Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kashmir Insight February 2020
Kashmir Insight February 2020
Vol: 26 No. 03
Monthly March 2020
INSIGHT
T
leaders’ claim that Jammu and Kashmir is an
attained the international attention post internal matter of India.
India’s 5th August 2019 move of repealing It is a fact that New Delhi wants to maintain
the special status of occupied Kashmir and status quo on Kashmir as far as its international
putting the territory under military siege and dimension is concerned. Its intransigence on the
communications blockade. Ever since, the Kashmir dispute has kept the peace, security and
residents of the Kashmir Valley are facing the prosperity of the region hostage for the last
unspeakable hardships due to the continued over seven decades. The inaction of the world
lockdown. community over their brutalities on the people of
The prevailing grim situation and the tension occupied Kashmir has emboldened Indian
between Pakistan and India have prompted the forces’ personnel bestowed with unbridled
world leaders including the UN Secretary powers under draconian laws to keep committing
General, Antonio Guterres, and the US war crimes in the territory to intimidate the
President, Donald Trump, to articulate their Kashmiris into
concerns. They have submission. However,
offered mediation on despite exhausting all
the Kashmir dispute its resources and
more than once. Very
EDITORIAL
using all brutal
recently, the UN chief tactics, New Delhi has
during his visit to miserably failed to
Pakistan said that subdue the freedom
the Kashmir dispute sentiment of the
needed to be settled Kashmiri people who
as per the UN are committed to
Security Council resolutions. President Trump continue their struggle till the achievement of
while visiting India stated that he is ready to do their right to self-determination promised to
anything he can to help in resolving the Kashmir them by the world community through several UN
dispute. Security Council resolutions.
Earlier, other world leaders including the Unfortunately, the world leaders have so far
Turkish President, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, remained confined to mere issuing statements on
Malaysian Prime Minister, Dr Mahathir the precarious situation in occupied Kashmir
Mohamad, the US lawmakers, the members of and they have not taken practical measures to
British and European Parliaments, the UN hold India accountable for its atrocities on the
human rights chief, Michelle Bachelet, the innocent people of Kashmir. Now they must
Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch acknowledge the reality that Modi-led fascist
have also expressed their concerns over the Indian government’s Hindutva ideology has
precarious human rights situation in occupied endangered the peace of entire world. They
Kashmir in the wake of repeal of special status of should come forward in a big way and initiate
the territory by India. practical measures for the settlement of the
Even the UN Security Council has twice held Kashmir dispute in accordance with the
discussion on the situation of occupied Kashmir Kashmiris’ aspirations. The UN Security Council
since August last year and this development in resolutions, which provide the best roadmap for
itself is a manifestation of the fact that Kashmir is achieving this objective, must be implemented
a disputed territory and rejection of Indian without any further delay.
S
Constitution and placed the
Narendra Modi’s fascist government expedited its efforts to territory under military
undermine Muslims in the country. Modi - a Hindu lockdown, which continued
nationalist and follower of Hindutva ideology of extremist Hindu when this report was written.
organisation, Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh - rose to political On August 31, 2019, the Indian
prominence in the early 2000s in a country that includes one of the government published a new
world’s largest Muslim populations as the chief minister of Gujarat. citizens’ register in the
Over two thousand Muslims were butchered by Hindu extremists in northeastern state of Assam
anti-Muslim violence in Gujarat in 2002 during Modi’s tenure as that left nearly two million
chief minister. He was widely accused of failing to stop the riots and residents without citizenship in
had used the mass murder of Muslims in Gujarat to his political any country. The deeply flawed
advantage. He was first elected as Prime Minister of India in 2014 process was widely understood
and since his re-election in May 2019 he has very much doubled his as an effort to exclude Muslims,
efforts to implement the RSS agenda of turning India into a Hindu many of whom were
state. Modi’s first term as prime minister saw Muslims being descendents of Bengalis who
lynched on the suspicion of transporting beef or slaughtering cows, arrived in Assam during the
considered sacred by many Hindus. colonial era. Those found to be
On August 5, 2019 the Modi government revoked the special status undocumented immigrants
of occupied Kashmir by repealing the Article 370 of the Indian were expected to be placed in
detention camps.
The Modi government then
passed a law, Citizenship
(Amendment) Act (CAA) in
December 2019 that excludes
Muslim immigrants to India of
certain citizenship eligibilities.
This law permits pre-2014
migrants from the neighbouring
Muslim-majority countries of
Bangladesh, Pakistan and
Afghanistan who are Hindu,
Christian, Jain, Buddhist and
Sikh, but not Muslim, to become
experienced mob violence, the likes of which it had not seen since the
Indian citizens. This anti-
1980s. Hindu mobs descended on poor neighbourhoods, attacking
Muslim law sparked massive
Muslims and ransacking their houses and businesses. Over 50
protests across India during
people died and more than 250 got injured during the violence.
which more than 25 people were
Indeed, the ominous signs were visible on February 23 itself, on the
killed in December 2019.
eve of US President Donald Trump’s arrival in India, when BJP
The new citizenship laws and
politician, Kapil Mishra, issued a chilling threat to Muslim women
repeal of special status of
protesting against the Citizenship Amendment Act in the Maujpur
occupied Kashmir have stoked
area of New Delhi. With police
officials standing beside him,
Mishra declared openly that he
would do nothing until Trump was
in town but as soon as the visiting
dignitary left on February 24, he
would organise a Hindu mob and
drive out the protesters. However,
the mobs did not even wait for
February 24. The attacks began
hours later on February 23 itself.
And for four days, Delhi Police
stood by, or took part in lynching
Muslims, as Delhi burned.
Jafrabad was one of the worst-hit
localities of New Delhi, a city that
fears that Modi's master plan is was marred by violence for four days. Mobs were seen wielding sticks
to remold India as a Hindu and pipes walking down streets in parts of northeast Delhi amid
nation and change the arson attacks and looting. Many of the wounded had suffered
demographic composition of the gunshot injuries. At least two mosques in northeast Delhi were set on
occupied territory. fire. The properties of Muslims were particularly targeted in the riots.
In late February 2020, New New Delhi High Court Judge, Justice S Muralidhar, who grilled the
Delhi, India's capital city central and state governments on February 25 over the violence in
U
N Secretary General, Antonio Guterres, visited Pakistan
from February 16 to 19, 2020 and called for the serving with full dedication and
implementation of the UN resolutions on Kashmir - giving a commitment to promote the
strong boost to Pakistan’s stance on the Kashmir dispute. values of the UN.
The Secretary General visited Pakistan to attend the international The UN Secretary General said
conference on 40 Years of Hosting Afghan Refugees in the country. It that Pakistan’s efforts against
was his maiden visit to Pakistan. In 2010 Ban Ki-Moon, the then terrorism were commendable
Secretary General of UN, visited Pakistan. and very successful. He said
The UN chief offered his role as a mediator, saying that his good that due to these efforts, now
offices could be used for the resolution of the Kashmir dispute. Islamabad had become a safe
Speaking at a joint news conference along with Pakistan Foreign family station for the UN staff.
Minister, Shah Mahmood Qureshi, in Islamabad, Antonio Guterres Speaking on the occasion,
said that full respect should be given to human and fundamental Foreign Minister, Shah
rights in occupied Kashmir. He said that the relevant UN resolutions Mahmood Qureshi, said that he
should be implemented on the issue. The UN chief said that Pakistan and the UN chief had a very
under Prime Minister, Imran Khan, was promoting peace and important and fruitful meeting
lamented India’s aggressive attitude. He said it is now high time that on the matter of Kashmir, a land
the world gets to see the positive image of Pakistan. which has illegally been
Talking about Pak-India relations, Antonio Guterres stressed the annexed and is being kept under
his delegation. During his stay He particularly conveyed his the Security Council must go on
in Lahore, the UN Secretary regard to the UN chief for for the resolution of Jammu and
General attended various demanding full respect for Kashmir dispute. Silence at that
functions and visited some human rights and fundamental highest forum is unacceptable
historic places in the city freedom for the people of and unfair to the people of
including Shahi Qila and occupied Kashmir just like it is occupied Kashmir, who are
Badshahi Mosque and being enjoyed by the people of under siege and being killed and
Kartarpur Gurdwara. A dinner Azad Jammu and Kashmir. brutalised every day. “The
was also arranged in his honour “Don’t take India’s ‘no’ for the extremist ruling party in India
at the Shahi Qila. use of good offices or diplomacy wants the international
While meeting the UN chief at and dialogue in accordance with community to be silent on the
the Foreign Office in Islamabad, the United Nations’ Charter. Kashmir conflict in order to hide
Azad Jammu and Kashmir This is a collective obligation of its crimes. The UN has spoken
President, Sardar Masood Khan, all nations. One UN member up and must continue to speak
also invited Antonio Guterres to cannot hold the entire up for Kashmiris,” he told the UN
v i s i t Secretary General.
Muzaffarabad, The AJK President
the capital of went on to say that
AJK. the UN is the flag-
S a r d a r bearer of the
Masood Khan international order
appreciated based on the rule of
the UN chief’s law. “The UN
offer to play Secretary General
role as a is seen as an
‘mediator’ international icon
between India w h o s h o u l d
and Pakistan demonstrate
to de-escalate leadership to save
tensions and for stressing on the organisation hostage by its humanity from the scourge of
resolution of the Kashmir obduracy,” the AJK President war and liberate people living
dispute in accordance with the said. under alien domination and
UN Security Council He also apprised the UN foreign occupation,” he added.
resolutions. Secretary General about the He also thanked Guterres for
Briefing Antonio Guterres about highly concerning and holding detailed conversations
the condition of 40,000 refugees precarious situation of the in the past with the Indian Prime
living in camps in Azad Kashmir civilians living along the LoC in Minister, Narendra Modi, and
and the plight of 640,000 AJK because of India’s frequent other leaders. “War would be a
civilians living along the Line of and unrelenting hostile fire devastating aberration for
Control (LoC), the AJK President while proposing Guterres to humanity, peace and
expressed his heartfelt gratitude make the submission of the reconciliation are a historic
to the Secretary General for UNMOGIP reports to the UN imperative in the region. This is
calling for de-escalating the Secretary General’s office and only possible by ensuring the
tensions between India and their circulation to all members realisation of the right to self-
Pakistan - both militarily and of the UN Security Council determination of the people of
verbally - especially along the mandatory. Kashmir,” he maintained.
LoC. “Conversations on Kashmir in (KI Report)
T
he delegation of All Parties Parliamentary Group on Pakistan but was pro-human
Kashmir (APPGK) in the British Parliament, whom India rights”.
denied a visit to Kashmir, visited Pakistan and Azad Debbie Abrahams along with
Jammu and Kashmir from February 19 to 23, 2020. the delegation in a meeting
The delegation was led by Debbie Abrahams, Member of the UK with the Foreign Minister,
Parliament and Chairperson of APPGK. The other members of Shah Mahmood Qureshi, in
the delegation included APPGK senior Vice Chairman Barrister Islamabad stressed that
Imran Hussain MP; Secretary, Lord Qurban Hussain; Treasurer, international community
James Daly MP; Shadow Minister for International must take the issue on priority
Development, Judith Commins MP; Mark Eastwood MP; Tahir and “make sure that human
Ali MP; Sarah Britcliffe MP; Raja Najabat Hussain, Chairman rights are not negotiable,
Jammu and Kashmir Self-Determination Movement regardless of religion,
International (JKSDMI); Councilor Yasmin Dar, Chairperson ethnicity, age and gender”.
JKSDMI-UK; and Harpreet Uppal and Sabah Kanwal, staff She said that the resolutions of
members of Debbie Abrahams. the UN Security Council were
The APPGK Chairperson, Debbie Abrahams, was deported from still in place and relevant for
Delhi on February 17 for her open stance on the prevailing the current situation in
human rights situation in occupied Kashmir. occupied Kashmir.
Lawmakers Debbie Abrahams and Imran Hussain in a press To a question on UK’s response
conference along with Pakistan Foreign Minister, Shah on looming threat of genocide
Mahmood Qureshi, at the Foreign Office in Islamabad on in occupied Kashmir, she said
February 19 called upon the international community to take the independent group did not
urgent notice of worsening human rights situation in occupied represent the British
Kashmir. government and could not
Debbie Abrahams said that the group members would report speak on its behalf. However,
back to their parties on India denying the visit and Pakistan she said the group had host of
allowing for an independent monitoring of its part of Kashmir. ways to draw attention of the
MP Hussain said the APPGK voice in the British Parliament against human rights violations in
had always desired to visit occupied Kashmir. Kashmir issue, India’s war hysteria and
both sides of the LoC. overall regional situation were discussed in the meeting. The
“Tragically, the Indian Punjab Governor said that India had become a den of extremism,
government did not allow us and for how long the world would keep mum over it. The world
this time as well to visit the community’s silence over Indian atrocities will not be less than an
other side of the LoC,” he said. offense, he added.
Talking about continued Punjab Governor on the occasion said that restricting British
detentions under draconian MPs’ visit to the occupied Kashmir was the shameful act by India.
laws in occupied Kashmir The British delegates said what was going on in occupied Kashmir
amid continued curfew and was alarming for the entire world community. They said, “India’s
communications blockade, MP citizenship law is also denial of basic human rights against which
Hussain said that if the Indian we will raise our voice.”
government had nothing to A delegation of Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front (JKLF) met
hide then it should allow the the visiting Members of British Parliament (MPs) in Islamabad on
APPGK team to visit the other February 22 and apprised them of the latest situation of occupied
side of the LoC. Kashmir.
“Today we repeat this request The JKLF delegates including Saleem Haroon, Rafiq Dar, Sajid
from here. We are still willing Sidiqi and Aftab Ahmed told the delegation that the Indian
to visit the government
other side…. had been
b e c a u s e committing
human rights the worst
a r e a n k i n d o f
international h u m a n
issue and can r i g h t s
never be a violations in
bilateral issue occupied
and we as the Kashmir.
all-party T h e y
parliamentary condemned
group would the Indian
continue to act of not
raise our voice allowing
a g a i n s t D e b b i e
persecution, Abrahams
oppression and injustice to visit India and occupied Kashmir and appreciated her role for
wherever they happen,” he raising Kashmiris’ voice at the international level.
said. Briefing the UK delegation about the prevailing situation in the
On February 21, the British occupied territory, the JKLF spokesman, Rafiq Dar, said that the
delegation called on Punjab Indian government had arrested thousands of Hurriyat activists
Governor, Chaudhry and youth since it scrapped the special status of occupied
Muhammad Sarwar, at the Kashmir and put it under military siege on August 5, 2019.
Governor’s House in Lahore. He also informed the visiting MPs about the deteriorating health
British delegation members of illegally detained party Chairman, Muhammad Yasin Malik,
assured the Governor that lodged in New Delhi’s infamous Tihar Jail and urged them to play
they would raise an effective their role in his early release. (KI Report)
I
ndian authorities further intensified restrictions in the
it added.
besieged occupied Kashmir, particularly in Kupwara
Meanwhile, Pakistan Prime
district, on February 23, 2020 to prevent people from
Minister, Imran Khan, through
expressing solidarity with the victims of Kunanposhpora mass
tweets on the day urged the
rape perpetrated by Indian troops on the completion of 29 years
global fraternity, especially
to the tragic incident.
women, to become the voice of
The troops had gang-raped around 100 women of all ages from
resilient Kashmiri women for
eight to eighty on the night of February 23 in 1991 during a siege
peace in occupied Kashmir
and search operation in Kunanposhpora area of the district.
that had been under Indian
The troops were deployed in strength on all entry and exit points
military lockdown for nearly
of the district to prevent people from expressing solidarity with
200 days.
the victims of the mass rape.
Highlighting the Kashmiri
In order to pay tributes to the courage of the survivors of the
Women’s Resistance Day, he
Kunanposhpora tragedy, 23rd February is being observed every
spoke of how the Indian forces
year since 2014 as Kashmiri Women’s Resistance Day. The three
have continuously been
decades-long struggle of the survivors from Kunanposhpora is a
engaged in war crimes against
part of the larger ongoing struggle in occupied Kashmir against
women of the territory for
the institutionalised and structural violence of the Indian state
almost 73 years.
in the territory.
“Today is Kashmiri Women’s
A report released by the Research Section of Kashmir Media
Resistance Day. For over 7
Service on the occasion of the Kashmiri Women’s Resistance Day
decades, Indian forces have
revealed that at least 671 women had been martyred by Indian
committed war crimes against
troops since January 2001 till February 23, 2020.
The report pointed out that since January 1989, the unabated women in IOJK. Their
Indian state terrorism rendered 22,911 women widowed while sufferings have multiplied
Indian forces’ personnel had molested 11,178 women. after 5 Aug siege by Modi Govt.
The report said that thousands of women lost their sons, I urge world community,
T
he Organisation of Islamic Cooperation Secretary unwavering support to the
General’s Special Envoy for Jammu and Kashmir, people of occupied Kashmir.
Ambassador Yousef M Al Dobeay, visited Pakistan and The prime minister apprised Al
Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK) from March 02-06, 2020 during Dobeay about the prevailing
which he assured for all-out support to bring an end to the situation in the occupied
sufferings of the Kashmiri people. Valley and said the people of
Al Dobeay was accompanied by a high-level delegation Pakistan and Kashmir look
comprising Ambassador Rizwan Shiekh, Pakistan’s Permanent towards the OIC and Muslim
Representative to OIC; Ahmad Sereer, Director Asian Affairs OIC Ummah to play role in the
Secretariat; members of the Political Affairs Department OIC settlement of the Kashmir
Secretariat and representatives of the Islamic Development dispute in accordance with the
Bank and the Islamic Solidarity Fund. resolutions of United Nations.
During the visit, the special envoy and his delegation members Al Dobeay said that the OIC
called on Prime Minister, Imran Khan, and held meetings with was very concerned about the
the Foreign Minister, Shah Mahmood Qureshi, Minister for situation in occupied Kashmir.
Kashmir Affairs and Gilgit-Baltistan, members of Parliamentary Later addressing a press
Committee on Kashmir, and Foreign Secretary. A delegation of conference along with Foreign
representatives of the All Parties Hurriyat Conference (APHC) Minister, Shah Mahmood
also met with the OIC delegation and apprised it of the prevailing Qureshi, he said, “OIC fully
grim situation in occupied Kashmir. supports resolution of the
During the meetings, the Pakistani leadership appreciated OIC’s Kashmir dispute. We reaffirm
steadfast support for the people of Jammu and Kashmir, that all of our member states
particularly in the aftermath of India’s unilateral and illegal are supporting settlement of
actions of repealing the special status of occupied Kashmir on this issue so that Kashmiris
5th August 2019. The Special Envoy was apprised of the dire can get the right of self-
human rights and humanitarian situation in the occupied determination."
territory and the threat to peace and security posed by India’s “Pakistan has shown the world
understanding of the
sufferings of Kashmiris under
India’s illegal occupation.
The Special Envoy emphasised
that Kashmir and Palestine
remained the top-most items
on the OIC agenda.
Reaffirming the OIC’s
principled position, the
Special Envoy stated that the
Jammu and Kashmir is an
internationally recognised
dispute, which needs to be
settled in accordance with the
relevant UN and OIC
resolutions. He assured that cause. Organisation has a dedicated
the OIC will take all necessary The Special Envoy’s visit was Contact Group on Jammu and
steps to mitigate the sufferings of particular significance in Kashmir since 1994.
of the Kashmiris and help the backdrop of India’s The OIC has remained actively
resolve the dispute according unilateral and illegal actions of seized of the deteriorating
to the wishes of the people of 5th August 2019 and the situation in occupied Kashmir
Jammu and Kashmir. strong message on the Jammu since 5th August 2019. The
This was the first visit of and Kashmir dispute OIC and its human rights
body, Independent Permanent
Human Rights Commission
(IPHRC), have issued several
statements condemning
India’s actions and reiterating
their principled position on the
Kashmir dispute. The OIC
Contact Group on Jammu and
Kashmir has met twice since
India’s 5th August move.
The communiqué issued by
the Contact Group’s meeting
in New York at the Ministerial
level reflected OIC’s strong
Ambassador Yousef M Al contained in the resolutions commitment to the Kashmir
Dobeay to Pakistan and AJK and communiqués of the OIC cause. Under its Standing
after his appointment as OIC Council of Foreign Ministers Mechanism to monitor human
Secretary General’s Special (CFM) and Summit meetings. rights situation in occupied
Envoy for Jammu and The OIC has extended its Kashmir, the IPHRC also held
Kashmir during the 14th steadfast support to the an unprecedented ‘Open
Summit of OIC held in Makkah Kashmiri people in their just Discussion’ on the worsening
in May 2019. The visit was also struggle for securing their situation in the occupied
a reaffirmation of the OIC’s inalienable right to self- territory in November 2019.
commitment to the Kashmir determination. The (KI Report)
S
peakers at different functions including seminars and August 5, last year, while a
conferences organised during the 43rd session of the number of people have been
United Nations Human Rights Council held in Geneva, killed during peaceful protests
Switzerland, from February 24 to March 20, 2020, condemned against the controversial
the gross human rights violations perpetrated by Indian troops citizenship act in New Delhi.
and police personnel in occupied Kashmir. They regretted that On March 27, the UN High
no steps have been taken to address excessive use of force and Commissioner for Human
other serious human rights violations by Indian forces in the Rights, Michelle Bachelet,
occupied territory. Federal Minister of Human Rights, Dr addressing the 43rd session of
Shireen Mazari, represented Pakistan at the UNHRC session. the UN Human Rights Council
Dr Shireen Mazari in her address to the session appealed to the expressed serious concern
Council to impress upon India to immediately lift the over the prevailing grim
communications blockade in
occupied Kashmir and
release Kashmiri detainees.
She demanded that all
actions taken by the Indian
government since August 05,
last year, be repealed. She
said that India continued to
violate the human rights of
the Kashmiri people. She
said that over six thousand
Kashmiri people were
arrested without the due
process of law and called for
their immediate release. Dr
Shireen Mazari added that
any inaction by the international community and the UNHRC situation in occupied Kashmir
will only embolden India to act with impunity. and the escalating anti-
On February 24, Dr Shireen Mazari also raised the issue of Muslim violence in New Delhi.
violations of human rights abuses by Indian troops in occupied She regretted that no steps
Kashmir with the European Union Special Representative on have been taken to address
Human Rights. She presented the case of Kashmir in a meeting excessive use of force and
with the EU Special Representative on Human Rights, Eamon other serious human rights
Gilmore. During the meeting she highlighted the human rights violations committed by
abuses by Indian troops in occupied Kashmir and the Indian troops in occupied
persecution of Muslims in India besides discussing the wave of Kashmir.
Islamophobia in the European countries. Both sides agreed to She noted that as many as 800
cooperate on human rights issue. Kashmiris including political
Occupied Kashmir has been under a repressive lockdown since leaders and activists
reportedly remain in
detention. “Schools,
businesses and livelihoods
have been disrupted by the
continued heavy military
presence,” she said.
The high commissioner also
noted that the Indian
government had partially
restored mobile and internet
services, after a decision by the
Indian Supreme Court.
However, she added that the
authorities continued to It is to mention here that Michelle Bachelet in her inaugural
impose excessive restrictions speech at the 42nd session of the UN Human Rights Council in
on the use of social media. Geneva in September 2019 had also expressed concern about
Michelle Bachelet said that in
restrictions imposed in occupied Kashmir.
India more broadly, the The Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights has
Citizenship Amendment Act also published two reports on human rights violations by Indian
adopted last December was of forces in the occupied Kashmir. These reports were released in
June 2018 and July 2019.
On the other hand, the International
Human Rights Association of American
Minorities (IHRAAM), a non-
governmental organisation, submitted a
written statement for the 43rd session of
the UN Human Rights Council’s agenda
item 4, human rights situation.
The statement said that Kashmiris in
occupied Kashmir is a distinct
national/ethnic/religious group, in
particular the Kashmiri Muslims, as
being recognised in the UN report 2019. It
great concern. Indians in huge said, the Kashmiris are subjected to
numbers, and from all genocide by the perpetrators with the intent to destroy, in whole
communities, have expressed or in part.
in a mostly peaceful manner The IHRAAM submitted in its statement that the international
their opposition to the Act, she human rights groups have admitted that Indian armed forces use
said. excessive force that leads to unlawful killings and thousands of
The high commissioner Kashmiris have been killed during the period 1990-2019.
expressed concern over The statement pointed out that Amnesty International, Human
reports of police “inaction” in Rights Watch and the International Commission of Jurists all
the face of attacks against claim that there were over 90 fatalities of Kashmiris in 2016 while
Muslims by Hindu groups, as during 2018, it is claimed that 160 Kashmiris were killed. The first
well as previous reports of half of 2019 (January-June 2019) continued with killings of
excessive use of force by police Kashmiris as 163 people were killed. The second half of 2019
against peaceful protesters. (July–December) recorded 64 killings. It maintained that 95,475
killings since January 1989 till in Northeast Delhi, which left the UN resolutions and
December 10, 2019 over 40 people dead and many international law. He said that
corroborated the argument others wounded. the Kashmir dispute should be
that there was a systematic MJ Akbar was addressing at resolved in accordance with
pattern in place with intent to an event titled “Muslims in the relevant UN resolutions on
destroy in whole or in part the plural India and constitution” the subject.
Kashmiris. organised by the Indian On March 09, another
On March 01, Indian government through a proxy Kashmiri representative,
delegation faced major on the sidelines of the 43rd Shamim Shawl, in her speech
embarrassment at its event in session of the UNHRC. said that when the world
Geneva when a Kashmiri The event was organised in the observed the International
activist sought comment from backdrop of a spontaneous Women’s Day on 8th March,
pro-Modi politician, MJ Akbar protest against India’s anti- the miseries and victimisation
on remarks that it was safer to Muslim Citizenship of the Kashmiri women at the
be a cow than a Muslim in Amendment Act and anti- hands of Indian troops and
India. police personnel
A well known continued unabated in
Kashmiri activist, occupied Kashmir. She
Hassan Al-Bana, told the participants
asked MJ Akbar, “One that thousands of
of your colleagues, Mr Kashmiri women have
Shashi Tharoor has been martyred by
said that it is safer to Indian troops and
be a cow than a police since January
Muslim in India.” 1989 till March 08,
Condoning Modi- 2020. She said that
backed terror attacks unabated Indian state
on Muslims in Delhi, Muslim terror attacks in Delhi. terrorism had
MJ Akbar called Tharoor’s Pro-Modi Muslim religious rendered 22,912 women
statement irresponsible leader, Umer Ahmed Ilyasi, widowed. She added that the
rhetoric. and pro-government troops had molested 11,179
“I don’t agree with Shashi journalist, Atika Ahmed women during this period. She
Tharoor. Whatever has been Farouqi, also spoke at the maintained that an eight-year-
said by him is far away from event and tried to justify old baby girl, Aasifa Bano, of
reality. He was in opposition India’s CAA. Kathua, was abducted, gang-
and his comments were just Interestingly, Akbar, Ilyasi and raped and subsequently
irresponsible rhetoric,” he Atika have been silent over murdered by Indian police
said, claiming that Indian mass killings of Muslims in personnel, in January 2018.
Muslims were enjoying equal Delhi. She also mentioned Insha
r i g h t s a n d e q u a l On March 06, Kashmiri Tariq who was arrested along
opportunities. representative, Syed Faiz with her father by Indian police
MJ Akbar bragged about Naqshbandi, addressing the and sleuths of National
progress and equal rights of UNHRC session said that the Investigation Agency during
the Muslims at a time when Modi government’s unilateral door-to-door search
Indian police and saffron illegal decision to repeal operations on March 04 in
terror groups jointly carried Kashmir’s special status on Pulwama.
out terror attacks on Muslims 5th August, 2019, was against (KI Report)
A chronological
Farooq and Khawaja Abdul
Ghani Lone.
The authorities also place
May 19: The All Parties Hurriyet Conference Chairman, Mirwaiz May 21: The occupation
Umar Farooq, addressing an event in Srinagar says that there is no authorities resort to large scale
democracy in Kashmir and all decisions are taken by Indian Army arrests, restrictions and
and police to run the day-to-day affairs. imposition of curfew to sabotage
A five-year-old girl is killed and two others are injured after the a march towards the Martyrs’
Indian Army's leftover shell goes off in Drang area of Tosa Maidan in Graveyard at Eidgah in Srinagar
Budgam. on the martyrdom anniversaries
May 20: The speakers at a seminar organised by Jammu and of prominent liberation leaders,
Kashmir Muslim League in Srinagar emphasise that the elections Mirwaiz Molvi Muhammad
under Indian authorities in occupied Kashmir are not a substitute of Farooq, Khawaja Abdul Ghani
the plebiscite, promised by the United Nations. They say India is Lone, and martyrs of Hawal. Call
using the holding of sham elections as diversionary tactics to for the march and complete
distract people’s attention from the ongoing liberation movement. shutdown is given by the All
The authorities place the APHC Chairman, Mirwaiz Umar Farooq, Parties Hurriyet Conference
under house arrest to prevent him from addressing a rally, Chairman, Mirwaiz Umar
The Teacher
A Kashmiri folktale
The village about which this four walls of the house except cultivate. On several occasions
story is related had a school with a veil hanging down to their he tried to enter into conversa-
where education in the tradi- toes. There is no question at all of tion with her. She never resented
tional manner was imparted to their talking to a stranger, such an attempt on his part but,
the village boys. The old white- however good-natured he may as far as she was concerned, the
bearded teacher, who taught at be. The village woman, on the matter ended there for her. It
the school for thirty years, had other hand, is free from many of never paved the way for a
passed away, much to the regret the taboos in the city. She moves friendship or even what may be
of the villagers. He had perhaps about freely and goody goody called an acquaintance because
never taught more than three or modesty is alien to her unsophis- the next time he had to begin
four pupils at a time, but his ticated nature. Her conduct is a once again from the lowest rung.
culture and good breeding won true reflection of her. She is Finding no indication of progress
him a warm niche in every heart. mostly a workingwoman in this way he changed his line of
He was succeeded by another assisting her husband in the action. The young boy of the
gentleman from a neighbouring fields or tending cattle on the housewife attended the school
village. outskirts of the village. She will where the teacher taught. The
The new teacher was a young meet anybody unflinchingly, be teacher frequently said to the boy
man. He was gifted with all those he a robber or even the devil, and "Remember me to your mother".
qualities, which make us look not faint with fear like some of The boy carried the message as
wistfully on our departed youth: her sophisticated sisters living in charged. The mother realised
energy, health, ambition, hope towns behind latticed curtains. that the teacher needed a purge
and vanity. Since his pedagogic In spite of that, however, her for his humour and she chalked
duties did not tax his energy to conduct is unblemished. out her line of action. She told her
any extent, he interested himself The schoolmaster referred to boy to inform the teacher that she
in other activities and was fond above had certain preconceived wanted to have a word with him
of the company of young men. In and illusory notions about at her house. It was conveyed to
the midst of his friends nothing village women. He thought he him that her husband was
would distinguish him from the could play the gallant and thus expected to be away for the
brotherhood of the laity. He even tickle his vanity. Women move whole day.
disclosed a strain of gallantry in about freely in villages and his The heart of the teacher fluttered
his nature. Some elderly people movements were so timed as to like a bird when he got the
recalled the fatherly attitude of cross a number of them on the message. He felt highly excited
his predecessor and sighed that road when they proceeded to and in his best attire went too
even those who were expected to their farms. Sometimes he early for the appointment. The
set the standard in public contrived to enter into conversa- housewife gave him a reception
behaviour failed to maintain tion with one either on the that seemed to lack nothing in
proper decorum. roadside or at the village spring warmth. She seemed to have
The life lived by a woman in the where they went daily to fetch placed full confidence in his
city is different from that of her water. There was nothing friendship and gallantry. He
sister in the village. In a city the indecent in his behaviour, but it could not conceal the lascivious-
standard is set by the official sprang from a motive, which did ness in his looks and she recipro-
class who for this purpose may not appear to be "brotherly" as cated by pretending to gaze at
be said to include the business was the case with the village folk. him fondly. She busied herself in
and professional class too. Till There was, in particular, a making tea for him and offered
recently their womenfolk, both housewife, both pretty and him a cupful.
Hindu and Muslim, lived in prosperous, whose acquaintance While the cup brimful with tea
‘pardah’ and would not leave the and friendship he wanted to was steaming in the hands of the
MARCH 2020 30
L I T E R A T U R E
MARCH 2020 31
F E E D B A C K
Freedom struggle prove that the Quaid’s two nation theory still
The people of Jammu and Kashmir have been holds true.
resisting the Indian occupation for the last over As a young Pakistani, no amount of gratitude or
72 years. They are engaged in a heroic freedom thanks to our founding fathers is enough for this
struggle, facing the worst kind of Indian state beautiful nation of which we are citizens.
terrorism. They have braved the Indian atrocities Sana Aslam
with great courage and New Delhi has failed to Gujranwala
intimidate them into submission. The festering
Muslims’ genocide
problem has led to the brutal killing of thousands
On 9 to 10 November 1938 the then government
of people, including women and children, in the
in Germany encouraged its supporters to burn
Kashmir Valley by the Indian armed forces. The
down synagogues and smash up Jewish homes,
legal protection to the Indian troops in the guise
shops, businesses and schools. At least 91 Jews -
of the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA)
and probably many more - were killed by Nazi
supporters egged on by Joseph Goebbels, the
minister for public enlightenment and
Editor genocide.
On 23 February 2020 in Delhi, Hindu nationalist
mobs roamed the streets burning and looting
mosques together with Muslim homes, shops and
is very much there. This brutal law has allowed businesses. They killed or burned alive Muslims
the Indian forces to deal with the people of the who could not escape and the victims were largely
Valley as they please with little fear of unprotected by the police. At least 50 people,
prosecution. As global players continue to ignore almost all Muslims, were killed and many others
the resolution of the Kashmir dispute, it has beaten half dead. A two-year-old baby was
become a humanitarian issue in the region. stripped by a gang to see if he was circumcised -
Kashmir remains an international dispute as Muslims usually are, but Hindus are not.
between Pakistan and India. However, because of Some Muslim women pretended to be Hindus in
its very weak case, New Delhi terms it a bilateral order to escape.
dispute and avoids internationalising the issue. The Indian government’s complicity was not as
Anis Ahmed direct as in Germany 82 years earlier but activists
Islamabad of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), led by
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, were
Two nation theory validated
reported as being in the forefront of the attacks on
The latest state-sponsored terrorism unleashed
Muslims. A video was published showing Muslim
by the fascist Bharatiya Janata Party
men, soaked in blood from beatings, being forced
government through its goons in the RSS against
to lie on the ground by police officers and
defenseless Indian Muslims has once again compelled to sing patriotic songs. Modi said
justified the demand of Muslims of the nothing for several days and then made a vague
subcontinent for their separate homeland on the appeal for “peace and brotherhood”.
basis of two nation theory. In fact, it validates as
The government’s real attitude towards the
absolutely true even after 82 years what Quiad-e- violence was observed when it instantly
Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah had first said in transferred a judge critical of its actions during
1937 about there being two nations existing in the riots. The Delhi High Court Judge, S.
the subcontinent. Muralidhar, was hearing petitions about the
This is not the first time that India’s communal violence when he said that the court could not
leaders have targeted minorities on religious allow “another 1984” to happen, referring to the
basis. The Ayodhya verdict, the curfew and killing of 3,000 Sikhs by mobs in Delhi in that
human rights violations in occupied Kashmir, the year after the assassination of former prime
recent promulgation of discriminatory laws, minister Indira Gandhi by her Sikh bodyguards.
attacks on Muslim students in libraries and Jahangir Ismail
setting mosques and Muslims houses on fire Karachi
“In accepting the accession they [the Government of India] refused to take
advantage of the immediate peril in which the State found itself and informed
the Ruler that the accession should finally be settled by plebiscite as soon as
peace had been restored. They have subsequently made it quite clear that they
are agreeable to the plebiscite being conducted if necessary under international
auspices.”