Professional Documents
Culture Documents
5 The Challenges of Individualism PDF
5 The Challenges of Individualism PDF
Introduction - The question of which comes first, - the society or the individual has been quixotic
to scholars. Whether we view it from historical perspective, or from the perspective of studies in
logic or even in governance, it has always been argumentative. We may liken the argument to the
question of which comes first, the ‘hen or the egg’? As soon as we come into the world our
society gets to work to mould and socialize us from a mere biological being into the culture of
our society, thereby we become, social beings. Anthropologists (commonly) believe that primitive
man is more completely moulded by his society than the civilized man. He is thus less
individualistic than the civilized man. There is an element of truth in this assertion. This is
because nonsophisticated traditional communities are more homogenous and they provide for
more opportunities for a far smaller diversity of individual occupations and skills than the
advanced modern societies (Carr E.A. 1985 : 33).
The Challenges of Individualism and Nation- Building in Nigeria - An Analysis from Social History
© 2012. Dr. Tijani, Abdulwahab. This is a research/review paper, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/), permitting all non-commercial
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
The Challenges of Individualism and Nation-
Building in Nigeria - An Analysis from Social
History
Tijani, Abdulwahab
Year 2012
I. Introduction II. Conceptual Framework
T
he question of which comes first, - the society or
Individualism as a component part of an
the individual has been quixotic to scholars.
ideology has in practical terms been a driving force
Whether we view it from historical perspective, or
behind the growth, development and globalization of the 37
from the perspective of studies in logic or even in
capitalist economic system. In this work, I have
governance, it has always been argumentative. We may
attempted to examine how individualism have affected
liken the argument to the question of which comes first,
in creating a new elite class, a new social group, whose corporations. They are thus often referred to as
existence was based on the doctrine of Lassezfaire, Comprador Bourgeoisie.
individualism, and utilitarianism. The question that is germaine to this discourse
Colonial rule resulted in the creation of a new concerns the extent to which this system enhances
elite. Lassezfaire economics, African enterprise, coupled nation-building or otherwise. To start with nation-building
with opportunities for university and professional involves the development of state of harmony where
education were factors that contributed to the rise of the ethnic, religious and other natural diversities do not lead
new social group, those we often refer to as the western to violent conflicts, and where the citizen view
educated elite. themselves first as a citizen rather than belonging to
This social group were bounded together by the primordial units. It is where the distribution of national
Year 2012
provision of the liberal democratic tenets which is the wealth is largely done with equity, social justice and
political offshoot of the capitalist system. They are often common good. This shall invariably enhance high
referred to as the nationalists, political leaders etc. Their degree of national integration.
policies and programmes were tailored along the lines For Schermerhon (1970), integration is seen as
of the colonial masters. a continuous process rather than a state of being,
38
2 They were interested not only in replacing the relative rather than all embracing corrective rather than
Europeans in leading positions of power and privilege, self-subsistent, a matter of degree rather than an all or
they were more interested in taking advantage of the non-phenomenon, and correlative with conflict rather
D ) Volume XII Issue X Version I
inherent social disorder from the colonial era rather than than a displacement of conflict.
transforming it. Ebijuwa, (1997 :195). In other words there is no system that is
completely free of conflict as well as integrative
IV. Nation – Building elements. Therefore, nation-building problems in
After the attainment of political independence, modern African nations cannot be divorced from the
these elites continued to use the divide-and-rule tactics consequences of tenets of the capitalist economic
of the colonial masters in their intra-class rivalry for system, colonial rule, the manipulative activities of the
power and control of resources. Thus it led to bitter ruling elites and as far as this discourse is concerned we
politics using ethnic, religious and geographical cannot divorce it from the effects of Lassezfaire
diversities as weapons. economic system which goes along with individualism .
The members of this social group use all these
natural diversities as weapons in achieving their V. Prospects and Set-Back of
Individualism
Global Journal of Human Social Science ( D
VI. he igeria xample led the people to become willing tools of the bourgeois
a) Mixed Economy class in their intra-class conflict which they portrayed as
For about thirty years after independence in ethnic interests. Adedeji, (1999) observes:
1960, Nigeria practised mixed economic system. That Mass poverty experienced by Nigerians over the
is, public enterprises existed side by side with privately years has also been identified as one of the potential
owned enterprises. There was direct government factors responsible for the general high level of
investment in production and provision of public instability in the country. Invariably, this has found
services such as the oil sector, Energy supply, Water expression in ethnic and religious conflagration (Adedeji,
supply, education, communication industry etc. In the 1991).
seventies, there was the indigenisation of some foreign The harsh economic realities of the nation often
owned companies. This was done in order to provide lead citizens to seek economic and social fulfilments
Year 2012
services to the citizens, to control the economy of the within their primordial groupings, especially of ethnic
nation; for national pride and for national security. and religions grouping. This would then make it possible
Therefore by 1991, public enterprises proliferated and to understand why citizens opt for their kinsmen and
rose up to 1,500 throughout the country. Of this, the women to occupy political posts. That was why the
Federal Government owned about 600. (Obasanjo, location of local government headquarters and the
election of local government Chairperson would lead to 39
1999).
These public enterprises owned by the states serious incessant crises such as Jos and Modakeke/Ife
crises, the former took on ethnic and religious clothing.
him in the Presidency, Economic Advisers. In the In addition to this, the economies of these
presidential cabinet, there are giants in various countries are:
academic fields, among whom are Professors and Often heavily dependent on a few exports,
others with Doctorate degree with years of experience in usually of primary products, and have experienced
public administration. severe external shocks in the last decades. Indeed the
Similarly within the Federal and State destabilisation caused by these shocks often spanned
government boards and boards of government their privatisation programmes. However their
companies and parastatals and in the ranks of the party experience of government control and protection has
leadership are quantum of expertise and experience in not been without it problems, and excessive
government and business, which they had gained as bureaucracy and corruption is common (Ibid : 246)
Year 2012
military administrators, tycoons, professionals, ministers, Through corruption and the looting of the
commissioners, traditional rulers, etc. Many of these resources of these pubic enterprises (Obasanjo : 1999),
have private businesses which they run at great profit, the ruling class became millionaires and billionaires.
while others are shareholders in lucrative businesses in Privatisation programme shall be appealing to them as
the banking industry, mining, construction companies an opportunity to invest their loot and ‘legitimise’ their
40
2 and commercial companies. The question is, with all wealth. In the process they serve as Comprador
these cream of experts and experienced men in Bourgeoisie .for the International Monetary Agencies
governments, why should public enterprises become and companies. It is in this line of thought that one can
D ) Volume XII Issue X Version I
inefficient and white elephant projects. And why should understand and answer the questions on the
the government fail or refuse to put all these imperativeness of privatisation and commercialization in
potentialities in use to strengthen the performance of the Nigeria and why in spite of the experienced experts
public enterprises. found in government the ‘inefficiency’ of public
The answer to these questions will take us enterprises cannot be arrested.
beyond the smokescreen of the imperativeness of It is important for the dependent capitalist
privatisation and commercialisation in Nigeria. countries to consider whether privatisation would
Privatisation programme in the dependent capitalist increase welfare of citizens; whether it would lead to the
national such as Nigeria, is the latest or highest stage in loss of control over the nation’s economy to foreign
the imperialistic drives of the capitalist metropolitan companies, and the International Monetary Agencies.
nations. This shall be achieved through the new market And whether it shall lead to the sacrifice of National
nationality of the IMF and World Bank and through the pride and security.
Global Journal of Human Social Science ( D
‘reserve army of labour’ (Ibid : 32). That is, the dependent capitalist country with all the indices of an
population of the unemployed and the under employed. underdeveloped economy shall have no human face.
Such people would readily accept low wages and Because of the under-development of the
miserable conditions of service under a privatised capital market the government would sell many of their
economy. This would further worsen the living standard enterprises to foreign investors. For example, NEPA was
of the citizens. billed for lease to Eskom , the South African Electricity
Privatisation programme in the capitalist Corporation in collaboration with Shell Company.
peripheries or dependent capitalist countries such as (Nigerian Tribune, April 9, 2002). This would have
Nigeria and other African countries differs significantly caused a lot of damage to our National pride because
from that of the capitalist metropolitan countries such as Eskom is owned by the government of South Africa, the
Britain. The British privatisation is: Corporation supplies about 40,000 megawatts daily in
Year 2012
A reasonably coherent and integrated policy, South Africa, while NEPA was still struggling to supply
even it owned its genesis more to expedient financial 4,000 megawatts (Ibid). NEPA is an example of public
and political forces than to a well thought-out enterprises that had gulped billions of Naira without
philosophy. (Peter & Catherine). result (Obasanjo, 1999).
When the economy becomes privatised, it is not Similarly, the plan to privatise the Nigerian
likely that the problem of inefficiency could be solved, Security Printing and Minting Company Limited 41
with rising prices and fares by the privatised enterprises (NSPMC) was most unpatriotic. The company is
Agencies in the exploitation of the resources of the stability which has eluded Nigeria, some 28 years after
country. the civil war ended, because the necessary structures of
Studies have shown that not all public equity, justice and democracy have not been put in
enterprises are inefficient, and inefficiency indicates a lot place”.
of disabilities in government control mechanisms which Insecurity as engendered by incessant violent,
is largely due to corruption, indiscipline and acquisition ethnic conflicts in modern African nations has been put
of undue foreign loans and the debt burden. It has been within the context of colonial and neo-colonial
observed that in some countries public enterprises were dependent capitalist economic system. The colonial
efficient and highly profitable. For instance it has been system had implanted structures, institutions and
observed that: policies that inevitably would pitch the various primordial
Year 2012
The most efficient steel company in the world is groupings against one another. The National Petite and
the Korean Posco (Pohang Steel Company) which is Comprador Bourgeoisie continued the line of colonial
state owned. Other examples of high-performance policies after independence.
public enterprises include the Kenyan Tea Development
Authority; the Ethiopian Telecommunications Authority; X. Recommendations
42
2 the Tanzanian Electric Supply Company and the Guma
Valley Water Company of Sierra-Leone (Ibid : 24). It is a fact that History is made by the interaction
Similarly, petro nas of Malaysia is a government of individuals and of groups in human societies, but the
role of individual in human history should not be over-
D ) Volume XII Issue X Version I
manufactured goods in exchange for primary products; what conditions ensure the success of his actions, what
through exploitative monetary relationship such as IMF guarantee is there that these actions will not remain an
and World Bank Loans and recently through the isolated act lost in the welter of contrary acts?
purchase of the economic live wires of such dependent
No matter the greatness or the political
capitalist countries as a new form of foreign domination
significance of an individual, he can neither suspend nor
otherwise known as privatisation and commercialisation.
reverse the objective process of history. The recognition
The inefficiency of these public enterprises in
gained by a political leader is determined by the
Nigeria is largely due to the culture of looting of public
accuracy with which he seizes up any situation within
enterprise which goes hand in hand with the inefficiency
the country or beyond it borders. Besides, this is also
and inability of government in arresting this problem.
due to his ability to work out the right strategies and
Therefore, rather than privatise and sacrifice
tactics for political struggle and by his links with the
national pride, security and economic independent and
masses.
welfare of ‘citizens, Nigeria should solve the problems of
The problem of unemployment, under-
inefficiency and unprofitability of public enterprises by
employment should be addressed adequately. This
enforcing discipline and curbing corruption and
would reduce the industrial reserve army that constitute
mismanagement of public funds. The managerial
the bulk of political thugs, kidnappers and ethnic militia.
stratum of public enterprises may be employed on new
This is because National Security cannot be attained
terms, even if the personnel remain the same, such as
without improving economic security. Dialogue and
attaching the conditions of service to the performance of
Rehabilitation of people that pose threat to National
the enterprise. The arrangements may require finding
security should be employed rather than military action
solutions to political pressures that may lead to revisal to
and high-handedness.
status quo, this is left for economist to explore.
To achieve economic development, political References Références Referencias
stability and to reduce insecurity through ethnic
conflicts, the necessary conditions of equity, and justice 1. Carr, E.C. ‘What is History?’. Macmillan, New
must be established. Segun (1994), rightly observes Zealand
that: “Economic development depends on political 2. Ebijuwa, T. (1997). ‘Ethnicity, Public Morality and the
© 2012 Global Journals Inc. (US)
The Challenges of Individualism and Nation-Building in Nigeria - An Analysis from Social History
Year 2012
6. Lenin, V.I. The three sources of Three Component
Parts of Marxism, Moscow, Progress Publishers,
1984, Pp. 32-34
7. National Council on Privatisation Handbook 3rd
Edition, Abuja, Nigeria B.P.E., April, 2001.
8. Nigerian Tribune, Tuesday 9th April, 2002, p. 26., 43
9. Peter M. and Catherine P.M. (ed). Privatisation and