Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 11

Tadris: Jurnal Keguruan dan Ilmu Tarbiyah 3 (2): 207-215 (2018)

DOI: 10.24042/tadris.v3i2.2941

English as a Second Language (ESL) Learning: Setting the Right


Environment for Second Language Acquisition

Haida Umiera Hashim, Melor Md Yunus*


Faculty of Education, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Malaysia

Abstract: Early exposure to English is very important as it is crucial


for learners to acquire English language at early age as English is a
Article History: global language that is used not only in the level of primary and
Received: September 4th, 2018 secondary school but also in tertiary level of education. Schools can
Revised: November 14th, 2018
Accepted: December 19th, 2018
be one of the important roles in influencing second language
Published: December 30th, 2018 acquisition, particularly English language. However, most schools
did not consider acquiring English from the perspective of learners’
fluency and rarely consider movements or approaches that they can
take to improve ESL learning among students. This study intended to
investigate the influence of school settings and routines on ESL
Keywords: learning among secondary students. A qualitative method is used in
ESL learning, this study as data were collected through the method of observation
School routines, and interview. The observation period throughout the process of
School settings, collecting data has been conducted based on a field note specifically
Second language acquisition,
prepared for this study. The participants involved in this study were
Secondary students.
all-girl school students located in Selangor. The gathered data were
then interpreted in the findings analysis. Based on this study, it was
proven that there are co-relations between the school settings and
routines on ESL learning among secondary students. It was found
*Correspondence Address: that school settings and routines do influence ESL learning among
melor@ukm.edu.my secondary students. Discussion and recommendations are further
explained in this study. Thus, it is hoped for future researchers to
conduct further research on related factors that might help to
contribute in ESL learning among ESL learners.

INTRODUCTION good in writing essays but not in


Various factors contribute to the communicating the language itself
success of Second Language Acquisition (Ghezlou & Biria, 2017; Khan & Khan,
(SLA) (Alves & Oliveira, 2014; Kalati, 2016). Schools play an important role in
2016). The learners’ environment and giving exposure to learners on the
setting have been acknowledged as an importance of English language and how
important one (Castello, 2015). Schools can they acquire the language (Ahmed,
are the place where English as a Second 2015; Nguyen & Terry, 2017).
Language (ESL) learners learn English Early exposure to English is very
other than at homes. Acquiring a language important as it is crucial for learners to
is not only understanding the concept or acquire English language at early age as
format of that language but being able to English is a global language that is used
speak the language fluently is what makes in basically everything not only in the
learners acquire the language (Dong & level of primary and secondary level
Ren, 2013). Some understand English and (Akcay, Butuner, & Arikan, 2015). In
© 2018 URPI Faculty of Education and Teacher Training
Universitas Islam Negeri Raden Intan Lampung
English as a Second Language … | H.U. Hashim, M.M. Yunus

Malaysia, English is accepted as the previous problems can be done by


second language and is widely used as a involving learners in performing two
medium of instruction in both formal and types of communicative tasks: focused,
informal settings. English is even used in communicative tasks and unfocused
tertiary level of education where every communicative tasks (Ellis, 2003). Both
lectures, journals, and books are all in of these tasks seek to engage learners in
English. According to the Deputy Prime using language pragmatically rather than
Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin, it is a displaying language. They seek to
priority to the government in getting develop language proficiency through
Malaysians to master English language as communication (Ellis, 2003).
the language played an important role in School setting in this study plays an
nation building (Shah, Othman, & Senom, important role as a catalyst to help ESL
2017; Thirusanku & Yunus, 2014). learners in the process of ESL learning.
Environment and setting could be one of School is the place where ESL learners
the best factors influencing ESL learning learn how to interact with peers, teachers,
among secondary students. School can be and staffs at school. Providing good
one of the important roles in influencing school setting and environment will be a
ESL learning (Akcay et al., 2015). This good medium in improving ESL learners’
statement indicates a crucial problem that language acquisition. Researches Firth
a lot of students face in learning and and Wagner mentioned that the
particularly communicating the second or interaction of social activity of learners
foreign language, specifically English with peers and environment is considered
language, in this case, many secondary as the best method of Second Language
learners express their problems related to Acquisition (Wagner, Altherr, Eckert, &
that and sometimes even acknowledge Jodl, 2007). Learning environment in
their inability in learning to speak English Hidden Curriculum 2014 is referred as the
(Akcay et al., 2015). diverse physical locations, contexts, and
It is only natural for students to cultures in which students learn, such as
encounter problems in learning. The outside-of-school locations and outdoor
dynamic of learning process could environments.
promote confusion and problems that As mentioned in a paper done by
could hinder the process of language Jantmary Thirusanku and Melor Md
acquisition. Students’ difficulties found Yunus (Thirusanku & Yunus, 2014), they
because of ineffective input and output, quoted on Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin’s
having no real need for interaction, claim regarding the first wave of the
attaching too much importance to Malaysian Education Blueprint Plan
language forms and written tests. Some 2013-2025 on an amount of 6100 English
learners also lack the motivation to speak Language teachers from primary and
English. They do not see a real need to secondary schools were retrained
learn or speak English (Al Hosni, 2014). nationwide to be more skilful in English
Some problems emerged in the language (Blueprint, 2015). The
students’ daily interaction as stated above. Malaysian Education Blueprint
The needs to interact in English need to emphasizes the importance of this
be fostered by raising the students’ language in schools and introduces many
awareness and understanding of why innovative teaching and learning
English should be mastered by them. The strategies to enhance students‘ English
students’ motivation should be paid a proficiency (Sidhu, Kaur, & Chi, 2018).
considerable attention since motivation is In The Government committed in
actually the driving force for the students promoting the use of English in schools to
to move further. For overcoming these ensure people, especially students to have

Tadris: Jurnal Keguruan dan Ilmu Tarbiyah 3 (2): 207-215 (2018) | 209
a better command of the language daily life is the part of the process of
(Thirusanku & Yunus, 2014). language learning. Harwati Hashim et al.
There are a lot of factors that might also mentioned in a study that language
contribute to ESL learning among learning process is not limited only within
secondary students. Therefore, this study the classroom but also may continue to
intends to see in what ways school setting happen in a conventional setting (Hashim,
can influence and affect ESL learning Yunus, & Embi, 2016). According to
among secondary students, especially in Supyan cited by Harwati Hashim et al.,
Malaysian context. It can further support, ESL students need social support or
or perhaps, disagree with past studies that scaffolding in improving their ESL
proves the influence of school setting and learning (Hashim et al., 2016).
routines on second language (L2) In today’s society, English is very
learning. important and is the most common global
language that is used for worldwide
THEORETICAL SUPPORT communication. The real situation that is
A simple way to define language currently happening in Malaysia is that
learning is the process which the language the English is used only in a limited or
capability develops in an individual. confined situations such as during any
Learning language per say takes presentation or written works that has to
strategies, and according to Wenden and be done in English, but other times,
Rubin, learning strategies can be defined Bahasa Malaysia is used. Learners are
as actions, steps, plans or routines taken lacking in exposure to the language as
by the learners in processing the there is quite a limited chances to use
information they received (Wendel, English outside of the classroom is one of
2011). Learners learn differently the causes that leads to limited English
according to their language learning styles proficiency among Malaysian learners
and preferences. Language learning and students. With all of this being said, it
cannot take place only in the brains of is obvious that learning English language
individual learners alone but are instead is one of big importance in today’s world.
related to social factors when learners In a study done by Ting et al., it is
interact in daily life with other people in important to provide an English-speaking
their surroundings in order to acquire the environment for Malaysian students’
language (Dil, Öğretildiği, & Sınıflarında, (Ting, Marzuki, Chuah, Misieng, &
2015; Yanti, Cole, & Hermon, 2017). The Jerome, 2017). Many students are very
results of research done by Stella show shy and afraid to speak English with other
that the context of metacognitive and friends (Cole, Hermon, & Yanti, 2015).
social strategies seems to play an This is then later agreed by Ansari and Al
important role in the learners’ strategy use Hosni in their study on speaking anxiety
in the process of acquiring new language in ESL/EFL classrooms whichhis
(Taquette & Minayo, 2017). This findings have found out that speaking
basically means that learning a language anxiety is the major cause that leads and
does not involve only the understanding contributes to learner’s language
of the theory and concept of the language. acquisition (Al Hosni, 2014; Ansari,
L2 learners also should be able to apply 2015). One’s effort and attempt to use and
the language itself in daily life depending communicate in English outside the
on the context and situation in order for classroom are seen by others as being
the language to be learnt or acquired. westernized and having the intention to
Interacting with other people using the abandon the use of Malay language, the
language and make use of the language in official language of Malaysia. Students
are also afraid of using broken English tests as a means to gauge students'
which is why schools somehow play an intelligence. He also created ZPD to
important role in setting the right further develop Jean Piaget's theory of
environment for learners’ language children being lone learners. The ZPD
acquisition where learners can speak concept is seen as a scaffolding; a
freely and not be afraid for using wrong structure of support points for performing
grammar or feel intimidated by other an action (Obukhova & Korepanova,
learners or the situation itself. 2009). This refers to the help or guidance
However, in regards to a whole received from an adult or more competent
school approach to supporting ESL peer to permit the child to work within the
learners, Idrus discusses in her study that ZPD.
there is a gap in current research Vygotsky’s theory of ZPD (Zone of
surrounding the importance of making Proximal Development) is to say that
personal connections to show greater learning awakens a variety of internal
empathy and support to ESL learners developmental processes that are able to
(Idrus & Nazri, 2016). Relatedly, we also function and work only when the child is
begin to learn that the whole school interacting with people in his environment
approaches to supporting ESL learners and communicating with his peers is an
have the potential to increase the important feature of learning. Vygotskian
academic and social success of the paradigms promotes the idea that learning
students. Idrus mentioned in her study is a social process that occurs when
that there has been minimal attention and learners interact, with an expert, with each
focus on whole school approaches in other and with their environment
helping and supporting ESL learners (Srivastava & Joshi, 2014). Srivastava
(Idrus & Nazri, 2016). Thus, she dan Joshi also mentioned in their study on
concluded in her study that the findings of how cognitive process happen to be
her study have shown that it is essential to helpful in the process of learning and
create inclusive, caring and risk-free mediated by social interaction which
school-wide environment for ESL results in the occurrence of learning
learners to succeed. Saad stated in her (Srivastava & Joshi, 2014). Through
finding that it is very crucial to provide interaction, learners will learn best.
good environmental conditions that are Interaction between learners can scaffold
able to assist and hamper English and assist in the L2 acquisition language.
language learning (Saad, 2015). In this way, social interaction is
ESL learning cannot be separated encouraged to help and improve learning.
by the initial capabilities of the students Vygotsky claims that the secret of
and how they are able to develop things effective learning came from the nature of
that they are lack of. The development the social interaction between two or
undergoes by the students could actually more people with different levels of skills
be monitored and thus, could be assisted and knowledge (Vygotsky, 1978).
in the specific aspects that need to be Motivation and attitude are could
improved. One theory that could be used also be considered an important point in
as a basis for such monitoring and ESL learning. How the students view the
assistance is the theory proposed by language and what kind of motivation
Vygotsky. The theory is well known as drives them could heavily affect its
the Zone of Proximal Development acquisition. It really isn’t possible to give
(ZPD). The concept of the zone of a simple definition of motivation, though
proximal development was originally one can list many characteristics of the
developed by Vygotsky to argue against motivated individual. For example, the
the use of academic, knowledge-based motivated individual is goal directed,

Tadris: Jurnal Keguruan dan Ilmu Tarbiyah 3 (2): 207-215 (2018) | 211
expends effort, is persistent, is attentive, notes were also included as the instrument
has desires (wants), exhibits positive of observation. Field notes were used to
affect, is aroused, has expectancies, record behaviors, activities, events or of
demonstrates self-confidence (self- setting being observed, in this situation
efficacy), and has reasons (motives) the school setting. Field notes helped in
(Kieinginna & Kleinginna, 1981). The observing a culture, setting or social
motivation to learn and acquire a second situation. The elements included in the
language is considered in the socio- field notes were as follows:
educational model of second language a. School Setting (includes the
acquisition (Gardner, 1985). Gardner’s environment of the school).
theory also argues that a positive attitude b. School Routines (includes all the
towards the second language community programs provided by the school in
is required in order to enhance the level of order to enhance students’ English
motivation to learn a second language and language proficiency).
a desire to become a part of that In order to further support the study
community is also equally important. and to answer the research question
mentioned, a casual but proper interview
METHOD with one of the students was done in
A school located in Petaling Jaya investigating her opinion as student on
had been chosen to be the participant for whether school settings and routines
this study due to its location which influence their English language learning.
situated exactly at the center of the city. The following is the flowchart of this
This study involved the whole school. study.
The particular school chosen is an all-girls
school located in Petaling Jaya. The Poor ASL
school consists of mix race students and
the participants in this study were all
selected randomly while the observation Observing
was conducted. The school had been
chosen due to its location and also due to
its history in a previous study by Rosli
Talif and Malachi Edwin that has been Observation
stated as one of the best urban area Interview
schools in Malaysia that shows a very
significant proofs of having mostly Field
proficient students in English language Notes
(Talif & Edwin, 2001).
A qualitative research strategy is
conducted which observation method was School Setting
selected as an instrument to collect the School Routines
data. Observations were conducted in that
particular school to observe the level of Better ASL
proficiency among secondary students. Figure 1. The Flowchart of the Study
Other than that, the most important part in
the observations conducted was the RESULT AND DISCUSSION
school’s settings and routines that have School Settings
been proven as one of the mediums in Based from the observation
language learning among secondary conducted, it can be seen that the school
students in that particular school. Field has such a good environment for the
students. The place is calming and has
all of the facilities that help students
to be able to learn perfectly. In terms of
acquiring language for secondary
students, it can be seen that the school
has
the perfect environment for students in and strategies in improving their students’
acquiring English as their second language proficiency in English language.
language. The school is famous for its School routines includes all of the
high proficient students who are fluent in activities that has been conducted by the
English. Based from the observation school in making students to get used to
conducted, it can be seen that most of the English language. In contrary to the
students of the school are all fluent in research findings from a study done by
English language. Most of the students in Idrus that says there is a gap in current
the school has high self-esteem, and they research surrounding the importance of
are very proficient in communicating in making personal connections to show
English language among themselves and greater empathy and support to ESL
even with other people (teachers, staffs, learners (Idrus & Nazri, 2016), it is found
etc.). One of the reasons is because of the from the observation conducted that the
school environment as has been supported school of study has done quite a lot of
and agreed by one of the students. “Yes!” activities that help students in improving
quoting the interviewee referring to their proficiency in English language.
researcher’s question of ‘Do you think These routines and programs are
that school is the main reason of your conducted regularly for the benefits of the
fluency and proficiency in English students. ’5-minutes English Reading
language.’ Everyone in that school mostly Routine’ is one of the activities conducted
interact and communicate in English with at the school. The routine needs students
each other including the teachers and to allocate 5 minutes of their time early in
staffs thus making students to feel more the morning on every Wednesdays to read
comfortable and more motivated to use any English materials before the learning
English in their daily interactions with the session begins. Apart from that, based on
society and community. The findings are the study, it has also been found that the
consistent with the findings from a study school has a routine of replacing every
paper done by Shobana and Zairus on Fridays’ assembly to a 20 minutes session
how social interaction is encouraged to of reading. Students are asked to read any
help and improve learning (Srivastava & English material during the assembly
Joshi, 2014). The findings are also time. This kind of routine help students to
parallel to the literature of Gardner and be able to train themselves to get used to
Lambert’s theory on how a positive reading and indirectly help expanding
attitude towards the second language their vocabulary in English language.
community is required to enhance the Reading is one of the best methods in
level of motivation to learn a second acquiring language.
language and a desire to become a part of Reading helps in improving
that community is also equally important. students’ level of accuracy in the use of
Apart from that, the school has a lot of English in their life. Students gain a lot
facilities that help students to be able to through reading and they sometimes
improve on their English language. Every acquire language through reading thus
corner of the school is occupied and filled maintaining a reading session weekly has
with English vocabulary that help been proven to be one of the best methods
students to get used to the words and in helping secondary students in acquiring
phrases of English language. language. Besides having the reading
programs as mentioned above, the school
School Routines also has a weekly routine of having Public
It takes practices and efforts in Speaking activity on every Tuesdays
order to acquire language. Every school in during assembly. Two volunteers were
the world obviously has taken their efforts chosen every week to perform their public

212 | Tadris: Jurnal Keguruan dan Ilmu Tarbiyah 3 (2): 207-215 (2018)
speaking during the morning assembly. school has helped her a lot in acquiring
This activity helps students to be able to English language. During the casual
get themselves used to speak and talk in interview, she mentioned in her statement:
public in front of the crowd without
feeling self-conscious and improving “I’ve always been a part of the Literature
students’ self-esteem in using English as Concert my school organizes annually
part of their daily routine. Feeling shy and each year, and I’ve participated in a few
scared to talk in public using English international English competition such as
language has always been the issue for the Sea Forensics. Thus I could fairly say
students when it comes to ESL learning. It my fluency in English boost up by
can be seen that through the program involving in various school-based
conducted by the school, majority of the programs and international competition
students in that school are not ashamed of the school participated in.”
talking in public. Most of the students are
participative and willing to speak in front The findings of the interview have
of public. This indirectly helps students’ shown that school routines do indirectly
level of proficiency by practicing their help students in boosting up their
fluency in speaking English language confidence level and produce sense of
casually. The findings are to be seen as belonging within students.
the strategies of the school in helping the
students to be more fluent in English CONCLUSION
language and to increase their level of School has been proven based on
proficiency. the findings of this present study, as one
On another note, as for the learning of the mediums for students to gain
session from the observation conducted, experiences in terms of sense-of-
English teachers are all encouraged to use belonging and confidence in the process
the worksheets and handouts in the of acquiring ESL. This suggests that
newspaper ‘The Star’ to be used in their students need to believe that they would
learning session. The motives of using the likely to get sufficient practice for
materials from the newspaper is for learning English language. This study also
students to be able to relate to real life believes that based from the findings of
with all the relatable themes provided in this present study, there are co-relations
the handouts and not restricting them to between school settings and routines with
only textbooks. The materials from the students’ performance on ESL learning.
newspaper are all interactive and The intersection point of these two
interesting thus help gaining students’ relations would be the motivation of the
attention to be more participative in the students as we can always enhance and
class during the teaching and learning improves students’ willingness to acquire
session. These routines help students to be ESL learning through motivations which
more confident in themselves in acquiring can always be provided by the school
and using the language at the same time. with the help of the teachers and the
These analysis have also included settings of the school. It has also been
the findings from an interview session proven that school settings and routines
with one of the students during the time of help students to have confidence, a sense
observation at the school to investigate of belonging and help them to maintain
the influence of school routines in their sense of optimism in their process of
language learning among secondary ESL learning and acquiring language.
students. Based on the interview, the It is believed that the findings of
interviewee mentioned that she thinks the this study can help both future and current
teachers to benefit from this study on Cole, P., Hermon, G., & Yanti. (2015).
gaining general ideas on how to help ESL Grammar of Binding in the
learners in acquiring L2 outside the languages of the world: Innate or
classroom by creating the right and learned? Cognition, 141.
suitable environment in helping learners https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.20
to acquire L2. However, there is no 15.04.005
specific measure to what extend do school Dil, Y., Öğretildiği, O., & Sınıflarında, D.
settings, and routines influence secondary (2015). Developing Critical Thinking
students’ learning on ESL as there are Skill In English Language Teaching
other possible factors that might Classes Through Novels.
contribute to the matter of acquiring International Journal of Language
language among secondary students. Academy, 3(2), 76–90.
Thus, it is hoped for future researchers to https://doi.org/http://dx.doi.org/10.18
have further researches on related factors 033/ijla.222
that might help to contribute in ESL Dong, G., & Ren, H. (2013). The Role of
learning among ESL learners. Age in Second Language Acquisition
A Psychological Perspective. British
REFERENCES Journal of English Linguistics, 1(1),
Ahmed, S. (2015). Attitudes towards 1–6.
English Language Learning among Ellis, R. (2003). Tasks-Based Language
EFL Learners at UMSKAL. Journal Learning and Teaching. Oxford
of Education and Practice, 6(18), 6– University Press.
17. Gardner, R. C. (1985). Social psychology
Akcay, A., Butuner, T. F., & Arikan, A. and second language learning: The
(2015). Reasons Behind Young role of attitudes and motivation.
Learners’ Learning of Foreign Arnold.
Languages. International Journal of Ghezlou, M., & Biria, R. (2017). On the
Language Academy, 3(2), 56–68. Relationship between Reading Self-
Al Hosni, S. (2014). Speaking Difficulties efficacy, Perceptual Learning Style
Encountered by Young EFL and the Use of Reading Strategies
Learners. International Journal on among Iranian EFL Learners.
Studies in English Language and International Journal of Literacies,
Literature (IJSELL), 2(6), 22–30. 19(4). https://doi.org/10.18848/2327-
Alves, S. M. L., & Oliveira, F. M. de. 0136/CGP/v19i04/48801
(2014). Vocabulary Acquisition in Hashim, H., Yunus, M. M., & Embi, M.
Second Language. International A. (2016). Pre-University English as
Journal of Humanities and Social Second Language (ESL) Learners’
Science, 4(13), 51–56. Attitude towards Mobile Learning.
Ansari, M. S. (2015). Speaking Anxiety in Creative Education, 7(8), 1147.
ESL/EFL Classrooms: A Holistic Idrus, F., & Nazri, N. I. M. (2016). The
Approach and practical study. Construction of Collective Identity in
International Journal of Education Malaysian ESL Secondary
Investigation, 2(4), 38–46. Classrooms. English Language
Blueprint, M. E. (2015). Blueprint 2015– Teaching, 9(10), 101.
2025 (Higher Education). Kalati, E. A. (2016). Learning Strategies
Castello, D. (2015). First Language in Second Language Acquisition.
Acquisition and Classroom Journal of Educational Studies
Language Learning: Similarities and Learning, 2(4), 4–8.
Differences. ELAL College of Arts & Khan, T. J., & Khan, N. (2016). Obstacles
Law, 1–18. in Learning English as a Second
Language among Intermediate Levels in English as a Second
Students of Districts Mianwali and Language Among Learners in
Bhakkar, Pakistan. Open Journal of Selected Rural and Urban Schools in
Social Sciences, 4, 154–162. Peninsular Malaysia. Paper
Kieinginna, P. R., & Kleinginna, A. M. Presented at the MELTA Home.
(1981). A Categorized List of Taquette, S. R., & Minayo, M. C. (2017).
Motivation Definitions , with a An analysis of articles on qualitative
Suggestion for a Consensual studies conducted by doctors
Definition. Motivation and Emotion, published in scientific journals in
5(3), 263–291. Brazil between 2004 and 2013.
Nguyen, H., & Terry, D. R. (2017). Physis Revista de Saúde Coletiva,
English Learning Strategies among 27(2), 357–374.
EFL Learners: A Narrative Thirusanku, J., & Yunus, M. M. (2014).
Approach. IAFOR Journal of Status of English in Malaysia. Asian
Language Learning, 3(1), 4–19. Social Science, 10(14), 254.
Obukhova, L. F., & Korepanova, I. A. Ting, S.-H., Marzuki, E., Chuah, K.-M.,
(2009). The Zone of Proximal Misieng, J., & Jerome, C. (2017).
Development. Journal of Russian Employers ’ Views on the
and East European Psychology, Importance of English Proficiency
47(6), 25–47. and Communication Skill for
https://doi.org/10.2753/RPO1061- Employability in Malaysia.
0405470602 Indonesian Journal of Applied
Saad, N. S. (2015). Environmental Linguistics, 7(2), 315–327.
Conditions for English Language Vygotsky, L. . (1978). Mind in Society.
Learning in Malaysia. European Cambridge: Harvard University
Journal of Language and Literature, Press.
3(1), 100–111. Wagner, A., Altherr, S., Eckert, B., &
Shah, S. S. A., Othman, J., & Senom, F. Jodl, H. (2007). Multimedia in
(2017). The Pronunciation Physics Education: Teaching Videos
Component in ESL Lessons: About Aero and Fluid Dynamics.
Teachers ’ Beliefs And Practices. European Journal of Physics, 28(1),
Indonesian Journal of Applied 33–37.
Linguistics, 6(2), 193–203. Wendel, P. (2011). Adding Value to
Sidhu, G. K., Kaur, S., & Chi, L. J. Force Diagrams: Representing
(2018). CEFR-aligned school-based Relative Force Magnitudes. The
assessment in the Malaysian primary Physics Teacher, 49(5), 308–311.
ESL classroom. Indonesian Journal Yanti, Cole, P., & Hermon, G. (2017).
of Applied Linguistics, 8(2), 452– The grammar of binding in the
463. languages of the world: A response
https://doi.org/10.17509/ijal.v8i2.133 to Reuland. Cognition, 168.
11 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.20
Srivastava, R., & Joshi, S. (2014). 17.04.001
Relationship between Self-concept
and Self-esteem in adolescents.
International Journal of Advanced
Research, 2(2), 36–43.
Talif, R., & Edwin, M. (2001). A
Comparative Study of the
Achievement and the Proficiency

You might also like