Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Visual Notes For Architects and Designers PDF
Visual Notes For Architects and Designers PDF
Norman Crowe
Professor Emeritus, School of Architecture
University of Notre Dame
Paul Laseau
Professor Emeritus, Department of Architecture
Ball State University
IV
Endnotes 226
Illustration and Photo Credits 227
Bibliography 229
Index 231
When we completed Visual Notes for publication We are told that sketching engages a different
in 1984, hand drawing with drafting instruments part of the brain than, for instance, taking pho-
was still the customary practice at the drawing tographs. Comparable research in 2003 by neu-
board for most designers. Cameras, however, roscientist Eleanor Maguire of University College
had virtually replaced field sketches for gather- London, though not focused directly on sketch-
ing information in the field. We recognized that ing, seems to emphasize the point. She discov-
something was missing and so we wrote Visual ered that spatial understanding is enhanced by
Notes for designers—especially architects, land- direct and intense experience with something
scape architects, planners, and engineers—to in its true three-dimensionality, versus viewing
reassert the value of visual notation. The book it in two dimensions as a photograph or other
proved to be remarkably successful, indicating abstract representation. In particular, her re-
that many agreed with our assessment. Since search involved London cabdrivers, who it turns
that time, digital cameras, computer aided de- out have a larger posterior hippocampus—the
sign software (CAD), hand-held digital sketch- region of the brain that files spatial memories—
pads, the Internet, smart phones, fax machines, than the average Londoner. Of course today,
and scanners have become just about ubiqui- one could negotiate London’s complex street
tous. While the aim of this edition is to continue network with a GPS navigational aid, but be-
to demonstrate the effectiveness of gathering cause it does not engage spatial organization in
visual information by means of freehand nota- the same way as a series of related, consecutive
tional sketches, ways of incorporating today’s active spatial experiences, the brain is deprived
available technologies, we believe, have become of developing more subtle and refined spatial
too important and effective to exclude. Thus, understanding. It would follow that operating
the objective of the current edition is two-fold: computer graphics, for instance, like negotiating
to provide further instruction on visual notation, the streets with a GPS device, short circuits the
and demonstrate how new graphic-oriented fuller neuronal involvement of drawing by hand.
technologies may expand the efficacy of gather-
ing visual information. Since the first publication of Visual Notes, an
inadvertent discovery involving the applica-
We noted in the first edition that sketching tion of computer graphics versus hand drawing
and keeping notes was once the mainstay of emerged in response to a decision made by the
a traveler’s skills. Recording visual information professional degree architectural program at the
alongside verbal notes—in forms that are dia- University of Notre Dame. After considerable
grammatic, abstract, pictorial, and realistic—was evaluation, it was decided that students would
simply a part of how one “took in” the important be prohibited from using computer graphics
qualities of a place, as well as to reinforce the in the design process until they had reached
memory of that place for a later time. But there their fourth year of architectural studies. The
is more to sketching in the field than meets the reason had to do with the observation that hand
eye, so to speak. While we engage in sketching drawing required a much greater conscious
for purposes of capturing information, we tend understanding of how things go together—in
to forget that an important effect has to do with constructional, architectural, and general spatial
truly seeing things in their deeper complexity, terms—than simply selecting a detail or element
thereby heightening a fuller and at the same from a digitized plan file in a CAD program,
time more subtle understanding of our environ- then modifying it to suit a particular applica-
ment. And this effect increases, becoming more tion. What happened, in addition to ensuring
efficient and useful as one’s habit of sketching a greater understanding of architectural form,
stretches over time. was that when architecture students who began
VII
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We would like to thank those who so generously We would also like to thank Holly M. Johnson
contributed their sketches to this edition. We for her generous time and expertise in gather-
believed from the onset that expanding those ing photographs for us in Philadelphia, Kenneth
sections of the book that feature a broad array of Johnson for technical consultation, and Michele
drawings by people from different fields was of Laseau for her design advice. Special thanks go
particular importance. New contributors to this to our editors, Margaret Cummins and Lauren
edition are Mohammed Bilbesi, Lauren Deeg, Poplawski, for their encouragement and helping
Wayne Estopinal, Susan Fox, Harry Eggink, us through the process of putting the book
Andrew Hesterman, Susan Fox, John Hoover, together. Finally, we would like to thank all those
Cathi and Steven House, Nancy Kreger, Leon who expressed their enthusiasm for Visual Notes
Krier, Jim Leggitt, Scott Lockard, Efthimios over the years and whose interest in visual nota-
Maniatis, William Morrish, Michel Mounayar, tion encouraged us to expand and revise the
Bruce Race, and Kevin Sloan. We wish we could original edition.
have included all the sketches they sent us, but
editing from such a wonderful preponderance
of drawings, we believe, provided us with the
best combination overall.
VIII
Visual notes are simply the graphic equivalent between the observer and the view. It can be-
of written notes. “Taking visual notes” refers to come a comparatively neutral instrument which
recording information which is primarily visual neither demands a high degree of selectivity nor
and, therefore, could not be recorded as effec- promotes out of necessity a very high level of
tively with words. understanding. Le Corbusier said that cameras
“get in the way of seeing.” Because visual notes
Keeping notes has always been an effective
do not accompany verbal ones as frequently as
hedge against an imperfect memory. Moreover,
they once did, we believe that something valu-
the act of taking notes, selecting and sifting
able has been lost. It is our purpose to encour-
through them, is an important tool for creativ-
age the development and use of visual skills,
ity. Keeping a notebook of observations and
especially in the form of simple, rapid, effective
experiences is a very old custom. Once visual
visual notation. We contend that the stigma
notes were seen by architects to be nearly as
against the use of graphic skills by those other
important as verbal ones. Sketching was a com-
than artists is based upon a false assumption
mon part of travel and education for the young
that one must be an artist, heavily endowed
architect.
with artistic aptitudes, in order to draw. Al-
Since the availability of easy, inexpensive though a certain kind of drawing is the province
photography, however, visual note-taking has of artists, that should not discourage others from
declined. With this decline has come a decline in using drawings to communicate information any
visual literacy in general. We have come to rely more than one might refuse to ever write any-
upon a camera to do all that notational sketches thing down because one is not an accomplished
once did. Of course, a camera can do much of journalist or author. Making visual notes can be
what sketching once did and it can perform cer- useful and effective and it can also be a particu-
tain tasks much faster and better. But a camera larly enjoyable endeavor. Once one has gotten
cannot record concepts, underlying structure, beyond the notion that one’s drawings have to
schematic organization, or anything else that be works of art, the activity of drawing gains a
the eye cannot see all at once. Although the momentum of its own and inevitably provides a
camera can be used creatively, it does not require certain satisfaction of its own.
any more than a superficial level of interaction
1-4 Visual notes of the same building, conveying a different kind of information
than the pictorial drawing above.
3
Written language does have its limitations. Visual access to a level of richness and understanding
information is not as easily conveyed by the writ- which would otherwise be unreachable. In our
ten word. Skillful writers have given us a special earlier description of the engineer, technician,
literary richness by describing something they scientist, and others making visual notes in order
wish us to see and feel, such as Balzac’s descrip- to facilitate their work, the impression might
tion of the interior of an apartment on the Place be that such notation is simply a means for the
des Vosges, or the Roman naturalist and writer transfer of information. Certainly notes might
Pliny’s description of his villas in Italy in letters serve only as information transfer and they
to his friends. But literature cannot convey all might only be perceived as such. Although basic
that seeing can provide. As in literature, the factual information is inert and without an intrin-
two drawings on the right represent a fanciful sic value, the very act of gathering the material,
transformation from factual reality into a fantasy selecting, sorting, and “getting it down” can
at the level of good fiction writing. The ritual disclose new associations and promote a deeper
mask was indeed inspired by a lion, but now understanding than any superficial observation
it is a thing of the imagination. Perhaps the could provide.
ancient artist first drew a lion from life to grasp
Communication, whether it is through literature,
the essential characteristics of “lion-ness,” then
mathematics, music, or graphics, is at the very
transformed those same characteristics into
heart of creativity which thrives upon relation-
something intentionally different though faithful
ships drawn between symbols and ideas. The
nonetheless to the factual lion. Visual media in
extent of one’s creativity is related to the depth
the form of drawing is capable of playing with
of one’s experience of the world in which one
the imagination in the same way as in literature.
lives. Imagination is built upon the richness of
It follows that just as verbal description is a perceptions gleaned from an active and con-
source for a rich and profound level of under- scious participation in that world of thoughts
standing, visual literacy can provide its own and substance.
1-7 Tribal ritual Lion Mask. It is intended that the mask be recognizable as a
lion, but this lion is of the spirit world, not an ordinary beast but a power-
ful, mystical, extraordinary one. A transformation has taken place through
the media of art and imagination.
VISUAL LITERACY
Verbal literacy is considered an essential skill in When most people look at a house, they see a
an industrialized, technologically-based society. roof, windows, doors, or the colors of the walls.
Most of us have learned how to take verbal or An artist also sees the lightness or darkness of
written notes. We learn to understand others the colors, the way the sun casts shadows, and
and express ourselves in a written language the reflections in the windows. The architect
usually by the completion of high school. But also sees the types of materials used, the details
understanding and expressing visual messages of a window frame or eaves, and the acces-
is a skill that remains poorly developed. sories such as gutters, downspouts, and lights.
The sociologist may see which windows have
Visual literacy includes two skills: visual acuity
curtains drawn, what symbols are presented in
and visual expression. Visual acuity is an intense
the style of the house, or how well the house
ability to see information or multiple messages
is maintained. Visual expression is the ability
in one’s environment with clarity and accuracy.
to initiate visual messages. It is most strongly
exhibited by people such as artists, designers, In A Primer of Visual Literacy D. A. Dondis has iden-
choreographers, photographers, or architects; tified three levels of visual messages.1 They are
but it is important to everyone. While visual representation, abstraction, and symbolism. Rep-
acuity is concerned with the visual messages we resentation seeks to accurately record what we
receive, visual expression is concerned with the can actually see or experience. Representative
visual messages we send. Just as listening and sketches function much as do photographs, but
speaking are related but distinct skills, seeing they are, of necessity, more selective. The photo-
and expressing are interdependent but separate. graph accurately duplicates all that can be seen
Seeing is a necessary prelude to visual expres- from a specific vantage point; the representative
sion. But to achieve visual literacy both must be sketch describes those parts of a view which are
consciously developed. Since most readers will of special interest to the person sketching. While
not start with these skills, they represent both a a photograph is a reproduction of what is vis-
goal and a benefit of visual note-taking. ible, the sketch is a record of how one sees that
1-11B 1-11C
1-12B 1-12C
THE NOTEBOOK
In keeping a notebook we use combinations of In her book, Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain,
representational, abstract, and symbolic mes- Dr. Edwards describes the transition from sym-
sages. This requires our understanding of the bolic drawings to producing nonsymbolic draw-
basic approach to creating each type of drawing ings as a process of limiting the involvement of
and the ways in which they can be combined. the portion of our brain which deals primarily
When children draw a person, they draw sym- with verbal information.3 Then that portion of
bols for all the parts they know must be there our brain which processes visual information
to make a human figure. The head is a circle and can take over. Rather than the drawing being
the body a larger circle below the head. Eyes comprised of symbolic elements, it becomes
are represented by two dots; nose, mouth, and a composition of shapes which represent the
hair by appropriately placed lines; arms and legs visual likeness of that which we are recording.
by single lines emanating from the body circle.
Likewise, a house is depicted as a rectangle with If one wishes to produce a true likeness, like
a triangle on top of it and a symbolic window an accurate photograph of something, it is
with a single crossed division on it resides on the important to draw the shape accurately, just
facade. Our training in school in mathematics as it is seen, and not to permit preconceived
and written language reinforces our tendency form or symbolic gestures to intercede. Dr.
toward symbolic drawings. Edwards describes this as “locking out the left
side of the brain” and she proposes exercises
10
11
Visual notation is not always the same as the in a single view. The shape and proportions of
realistic drawing mode described above, but it the object must still be reasonably accurate with
shares certain characteristics with lifelike draw- respect to the unrealistic view; therefore some
ing skills such as those Dr. Edwards’ techniques basic drawing skills are a prerequisite to making
seek to teach. As you will see in the ensuing ex- visual notes. Basic drawing skills arise out of the
amples, an accurate representation of shape and note-taking process. The sketchy and often skel-
proportion is frequently important, even though etal or abstract character of visual note-taking, as
reproduction of optical accuracy is not always depicted above, is usually a consequence of in-
the goal in visual notation. In optically accurate tentionally drawing quickly, while still capturing
drawings, lines are drawn onto a flat piece of shape and proportions accurately. However, if
paper as an abstraction of the depicted object after several attempts at visual note-taking, you
or scene. Seen in light of a child’s propensity to cannot grasp the means for recording shape and
draw symbolic objects rather than the actual proportion with reasonable accuracy, we sug-
subject being depicted we assert the impor- gest that you refer to the Appendix or you might
tance of recognizing optical qualities of perspec- spend some time with Dr. Edwards’ book. Then
tive and visual recognition of form, shape, and you may return to your visual notebook, having
proportion. Visual notation will not necessarily gained more confidence in your ability to make
depict objects as seen, but rather they might be your pen or pencil record shape and proportion
shown from above or below, with portions re- with acceptable accuracy.
moved or rotated to show what cannot be seen
12
13
14