Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Constitutional Law Project
Constitutional Law Project
INDIA
PROJECT ON CITIZENSHIP
Ashmita Sandhu
2
Index
1. Table Of Cases………………………………….... 4
2. Introduction ……………………………………....5
3. Citizenship and Nationality …………………6
4. Scenario Of Citizenship In India …………..7
5. Citizenship At The Commencement Of The
Constitution ……………………………………….8
6. No Dual Citizenship ……………………..........14
7. Continuance Of Right Of Citizenship……15
8. Citizenship Act Of India 1955 …………….16
9. Overseas Citizenship …………………………21
10. Commonwealth Citizenship ……………….22
11. Termination Of Citizenship ………………..23
12. Current Affairs Relating To Citizenship 26
13. Bibliography …………………………………….29
14. Webliography …………………………………..29
3
Table Of Cases
4
Introduction
1
Cambridge Academic Content Dictionary, 2018, Cambridge University Press, UK.
2
Merriam-Webster Dictionary, 2018, Merriam-Webster, Incorporated.
3
Kumar, Narender, Constitutional Law Of India, 2015, Allahabad Law Agency, Faridabad, India.
5
Citizenship And Nationality
4
D.D., Basu, Commentary on the Constitution of India, 1982.
5
Encyclopaedia, Britannica, XVI Edition
6
Article 2, the Conflict of Nationality Laws Convention, Hague, 1930.
7
Digest Of International Law Cases, 1998.
6
Scenario Of Citizenship In India
7
2. By migration
3. By registration
Domicile
8
Thus, there must be both, the factum and animus; to
constitute the existence of domicile, for neither mere
residence nor mere intention to reside at the place is
sufficient to constitute the domicile of the person. 10
Kinds Of Domicile
Basically there are three types of domicile, as
organized under common law and statutes[i]. They
are:
• domicile of origin,
• domicile of choice or necessary domicile; and
• domicile by operation of law.
Domicile by birth is the domicile that is acquired by a
child for the reason of its birth. Thus it is attributed to
everyone at birth. For example, a child born in a
10
Halsbury’s Laws Of England
11
AIR 1966 SC 1436
9
marital relationship will take the domicile of its father,
and a child born outside wedlock will take the
domicile of its mother.
However, any person without a legal disability can
have a domicile of choice. Domicile by choice is the
domicile that is presumed or inferred by law. The law
will presume a domicile of choice if there is a change
of residence coupled with an intention of making the
change permanent[ii].
Domicile by operation of law is the one that is
imposed by law. The following are the examples of
domicile by operation of law:
• When the parents of a child changes their domicile,
the domicile of the child will also get changed by the
operation of law; and
• When a woman is married, she acquires the domicile
of her husband. However, a married woman can
acquire her own domicile, independent of her
husband.
12
AIR 1984 SC 1420
10
2) Citizenship By Migration (Article 6)
Article 6: Rights of citizenship of certain persons who
have migrated to India from Pakistan.13
• Notwithstanding anything in Article 5, a person who
has migrated to the territory of India from the
territory now included in Pakistan shall be deemed to
be a citizen of India at the commencement of this
Constitution if-
• he or either of his parents or any of his grand-
parents was born in India as defined in the
Government of India Act, 1935 (as originally
enacted); and
• (i) in the case where such person has so migrated
before the nineteenth day of July, 1948, he has been
ordinarily resident in the territory of India since the
date of his migration, or
• (ii) in the case where such person has so migrated
on or after the nineteenth day of July, 1948, he has
been registered as a citizen of India by an officer
appointed in that behalf by the Government of the
Dominion of India on an application made by him
there for to such officer before the commencement of
this Constitution in the form and manner prescribed
by that Government:
•Provided that no person shall be so registered unless
he has been resident in the territory of India for at
least six months immediately preceding the date of
his application.
Article 6 deals with those persons who migrated to
India from Pakistan. India as defined in the
Government of India Act, 1935, means undivided
13
Govt. Of India Act, 1935.
11
India. These persons were divided into two
categories.
• Category 1: Those who came before July 19, 1948
• Category 2: Those who came after July 19, 1948
Those who came from Pakistan to India before July
19, 1948 would automatically become Indian Citizens.
Those who came after July 19, 1948 would become
Indian Citizens provided they had been registered in
the form and manner as prescribed by the
Government of India.14
12
He again left for Pakistan and came back to India
in 1956. The Supreme Court held that he had lost
his Indian citizenship because of his migrating to
Pakistan.
13
unlike Articles 5 and 6, a person could become a
citizen of India, not only at the commencement of
the Constitution but also subsequent to such
commencement.
16
B. Shiva Rao, Framing of India’s Constitution, 1968.
14
Continuance of right of Citizenship (Article 10)
Every person who is or is deemed to be a citizen of
India under any of the foregoing provisions of this
Part shall, subject to the provisions of any law that
may be made by Parliament, continue to be such
citizen. It thus enacts that an express law made by
the Union Parliament for the purpose can only take
the right to citizenship of India given under the
Constitution, away.
Case: Ebrahim Wazir vs. State Of Bombay17. The
appellant, a citizen of India, having entered India
from Pakistan without a permit, was ordered to be
removed to Pakistan under Section 7 of The Influx
From Pakistan (Control) Act, 1949. The Supreme
Court held Section 7 ultra vires the Parliament
because it allowed the forcible removal of an
Indian citizen from India, destroying his right of
citizenship, conferred by Part II of the
Constitution. The right of citizenship, the Court
ruled, would only be taken away by recourse to
Article 11 of the Constitution. It was thus held,
that the absence of a law expressly made under
Article 11, the right of citizenship, which a person
had acquired under Part II, could not be destroyed
by an act made for a different purpose.
17
AIR 1954 SC 229
15
Citizenship Of India After The
Commencement Of The Constitution
(The Citizenship Act 1955)
The Citizenship Act, 1955 that came into force with
effect from 30th December 1955 deals with matters
relating to the acquisition, determination and
termination of Indian citizenship. It provides for the
acquisition of Indian citizenship by birth, by
descent, by registration and by naturalization. 18
18
Kumar, Narender, Constitutional Law Of India, 2015, Allahabad Law Agency, Faridabad, India
19
Ins, by the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 1986.
20
Ibid.
16
• His father (or mother)21 is an enemy alien and his
birth takes place in a territory then under enemy
occupation.
There has been many amendments in this section
but latest amendment was done by The Citizenship
Act, 2003 to the effect that a person born in India on
or after the commencement of this Amendment Act,
shall be a citizen of India by birth if at the time of
his birth both of his parents are citizens of India or
one of whose parents is a citizen of India and the
other is not an illegal migrant.
17
December, 2004, is considered as a citizen of India
if either of his parents was a citizen of India by birth
at the time of his birth. In case either of the parents
was a citizen of India by descent, that person shall
not be a citizen of India, unless his birth is
registered at an Indian Consulate within one year
from the date of birth or with the permission of the
Central Government, after the expiry of the said
period.
• A person born outside India on or after 3rd
December, 2004 shall not be a citizen of India,
unless the parents declare that the minor does not
hold passport of another country and his birth is
registered at an Indian consulate within one year of
the date of birth or with the permission of the
Central Government, after the expiry of the said
period.
18
years (as mentioned at (a) above) before making
application under section 5(1)(c). Application shall
be made in Form-II.
Minor children whose both parents are Indian
citizens under section 5(1)(d). His parents in Form-
III shall make application.
Persons of full age whose both parents are
registered as citizens of India under section 5(1)(a)
or section 6(1) can acquire Indian citizenship under
section 5(1)(e). Application shall be made in Form
III-A.
Persons of full age who or either of the parents
were earlier citizen of Independent India and
residing in India for ONE YEAR immediately before
making application under section 5(1)(f).
Application shall be made in Form III- B.
Persons of full age and capacity who has been
registered as an Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) for
five years and residing in India for one year before
making application under section 5(1)(g).
Application shall be made in Form III-C.
Clarification: A person shall be deemed to be a
Person of Indian origin if he, or either of his parents,
was born in undivided India or in such other
territory which became part of India after the 15th
day of August 1947.
19
rights of citizenship conferred by a State upon a
person who was before, an alien to that State”. A
foreign citizen not covered by any of the above
methods can get Indian citizenship on application of
Naturalization to the Government of India; with the
following conditions:
23
The Indian Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 1986.
24
Subs. By the Citizenship ( Amendment) Act, 2003
25
The Citizenship ( Amendment) Act,1986
26
The Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2003
20
The Government of India may waive all or any of the
above conditions for naturalization, in the case of a
person who, in its opinion, has rendered distinguished
service for the cause of science, philosophy, world
peace or human progress generally.27
21
they will not have any political rights, will not be
allowed to vote, or run for office or take jobs in
defense services. However, the Prime Minister Sh.
Manmohan Singh on 10th January 2010 declared at the
Pravasi Bharatiya Diwas, that all NRIs would get a
chance to vote by the time the next general elections
in 2010. The Act would fulfill the long pending
demand of the NRIs. It would enable both Bharatvasis
and Bharatvanshis to contribute together to the cause
of India’s development. 28
28
Kumar, Narender, Constitutional Law Of India, 2015, Allahabad Law Agency, Faridabad, India
22
As regards the termination of Citizenship of India
subsequent to the commencement of the Constitution,
the Citizenship Act 1955, provides the following ways-
a) by renunciation
b) by termination
c) by deprivation
23
Section 10 of the Citizenship Act 1955 provides that
a citizen of India, whether by naturalization or y
registration or by domicile or by residence, may be
deprived of his citizenship of India by an order of
the Central Government if it is satisfied:
i) that the registration or certificate of
naturalization was obtained by him by means
of fraud, false representation or concealment of
any material fact; or
ii) that he has shown himself by act or speech, to
be disloyal or diseffected towards the
Constitution of India; or
iii) that he, during a war in which India may be
engaged, unlawfully traded or communicated
with the enemy; or
iv) that within 5 years of his registration or
naturalization, he has been sentenced to
imprisonment for not less than 2 years; or
v) that he has been ordinarily resident of India for
seven years and during that period he has neither
been at any time, a student of an educational
institution in a country outside India; nor in service
of Goverment of India, or of International
Organization of which India is a member; nor
registered annually in the prescribed manner, at an
Indian consulate his intention to retain his
citizenship of India.
24
A Company or Corporation, whether a Citizen of
India
30
AIR 1963 SC 1811
31
AIR 1970 SC 564
25
India
India has effectively stripped 4 million people from
the state of Assam of their citizenship.
The state has a National Register of Citizens (NRC),
which includes the names of all those who can prove
they came to the state before 24 March 1971 – the day
before Bangladesh declared independence.
India has now released a final draft of a list of its
citizens, leaving some 4 million people to prove their
Indian nationality.
The application process for inclusion in India’s
national register started in 2015. Of the 32.9 million
applicants, the names of 28.9 million have been
approved and included in the draft, India’s registrar-
general Sailesh told reporters in Gauhati, the capital of
Assam state.
Mr. Sailesh said more than 4 million who have been
left out can file appeals by 30 September and prove
their Indian nationality by providing documents –
until then, no one will be declared an illegal migrant.
“Adequate and ample scope will be given to people for
making objections. No genuine Indian citizen should
have any fear,” Mr Sailesh said.
Allegations of illegal movement of people from India’s
border with Bangladesh have triggered sectarian
tensions between the state’s indigenous population
and Bengali-speaking Muslims.
Hundreds of Bengali-speaking Muslims whose
nationalities are suspect are living in detention camps
in Assam state.
26
People were asked to provide documents proving that
they or their family members lived in India before
Bangladesh’s independence.
The final national register containing the names of
only Indian nationals, after determining illegal
migrants, will be published after the disputed claims
are settled.
“Nowhere else in India have we carried out such an
exercise to have a list of Indian nationals,” said
National Register of Citizens coordinator Prateek
Hajela.32
Europe, USA
27
including the UK - amid concerns that they pose a
corruption risk. In the US, government financial
investigators say individuals are buying citizenship to
hide their true identity, in an attempt to flout
economic sanctions against Iran. 33
Bibilography
33
Harte, Alys, BBC World News, 6th June 2018, www.bbcworldnews.co.uk
28
1. Basu D.; Introduction to the Constitution of India,
2008, Wadhwa, Nagpur.
2.Kumar Narender; Constitutional law of India, 2010,
Allahabad law agency; Delhi.
Webliography
1. http://www.outlookindia.com/article.aspx?239,
accessed on 8th August 2018 at 7:30 pm.
2. http://icon.oxfordjournals.org./content/8/14/71
4.abstract accessed on 8th August 2018 at 7:43
pm.
3. www.indiankanoon.com accessed on 10th August
2018 at 6:30 pm.
4. www.legaservicesindia.com/article23123
accessed on 14th August 2018 at 9:17 pm.
29