Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 1

Nutrition & Dietetics 2009; 66: 195–196 DOI: 10.1111/j.1747-0080.2009.01366.

BOOK REVIEWS ndi_1366 195..••

Williams’ Basic Nutrition and Diet Although an extensive range of topics are covered in this
Therapy. 13th Edition text, there is insufficient coverage for those wishing to
explore medical nutrition therapy, public health nutrition or
Nix S. Mosby Elsevier, St Louis, Missouri, 2009, 535 sports nutrition in any depth. The clinical nutrition section
pages, $99.00, ISBN 978-0-323-05199-6 (Part 4) is specifically written for nursing students and
Williams’ Basic Nutrition and Diet Therapy is an established text appears slightly out of place within the context of the rest of
written for the US market that provides an overview of the the text. The section on community nutrition and health care
fundamental concepts in nutrition. The book was first written is a mismatch of topics that could be expanded to compre-
in 1958 by Sue Rodwell Williams and the 13th edition, hensively cover eating patterns and food use in society, and
written by registered dietitian Staci Nix, is an updated version the role of nutrition in chronic disease prevention.
of the 2005 edition. The preface describes the target audience The text is written in a conversational style, which may
as nursing or health-related professionals, and diet aides or appeal to some readers but may prove frustrating for indi-
technicians. There is a strong emphasis on the suitability of viduals after a more scientific approach. Furthermore, the
the text for nursing students with 19 of the 45 reviewers text is minimally referenced throughout, although a list of
trained as registered nurses and associated with nursing references and further readings are provided at the end of
programs. However, the text could potentially be suitable for each chapter. Each chapter has a section on clinical applica-
teaching basic nutrition concepts to undergraduate nutrition tions, critical thinking questions and basic level challenge
and dietetic students or those studying nutrition as part of questions, which are useful additions for educators and stu-
other allied health degrees, and members of the public who dents. The text is well set out and the larger size is a welcome
wish to gain a greater insight into nutrition. addition. The book is particularly visually appealing with the
The book is set out in four sections that cover basic use of colour to highlight headings, key words, stand-alone
principles of nutrition, lifecycle nutrition, community nutri- sections, photographs and figures. The inclusion of a com-
tion and health care, and clinical nutrition. Part 1 covers the panion nutritional analysis software CD (‘Nutritrac’) is a
macro- and micronutrients, digestion and metabolism, selling point of the book; however, this is based on American
energy and water balance. Nutrition through pregnancy and food composition databases and standards of reference, and
lactation, infancy and childhood, and adolescence through would not be suitable for use in Australia.
to adulthood are covered in Part 2. Part 3 focuses on cultural It is unfortunate that there are currently few introductory
and religious eating patterns, weight management and nutrition texts written from the Australian perspective that
physical fitness, food safety and nutrition labelling. Finally, offer similar resources and layout to this text. Despite the
Part 4 covers the nutrition care process, and nutrition obvious shortfalls, Williams’ Basic Nutrition and Diet Therapy
therapy for gastrointestinal disease, heart disease, diabetes, may be useful as an additional resource for educators, who
renal disease, surgery, cancer and AIDS. can provide directed readings for students.
Changes to the new edition include:
• More emphasis on disease prevention through nutrition Fiona Pelly, PhD, APD
rather than the role of nutrition in the treatment of disease Senior Lecturer Nutrition and Dietetics
• Increased focus on cultural diversity in relation to food University of the Sunshine Coast
patterns and healthcare needs Sippy Downs, Queensland, Australia
• More emphasis on health promotion and the role of
nutrition
As with many introductory nutrition texts, this book is
written specifically for the US market and therefore has a Essentials of Human Nutrition.
number of limitations for use by Australian dietitians and Third edition ndi_1367 195..••

educators. The units of measure used for energy are provided


as kilocalories, while weight and height are referred to in Mann J and Truswell AS. Oxford University
pounds and feet. Although a conversion table is provided in Press, Oxford, 2007, 599 pages, $120.00, ISBN
the appendices, converting to metric is a tedious activity for 9780199290970
the reader. The nutrient reference values are based on US This excellent textbook has been substantially revamped
standards, and there is constant reference to the American from the second edition with the inclusion of a number of
food supply, professional organisations and regulatory different authors and many chapters completely revised.
bodies throughout the text. The chapter on food habits and This book is aimed towards students studying nutrition,
cultural patterns places a strong emphasis on North and health and food science; health professionals, teachers and
South American cuisine. food scientists; as well as an informed public. As such, it

© 2009 The Authors 195


Journal compilation © 2009 Dietitians Association of Australia

You might also like