Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Three Ethical Treatises: Aretē Praxis Nicomachean Ethics
Three Ethical Treatises: Aretē Praxis Nicomachean Ethics
Contents
Aristotle as a Socratic[edit]
Some scholars regarded Aristotle as a Socratic thinker.[citation needed] Aristotle's ethics builds upon earlier
Greek thought, particularly that of his teacher Plato and Plato's teacher, Socrates. While Socrates
left no written works, and Plato wrote dialogues and a few letters, Aristotle wrote treatises in which
he sets forth philosophical doctrines directly. To be more precise, Aristotle did write dialogues, but
they unfortunately survive only in fragments.[citation needed]
According to Aristotle in his Metaphysics, Socrates was the first Greek philosopher to concentrate on
ethics, although he apparently did not give it this name, as a philosophical inquiry concerning how
people should best live. Aristotle dealt with this same question but giving it two names, "the political"
(or Politics) and "the ethical" (Ethics), both with Politics being the name for the two together as the
more important part. The original Socratic questioning on ethics started at least partly as a response
to sophism, which was a popular style of education and speech at the time. Sophism
emphasized rhetoric, and argument, and therefore often involved criticism of traditional Greek
religion and flirtation with moral relativism.[citation needed]
Aristotle's ethics, or study of character, is built around the premise that people should achieve an
excellent character (a virtuous character, "ethikē aretē" in Greek) as a pre-condition for attaining
happiness or well-being (eudaimonia). It is sometimes referred to in comparison to later ethical
theories as a "character based ethics". Like Plato and Socrates he emphasized the importance
of reason for human happiness, and that there were logical and natural reasons for humans to
behave virtuously, and try to become virtuous.
Aristotle's treatment of the subject is distinct in several ways from that found in Plato's Socratic
dialogues.
Aristotle's presentation is obviously different from Plato's because he does not write
in dialogues, but in treatises. Apart from this difference, Aristotle explicitly stated that his
presentation was different from Plato's because he started from whatever could be agreed upon
by well brought-up gentlemen, and not from any attempt to develop a general theory of what
makes anything good. He explained that it was necessary not to aim at too much accuracy at
the starting point of any discussion to do with controversial matters such as those concerning
what is just or what is beautiful.[6] (From this starting point however, he built up to similar
theoretical conclusions concerning the importance of intellectual virtue and a contemplative life.)
[7]
Practical ethics