賞及 foster the city’s art, leisure and cultural 者,包括服務營運者、藝術團體及其 maintenance of Tai Kwun, provision of
development. 他合作伙伴。 heritage interpretation programmes
across the site, and also the
This revitalisation project comprises collaborations with local and overseas
an approximate total construction stakeholders including all site occupants,
floor area of 27,900 square metres, in art communities and other project
partners.
根據活化計劃,幾幢建於二十世紀、保育價值較低的建築,包括車房、洗衣
場 及辦公大樓被拆卸 , 並 分 別 改 建 為 機 房 、 賽 馬 會 立 方 及 賽 馬 會 藝 方 。 中區警署建築群修復後的構想鳥瞰圖。
Under the revitalisation plan, the Garage, the Laundry Yard and the General Office, An imaginary aerial view of the Central Police
which were built in the 20th Century and had lower heritage value, were demolished. Station compound after restoration.
The floor space was freed up for the construction of plant room, JC Cube and JC (photo/ Herzog & de Meuron)
Contemporary respectively.
11 12
大館歷史時間表
TAI KWUN HISTORICAL TIMELINE
1841 1858–1862 1893 1919 1937–1939 1946
威廉.堅偉上尉被委任為首 香港人口急劇增加令治安變 1893年,港督威廉.羅便臣 座落營房大樓北面的警署總部 1937年,隨著囚犯被遷 中區警署、中央裁判司署
席裁判司,負責建立及維護 差,監獄爆滿,囚室需求上 爵士批准擴建監獄,拆除域 大樓落成,面向荷李活道的大 至新落成的赤柱監獄, 和域多利監獄於戰後修葺
香港法治,並監督香港首座 升。政府遂決定於域多利監 多利監獄部分「放射型」監 樓正面屬新古典復古設計。 域多利監獄短暫關閉, 及重建後,重新運作。
裁判司署和監獄的興建。 獄範圍興建「放射型」監 倉,只留下「T字型」建築, 後於1939年重開,監獄
A new Central Police The Central Police Station,
倉,增加監獄容量。 同時興建新建築物。 部分位置被改成「域多
Captain William Caine was Headquarters Block was built at the Central Magistracy
利收押所」。
appointed Chief Magistrate to Prison overcrowding due to In 1893, Governor Sir William the north of the Barrack Block. and the Victoria Prison
establish law and order and an increase in population and Robinson approved a further The façade facing Hollywood Victoria Prison was briefly reopened after the
oversee the construction of the crime led to the redevelopment prison extension. New buildings Road was built in Colonial, closed in 1937 after the post-war repairs and
first magistracy and prison in of Victoria Prison based on a were added and part of Neoclassical Revival design. prisoners were transferred reconstructions.
Hong Kong. radial plan. the radial-plan prison was to the newly-built Stanley
demolished leaving a T-shaped Prison. It reopened in 1939
prison building. and part of the Victoria
Prison was turned into the
Victoria Remand Prison.
13 14
大館歷史時間表(續)
TAI KWUN HISTORICAL TIMELINE (CONT.)
1956–1967 1980 1982–1984 2004–2006
15 16
第三章 CHAPTER 3
大館的歷史 HISTORY OF
與香港發展 TAI KWUN AND
HONG KONG 1843年,《南京條約》生效,香港正
式成為英國殖民地,砵甸乍爵士成為首
crime rate that followed. Victoria Gaol was
hence erected in August 1841. Not only was
DEVELOPMENT 任香港總督,並兼任警察總長及總巡理 it the first prison in Hong Kong, but also the
府。一年後,最高法院落成,曉吾成為 city’s earliest western building constructed
法治是香港賴以成功的基石,而大館 Rule of law is Hong Kong’s cornerstone 首任首席按察司,這標示著香港的行政 of granite and bricks.
在過去逾一世紀,在香港維持法治與 of success, and Tai Kwun has played an 和 司 法 權 力正式獨立分家。
In 1843, Hong Kong officially became a
社 會 秩 序一環扮演重要的角色。 important role in maintaining the city’s
1844年,香港頒佈《警察條例》, British Crown Colony under the Treaty of
law and order for over a century.
確立警察編制。梅理被任命為警察 Nanjing. Sir Henry Pottinger became the
司,1845年到港履新。一支共有171 first Governor of Hong Kong, the Chief
人,包括歐洲人、印度人和華人的警隊 Superintendent and the Chief Magistrate.
正式成立。最早的警署座落在華人的聚 A year later, the Supreme Court was
十九世紀 居 地 太 平 山 街。 established, John Walter Hulme was
19TH CENTURY appointed as the first Chief Justice. This
symbolised the separation of executive and
judicial powers in Hong Kong.
17 18
The expanded gaol was soon full and the
government was desperate to find a new
As the capacity of the old Victoria Gaol prison location. Sir Hercules Robinson, the
and Magistracy had been stretched to their fifth Governor of Hong Kong, recommended
limits owing to rapid population increase, the construction of a new prison on
Charles May suggested the conversion of Stonecutters Island and relocation of all the
the Magistrate’s house into a prison in 1845. 不久,新建成的監倉亦告爆滿,政府 inmates in the Victoria Gaol. The expanding
眼見舊域多利監獄及法院隨著人口增 Half of the building served as a Debtor’s 急於覓地建監房。香港第五任港督羅 Colonial Police Force hence moved the
長而超出負荷,梅理在1845年建議將 Prison and the remaining as Gaoler’s 便臣爵士建議在昂船洲興建新監獄, Central Police Station (“Tai Kwun” as called
裁判官邸改建成監獄,半座建築物用 residence. More prison cells were built, 並移送所有域多利監獄的囚犯。這 by the locals) to the vacant prison site. By
作關押錢債犯人,另一半則繼續為監 where two blocks were for the containment 時,正擴張的殖民地警隊,將中區警 1864, the construction of a three storey
獄長官邸。當局亦擴建監房,並預留 of Chinese prisoners, and another with 署(俗稱「大館」)遷到閒置的監獄 Barrack Block and married inspectors’
其中兩座關押華人囚犯,另一座有更 bigger cells was for the Europeans. Also, a 原址。1864年,三層高的營房大樓及 quarters were completed. The site began
大 囚 室 的,則囚禁歐洲籍犯人。 1 8 4 0 new Magistracy was built in the mid 1840s 已婚督察宿舍落成。這一小片土地開 to serve the functions of police station,
年中葉,一座能處理更多審訊的新裁 which could accommodate more trial 始同時發揮警署、裁判司署及監獄的 magistracy and prison, forming a close-
判 司 署 落成。 proceedings. 功能,成為本港執法核心。 knitted law enforcement system.
1850年代,大量中國人因太平天國 In the 1850s, an influx of Chinese refugees 後來政府發現昂船洲並不是理想的監 However, Stonecutters Island was soon
逃難到香港。為減輕域多利監獄的負 fled the Taiping Rebellion. In order to ease 獄選址。不少囚犯被船送到該處服刑 proven to be a poor location for a prison.
擔,政府在1858年開始興建一座新 the overcrowding of the old Victoria Gaol, 時遇上沉船而溺斃,部分亦輕易逃離 Inmates died after a capsize when they
監獄。不過因為缺乏資金,原本放射 the construction works of a new prison 依岸而建的監獄。1866年,昂船洲監 were transported to the island. Some
狀的監獄建築,最後只能建成南面半 complex commenced in 1858. However, 獄停用,囚犯被送回域多利監獄。營 inmates escaped easily from the prison just
幢。 only the southern half of the radial prison 房大樓成為了隔開南面監獄與北面中 off the coast. The prison was abandoned
design was built because of a lack of 區警署的建築物。 in 1866 and the inmates were sent back
funding. to Victoria Gaol. The Barrack Block hence
became the physical separation between
the Gaol in the south and the Central Police
Station in the north.
建於1862至1864年間的營房大樓,是建築群最
古舊的建築物之一 。
這張平面圖顯示監獄原本呈放射式設計。 Constructed between 1862 and 1864, the Barrack
This floor plan shows the original radial plan of Block is one of the oldest buildings on the site. (photo/
the Gaol. (photo/ The National Archives) Purcell Architects)
19 20
From 1879, the Police Force was
Meanwhile, there were other new
permanently separated from the Gaol
construction works on the site. The new
1879年,警隊脫離監獄系統,監獄 system; the Gaol was under the control of
Central Magistracy was built on the
由專責委員會管理,並直接向港督匯 the Gaol Committee which directly reported
同時,其他新建築亦陸續落成。1912 same location of the old one, which was
報。 to the Governor.
年,舊中央裁判司署大樓拆卸,新大 demolished in 1912. Adjoining the Central
樓在原址興建。這座四層高的大樓毗 Police Station and the Gaol, this four storey
1893年,港督羅便臣爵士批准擴建監 In 1893, Governor Sir William Robinson
鄰中區警署及域多利監獄,設有法 building was equipped with courts, offices,
獄。至1895年底,兩座新監獄大樓落 approved a further prison extension in order
庭、辦公室、犯人等候室、羈押室、 prisoners’ waiting rooms, cells, strong rooms,
成,部分舊建築則被拆卸。在1850年 to increase gaol capacity. In late 1895, two
保險庫,以及法院人員和警察宿舍 as well as accommodation for magistrates
代中建成的D倉,部分空間用作女子 prison buildings were added and part of the
等。大樓在1915年4日26日展開首次 and police officers. It was opened for its first
監獄,監獄操場上亦建起女獄長的住 old buildings was demolished. A part of D
審訊。 judicial sessions on 26 April 1915.
所。往後數年,為擴建操場及更多囚 Hall, which was built in the mid 1850s, was
室,放射型監獄的部分建築亦被逐步 converted into a Female Prison. A house
早在1913年,港督已經決定擴建中區 Plans to build a major extension to the
拆卸。 was also built for the Matron in the Prison
警 署 。 1 9 14 年 , 政 府 收 回 荷 里 活 道 和 Central Police Station were prompted by the
Yard. The radial layout of the prison was
中區警署北面邊界之間的土地,兩年 Governor in 1913. In order to give room for the
further eradicated in the following years due
後拆卸部分座落在警署範圍內的舊建 construction works, a plot of land occupied
to the expansion of yard space and prison
築,以騰出土地興建大樓。1919年, the area between Hollywood Road and the
cells.
警察總部大樓落成。 northern boundary wall of the police station
was resumed by the Government in 1914,
二十世紀初 and some old buildings occupying the site
EARLY 20TH CENTURY were demolished two years later. In 1919, the
Police Headquarters Block was completed.
21 22
罰則的轉變 CHANGE IN PUNISHMENT In the 1930s, Hong Kong became the hiding
place for many fleeing revolutionists. Ho
Chi-minh, the national father of Vietnam,
在十九世紀,域多利監獄和監獄內施行的刑罰,
都出現不少轉變。當時罪犯除了被判監禁和罰款 was sentenced to death in 1929 from the
外,還需接受笞刑、枷號示眾、放逐、烙印、剪 Vinh Court in Indochina for his involvement
辮等刑罰,有囚犯更因抵受不住酷刑而死在獄 in the revolutionary work. Fleeing to Hong
中。 Kong, his hideout was detected by the
1930年代,香港成為不少革命分子 French authority, and the information was
1877 年,港督軒尼詩爵士建議停止公開笞刑及減少
鞭打犯人次數,若執行笞刑,也不要鞭打犯人背部 這照片記錄域多利監獄 F 倉及監 的藏身之地,越南國父胡志明是其中 passed to the Hong Kong authority. In 1931,
獄操場的舊貌。 之一。他在1929年被印度支那法庭以 he was arrested by the Hong Kong Police.
而打臀部,並以藤鞭代替九尾鞭。但英國殖民地大
This photo records the old image
臣卡納芬伯爵擔心這未能阻嚇犯罪分子來港,未有 參與革命工作被判死刑,之後逃到香 He refused to admit his true identity and
of the F Hall of Victoria Prison
積極支持建議。 1 8 8 0 年 代 , 寶 雲 爵 士 就 任 港 督 期 港,但法國政府得悉其藏身地點,將 insisted on claiming himself to be Sung
and the Prison Yard.
間,取消烙印和放逐囚犯等不人道的刑罰,笞刑和 (photo/ Antiquities and 資料交予香港政府。1931年,胡志明 Man-cho, a Chinese national. As there were
枷號示眾則在 1903 年和 1909 年相繼廢除。 Monuments Office)
被警方逮捕。他拒絕承認自己的真實 insufficient grounds for his extradition
繯首死刑則用以懲罰重犯,首宗有記錄的問吊在1844年11月4日進行,犯人是 身分,堅稱是中國人宋文初。法庭沒 to Indochina, he was jailed in Victoria
一名謀殺歐籍警官的華人。最初執行絞刑的地方在仍屬郊區的堅尼地城, 1856 有足夠證據遞解他回印度支那,就在 Gaol from June 1931, and later the prison
年轉到裁判司署的廣場上或監獄操場公開行刑。由於社會上有反對之聲,最後 1931年6月將他囚禁在域多利監獄, hospital. After repeated court proceedings
一次公開處決在 1894 年 4 月 5 日執行,之後改由在獄警和記者監察下行刑。 其後轉送監獄醫院服刑。經過多次的 and diplomatic struggles, he was released
審訊和外交角力,胡志明在1932年底 secretly in late 1932 and he fled Hong Kong
Not only had the Gaol undergone changes, the punishment in the Gaol had also
被 秘 密 釋 放 , 1 9 33 年 初 離 開 香 港 。 in early 1933.
changed over decades in the 19th Century. Besides imprisonment and monetary fines,
criminals were punished by caning, public display in shackles, exiling, branding, and
the cutting of the braid. Some criminals died in prison, unable to withstand the severe 同時,監獄的管理變得更制度化。 Meanwhile, management of prisons became
punishment. 1920年,獨立於警務處的監獄署成 more systematic. In 1920, the Prisons
立。署方亦在其他地區興建新監獄, Department, a unit independent from
In 1877, Governor Sir John Pope Hennessy proposed to abandon caning and the 舒緩域多利監獄的壓力。收容女囚犯 the Police, was established. More prisons
reduction of the number of strokes inflicted; that the area of caning be restricted to
的荔枝角監獄在1932年啟用;赤柱 were built in other districts so as to ease
the bottom rather than to the back, and that the “cat o’ nine tails” be replaced by rattan
監獄則在1937年建成。當囚犯都被 the pressure of Victoria Gaol. Lai Chi Kok
canes. These suggestions did not gain the favour of then Colonial Secretary Earl of
Carnarvon, who feared that criminals might not be deterred by lighter punishment. 送到新監獄復刑後,域多利監獄宣告 Prison for female inmates was in use in
In the 1880s during the tenancy of the Governor Sir George Bowen, inhumane 結役。不過,赤柱監獄囚位很快爆 1932, and Stanley Prison was built in 1937.
punishments such as branding and exiling were abolished; caning and public display in 滿,1939年,域多利監獄重開接收還 All prisoners at Victoria Gaol were thus
shackles were abolished in 1903 and 1909 respectively. 押 犯 , 並改 稱 域 多 利 收 押 所 。 transferred to the new prisons, and the Gaol
was closed. Owing to the rapid overcrowding
Death penalty was used to punish felons. The first recorded hanging was carried out
in Stanley Prison, however, Victoria Gaol
on 4 November 1844, with the criminal being a Chinese who murdered a European Police
was re-opened in 1939 for holding remand
Officer. In the beginning, hanging was carried out in the suburb of Kennedy Town. From
1856, executions took place publicly at the open space of the Central Magistracy or in prisoners, and the prison was renamed as
the Prison Yard. Responding to voices of opposition in society, the last public execution Victoria Remand Prison.
was held on 5 April 1894, and subsequent death penalties were carried out in the
witness of jailers and journalists.
23 24
1946年,中區警署和域多利收押所經 In 1946, the Central Police Station
復修後重開,警察總部遷址至軍器廠 and Victoria Remand Prison reopened
街。 upon repairs and constructions. The
headquarters of Hong Kong Police Force
was moved to Arsenal Road.
建於1912至1914年的中央裁判司署,
是香港司法權力的象徵。
Built between 1912 and 1914, the Central
Magistracy symbolised the judicial power
of Hong Kong. (photo/ Antiquities and
Monuments Office)
警察總部大樓的部分結構在二戰時被炸毀。
Some striations of the Police Headquarters
Block were destroyed by airstrikes during WWII.
(photo/ Purcell Architects)
二戰前後
WORLD WAR II – BEFORE AND AFTER
二十世紀後期
Late 20th Century
1941年12月8日,日軍開始侵佔香 On 8 December 1941, Japan began
港,檢閱廣場、警察總部大樓地下及 its invasion of Hong Kong. The Parade
地底被空襲炸毀。日佔時期,建築群 Ground, ground floor and basement 戰後香港的執法機關出現不少轉變。警 The post war period marked many changes
為日軍佔用。時任警務處長俞允時下 of the Headquarters Block suffered 隊開始使用無線電執勤,首名女性亦在 in Hong Kong’s law enforcement system.
達指令,勸喻在職警員即使在日本人 severe damage during the airstrikes. The 1949年加入警隊。1967年香港暴動期 Radio was used by the Police Force, and
的 統 治下 ,仍得繼續維持治安。 compound was used by the Japanese army 間,包括中區警署在內的不少警署,均 the first female police officer joined the
during Japanese military occupation in 被左派暴徒襲擊。當時中區警署被用作 Force in 1949. During the 1967 Riots, leftist
Hong Kong. John Pennefather-Evans, then 港 島 區 的指揮中心。 protestors attacked many police stations
Commissioner of Police, ordered the police including the Central Police Station. The
officers to continue to maintain order even CPS was used as the Force’s Hong Kong
under Japanese rule. Island district centre during the riots.
25 26
香港的懲教制度亦隨著時代變遷而轉 The penal system in Hong Kong had 中 區 警 署 建 築 群 於 2006年 正 式 結 The CPS compound ceased operation in
變。1966年,香港暫停執行死刑。 undergone changes over the years. In 1966, 役 。 2008 年,政府接納由香港賽馬會 2006. In 2008, the Government accepted
1982 年,監獄署易名為懲教署,反映 capital punishment was suspended. In 1982, (馬會)提出的活化建築群建議,經 the revitalisation proposal submitted by
其 懲 罰和更生並重的目標。 the Prisons Department was renamed as 過數年的專業修繕和興建工程,大館 the Hong Kong Jockey Club (HKJC). In mid
the Correctional Services Department to ― 香 港 古 蹟 及 藝 術 館 於 2018年 正 式 2008, the revitalisation works began . After
域多利監獄亦適時應對社會的各種轉 emphasise the rehabilitation of prisons. 向公眾開放。 years of restoration and construction, Tai
變。1975年,香港成為越南船民的 Kwun is opened to the public in 2018 as
第一收容港,監獄部分空間被入境處 Victoria Prison had also adapted to all the Hong Kong’s Centre for Heritage and Arts.
徵用,尤其在1989年政府宣布強制 changes in society. In 1975, Hong Kong
遣返後,被捕的越南船民都會被囚禁 became the port of first asylum for Vietnam
該處。此外,自1977年起,部分空間 refugees. Part of the prison area was
再次用作中度設防的監獄。1984年, converted for Immigration Department’s
紫荊樓變成本港首間女囚犯的中途宿 use, especially following the 1989 decision
舍。 for the mandatory repatriation. Meanwhile
since 1977, part of the area had been used
小資料 QUICK FACT
1995 年 ,古物古蹟辦事處宣布將前中 again as a medium-security prison. In 1984,
區警署、中央裁判司署及域多利監獄 Bauhinia House was converted into a half-
1 949 年,馬來西亞華僑許錦濤獲委任為香港首位女
列為法定古蹟。2003年,政府建議 way house for female inmates.
副 督 察 。由於她的英文名字「 K im my Ko h 」與廣
調遷建築群內的政府部門,並改作零 東話「高健美」發音相近,所以這個中文名字亦伴
售、餐飲、文化及藝術用途,交由私 In 1995, the Antiquities and Monuments 隨 她 直至 1 9 6 1 年退休,到八十年代才被「正名」。
營 機 構 營運。 Office declared the former Central Police
Station, the Central Magistracy and the 警隊於1951年聘用九位女警,負責偵緝關於婦孺棄
Victoria Prison as monuments. In 2003, the 嬰、失蹤少女的案件,並負責搜身工作。1972年警 許錦濤(前排中)
隊增設女總督察職位,可見女性的工作表現獲得肯 Kimmy Koh (middle, front
Government recommended the possible
定。 row) (photo/ Hong Kong
relocation of governmental departments Police Museum)
which occupied the compound, and the
Malaysian Chinese Kimmy Koh was recruited as the first
adaptive reuse of the site to a retail, dining, woman Sub-Inspector in 1949. As the pronunciation of
cultural and entertainment space operated her English name was similar to “Ko Kin Mei” (高健美) in
by the private sector. Cantonese, this name was with her until her retirement
in 1961, and was eventually corrected in the 1980s.
27 28
第四章 CHAPTER 4
大館—保育 TAI KWUN -
CONSERVATION
GUIDING PRINCIPLES OF
保育的指導原則 CONSERVATION
29 30
警察總部大樓的紅磚以原廠物料修補,保
留其古典英國建築風格。
The red brick wall on the Police Headquarters
可逆轉性 REVERSIBILITY Block is restored with the same materials
manufactured by the original supplier, which
所有對於建築的干預和活化都可 Any intervention or adaptation to the
perfectly conserves the building’s classical British
還原,一旦這些工程將來被拆 building fabric should be reversible, architectural style. (photo/ M&C)
除,都不會破壞文物的原有結 without causing any damage to
構。 the existing structure when such
intervention is to be removed in the
新舊結合 future. 保育大館 CONSERVATION OF TAI KWUN
如要在文物上新增構築物,無論 大館的保育工作參照《威尼斯憲章》 The conservation of Tai Kwun respects
其比例、形式、設計和物料,都 INTEGRATING OLD AND NEW (國際古蹟保護與修復憲章)、《布 the international principles in
要與原建築呼應。新構築物的結 When adding new construction to 拉憲章》(澳洲國際古蹟遺址理事會 conservation such as Venice Charter
構和外形均要與文物兼容,但須 heritage buildings, the proposed 保存重大文化意義地方憲章)和《中 (International Charter for Conservation
有其獨特性,不能刻意與文物混 new works should be sympathetic 國文物古蹟保護準則》等國際保育標 and Restoration of Monuments and Sites),
淆。 to the heritage place in terms of 準,同時遵照古物古蹟辦事處(古蹟 Burra Charter (The Australia ICOMOS
its compatible proportion, form, 辦)的規定,讓整個建築群的歷史特 Charter for the Conservation of Places
design and materials. They should be 色和完整性得以保留。 of Cultural Significance) and Principle
physically and visually compatible for the Conservation of Heritage Sites in
with and distinguishable from the 部分歷史價值較高的建築物,例如警 China. Conservation works of Tai Kwun
original fabric of the historic place. 察總部大樓、營房大樓和中央裁判司 also follow the preservation requirements
署,其內外結構都被保存。 set by the Antiquities and Monuments
Office (AMO) in order to preserve the
historic character and integrity of the
original layout of the compound.
31 32
建築群保留了監獄條例告示版。
An original plaque with the engraving of Prisons
For other buildings in the compound, Ordinance is conserved on the site. (photo/ M&C)
certain flexibility in reuse and internal
建築群內的其他建築物,容許被活化 alteration is allowed. However, the
Most of the buildings and structures in Tai
再利用及更改內部結構。不過一些具 historic architectural features such as
Kwun were built a long time ago. In order
歷史價值而被古蹟辦確認的建築特 timber doors and windows, staircases
to comply with the current building safety
色,例如木門及窗戶、樓梯和欄杆、 and balustrades, roofs and façade, which
and health requirements, structural
簷 篷 和 外牆等,則需要好好保留。 are identified by AMO, are well conserved.
大館內的建築物都有多年歷史。為符 assessments have been carried out
合現有的建築物安全及衞生要求,所 in all buildings in the compound, and
大館保存了原有的建築元素,連活化 Not only are the original architectural
有建築物都經過結構評估,亦按現今 building services have been installed in
所需要的部分物料,例如紅磚和屋簷 elements kept in the compound, some
的 標 準 加設 屋 宇 裝 備 。 accordance with the modern standard.
瓦頂,都是由百多年前向中區警署提 building materials, such as clay bricks
供物料的廠商生產。此外,建築物亦 and roof tiles used for the restoration
重新被塗上與以往一樣的顏色,好讓 works, have been made by the same 關鍵詞 KEYWORD
其 韻 味 得以原汁原味地保留。 factories which provided construction
materials for the original CPS compound 《 威 尼 斯 憲 章 》 和 《 布 拉 憲 章 》 Venice Charter and Burra Charter
為保存建築群內的綠化環境,部分樹 over 100 years ago. The buildings are 1964 年 通 過 的 《 威 尼 斯 憲 章 》 ( 國 際 古 蹟 保 護 與 修 復 憲 章 ) 是 國 際 上 最 具 影
響力的文物保育原則,為保育及復修歷史建築及遺址訂定專業標準。憲章訂
木 亦 被 保留。 also painted the same colour as they 明保育和復修古蹟,不單旨在保護其藝術價值,亦保護其歷史價值。此外,
were originally so as to bring out their rich 保 護 古蹟的真實和完整性,亦是保育工作的核心原則。
beauty.
《布拉憲章》(澳洲國際古蹟遺址理事會保存重大文化意義地方憲章)在
1979年首次通過,它建基於《威尼斯憲章》的哲學和概念之上,更將古蹟的定
Some trees in the site are also conserved 義由歷史遺產,推展至具文化價值的場所。它亦訂定文化價值評估、政策制
in order to retain the greenery of the 訂 及 推行等實務指引,讓從事保育者易於遵行。
compound.
The Venice Charter (International Charter for the Conservation and Restoration
of Monuments and Sites), adopted in 1964, is the most influential set of heritage
大 館 外 牆 上 的 路 牌 , 見 證了中區警署建築群的歷史。
conservation principles internationally. It codifies professional standards of
Road signs on the wall of Tai Kwun are witnesses to the history of the site.
conservation and restoration of historic buildings and sites. The intention in
(photo/ M&C)
conserving and restoring monuments, as it states, is to safeguard them no less as
works of art than as historical evidence. Authenticity and integrity are foremost
principles when conservation works are carried out.
The Burra Charter (The Australia ICOMOS Charter for the Conservation of Places of
Cultural Significance), first adopted in 1979, accepts the philosophy and concepts of
the Venice Charter, but further elaborates the notion of heritage places from historic
monuments to places with cultural significance. It also sets forth practical guidelines
including assessment of cultural significance, policy development and implementation
of conservation policy for practitioners to follow.
33 34
課堂活動 CLASS ACTIVITY
每 組 被 分 派 一 個 大 館 持 份 者 的 角 色 , 可 包 括 ( 1) 政 府 官
學 生扮演成大館的不同持份者,辯論發展和 保 育 的 矛 盾
員 、 ( 2) 古 蹟 保 育 專 家 、 ( 3) 建 築 師 、 ( 4) 城 市 規 劃
STUDENTS ASSUME THE ROLES OF DIFFERENT STAKEHOLDERS OF TAI
師 、 ( 5) 大 館 附 近 的 商 戶 、 ( 6) 大 館 附 近 的 居 民 及 ( 7)
KWUN AND DEBATE ON THE CONFLICTS BETWEEN DEVELOPMENT AND
公眾人士。
CONSERVATION
EACH GROUP IS ASSIGNED A DIFFERENT ROLE OF TAI KWUN’S
一節課( 1-1.5 小 時 ) 1 lesson (1-1.5 hour)
STAKEHOLDERS, which may include (1) Government officials;
初中及高中學 生 (2) Heritage conservation specialists; (3) Architects; (4) Urban
Junior to senior secondary school students planners; (5) Retailers near Tai Kwun; (6) Residents near Tai Kwun;
(7) General public.
讓學生代入不 同 持 份 者 的 想 法 , 了 解 保 育 和 活化 面 對 的 問 題 和 挑 戰
Students can put themselves in different stakeholders’ shoes and learn about the 學生須代入被委派的角色去思考,並就以下題目作出討論:
problems and challenges of conservation and revitalisation. 1. 你們會否支持活化再用大館?為甚麼?
30 分 鐘
2. 你們認為活化工程之中,要考慮甚麼因素?
30 Minutes
3. 你 們 認 為 活 化 大 館 對 區 內 的 環 境 和 社 會 發 展 構 成 甚 麼 影
時 間 TIME 流程 PROCEDURE
響?
5 分鐘 教師簡介活動 4. 你們認為活化的方案如何能平衡保育和發展的需要?
5 Minutes Teacher gives brief instructions to students.
Students are expected to address the following questions
協助學生分組,5 至 6 人一組 ACCORDING TO THE ROLE THEY PLAY:
5 分鐘 Students are divided into groups of 5 to 6 people. 1. Do you support revitalising Tai Kwun? Why?
5 Minutes 2. What factors do you consider during the revitalisation process?
派發所需文具及畫紙予各組
3. How do you think revitalisation would affect the environment of
Every group is given stationery and drawing paper.
the district and development of society?
4. How do you think revitalisation balances the needs of
conservation and development?
學生須用概念圖在畫紙上記錄討論內容
Students should draw a MIND MAP as a record of their discussions.
教師可邀請各組作匯報分享(如時間不足,可於另一天進行)
30 分 鐘
Teacher may invite every group to PRESENT THEIR IDEAS.
30 Minutes
Presentations can be conducted on another day if time is limited.
5 分鐘 教師總結活動
5 Minutes Teacher concludes the activity.
35 36
建議答案 SUGGESTED ANSWERS
持 份者STAKEHOLDER 意見 OPINIONS
中區警署建築群極具歷史價值,為法定古蹟,政府有
責任去保護。 中區警署建築群能為中環這擠迫的社區,帶來休憩空
間和文藝欣賞的地方。
The Central Police Station compound has a high historical 城市規劃師
value and it was declared as monuments under the URBAN PLANNERS The Central Police Station compound provides a new leisure
Antiquities and Monuments Ordinance. The government and arts venue to the densely populated community in
should shoulder the responsibility to protect the CPS Central.
compound.
保育項目會為附近商戶帶來人流,從而有利生意。
藉保育古蹟,保存市民的集體回憶,提升市民對香港
The Project can attract more people to the area and benefit to
的歸屬感。 the retailers located nearby.
大 館附近的商戶
Heritage conservation helps preserve the collective memory THE RETAILERS 保育工程期間可能帶來噪音、空氣污染和大量大型車
of the public, and hence reinforces citizens’ sense of
NEAR TAI KWUN 輛出入的問題。
政府 belonging to Hong Kong.
GOVERNMENT The construction may bring noise and air pollution; and many
活化再利用古蹟有助發展文化旅遊,帶動香港經濟 large vehicles passing by also causes inconvenience.
發展。
Adaptive reuse of historical buildings helps develop cultural 保育項目保存了老街坊的集體回憶。
tourism, which can drive Hong Kong’s economy. The project preserves the collective memory of the residents,
讓下一代認識香港歷史,尤其是刑法制度史方面。 notably that of the older generation.
Let the new generations better understand the history of Hong 社區將多一個公共空間及文化藝術欣賞地方,可提升
大 館附近的居民 居民的文化生活素質。
Kong, especially its history in the legal and penal systems.
RESIDENTS
如政府不保育中區警署建築群,將會面對很多反對 The public can enjoy a new communal space and a cultural
NEAR TAI KWUN and arts venue, and people’s living quality can be improved.
聲音。
The government has to face various objections if it rejects to 保育工程可能產生噪音及空氣污染。
conserve the CPS compound. The conservation project may cause noise and air pollution.
中區警署建築群包括香港第一間警察總部、法院及監
文物保育 專 家 獄,是法定古蹟,極具歷史價值。 保育項目保存了香港市民的集體回憶。
HERITAGE CONSERVATION The Central Police Station compound, which includes the first The project can preserve the collective memory of Hong Kong
SPECIALISTS police headquarters, court and prison in Hong Kong, has a people.
high historical value. 社區將多一個公共空間及文化藝術欣賞地方。
The public can enjoy a new communal space and a cultural
中區警署建築群極具建築特色和歷史價值,值得保
and arts venue.
育。
有助發展文化旅遊,帶動香港經濟發展。
The Central Police Station compound deserves to be 公眾人士
conserved because of its distinctive architectural features The project can foster cultural tourism and stimulate the
GENERAL PUBLIC
建築師 and historical value. economy of Hong Kong.
ARCHITECTS 在保育古建築時會遇上較多的困難,在決定拆卸或是 擔心活化後的建築群組太側重商業(例如:高檔次餐
繼續保留時,更應考慮建築物所帶來的安全問題。 廳、商店)而欠缺文化保育成分。
There may be difficulties in conserving older heritage The general public may worry that the project may over-
buildings. Should we demolish them or continue to preserve emphasise the commercial aspects (e.g. having expensive
them if there is potential danger? Would they cause safety restaurants and shops as tenants) but lack cultural
issues if kept? conservation elements.
37 38
第五章 CHAPTER 5
大館—活化再用 TAI KWUN -
ADAPTIVE REUSE
保育具文化價值的歷史建築,除了保 To conserve historic buildings and retain both integrity and authenticity of
存、復修和重建外,亦可藉著活化再 their cultural significance, more can be the heritage and not to attempt to
用 , 賦予 建築物新生命。 done beyond preservation, restoration falsify history (i.e., the new should be
and reconstruction. Heritage buildings distinguishable from but also compatible
近年政府積極推廣將歷史建築活化再 can also be given a second life through with the old, and the new should not be
用,這不但可以令保育和發展並存, adaptive reuse. made to look like the old).
亦能活化歷史建築的實質及經濟價
值。再者,它亦將建築與社區甚至整 In recent years, the Government 大館是活化再用的範例。建築群的獨 Tai Kwun demonstrates best practice
個 社 會重 新聯繫起來。 has been promoting revitalisation of 有特徵不但被保留,重新利用舊建 in adaptive reuse. Not only are the
historic buildings with the approach of 築,亦能反映它們的歷史和美學價 character-defining architectural
一般來說,活化再用遵從幾個原則, adaptive reuse. This approach not only 值。新增建築對古蹟的干預極少,卻 elements preserved, the new uses of the
包括減少干預古蹟的獨有特徵、所有 achieves the objective of co-existence 可以更妥善地利用建築群的原址。 old buildings also reflect their historic and
改建和加建工程需可回復、工程需要 of conservation and development, but aesthetic values, and minimal additions
尊重古蹟的真實和完整性,不能篡改 also rejuvenates the heritage buildings works have been carefully carried out to
歷史— 新建築既要與舊建築融合, in terms of both physical and economic maximise the use of the heritage site.
同 時 不能 仿舊,令人混淆。 values. It also reconnects the buildings
and districts with the community and
society.
例 子 EX AMP L ES
In general, adaptive reuse of the heritage
buildings follows several principles. It
should pose minimal intervention to 警察總部大樓變成一座多用途建築,並設有
the character-defining elements of the 警察服務中心,大館原有的用途得以延續。
heritage. Alteration and additions works The Police Headquarters Block is transformed
into a multifunction building with a police service
should be carried out in a reversible centre, which the building was meant to be.
manner. The works should also uphold (photo/ Antiquities and Monuments Office)
39 40
作為當代藝術的中心,大館的部分建 As Tai Kwun is a centre for contemporary
築物被活化成藝術教育、推廣及發展 arts, several buildings are reused for arts
例 子 EXAM PLES 的場所。 education, promotion and development.
中央裁判司署由司法場所變成教育場所― 審
為了向參觀者提供最佳的體驗,大館 In order to offer the best visitor
判室和地下羈押室被保留並活化成模擬法庭的
場地,參觀人士可藉著角色扮演及辯論,了解 亦利用歷史建築物的空間,提供餐飲 experience, Tai Kwun also makes use of
香港的司法制度。 及零售設施。檢閱廣場和監獄操場這 several historic buildings to provide food
The Central Magistracy has been transformed
兩個戶外空間,亦活化成公共節目及 and beverage as well as retail facilities.
from a judicial venue into an educational venue
– a courtroom and basement cells have been 娛 樂 的 場所 。 The two major open spaces on the site,
conserved and reused for the venue of moot Parade Ground and Prison Yard, are
court. Visitors can learn more about Hong Kong’s
also reused for public programmes and
judicial system via role play and debate.
(photo/ Purcell Architects) entertainment purposes.
例 子 EX AMP L ES
監獄B倉用作探知空間,原有的囚室(下)被
保留,讓參觀人士感受監獄實況。
The B Hall is used for interpretation space, and
the prison cells have been retained (below)
in order to provide impression of the prison 監獄D和E倉(上)連接賽馬會立方,設有後
conditions. (photo/ Purcell Architects) 勤設施;F倉(下)則成為賽馬會藝方的延伸
空間。
D and E Halls (top) are connected to the JC Cube
for back-of-house facilities; and F Hall (bottom) is
the extension of JC Contemporary.
(photo/ Purcell Architects)
41 42
賽馬會藝方的概念圖。 JC Contemporary provides 1,500 square
Artist’s impression of the JC Contemporary. metres of exhibition space for hosting
(photo/ Herzog & de Meuron)
contemporary art exhibitions. The gallery
賽馬會藝方提供1,500平方米的展覽 spaces, lighting and climate control
空間,用作舉辦當代藝術展覽。它的 system are designed in accordance
展廊、照明及氣候調節控制系統均符 with international museum standards,
合國際博物館標準,為藝術品提供最 which can provide the most suitable
適合的存放環境。 environment for artworks.
43 44
第六章 CHAPTER 6
大館與 TAI KWUN AND
城市可持續發展 SUSTAINABLE
URBAN
DEVELOPMENT
大館的活化工程,正正展示了古蹟保 The revitalisation of Tai Kwun
育和活化再用實現了城市可持續發 demonstrates how heritage conservation
展 , 以 及為 社 群 帶 來 不 同 效 益 。 and adaptive reuse can achieve
根據聯合國環境與發展世界委員會的
sustainable urban development and
Sustainable development, defined by
定義,可持續發展指「既能滿足當代
community benefits.
the United Nations’ World Commission
的需要,而同時又不損及後代滿足其 on Environment and Development, is
本 身 需 要的發展模式」。 “development that meets the needs of
the present without compromising the
為了實踐可持續發展,政府為香港城 ability of future generations to meet their
市居住空間的可持續發展訂定策略性 own needs”.
方向。古蹟保育― 尤其是活化再用
― 扮演重要的角色,並對當今及後 In order to pursue sustainable
世 帶 來社會、經濟和環境效益。 development, the Government has set
out a strategic direction for Hong Kong’s
sustainable development in urban living
space. Heritage conservation, especially 關鍵詞 KEYWORD
with the approach of adaptive reuse,
可 持 續發展評估 Sustainability Assessment
plays a vital role, and it brings social,
自 2001 年 起 , 政 府 實 行 一 套 可 持 續 發 展 評 估 制 度 , 規 定 各 決 策 局 和 部 門 , 均
economic and environmental benefits to 須就可能對香港經濟、環境及社會帶來明顯或持久影響的新策略性措施或重
the present and future generations. 大 計 劃 , 進 行 可 持 續 發 展 評 估 。 另 外 , 自 2002年 4月 起 , 所 有 提 交 予 行 政 會 議
和 / 或政務司司長政策委員會的文件,須闡述可持續發展評估的結果。
Since 2001, the Government implemented a sustainability assessment (SA) system
that required all Bureaux and Departments to carry out SA of new strategic initiatives
or major programmes that have significant economic, environmental and social
impact. Since April 2002, all proposal submissions to the Executive Council and/or the
Chief Secretary’s Policy Committee are required to include SA findings or results.
45 46
社會效益 經濟效益 環境效益 社會效益 經濟效益 環境效益
SOCIAL BENEFITS ECONOMIC BENEFITS ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS SOCIAL BENEFITS ECONOMIC BENEFITS ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS
歷史建築既展示我們的文化及身分, Historical places and buildings are 古蹟活化再用能為業主、鄰里以至整 Adaptive reuse of built heritage can bring
也訴說我城的歷史故事,不能以其他 important expressions of our culture 個社會帶來經濟回報。它可以提升建 economic returns not only to the owners
沒有類似內涵的建築物取代或複製。 and identity, and tell stories of our city’s 築物的利用價值、創造就業機會、促 but also the neighbourhood or even the
因此,它們的社會及文化價值,就是 history. This cannot be substituted or 進 古 蹟 旅遊 , 並 吸 引 當 區 的 投 資 。 community at large. It can stimulate
不可再生的社會資源。古蹟的保育 replicated by a building that has no higher use values of the buildings, create
和活化再用不但幫助我們保留文化根 similar content. Therefore, their social 大館為參觀者提供餐飲及零售設施, job opportunities, promote heritage
源,也有助社區的宜居性和可持續發 and cultural values are non-renewable 這不單能創造就業機會,也能吸引更 tourism, and attract investments in the
展。 resources to our society. Not only do 多參觀者到訪。這些業務的收入,也 district.
conservation and adaptive reuse of 有助大館在財政上自給自足。而鄰近
作為香港殖民地時代的刑事及司法系 heritage buildings help keep our roots, 的餐館和商店,亦可受惠於由大館帶 Tai Kwun offers food, beverage and
統樞紐,大館見證著這個城市的其中 they also contribute to the livability and 動的遊客增長。此外,大館作為當代 retail facilities to visitors, which can
一個最重要理念— 法律與秩序— sustainability of communities. 藝術的中心,可吸引藝術家、策展人 create interesting career opportunities
的發展。透過參觀大館,公眾可更深 和買家到訪,從而促進香港藝術產業 and attract more visitors. The revenue
入了解作為香港成功支柱的司法制 As the hub of colonial Hong Kong’s 的發展。 generated can also help Tai Kwun to
度,當中包括公平、透明及尋求司法 criminal justice system, Tai Kwun has be financially self sustainable. The
公 正 這三 大特點。 witnessed the development of one of neighbouring restaurants and shops can
the defining ideologies of this city – law also benefit from the growth of visitors
and order. Through the visit to Tai Kwun, and gallery goers. Moreover, as a hub
visitors can learn more about the legal of contemporary art, it attracts artists,
system, which embraces fairness, curators and buyers to the district, which
transparency and access to justice, as a can also foster the growth of art business
pillar of Hong Kong’s success. in Hong Kong.
47 48
社會效益 經濟效益 環境效益
SOCIAL BENEFITS ECONOMIC BENEFITS ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS
課堂活動 CLASS ACTIVITY
建築過程涉及大量能源消耗。重用歷 The construction of a building involves
史建築則可以保留其「內含能源」, vast energy consumption. Reusing historic 課堂 討 論 保 育 和 活 化 再 用 如 何 推 動 城 市 可 持 續 發 展
CLASS DISCUSSION ON HOW CONSERVATION AND ADAPTIVE REUSE FOSTER
從而達致環境可持續性。此外,這亦 buildings can retain their “embodied
SUSTAINABLE URBAN DEVELOPMENT
可減少及避免拆卸和重建所造成的浪 energy”, so as to achieve environmental
一 節課(1-1.5 小時)1 lesson (1-1.5 hour)
費。 sustainability. Furthermore, it prevents 高 中學生
and minimises the wasteful process of Senior secondary school students.
大 館 活 化 工 程 保 育 了 16幢 歷 史 建 築 demolition and reconstruction. 讓 學生認識活化再用對城市可持續發展的重要性
物,它們並均按照現今的需要被賦予 Students can learn the importance of adaptive reuse in sustainable urban
development.
新用途。活化工程對建築物的干預減 Revitalisation of Tai Kwun involves
至最少,因此,工程既能為它們注入 conservation of 16 historic buildings and 時間 TIME 流 程 PROCEDURE
新生命,亦減少能源和材料的投放。 adaptive reuse to fit the current needs. 教師簡介活動及重溫活化再用及可持續發展的概念
5 分鐘
另外,建築群內只有兩幢新建築物, The buildings have undergone minimal Teacher introduces the activity and revisits the concepts of
5 M i n ute s
adaptive reuse and sustainable urban development.
它們均由回收材料建造,這有助保 intervention, and so little input in terms of
協助學生分組,5 至 6 人一組
護環境,及實現城市可持續發展的目 energy and material is needed for bringing
5 分鐘 Students are divided into groups of 5 to 6 people.
標。 them new lives. In addition, the two 5 M i n ute s 派發所需文具及畫紙予各組
newly constructed buildings are built with Every group is given stationery and drawing paper.
recycled materials. This also helps protect 學生須就以下題目分組作出討論:
the environment and achieve sustainable · 從社會、經濟及環境方面,討論保育及活化再用如何推動
urban development. 城市可持續發展。須引用大館或其他活化項目作討論例
子。
Students are expected to address the following question in the
group discussion:
30 分 鐘
30 M i nu te s · How can conservation and adaptive reuse foster sustainable
小資料 QUICK FACT
urban development in terms of SOCIAL, ECONOMIC AND
ENVIRONMENTAL aspects? The case of Tai Kwun or other
財政可持續性 Financial Sustainability
大館的活化工程,顧及社會效益和經濟收益之間的平衡。香港賽馬會轄下慈
revitalisation projects should be used as examples.
善信託基金捐出款項,用作大館翻新工程及發展的費用,以及開幕初年的營 學生須用概念圖在畫紙上記錄討論內容
運虧損。長遠而言,從零售及餐飲設施的租務收入,能幫助大館在財政上自 Students should draw a MIND MAP as a record of their discussions.
給自足。
30 分 鐘 教師可邀請各組作匯報分享。
The adaptive reuse of Tai Kwun considered the balance between social benefits and
30 M i nu te s Teacher may invite every group to PRESENT THEIR IDEAS.
economic returns. The donation from HKJC’s Charities Trust will cover the renovation
and development cost and the operating costs in the initial years. In the long run, 5 分鐘 教師總結活動
income sources such as the rents from retail and food and beverage facilities will help 5 Minutes Teacher concludes the activity.
Tai Kwun to be financially self-sustained.
49 50
建議答案 SUGGESTED ANSWERS
社 會 SOCIETY
保留社區的集體回憶
Preserve the collective memory of the community.
有助市民認識社區及香港歷史,從而提升社區凝聚力/歸屬感
Citizens can achieve a better understanding of society and Hong Kong history, hence
strengthening community cohesion/sense of belonging.
大館提供了古蹟及藝術方面的教育,以提升文化方面的生活素質
Tai Kwun’s heritage and arts education can enhance quality of life from cultural aspect.
提高市民的保育意識
Increase public awareness of conservation.
經 濟 E CON OM Y
促進文化旅遊業(古蹟、藝術遊)
Accelerate the development of cultural tourism (heritage and arts tourism).
促進當區的經濟發展(如:小商戶、餐廳)
Stimulate the economic development in the district (e.g. small businesses, restaurants).
環 境 E N V I R ON M E N T
增加市民休憩空間
Provide more leisure spaces.
減少城市的擠迫感,營造空間
Alleviate the urban crowdedness.
令城市/社區更美觀
Beautify the city/ community.
51 52
主要參考資料 REFERENCE
#
按 筆劃及字母排序
書目 國際古蹟遺址理事會(Australia ICOMOS):《文化紀念物與歷史場所維護與修復憲章》
何家騏、陳效能:《香港女警六十年》,香港:商務印書館,2015年。 (Charter for the Conservation and Restoration of Monuments and Sites), 1964年 。 擷取自
網頁 : http://www.icomos.org/charters/venice_e.pdf。
賽馬會文物保育有限公司:中區警署建築群活化計劃小冊子,2015年。
聯合國:2012年7月27日大會決議。擷取自網頁:http://www.un.org/ga/search/view_doc.
文章 asp?symbol=A/RES/66/288&referer=/english/&Lang=C。
香港警務署:〈第一代女督察 笑看風雲 細說往事〉,收於《警聲》699期,2001
年。擷取自網頁:http://www.police.gov.hk/offbeat/699/021_c.htm。 賽馬會文物保育有限公司:中區警署保育及活化計劃-考古調查報告,2011年9月。
香 港 警 務 署 : 〈 昔 日 警 隊 小 典 故 〉 , 收 於 《 警 聲 》 1 0 2 2 期 , 2 0 14 年 。 擷 取 自 網 Purcell Miller Tritton LLP. (2008, June). The Old Central Police Station and Victoria Prison Hong Kong:
頁:http://www.police.gov.hk/offbeat/1022/chi/1924.html。 Conservation Management Plan.
文件、新聞公報 網頁
立法會民政事務委員會文物保護小組委員會:活化再利用中區警署建築群-香港賽馬會 大館-古蹟及藝術館
的建議[討論文件],2007年。擷取自網頁: http://www.taikwun.hk/
http://www.legco.gov.hk/yr07-08/chinese/panels/ha/ha_hec/papers/ha_hec1113cb2-290-2-c.
pdf。 發展局工務科:香港歷史文物 - 保育.活化
https://www.heritage.gov.hk/en/conserve/central.htm
香港特別行政區政府:行政長官施政報告,2003年。
香港記憶:中區警署
香港賽馬會:「活化及保育中區警署建築群」公眾諮詢報告,2008年5月。擷取自網 http://www.hkmemory.org/central-police/
頁:http://www.taikwun.hk/media/Public_Consultation_Report_Chinese.pdf。
香港警務處:警隊歷史
發展局:政府與香港賽馬會攜手保育及活化中區警署[新聞稿],2008年7月15日。擷取自 http://www.police.gov.hk/ppp_tc/01_about_us/ph.html
網頁:http://www.devb.gov.hk/en/publications_and_press_releases/press/index_id_5458.
html。 香港懲教署:懲教署發展及香港刑法年誌
http://www.csd.gov.hk/tc_chi/about/about_history/abt_his.shtml
澳洲國際古蹟遺址理事會(Australia ICOMOS):《布拉憲章》(Burra Charter),1979
年,1999年及2013年修訂。擷取自網頁:http://australia.icomos.org/wp-content/uploads/ 康樂及文化事務署,古物古蹟辦事處
The-Burra-Charter-2013-Adopted-31.10.2013.pdf。 http://www.amo.gov.hk/b5/oe_central_police_station.php
53 54
筆記 NOTES
55 56
57 58
59 60
免責聲明 DISCLAIMER