Professional Documents
Culture Documents
European Polymer Journal: Abbas Hijazi, Antoine Khater
European Polymer Journal: Abbas Hijazi, Antoine Khater
European Polymer Journal: Abbas Hijazi, Antoine Khater
Macromolecular Nanotechnology
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
MACROMOLECULAR NANOTECHNOLOGY
Article history: A molecular dynamics simulation is presented to calculate the Probability Distribution
Received 7 April 2008 Functions (PDF) for the spatial positions and angular orientations of macromolecular
Received in revised form 19 June 2008 rod-like particles in dilute solutions, under hydrodynamic flow, in the vicinity of uneven
Accepted 5 August 2008
solid boundaries. The Brownian and hydrodynamic restitution model for ideally flat sur-
Available online 20 August 2008
faces is generalized to simulate the diffusive collisions between the macromolecular parti-
cles and an uneven solid surface. Two types of uneven surfaces are particularly considered:
the periodic grating and the random rough, with characteristic profiles of heights and lat-
Keywords:
Boeder PDF
eral variations. Different from ideally flat surfaces, the simulation results demonstrate that
Complex fluids uneven surfaces have characteristic depletion layers, and characteristic and variable PDF.
Numerical simulations This is the case under varying conditions of hydrodynamic flow, Brownian movement
Uneven surfaces and diffusive collisions. These characteristics uniquely identify Boeder PDF signatures for
Mesopore nanotechnology the uneven surface topography.
Ó 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0014-3057/$ - see front matter Ó 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.eurpolymj.2008.08.007
3410 A. Hijazi, A. Khater / European Polymer Journal 44 (2008) 3409–3416
laminar flow of the solutions is in contrast characteristic of found in agreement with the exact analytical solutions of
the hydrodynamic flow conditions. For one and the same the bulk BDE. Furthermore, the assumptions of restitution
macromolecule, low and high a correspond then, respec- were tested experimentally and found valid for micro-
tively, to low and high flow. scopic macromolecular particles [12]. Surface PDF distribu-
Boeder gave a series mathematical solution valid for tions, given as a function of the spatial positions of the
only small values of a, and a Taylor series development centres of mass and of the angular orientations of the mac-
for the high values of a that suffered from the difficulty romolecular rod-like particles, are thus calculated for the
of identifying the necessary boundary conditions. Some physical range of possible values of the restitution.
improvements have been made, first to remove restrictions The simulated surface spatial PDF distributions for
on the cross-sectional areas of such macromolecules, and ideally flat surfaces are consistently concave in the deple-
secondly to be able to consider their rotational diffusion tion layer as is physically expected. For small a i.e. low flow
in three dimensions [6–8], but these efforts have been lim- conditions, these PDF distributions are shown to be the
ited to small values of a. result of a dynamic balance between competing Brownian
The analytical solution of the Boeder Differential Equa- and hydrodynamic diffusive collisions. For large a, the
tion in the bulk has been obtained recently in general in macromolecular particles are shown to be evacuated from
two dimensions, in the plane of the linear flow, for a wide the depletion layer by the dominant hydrodynamic colli-
range of a [9]. Special analytical as well as numerical meth- sions, which effect is consistent with experimental obser-
ods are developed in order to calculate accurately the PDF vations. On the other hand, the numerically simulated
distributions, for all arbitrary values of a. Turbulence ef- surface angular PDF distributions for the depletion layer
fects, however, are known to take place for a P 104, and show marked differences from their bulk counterpart.
the BDE equation ceases to apply in a strict physical sense The purpose of this paper is to perform Boeder Brown-
beyond this value.
MACROMOLECULAR NANOTECHNOLOGY
Fig. 1. A typical topography of a rough solid surface at the microscopic scale, from Ref. [16].
MACROMOLECULAR NANOTECHNOLOGY
Fig. 2. A typical topography of a grating solid surface at the microscopic scale, from Ref. [23].
face results. It is seen that these PDF distributions are char- boundary this translation diffusion contributes to deter-
acteristic of the unevenness of the solid boundary. mining the displacement of the particles from the bulk
towards the depletion layer and vice versa. Brownian diffu-
sion comprises hence both rotation and translation diffu-
2. The model algorithm for simulations sion in the neighbourhood of solid boundaries, and for
relatively low concentrations of the particles it is possible
In this section, we present the model for numerical to treat the diffusive collisions arising from both processes
simulations. The notion of restitution is developed to separately.
develop an algorithm for the diffusive collisions of the Since, the detailed nature of the collisions is quite com-
macromolecular particles with the uneven grating and plex, we introduce the notion of mechanical restitution for
the random rough surfaces. The joint PDF distributions, both Brownian and hydrodynamic collisions. These colli-
P(h, n), are calculated as a function of the angular orienta- sions take place in the algorithm following, respectively,
tions h of the macromolecular particles and the normalized a Brownian or a hydrodynamic bulk movement that brings
distance of their center of mass n, measured from a refer- a macromolecular extremity into contact with the solid
ence plane at the boundary. The solution is considered sta- surface boundary. They are distinguished physically by
tionary in contact with the uneven solid surface boundary, treating the Brownian collision as due to a Brownian ran-
and the shear rate field c_ is assumed to be uniform beyond dom event following which the macromolecule should
the uneven topography. come away from the surface in an equally random manner;
For the dynamics of the macromolecular particles, zc in this sense a surface Brownian collision intercedes across
shall denote the distance that separates their centre of the same random Brownian movement. The hydrodynamic
mass from a chosen reference plane in the boundary. In collision in contrast is caused by the laminar flow before
the bulk it is possible to neglect the Brownian translation and after such a collision; in this sense a surface hydrody-
diffusion, since this has no statistical incidence on the namic collision intercedes across the causal flow, forma-
angular PDF distributions, P(h). However, near a surface lised by the turning of the macromolecular rod-like about
3412 A. Hijazi, A. Khater / European Polymer Journal 44 (2008) 3409–3416
its extremity after the hydrodynamic collision. Two inde- A generalized Brownian random variable, Dzc,tr is intro-
pendent restitution coefficients, e and e0 , are then consid- duced that displaces the particle in either sense normal to
ered to describe, respectively, the Brownian and hydrody the reference plane in the boundary. The ambiguities aris-
namic collisions. The two restitution coefficients, are both ing from the arbitrary simulation time steps are eliminated
defined on a [0, 1] measure interval, as detailed next. in order to derive an expression for Dzc,tr = zc(n + 1)zc(n)
The collisions algorithm is constructed next over a as a function of the simulation variable Dh = h(n + 1)h(n).
sequence of events, named n, ncollision, n + 1, for a collision In the case when a random translation Brownian diffusion
arising due to translation diffusion. Note that n denotes event brings one of the extremities of the rod-like molecu-
the event before collision, and n + 1 the event after colli- lar particle into collision with the surface, we may write
sion and that near a surface boundary the extremities need that
to be identified in order to distinguish and follow the col-
lisions of one or the other with the surface boundary. To zc ðn þ 1Þ ¼ zcollision þ e½zc ðnÞ zcollision
illustrate this see Fig. 3a for the case of the grating surface zcollision ¼ L=2 j sin hðnÞ j þbran ð0; 1Þ ð4Þ
and rod-like particle. Without loss of generality we con-
sider the grating spacing and the periodic microstructure L=2 sin hðnÞ j is the touch distance of the centre of mass of
to be of equal lengths, namely a. The height of the micro- the particle from a reference plane, here considered to be
structure is b, and L is the common length of the rod-like the base plane for a grating surface. For such a periodic
macromolecules. It is assumed that grating surface, the algorithm element ran(0,1) is consid-
ered as a purely random integer that is either 0 or 1, with
b < L << a ð3Þ equal probabilities. The touch angle for the present
This is a general condition applying for macromolecules of sequence is h(n) = h(n + 1). This sequence determines Dzc,tr,
variable lengths provided they scale following Eq. (3). whereas the next event beyond n + 1, moves the particle
MACROMOLECULAR NANOTECHNOLOGY
In a given simulation sequence for a Brownian transla- into other accessible configurations.
tion diffusion, the limiting case e = 0 corresponds to stick- The Brownian rotation diffusion that brings one of the
ing, whereas e = 1 corresponds to the restitution of the extremities of the particle into collision with the boundary
macromolecular particle to its previous position. The resti- may be characterized in a comparable manner. In this case
tution coefficient satisfies in general the conditions zc(n + 1) = zc(n) is the touch distance of the centre of mass
0 6 e 6 1, and the simulations are investigated for different from the reference plane, and we have the rotation algo-
possibilities. rithm for collisions as
Zc(n+1)
L/2
2D profile of
rough surface
Variable height = Zc(n) θ (n+1)
b ran(0,1)
Fig. 3. Basic algorithm elements for the collision configurations of the rod-like macromolecular particles with a grating surface in Fig. 3a, and with a rough
surface in Fig. 3b.
A. Hijazi, A. Khater / European Polymer Journal 44 (2008) 3409–3416 3413
MACROMOLECULAR NANOTECHNOLOGY
a periodic grating surface α =2. e=0.5
0.004
P(ξ ) normalized
0.003
0.002 e'=0
e'=0.5
e'=1
0.001
0.000
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
ξ
0.005
0.004
P(ξ) normalized
0.003
e'=0
0.002 e'=0.5
e'=1
0.001
0.000
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
ξ
Fig. 4. Typical simulation results, for a surface grating, for the normalized PDF P(n), folded over the orientations, as a function of the normalized distance, n,
of the centre of mass of the macromolecular rod-like particles, measured from the reference plane. The P(n) are calculated in the depletion layer in the
vicinity of the surface grating, for a fixed choice of the restitution coefficient e = 0.5, and for variable e0 , at conditions of relatively low flow, a = 2, in Fig. 4a,
and of relatively high flow, a = 50, in Fig. 4b, for comparison.
3414 A. Hijazi, A. Khater / European Polymer Journal 44 (2008) 3409–3416
application of the model to such surfaces is useful to test algorithm condition b << L, and go through N = 108 events
the algorithm. per Monte Carlo simulation run.
In Fig. 3b the algorithm scheme of the diffusive colli- In Fig. 4, are presented, for the surface grating, typical
sions of the rod-like particles with an uneven surface is simulation results for the joint normalized PDF P(n), folded
presented, for random rough surfaces. The reference plane over the orientations, as a function of the normalized dis-
is a flat plane that corresponds to the base line in Fig. 3b. tance of the centre of mass of the macromolecular rod-like
Further, we assume that successive diffusive collisions particles, n, from the reference base plane. The P(n) are cal-
with the uneven surface are independent of surface topo- culated, for a fixed choice of the Brownian restitution
graphic correlations, for the choice of b and L. This assump- e = 0.5, and for variable hydrodynamic restitutions e0 = 0,
tion, however, is not applicable when the length of the 0.5, and 1, at conditions of low hydrodynamic flow, a = 2,
macromolecular particle is comparable to the mean height in Fig. 4a, and high flow, a = 50, in Fig. 4b. The first obser-
of the uneven surface, for which b P L, when both lateral vation is the existence of effectively two depletion layers,
and normal correlations of the uneven surface, become the first in the interval 0 6 n 6 0.5, as for an ideally flat sur-
important. face, and the second in the interval 0.5 6 n 6 0.5 + 2b /L.
This is a new effect absent from the case of an ideally flat
surface. It may be readily understood in terms of the
3. Simulation results and conclusions cumulative effects of the collisions of the rod-like particles
relative to the reference plane between the grating ele-
The numerical simulations are applied next for two ments, and to the height of the grating elements above
uneven surfaces types, the periodic grating and random the reference plane. Note that P(n) is consistently concave
rough. We consider in general that b = L/10 to satisfy the in the total depletion layer, with pinning at n = 0.5, and that
MACROMOLECULAR NANOTECHNOLOGY
a 0.005
random rough surface α =15
0.004
P(ξ) normalized
0.003
0.002 e=e'=0
e=e'=0.5
e=e'=1
0.001
0.000
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
ξ
0.005
b
random rough surface α=100
0.004
P(ξ) normalized
0.003
0.002
e=e'=0
e=e'=0.5
0.001 e=e'=1
0.000
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
ξ
Fig. 5. Typical simulation results, for a rough surface, for the normalized PDF P(n), folded over the orientations, as a function of the normalized distance, n, of
the centre of mass of the macromolecular rod-like particles, measured from the reference plane. The P(n) are calculated in the depletion layer in the vicinity
of the rough surface, for variable values of e = e0 , at conditions of relatively medium flow, a = 15, in Fig. 5a, and of relatively high flow, a = 100, in Fig. 5b, for
comparison.
A. Hijazi, A. Khater / European Polymer Journal 44 (2008) 3409–3416 3415
flat surface
grating surface
α=0. e=0. e'=0
random rough surface
0.0040
0.0035
0.0030
0.0020
0.0015
0.0010
0.0005
0.0000
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
X
Fig. 6. A comparison of simulation results for the PDF P(n), under identical conditions, for the flat, grating and rough surfaces, where the normalized n is
measured from a common reference plane. The P(n) are calculated for a stationary liquid, a = 0, and for e = e0 = 0.
MACROMOLECULAR NANOTECHNOLOGY
it decreases with increasing a. This is expected and is due is to compare under the same conditions the results for
to the hydrodynamic flow which tends to evacuate the par- three different surfaces. It is seen that the differences
ticles with increasing a. in the PDFs are significantly enhanced in the depletion
In Fig. 5, are presented, for the random rough surface, layer under certain restitution conditions. The normal-
typical simulation results for the joint normalized PDF ized n is measured from a common reference plane for
P(n). This is calculated for variable values of the Brownian all three surfaces.
and hydrodynamic restitutions, e = e0 = 0, 0.5, and 1, at In Fig. 7 we present simulation results for the normal-
conditions of medium flow, a = 15, in Fig. 5a, and high flow, ized PDF P(h), folded over the distances, n, of the centre
a = 100, in Fig. 5b. It is observed that the rough surface of mass of the particles in the depletion layer of the grat-
washes away the trace of the two distinct depletion layers ing surface, as a function of the orientations, h, measured
observed in the previous case of a periodic grating surface. with respect to the reference angle h = 0 parallel to the
For a random rough surface the depletion layer is effec- flow. The P(h) PDF are calculated, for the variable condi-
tively a single homogeneous layer over the entire interval tions of low hydrodynamic flow, a = 0, 2, 6, for
0 6 n 6 0.5 + 2b /L. The second observation concerns the e = e0 = 0.5 in Fig. 7a, and for e = e0 = 1 in Fig. 7b. As ex-
concavity of the PDF P(n), in the depletion layer, for differ- pected these P(h) PDF are symmetric with a maximum
ent e and e0 . For the medium hydrodynamic flow, a = 15, about the reference angle h = 0, for a stationary liquid
P(n) is convex for e = e0 = 0 and as such is the inverse of at rest. It is interesting to note that the P(h) PDF are
the concavity for e = e0 – 0. The convex character is modi- asymmetric with increasing flow a – 0. In particular
fied for the high hydrodynamic flow, a = 100, for which the peak displaces with increasing a in a monotonic
conditions the differences between the individual PDF manner for full restitution e = e0 = 1, but has a varying
P(n), for different e = e0 – 0, also become amplified. This behaviour for partial restitution e = e0 = 0.5.
P(n) signature corresponds to a greater probability of find- In this paper we have presented a model for numerical
ing the rod-like particles in the depletion layer for simulations to determine the angular and spatial Boeder
e = e0 = 0, as compared to the situation for e = e0 – 0. Note PDF probability distributions for macromolecular rod-like
that a critical nc1.3 signals the departure of the concavity particles under equilibrium dynamics of Brownian motion,
in one sense and another, which value is evidently charac- hydrodynamic flow and diffusive collisions at uneven solid
teristic of the random rough surface at low hydrodynamic surface boundaries. The simulation results indicate that
flow. This signals for low Brownian and hydrodynamic res- such surfaces have characteristic depletion layers and
titutions the build up of the rod-like particles in the deple- characteristic PDF probability distributions, different from
tion layer near the rough surface when sticking collision those for ideally flat surface boundaries.
events are allowed for e = e0 = 0. Furthermore, it is demon-
strated that the Brownian and hydrodynamic restitution Acknowledgments
effects are of comparable magnitude for low flow condi-
tions, whereas the hydrodynamic restitution dominates Antoine Khater wishes to thank Luc Barbier, Bernard
for high flow conditions. Salanon, and the Service de Physique et Chimie des
Fig. 6 presents the simulation results for the PDF P(n), Surfaces et des Interfaces of the Commissariat à l’Energie
for a solution at rest, a = 0, and for the Brownian and Atomique (CEA), Saclay, France, for their support during
hydrodynamic restitutions e = e0 = 0. The purpose here his visit.
3416 A. Hijazi, A. Khater / European Polymer Journal 44 (2008) 3409–3416
P(ξ) normalized
0.008
0.006
0.004
0.002
0.000
-80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80
θ
0.012 α =0
α=2
0.010 α =6
P(ξ) normalisée
0.008
0.006
0.004
0.002
0.000
-80 -60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60 80
θ
Fig. 7. Typical simulation results for the normalized PDF P(h), folded over the distances of the centre of mass of the macromolecular rod-like particles in the
depletion layer of the grating surface, as a function of the orientations, h, measured with respect to the reference angle h = 0 parallel to the flow. The P(h), are
calculated, for the variable conditions of the relatively low flow, a = 0, 2, 6, for e = e0 = 0.5 in Fig. 7a, and for e = e0 = 1 in Fig. 7b, for comparison.