Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To Study Credit Appraisal in Home Loan Fin - Final - Docx 1
To Study Credit Appraisal in Home Loan Fin - Final - Docx 1
To Study Credit Appraisal in Home Loan Fin - Final - Docx 1
DISSERTATION
ON
1
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Working on dissertation was a memorable and learning experience for me. The sole efforts
of any Individual are not sufficient enough to complete the Dissertation. The completion of
a dissertation t involves the effort and interest of many people. I would like to extend my
gratitude and thanks to all those that gave up their time, and invaluable knowledge, to
make this dissertation successful.
I would like to thank our Dissertation guide Prof. Praveen Suryawanshi for providing me
an opportunity to undertake the dissertation.
I would like to take this opportunity as privilege to articulate my de sense of gratefulness to
Dr. Shalaka Parker, Dean of Padmashree. Dr. D.Y.PatilPrathisthan’s
Dr. D Y Patil Institute of MCA & MBA for her continuous encouragement and
invaluable guidance for the completion the dissertation.
I wish to express my special thanks to all Faculties for their continuous support.
Date:
Place: Pune Name: Namrata Dhakate
2
DECLARATION
I do hereby declare that this dissertation work entitled “to study credit appraisal in home
loan finance” submitted by me to the Savitribai Phule Pune University of for the partial
fulfillment of the requirement for the award of Master of Business Administration (MBA)
is a record of my own research work. The report embodies the finding based on my study
and observation and has not been submitted earlier for the award of any degree or diploma
to any Institute or University.
Date:
3
INDEX
1 INTRODUCTION 5-11
6 FINDINGS 57-58
7 SUGGESTIONS 59-60
8 CONCLUSION 61-62
9 BIBLIOGRAPHY 63-64
4
INTRODUCTION
5
1.1 Introduction of Dissertation
There are four basics types of credit. By understanding how each works.
1. Service credit is monthly payments for utilities such as telephone, gas, electricity,
and water. You often have to pay a deposit, and you may pay a late charge if your
payment is not on time.
2. Loan let you borrow cash. Loan can be for small or large amounts and for a few
days or several years. Money can be repaid in lump sum or in several regular
payments until the amount you borrowed and the finance charges are paid in full.
Loan can be secured or unsecured.
3. Installment credit may be described as buying on time, financing through the store
or the easy payment plan. The borrower takes the goods homes in exchange for a
promise to pay later. Cars, major appliances, and furniture are often purchased this
way. You usually sign a contract, make a down payment, and agree to pay the
balance with a specified number of equal payments called installments. The finance
charges are included in the payments. The item you purchase may be used as
security for the loan.
6
4. Credit cards are issued by an individual retail stores, banks, or businesses. Using a
credit card can be the equivalent of an interest-free loan, if you pay for the use of it
in full at the end of each month.[ CITATION AJo13 \l 1033 ]
The Credit Appraisal is a complete exercise which starts from the time a potential borrower
walks into the branch and concludes in credit delivery and monitoring with the objective of
certifying and maintaining the quality of lending and managing credit risk. Credit appraisal
is the assessment of the viability of proposed long term investments in terms of
shareholder wealth and the formal analysis of all project costs and benefits which is used to
justify the project proposal. The bank has over the years designed and adopted the Best
Practices Code. This in effect represents the bank's philosophy towards effective Corporate
Governance.
The starting point for appraisal: applicants should provide detailed description of the
project; identifying the local need it aims to meet. Appraisal helps to show if the project is
the right response, and highlights what the project would be doing and for whom.
This is an important step in the housing finance cycle to keep the organization moving
successfully. It is essential to generate cases to credit bank uses methods to source
business & generate leads-
1. Mail.
2. Walk-in interview.
7
3. Telephone enquiry.
4. Customer reference.
Once the lead has been sourced the sales officer contacts him & gives him a list of
documents long with other corresponding information. When the documents are
handed over to sales officer, he submits documents along with the application form to
bank. Sales officer gives an idea about how much loan can customer avail as per his
income.
C. Completion of documents:
The document have been collected by the sales officer hand over to the back office
executive, executive then complete documents in special file provided for bank in
accordance with the requirement of bank.
After completing the documents the back office executive ties the field investigation
report with the data compiled from the file before moving it on the next stage.
After completion of documents and filing of it, the documents are handed over to the
Sales manager, who verifies the documents to check for loan analysis the strength and
8
weakness of a case, the loan eligibility & the requirement of additional documents.
The sales manager act as a filter allowing good case to flow through for final approval
while do not fit, into the polices of bank. Sales manager make signature if the case fit
into policies of the bank.
F. Personal discussion:
The file is send to the branch credit manager for final approval, after checking the file
branch credit manager take final decision of approval or rejection of the case. If the
case is rejected the documents are returned to the customer & if the case is approved
then it goes to the next step.
This is the final step in sanction process after receiving the sanction letter it hand over
the sanction letter to customer along with a list of legal documents required for the
next stage i.e. disbursement stage.
Disbursement stage:
A. Collection of legal documents.
B. Completion of documents.
C. Legal appraisal.
D. Technical appraisal.
E. Final check by the BCM.
9
A. Collection of legal documents:
This is the first step towards the disbursement of cheque after sanction of the case.
Already the sales officer collect the legal document from the customer in case of
self-construction& or collect it from the builder from whom the customer is
purchasing the property.
B. Completion of documents:
Once the documents are collected by the sales officer he hand it over to the back
office executive for compilation the executive complete the documents and process.
C. Legal Appraisal:
The legal appraisal of a case is an important step & it done by lawyer specially
appointed by bank. The lawyer verifies the documents to check if the title of the
property is free & marketable from all obligations; other legal aspect is free from
any fraud. Once the documents have been verified he submits a legal report to
bank. The lawyer report is very essential without his approval no case is clear. In
case of negative remark mentioned by the lawyer the case is being rejected.
D. Technical Appraisal:
1. If the property is in accordance with the plans rules and regulations approved by
NMC.
2. If there are any legal and unauthorized construction on the site.
3. If the owner of the property is the same as mentioned on the legal Documents.
4. The extract or stage of constructions.
10
5. The raw material etc. available on the site.
6. He checks to see the cost is being incurred on the property is equivalent to the
estimate shown by the customer.
7. He also provides an estimated date of compilation of the property.
8. Checking the age and conciliation of the property in case of resale Property.
The BCM makes a final check of the documents before taking his decision. If the
case is clear then BCM sends the file to operational manager.
F. Cheque disbursement:
This is final step in the disbursement stage. The operation manager prepare the cheque
along with the letter which is handed over to the sales officer who then five it to the
customer. Disbursement of cheque is done in accordance with the stage of construction
as reported by technical advisor.
The cheque is disbursed in two ways,
1. as a part disbursement.
2. fully disbursement.
11
1.4 SELECTION OF TOPIC
We know three basic needs of human beings i.e. food, clothing & shelter. For all these
needs we want money? It involves large investment. Everyone does not have that much
money to invest at once. Borrowing and lending is the important function of the every
developing economy. It is in existence right from ancient time. Previously in barter era the
goods are exchange against goods. Now the scenario has changed to fulfill the need of
human beings the old concept which emerge as a new is nothing but “Loan”.
Co-operative banks are an integral part of the Indian financial system. They comprise
urban co-operative banks and rural co-operative credit institutions. Co-operative banks in
India are more than 100 years old. Urban Co-operative Banks (UCBs) also referred to as
primary cooperative banks? Play an important role in meeting the growing credit needs of
urban and semi-urban areas of the country. UCBs mobilize savings from the middle and
lower income groups and purvey credit to small borrowers, including weaker sections of
the society. Scheduled UCBs are under closer regulatory and supervisory framework of the
RBI. Rural co-operative banks operate mainly for the benefit of rural areas, particularly the
agricultural sector.
The Prerana Co-operative Bank has been undergoing some fundamental changes in its
approach to Co-operative Banking. There has been a perceptible shift towards Customer
Relationship Management (CRM) mainly arising out of the element of intensive
competition infused into the industry by the arrival of private players. With the free
economic reforms government permitted private players to enter in banking business along
with existing nationalized banks.
12
Credit Policy
“Credit has done a thousand times more to enrich mankind than all the gold mines in the
world. It has exalted labor, stimulated manufacture, and pushed commerce over every sea.”
13
THEORETICAL
BACKGROUND
14
Topic under study
HOME LOAN
A new home brings with it new hopes, joys and emotions. At Prerana cooperative bank, we
have shared new hopes, joys and emotions with over 15000 customers. Every customer has
a specific and unique concern. Having earned an experience of 10 years in home loans, our
home loan product is customized to provide you solutions for your unique concern.
Features
Maximum loan
85% of the cost of the property (including the cost of the land) and based on the
repayment capacity of the customer.
Maximum Term
20 years subject to your retirement age.
15
2-in-1 Home Loans
2-in-1 Home Loan provides customers with a choice of breaking up the loan
requirement into Adjustable and Fixed Rate loans. Customers benefit both ways, as
it helps them hedge their interest rate risk against rising interest rates to the extent
of the fixed rate portion of the loan and take the advantage of falling interest rates,
with the Adjustable Rate portion. 2-in-1 Home Loans can be taken in any
proportion. With no prepayment charges* under the Adjustable Rate Home Loan,
customers planning to make part prepayments can take a portion of the loan
intended for prepayment under Adjustable Rate loan option; the rest can be taken
under Fixed Rate Loan option.
Purpose
Purchase of
Self-Construction
Fees:1% of the loan amount applied plus applicable service taxes and cess.
No Charges for:
1. Replacement of cheques
2. Income Tax Certificates
3. Accelerated Repayment Option
16
Redemption Charges
Repayment Option:
Helps young executives take a much bigger loan today based on an increase in
their future income, this helps executives buy a bigger home today!
Often customers, parents and their children, wish to purchase properties together.
The parent is nearing retirement and their children have just started working. This
option helps such customers combine the incomes and take a long term home loan
where in the installment reduces upon retirement of the earning parent.
17
Tranche Based EMI
Accelerated Repayment Scheme offers you a great opportunity to repay the loan
faster by increasing the EMI. Whenever you get an increment, increase in your
disposable income or have lump sum funds for loan prepayment, you can benefit
by, Increase in EMI means faster loan repayment saving of interest because of
faster loan repayment you can invest lump sum funds rather than use it for loan
prepayment. The return from investments also gives you the comfort of paying the
increased EMI..
Security
Security for the loan is a first mortgage of the property to be financed, normally by
way of deposit of title deeds and/or such other collateral security as may be
necessary. Interim security may be required, if the property is under construction.
18
Documents forms integrate part of any legal or financial transaction. The documents
which are necessary for appraisal of home loan are divided into two stage documents as
follows.
These documents are submitted for an approval or sanction of housing loan. The
credit documents all collected to analyze the credit worth need of client. They help to
understand the financial strength & weakness of a case that how much loan can he/she
get, calculation of installment is done on the basis of these documents.
19
Self Employed Self Employed
Salaried (Professionals) (Businessman)
Business).
Last 3 years Profit /Loss Last 3 years Profit /Loss Last 3 years Income Tax
and Balance Sheet.
And Balance Sheet. returns (self and business)
20
Customer – Basic Eligibility Criteria.
Customers: Borrowers
Resident Indians
Salaried
Self Employed Professionals
Self Employed Non Professionals
21
Self-Employed - Professionals
1. CA/ICWA/ CS.
2. Architects.
6. Doctors / Pathologist
2. For Consultants like Engineers, MBAs etc.Net profit should be Rs.15000 p.a
22
Age Norm:
a. Required.
b. In lieu of certificate, surrogates viz. membership certificate can be accepted.
Eligible entities:
Individuals
a. Proprietors
b. Partners
c. Directors of Pt. Ltd. Cos.
23
Minimum Income to be ascertained as follows:
For fulfilling minimum income norms adding nominal expenses like depreciation,
interest on capital to partners / directors etc. to net profit shall not be considered.
Age Norm
a. Minimum 21 years at Loan Application.
b. Maximum 65 or Age of Retirement, whichever is less at Loan Maturity.
24
How we treat income from other sources?
The agreement of the eligibility from other sources of income must not be more than 100
% of the agreement of the main salary income.
2)Self-Employed – Professional:-
For calculation purpose SEPs can be classified as per following pattern –
I. Doctors
a. Allopathic (MBBS plus)
b. Other (BHMS, BUMS, etc.)
c. Others (CA, CWA, CS, Lawyer, Consultant etc.)
25
II. Methods Used:
a. GPR Multiplier Method
b. Eligibility based on Net Profit
5) Eligibility calculation
Particulars Amt. Amt.
Total Appraised Income xxxxx ------
Add: Income from other xxxxx ------
sources
Total Income ------ Xxxxx
Total Income p.m. xxxxx ------
(TI/12)
Less: Obligations xxxxx ------
Maximum Payable EMI ------ Xxxxx
26
Understanding Income Documents:
1) Salary Slip Analysis
a. Name of the Applicant – whether matches with the salary slip or not?
b. Designation
c. Name of the Employer
d. Is the latest salary credit as per the salary slip
e. Are the salary credits in the PCB statements as per the salary slip
f. Is the salary fixed or variable
g. Any regular deductions reflecting in the salary slip.
Post sanction is legal documents on the basis of which a cheque is disbursed to the
customer. The only security that bank has against a loan in this legal documents & no
deviation is usually allowed in legal document. These documents are sent to the lawyer
who verifies before being accepted by bank. These are as follows:
28
a. Share Certificate
b. Allotment Letter
c. No Objection Certificate from Society
d. Own contribution receipt from Society
e. Copy of Society Bye Laws
f. Society Registration Certificate
g. Registered Agreement if not Original member
4) Resale Case:
a. Sale Deed/Agreement with Registration Receipt
b. Previous Customers Sale Deed/ Agreement with Registration Receipt
c. Own Contribution Receipt
d. NOC from Builder/Society
e. Title Certificate
f. Share Certificate & Allotment Letter (if applicable)
g. NA Order & NA Tax Receipt (Xerox)
h. ULC (Xerox)
i. 7/12 & 6-D Extract (Xerox)
j. Commencement Certificate & Completion Certificate (Xerox)
k. Society Registration Certificate & Bye-Laws (Xerox)
l. Title Certificate (Xerox)
29
m. Building Plan (Xerox)
7) Agreements
a. Current agreement must be registered
b. Stamp Duty receipt required
c. Registration receipt required.
d. Stamp duty receipt and registration receipt amount to be added to cost of
property and calculated as OLakhs too.
8) NOC
a. NOC should be on the letterhead of the Society/ Builder / Development
Authority
b. Should have the stamp of the society / Builder / Development Authority
30
c. Address should match as per the agreement, Flat No., Wing No. etc.
d. Should be as per the procedures and drafts for different transaction types.
e. Must be dated
The housing finance cycle at PCB is of two stages; both are important and play a vital role
in fulfilling the requirements of housing finance institution.
31
1. Sanction stage.
It is a stage where the customer gets sanction or approval that he is eligible to take
a loan of specific amount calculated on the basis of his income from Prerana co-
operative bank.
2. Disbursement stage.
It is a stage where the cheque of sanctioned amount is handover to the customer or
concerned person.
Sanction stage.
C. Completion of documents.
G. Personal discussion.
32
A) Generation of leads/Sourcing of business:-
This is an important step in the housing finance cycle to keep the organization moving
successfully. It is essential to generate cases to credit bank uses methods to source
business & generate leads.
Mail.
Walk-in interview.
Telephone enquiry.
Customer reference.
Once the lead has been sourced the sales officer contacts him & gives him a list of
documents long with other corresponding information. When the documents are
handed over to sales officer, he submits documents along with the application form to
bank. Sales officer gives an idea about how much loan customer avail as per his
income can.
C) Completion of documents:-
The document have been collected by the sales officer hand over to the back office
executive, executive then complete documents in special file provided for bank in
accordance with the requirement of bank
33
D) Field investigation report:-
After completing the documents the back office executive ties the field investigation
report with the data compiled from the file before moving it on the next stage.
The CIBIL score of the applicant should be more than 750, if in case the score is
less than 750 then the chances of getting loan are less.
After completion of documents and filing of it, the documents are handed over to the
Sales manager, who verifies the documents to check for loan analysis the strength and
weakness of a case, the loan eligibility & the requirement of additional documents.
The sales manager act as a filter allowing good case to flow through for final approval
while do not fit, into the polices of bank. Sales manager make signature if the case fit
into policies of the bank.
G) Personal discussion:-
The file is send to the branch credit manager for final approval, after checking the
file branch credit manager take final decision of approval or rejection of the case.
34
If the case is rejected the documents are returned to the customer & if the case is
approved then it goes to the next step.
This is the final step in sanction process after receiving the sanction letter it hand
over the sanction letter to customer along with a list of legal documents required for
the next stage i.e. disbursement stage.
DISBURSEMENT STAGE
This is the first step towards the disbursement of cheque after sanction of the case.
Already the sales officer collect the legal document from the customer in case of
self-construction& or collect it from the builder from whom the customer is
purchasing the property.
B. Completion of documents:-
Once the documents are collected by the sales officer he hand it over to the back
office executive for compilation the executive complete the documents and process.
C. Legal Appraisal:-
The legal appraisal of a case is an important step & it done by lawyer specially
appointed by Bank. The lawyer verifies the documents to check if the title of the
property is free & marketable from all obligations; other legal aspect is free from
any fraud. Once the documents have been verified he submits a legal report to
bank. The lawyer report is very essential without his approval no case is clear. In
case of negative remark mentioned by the lawyer the case is being rejected.
35
D. Technical Appraisal:-
The BCM makes a final check of the documents before taking his decision. If the
case is clear then BCM send s the file to operational manager.
F. Cheque disbursement:-
This is final step in the disbursement stage. The operation manager prepare the
cheque along with the letter which is handed over to the sales officer who then five
it to the customer. Disbursement of cheque is done in accordance with the stage of
construction as reported by technical advisor.
The cheque is disbursed in two ways,
1. As a part disbursement.
2. Fully disbursement.
36
General Causes of Rejection of the Proposal
Not every case that comes into SAD can be approved for a loan. Certain cases get
rejected there are various causes which lead to the rejection of a case. Some important
causes of rejection are follows.
1) Documentation / Property:
1.1 Credit Documentation not as per Policy.
1.2 Technical Norms not met
1.3 Legal Documentation not as per Policy.
1.4 Fraud Document Submitted
2) Financial Reasons:
2.1 AF Cheque Bounce
2.2 Negative RCU
2.3 Unsatisfactory RTR / Credit history
2.4 Income Norms not met
2.5 Employment norms not met
2.6 Poor Financial (SE Case)
2.7 High Outstanding of Debtors
2.8 Too many existing Obligations
3) Geographical Reasons:
3.1 Outside Geo Limits
3.2 Property in Negative Area
3.3 Residence in Negative Area
4) Personal Profile:
4.1 Negative Profile
4.2 Debut match found
4.3 Income Ownership norms not met
4.4 Poor Saving Habits’
4.5 Dependents > 5
4.6 Undisclosed/Manipulated material facts
4.7 Internal Family Transaction of the Property
4.8 Age norms not met
4.9 Customer withdrawing
4.10 Negative references.
37
COMPANY
PROFILE
38
3.1 Profile of the Organization
Birth:
Registered with an authorized capital of Rs.10.00 lakh and commenced business on 24th
January 1999.
Our Philosophy:
Technology with personal touch. The Bank has also launched aggressively the concept of
“Our Inspiration Your Progress”
OUR AIM:
The bank wishes to cater to all types of needs of the entire family, in the whole country. Its
dream is "One Family, One Bank.
Our Emblem
Mission
40
3.2 Organization Chart
Board of Director.
Business Head.
Sales Manager.
(Channel Head)
Financial Planners.
Co-Executive.
41
3.3 PRODUCT RANGE
1. Home Loan:-
A new home brings with it new hopes, joys and emotions. At Prerana co-operative Bank,
we have shared new hopes, joys and emotions with over 2000 customers. Every customer
has a specific and unique concern. Having earned an experience of 10 years in home loans,
our home loan product is customized to provide you solutions for your unique concern.
Features :
Purpose
Purchase of
1 Flat, row house, bungalow from developers.
2 Existing freehold properties.
3 Properties in an existing or proposed co-operative housing society
or apartment owner's association.
Maximum loan
80% of the cost of the property (including the cost of the land) and based on the
repayment capacity of the customer.
Maximum Term
20 years subject to your retirement age.
Fees:1% of the loan amount applied plus applicable service taxes and cess.
No Charges for :
1) Replacement of cheques.
2) Income Tax Certificates.
3) Accelerated Repayment Option.
Security
Security for the loan is a first mortgage of the property to be financed, normally by way of
deposit of title deeds and/or such other collateral security as may be necessary. Interim
security may be required, if the property is under construction.
42
Self-Construction
Maximum loan
80% of the cost of the property (including the cost of the land) and based on the
repayment capacity of the customer.
Maximum Term
20 years subject to your retirement age.
Fees
1% of the loan amount applied plus applicable service taxes and cess.
No Charges for :
4) Replacement of cheques.
5) Income Tax Certificates.
6) Accelerated Repayment Option.
Security
Security for the loan is a first mortgage of the property to be financed, normally by way of
deposit of title deeds and/or such other collateral security as may be necessary. Interim
security may be required, if the property is under construction.
Features
Purpose
1. External repairs.
2. Tiling and flooring.
3. Internal and external painting.
4. Waterproofing and roofing.
5. Waterproofing on terrace.
6. Paving of compound wall (with stone/tile/etc.).
7. Bore well
43
Maximum loan
ForExisting Customer: 100% of the cost of improvement.
New Customer:80% of the cost of improvement subject to market value of the
property.
Maximum Term-20 years subject to your retirement age.
Security
Security
Features
44
Maximum loan: 80% of cost of the land and based on the repayment capacity of
the customer.
Security: Security for the loan is a first mortgage of the property to be financed, normally
by way of deposit of title deeds and/or such other collateral security as may be necessary.
Features
Purpose
45
Purchase of
1. Flat, row house, bungalow from developers.
2. Existing freehold properties.
3. Properties in an existing or proposed co-operative housing society or apartment
owner's association.
Maximum loan: 80% of the cost of the property (including the cost of the land)
and based on the repayment capacity of the customer.
Fees :1% of the loan amount applied plus applicable service taxes and cess.
No Charges for
1. Replacement of cheques.
2. Income Tax Certificates.
3. Accelerated Repayment Option.
Security:Security for the loan is a first mortgage of the property to be financed, normally
by way of deposit of title deeds and/or such other collateral security as may be necessary.
Interim security may be required, if the property is under construction.
Self-Construction
Maximum loan: 85% of the cost of the property (including the cost of the land)
and based on the repayment capacity of the customer.
Fees :1% of the loan amount applied plus applicable service taxes and cess.
No Charges for
1. Replacement of cheques.
2. Income Tax Certificates.
3. Accelerated Repayment Option.
46
Security: Security for the loan is a first mortgage of the property to be financed,
normally by way of deposit of title deeds and/or such other collateral security as
may be necessary. Interim security may be required, if the property is under
construction.
2)Home Improvement Loan:-
Purpose
External repairs.
Tiling and flooring.
Internal and external painting.
Waterproofing and roofing.
Waterproofing on terrace.
Paving of compound wall (with stone/tile/etc.).
Bore well.
Maximum loanfor
New Customer:85% of the cost of improvement subject to market value of the
property.
Maximum Term-20 years subject to your retirement age.
Security For:
Existing customer: Extension of the mortgage already created on the property
financed and/or other security as may be required by Prerana Co-operative Bank.
New Customer :For others, security for the loan is a mortgage on the entire
property beingimproved and /or other security as may be required by Bank.
Security For:
Features :
Maximum loan: 85% of cost of the land and based on the repayment capacity of
the customer.
Maximum Term:15 years subject to your retirement age.
Security: Security for the loan is a first mortgage of the property to be financed,
normally by way of deposit of title deeds and/or such other collateral security as
may be necessary.
48
may be necessary. Interim security may be required, if the property is under
construction.
3.4 Competitors
Prerana cooperative bank is competitor for other banks in the market and it also has
competition from other banks like:
1.State Bank of India
2.Punjab National Bank
3.PawnaCooperative Bank
4. The Thane JanataSahakari Bank
5.JanataSahakari Bank
49
RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY
50
4.1 Research Methodology
Research in common parlance refers to a search for knowledge. One can also define
research as a scientific and systematic search for pertinent information on a specific topic.
In fact research is an art of scientific investigation. Another meaning of research as “a
careful investigation or inquiry specially through for new facts in any branch of
knowledge.”
Redman and Mory define research as a “systemized effort to gain new knowledge.” Some
people consider as movement a movement from the known to the unknown it is actually a
voyage of discovery.
Data Sources:
In the Preparation of this project it is necessity to collect the Secondary data
Secondary Data:
The Secondary Data on the other hand, are based on second-hand information. The
data which have been already been collected, compiled & presented easier by any
agency may be used for the purpose of investigated such data may be called
“Secondary Data”. Collecting the information with the help of Annual Reports,
Magazines, Internet, and Reference Book. The Secondary data provide by
organization. The needed information is collected from Journals Annual Reports,
Magazines, etc.
Indian Banking has witnessed tremendous changes in the wake of the new economic
reforms in the year 1992. The reforms have positively impacted on the banking system,
which have become more resilient competitive and efficient, with the better productivity.
It’s a role of primacy in financial intermediation and has not been challenged by other
financial entities. On the contrary, it has become more entrenched and diversified having
mode forays into insurance and investment banking. Some of the banks have acquired the
status of universal banks.
From the mass banking of yester years, Indian banks have travelled a long distance
in the past economic reforms era. Now they are profitable, strong and stable with
impressive performance indices. They have become tech–savvy and competitive as well.
The winning strategies for them could be clear customer segmentation and product offering
focus on cost efficiencies and entrepreneurial ability to face stiff competition. Perhaps
banks should not charge high interest rates but manage cost and builds up quality credit.
51
In its recent policy statement it explains that it is committed to maintain adequate
liquidity in the market with the preference for soft interest rates.
The Loans are important functions that are providing as fund based Loans and non-
fund based Loans. In last years before the globalization the only traditional Institutions
providing finance.
In providing Loans the Credit Appraisal System playing very important role.
Recently RBI interrelated the interest rates on Loans and Deposits. Even today all banks
Increase rate on Deposits when they increase the interest rate on loans. There is perfect
correlation between interest’s rates on loans and interest rates on Deposits.
Construction of house needs large amount of investment, it is always difficult
on the part of person to invest surcharge amount out of his small saving. Hence, need of
housing arises people to take loan, purchase or construct their & own house stay their &
can repay the housing loan within the period of 15 to 20 years &can have their own house
in this way there is always demand for all the people whether rich or poor person hence,
house can develop by the supply of housing loan to the community, country can develop
their proper accommodates provided to each & every person.
The project study helped me to get the practical exposure to the banking world. It
also gave an opportunity & experience to collect data, analyze it and interpret it, which
helped to develop my analytical skills. It helped me to gain knowledge about the loan
facilities of the bank. This knowledge will be helpful to me for my career or even in other
way. The project will help the bank to analyze its performance and to make necessary
improvements.
52
DATA ANALYSIS AND
INTERPRETATION
53
CASE STUDY
Case study 1
Applicant Co-applicant
Date of birth 15/6/1976 3/05/1976
Membership No. Applied Applied
PAN No. A0mpp6087B Afzpp6527k
Residential status Ownership Ownership
Area sq ft. 1250 1250
Address NaviSangavi NaviSangavi
Name and address of Navami Enterprises, Sadguru oil depo.
organization NaviSangavi NaviSangavi
Gross Salary P.M 80,000 20000
Net Salary P.M 75,000 19000
Auto loan: 1000 p/m Nil
Other deductions 500 p/m 200p/m
Qualification B.E B.Com
No. of dependents 2
Age at the time of 39 Years 39 Years
application
54
Purchase of flat (Total Amt): 50 lakh
Advance paid: 30.5 lakh
Amtapplied: 10 lakh
Balance in account : 10,000
Deficit : Nil
Interpretation:
Criterion Eligibility
Residential Indian YES NO
:Salaried
Minimum salary: 8000 p/m
Minimum age: 21 years
Minimum qualification:
SSC
Minimum number of years
in total employment: 1
Year
Number of dependents not
to exceed 5
Property should not be in
negative area, E.g. Red
zone area, agricultural
Non-Negative profile
category
CIBIL Rating(above 750)
Documentation of
property(Positive)
Calculation of EMI:
EMI p/m: Rs. 14,347.09
Debt to income ratio: Monthly debt payments (14,347.09 + 1000+ 500) = 15847.09
Gross monthly income: 80,000
Therefore: Debt to income ratio is 19.8%
Case study 2
Applicant Co-applicant
Date of birth 14/2/1978 08/02/1979
Membership No. Applied Applied
PAN No. Apnqq7198D Agyqq7618L
Residential status Ownership Ownership
Area sq ft. 800 800
Address Pimple Gurav, Dapodi Pimple Gurav, Dapodi
Name and address of S.P Auto Parts, Bhosri B.R GholapVidylaya,
organization Pimple Gurav
Gross Salary P.M 75000 25,000
Net Salary P.M 68000 24000
Other Deductions 1500 p/m 500 p/m
Qualification B.E B.A.Ed.
No. of dependents 1
Age at the time of 37 Years 36 Years
application
56
Advance paid : 20 lakh
Amt applied : 20 lakh
Balance in account : 20,000
Deficit : Nil
Interpretation
Criterion Eligibility
Residential Indian YES NO
:Salaried
Minimum salary: 8000 p/m
Minimum age: 21 years
Minimum qualification:
SSC
Minimum number of years
in total employment: 1
Year
Number of dependents not
to exceed 5
Property should not be in
negative area, E.g. Red
zone area, agricultural
Non-Negative profile
category
CIBIL Rating(above 750)
Documentation of
property(Positive)
Calculation of EMI:
EMI p/m: Rs. 22021
57
Tenure Requested is 20 Years; In this case applicant’s age is 37 years, so the
requested tenure is granted.
Case study 3
Applicant Co-applicant
Date of birth 06/3/1978 9/05/1980
Membership No. Applied Applied
PAN No. Apnqq7198C Afzqq7418l
Residential status Ownership Ownership
Area sq ft. 1200 1200
Address Kalewadi Kalewadi
Name and address of Honey Well software Systech Solutions
organization solutions
Gross Salary P.M 58000 35000
Net Salary P.M 48000 33000
Other Deductions 800 300
Qualification B.Com, M.B.A B.C.S
No. of dependents 2
Age at the time of 37 Years 35 Years
application
Interpretation:
Criterion Eligibility
Residential Indian YES NO
:Salaried
Minimum salary: 8000 p/m
Minimum age: 21 years
Minimum qualification:
SSC
Minimum number of years
in total employment: 1
Year
Number of dependents not
to exceed 5
Property should not be in
negative area, E.g. Red
zone area, agricultural
Non-Negative profile
category
CIBIL Rating(above 750)
Documentation of
property(Positive)
Calculation of EMI:
EMI p/m: Rs. 15761
59
Tenure Requested is 10 Years; In this case applicant’s age is 37 years, so the
requested tenure is granted.
Case study 4
Interpretation:
Criterion Eligibility
Residential Indian YES NO
:Salaried
Minimum salary: 8000 p/m
Minimum age: 21 years
Minimum qualification:
SSC
Minimum number of years
in total employment: 1
Year
Number of dependents not
to exceed 5
Property should not be in
negative area, E.g. Red
zone area, agricultural
Non-Negative profile
category
CIBIL Rating(above 750)
Documentation of
property(Positive)
Calculation of EMI:
EMI p/m: Rs. 21603.
61
Tenure Requested is 15 Years; In this case applicant’s age is 33 years, so the
requested tenure is granted.
FINDINGS
62
Findings:
1. Credit appraisal is done to check the commercial, financial and technical viability
of the project proposed and its funding pattern and further checks the primary or
collateral security cover available for the recovery of such funds.
2. Credit is core activity of bank and important source of their earnings which go to
pay interest to depositors, salaries to the employees and dividend to shareholders.
4. It has been found that the key issues in disbursement of loan process are truly hard.
8. The rate of interest charged by the bank is comparatively higher than State Bank of
India which may become a reason for shifts in customer preference.
9. CIBIL score is one of the important aspect which is considered by all the banks
before lending loan.
63
SUGGESTIONS
64
Suggestions:
1. Investment is the major income generating source of the bank. Though the bank is
making tremendous growth in the investment, there are some problems in the credit
appraisal system. By evaluation the credit appraisal practice of the bank
recommendations have suggested for the improvement of the credit appraisal
system which is as following:
4. One proper standard procedure should be developed for all type of clients and no
interpersonal relationship should be involved approval of loan.
5. The time period taken by the bank to sanction the limits should be significantly
reduced to allow the borrower to make use of credit when the need is most felt.
6. Risk of default should be reduced by funding the right customer, by using various
tools of appraising like personal interviews, Field Investigation, document
verification etc.
7. Employee should get training so that time required for file lock in should get
reduced.
65
CONCLUSION
66
Conclusion:
2. Prerana Cooperative Bank has made a continuous growth in all the areas of
operation from the starting of its operation in 1999. Within a span of 16 years bank
has become a competitor for other banks in the banking sector.
3. Credit Appraisal plays the most significant role in funding the right and eligible
person.
4. There is heavy risk involved in funding of any property like, double funding.
5. The customers who want to access credits must meet certain conditions in terms of
purpose of loan, amount, tenure and the provision of security in order to enhance
access to loans.
6. Here in this study an assessment of the credit appraisal procedure system of the
bank was made and critically evaluated. Some problems were found such as time
consuming procedure, lack of skilled officers etc.
67
BIBLIOGRAPHY
68
Bibliography
BOOKS:
Management of Indian Financial Institutions; Shrivastava R.M & Nigam Divya, 10th
Edition 2010, Himalaya Publishing House
Financial Institutions and Markets: Bhole L.M, 5th Edition 2009, TATA McGraw Hills 7
69