Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ed&S WebQuests
Ed&S WebQuests
http://www.bloorstreet.com/indact.htm#13
a) Define enfranchisement as it pertains to 'Indians'.
Enfranchisement is a term used to describe the loss of Indian status and Band
membership through the operation of the Act or, as in these repealed sections, voluntary.
"Enfranchisement" is quite literally translated to "gaining the vote" and harks back to the
time before 1960 when Indians were, by virtue of their status, denied the vote in federal or
provincial elections.
b) Who did this a ect and under 'what' conditions?
This affected both indigenous people and non-indigenous people. Indigenous
people were affected in the sense that they were forced to conform to white culture, and
eradicated from their communities,values, beliefs, and language. Non-Indigenous people
were affected in that they were the enforcers; whether their actions were intentional or
otherwise, their actions directly affected the Indigenous peoples in their society negatively.
c) Why is this important for all Canadians to know
This is important for Canadians to know for us to be able to understand the
long-lasting and detrimental effects imposed on Indigenous people through bias and greed.
Creates a way for us to reflect on these wrongdoings and using these reflections to
implement a cultural recovery system. The awareness received on this topic has resulted in
breakthrough programs to reintegrate culture into these families and a call-to-action
attitude to create a more inclusive and understanding environment for all to thrive.
→ Scroll down through Sections 114 through to Sections 122 and complete the following questions: ←
a) What pattern(s) emerge from your reviewing of the sections?
The pattern of control arose predominantly throughout the sections. The focus on
school attendance may serve as an attempt to make the individuals functioning members of
society, bettering the economy, as well as breaking the pattern of negative
intergenerational effects resulting from previous assimilation of Indigenous culture. Yet,
does so by putting the benefit of the economy of greater value than the student, creating a
new set of expected values and stresses that affect the students. The restrictions in the
sections denies students the freedom to explore means of life on reserves or meeting
traditional expectations adhering to the different dimensions of Aboriginal values.
b) Who has the authority in determining the 'education of Native Peoples'?
The authority for governing the education of Native peoples remain on the
shoulders of our Minister. The Minister is elected by the Governor in Council and they are
to make decisions regarding the education of Indigenous peoples. Fascinatingly, those in
authority here, were more-often-than-not religious and were to teach in a school that
follows their given religion, be it Protestant or Roman Catholic. It was further outlined in
the Indian Act that students were not to attend a school that conflicted with their religious
practices, therefore a Minister must place students in schools according to their views.
c) Why (or why not) is this problematic?
This can be problematic as students may not follow a religion, or have an institution
that accurately represents or values their beliefs. Forcing Indigenous families to choose
between two religions that were not their own in order to provide their child with a
sufficient education was an act of assimilation. These appointed schools reformed children
and their beliefs and stripped them of their culture and language.
d) Identify 1 section that 'shocked' you as it relates to 'Native Peoples'
One section that shocked me relating to Native peoples, was the possible
imprisonment of the person on whom the notice was served to, for being guilty of an
offence relating to truancy. There must be implications to this law. What if the student
refuses to go to school, even though the family continues to push them to attend? If the
parent was given the notice, is the parent still responsible for this child not going, will they
be arrested or would the child? What if the child lies about his whereabouts? What if after
receiving the notice the child takes off? Who is to blame? Who would be imprisoned? The
severity of the repercussions of students not attending school, does not take into
consideration diverse issues students may be dealing with in their home, mentally,
physically, at school, etc. And give no wiggle room for struggling students and parents
trying to do the right thing. If there is an imprisonment does it remain on their record and
affect their future endeavors? If so, in what ways does this benefit the child? There are
many ways in which this law can be misconstrued and misused to fit into accepted ideas of
a valuable member of society.
→ Define 'cultural genocide:
Genocide is defined as the deliberate killing of a large group of people, especially
those of a particular ethnic group or nation. Therefore, cultural genocide can be seen as
the assimilation of beliefs, values, and customs of a culture and forced adoption of
preferred cultural values.
→ Is this 'Act' an example of this?
Whether the Act is an example of cultural genocide or not, would be dependent on
the material being offered and accommodated for at the school. The Act discusses legalities
of forcing individuals to go to school and quite overtly uses the fear of punishment to
assert power and control but, it is hard to determine whether this is cultural genocide as
these policies are upheld regardless of race or culture for every child. School is set up in a
way to better prepare students to make well-educated decisions and be able to provide for
themselves or others in the future, and generally has good intentions for each student.
Whether we consider the obvious control here as cultural genocide though depends on the
content, beliefs, and values that are being projected, and if they are inclusive and
accommodating to a wide range of individuals, or if rather, they are using this control to
force Western values unto the general population. This is important for Canadians to know
for us to understand the long-lasting and detrimental effects imposed on Indigenous
people through bias and greed, and creates a way for us to reflect on these wrongdoings
and using these reflections to implement a cultural recovery system. The awareness
received on this topic has resulted in breakthrough programs to reintegrate culture into
these families and a call-to-action attitude to create a more inclusive and understanding
environment for all to thrive.
WEBQUEST #2
What are First Nations' approaches, issues and recommendations regarding Education?
a.) Identify using bullet points 7 important components of Native education.
❏ The curriculum is holistic-drawing on relevant beliefs and values
❏ The essential role of elders and spiritual leaders is integral to the learning
process
❏ Curriculum does not reject Western concepts, but it does not attempt to
assimilate students into the logic of Western beliefs either.
❏ Development during the 4 stages of the life cycle: child, youth, adult, elder,
with each stage developing the whole human being
❏ Includes experiential components that link theories learned in the classroom
to the life of the community.
❏ The curriculum development process used community involvement in an
optimal way. Uses resources of the whole community (elders, historians,
spiritual leaders)
❏ The connection between dimensions of learning and development . The
individual is viewed as a whole person with intellectual, spiritual, emotional,
and physical dimensions that must be addressed in the learning process.
b.) Search ‘Elsie Wuttunee’ (page 26) and list 4 points that she identified as being of
central concern for Native parents regarding the education of Native children.
When an Aboriginal child’s identity has been threatened, they will:
❏ Withdraw into themselves
❏ Become silent and refuse to participate as a means of protecting themselves
from criticism and rejection
❏ Attempt to abandon their previous identity and moved themselves to the
culture which they perceive as more valid or acceptable
❏ May take on non-productive and rejecting attitudes which generally
culminate in failure or dropping out
-primarily when the values and worldview that prevail at school contradicts or
ignores the existence of different perspectives the child lives with at home.
c.) Identify at least four important points that non-Native educators need to be aware
of in relation to the education of Native children.
5.6: e Education of Non-Aboriginal Teachers
❏ Non-Aboriginal persons must be made aware of the history and traditional
lifestyle, and the downfall and resurgence of Aboriginal peoples, as history
has evolved today.
❏ They cannot convey accurate information about Aboriginal people and instil
respectful attitudes unless they have been prepared to do so.
❏ Accurate information about the history and cultures of Aboriginal peoples
and nations, the role of treaties in the formation of Canada, and the
distinctive contributions of Aboriginal people to contemporary Canada,
should form part of every Canadian students education.
❏ The need to correct erroneous assumptions and to dispel stereotypes that
still abound the minds of many Canadians, distorting their relationships with
Aboriginal People.
Evaluation:
Write a summary conclusion that takes into consideration both Web Quests 1 and 2.
Non-Indigenous forms of education introduced in North America were embedded
with beliefs about superiority versus inferiority; expert versus non-expert; and civilized
versus savage. Due to this Eurocentric worldview, Indigenous people were outcasted and
labelled as uncivilized, paving the way for residential schools to become a reality. It is now
our duty to provide invitational and affirming learning environments to improve Indigenous
student achievement and enhance cross-cultural harmony through more holistic
approaches to teaching. We must create an authentic connection that reinforces
Indigenous cultures, traditions, and ways of knowing, through personally meaningful and
relevant content that is useful to their everyday lives.
Henderson’s Annotated Indian Act reinforces the idea that having Indigenous
students as functioning members of society, is of greater importance than their well-being
and cultural values. Though the sections may have good intentions, people who have never
experienced the negative effects and deculturation Indigenous people have faced, have no
business making such grave policies that inherently determine the needs and values that
should be upheld by these students, and the repercussions that follow for not adhering to
these expectations, especially with no input from the people whom these laws directly
affect.
References
PDF file “Aboriginal Education”
“Henderson's Annotated Indian Act”. http://www.bloorstreet.com/indact.htm#13.