Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Imaging of Osteomyelitis: The Key Is in The Combination
Imaging of Osteomyelitis: The Key Is in The Combination
An accurate diagnosis of osteomyelitis requires the combination of anatomical and functional imaging
techniques. Conventional radiography is the first imaging modality to begin with, as it provides an overview
of both the anatomy and the pathologic conditions of the bone. Sonography is most useful in the diagnosis
of fluid collections, periosteal involvement and soft tissue abnormalities, and may provide guidance for
diagnostic or therapeutic interventions. MRI highlights sites with tissue edema and increased regional
perfusion, and provides accurate information of the extent of the infectious process and the tissues
involved. To detect osteomyelitis before anatomical changes are present, functional imaging could have
some advantages over anatomical imaging. Fluorine-18 fluorodeoxyglucose-PET has the highest diagnostic
accuracy for confirming or excluding the diagnosis of chronic osteomyelitis. For both SPECT and PET,
specificity improves considerably when the scintigraphic images are fused with computed tomography.
Close cooperation between clinicians and imagers remains the key to early and adequate diagnosis when
osteomyelitis is suspected or evaluated.
KEYWORDS: computed tomography n hybrid systems n imaging n MRI n nuclear Carlos Pineda†1,
medicine n osteomyelitis n ultrasonography Angelica Pena2, Rolando
Espinosa2 & Cristina
Osteomyelitis is inflammation of the bone that osteomyelitis. The ideal imaging technique Hernández-Díaz1
is usually due to infection. There are different should have a high sensitivity and specificity; 1
Musculoskeletal Ultrasound
Department, Instituto Nacional de
classification systems to categorize osteomyeli- numerous studies have been published con- Rehabilitacion, Avenida
tis. Traditionally, it has been labeled as acute, cerning the accuracy of the various modali- Mexico‑Xochimilco No. 289, Arenal de
Guadalupe, Tlalpan, Mexico City
subacute or chronic, depending on its clinical ties in diagnosing chronic osteomyelitis [2–4] . 14389, Mexico
course, histologic findings and disease dura- Confirmation of the presence of osteomyeli- 2
Rheumatology Department, Instituto
tion, but there is no consensual agreement on tis usually entails a combination of imaging Nacional de Rehabilitacion, Mexico
City, Mexico
the temporal scale used or specific findings. techniques. Table 1 shows the main pathologic †
Author for correspondence:
As a result, some researchers have proposed findings of osteomyelitis assessed by diverse Tel.: +52 559 991 000 ext. 13229
carpineda@yahoo.com
more detailed classification systems, such as imaging techniques.
the Waldvogel classification system based on
etiology of the infection (hematogenous spread Conventional radiography
of an organism, direct inoculation of an organ- Plain films are usually the first imaging test
ism through trauma or contiguous spread from ordered by clinicians [5] . Conventional radio
a soft tissue infection), and Cierny-Mader clas- graphy should not be used to exclude acute
sification, a descriptive system that takes into osteomyelitis in a patient who has experienced
account both anatomic factors and the host’s symptoms for less than 10 days. Nevertheless,
physiologic status [1,2] . deep soft tissue swelling, joint effusion or early
An inadequate or late diagnosis increases periosteal changes may be seen within days
the degree of complications and morbidity; for after onset of infection. Furthermore, conven-
these reasons, imaging techniques are essential tional radiography helps to exclude fracture
to confirm the presumed clinical diagnosis and or tumor.
to provide information regarding the exact site Destructive bone changes do not occur until
and extent of the infection process [1] . 7–10 days after the onset of infection. During the
Although a variety of diagnostic imaging first 2–3 days of symptoms, radionuclide bone
techniques is available for excluding or con- imaging may be particularly useful in showing
firming osteomyelitis, it is often difficult to a well-defined focus of increased uptake on the
choose the most appropriate technique to dynamic perfusion, as well as early blood pool
conclusively establish the diagnosis of osteo- and delayed images corresponding to the area
myelitis. Several imaging modalities have of hyperemia [6] . At this early stage, the main
been used in the evaluation of suspected utility of plain film is to provide a global view
10.2217/IJR.10.100 © 2011 Future Medicine Ltd Int. J. Clin. Rheumatol. (2011) 6(1), 25–33 ISSN 1758-4272 25
Special Report Pineda, Pena, Espinosa & Hernández-Díaz
of the suspect part of the skeleton and to provide does not exhibit the osteopenia of the adjacent
information regarding differential diagnosis in a living bone. A wide scope of bone lesions may
patient complaining of pain. present with an image suggestive of sequestrum
Structural bony changes and periosteal reac- including osteoid osteoma, eosinophilic granu-
tion consist first of subperiosteal resorption or loma and primary lymphoma [7] .
scalloping, which creates radiolucencies within A lucent circumscribed lesion (Brodie’s
cortical bone that may progress to irregular abscess) in the metaphyses of long bones pre-
destruction with areas of periosteal new bone dominantly abutting the growth plate with
formation. However, hematogenous osteo well-defined dense margins is commonly seen
myelitis in children typically arises within can- in the tibia and femur of children with subacute
cellous bone, mostly in the vicinity of physeal osteomyelitis.
plates, and secondarily involves cortical bone Periostitis, involucrum formation and sinus
and periosteum. tracts are due to a subperiosteal abscess with
In general, osteopenia becomes evident lifting of the periosteum, new bone formation
on conventional radiographs after the loss of and soft tissue fistulas. All of these findings
approximately 30–50% of bone mineraliza- are indicative of the protracted nature of the
tion. Follow-up radiographs may be normal infection process.
if therapy is successful, or in some instances
periosteal new bone formation may be apparent. Special situations
The search for sequestra is a common and Diabetic foot
important diagnostic challenge in chronic In a recent meta-analysis of the accuracy of
osteomyelitis. The presence of a sequestrum diagnostic tests for osteomyelitis in diabetic
may lead to a decision of surgery. A bone seques- patients with foot ulcers, the sensitivity of
trum manifests on conventional radiographs as plain radiography for diagnosis of osteomyeli-
a piece of calcified tissue within a lucent lesion. tis was highly variable, ranging from 0.28 to
The increased density of the sequestrum rela- 0.75. The wide variation may be attributable
tive to the surrounding bone is a consequence to the timing of performance of the radiograph
of its absence of blood supply. As a result of this in relation to the chronicity of the ulcer. The
devascularization, the sequestrum does not par- pooled sensitivity was 0.54 and the pooled
ticipate in the reactive hyperemia and therefore specificity was 0.68. The diagnostic odds ratio
D E
Figure 1. Tuberculous arthritis. (A) Conventional radiography frontal view of the right knee
displaying diffuse soft tissue swelling, osteopenia, lateral joint space narrowing and medial and
lateral compartment ‘corner defects’. (B) Sagittal T2-weighted MRI demonstrates hypointense
thickened synovium covering the posterior aspect of lateral condile affecting the articular joint
space, tibial plateau and suprapatellar bursae. (C) Sagital T2 fat-saturation MRI with enhancement
of the liquid collection and cortical defects. (D & E) Anterior and lateral view of a
methoxyisobutylisonitrile-technetium-99m showing diffuse captation in the right knee.
limited spatial resolution, low specificity, Today, labeled leukocyte imaging is the pro-
physiological bowel excretion and the high cedure of choice for diagnosing prosthetic joint
radiation dose [23] . infection [25] .
Gallium scans may reveal abnormal accumu- The main disadvantages of 111In-WBC and
lation in patients who have active osteomyelitis 99m
Tc-WBC are their laborious preparation,
when technetium scans reveal decreased activ- requirement of specialized equipment, and the
ity (‘cold’ lesions) or perhaps normal activity. handling of potentially infectious blood [23] .
67
Ga-citrate has been used with reasonable sensi-
tivity (73%) and relatively low specificity (61%). Radiolabeled specific
67
Ga-citrate is now less frequently used owing to antigranulocyte monoclonal antibodies
the availability of more favorable compounds Considerable effort has been devoted to
and techniques [23] . the search for in vivo methods of label-
ing leukocytes, including peptides and
Radiolabeled leukocytes antigranulocyte antibodies.
White blood cell scan was performed originally Radiolabeled antigranulocyte antibod-
with 111In-WBC and more recently with 99mTc ies have been developed for in vivo labeling
hexamethylpropyleneamine oxime-labeled white of white blood cells. Antibodies accumulate
cells. The principle is that the labeled WBCs in infectious and inflammatory foci mainly
concentrate in areas of inflammation, and the by nonspecific extravasations, because of the
specificity of the study is improved to 80–90% enhanced vascular permeability in combi-
compared with bone scans, particularly when nation with specific targeting of infiltrated
complicating conditions are superimposed. granulocytes. Overall sensitivity for infec-
In a review and meta-analysis, the sensitivity tion detection with radiolabeled antibodies
for extra-axial chronic osteomyelitis was 84% is approximately 80–90%. Peripheral bone
compared with 21% for the detection of chronic infections are adequately visualized; however,
osteomyelitis in axial skeleton [3,8] . Combined sensitivity decreases when the infections are
111
In-WBC and bone marrow imaging with located near to the spine. 99mTc-anti-CD15
99m
Tc-sulfur colloid demonstrated a 100% sen- IgM and 99mTc-anti-NCA-95 IgG are some of
sitivity and 98% specificity in 50 patients with the most effective antibodies to diagnose bone
suspected infected total-hip arthroplasty [24] . and joint infections.
functionally active area of a known lesion and in Ultrasound represents a noninvasive method to
precisely drawing regions of interest to perform evaluate the involved soft tissues and cortical
quantitative studies [30] . bone and may provide guidance for diagnostic
Nevertheless, data are still very limited, espe- or therapeutic interventional, drainage or tis-
cially for PET/CT in patients with arthroplasty, sue biopsy. PET and SPECT are highly accu-
and further prospective studies are required rate techniques for the evaluation of chronic
to fully verify the clinical role and the added osteomyelitis, al lowing d ifferentiation from
value of SPECT/CT and PET/CT in the soft tissue infection.
diagnosis of osteomyelitis and prosthetic bone
infection [31–33] . Future perspective
Some examples of these hybrid techniques An ideal imaging technique should demon-
include SPECT/CT 67Ga- and 111In-labeled leu- strate functional and anatomical definition,
kocyte scintigraphy; a study by Bar-Shalom et al. excluding inflammatory or tumoral patholo-
demonstrated that this combination is useful to gies. Currently, there is no perfect imaging
define the anatomical localization of foci and its technique for the diagnosis of osteomyelitis.
extent [34] . The hybrid imaging systems are able to acquire
Filippi et al., using SPECT/CT and 99mTc- functional and structural data in the same scan-
hexamethylpropyleneamine oxime-labeled leu- ning session and, therefore, to limit the prob-
kocyte scintigraphy, suggested that this hybrid lems often observed with software approaches
device could also improve localization and for image registration and fusion. Hybrid imag-
definition of the infection extent [35] . ing systems represent the present and future of
diagnostic imaging in osteomyelitis. However,
Conclusion technical improvements, widespread avail-
Osteomyelitis frequently requires more than ability and lower costs in this computer-aided
one imaging technique for an accurate diag- imaging techniques are encouraged.
nosis. Conventional radiography still remains
the first imaging modality. MRI and nuclear Financial & competing interests disclosure
medicine are the most sensitive and specific The authors have no relevant affiliations or financial
methods for the detection of osteomyelitis. A involvement with any organization or entity with a finan-
CT scan can be a useful method to detect early cial interest in or financial conflict with the subject matter
osseous erosion and to document the presence or materials discussed in the manuscript. This includes
of sequestrum, foreign body or gas forma- employment, consultancies, honoraria, stock ownership or
tion; it is generally less sensitive than other options, expert testimony, grants or patents received or
modalities for the detection of bone infection. pending, or royalties.
MRI provides more accurate information No writing assistance was utilized in the production of
regarding the extent of the infectious process. this manuscript.
Executive summary
Conventional radiography
First imaging technique used to gain an overview of the anatomy and pathology of bone.
Changes are visible after several days from the beginning of the process.
Main findings include osteopenia, lytic lesions, periosteal thickening and loss of trabecular architecture.
Sinography
Useful to define the course and extent of the sinus tract and its possible communications with neighboring structures.
Ultrasonography
Allows identification of early soft tissue changes: fistulous tracts, fluid collections, cortical discontinuity and abscess.
Ultrasonography is accessible, low cost and noninvasive.
MRI
Provides excellent delineation between bone and soft tissue as well as abnormal and normal bone marrow. Detects osteomyelitis as early
as 3–5 days after infection. Used for the evaluation of the extent of the abnormalities.
Computed tomography
Provides a good definition of cortical bone abnormalities, sequestra, involucra, intraosseous gas, periosteal reaction and blurring of
fat planes.
Nuclear medicine
Various modalities detect osteomyelitis 10–14 days before changes are visible on plain radiographs. These techniques are highly sensitive
and depending on the clinical situation have a moderate-to-high specificity.