Professional Documents
Culture Documents
General Relativity: Theory of Gravity: Sarthak Duary
General Relativity: Theory of Gravity: Sarthak Duary
Sarthak Duary
International Centre for Theoretical Sciences, Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Shivakote,
Bengaluru 560089, India.
E-mail: sarthak.duary@icts.res.in
3 Generalization to gravity 9
The following section is based on Ashoke Sen lecture note page no. G.44, G.45 and G.46.
In this section we describe an application of the equations of motion of a free particle
known as Gravitational red shift.
We have
∆τ = Proper time taken by the second hand of the clock to move one step
= 1 second .
In the locally inertial frame the second hand takes one second to move one step.
Time elapsed during this process
–1–
If (−g00 )−1/2 < 1, the clock moves slower.
If (−g00 )−1/2 > 1, the clock moves faster.
But everything else also moves slower. So we will not feel it.
In order to see this we have to compare clocks at two different points with two different
values of g00 .
−1/2
∆x0 = − g00 (~x1 ) × 1 second
−1/2 (1.4)
∆x0 = − g00 (~x2 ) × 1 second .
Thus the ratio of the time taken by the second hand to move 1 second is given by
" #−1/2
∆t(1) g00 (~x1 )
(2)
= . (1.5)
∆t g00 (~x2 )
–2–
We have
!
∆ν GM 1 1
=− 2 −
ν c r2 r1
! (1.12)
GM 1 1
= 2 − .
c r1 r2
The following section is based on Ashoke Sen lecture note page no. G.50
A clock is sitting at each point. Proper time elapsed between two successive pulse is ∆τ .
Clock at ~x(1) .
Now, we calculate the proper time elapsed for the clock at ~x(2) between these two signals
which is given by
q
∆τ̃ = ∆x0 −g00 (~x(2) )
s
−g00 (~x(2) )
= ∆τ .
−g00 (~x(1) )
Thus, s
Period of clock at ~x(2) ∆τ g00 (~x(1) )
= = . (1.14)
Period of clock at ~x(1) ∆τ̃ g00 (~x(2) )
Principle of equivalence can be applied to any system, not just a free particle.
–3–
Equation of motion for a free particle is given by
d2 xµ µ dxν dxρ
+ Γ νρ =0 , (2.1)
dτ 2 dτ dτ
where
dxµ dxν
gµν = −1 (τ is the proper time). (2.2)
dτ dτ
This can be also regarded as a principle of equivalence because in the local inertial frame
where Γ is zero this is exactly the equation of motion of a free particle that we see in the
absence of gravity.
Now, suppose we are interested in studying how a particle behaves in the presence of a
force acting on it. Let’s suppose we try to use principle of equivalence to guess what the new
equations will look like.
Principle of equivalence tells us that if we go to a frame in which
Γ0µνρ = 0 , gµν
0
= ηµν (local inertial frame) , (2.3)
Therefore we have
d2 xα α dxρ dxσ
+ Γ ρσ = f α (x) . (2.8)
dτ 2 dτ dτ
Suppose x00 is another general coordinate system. We have
d2 x00α 00ρ
00α dx dx
00σ
+ Γ ρσ = f 00α . (2.9)
dτ 2 dτ dτ
–4–
where
f 00α = ∂µ0 x00α f 0µ
f α = ∂µ0 xα f 0µ (2.10)
=⇒ f 00α = ∂β x00α f β .
Example 1:
Consider a charged particle moving under the the simultaneous influence of electromag-
netic and gravitational field.
Q. What will be its equation of motion.
–1. In the locally inertial frame the equation of motion will be that of a relativistic
particle moving under the influence of the electromagnetic field.
–2. Convert this equation back to the general coordinate system.
Equation of motion of a relativistic particle in background electromagnetic field is given
by
d2 xµ
m 2 = fµ ,
dτ
dxρ
Relativistic force = f µ = qη µν Fνρ [Set c = 1] . (2.11)
dτ
Electromagnetic field strength tensor = Fνρ = ∂ν Aρ − ∂ρ Aν . (2.12)
(A0 , A1 , A2 , A3 ) , A0 = electrostatic scalar potential .
| {z }
vector potential
Ei = −F0i = ∂i A0 − ∂0 Ai
~
~ = −∇φ
E ~ − ∂A . (2.13)
∂t
1 X
Bi = ijk Fjk
2 j,k=1,2,3
F23 = B1 = ∂2 A3 − ∂3 A2
F31 = B2 = ∂3 A1 − ∂1 A3
F12 = B3 = ∂1 A2 − ∂2 A1
~ =∇
B ~ ×A
~ . (2.14)
For µ = i we have
! !
d dxi dxρ
m = q η ij Fjρ
dτ dτ dτ
3
!
dx0 X dxk
= q Fi0 + Fik
dτ k=1
dτ
!
dx0 dxk
= q Ei + ikl B l
dτ dτ
–5–
!
dpi dpi dx0 dx0 dxk dx0
= = q Ei + ikl B l
dτ dt dτ dτ dt dτ
!
dpi dxk (2.15)
=⇒ = q Ei + ikl B l
dt dt
dpi h i
~ i .
=⇒ = q Ei + (~v × B)
dt
In local inertial frame (Γ0µνρ = 0 , gµν0 = η ) we have equations of motion given by
µν
principle of equivalence
d2 x0µ q 0 dx
0ρ
2
= g 0µν Fνρ . (2.16)
dτ m dτ
L.H.S. is given by !
d2 x0µ d2 xν dxρ dxσ
2
= ∂ν x0µ 2
+ Γν ρσ .
dτ dτ dτ dτ
R.H.S. is given by
q dxγ
∂α x0µ ∂β x0ν g αβ Fνρ
0
∂γ x0ρ .
m dτ
Multiplying both sides by ∂µ0 xδ
!
d 2 xν dxρ dxσ q 0 δ dxγ
∂ν x0µ ∂µ0 xδ + Γ ν
ρσ = ∂µ x ∂α x0µ ∂β x0ν g αβ Fνρ
0
∂γ x0ρ
dτ 2 dτ dτ m dτ
(2.17)
d2 xδ dxρ dxσ 0ν δβ 0 0ρ dx
γ
=⇒ + Γδ ρσ = ∂ β x g Fνρ ∂γ x .
dτ 2 dτ dτ dτ
Now we define
Fβγ ≡ ∂β x0ν ∂γ x0ρ Fνρ
0
.
We have
d2 xδ ρ
δ dx dx
σ q δβ dxγ
+ Γ ρσ = g Fβγ . (2.18)
dτ 2 dτ dτ m dτ
We can show that
Fβγ = ∂β Aγ − ∂γ Aβ
Aβ = ∂β x0µ A0µ
A00β = ∂β00 x0µ A0µ (2.19)
=⇒ A00β = ∂β00 xα Aα .
Aβ : rank (0, 1) tensor
Fαβ : rank (0, 2) tensor .
Equation of a particle in electromagnetic field derived from principle of equivalence
d2 xδ ρ
δ dx dx
σ q δβ dxγ
+ Γ ρσ = g Fβγ . (2.20)
dτ 2 dτ dτ m dτ
–6–
From general coordinate invariance
d2 xδ ρ
δ dx dx
σ q δβ dxγ δ dxα βγ
+ Γ ρσ = g Fβγ + aR αβγ F . (2.21)
dτ 2 dτ dτ m dτ dτ
Eq.(2.21) violates principle of equivalence. Even in local inertial frame Riemann tensor doesn’t
vanish. This is a demonstration that general coordinate invariance doesn’t necessarily require
that equation has to satisfy principle of equivalence. Principle of equivalence is a useful
principle to arrive at the correct equations to a very good accuracy. Principle of equivalence
is not a sacred principal. Sacred principal is general coordinate invariance.
Coefficient a should have a dimension of (length)2 .
From stringy corrections
Fµν = ∂µ Aν − ∂ν Aµ . (2.23)
∂(µ Fνρ) = 0 ,
=⇒ ∂µ Fνρ + ∂ν Fρµ + ∂ρ Fµν = 0 . (2.24)
~ B
∇. ~ =0
~
~ ×E
∇ ~ + ∂B = 0 (2.25)
∂t
Eq.(2.23) contains the same information as eq.(2.24).
Dynamical equations (equations for the source) is given by
–7–
0 0 0
∂(ρ Fµν) =0 (follows from Fµν = ∂µ0 A0ν − ∂ν0 A0µ )
(2.28)
∂ 0µ Fµν
0
= −Jν0 .
In a general frame
0
Fµν = ∂µ0 xρ ∂ν0 xσ Fρσ (x)
(2.29)
Define Jν ≡ ∂ν x0σ Jσ0 ,
we get
Dµ Fµν = −Jν . (2.30)
Eq.(2.30) is consistent with principle of equivalence.
Now we combine
Jν = ∂ν x0σ Jσ0 (2.31)
with
Jν00 = ∂ν00 x0σ Jσ0 (2.32)
to eliminate J0 and obtain
Jν00 (x00 ) = ∂ν00 xσ Jσ (x) . (2.33)
Now,
Fµν = Dµ Aν − Dν Aµ = ∂µ Aν − ∂ν Aµ . (2.34)
Now,
Dµ Fµν = −Jν
=⇒ Dν Dµ Fµν = −Dν Jν .
Now, Fµν is antisymmetric.
Using this we get
−Dµ Dν Fµν = −Dν Dµ Fνµ
= Dν Dµ Fµν
1
=⇒ Dν Dµ Fµν = [Dν , Dµ ]Fµν .
2
Therefore we have
1 ν µ
[D , D ]Fµν = −Dν Jν .
2
Now we calculate L.H.S. [Dν , Dµ ]Fµν
[Dν , Dµ ]Fαβ = −Rασ µν Fσβ − Rβσ µν Fασ
=⇒ [Dν , Dµ ]Fµν = −Rµσ µν Fσν − Rνσ µν Fµσ
= −Rσν Fσν + Rσµ Fµσ
=0 (since R is symmetric in two indices and F is antisymmetric in two indices) .
(2.35)
–8–
Therefore, we have
Dν Jν = 0 . (2.36)
It follows from current conservation law in flat spacetime
∂ 0ν Jν0 = 0 . (2.37)
3 Generalization to gravity
∇2 φ = 4πGρm , (3.1)
We have
Rµν + cRgµν = aTµν (dropping b) . (3.4)
Assuming in the local inertial frame
∂ 0µ Tµν
0
=0
we have
Dµ Tµν = 0
=⇒ Dµ (Rµν + cRgµν ) = 0 identically
1 (3.5)
=⇒ Dµ Rµν − Rgµν = 0 .
2
It follows from Bianchi identity.
Ds Rijkl + Dk Rijls + Dl Rijsk = 0 (s,k,l anti.symm., R already anti.symm. in k and l gives cyclic perm.)
(3.6)
Multiply this by g js
Dj Rijkl + Dk Ril − Dl Rik = 0
–9–
Contraction with g ik gives
Dj Rjl + Di Ril − Dl R = 0
=⇒ 2Dj Rjl − Dl R = 0 (3.7)
1
=⇒ 2Dj Rjl − Rgjl = 0 ,
2
where Rjl − 21 Rgjl is the Einstein tensor.
Therefore,
1
Rµν − Rgµν = aTµν .
2
Now, we fix a. In weak field non-relativistic limit the 00 component of both sides give
g00 = −1 − 2φ
(3.8)
=⇒ −2∇2 φ = aρm .
Let’s suppose we have a particle moving along a trajectory denoted by x̃i (t), i = 1, 2, 3.
Particle carries charge q. We are working in flat space.
Charge density is given by
This tells us at any given time the charge density is nonzero if the coordinate ~x coincides
with the particle location ~x̃(t), otherwise this is zero. The normalization is fixed by requiring
that for any time t if we integrate over x we get q.
Similarly,
dx̃i (t)
J i (~x, t) = qδ (3) (~x − ~x̃(t)) . (4.2)
dt
Write a Lorentz covariant expression:
We use parametric form X µ (u), where µ = 0, 1, 2, 3. Here, u is the parameter along the
trajectory.
X: particle trajectory, x: spacetime point or variables that we want to vary.
– 10 –
In flat spacetime (Minkowski spacetime)
~ 2
ds2 = −(dX 0 )2 + (dX)
= −(dX 0 )2 + (dX 1 )2 + (dX 2 )2 + (dX 3 )2
= −dτ 2
<0 for a physical particle . (4.4)
dX 0 2 dX i 2
=⇒ =1+
dτ dτ
dX 0 2
=⇒ >1 .
dτ
0
Choosing dX 0
dτ to be positive for physical particle. We can choose τ to be u. X is monotonic
increasing function of τ .
Therefore X 0 (u) = t gives unique solution.
Claim: Z ∞ dX µ
µ
J (x) = du q δ (4) xµ − X µ (u) . (4.5)
−∞ du
Proof: We use δ (0) x0 − X 0 (u) to do the u integral. Solving X 0 (u) = x0 = t (c=1) to
find u as a function of t.
This gives
dX µ 1
J µ (~x, t) = qδ (3) (~x − ~x̃(t)) 0 , (4.6)
du | dX
du |
using
δ(u − u0 )
δ(f (u)) = where f (u) = 0 at u = u0 . (4.7)
|f 0 (u0 )|
This finally gives
J 0 (~x, t) = qδ (3) (~x − ~x̃(t))
dx̃i (t)
J i (~x, t) = qδ (3) (~x − ~x̃(t)) . (4.8)
dt
Replacing u by τ (proper time) defined by
dX µ dX ν
ηµν = −1 ,
dτ dτ
we have Z ∞ dX µ
J µ (x) = dτ q δ (4) xµ − X µ (τ ) . (4.9)
−∞ dτ
For multiple particles with different trajectories and charges we have
Z ∞ dX µ
n
X
µ
J (x) = qn dτn δ (4) xµ − Xnµ (τn ) . (4.10)
n −∞ dτn
– 11 –
Energy-momentum tensor/Four momentum current T µν :
T µ0 -energy four current i.e.T 00 -energy density and T i0 -current of energy density .
T µi -momentum four current i.e. T 0i -momentum density and T ji -momentum current .
µν νµ
Here, T(matter) = T(matter) .
Conservation laws:
Z ∞ 3 dX µ (τ )
n n
X X Y
∂µ J µ = ∂µ qn dτn δ xρ − Xnρ (τn )
µ n −∞ ρ=0
dτn
Z ∞ Y dX µ (τ )
n n
δ xρ − Xnρ (τn ) δ 0 xµ − Xnµ (τn )
XX
= qn dτn
µ n −∞ ρ6=µ
dτn
Z ∞
XX Y d µ
= qn dτn δ xρ − Xnρ (τn ) − δ x − Xnµ (τn )
µ n −∞ dτn
ρ6=µ (4.12)
Z ∞ 3
X d Y
= qn dτn − δ xρ − Xnρ (τn )
n −∞ dτn ρ=0
3 τn =∞
X Y
ρ
=− qn δ x − Xnρ (τn )
n
ρ=0 τn =−∞
=0 (since Xn0 (τn = −∞) = −∞ and Xn0 (τn = ∞) = ∞) .
– 12 –
3
µν
X XZ ∞ Y dXnµ (τn ) dXnν (τn )
∂µ T(matter) = ∂µ dτn δ xρ − Xnρ (τn ) mn
µ n −∞ ρ=0
dτn dτn
XXZ ∞ Y dX µ (τ ) dXnν (τn )
n n
= dτn δ xρ − Xnρ (τn ) δ 0 xµ − Xnµ (τn ) mn
µ n −∞ ρ6=µ
dτn dτn
XXZ ∞ Y d µ dXnν (τn )
= dτn δ xρ − Xnρ (τn ) − δ x − Xnµ (τn ) mn
µ n −∞ ρ6=µ
dτn dτn
3
" #
XZ ∞ d Y dXnν (τn )
= dτn − δ xρ − Xnρ (τn ) mn
n −∞ dτn ρ=0 dτn
3
XZ ∞ Y d2 Xnν (τn )
= boundary term + dτn δ xρ − Xnρ (τn ) mn
n −∞ ρ=0
dτn2
3
XZ ∞ Y d2 Xnν (τn )
= dτn δ xρ − Xnρ (τn ) mn
n −∞ ρ=0
dτn2
!
d2 Xnν
=0 since for free particle =0 .
dτn2
(4.13)
Suppose we have a set of particles moving under a background electromagnetic field. Equation
of motion is given by
d2 X νn ν dX αn (τn )
mn = q F | α
n α X n (τn ) . (4.14)
dτn2 dτn
Now, we calculate
3
µν
XZ ∞ Y d2 Xnν (τn )
∂µ T(matter) = dτn δ xρ − Xnρ (τn ) mn
n −∞ ρ=0
dτn2
3
XZ ∞ Y dX αn (τn )
= dτn δ xρ − Xnρ (τn ) qn F να |X αn (τn )
n −∞ ρ=0
dτn
Z ∞ dX α (τ )
n n
X
= F να (x) qn dτn δ (4) x − Xn (τn )
n −∞ dτn
= F να (x)J (x) α
(4.15)
= F να (−∂ ρ Fρ α )
= −F να ∂ ρ Fρ α
= −F να ∂ ρ Fρ α
µν
= −∂µ T(EM )
!
µν µν
=⇒ ∂µ T(matter) + T(EM ) =0 .
– 13 –
where we use EM field equation
µν µα ν 1
T(EM ) =F F α − η µν Fαβ F αβ (where indices raised and lowered by ηµν ) . (4.16)
4
Curved space: In local inertial frame
dXn0µ (τn )
Z
J 0µ (x0 ) = dτn δ (4) (x0 − Xn0 (τn ))
X
qn . (4.17)
n dτn
Now,
J ρ (x) = ∂µ0 xρ J 0µ (x0 ) . (4.18)
J ρ (x) is given by
dXn0µ (τn )
Z
dτn δ (4) (x0 − Xn0 (τn ))∂µ0 xρ
X
ρ
J (x) = qn
n dτn
dXnµ (τn )
Z
dτn δ (4) (x0 − Xn0 (τn ))
X
= qn
n dτn
µ (4.19)
−1 dXn (τn )
Z
0β
X
(4)
= qn dτn δ (x − Xn (τn ))|det(∂α x )|
n dτn
dXnµ (τn ) 1
X Z
= qn dτn δ (4) (x − Xn (τn )) √ .
n dτn −detg
Here, we will prove the identity given by eq.(4.20) and eq.(4.22) we used to obtain eq.(4.19).
Identity:
δ (4) (x0 − Xn0 (τn )) = δ (4) (x − Xn (τn ))|det(∂α x0β )|−1 . (4.20)
This eq.(4.20) follows from eq.(4.21) where we have for x1 , · · · , xn functions f 1 (~x), · · · , f n (~x)
n n ∂f j −1
Y XY
i i i (4.21)
δ f (~x) = δ x − x (k) det ,
∂xi
i=1 k i=1
where ~x(k) satisfies f i ~x(k) = 0 .
Now,
– 14 –
In a general coordinate frame electromagnetic current is given by
1 dXnµ (τ )
Z X
J µ (x) = p dτ qn δ (4) (x − Xn (τ )) . (4.23)
−detg(x) n dτ
The way we arrive at this expression given by eq.(4.23) is we first calculate this in a
local inertial frame and then transform into the general coordinate frame.
µν 0ρσ
T(EM) = ∂ρ0 xµ ∂σ0 xν T(EM)
µν µα ν 1
T(EM ) =F F α − g µν Fαβ F αβ (where indices raised and lowered by gµν ) . (4.24)
4
– 15 –