Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Laboratory Exercise Myoglobin Structure and Function: A Multiweek Biochemistry Laboratory Project
Laboratory Exercise Myoglobin Structure and Function: A Multiweek Biochemistry Laboratory Project
Todd P. Silverstein*
Myoglobin Structure and Function: A Sarah R. Kirk
Multiweek Biochemistry Laboratory Scott C. Meyer
Karen L. McFarlane
Projectw
s
Holman
Abstract
We have developed a multiweek laboratory project in binding equilibrium) and are instructed on topics in data
which students isolate myoglobin and characterize its analysis (calibration curves, nonlinear vs. linear regres-
structure, function, and redox state. The important labora- sion). This upper division biochemistry laboratory project
tory techniques covered in this project include size- is a challenging and rewarding one that not only exposes
exclusion chromatography, electrophoresis, spectropho- students to a wide variety of important biochemical labo-
tometric titration, and FTIR spectroscopy. Regarding pro- ratory techniques but also ties those techniques together
tein structure, students work with computer modeling to work with a single readily available and easily charac-
and visualization of myoglobin and its homologues, after terized protein, myoglobin. V C 2015 by The International
which they spectroscopically characterize its thermal Union of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, 43(3):181–
denaturation. Students also study protein function (ligand 188, 2015.
in muscle [26, 27]. Unlike Hb, which is tetrameric and characterize the reduced and oxidized samples. In Period 2
binds oxygen cooperatively with a Hill coefficient of n 5 2.8, students employ SDS-PAGE to characterize the extracted
Mb is monomeric and binds oxygen noncooperatively samples. In Period 3, azide binding to metMb is examined
(n 5 1). Mb is easily extracted from muscle tissue and spec- via spectrophotometric titration. In Periods 4 and 5, stu-
trophotometric characterization of the Fe-heme is facile, as dents use online databases, websites, and software to char-
it absorbs strongly in the visible and UV ranges. In fact, the acterize the structure of Mb and a selected novel homolog.
visible absorption of heme-coordinated Fe(II) in Mb is In the final period, students employ FTIR spectroscopy to
responsible for the reddish appearance of fresh (reduced) probe protein secondary structure in both the native and
meat, whereas the visible absorption of heme-coordinated thermally denatured conformations.
Fe(III) in metMb is consistent with the brownish color of Students work in pairs throughout this experiment.
old (oxidized) meat [28, 29]. Because use of the FTIR spectrophotometer takes up all
We describe here our six-period project, in which stu- 3 h of Period 6, we can only schedule use of the instru-
dents isolate Mb from ground beef [29], spectrophotometri- ment if students are paired. During Periods 1 and 3, each
cally characterize its oxidized and reduced forms [29], student pair has access to its own small Thermo-Electron
probe its ligand binding equilibrium [30], perform molecu- Genesys-10 UV-Vis spectrophotometer. In Period 2, all
lar modeling on its structure and that of its homologues pairs mount their gels and run from a single electrophore-
[31], and use FTIR to characterize its secondary structure sis power supply. In Periods 4 and 5, paired students sit
in the native and denatured forms [32]. We have based our adjacent to each other, but each works on his/her own
extended Mb project on the four papers cited above desktop computer in our computer room. We have run
[29–32], adapting and expanding the projects beyond what this project six times, every spring since 2009. Course
is described in the original source papers. Specifically, we enrollment has varied from 7 to 20 students, averaging
have added new methods of analysis (e.g., SDS-PAGE), 10212.
adapted to changes in molecular modeling websites, and
Period 1, Part IA: Myoglobin Extraction,
added extensive quantitative data analysis and curve-fitting
Separation, and Spectral Characterization
components.
To begin the project, students extract Mb from ground beef
Student Learning Objectives: in a single 3-h laboratory period, following a modification
1. Proficiency in carrying out the following biochemical of the protocol of Bylkas and Andersson [29]. In this part of
techniques: centrifugation and protein isolation; column the project, students work from the original literature
chromatography and SDS-PAGE (proteins); and use of source; their laboratory manual contains screenshots of
protein structure databases selected paragraphs taken directly from the Bylkas and
2. Strengthened understanding of the following biochemical Andersson paper (see Supporting Information). A portion of
topics: protein structure modeling, characterization, and the extracted Mb is fully reduced from Fe(III) to Fe(II) with
denaturation; protein homology and evolution; and dithionite (turning deep red) and a separate portion is fully
protein-ligand binding equilibrium oxidized to Fe(III) with ferricyanide (turning brown). Fol-
3. Increased competence in biochemical data analysis, lowing oxidation, the metMb is separated from excess ferri-
including: x-y scatter plots and curve fitting (both linear cyanide using a Sephadex G-25 size-exclusion gel chroma-
and nonlinear regression); and calibration curves tography “desalting” column. The three forms of Mb
4. Increased confidence and mastery in using the following (original extract, reduced, and oxidized) can then be char-
instruments: UV-Vis and FTIR spectrophotometers; gel acterized spectrophotometrically. Reduced Mb features O2
electrophoresis; and in silico computer modeling of pro- bound to the Fe(II) center in the heme. It has prominent
tein structure peaks in the visible range at about 540 and 580 nm, and its
5. Enhanced ability to: employ critical thinking and scien- Soret band is at 417 nm with e417 5 128,000 M21 cm21
tific reasoning; speak and write effectively about scien- [29]. The oxidized metMb has H2O bound to the Fe(III)-
tific concepts. heme; its visible peaks appear at 505 and 620 nm, and its
Soret band is at 409 nm with e409 5 179,000 M21 cm21
[29]. Given the prominent changes in the wavelength and
Teaching and Laboratory Procedures molar absorptivities of the Soret band absorbance peaks, it
is straightforward to spectrophotometrically determine the
This extended laboratory project centered around Mb
concentrations of Mb and metMb, and monitor changes in
requires six 3-h laboratory periods, which include some in-
Fe(II)/(III) redox chemistry and ligand binding.
class time for data analysis. Detailed instructions are pro-
vided in the Supporting Information. In laboratory Period 1, Period 2: SDS-PAGE
students extract Mb from ground beef, reduce, and oxidize In a subsequent 3-h laboratory period students use SDS-
portions of the sample, use a Sephadex column to “desalt” PAGE to separate and visualize the protein components of
the excess oxidizing agent, and use UV-Vis absorbance to both the original Mb extract, and the desalted metMb
Silverstein et al 183
Biochemistry and
Molecular Biology Education
Mb structure comparison. (A) solved structure of sperm whale Mb, pdb file 1VXA; (B) Swiss model predicted structure
FIG 3 of Mb from unicorn icefish (Channichthys rhinoceratus), UniProt file E5G628. Color key for amino acid side chain types
at the protein surface: white 5 hydrophobic; red 5 negative; blue5 positive; pink 5 polar neutral; yellow 5 aromatic;
green 5 proline. Note the heme binding cavity in the center of both structures; most of the surface directly above this
cavity is identical in both (A) and (B). Besides these and other similarities, six key differences between the two forms of
Mb are marked above.
values derived from nonlinear regression, of 215% and pare the 3D structure of original protein to that of its novel
24.5% in Kd and n, respectively; the Scatchard plot is a lit- homolog.
tle better, with errors of 29% and 21.7%, respectively.
Periods 4 and 5
It takes students about 4.5 h to finish operations (a–d) listed
Part II: Myoglobin Three-Dimensional Structure: above. We have our students use the final 1.5 h in laboratory
Native vs. Denatured period 5 to prepare figures for an oral presentation in which
Myoglobin Structure on the Web they carefully characterize the major differences and simi-
In 1998, Leon et al. published a biochemistry laboratory larities between the original protein and its novel homolog.
project in which students used internet websites and free- All of the websites described by Leon et al. have
ware to model protein structure [31].1 Leon et al. describe changed dramatically in the nearly 2 decades since the
a project in which students select a protein whose structure original publication. Some things have gotten easier. For
has already been solved and deposited in the Protein Data example, in 1998 one had to visit three separate websites
Bank (PDB). They then carry out a series of four operations to obtain a protein’s structure coordinates (PDB), structure,
on the internet: (a) use search programs to find a “novel and function information (UniProt/SwissProt), and perform
homolog,” i.e., a homologous protein whose structure has homology searching (Blitz). Currently all of this information
NOT yet been solved; (b) submit the amino acid sequence can be obtained from the PDB website and links therein.
of the novel homolog to secondary structure prediction pro- On the other hand, other aspects of the project have gotten
grams and compare secondary structures of the original more difficult. The protein visualization program recom-
protein and its novel homolog; (c) submit the amino acid mended by Leon et al., Rasmac, is woefully outdated; in
sequence of the novel homolog to Swiss Model to obtain a addition, a useful protein structure comparison program
predicted three-dimensional structure; and finally (d) com- that we discovered around 2000, Protein Explorer, has not
been supported since about 2006. However, an even better
freeware program, PyMOL, has since come into wide use
1 [2, 37238]. This program not only allows homologous pro-
In order to increase the diversity of protein structures exam-
ined, we have half of the students start with myoglobin, a pre-
teins to be aligned and visualized, but it also has many dif-
dominantly alpha-helical protein, and the other half start with ferent viewing modes that can be implemented. We encour-
the predominantly beta-sheet protein, lysozyme. age students to explore the capabilities of PyMOL on their
Silverstein et al 185
Biochemistry and
Molecular Biology Education
FTIR characterization of Mb thermal denaturation (representative student results). (a) Relative absorbance (Ak/A1651) of
FIG 4 60 mg/mL Mb in D2O, at eleven different temperatures, 22–87 C. Note the appearance, above 64 C, of shoulders at 1618
and 1680 cm21, and an aggregated protein peak at 1570 cm21. (b) The three wavelengths in the spectra in (A) that
change dramatically with T are plotted: R shoulder, A1618/A1651 (black circles); L shoulder, A1680/A1651 (blue diamonds);
and aggregated protein peak, A1570/A1651 (blue diamonds). Fitting the R shoulder points using Eq. (2) gives
DH U 5 290 6 70 kcal/mol and TU 5 65.79 6 0.15 C; fitting the L shoulder and aggregated protein points gives
DH U 5 120 6 50 kcal/mol and TU 5 68.3 6 1.2 C. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at
wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
Silverstein et al 187
Biochemistry and
Molecular Biology Education
[10] Waldmann, H. and Janning, P. (2004) Chemical Biology, A Practical the effects of ligand binding on myoglobin using optical, EPR, and NMR
Course. Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, Germany, pp. 137–144. spectroscopy. J. Chem. Educ. 88, 223–225.
[11] Boyer, R. (2000) Modern Experimental Biochemistry, 3rd ed., Benjamin- [29] Bylkas, S. A. and Andersson, L. A. (1997) Microburger biochemistry:
Cummings, San Francisco, CA, pp. 257–302, 357–370. Extraction and spectral characterization of myoglobin from hamburger.
[12] Dryer, R. L. and Lata, G. F. (1989) Experimental Biochemistry, Oxford J. Chem. Educ. 74, 426–429.
Univ. Press, New York, pp. 375–441. [30] Marcoline, A. T. and Elgren, T. E. (1998) A thermodynamic study of
[13] Plummer, D. T. (1987) An Introduction to Practical Biochemistry, 3rd azide binding to myoglobin. J. Chem. Educ. 75, 1622–1623.
ed., McGraw-Hill Book Co., London, pp. 160–162, 236–249. [31] Leon, D., Uridil, S., and Miranda, J. (1998) Structural analysis and mod-
[14] Stenesh, J. (1984) Experimental Biochemistry, Allyn & Bacon, Inc., Bos- eling of proteins on the web: An investigation for biochemistry under-
ton, pp. 55–77; 97–110, 135–236. graduates. J. Chem. Educ. 75, 731–734.
[15] Zeidan, H. M. and Dashek, W. V. (1996) Experimental Approaches in [32] Olchowitz, J. C., Coles, D. R., Kain, L. E., and MacDonald, G. (2002)
Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Wm. C. Brown Publishers, Dubu- Using infrared spectroscopy to investigate protein structure. J. Chem.
que, IA, pp. 29–78. Educ. 79, 369–371.
[16] Dryer, R. L. and Lata, G. F. (1989) Experimental Biochemistry, Oxford [33] Martin, R. B. (1997) Disadvantages of double reciprocal plots. J. Chem.
Univ. Press, New York, pp. 375–408. Educ. 74, 1238–1240.
[17] Kirk, S. R., Silverstein, T. P., Holman, K. M., and Taylor, B. L. H. (2008) [34] Silverstein, T. P. (2008) Quantitative determination of DNA-ligand bind-
Probing changes in the conformation of tRNAPhe: An integrated bio- ing: Improved data analysis by nonlinear regression. J. Chem. Educ. 85,
chemistry laboratory course. J. Chem. Educ. 85, 666–673. 1192–1193.
[18] Kirk, S. R., Silverstein, T. P., Holman, K. M., and Taylor, B. L. H. (2008) [35] Silverstein, T. P. (2011) Nonlinear and linear regression applied to con-
UV thermal melting curves of tRNA in the presence of ligands. J Chem. centration vs. time kinetic data from Pinhas’s sanitizer evaporation pro-
Educ. 85, 674–675. ject. J. Chem. Educ. 88, 1589–1590.
[19] Kirk, S. R., Silverstein, T. P., Holman, K. M., and Taylor, B. L. H. (2008) [36] Stone, J. R., Sands, R. H., Dunham, W. R., and Marletta, M. A. (1996)
Metal-catalyzed cleavage of tRNAPhe, J. Chem. Educ. 85, 676–677. Spectral and ligand-binding properties of an unusual hemoprotein,
[20] Kirk, S. R., Silverstein, T. P., Holman, K. M., and Taylor, B. L. H. (2008) the ferric form of soluble guanylate cyclase. Biochem. 35, 3258–
Fluorescence spectroscopy of tRNAPhe Y base in the presence of Mg 3262.
21 and small molecule ligands. J. Chem. Educ. 85, 678–679. [37] Bethel, C. M. and Lieberman, R. L. (2014) Protein structure and function:
[21] Markwell, J. (1993) Focusing on a single enzyme. J. Chem. Educ. 70, An interdisciplinary multimedia-based guided-inquiry education module
1018–1019. for the high school science classroom, J. Chem. Educ. 91, 52–55.
[22] Craig, P. A. (1999) A project-oriented biochemistry laboratory course, J. [38] Yeturu, K. and Chandra, N. (2011) PocketAlign: Novel algorithm for
Chem. Educ. 76, 1130–1135. aligning binding sites in protein structures. J. Chem. Inf. Model. 51,
[23] Wolfson, A. J., Hall, M. L., and Branham, T. R. (1996) An integrated bio- 1725–1736.
chemistry laboratory, including molecular modeling. J. Chem. Educ. 73, [39] My PyMOL Script Repository: Available at: http://pldserver1.biochem.
1026–1029. queensu.ca/rlc/work/pymol/(checked Jan. 2015).
[24] Vincent, J. B. and Woski, S. A. (2005) Cytochrome c: A biochemistry [40] Mehl, A. F., Crawford, M. A., and Zhang, L. (2009) Determination of
laboratory course. J. Chem. Educ. 82, 1211–1214. myoglobin stability by circular dichroism spectroscopy: Classic and
[25] Saderholm, M. and Reynolds, A. (2011) Jmol-enhanced biochemistry modern data analysis. J. Chem. Educ. 86, 600–602.
research projects. J. Chem. Educ. 88, 1074–1078. [41] Moriyama, Y. and Takeda, K. (2010) Critical temperature of secondary
[26] Cossins, A. and Berenbrink, M. (2008) Myoglobin’s new clothes. Nature. structural change of myoglobin in thermal denaturation up to 130 C
454, 416–417. and effect of sodium dodcyl sulfate on the change. J. Phys. Chem. B
[27] Hendgen-Cotta, U. B., Merx, M. W., Shiva, S., Schmitz, J., Becher, S., 114, 2430–2434.
Klare, J. P., Steinhoff, H. J., Goedecke, A., Schrader, J., Gladwin, M. T., [42] Shih, P., Holland, D. R., and Kirsch, J. F. (1995) Thermal stability deter-
Kelm, M., and Rassaf, T. (2008) Nitrite reductase activity of myoglobin minants of chicken egg-white lysozyme core mutants: Hydrophobicity,
regulates respiration and cellular viability in myocardial ischemia- packing volume, and conserved buried water molecules, Protein Sci. 4,
reperfusion injury. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 105, 10256–10261. 2050–2062.
[28] Linenberger, K., Lowery-Bretz, S., Crowder, M. W., McCarrick, R., [43] Silverstein, T. P. and Blomberg, L. E. (1992) Probing denaturation by
Lorigan, G. A., and Tierney, D. L. (2011) What is the true color of fresh monitoring residual enzyme activity and intrinsic fluorescence: An
meat? A biophysical undergraduate laboratory experiment investigating undergraduate biochemistry experiment. J. Chem. Educ. 69, 852–855.