Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Enpe523 Chapter4 PDF
Enpe523 Chapter4 PDF
Enpe523 Chapter4 PDF
ENPE+523+-+Chapter+4
Chapter 4
Oil Reservoirs – Recovery Mechanisms and Material Balance Equations
There are two objectives of this chapter: 1) to discuss the various primary recovery
mechanisms and their effects on the overall performance of oil reservoirs; 2) to learn the
material balance equations and use them to predict the volumetric performance of different
oil reservoirs.
x Inefficient recovery.
Recovery of primary production and waterflooding in different reservoirs are:
Heavy oil ~ 5-10% IOIP or OOIP (Initial or original oil in place)
Medium oil ~ 15%
Light oil ~ 25 –35%
x Early water breakthrough and high water cut
x Low oil production rate
1
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
Enhanced oil recovery (EOR) is a generic term of techniques for increasing the recovery of
crude oil after waterflood. Using EOR, 30-60 %, or more, of the reservoir's original oil in
place can be recovered compared with 20-40% using primary and secondary recovery.
Mechanisms:
x Generate miscibility
x Swell the oil
2
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
Chemical Floodings
Mechanisms:
x Lowering oil-water interfacial tension
x Solubilization of oil in some micellar systems
x Emulsification of oil and water
x Wettability alternation
x Mobility enhancement
3
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
Thermal recovery
Steam drive
Cyclic steam injection (steam huff ‘n’ puff or CSS)
Steam assisted gravity drainage (SAGD)
Mechanisms:
x Viscosity reduction
x Supplying pressure to drive oil to the producing wells or gravity drainage
Water drive
Energy available from free water in the reservoir to move the hydrocarbon out of the
reservoir. Water drive reservoirs can have bottom-water drive (Figure 4.4) or edgewater drive
(Figure 4.5).
4
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
Gas drive
There are two types of gas drives:
x Solution gas drive (dissolved gas drive) Light hydrocarbon components in the oil
become gaseous when the reservoir pressure is decreased. Gas evolution and
expansion will take more pore space and push oil out of the formation through
production well (Figure 4.6).
x Gas cap drive In some reservoirs, there is a gas cap on the top of the oil layer in
equilibrium with the oil layer. When the reservoir pressure is reduced, the pressure of
the compressed gas in the gas cap expands and pushes the oil downward to
production well (Figure 4.7).
5
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
Combination drive
More than one drive can work in a reservoir at the same time, such as:
x Gas cap and bottom water
x Solution gas and bottom water
6
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
In the derivation of the general material balance equation, the changes in the oil, gas, water,
and rock volumes that occur between the start of production and any time t are considered.
The change in the rock volume is expressed as a change in the pore volume, which is simply
the negative of the change of the rock volume.
In the development of the general material balance equation, the following symbols are used:
N Initial reservoir oil, STB
Np Cumulative produced oil, STB
Boi Initial oil formation volume factor, bbl/STB
Bo Oil formation volume factor, bbl/STB
Bt Total oil formation volume factor, bbl/STB
Bgi Initial gas formation volume factor, bbl/SCF
Bg Gas formation volume factor, bbl/SCF
Bw Water formation volume factor, bbl/STB
G Initial reservoir gas, SCF
Gf Amount of free gas in the reservoir, SCF
Rsoi Initial solution gas-oil ratio, SCF/STB
Rso Solution gas-oil ratio, SCF/STB
Rp Cumulative produced gas-oil ratio at time t, SCF/STB
W Initial reservoir water, bbl
Wp Cumulative produced water, STB
We Water influx into reservoir, bbl
cw Water isothermal compressibility, psi-1
cf Formation isothermal compressibility, psi -1
'p Change in average reservoir pressure, psi
Swi Initial water saturation
Vf Initial void space, bbl
7
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
The development of the general material balance for oil reservoirs can be best understood by
defining the following terms first:
Oil
NBoi Original (initial) oil volume in place
(expressed at reservoir conditions)
(N-Np)Bo Oil volume in reservoir at time t
(expressed at reservoir conditions)
NBoi - (N-Np)Bo Change (decrease) in oil volume in reservoir at time t
(expressed at reservoir conditions)
Gas
GBgi Original (initial) free gas volume in place
(expressed at reservoir conditions)
GBgi
m Ratio of initial free gas (in gas cap) to the original
NBoi
(initial) oil in place (expressed at reservoir conditions)
Therefore
mNBoi = GBgi = Original (initial) free gas volume in place
(expressed at reservoir conditions)
ª mNBoi º
« » Original (initial) free gas in place
¬« Bgi ¼»
(expressed at standard conditions)
ª mNBoi º
« NRsoi » Original gas (both free and solution) volume in
¬« Bgi ¼»
reservoir (expressed at standard conditions)
Gp N p Rp Cumulative volume of produced gas at time t
(expressed at standard conditions)
N N Rp so Volume of solution gas remaining in oil at time t
(expressed at standard conditions)
8
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
Define:
Initial reservoir free gas volume GBgi
m (4.2)
Initial reservoir oil volume NBoi
ª mNBoi º
Free gas at time t « NRsoi » N p R p N N p Rso (in SCF)
«¬ Bgi »¼
ª mNBoi º
Re servoir free gas volume at time t « NRsoi N p R p N N p Rso » Bg
«¬ Bgi »¼
ª mNBoi º
Change in free gas volume mNBoi « NRsoi N p R p N N p Rso » Bg
«¬ Bgi »¼
(reservoir volume) (4.3)
9
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
Change in Change in
water + pore
volume volume
ª cw S wi c f º
= We W p Bw (1 m) NBoi « » 'p (4.8)
¬ 1 S wi ¼
10
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
Equating the changes in the oil and free gas volumes to the negative of the changes in the
water and rock volumes:
+ in
Change = in
Change + + in
Change Change in
oil volume + free gas = water + pore space
volume volume volume
ª mNBoi Bg º
NBoi NBo N p Bo mNBoi « » NRsoi Bg N p R p Bg NBg Rso N p Bg Rso
«¬ Bgi »¼
ªc S c f º
˙ We W p Bw (1 m) NBoi « w wi » 'p (4.9)
¬ 1 S wi ¼
Bt Bo ( Rsoi Rso ) Bg
ªc S c f º
˙W e W p Bw (1 m) NBoi « w wi » 'p (4.10)
¬ 1 S wi ¼
mNBoi ªc S cf º
N ( Bt Boi ) ( Bg Bgi ) (1 m) NBoi « w wi » 'p We
Bgi ¬ 1 S wi ¼
N p [ Bt ( R p Rsoi ) Bg ] W p Bw (4.11)
[ Bt ( R p Rsoi ) Bg ] [ Bo ( R p Rso ) Bg ]
Therefore, either term can be used in the calculation depending on the convenience of the
calculation and the availability of the corresponding data.
11
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
x The first two terms account for the expansion of any oil and/or gas zones.
x The third term accounts for the change in pore volume, which includes pore space
decrease and expansion of the connate water.
x The fourth term is the amount of water influx that has occurred into the reservoir.
The material can only be used when there is pressure and production data as well as PVT
data of the reservoir fluids. Also needed are reservoir rock properties. To aid the analysis, the
type of drive mechanism that motivates the petroleum fluids to be produced should be known.
One key assumption of the material balance method is that the pressure throughout the
reservoir is constant. That is, the pressure and fluid properties are averaged throughout the
entire reservoir.
The general material balance equation (Equation 4.11) for undersaturated oil reservoirs can
be simplified as:
ªc S cf º
N ( Bt Boi ) NBoi « w wi » 'p We N p [ Bt ( R p Rsoi ) Bg ] W p Bw (4.12)
¬ 1 S wi ¼
In equation 4.12 the effect of water and formation commpressibilities are accounted for.
Rearranging Equation 4.12 gives the equation of calculating N (initial oil in place):
N p [ Bt ( R p Rsoi ) Bg ] We W p Bw
N (4.13)
ªc S cf º
Bt Boi Boi « w wi » 'p
¬ 1 S wi ¼
12
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
Equations 4.12 and 4.13 are general material balance equation for undersaturated oil
reservoirs.
In a solution gas drive reservoir, the major drive mechanism is the expansion of the solution
gas that was originally dissolved in the oil. As shown in Figure 4.9, there are two stages of a
solution gas drive reservoir. In the first stage, the oil is undersaturated (p < pb) and there is no
gas phase in the reservoir. As fluids (oil and water) is produced from the reservoir, the
pressure falls until it reaches and decreases below the bubble point pressure of the reservoir
and some of the dissolved gas comes out of solution to form gas bubbles (gas phase). In this
stage, free gas exists in the reservoir.
A schematic of the typical production history of a solution gas drive reservoir is shown in
Figure 4.10. The reason for the slight dip in the produced GOR is because after free gas
forms, the gas saturation has to rise above the critical gas saturation to become mobile in the
reservoir. Later in the process, the produced GOR drops because most of the gas has been
produced from the reservoir.
Figure 4.10 Pressure and produced gas-oil ratio history in a solution gas drive reservoir
13
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
In this case,
x Assume that water influx is zero, We = 0
x All the gas produced at the surface originates from dissolved gas in the oil. there is:
Rso = Rsoi = Rp.
ªc S c º
N ( Bo Boi ) NBoi « w wi f » 'p N p Bo BwW p (4.14)
¬ 1 S wi ¼
Solve for N:
N p Bo BwW p
N (4.15)
ªc S c º
Bo Boi Boi « w wi f » 'p
¬ 1 S wi ¼
vo voi Bo Boi
co (4.16)
voi ( pi p ) Boi 'p
Therefore,
Bo Boi Boi co 'p (4.17)
Expansion of oil is
NBoi
N ( Bo Boi ) NBoi co 'p V f Soco 'p Soco 'p (4.18)
1 S wi
ª co S o c w S wi c f º
NBoi « » 'p N p Bo BwW p (4.19)
¬ 1 S wi ¼
co S o cw S wi c f
ce (4.20)
1 S wi
14
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
N p B o BwW p
N (4.22)
Boi ce 'p
N p Bo
N (4.23)
ce 'p Boi
Np Boi ce 'p
FR (4.24)
N Bo
In an undersaturated oil reservoir at pressures above bubble point pressure both oil expansion
and water and formation compressibilities contribute to the oil production. Neglecting the
water and formation compressibilities can introduce an error as high as 70% in the estimation
of original oil in place from the production data.
In this case, there is no initial gas cap (m = 0), and we will assume that water influx is zero
(We = 0). The gas compressibility is usually a couple orders of magnitude higher than that of
the water and rock. Once appreciable gas saturation has developed in the reservoir, the water
and formation compressibilities are negligible. The generalized material balance simplifies to
N p [ Bt ( R p Rsoi ) Bg ] W p Bw
N ,
Bt Bti
which can be written as
N p [ Bo ( R p Rso ) Bg ] W p Bw
N (4.25)
Bo Boi ( Rsoi Rso ) Bg
or
N [( Bo Boi ) ( Rsoi Rso ) Bg ] N p [ Bo ( R p Rso ) Bg ] W p Bw (4.26)
The left hand side of this equation represents the expansion of the oil and originally dissolved
gas; the right hand side represents the production of oil, gas, and water. If water production is
negligible, the recovery factor is:
15
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
This relationship reveals that high recovery factors are obtained when the producing GOR,
Rp, is as small as possible. That is, to obtain high recoveries, the production of gas should be
as low as possible or gas retained in the reservoir should be as high as possible.
For undersaturated oil reservoirs without water influx and water production, formulas for
calculating gas and oil saturations can be derived as follows:
Assume: We = 0, Wp = 0.
The liberated gas volume, GL, in the reservoir is the difference between the initial oil in the
reservoir and that remaining at time t:
NBoi
GL S gV p Sg (4.28)
1 S wi
where Sg is the gas saturation and Vpis the pore volume. The librated gas volume in the
reservoir is also given by:
GL NBoi ( N N p ) Bo (4.29)
Combining the above two equations give s the free gas saturation in the reservoir:
§ N ·B
Sg 1 ¨¨1 p ¸¸ o (1 S wi ). (4.30)
© N ¹ Boi
The oil saturation is given by the oil volume remaining at time t divided by the pore volume:
( N N p ) Bo
So (1 S wi ). (4.40)
NBoi
In a gas cap drive reservoir, the drive mechanism arises from the expansion of the gas cap
gas. Figure 4.11 presents a schematic of the gas cap expansion drive mechanism. A
schematic of the typical production history of a gas cap drive reservoir is shown in Figure
4.12.
16
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
Figure 4.12 Pressure and produced gas-oil ratio history in a gas cap drive reservoir
Because of the existence of the gas cap, the effect of the water and rock compressibilities is
small. If it is assumed that the water influx is negligible (We = 0), the general material
balance equation is simplified to:
mNBoi
N ( Bt Boi ) ( Bg Bgi ) N p [ Bt ( R p Rsoi ) Bg ] W p Bw (4.41)
Bgi
and
N p [ Bt ( R p Rsoi ) Bg ] W p Bw
N (4.42)
B Bgi
Bt Boi mBoi g
Bgi
17
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
In a natural water drive reservoir with conditions above the bubble point pressure, the drive
mechanism arises from the expansion of water in an adjacent aquifer and consequent influx
of the water into the oil reservoir. Figure 4.13 presents a schematic of the natural water drive
mechanism. A schematic of the typical production history of a natural water drive
undersaturated oil reservoir is shown in Figure 4.14.
Figure 4.14 Pressure, water cut, and produced gas-oil ratio history in a water drive reservoir
18
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
In this case, assuming no initial gas cap and pressure is above the bubble point pressure of
the reservoir, the general material balance equation is simplified as:
ªc S cf º
N ( Bo Boi ) NBoi « w wi » 'p We N p Bo W p Bw (4.43)
¬ 1 S wi ¼
Rearranging Equation 4.43 gives the equation of calculating N (initial oil in place):
N p Bo We Wp Bw
N (4.44)
ªc S cf º
Bo Boi Boi « w wi » 'p
¬ 1 S wi ¼
In many reservoirs, two or more drive mechanisms act together to produce a reservoir. In
these types of reservoirs, typically pressure maintenance by injecting gas or water or both
is done to improve the ultimate recovery from the reservoir.
With neglecting the effects from the compressibilities of water and rock, the general material
balance equation can be rearranged to give three fractions, each an index associated with one
of the primary drive mechanisms, that sum to one:
mNBti
( Bg Bgi )
N ( Bt Boi ) Bgi We W p Bw
1 (4.45)
N p [ Bo ( R p Rso ) Bg ] N p [ Bo ( R p Rso ) Bg ] N p [ Bo ( R p Rso ) Bg ]
x The first index is associated with solution gas drive and called the Depletion Drive
Index (DDI);
x The second index is associated with gas cap drive and called the Gas-cap Drive Index
(GDI);
x The third one is associated with natural water drive and called the Water Drive Index
(WDI).
If it is possible to evaluate the three indices, the relative role of each of the drive mechanisms
can be deduced. A decline in the pressure and with growing production GOR would suggest
that the dominant mechanisms are solution gas drive and gas cap drive. This result might
indicate that water injection be done to augment the natural water drive to raise recovery.
Table 4.1 summarizes the characteristics of the three drive mechanisms.
19
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
Table 4.1 Characteristics of solution gas, gas cap, and natural water drive mechanisms
Characteristic Solution gas drive Gas cap drive Natural water drive
The Havlena-Odeh method begins with the material balance equation written as:
N p [ Bt ( R p Rsoi ) Bg ] W p Bw WI GI BIg
mNBoi ªc S cf º
N ( Bt Boi ) ( Bg Bgi ) (1 m) NBoi « w wi » 'p We (4.46)
Bgi ¬ 1 S wi ¼
In Equation 4.46 the three terms WI, the cumulative water injection (in reservoir conditions),
GI, the cumulative gas injection (in standard conditions), and BIg, the formation volume
factor of the injected gas, have been added to Eq. (4.11). Havlena and Odeh defined the
following terms:
20
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
F { N p [ Bt ( R p Rsoi ) Bg ] W p Bw WI GI BIg
Eo { Bt Boi
Eg { Bg Bgi
ª c cw S wi º
E fw { « f » 'p
¬ 1 S wi ¼
G
Rp { p
Np
Where F represents the fluids cumulative production, Eo represents the expansion of the oil
and the gas originally dissolved in it, Eg describe the expansion of the gas cap gas, and Efw
captures the expansion of the connate water and rock. Using the above definitions, Equation
4.46 can be rewritten as:
NmBoi
F NEo E g N (1 m) Boi E fw We (4.47)
Bgi
Havlena and Odeh proposed a series of linear plots to determine the original oil or gas in
place from all measured pressure and production data rather than calculating them from
individual data points. The plots can be applied to volumetric (i.e.,no water influx) reservoirs
to determine OOIP and OGIP and to water drive reservoirs to determine aquifer parameters.
Towler (2002) extend these ideas to propose a series of diagnostic plots that not only can
determine OOIP and OGIP but also can diagnose a water drive early in the life of the
reservoir and determine aquifer parameters. These proposed plots are not the same as
Havlena and Odeh's but are based on some of their plots. Towler’s plots always include the
formation-water expansion term, Efw and suggest that it is safer to measure and include this
term. It is true that in some cases neglecting or underestimating formation compressibilities
eventually leads to large errors.
In undersaturated oil reservoir, pressure is above the bubble point pressure and there is no gas
cap or free gas originally in the reservoir. Therefore, m = 0. If GI = 0 and WI = 0 are
assumed, Equation 5.47 reduces to:
F NEo NBoi E fw We
where
F { N p [ Bt ( R p Rsoi ) Bg ] W p Bw
Eo { Bt Boi
21
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
ª c cw S wi º
E fw { « f » 'p
¬ 1 S wi ¼
F We
N
Eo Boi E fw Eo Boi E fw
The oil in place N can be obtained from the intercept of the plot F We .
vs.
Eo Boi E fw Eo Boi E fw
The plot is horizontal if water drive is not present. If water drive is present the plot of
F We
vs. increases with time.
Eo Boi E fw Eo Boi E fw
F We
N
Eo Eo
F
The water drive can be also diagnosed by plotting vs. t (or N p ) .
Eo
If it is known for sure that there is no water influx (We =0) in an undersaturated oil reservoir
(solution gas drive reservoir) and GI = 0 and WI = 0, Equation 5.47 reduces to:
F NEo NBoi E fw
The straight line equation is:
F N ( Eo Boi E fw )
The oil in place N can be obtained from the sloe of the plot F vs. ( Eo Boi E fw ) .
22
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
In a reservoir with no gas cap, no water influx and injection, no gas injection, and small
influence of water and rock compressibilities, this simplifies to:
F NEo
In this case, if F is plotted versus Eo, the slope will be the original oil in place. If the plot is
not linear, this is indicative that another drive mechanism is at work, for example, there
might water influx or gravity drainage. It also indicates that possibly the fluid properties used
in the calculation are in error.
In a saturated oil reservoir without water and gas injection, the following material balance
equation is obtained by substituting gas in place G NmBoi into Equation 5.47:
Bgi
F NEo GE g NBoi E fw GBgi E fw We
F We N ( Eo Boi E fw ) G ( E g Bgi E fw )
where
F { N p [ Bt ( R p Rsoi ) Bg ] W p Bw
Eo { Bt Boi
Eg { Bg Bgi
ª c cw S wi º
E fw { « f » 'p
¬ 1 S wi ¼
Two straight line (plot) equations can be obtained by rearranging material balance equation:
F We Eg Bgi E fw
N G
Eo Boi E fw Eo Boi E fw
and
F We Eo Boi E fw
GN
Eg Bgi E fw Eg Bgi E fw
The first equation implies that, if a plot of F We E g Bgi E fw is made, a straight line
vs.
Eo Boi E fw Eo Boi E fw
with slope, equal to G, and intercept, equal to N, is obtained. Hence, with this one plot, both
the oil and free gas in place can be determined; the second equation implies that, if a plot of
23
Winter 2016 Chapter 4
F We E Boi E fw
vs. o is made, a straight line with slope, equal to N, and intercept, equal
Eg Bgi E fw Eg Bgi E fw
to G, is obtained. Hence, with this one plot, both the oil and free gas in place can also be
determined.
For a saturated oil reservoir with a gas cap but no water drive, We = 0, the material balance
equation becomes:
F N ( Eo Boi E fw ) G ( E g Bgi E fw )
Two straight line (plot) equations can also be obtained by rearranging material balance
equation:
F Eg Bgi E fw
N G
Eo Boi E fw Eo Boi E fw
and
F Eo Boi E fw
GN
Eg Bgi E fw Eg Bgi E fw
If water and rock compressibilities are negligible, the two straight line equations become to:
F Eg
N G
Eo Eo
and
F Eo
GN .
Eg Eg
24
Winter 2016 Chapter 4