Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mehrpoo2019 PDF
Mehrpoo2019 PDF
Mehrpoo2019 PDF
m.mehrpoo@ieee.org
MUX
and readout of quantum bits (qubits). A fault-tolerant quan- LNA
tum computer operates at deep cryogenic temperatures (i.e., LOI/Q
READOUT
<100 mK) and requires thousands of qubits for running practical
Digital Control
(ASIC/FPGA)
Quantum Processor
quantum algorithms. Consequently, CMOS radio-frequency (RF)
LOI/Q Phase
integrated circuits operating at cryogenic temperatures down Detector
to 4 K (Cryo-CMOS) offer a higher level of system integration
and scalability for future quantum computers. In this paper, we Frequency Synthesizer
extensively discuss the role, benefits, and constraints of Cryo- CONTROL LOI/Q
CMOS for qubits control and readout. The main characteristics
DEMUX
of the CMOS transistors and their impacts on RF circuit designs Driver DAC
are described. Furthermore, opportunities and challenges of low Pprobe
noise RF signal generation and amplification are investigated. 1-4K
20-100mK 300K
I. I NTRODUCTION
Fig. 1. Block diagram of a cryo-CMOS circuit for qubits readout and control.
Quantum computing promises to solve specific compu-
tational problems exponentially faster than any imaginable multiple RF and DC cables per qubit, which are each con-
digital computer. These problems include DNA analysis, effi- nected to room temperature laboratory instruments [6], [7].
cient search in gigantic data sets concerning medical research, However, more than 100 logical qubits are needed to reach
consumer behavior and financial markets [1], and optimization quantum supremacy or solve a quantum chemistry problem
of materials and industrial chemical processes [2]. Quantum even with the most straightforward quantum algorithms [8].
mechanics permits a particle to exist in a superposition state This indicates the need for thousands or millions of phys-
and be entangled to physically separated systems. These phe- ical qubits by considering the redundancy added by QCE
nomena are exploited by quantum machines to simultaneously schemes, such as surface codes [5]. Consequently, for the
produce rich configuration states and highly correlated behav- fault-tolerant quantum computer with millions of qubits, indi-
ior to tackle classically intractable computational problems. vidually connecting each qubit to a room-temperature off-the-
A quantum computer operates by processing the information shelf electronics becomes challenging, if not impossible, due
stored in quantum bits (qubits), the states of which is repre- to the utter interconnect complexity, poor system reliability,
sented using Dirac’s notation, as a superposition of |0i and |1i and cost. A more promising approach is to integrate the
states. Although qubits usually operate at deep cryogenic tem- readout and control circuitry in a standard CMOS technology
peratures, their coherence time and gate fidelity are typically operating at cryogenic temperatures (cryo-CMOS), leading to
not sufficient to be used as computational qubits directly [3], a significant reduction of form factor, power consumption,
[4]. It is, however, possible to perform fault-tolerant quantum and system cost/complexity and most importantly enabling
computing by exploiting quantum error correction (QCE), scalability [9]–[11]. This approach significantly improves the
which encodes the information in a logical qubit constructed latency of the QEC loop by reducing the round-trip delay of
from a collection of physical qubits [5]. cables and filters, which is considerable with respect to the
Performing operations on the qubits requires a classical qubit operation time.
electronic controller for manipulating the qubits and reading Qubit control and readout require generation and acquisition
out their quantum state. Currently, state-of-the-art quantum of specific RF signals. For instance, for control of transmons
processors contain only a few qubits (<20 qubits) and require (superconducting qubits), a 4-8 GHz microwave signal with a
duration of <1µs must be applied [12], [13], and for their state
This work was supported by Intel Corporation. readout, the resonant frequency of a microwave resonator that
VDD
POUT
RL
Pin
Vb
Fig. 2. (a)-(g) DC characterization and translated parameters of an NMOS transistor (W/L = 1.2 µm/40 nm) at 300 K and 4 K, (h) a class-A power amplifier.
is strongly coupled to the qubit is measured. Consequently, as while no change in gate capacitance (gate oxide/metallization
can be gathered from Fig.1, the simplified block diagram of variation) points to an increase in device transit frequency (fT )
the Cryo-CMOS controller comprises several RF blocks and [17]. Fig. 2(d) which shows the rout of the devices at RT and
closely resembles a wireless transceiver. 4 K, suggesting that the rout decreases by a factor of 2 in the
In this paper, we focus on the benefits, constraints, and strong inversion.1 Finally, from Fig. 2(c) and Fig. 2(d), one can
challenges of designing cryogenic CMOS RF circuits. The infer that there is no increase in the intrinsic gain of the device
primary characteristics of CMOS transistors and their impacts at 4 K compared to RT, as shown in Fig. 2(f).
on RF circuit designs are described in Section II. Section III After analyzing the effect of device parameter variations,
and IV focuses on the design opportunities and challenges of let’s consider the design example of a highly linear class-
the implementation of two fundamental blocks present in the A Cryo-CMOS (power) amplifier, as shown in Fig. 2(h). The
system diagram in Fig. 1, i.e., readout circuits and frequency voltage gain of such an amplifier is governed by
synthesizers, respectively. Conclusions are drawn in section V. gm
Av = gm × RL = × (RL .ID ) (1)
II. C RYO -CMOS CHARACTERIZATION AND IMPACT ON RF ID
CIRCUIT DESIGN where RL (RL << rout ) is the load resistance seen by the
DC characterization results of 40-nm CMOS devices, shown amplifier and is fixed by the matching network, ID is the
in Fig. 2(a)-(c), can be translated into design-oriented param- current of the amplifier and is determined by the output power
eters in Fig. 2(d)-(g), to analyze how cryogenic CMOS affects (POU T ) required to drive the qubits. As can be gathered from
RF circuit design choices and strategies. From the ID -VGS Fig. 2(g), in order to obtain the best linearity, the device should
curves shown in Fig. 2(a), it can be observed that the threshold be biased in the strong inversion region at an overdrive voltage
voltage at 4 K increases by almost 100 mV compared to room of ∼0.25 V, for both 4 K and RT. The device can then be sized
temperature (RT), due to an increase in ionization energy [14] based on the calculated load current and overdrive voltage.
[15] [16]. This presents a challenge for voltage headroom, From Fig. 2(e)), it can be observed that in the moderate and
especially in case of stacked transistor-based circuit topologies strong inversion, the gm /ID remains almost the same over
with demanding high linearity requirements. Hence, there is an temperature. Consequently, the voltage gain of the amplifier
urge to use low VT H devices and constant current biasing. As would be the same over temperature, for large signal operation
shown in ID -VDS curves of Fig. 2(b), there is an increase in where linearity is crucial. However, if the linearity require-
the current driving capability of the device mainly caused by ments are more relaxed, in blocks such as readout low noise
an increase in mobility of the devices at 4 K due to a decrease amplifiers, it is suggested to bias the transistor towards the
in electron scattering [15]. weak-inversion, where gm /ID is higher at 4 K, and thus the
Fig. 2(c) shows the transconductance (gm ) as a function of circuit can be more power efficient at cryogenic temperatures.
VGS , suggesting that there is an increase in gm by almost a 1 To ensure the same operating region, the plots are made with the same
factor of 2 in the strong inversion region. An increase in gm , overdrive voltage (hence 100 mV increase in VGS at 4 K).
III. C RYOGENIC R EADOUT probe
pulse amp.
signal gen.
digital readout chain
qubits state
High-fidelity readout of qubits is an essential element of matched amplification
filters downconv.
AWG
ωr1
ωr,n
any superconducting-based quantum computer, imposing strin- ADC
300K
gent requirements on the noise performance of the readout
chain [12], [13]. Moreover, a promising scalable readout Tpulse HEMT ~4K
20dB LNA stage
solution relies on the frequency multiplexing of many qubits, time
that would require circuits with GHz-range amplification band- supercond.
50mK
attenuator
Quantum Chip parametric
width and large dynamic range [18], [19]. stage
readout feedline amplifier
The readout of superconducting qubits, as schematically
30dB
depicted in Fig. 3, is typically implemented by dispersively
Port 2
Port 1
coupling each qubit to individual frequency multiplexed res- high-Q 0
readout
S21(dB)
onators, which are capacitively coupled to a common feedline.
resonator ωr1 ωr,n
During the readout operation, the feedline is probed with a
ωr1 ωr,n
short (100–300 ns [12], [13], [18]–[21]) weak RF pulse with super-
zoomed
the same frequency as the qubit, which is typically within 4– conducting
Qubits ωQ1 ωQ,n
8 GHz. Due to the qubit-state-dependent frequency shift [19], |0 |1
the notch in the feedline transmission curve (S21 ) gets slightly ωr1 ω +Δ
(a) r1 1 (b)
shifted causing a state-dependent phase shift of the output
pulse, as shown for Q1 in Fig. 3(b). To be able to detect Fig. 3. (a) Schematic of a typical frequency-multiplexed readout scheme for
superconducting qubits, with the readout electronics at RT. (b) an example
this phase modulated signal with a power level of around transmission spectra and the qubit-state-dependent frequency shift.
-130 dBm [20], the output signals should be amplified by
around 120 dB in a few stages before downconversion to realization of LNAs with a few Kelvin noise temperature
a relatively low-intermediate frequency (IF) and digitization requirements [10]. Consequently, to be able to break the
over a large bandwidth. Each carrier of the digitized signal noise-power consumption trade-off of the active devices and
is then filtered with a matched filter to provide near optimal benefit from the cryogenic operation, alternative RF CMOS
signal-to-noise ratios. amplification techniques such as parametric amplifiers need to
To be able to achieve high-fidelity (>99% [13], [18]– be investigated.
[20]) readout, many recent developments [12], [13], [18]– A parametric amplifier utilizes a nonlinear capacitance or
[21] rely on a superconducting parametric amplifier, operating inductance together with a relatively large amplitude pump
at the base temperature close to the qubits, followed by a signal to provide amplification of the desired signal [28]. The
high-electron-mobility transistors (HEMT) low-noise ampli- operation principle can be intuitively explained by assuming a
fier (LNA), operating at 4 K. State-of-the-art superconducting simple time-invariant nonlinear response between the amplifier
3
parametric amplifiers [22], [23] have shown broad bandwidths, output (vout ) and its input (vin ), where vout = vin +a3 vin . By
a typical gain of 20 dB, and noise temperatures close to the applying the desired signal (As cos(ωs t)) and the pump signal
quantum limit (e.g., 0.336 K at 7 GHz), making them crucial (Ap cos(ωp t)) to the amplifier input, a component proportional
components for multiplexed, high-fidelity readout operations. to a3 A2p As appears at the frequency of the desired signal. Hav-
The HEMT LNAs, however, have 10× larger noise tempera- ing sufficient nonlinearity and a large pump signal amplitude,
tures (e.g., the commercial LNA in [24], which is widely used an amplification of ∝ a3 A2p can be achieved. As the noise of
in the state-of-the-art readout setups [12], [13], [18], [19], has reactive components is directly proportional to their loss and
the best noise temperature of 2.2 K over 4 to 8 GHz range with the ambient temperature, the parametric amplifier can be a
a power consumption of 7.7 mW). promising candidate for low-noise amplification at cryogenic
To be able to integrate the whole readout chain in a temperatures.
deep-submicron CMOS technology, the applicability of low- The aforementioned superconducting parametric amplifiers
power RF CMOS LNAs at cryogenic temperatures has to be typically rely on a nonlinear extremely-low-loss junction that
investigated. Besides the analog/RF characteristics improve- operates similar to an inductor [22], which is currently not
ment at cryogenic temperatures mentioned in section-II, the available in bulk CMOS processes. Nonlinear varactors have
minimum noise temperature has been also reported to improve thus been employed by a few works [29]–[31] to achieve a
by approximately 10× in 32-nm SOI CMOS [25] at 6 K. This parametric gain in CMOS, where only [31] has demonstrated
might be surprising since a more significant change is expected RF parametric amplification using inductors and varactors. The
as the temperature has reduced by 50×. This has been recently implementation in [31] is still based on an active LNA preced-
explained by observing that the channel noise in nanoscale ing the parametric amplifier and has a limited 1dB-bandwidth
CMOS (with LCH <100 nm) is dominated by the suppressed of around 400 MHz, and, more importantly, it is sensitive to
shot noise (Sid = 2qIDS F ) in the medium to strong inversion the phase difference between the desired and pump signals,
regime [26], [27]. Such saturation of noise improvement versus making it impractical for a multiplexed readout. Thus, several
temperature can lead to excessive power consumption in the hurdles must be overcome to fully benefit from parametric
In order to mitigate the effect of the increase in the 1/f 3
101 corner, one needs to resort to oscillator topologies with low
flicker noise upconversion. It is well-known that the flicker
Resistivity [10-9 Ω.m]