Slyder 1

Kara Slyder

Prof.Colvin

English Composition

16 February 2020

Analyzing Visual Text

Elton John’s 1971 model of “Your Song” and Ewan McGregor’s version have several

variations and really few similarities. Right from the beginning it shows the variations between

the 2 songs World Health Organization the “Your” is within the song. within the 1971 version,

Elton John is chatting with the gang, not an exact person. Whereas in Ewan McGregor’s 2001

version, it's part of a awfully essential scene in an exceedingly film wherever he professes his

love for a girl he’s loving with. “Your Song” is shown in 2 utterly exclusive ways that. Ewan

McGregor makes use of it as communicate within the film to help offer an evidence for the way

he’s feeling while Elton John is just singing the music as associate degree creator. McGregor has

created it into a scene regarding falling infatuated.

Elton John is associate degree all time unbelievable World Health Organization has

several distinctive hits. “Your Song” may additionally not be his initial-rate track ever but it had

been his first huge hit that created anybody fall infatuated along with his music. The track was

once meant to unfold happiness and love. It’s referred to as “Your Song” as a result of its

dedicated to anybody that has created your life higher. He’s inserting down into words however

marvelous the woman in his life is and created it into a song. 2 Ewan McGregor created it into

his own version to exhibit his love for the girl within the moving picture. The phrases area unit
 Slyder 1

Elton John’s tune however he has used it as the way to proclaim his love. The woman within the

moving picture is basically compelled to be with a person that's made. Ewan McGregor has used

this song to mention he will use his cash to induce her like this different man however he can

offer her all of his love.

In the commencing of Ewan McGregor’s model of “Your Song”, Ewan McGregor and

Nicole Kidman area unit shown in her room as he’s looking out over Paris, France. As he starts

to shout in song, she is true away drawn to him and takes notice. He looks fearful initially till he

notices the larger he sings, the additional she appearance fondly back. McGregor is that the

usage of this tune as speak in an exceedingly film that matches cleanly as the way to point out

his love.

Elton John’s message is associate degree elementary method of claiming to utterly

everybody however somebody will sense after they have love in their life. Ewan McGregor is

right away speaking to Nicole Kidman. McGregor is that the North American nation of those

lyrics in actual communicate to form us settle for as true with he's very not singing as tons as he's

simply rebuke her. Elton John is simply singing his song to the planet, there's nobody in specific.

So, the method the music is shown is certainly completely different, however the message is that

the same. because the message is to let the love of your lifestyles comprehend, she’s vital.

Elton John is shown in his song video singing and taking part in the piano to a complete

crowd which provides the concept that he's singing to everybody, not a novel person. The meant

audience of the 2 music videos area unit terribly completely different. As Ewan is speaking on to
 Slyder 1

Nicole and Elton is chatting with the planet. The target marketplace for each movie may be a

broad vary of people in general although, any gender, any age, any religion or race.

Pathos is employed in each video as they will pull people in general in with the love

within the song. somebody may be showing emotion drawn by Ewan McGregor’s model thanks

to the visible illustration of the 2 falling infatuated at some purpose of the song. girls principally

might want to visualize the video of Ewan singing to her and grow to be connected to that as

they could need any individual to feel that method regarding them.

In conclusion, Ewan McGregor took Elton John’s gorgeous tune and created it into a

awfully completely different moving picture scene. McGregor declares his love with constant

lyrics John utilized in a song. the 2 movies have a exceptional issue on the music however the

equal message of displaying “Your Love” to the individual you're keen on. The “Your” within

the tune is while not a doubt every person in Elton John’s version whereas it's a particular

character in Ewan McGregor’s version. Ewan McGregor’s model is simply associate degree up

so far method of displaying love in distinction to Elton John’s version.

 Slyder 1

Works Cited:

Elton John - Your Song( Top of the Pops 1971)." Youtube, 11 Nov.

2018, www.youtube.com/watch?v=GlPlfCy1urI. Accessed 9 Feb. 2020.

"Ewan McGregor Your Song with Lyrics from Moulin Rouge." Youtube, 26 June

2014, www.youtube.com/watch?v=jkxj-FBEH1w. Accessed 9 Feb. 2020.