Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Issue 60 MFSB - MM
Issue 60 MFSB - MM
Issue 60 MFSB - MM
NEWS
Myanmar Financial ANALYSIS
COMPANIES
Services Brief DATA
This tier 2 capital was “subject to approval of Issuing sub debt to foreign investors is an
the Central Bank of Myanmar” and in the option, but as many local lenders point out,
immediate aftermath of the regulations, the the July 2017 regulations have caused serious
central bank did not provide any guidance on issues in the banking industry and made it less
what instruments would qualify as tier 2 attractive to international accounts.
capital.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 3
This, in turn, has implications for banks trying Local banks have also asked the central bank
to attract foreign equity investors. U Soe Thein to approve fixed asset revaluation, saying that
said that the CBM had approved foreign equity asset values are increasing, according to the
investment of up to 35% in order to help banks deputy governor.
raise capital.
But the central bank believes that asset
The IFC turned its $5m convertible loan into a revaluation will cost a lot of money and that
5% stake in Yoma Bank, but several other banks’ capital will not rise as much as they
potential investments are not going ahead. expected due to falling asset values, said U Soe
Thein.
At the same time, the local stock exchange is It could be that the central bank will not be
currently sluggish, and banks are not willing to publishing any official directives or regulations
list and sell shares to the public to raise more on revaluation.
capital, U Soe Thein said. Banks want many
multiples of their book value even though However, the regulator has a history of
many are struggling to stay profitable, he rejecting asset revaluations, and it is unclear
added. whether the central bank has actually given
final signoff to any banks in this regard.
“They can also choose private placement *of
shares+ and if it is a reasonable deal, investors Again, we are aware of several large banks
will buy,” the deputy governor said. that believe revaluation will result in a
significant increase in asset value and
We note that banks’ typical response to this is therefore capital. For some smaller banks, a
that the central bank’s approach to regulation successful revaluation will mean no room for
has made the banking sector less stable and tier 2 issuance.
therefore investment harder to attract. For a
more in-depth look at this argument see U Soe Thein, however, seemed to stress that
our 2018 Financial Services Report. banks cannot rely on asset revaluation and
should look to raise tier 2 and equity capital.
Even U Soe Thein admitted that investors
would prefer accessible bank deposits paying The deputy governor also said that many
8%-9% over preference shares with a fixed banks will have to merge if they want to
dividend above 10%. survive, a point he has made many times
before.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 4
Yoma Bank's deposits increased by 25% FMI reports Yoma Bank now has 80 home loan
between 2017-18 and 2018-19, passing Ks2trn. specialists and 80 SME specialists across its
We note that this is exactly the same branches.
percentage increase as between 2016-17 and
2017-18. The bank also offers largely digital home loan
and hire purchase loan processing, according
Over the course of the last financial year, to the parent firm.
Yoma launched a digital banking product called
SMART, which provides customers with 24/7 Yoma Bank has continued to pursue lending to
banking services without having to visit a the MFI and NBFI sector throughout 2017-
branch. There are now over 250,000 SMART 18 and introduced a new SMART Credit
customers, with around 1,000 being added Business product.
daily, according to the FMI report.
The SMART Credit product is aimed at small-
Despite strong growth the bank is not in sight scale entrepreneurs who are a part of a larger
of the three largest banks when it comes to company's value chain, and relies on an
deposits. CB Bank, the smallest of the top automated algorithmic credit scoring system
three, has deposits of over Ks4trn. developed in partnership with Experian. FMI
reports that over 6,000 SMART Credit loans
have been issued thus far.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 5
We note that AYA Bank, which had a loan book The process also includes a call for expressions
of Ks2.4bn at the end of the 2017-18 financial of interest (EOI) from potential foreign banks.
year, posted net interest revenue of Ks60bn
that same year. It remains unclear which of the eight
consulting firms submitted an RFP by the
deadline on 24 June.
Banking
Country could see 20 foreign banks by year-
end
Then in April 2019, the deputy governor said:
The Central Bank of Myanmar (CBM) plans to "We will allow…not many *new foreign banks+,
allow around seven new foreign banks to but they will be from our neighbouring
operate by the end of 2019, according to its countries that have strong economic and
deputy governor U Soe Thein. political relations with *our+ country. However,
nothing has been decided exactly.”
"There are 13 foreign banks at present and
*there+ will be around 20 at the end of this The following month, U Soe Thein announced
year, as new foreign banks will be permitted," that "an appropriate number" of new foreign
U Soe Thein said at a recent seminar held by banks would be allowed to operate in the
the Commerce Graduates' Association (CGA). country through branches or subsidiaries in
late 2020.
In late May 2019, the central bank issued
requests for proposals (RFP) to eight We note that over the last year the central
international consulting firms - including bank governors U Soe Thein and U Bo Bo Nge
Deloitte, PwC, E&Y and KPMG - to oversee a have variously said “in 2019”, “by 2020” and
foreign bank selection process. “late 2020” when referring to the date at
which new foreign banks would be allowed
into the market.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 6
The deputy governor also addressed the issue Myanmar Financial Services Monitor notes
of capital, which we have covered in a that the Myanmar Insurance Association (MIA)
separate story in this week's brief. launched a similar product called "education
life insurance" in April this year.
Insurance
GGI launches student life product Differences between the two products include
that education life insurance comes in
Grand Guardian Insurance (GGI) introduced a maturities of nine, eleven and fourteen years,
student life insurance on 1 July, according to and the minimum sum insured is Ks5m. Both
local media reports. products have the same Ks100m maximum.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 7
The fund also stated on its website that it has The shares will be issued at no less than $20
already provided over Ks15.9bn to 504 per share, significantly higher than the closing
projects in all states and regions and some mid-market price of $10.5 on 28 June.
Ks2bn remains available for potential SMEs.
However, it is unclear if RBF will empty the We note that in the six months to September
remaining balance in this fourth round. 2018, MSH reported raising just over $3m
from 153,500 new shares priced at $20 per
For the fourth round, SMEs are required to share.
implement innovative projects in the following
areas in order to be eligible for a grant:: In the 1 July announcement, the firm said the
share sale would allow MSH to scale-up and
Energy Efficiency expand operations more quickly, take
Water Use Efficiency advantage of additional investment
opportunities, and “partially satisfy market
Waste Treatment and Recycling demand” and “improve liquidity” for MSH
shares.
Occupational Safety and Health
Food Safety
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 8
The services division was newly created during Other media reports offered similar figures,
the six-month period to 30 September 2018, which give the impression that 90-100 money
following MSH’s purchase of security firm laundering cases have been investigated under
EXERA for $2.2m back in June that year. the current government, with the vast
majority relating to drugs.
Revenues in the education business more than
doubled year-on-year from $539,149 to However, Kyaw Win Thein also told BNI that:
$1.2m. “In terms of money laundering, illegal trading
of natural resources such as jade and forest
This helped reduce the group's net loss for the products ranks first and tax evasion and
six months to September 2018 to $900,000, corruption rank second and third respectively.
compared with $1.08m for the same period in
2017. Deputy Home Minister Major-General Aung
Thu, chair of the Central Committee for
Combating Money Laundering and Terrorism
Financing, also leads the Strategy Drafting
Committee.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 9
Myanmar was removed from both the FATF Some 10 local lenders have digital banking
black and grey lists in 2016. platforms, though only KBZ, CB, MAB and AGD
have wallet-based apps.
E-Money
KBZ e-wallet adds ATM function KBZ Pay, CB Pay and MAB mobile bank all offer
similar functions and are available to
KBZ Bank has enabled ATM cash-out services customers without an existing deposit account
for its KBZPay e-wallet customers, who can at those lenders.
now withdraw funds at any of the bank’s ATMs
across the country. AGD Pay, however, is not yet available for
customers who do not have either an AGD
Previously, KBZPay users were only able to bank accounts or credit card.
deposit and withdraw cash at KBZ Bank Click here to view a comparison among mobile
branches and its agents. wallets.
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 10
Insurance
Local insurers extending branch channels
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 11
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 12
"The figure does not even count the 2017-18 Between 2012 and 2017, farmers have
and 2018-19 fiscal years", said U Nyunt Shwe. defaulted on Ks125bn in seasonal loans in
Ayeyarwady Region.
Daily Eleven previously reported that total
defaulted loans between the 2012 monsoon Separately, The Myanmar Times recently
season and winter 2017 in Bago Region were reported that MADB lent Ks287.5bn monsoon
in excess of Ks56bn. MADB makes winter loan late last year, and that it has only been
loans, pre-monsoon loans and monsoon able to collect Ks199.7bn.
loans.
The same report said that only Ks49.9bn out of
Myanmar Financial Services Monitor notes Ks93.1bn in last year’s winter loans had been
that the volume of defaulted loans in recovered.
Ayeyarwady Region between 2012 and 2017
was double that of Bago Region.
*AGD has a partnership with True Money, and the agent network figure refers to the True Money
agent network
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 13
1 Innwa 9%
2 A Bank 8.7%
3 AGD 8.6%
4 SMIDB 8.5%
8 TCB 8.5%
8.25% - 8.45%
9 GTB
(dependent on amount)
10 MD Bank 8.5%
11 MAB 8.25%
12 CHIDB 8.25%
8.25%
13 Yoma
8% (from 1 July)
14 MCB 8.25%
15 CB 8.25%
16 MMB 8.25%
17 UAB 8.25%
18 MOB 8.25%
19 G Bank 8.25%
8% (Corporate)
20 Myawaddy
8.25% (Individuals)
21 AYA Bank 8%
22 KBZ 8%
23 FPB 8%
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 14
1 Myanma Insurance 39
2 GGI 23
3 IKBZ 19
4 FNI 15
5 AMI 13
6 Capital Life 7
7 Global World 6
8 Aung Thitsa Oo 3
10 EFI 1
12 CB Insurance 1
Total 130
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 15
Sale price
Date Investment Investors Sector
($m)
January 2014 Asia Beverages Group Yoma Strategic Holdings, Delta Capital 18.4 Alcohol
April 2017 Ruby Hill Microfinance Dragon Capital, Loi Hein Group N/A Financial services
May 2018 Yoma Micro Power IFC, Government of Canada, Norfund 28 Energy
Pyramid Solutions
September 2018 N/A N/A Listings/media
(MyJobs)
September 2018 FMR Research Trust Venture Partners (TVP) N/A Research firm
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 16
Sale price
Date Investment Investors Sector
($m)
October 2018 MMTutors Seed Myanmar Five-figure Education
Seed Myanmar, Yangon Capital
October 2018 Flexible Pass Six-figure Fitness
Partners, Nest Tech
January 2019 Live the Dream Trust Venture Partners N/A Career consultancy
Myanmar Institute
January 2019 Trust Venture Partners N/A Education
of Business (MIB)
February 2019 Mote Poh EME, Nest Tech Six-figure Employee benefits
LanThit Master-
March 2019 EME N/A Call centre
piece Limited
Shwe Taung
March 2019 SPC N/A Fuel retail
Energy
MM Digital
April 2019 Seed Myanmar, Theta Capital Six-figure IT solutions
Solutions
April 2019 Yoma Fleet Tokyo Century Corporation 26.6 Vehicle leasing
May 2019 Daung Capital BOD Tech Ventures, Majuven N/A Financial services
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 17
COMPANY UPDATES
A selection of recently-updated profiles from the Myanmar Financial Services Monitor.
Access is available to Premium Subscribers only.
DATA UPDATES
1700
1100
1000
9-May
21-Jun
26-Jun
10-Jun
11-Jun
12-Jun
13-Jun
14-Jun
17-Jun
18-Jun
19-Jun
20-Jun
24-Jun
25-Jun
27-Jun
28-Jun
1-Jul
2-Jul
3-Jun
4-Jun
5-Jun
6-Jun
7-Jun
21-May
24-May
29-May
10-May
13-May
14-May
15-May
16-May
17-May
20-May
22-May
23-May
27-May
28-May
30-May
31-May
13,000 8,500 FMI 00001 100 0.9 14.7 847 11,000 10,500 11,000 0
3,450 2,750 MTSH 00002 230 6.8 10.7 6,067 3,350 3,300 3,350 0
8,800 7,000 MCB 00003 200 2.5 25.5 0 7,800 7,800 7,800 0
27,000 20,000 FPB 00004 2,000 8.3 9.5 10 24,000 24,000 24,000 0
finance.frontiermyanmar.com
Myanmar Financial Services Brief, 3 July 2019 18
About Us
May Lynn
may.lynn@frontiermyanmar.com
+95 9 965 015 389
London address (Frontier MEA Ltd) Includes Weekly Brief PDF, plus full access to
online News, Company Profiles and Data
International House
24 Holborn Viaduct One year rate: $4,200
London
EC1A 2BN Rates are subject to 5% Myanmar sales tax
United Kingdom where applicable.
www.frontiermea.com
For full subscription options and pricing, please
visit our Subscribe page
finance.frontiermyanmar.com