4:00PM Jess and Kevin: George Appel

In Sing Sing there isn’t a chapel

For a murderer deeply to grapple
My famous last words
Are well known to nerds
The Chair baked me Gentlemen, I’m….

4:15PM Cecile & Parker: Cthulu

Name a beast you'd likely construe to

a dragon-ish person – here's a clue to:
An entity, god-ian
the great cephalopod-ian.
Did you guess it's the monster ______?

4:30PM Chloe and Michael: Jersey Devil

A creature rarely seen at ground level,
goat-headed with horns with which to revel.
With bat-like wings it moves -
clawed hands and hooves -
is the monster called the _______

4:45PM Cyndi and Mitch: Ed Gein

This butcher was odd as a teen,

He wanted to crawl into a queen,
A heart in a bag
His lampshades did sag
A true PSYCHO he was ____   

Here’s another:

A tale told at least twice on the big screen

of a man-incarnation of Halloween.
His clothing was sewn
from girls skin and bone -
the butcher of Plainfield, ___________

5:00PM Nicole and Izzy: Lobster Boy

His circus acts would make mobs deploy

In his claws they found macabre joy
He killed in a fit,
His own death was a hit,
And that’s the weird story of -----------

5:15PM Dan and Alice: Fresno Nightcrawler

California’s preeminent fright scholar

Says I am a meter or a mite taller
We bi-peds have charms:
Long legs and no arms!
They’re describing me, the -------------

5:30PM Deshja and Troy: Slenderman

I was breathed into life by a meme fan

In my suit, stalking kids is my game plan
Unnaturally tall with no face at all
I haunt dreams and they call me…

5:45PM Michelle: Ted Bundy

Women said I was charming and hunky

As I murdered throughout the whole country
In my bug I feigned ill and lured them to the kill
With a blow to the head, I’m________________

6:00PM Amanda: Eileen Wuornos

This lady burned hot like a furnace,

A monster who never would burn us, [Us being the
ladies so only a lady can read this out loud for it to
make sense]
The victims were nude,
A pistol was used,
That Damsel of Death. _____
6:15PM Heather: Mothman

We saw this white thing and we both ran

I was so scared I dropped my hot broth pan
Its wingspan? Big size!
With creepy red eyes
The town was convinced it was ….

6:45PM Kay and Packy: HH Holmes

My Chicago Hotel featured catacombs

I had bigamy and other syndromes
With my ’stache and bowler hat
I lured ladies in like that!
No landlord out-kills me, ------------