DSM

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 5

Neuroradiolog y / Head and Neck Imaging • Original Research

Hoxworth et al.
Digital Subtraction Myelography of Spinal CSF Leaks

Neuroradiology/Head and Neck Imaging


Original Research

The Role of Digital Subtraction


Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 129.67.118.203 on 05/12/19 from IP address 129.67.118.203. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

Myelography in the Diagnosis


and Localization of Spontaneous
Spinal CSF Leaks
Joseph M. Hoxworth1 OBJECTIVE. The objective of our study was to review the clinical utility of digital sub-
Terrence L. Trentman2 traction myelography for the diagnosis of spinal CSF leaks in patients with spontaneous in-
Amy L. Kotsenas 3 tracranial hypotension (SIH) and those with superficial siderosis.
Kent R. Thielen 3 MATERIALS AND METHODS. Procedure logs from 2007 to 2011 were reviewed to
Kent D. Nelson1 identify cases in which digital subtraction myelography was performed to diagnose spinal
CSF leaks. Electronic medical records were reviewed to obtain information regarding diag-
David W. Dodick 4
nosis and outcome. For patients to be included in the study, preprocedural spinal MRI had to
Hoxworth JM, Trentman TL, Kotsenas AL, Thielen show an extradural fluid collection spanning more than one vertebral level and postmyelo-
KR, Nelson KD, Dodick DW graphic CT had to confirm the presence of an active CSF leak. If digital subtraction myelog-
raphy successfully showed the site of the CSF leak, the location was documented.
RESULTS. Eleven patients (seven men and four women; mean age, 49.0 years) under-
went digital subtraction myelography during the study period. Six patients had SIH and five
patients had superficial siderosis. The extradural fluid collection on spinal MRI averaged a
length of 15.5 vertebral levels. Digital subtraction myelography successfully showed the site
of the CSF leak in nine of the 11 patients, and all of the dural tears were located in the tho-
racic spine between T3 and T11.
CONCLUSION. Digital subtraction myelography is a valuable diagnostic tool for the
localization of rapid spinal CSF leaks and should be considered in patients who are clinically
suspected to have a dural tear that is accompanied by a longitudinally extensive extradural
fluid collection on spinal MRI.

C
SF leaks along the spinal axis are adult-onset, slowly progressive sensorineural
now recognized as a cause of both hearing loss, gait ataxia, and cerebellar dysar-
spontaneous intracranial hypoten- thria. Similar to patients with SIH, a subset of
Keywords: digital subtraction myelography, dural tear, sion (SIH) and superficial siderosis superficial siderosis patients also have a longi-
spinal CSF leak, spontaneous intracranial hypotension, of the CNS [1, 2]. Although sharing spinal dural tudinally extensive extradural fluid collection
superficial siderosis defects as a cause, these entities have different in the spinal canal that communicates with the
clinical presentations. The clinical syndrome subarachnoid space through a dural defect, the
DOI:10.2214/AJR.11.8238
commonly referred to as SIH has a variety of closure of which has been associated with
Received November 16, 2011; accepted after revision associated spine imaging findings, one of which symptom stabilization or improvement [7, 9].
January 2, 2012. is an extradural fluid collection secondary to the Although the precise mechanism of chronic
1 CSF leak [3–6]. SIH prototypically manifests bleeding remains unclear, the link between
Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, 5777 E Mayo
Blvd, Phoenix, AZ 85054. Address correspondence to as an orthostatic headache and is potentially ac- spinal CSF leak and superficial siderosis is
J. M. Hoxworth (Hoxworth.Joseph@mayo.edu). companied by a wide range of other neurologic now well established.
symptoms. In patients with SIH, the spontane- Definitive treatment of a spinal CSF leak re-
2
Department of Anesthesiology, Mayo Clinic, Phoenix, AZ. ous spinal CSF leak culminates in decreased quires closure of the dural tear. Closure is per-
3
Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN.
buoyancy of the brain, which leads to down- formed surgically in most patients with superfi-
ward traction on pain-sensitive structures. In cial siderosis [7, 9]. When conservative medical
4
Department of Neurology, Mayo Clinic, Phoenix, AZ. contrast, superficial siderosis is caused by re- therapy or empirical lumbar epidural blood
current bleeding into the subarachnoid space patches fail to achieve durable symptom reso-
AJR 2012; 199:649–653 and results in subpial deposition of hemosid- lution, a smaller number of SIH patients require
0361–803X/12/1993–649
erin within the brain and spinal cord [7, 8]. a localized epidural blood patch, a targeted fi-
Patients with superficial siderosis character- brin glue injection, or surgery [1]. In these cas-
© American Roentgen Ray Society istically come to clinical attention because of es, treatment requires that the precise site of the

AJR:199, September 2012 649


Hoxworth et al.

Fig. 1—Gray lines show longitudinal extent of extradural fluid collections identified on preprocedural MRI of
C2 11 study patients who underwent digital subtraction myelography. Location of leak () is shown for patients in
whom site of CSF leak was ultimately identified. This was accomplished with digital subtraction myelography
C5 in 9 of 11 patients. Digital subtraction myelography was unsuccessful in localizing the CSF leak in two patients.
Patient 7 was unable to undergo additional evaluation because of declining health, so the site of CSF leak is
T1
not known. The CSF leak in patient 8 was localized with dynamic CT myelography after digital subtraction
myelography was unsuccessful.
Vertebral Level

T4
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 129.67.118.203 on 05/12/19 from IP address 129.67.118.203. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

T7

T10

L1

L4

S2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Patient No.

A B C
Fig. 2—54-year-old man with superficial siderosis and CSF leak at T3 from remote fracture.
A, Sagittal T2-weighted image of thoracic spine shows ventral extradural fluid collection (arrowheads) dorsally displacing dura. Because fat-suppressed imaging was not
available for review, this collection was confirmed to represent fluid through comparison with T1-weighted sequences (not shown).
B, Axial CT myelogram through T3 level confirms that ventral extradural fluid collection (asterisk) freely communicates with subarachnoid space. Dorsally displaced dura
(arrowheads) is visible as thin line.
C, Lateral digital subtraction myelographic image is annotated to designate normal flow of contrast material within subarachnoid space (black arrows), site of CSF leak
at T3 (white arrow), and contrast material spreading within extradural fluid collection (arrowheads). For reference, please note that left side and top of digital subtraction
myelographic image correspond to anterior and cephalad aspects of patient, respectively.

CSF leak be known. Although noninvasive im- techniques is typically needed to conclusively material injected into the subarachnoid space
aging of the spine with MRI may show features document the exact site of the dural defect. via lumbar puncture may egress from the the-
that indicate the presence of a CSF leak in both In patients with a dural tear accompanied by cal sac too rapidly to allow identification of the
cohorts, additional testing with myelographic a sizeable extradural fluid collection, contrast site of the dural tear. Although routine postmy-

650 AJR:199, September 2012


Digital Subtraction Myelography of Spinal CSF Leaks

in the electronic medical record to obtain informa- patients experienced procedure-related com-
tion regarding diagnosis and follow-up. The patients plications. The cohort was composed of sev-
had undergone preprocedural MRI of the entire en men and four women with a mean age of
spine that included sagittal and axial T2-weighted 49.0 years (range, 28–75 years). Six of the pa-
sequences. A board-certified neuroradiologist re- tients met the criteria established in the sec-
viewed the spinal MRI examinations to confirm the ond edition of the International Classification
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 129.67.118.203 on 05/12/19 from IP address 129.67.118.203. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

presence of and determine the length of the extradu- of Headache Disorders [12] for headache at-
ral fluid collection. In addition to the presence of an tributed to spontaneous or idiopathic low CSF
abnormal extradural fluid collection within the spi- pressure (i.e., SIH), whereas superficial sider-
nal canal spanning more than one vertebral level on osis had been diagnosed in the other five pa-
preprocedural MRI, extradural contrast material had tients. The duration of symptoms ranged from
to be seen on postmyelographic CT to confirm the 3 months to 7 years (mean ± SD, 31.5 ± 25.0
presence of an active CSF leak. Patients with con- months). All patients had an abnormal ventral-
traindications for lumbar puncture or iodinated con- predominant extradural fluid collection on spi-
trast administration were not permitted to undergo nal MRI spanning an average of 15.5 vertebral
digital subtraction myelography. levels (SD, 5.1 vertebral levels), and the site of
The digital subtraction myelographic procedure the CSF leak relative to each extradural fluid
has previously been described in detail [11]. As is collection is illustrated in Figure 1. Routine
standard for myelography at our institution, nei- postmyelographic CT uniformly confirmed
ther IV conscious sedation nor general anesthe- the presence of an active spinal CSF leak in
sia was necessary. In brief, the patient was placed all patients through the clear communication
Fig. 3—31-year-old woman with spontaneous in the prone position on the fluoroscopy table. Ei- of contrast medium between the subarachnoid
intracranial hypotension and CSF leak at T8–T9 from ther through table tilt or elevation of the pelvis with space and extradural fluid (Fig. 2B).
transdural disk extrusion. Lateral digital subtraction foam padding, the lumbar spinal canal was elevated The site of the CSF leak was visualized
myelographic image is annotated to designate normal
flow of contrast material within subarachnoid space to a higher gravitational position relative to the cer- on digital subtraction myelography as active
(black arrows), site of CSF leak at T8–T9 (white vical and thoracic spine. Given that the entire spine extravasation of contrast medium from the
arrow), and contrast spreading within extradural cannot be visualized simultaneously because of the thecal sac in nine of the 11 patients (Figs.
fluid collection (arrowheads). For reference, please
note that left side and top of digital subtraction
limited size of the image intensifier, the region of
myelographic image correspond to anterior and greatest suspicion based on prior spinal MRI and
cephalad aspects of patient, respectively. other cross-sectional imaging, if available, was tar-
geted. Specifically, most of the extradural fluid col-
lection was included in the imaging field with partic-
elographic CT usually confirms the presence ular attention directed toward known predisposing
of a CSF leak in these cases, localization of factors for dural tear such as transdural disk extru-
the dural tear may not be possible because the sion, a focally prominent osteophyte, a remote ver-
extravasated contrast material in the epidural tebral compression fracture, and so on. Radiopaque
space spans multiple vertebral levels. Dynamic skin markers were placed to allow reliable postpro-
CT myelography was introduced in an attempt cedure vertebral numbering. Lumbar puncture was
to overcome this latter limitation, but the tem- performed in the usual fashion with a 20-gauge spi-
poral resolution of this technique remains in- nal needle. While patient respiration was suspend-
adequate in some cases [10]. Digital subtrac- ed and during the steady intrathecal infusion of ap-
tion myelography was subsequently reported proximately 12–16 mL of iopamidol (Isovue M 200,
as an alternative means of localizing these rap- Bracco Diagnostics) or iohexol (Omnipaque 300,
id spinal CSF leaks [11]. The goal of the cur- GE Healthcare), a digital subtraction acquisition at a
rent study was to review the diagnostic utility film rate of 3–6 frames per second was performed in
of digital subtraction myelography in a series the lateral plane; the anteroposterior plane was add-
of patients with documented spinal CSF leaks. ed when biplane equipment was available. Local-
ization of the CSF leak with digital subtraction my-
Materials and Methods elography was defined as identification of contrast
This retrospective study was approved by our in- material clearly diverging from the normal contrast Fig. 4—57-year-old man with superficial siderosis
stitutional review board. The procedure logs at our stream within the subarachnoid space. and CSF leak at T6–T7 from focal disk osteophyte.
institution for the period from November 1, 2007 Descriptive statistics were calculated using Mi- Lateral digital subtraction myelographic image is
annotated to designate normal flow of contrast
(beginning with the index case for which digital sub- crosoft Excel 2011 for Macintosh (Apple). material within subarachnoid space (black arrows),
traction myelography was developed), through July site of CSF leak at T6–T7 (white arrow), and contrast
31, 2011, were reviewed to identify cases in which Results material spreading within extradural fluid collection
(arrowheads). For reference, please note that left
digital subtraction myelography was performed. All A total of 11 patients underwent digital sub- side and top of digital subtraction myelographic
of the patients underwent evaluation by a board-cer- traction myelography during the study period image correspond to anterior and cephalad aspects
tified neurologist, and clinical notes were reviewed and were included in the analysis. None of the of patient, respectively.

AJR:199, September 2012 651


Hoxworth et al.

Fig. 5—38-year-old man with spontaneous intracranial


hypotension and CSF leak to right of midline at T11
from unknown cause. Genetic predisposition to dural
fragility was presumed because of his history of
multiple previous spontaneous CSF leaks involving
different spinal levels.
A, Lateral digital subtraction myelographic image is
annotated to designate normal flow of contrast material
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 129.67.118.203 on 05/12/19 from IP address 129.67.118.203. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

within subarachnoid space (black arrows), site of CSF


leak at T11 (white arrow), and contrast material spreading
within extradural fluid collection (arrowheads). For
reference, please note that left side and top of digital
subtraction myelographic image correspond to anterior
and cephalad aspects of patient, respectively.
B, In frontal projection, site of CSF leak is visualized
as double-density sign (white arrows) superimposed
on contrast material within subarachnoid space
(black arrows). Please note that left side and top of
digital subtraction myelographic image correspond
to left and cephalad aspects of patient, respectively.
(Because patient was in prone position, normal
radiographic convention was not followed.)

A B

2–5). Because of the ventral location of the been managing their symptoms with con- ning multiple vertebral levels tend to behave
dural tears, the CSF leaks were typical- servative treatment. As we noted earlier, analogous to pseudomeningoceles in which
ly best visualized in the lateral projection, the poor medical condition of one patient the fluid freely communicates with the sub-
but the anteroposterior plane was useful for with superficial siderosis precluded further arachnoid space. This equilibration permits
defining laterality in some instances (Fig. workup and treatment. the rapid extravasation of contrast material,
5B). Of the nine cases confirmed with digi- often in a matter of seconds, from the thecal
tal subtraction myelography, the most com- Discussion
mon cause for the dural tear was a focally Spontaneous spinal CSF leaks have been
prominent disk osteophyte (five patients). firmly established as a cause of SIH, and spinal
An additional patient had a noncalcified dural tears are also an increasingly recognized
transdural disk extrusion. Two patients had association with superficial siderosis [1, 2].
a history of remote trauma with associated In both of these instances, routine MRI of the
mild vertebral compression fractures at the spine and conventional CT myelography are
site of CSF leak. One patient had no clear frequently sufficient to suggest the presence of
structural cause for the dural tear but had a CSF leak but may not offer conclusive local-
a presumed genetic predisposition to dural ization. Targeted minimally invasive therapies
fragility given his history of multiple pre- and surgical approaches, when necessary, re-
vious spontaneous CSF leaks involving dif- quire precise localization of the site of the CSF
ferent spinal levels. leak, and additional myelographic techniques
Of the two patients in whom digital sub- have been developed and used successfully for
traction myelography was nondiagnostic, this purpose. Dynamic CT myelography with
the CSF leak is presumed to have been a intrathecal administration of contrast material
slow process that could not readily be vis- performed during CT acquisition improves the
ualized during the brief 20- to 30-second likelihood of visualizing the site of a CSF leak
digital subtraction myelographic acquisi- [10]. Although offering superior anatomic de-
tion. The clinical condition of one patient tail, dynamic CT myelography may still not be
with superficial siderosis deteriorated sec- able to localize very rapid CSF leaks, so digi-
ondary to multiple medical comorbidities, tal subtraction myelography was developed as
and no further workup was undertaken for an adjunct test that provides improved tempo- Fig. 6—Lateral digital subtraction myelography
of cervical spine with left side and top of digital
his CSF leak. The second patient with SIH ral resolution [11]. subtraction myelographic image corresponding
had a partially calcified disk extrusion at The results of the current retrospective to anterior and cephalad aspects of 42-year-old
T11–T12, which was confirmed as the site study confirm that digital subtraction my- man with spontaneous intracranial hypotension,
respectively. Visualization of myelographic
of the CSF leak on subsequently performed elography is a useful test for the localization contrast material near cervicothoracic junction
dynamic CT myelography. of spinal dural tears in select patients. In our is impaired because of radiation attenuation from
Six patients (two of six with SIH, four of experience, the rapidity of a spinal CSF leak shoulders (arrows). In addition, ventral projection of
five with superficial siderosis) underwent can be estimated through an analysis of pre- contrast material within normal nerve root sleeves
(arrowheads) could potentially obscure contrast
primary surgical closure of the dural tear. procedural spinal MRI. Elongated extradural material extravasating into ventral epidural fluid
The remaining four patients with SIH have fluid collections within the spinal canal span- collection.

652 AJR:199, September 2012


Digital Subtraction Myelography of Spinal CSF Leaks

sac into the extradural collection. As a result, the next step. Again, limiting the digital sub- radiological findings in nine patients with sponta-
the injection of intrathecal contrast material traction myelographic technique to patients neous intracranial hypotension. Neuroradiology
in the fluoroscopy suite using a standard my- with multilevel extradural fluid collections is 2002; 44:143–150; discussion, 151–152
elographic technique followed by transfer of an important part of preprocedural screen- 5. Watanabe A, Horikoshi T, Uchida M, Koizumi H,
the patient to CT for cross-sectional imaging ing. For example, routine CT myelography Yagishita T, Kinouchi H. Diagnostic value of spi-
allows too much time to elapse. The extra- usually works well in evaluating patients nal MR imaging in spontaneous intracranial hy-
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 129.67.118.203 on 05/12/19 from IP address 129.67.118.203. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved

dural contrast material has frequently already who have small, localized extradural fluid potension syndrome. AJNR 2009; 30:147–151
disseminated over multiple vertebral levels collections. Other patients with CSF leaks 6. Rabin BM, Roychowdhury S, Meyer JR, Cohen
so that localization of the dural tear is not that are suspected to be slow or intermit- BA, LaPat KD, Russell EJ. Spontaneous intracra-
successful. Dynamic CT myelography offers tent, as is often the case with CSF leaks from nial hypotension: spinal MR findings. AJNR
greatly improved temporal resolution com- meningeal diverticula, require techniques 1998; 19:1034–1039
pared with conventional postmyelograph- that afford delayed imaging. Although de- 7. Kumar N, Cohen-Gadol AA, Wright RA, Miller
ic CT but is unable to achieve the multiple layed imaging can be accomplished with CT, GM, Piepgras DG, Ahlskog JE. Superficial sider-
frames per second acquired with digital sub- the added radiation exposure is undesirable osis. Neurology 2006; 66:1144–1152
traction myelography. Consequently, when and the gravitational dependence of iodin- 8. Koeppen AH, Michael SC, Li D, et al. The pathol-
a patient with a suspected rapid spinal CSF ated contrast material requires the patient ogy of superficial siderosis of the central nervous
leak is referred for myelography, intrathe- to remain in the recumbent position. Radio- system. Acta Neuropathol 2008; 116:371–382
cal injection of contrast material using digi- nuclide cisternography has the advantage of 9. Kumar N. Superficial siderosis: associations and
tal subtraction myelography is now frequent- delayed imaging and has been used success- therapeutic implications. Arch Neurol 2007;
ly performed at our institution to overcome fully but often must rely on indirect signs of 64:491–496
the temporal limitations of other techniques. CSF leak for diagnosis because the lack of 10. Luetmer PH, Mokri B. Dynamic CT myelography:
In spite of the 82% success rate in local- spatial detail precludes direct localization a technique for localizing high-flow spinal cere-
izing the site of the dural tear in this series, of the CSF leak in many cases [13–15]. As brospinal fluid leaks. AJNR 2003; 24:1711–1714
digital subtraction myelography has sever- a result, the intrathecal injection of gadolin- 11. Hoxworth JM, Patel AC, Bosch EP, Nelson KD.
al potential limitations that must be consid- ium-based contrast agents for MR myelogra- Localization of a rapid CSF leak with digital sub-
ered when determining whether this imag- phy has shown increased promise in patients traction myelography. AJNR 2009; 30:516–519
ing technique is appropriate for a given case. who require delayed imaging [16–18]. Spe- 12. Headache Classification Subcommittee of the In-
First, the digital subtraction acquisition is ex- cifically, the gadolinium contrast agent re- ternational Headache Society. The international
tremely sensitive to motion degradation, so mains better dispersed within the subarach- classification of headache disorders: 2nd edition.
patients must be able to comfortably suspend noid space rather than moving to the most Cephalalgia 2004; 24(suppl 1):9–160
respiration in the prone position. With ap- gravitationally dependent region. Gadolini- 13. Hyun SH, Lee KH, Lee SJ, et al. Potential value of
propriate patient counseling, we have found um permits patients to be active and perform radionuclide cisternography in diagnosis and
general anesthesia with suspended respira- provocative maneuvers while waiting to un- management planning of spontaneous intracrani-
tion is not necessary for diagnostic-quality dergo delayed imaging hours after injection. al hypotension. Clin Neurol Neurosurg 2008;
imaging. Second, the detection of cervical Because intrathecal injection of gadolini- 110:657–661
and upper thoracic CSF leaks may be lim- um-based contrast material is not approved 14. Hashizume K, Watanabe K, Kawaguchi M, Taoka
ited on digital subtraction myelography for by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, T, Shinkai T, Furuya H. Comparison of computed
technical reasons. The added density of the MR myelography represents an off-label use. tomography myelography and radioisotope cister-
patient’s shoulders can make the stream of However, recent data are increasingly sup- nography to detect cerebrospinal fluid leakage in
myelographic contrast agent appear attenu- portive of its safety profile [16]. spontaneous intracranial hypotension. Spine (Ph-
ated, and the normal anterolateral projection In conclusion, digital subtraction myelog- ila Pa 1976) 2012; 37:E237–E242
of cervical nerve root sleeves could poten- raphy is a valuable diagnostic tool for the 15. Morioka T, Aoki T, Tomoda Y, et al. Cerebrospi-
tially mask a ventral CSF leak (Fig. 6). Last, localization of rapid spinal CSF leaks and nal fluid leakage in intracranial hypotension syn-
the duration of the digital subtraction acqui- should be considered in patients who are drome: usefulness of indirect findings in radionu-
sition is only 20–30 seconds, so some CSF clinically suspected to have a dural tear that clide cisternography for detection and treatment
leaks may not be rapid enough to be visual- is accompanied by a longitudinally extensive monitoring. Clin Nucl Med 2008; 33:181–185
ized. Slow leaks presumably occurred in the extradural fluid collection on spinal MRI. 16. Albayram S, Kilic F, Ozer H, Baghaki S, Kocer N,
two cases in this series for which the sites of Islak C. Gadolinium-enhanced MR cisternogra-
the CSF leaks were not identified with digital References phy to evaluate dural leaks in intracranial hypo-
subtraction myelography. 1. Schievink WI. Spontaneous spinal cerebrospinal tension syndrome. AJNR 2008; 29:116–121
If digital subtraction myelography fails to fluid leaks. Cephalalgia 2008; 28:1345–1356 17. Dillon WP. Intrathecal gadolinium: its time has
identify the site of a CSF leak but longitudi- 2. Kumar N. Neuroimaging in superficial siderosis: come? AJNR 2008; 29:3–4
nally extensive extradural fluid is present on an in-depth look. AJNR 2010; 31:5–14 18. Vanopdenbosch LJ, Dedeken P, Casselman JW,
spinal MRI, then we typically examine the 3. Medina JH, Abrams K, Falcone S, Bhatia RG. Vlaminck SA. MRI with intrathecal gadolinium
region of interest using dynamic CT myelog- Spinal imaging findings in spontaneous intracra- to detect a CSF leak: a prospective open-label co-
raphy on a different day, to allow the previ- nial hypotension. AJR 2010; 195:459–464 hort study. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2011;
ously injected contrast medium to clear, as 4. Chiapparini L, Farina L, D’Incerti L, et al. Spinal 82:456–458

AJR:199, September 2012 653

You might also like