Professional Documents
Culture Documents
28 Trizics Roadmap
28 Trizics Roadmap
28 Trizics Roadmap
Carlos J. Espinoza-González
Carlos A. Ávila-Orta
Guillermo Martínez-Colunga
Darío Bueno-Baqués
Alfonso Maffezzoli
Francesca Lionetto
Abstract
The application of TRIZICS as a comprehensive and logical problem understanding-
solving framework for early-stages of technology research is presented. Analytical TRIZ and
non-TRIZ tools are applied to identify key issues to address improvements and developments
in melt processing of polymeric materials using the ultrasonic treatment technology. The
technological evolution of the ultrasonic treatment technology of polymer melts shows an
unexpected pattern of evolution during its fifty years of history. A quantitative evaluation of
the evolution patterns and the logical patterns in a Learning process suggests a more in-depth
understanding of the scientific principles of the technology. TRIZICS is proposed as a
successful roadmap to address more efficiently the early-stages of technology research
processes.
1. Introduction
The technology research could be defined as a process used to collect and analyze information
concerning the discovery and interpretation of facts, which are oriented toward technological
applications. As general consensus, a research process involves the phases/steps of i)
formulation of the research problem, ii) extensive literature review, iii) specification of the
purpose of research, iv) determination of specific research questions or hypotheses, v) data
collection, vi) analysis and interpretation of data, and vii) report and evaluation of research [1].
In the field of the technology development, the early-stages in the research process (the first
four steps above mentioned) represent the most crucial stages, since the level of success of
such technology is dictated by an accurate selection of which components/parts of a
technology require to be improved or developed.
How important could be to “spend time” in those four steps? Nowadays, most companies that
emerge from technologies developed in academic and research institutions (spin-offs)
acknowledge that a rigorous technology research process is required to develop new products,
or find the next generation of any current system or product. Thus, the phrase “spend time”
can be better replaced by “invest time”. The first four steps in the research process could be
viewed as easy steps to follow; however, when we talk about improvement and development
of new technologies, these “easy” steps can sometimes be very difficult to follow.
TRIZ (Theory of Inventive Problem Solving) is an engineering problem solving toolkit that
has demonstrated to play a crucial role in the improvement and development of technological
systems. TRIZ tools help to investigate and find the existing answers to our problem through
1
7º Congreso Iberoamericano de Innovación Tecnológica
Orizaba, Veracruz, del 14 al 18 de noviembre del 2012
an entire problem understanding. However, TRIZ tools are not normally organized into a step-
by-step process, therefore in some cases, is difficult to achieve an entire problem
understanding. Recently, Gordon Cameron (TRIZ trainer and elected President of the Arizona
TRIZ Association) integrated all TRIZ tools with other non-TRIZ problem solving tools into
a comprehensive and logical problem understanding-solving framework called TRIZICS [2],
which facilitates the process of understanding and problems solving.
Recently, we performed an analysis of the current state of the art of the ultrasonic treatment
technology of polymer melts following the TRIZICS roadmap, in order to find opportunities
for future investigations, improvements and developments [3]. Technological and scientific
issues concerning with the physical and chemical effects of the ultrasound in polymer melts
were discussed. In the present paper, the step-by-step process of the TRIZICS roadmap is
revealed and presented as a roadmap to address more efficiently the early-stages of
technology research processes.
2. Background theory
2.1 TRIZICS roadmap
TRIZ tools are not typically organized into a step-by-step process, so inexperienced TRIZ
users find it difficult to decide which TRIZ tools to use and when to apply them. There is an
algorithm called ARIZ [4], which come from the Russian acronym Algorithm Rezhenija
Izobretatelskih Zadach known as the Algorithm for Solving Inventive Problems (ASIP in
English). This algorithm combines several TRIZ solution tools into a sequential process;
however, ARIZ does not form an overall problem solving process because it is a method for
taking a specific problem with known root cause and solving it.
TRIZICS is a structured and practical problem solving framework for the application of TRIZ
tools, which leads from the beginning of a problem solving process to the end, that is – from
problem definition to implementation and validation of the solution. Figure 1 shows the six
main stages regarding to problem understanding and solving process using TRIZICS. From
this figure, the first four stages of TRIZICS represent the early-stages of the research process.
2
7º Congreso Iberoamericano de Innovación Tecnológica
Orizaba, Veracruz, del 14 al 18 de noviembre del 2012
3
7º Congreso Iberoamericano de Innovación Tecnológica
Orizaba, Veracruz, del 14 al 18 de noviembre del 2012
4
7º Congreso Iberoamericano de Innovación Tecnológica
Orizaba, Veracruz, del 14 al 18 de noviembre del 2012
Figure 6. “The most important graph in the world” by Tony Buzan [7].
The most important graph in the world is based in seven Memory laws distributed along a
learning curve with the vertical axis indicating the intensity of interest, and the horizontal axis
indicating the time of the learning period from where learning starts to where learning ends.
How can it be applied to understand the patterns of evolution? At the beginning, the curve
indicates a memory law known as the Primacy Effect (P), representing the moment in which
a prime interest in developing or improving a technological process is born. This action could
derive from current needs or previous studies performed. The “X” on the curve indicates the
memory law called the Understanding and Misunderstanding Effect (U). This law
represents the brain’s ability to make connections, and can be related with the infancy stage of
the S-curve (see Figure 5), in which the scientific principles are used to build a platform
innovation.
As the technology systems evolve, the scientific principles are applied to develop new
applications, products and increase the ideality of the system. These facts represent the
memory law called Association Effect (Ax ; x = 1, 2, 3, …), which is presented during the
learning process. The continuous application of the association effect Memory law will
originate the Memory law called the Von Restorff Effect (VR), which represents the growth
stage on the S-curve.
At this time, the continuous improvements and developments in components and designs have
increased significantly the ideality of the system. Thus, the Von Restorff effect leads to the
next Memory law called the Effect of Meaning (M). The “smiley face” on the graph
represents the point at which the scientific principles from platform innovation have been
completely understood and successfully exploited. The ideality of the system has reached its
maximum within the technological platform. This point on the graph represents the maturity
stage in the S-curve.
On the other hand, arrows located during the learning process indicate the moments of
injection of interest, which represent the Memory law called Interest Effect (I). In a
technological system, this effect represents the needs in improving and developing in
components and design. Finally, at the end of the learning process, the continuous
development of the system within its technological platform does not contribute to system’s
5
7º Congreso Iberoamericano de Innovación Tecnológica
Orizaba, Veracruz, del 14 al 18 de noviembre del 2012
development and the ideality of the system is not increased. This point represents the Memory
law called Recency Effect (R).
2.1.4 Define a specific problem
Applying the analytical tools often leads to a re-definition of the original problem and the
definition of a number of different new specific problems to address. Once the problems list is
created, should be selected those specific problems that will really contribute to system’s
development. Afterwards, in order to apply the TRIZ solutions tools, the selected specific
problem must be re-stated as a technical contradiction, physical contradiction, Substance-field
(Su-field) model, function statement, or a search for a trend of evolution (Figure 7).
6
7º Congreso Iberoamericano de Innovación Tecnológica
Orizaba, Veracruz, del 14 al 18 de noviembre del 2012
7
7º Congreso Iberoamericano de Innovación Tecnológica
Orizaba, Veracruz, del 14 al 18 de noviembre del 2012
rubbers, as well as the introduction the ultrasonic treatment technology to polymer blends
and polymer nanocomposites field.
• The onset of the maturity stage (from 2000 to present): Described by the decreasing in the
functionalities and applications of this technology.
8
7º Congreso Iberoamericano de Innovación Tecnológica
Orizaba, Veracruz, del 14 al 18 de noviembre del 2012
9
7º Congreso Iberoamericano de Innovación Tecnológica
Orizaba, Veracruz, del 14 al 18 de noviembre del 2012
10
7º Congreso Iberoamericano de Innovación Tecnológica
Orizaba, Veracruz, del 14 al 18 de noviembre del 2012
Figure 10. Level of inventiveness of the patents related to the ultrasonic treatment technology of
polymer melts.
Figure 11. Evaluation of the trends of evolution for ultrasonic treatment technology of polymer
melts
11
7º Congreso Iberoamericano de Innovación Tecnológica
Orizaba, Veracruz, del 14 al 18 de noviembre del 2012
Figure 12. Law of wholeness of parts applied to ultrasonic treatment technology of polymer
melts. The elements of the system are represented as car parts.
3.1.3.3 The most important graph in the world. What are we forgetting?
The ultrasonic treatment technology of polymer melts has passed through the three stages of a
technological evolution without a sufficient understanding of its technological platform,
resulting in an “accelerated aging”. In terms of a learning process, the Memory law of the
Understanding and Misunderstanding Effect has not been properly applied by scientists and
inventors in the field. The scientific principles used to understand the mechanism of
ultrasound in polymer melts are not accurate. This misunderstanding has not allowed the
development of the complete and right Associations Effects during the technological evolution
(see Figure 13). So, if the understanding of the mechanism for polymer melts is not well
understood, then the Von Restorff Effect observed during the evolution of this technology
(from 1990 to 2000) does not really represents the Von Restorff Effect that the ultrasound
technology should reach.
Figure 13. “The most important graph in the world” applied to current state of the art of the
ultrasonic treatment technology of polymer melts
Nowadays, the ultrasonic treatment technology of polymer melts is located on the Meaning
Effect, point in which the analysis of this technology is discussed. The “smiley face” turns
into a “sad face”, due to not well understood scientific principles applied to this technology.
In this point, in which the “sad face” is asking for something forgotten, the S-curve and the
trends of evolution analysis demonstrate that the entire understanding of the scientific
12
7º Congreso Iberoamericano de Innovación Tecnológica
Orizaba, Veracruz, del 14 al 18 de noviembre del 2012
principles of the ultrasonic treatment technology of polymer melts has been forgotten in the
learning process or evolution of this technology.
3.1.4 Defining the specific problem
In order to improve and develop more efficient methods for processing of polymeric materials
using the ultrasonic treatment technology, the application of TRIZ analytical tools and the
interpretation of the learning process by means of “the most important graph in the world”
demonstrate that the understanding of the mechanisms underlying the effects of the ultrasound
in polymer melts is the key issue for future innovations.
The addressing of research on the mechanisms underlying the effects of the ultrasound in
polymer melts will lead towards a re-definition of the ultrasonic treatment technology of
polymer melts and foster future developments.
4. Conclusions
TRIZICS roadmap resulted as an organized problem solving framework for the application of
TRIZ tools to early-stages of technology research. S-curves and trends of evolution analysis
shows that the ultrasonic treatment technology of polymer melts has passed through the three
stages of a technological evolution without sufficient understanding of its technological
platform, resulting in an “accelerated aging”.
The evaluation of the Altshullerian laws and the interpretation of the learning process of the
ultrasonic treatment technology of polymer melts, by means of “the most important graph in
the world”, converge to establish that in-depth investigations on understanding of the
scientific principles of this technology are the key issues to lead improvements and
developments in melt processing of polymeric materials using the ultrasonic treatment
technology.
The way as TRIZ and non-TRIZ tools are integrated into TRIZICS roadmap facilitated the
searching of keys issues to develop future innovations using the ultrasonic treatment
technology of polymer melts. TRIZICS can be successfully used for early-stages of
technology research.
Acknowledgements
Author details
*Address all correspondence to: E-mail: cavila@ciqa.mx ; Phone: +52 844 4389830 ext.
1
Research Center for Applied Chemistry, Department of Advanced Materials, Blvd. Enrique
Reyna #140, 25294 Saltillo, Coahuila, Mexico.
13
7º Congreso Iberoamericano de Innovación Tecnológica
Orizaba, Veracruz, del 14 al 18 de noviembre del 2012
2
Research Center for Applied Chemistry, Department of Plastics Transformation Processing,
Blvd. Enrique Reyna #140, 25294 Saltillo, Coahuila, Mexico.
3
University of Salento, Department of Engineering for Innovation, 73100 Lecce, Italy.
References
[1] Creswell J. W., Educational Research: Planning, Conducting, and Evaluating Quantitative
and Qualitative Research, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 2008.
[2] Cameron G, Trizics: Teach yourself TRIZ, how to invent, innovate and solve "impossible"
technical problems systematically: CreateSpace, 2010.
[3] Ávila-Orta C.; C. Espinoza-González; G. Martínez-Colunga; D. Bueno-Baqués; A.
Maffezzoli; F. Lionetto. "An overview of progress and current challenges in ultrasonic
treatment of polymer melts," Advances in Polymer Technology 2012, doi:
10.1002/adv.21303.
[4] Savransky S. D. In Engineering of Creativity: Introduction to TRIZ Methodology of
Inventive Problem Solving, CRC Press LLC: Boca Raton, FL, 2000, p 303-338.
[5] Sood A; G. J. Tellis. "Technological Evolution and Radical Innovation," Journal of
Marketing 2005, 69, 152–168.
[6] Cavallucci D; R. D. Weill. "Integrating Altshuller's development laws for technical
systems into the design process," CIRP Annals - Manufacturing Technology 2001, 50,
115-120.
[7] Buzan T; J. Goddard; J Castaneda, The Most Important Graph in the World...and How it
Will Change Your Life!, Cardiff, UK: Proactive Press, 2012.
[8] Isayev A. I.; S. Ghose. In Rubber Recycling; Isayev, A. I.; Khait, K.; De, S. K., (Eds.),
CRC Press, 2005.
[9] Lin H.; A. I. Isayev. "Ultrasonic treatment of polypropylene, polyamide 6, and their
blends," Journal of Applied Polymer Science 2006, 102, 2643-2653.
[10] Isayev A. I.; R. Kumar; T. M. Lewis. "Ultrasound assisted twin screw extrusion of
polymer-nanocomposites containing carbon nanotubes," Polymer 2009, 50, 250-260.
[11] Ávila C. A.; J. G. Martínez; D. Bueno; C. E. Raudry; V. J. Cruz; P. González; J. A.
Valdez; M. E. Esparza; C. J. Espinoza; J. A. Rodríguez. Int Patent Publ WO
2010/117253, 2010.
[12] Leon N. "Trends and patterns of evolution for product innovation," TRIZ Journal 2006,
October.
[13] Lerch B. W. US Patent 3071809, 1963.
[14] Isayev A.; C. K. Hong. US Patent 2003/124211, 2003.
[15] Bodine A. G. US Patent 3169589, 1965.
[16] Yashin V. V.; A. I. Isayev. "A Model for Rubber Degradation under Ultrasonic
Treatment: Part I. Acoustic Cavitation in Viscoelastic Solid," Rubber Chemistry and
Technology 1999, 72, 741-758.
14