Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Geologically-Driven Pore Fluid Pressure Models and Their Implications For Petroleum Exploration. Introduction To Thematic Set, 2011
Geologically-Driven Pore Fluid Pressure Models and Their Implications For Petroleum Exploration. Introduction To Thematic Set, 2011
ABSTRACT
Abnormal pressure, either low or high, is commonly found in many basins around the world. A clear understand-
ing of these pressure regimes is needed if wells are to be drilled safely. One of the prerequisites for this planning
is prediction of pore fluid pressure, in both reservoirs and also in shales and other low-permeability lithologies. To
this end, recent advances, captured in this thematic set, have seen the development of geologically derived pres-
sure models, underpinned by an understanding of the multiple mechanisms that cause abnormal pressures. These
understandings lead to more accurate pore fluid pressure interpretation in more complex lithological regimes such
as carbonate ⁄ clastic systems and salt-dominated systems that often contain highly overpressured intra-salt reser-
voirs. Further, these models are now being used to drive new exploration plays by improving velocity predictions
to improve sub-salt pore pressure predictions and identifying hydrodynamic aquifers that provide lateral migration
paths for fluids.
Corresponding author: Stephen O’Connor, GeoPressure Technology Ltd, Mountjoy Research Centre, Durham, DH1
3UZ, UK.
Email: s.a.oconnor@geopressure.co.uk. Tel ⁄ Fax: +3 0191 3342191.
understanding the mechanisms that create ‘additional’ or of burial. The main reason for the presence of high porosi-
overpressure. The combined pressure-geological approach ties is because of the ineffective dewatering of shales during
is currently being applied to predict pore fluid pressures in burial, whereby part of the increasing vertical load of the
conventional regimes, carbonate ⁄ clastic systems and salt- overburden (combined weight of the rock column and flu-
dominated systems that often contain highly overpressured ids) is transferred to the fluid phase, increasing pore pres-
intra-salt reservoirs. sure above hydrostatic. Both relationships are derived from
The importance of pressure and pressure data on the the soil mechanics work of Terzaghi (1943) (Eq. 1) and
analysis of a petroleum system is the main purpose of the relate the values from log data, such as sonic (or seismic
thematic set. The four papers in the thematic set provide velocity data) and resistivity, to values associated with nor-
further insights into the understanding of overpressure mal porosity loss by the use of a normal compaction curve
mechanisms that will help form the basis for the next gen- (Fig. 1a).
eration of pore pressure models. Furthermore, the papers
Sv ¼ v þ Pf ð1Þ
demonstrate the use of pressure data in providing a new
exploration model for the Central North Sea via natural where, rv, vertical effective stress; Pf, pore fluid pressure;
drainage of pore pressures and hydrodynamic aquifers. Sv, vertical stress, derived from density data or sonic-
However, to appreciate the significance of the papers and derived density data.
their context, a short summary of prediction methodology In geological settings where sedimentation rates are
is here presented, coupled with a discussion of their limita- high, such as the shallow section of the Malay Basin (Yus-
tions. sof and Swarbrick 1994; Madon 2007) and the Nile Delta
(Mann & MacKenzie 1990), the sediments are relatively
young and geothermal gradients are low; the main mecha-
LOW-TEMPERATURE PORE PRESSURE
nism of overpressure generation is under-compaction often
PREDICTION METHODS
referred to as disequilibrium compaction (Hubbert &
Commonly used methods to estimate the magnitude of Ruby 1959). The pore pressure profile in this environment
pore pressures in shales include the equivalent depth or is overburden parallel when dominated by low-permeability
‘vertical’ method and the Eaton ratio or ‘horizontal’ shales (Swarbrick et al. 2002), that is, increasing overpres-
(Eaton 1975) method. These techniques are based on the sure with increasing depth at a near-constant porosity imply-
identification of anomalously high porosities for the depth ing a near-constant vertical effective stress (overburden
C2 C1
Fig. 1. (a) Sonic data is anomalously compared with that predicted by normal compaction behaviour as overpressure builds (b) as porosity is retained effec-
tive stress remains constant and overpressure as caused disequilibrium increases (path A-B). Path B-C defines the increases in pore fluid pressure (and
decrease in effective stress) during fluid expansion and and load transfer. On (a), the respective changes in porosity are shown i.e. C1 for fluid expansion, C2
for load transfer.
minus pore pressure) (Path A–B; Fig. 1b). The predicted turbidities. More laterally extensive sands have the ability
shale-based pore pressure can then be compared to those to drain this pressure away. Fluid expansion ⁄ fluid volume
direct pressure measurements from wireline formation test processes (termed ‘unloading’ by Bowers 1994) include
tools in porous reservoir lithologies. If the reservoirs are dehydration reactions, such as gypsum to anhydrite and
confined and limited in extent, then they provide valuable smectite to illite, producing water and silica. Maturation of
calibration to the shale-based prediction. hydrocarbons, particularly in the case of gas generation,
produces rapid volume expansion, reducing sonic and seis-
mic velocities (and decreasing resistivity) and increasing
PRESSURE PREDICTION WITHIN COMPLEX
pore pressure substantially. These processes are not associ-
REGIONS
ated with anomalously high porosity for depth of burial
The industry is now searching for hydrocarbons in environ- (disequilibrium compaction), as porosity loss is irreversible.
ments where temperatures typically exceed 100C. At these If no porosity anomaly is detectable, under-compaction-
temperatures, additional mechanisms other than disequilib- based relationships will under-predict pressure. Relation-
rium compaction commence to generate overpressure. ships described by Bowers (1994) provide a solution where
Thermally driven processes include aquathermal expansion, fluid expansion is present or assumed. The method relies
mineral transformation and hydrocarbon generation on changes in velocity as a result of flexing of the connect-
(Osborne & Swarbrick 1997; Swarbrick & Osborne 1998). ing pore network, rather than changing the inter-granular
Pore fluid pressures may increase because of fluid volume or ‘storage’ porosity. The flexing as a result of increasing
expansion or by framework weakening and load transfer. pore pressure reduces the grain-to-grain contact areas and
The depth at which 100C is reached depends on regio- therefore impacts on sonic (and seismic velocities) and
nal heat flow. The 100C isotherm can be located at rela- resistivity responses but has little effect on density or neu-
tively shallow depths, for example, <2 km in the Malay tron values (as the bulk rock porosity remains essentially
Basin where the geothermal gradient is 51.8C km)1 (Ha- unchanged). After unloading, an increase in effective stress
lim 1994). By contrast in the Caspian Sea, the 100C iso- (caused by a reduction in pore pressure) should result in a
therm can be at depths in excess of 6 km (Bredehoeft return to the primary compaction curve via a hysteresis
et al., 1988). In the Central North Sea, temperatures in pathway.
excess of 100C occur for most exploration targets of Cre- Lahann et al. (2001), Lahann (2002) argued that the
taceous and older reservoirs, with the added complexity of primary influence of the smectite to illite chemical reaction
the presence of carbonates as well as the fact that the was actually to affect rock compressibility, rather than to
Jurassic target rocks are ‘old’ and likely cemented and fault create additional overpressure by the released water (Harri-
compartmentalized. In these environments, algorithms son & Summa 1991; Audet 1995). Shale diagenesis
such as (Eaton 1975) that relies on the tool response to changes the mineralogy, volume and orientation of the
function as a proxy for porosity, provide very unreliable load-bearing grains in the shale, such as potassium feldspar
results. In summary, additional (often secondary) mecha- and kerogen as well as reducing the volume of bound
nisms, plus modification of porosity in shales by diagenetic water. The process creates a weaker (more compactable)
change at elevated pressures, mean that there is not a sim- grain framework (Lahann et al. 2001, Lahann 2002). The
ple and predictable relationship porosity between effective resulting overpressure is referred to as load transfer in
stress. Swarbrick et al. (2002) as load is transferred from load-
The key to reducing risk and constraining pore pressures bearing mineral grains onto the pore fluid. These reactions
in these environments is to understand the mechanisms occur where the temperature exceeds approximately 80C,
that generate (and then distribute throughout a basin) the although the temperature of recognizable reaction is more
pore pressures. By understanding these pore fluid pres- typically in the range of 100–120C during the onset in
sures, an assessment of the locations of vertical and lateral young Tertiary sediments. If the fluids generated by min-
seals (flow barriers) can be made. Recognizing the ability eral transformation cannot escape, velocity is reduced and
for different lithologies to maintain or dissipate fluid pres- density may increase, and overpressure builds.
sures over geological time is essential for constructing geo- Where processes occur that affect compressibility, defor-
logically driven pore fluid pressure models. mation will be inelastic, and the compaction state of the
rock permanently altered and therefore a separate, deep
compaction model may be required in addition to a shal-
SECONDARY MECHANISMS OF
low model (Kathara 2006). In a relatively impermeable sys-
OVERPRESSURE GENERATION
tem, there will be an extra load superimposed onto the
The secondary overpressure (not compaction disequilib- fluid phase as a result of the applied stress. Unloading
rium), as described earlier, can be transmitted to any asso- as described by Bowers (1994) assumes that sediment
ciated sands, particularly sands of restricted extent, such as behaviour is between elastic and plastic, and therefore, this
(a) (b)
Un-drained pressure
Building up during burial
Water
gradient
Clastic
mini-basin
Kukla et al. (2011)
Pressure dissipation
Gas
gradient Stratigraphically-isolated Ara
carbonates
Water Pressures retained
gradient (Kukla et al. 2011)
Impermeable
rock
(salt or shale)
Fig. 3. Schematic illustrating the relationship between reservoirs that (a) have the ability to laterally lose pressure as a result of areal extent and ⁄ or juxtaposi-
tion with high permeability sediments e.g. mini-basin clastic (Kukla et al., 2011) and (b) reservoirs that are stratigraphically isolated, and therefore maintain
pressure generated during burial.
effects; and (iii) kerogen conversion to fluid hydrocarbons. to create ‘velocity layers’ sub-salt, merging with the supra-
The authors argue that if the normally pressured reservoirs salt seismic-based velocity model.
were originally at the same overpressure as all other reser- The authors propose that with their modelling approach,
voirs during salt kinetics and early Cambrian to early Ordo- the velocities in shales are age-constrained and stable over
vician tectonics, these reservoirs came into contact with significant distances. Their conclusions are strengthened by
clastic mini-basins, then the overpressures could be lost via the building of a robust sequence stratigraphic framework
highly permeably layers that would act as ‘pressure valves’ into which well information such as pressure ⁄ kick data and
(Fig. 3). Black, hydrocarbon-stained cores of Ara salt sur- real-time LWD and drilling data have been integrated.
rounding the normally and highly overpressured reservoirs Once accurate velocities have been derived, sub-salt, pore
suggest that loss of seal capacity and hydrocarbon flow has pressures are predicted using a combination of Eaton
occurred, because pore pressures caused dilation of the salt. (1975) and Bowers (1994) methods. The authors describe
A cross-discipline pore pressure prediction approach is how this improved understanding of sub-salt pore pres-
taken by Taylor et al. (2011). The authors integrate multi- sures allows more accurate estimate of trap risking, hydro-
ple geological and geophysical data types from the deep- carbon column length and reserve estimation.
water Lower Tertiary trend of Walker Ridge and Keathley
Canyon, Gulf of Mexico. Their approach constrains the
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
sub-salt seismic velocity data (subsequently used to inter-
pret pore pressure) with the use of a model that integrates The authors would like to thank the organizers of the Over-
velocity, density and pressure data with geomechanical rock pressure 2008 conference and to thank the presenters for
properties to aid well planning and risking. Often, detailed their contributions to a successful and stimulating confer-
seismic velocities closely match well velocities above salt, ence. We would like to thank Janie Walsh for all her efforts
but are inadequate to resolve the complex sub-salt velocity in coordinating this thematic set. Our thanks to Alexander
structure. Their approach, therefore, is to constrain sub- Edwards for reviewing a previous edition and his construc-
salt velocities by analysing numerous wells in the vicinity to tive comments. Thanks also to Professor Richard Worden,
build a regional understanding of how lithology and age editor of Geofluids, for the opportunity to present these
affect sub-salt overpressures. The authors use well velocities papers and his hard work in bringing them to publication.
Geofluids
Volume 11, Numbers 4, November 2011
ISSN 1468-8115
CONTENTS
343 Geologically driven pore fluid pressure models and their implications for petroleum
exploration. Introduction to thematic set
S. O’Connor, R. Swarbrick and R. Lahann
349 Distribution and mechanisms of overpressure generation and deflation in the late
Neoproterozoic to early Cambrian South Oman Salt Basin
P.A. Kukla, L. Reuning, S. Becker, J.L. Urai and J. Schoenherr
362 Overpressure generation by load transfer following shale framework weakening due
to smectite diagenesis
R.W. Lahann and R.E. Swarbrick
376 Velocity modeling workflows for sub-salt geopressure prediction: a case study from
the Lower Tertiary trend, Gulf of Mexico
J. Taylor, T. Fishburn, O. Djordjevic and R. Sullivan
388 Integrating a hydrodynamically-titled OWC and a salt-withdrawal depositional model
to explore the Ula Trend
S. O’Connor, H. Rasmussen, R. Swarbrick and J. Wood