Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Waterloo Bay Massacre
Waterloo Bay Massacre
Contents
1Background
2Recorded events
3Later accounts of a massacre
4Memorialisation
5Authenticity and interpretations
6Footnotes
7References
8Further reading
Background[edit]
Recorded events[edit]
According to official records, on 27 May 1849, stores were taken from a hut on Thomas
Cooper Horn's station and a hutkeeper and shepherd were threatened by Aboriginal
people, who left with the goods they had taken. The station owner and some of his
station hands pursued the group, and when they caught up with the fleeing party of
Aboriginal people shots were fired and spears thrown. The Aboriginal group split in two,
and Horn and his men followed one party to the Waterloo Bay cliffs, which the group
tried to climb down to make their escape. Horn and his men opened fire, and two
Aboriginal people were killed and one fatally wounded; several more were captured. [6]
The Government Resident and the police inspector from Port Lincoln both wrote
detailed accounts of the incident, neither mentioning the many casualties. One specified
that only two Aboriginal people were killed. In September, a group of Aboriginal men
were transported to Adelaide for trial. Two were convicted of Beevor's murder and were
transported back to the Elliston district, where they were hanged outside his hut. Three
were charged with the murder of Easton, but were acquitted due to lack of evidence.
Others were charged over the confrontation at the hut on Horn's station. Shortly after
this, two more Aboriginal men were arrested in Port Lincoln by the police and charged
with the murder of Hamp. Found guilty and sentenced to death, they were later released
when doubts were raised about the testimony of Aboriginal witnesses located by the
police.[6] In February 1852 another Aboriginal male was arrested as an accomplice in
Hamp's murder, but after being transported to Adelaide, he too was released for lack of
evidence. He tried to walk home to his country, and was murdered by four Aboriginal
men for trespassing.[7]
Elliston
Adelaide
On 14 August 1880, an account of the events of the late 1840s on the Eyre Peninsula,
written by the adventurer, journalist and preacher Henry John Congreve, was published
in the Adelaide Observer, a weekly newspaper, as "A Reminiscence of Port Lincoln".
The authors Robert Foster, Rick Hosking and Amanda Nettelbeck describe this as a
"fanciful and sometimes wildly inaccurate fictionalising" of what occurred. [8][9] It ascribed
four murders to one Aboriginal male, stated that Easton's infant had also been
murdered, said that many Aboriginal people were shot and survivors driven over a cliff,
and mixed up several of the recorded details. [10] In a letter to the editor, a correspondent
noted several errors in the account, and Congreve was asked to respond. He stated
that he never intended the story to have the "weight of a historical document", and that it
was written merely as "illustrative of the trials and dangers of the early settlers".
According to Foster and his co-authors, Congreve's account was "not history, but fiction
designed to illustrate", which had "exaggerated and distorted what had (probably)
happened".[11]
The next account of the 1848–49 events in the Elliston district was a short story called
"Doctor" written by the author Ellen Liston, [12] and published in the Adelaide Observer of
17 June 1882. It was based loosely on the murder of Annie Easton, although
the protagonist was pregnant and was not herself killed, but lost her baby as a result of
the attack. In Liston's story, the "hands" from surrounding stations then undertook a
"crusade against the natives".[11] Foster, Hosking and Nettelbeck note that the
Government Resident's clerk reported on 16 May 1849 that three parties of volunteers
were out looking for the Aboriginal people responsible for the Beevor and Easton
murders.[11] Liston's story was reprinted twice in 1936, the centennial year of South
Australia. In the first case, Liston's story was reprinted with the removal of three
paragraphs—one about "troublesome blacks", another about the protagonist's sense of
a "vast and terrible stillness", and the third about the "hands" conducting a "crusade
against the natives". In the second case, Liston's story was reproduced verbatim. [13]
By the turn of the century, what has been described by a Foster, Hosking and
Nettelbeck as a "well-developed local legend" was circulating about the "Elliston
incident".[13] In 1906, a travel guide, The Real West Coast: A Picture of a Rumour-
Damaged Country, was published by E. W. Parish.[14] In it, Parish related that while
travelling in the area he had heard different versions of a "tragic legend" regarding a
massacre. The key elements of this legend were that Hamp's severed head was found
in a camp oven at his hut by his 12-year-old son, John Chipp Hamp, that the Aboriginal
people responsible for the murders had been rounded up by a group of horsemen and
herded over the cliffs, and that there were many Aboriginal casualties. [15] In 1915, a
former policeman from the district who had served there well after the events described
had his recollections published in the South Australian Register newspaper. His version
included all the now-familiar aspects of the legend, including the head in the camp oven,
but also the detail that Hamp's son had been held captive by Aboriginal people for three
months before he was rescued.[16] There was no evidence given in the Supreme
Court trial of his murderers that supports the idea that Hamp was decapitated, or that
his son was present when his body was discovered or that he was abducted. [17]
In 1926, a letter to the editor of the Register asking about the origin of the name
Waterloo Bay sparked a lively exchange between a Register journalist and west coast
local Archie Beviss and others. According to Foster and his co-authors, Beviss was
relying on local hearsay about the massacre, and he is now associated with the "most
bloodthirsty versions of the legend". Beviss claimed to have been told about the
massacre by several people, including Hamp's son, as well as James Geharty, one of
the police officers involved in investigating the murders. Beviss stated that Hamp's son
was a 16-year-old shepherd at the time of his father's murder, and that he had found his
father's head, which had been cut off with a crosscut saw, in a camp oven. According to
Beviss, after the murder of Easton, Geharty urged the government to take action, and
after approval was given, a force of 160 men was raised. The force then drove about
260 Aboriginal people over the cliffs. Finally, Beviss stated that Geharty named
Waterloo Bay after the massacre. Foster, Hosking and Nettelbeck have identified
several inconsistencies in Beviss' account: Geharty did not name Waterloo Bay; Beviss
named Easton's husband as being involved in the drive against the Aboriginal people,
but James Easton went to Adelaide after his wife's murder and never returned; there is
no evidence that the government sanctioned the raising of a force; and if 160 men
participated in the drive, the authors question why no first-hand accounts of the
massacre exist.[18]
Despite its inaccuracies, the Beviss account had a strong influence on later retellings of
the story. For many years, both John Chipp Hamp and Geharty figured prominently in
stories of the massacre. According to several accounts, Hamp's son was also involved
in spreading the story of his father's death, including the episode of the head in the
camp oven, and that he was the one who discovered the body. [19] Geharty was also
mentioned by several of those telling the story but, again, there are serious questions
about the accuracy of his statements.[20] In 1932, a version was told in The Advertiser in
which a party of 200 bushmen drove a group of Aboriginal people to the cliffs, but there
was possibly only one victim. The writer claimed he had been told this by Geharty.
[21]
From 1926 onwards, most accounts of the massacre usually referred to the archival
and newspaper record and noted that there was no evidence for a massacre on the
scale of that claimed by Congreve, Beviss or John Chipp Hamp. [22] In 1936, the
historian James Dugald Somerville wrote a series of articles in the Port Lincoln
Times regarding early settler life on the Eyre Peninsula, in which he concluded that "it is
a certainty that the Waterloo Bay 'massacre', as pictured by H.J.C. [Congreve],.. A.
Beviss and others did not occur, and that the natives did not cut the head off Hamps'
body and place it in the camp oven".[23][24]
In 1937, it was suggested by the Adelaide newspaper, The Chronicle, that the gazetted
name for the bay around which Elliston is built, Waterloo Bay, [25] is a reference to the
Aborigines who "met their Waterloo" there in the 1840s. [26] The presence of adjacent
landmarks with gazetted names associated with the Duke of Wellington's defeat of
Napoleon at the Battle of Waterloo, such as Wellesley Point and Wellington Point, and
the fact that the names were not associated with those places until 13 years after the
massacre, raise questions about this interpretation. [26]
In 1969, local author Neil Thompson published a book, The Elliston Incident,[27] which
included the camp oven story and said that Geharty (spelled Gehirty in the book) was
involved in rounding up Aboriginal people and driving them over the cliffs south of
Elliston, resulting in 20 deaths.[28] For many years, Aboriginal people from the west coast
of South Australia have retold the story of a massacre at Elliston as part of their oral
history.[29]
Memorialisation[edit]
The memorial plaque at Elliston commemorating the massacre
In 1970, the Federal Council for the Advancement of Aboriginals and Torres Strait
Islanders and the South Australian Aborigines Progress Association (SAAPA) unveiled
a plan to build a cairn on the cliffs at Waterloo Bay to "commemorate a massacre of 250
Aboriginal people by white settlers in 1846". It was intended that the cairn would be part
of a national mourning campaign by Aboriginal people, timed to coincide with the
bicentenary of the landing of Captain James Cook at Botany Bay in New South Wales in
1770. John Moriarty, the deputy president of SAAPA, said that "the Elliston massacre
was part of the history of the West Coast Aboriginal population, despite strenuous
efforts by the relatives of the whites involved to discredit what is a well-known fact". [30]
The chairman of the District Council of Elliston, J. B. Cameron, said that the council
would agree to the cairn being built if it could be proved that the massacre took place.
He also said that a memorial to Aboriginal people who lost their lives in the early
development of the area might be built. Foster, Hosking and Nettelbeck note that this
offer was presumably on the condition that there would not be any reference to the
alleged massacre at Waterloo Bay. This story, published in The Advertiser, resulted in a
series of letters to the newspaper, from people with a range of differing viewpoints about
the massacre story. These included assertions of the existence of an oral history among
Aboriginal people of the west coast that a massacre did occur. [31]
In December 1971, a small granite memorial to Hamp was erected at the site of his hut,
and in the early 1970s the locations of events leading up the alleged massacre were
marked by P. J. Baillie. These included the sites of the Beevor and Easton huts, the tree
from which Beevor's murderers were hanged, and Easton's grave at Lake Hamilton.
Until 2017, no memorial to the Aboriginal people killed in the lead-up to or during the
fatal clash had been erected.[32] In May 2017 it was reported that a memorial to these
events at Waterloo Bay had been unveiled by the local council at Elliston, [33] and after
some discussion in the district over whether what happened there should be referred to
as a massacre or an incident,[34] the council agreed on including the word "massacre" on
the plaque.[35][36]
The Elliston council's work to acknowledge the massacre through the memorial was
recognised in the 2018 National Local Government Awards in the "Promoting
Indigenous Recognition" category.[37] The mayor who presided over the sometimes
rancorous process through which the memorial was established, Kym Callaghan, later
said that he was very proud that the massacre had been properly recognised, and
observed that "it's like a big dark cloud has been lifted off the town". He ascribed his
defeat in the November 2018 mayoral election to a backlash over his role with the
project.[38]
Footnotes[edit]
1. ^ Foster & Nettelbeck 2012, pp. 40–45.
2. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 5–8.
3. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 44, 46–47.
4. ^ Foster & Nettelbeck 2012, p. 85.
5. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 47–48.
6. ^ Jump up to:a b Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 48–49.
7. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, p. 50.
8. ^ Congreve 1880, p. 41.
9. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 50–51.
10. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 51–52.
11. ^ Jump up to:a b c Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, p. 53.
12. ^ Liston 1882, p. 44.
13. ^ Jump up to:a b Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, p. 54.
14. ^ Parish 1906.
15. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 54–55.
16. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, p. 55.
17. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, p. 64.
18. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 55–56.
19. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 56–59.
20. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 59–60.
21. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 60–61.
22. ^ Jump up to:a b Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, p. 66.
23. ^ Jump up to:a b Somerville 13 November 1936.
24. ^ Jump up to:a b Somerville 27 November 1936.
25. ^ "Property Location Browser (search for 'Waterloo Bay, BAY')". Government of South
Australia. Archived from the original on 7 December 2015. Retrieved 9 December2015.
26. ^ Jump up to:a b The Chronicle 1937.
27. ^ Thompson 1969.
28. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, p. 46.
29. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 69–71.
30. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 69–70.
31. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 70–71.
32. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 71–72.
33. ^ Jump up to:a b Gage 19 May 2017.
34. ^ Gage 21 July 2017.
35. ^ West Coast Sentinel 17 October 2017.
36. ^ Cave 4 December 2018.
37. ^ Barnes 18 May 2018.
38. ^ Allam & Earl 7 March 2019.
39. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 66–67.
40. ^ Jump up to:a b Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, p. 71.
41. ^ Burgoyne 2000, p. 114.
42. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 72–73.
43. ^ Foster, Hosking & Nettelbeck 2001, pp. 8–9.
References[edit]
Allam, Lorena; Earl, Carly (7 March 2019). "The Killing Times – 'It's like a big dark cloud
has lifted': the town dragged into reconciliation". Guardian Australia online. Guardian News
& Media. Retrieved 13 March 2019.
Barnes, Olivia (18 May 2018). "Elliston reconciliation monument promoting Indigenous
recognition". Port Lincoln Times Online. Port Lincoln Times. Retrieved 18 May 2018.
Burgoyne, Iris (2000). Mirning: We are the Whales : a Mirning-Kokatha Woman
Recounts Life Before and After Dispossession. Broome, Western Australia: Magabala
Books. ISBN 978-1-875641-56-7.
Cave, Damien (4 December 2018). "Were These Killings a 'Massacre'? And Who Gets
to Decide?". New York Times Online. New York Times. Retrieved 6 December 2018.
Congreve, Henry John (14 August 1880). "The Sketcher". Adelaide
Observer. XXXVII (2028). South Australia. p. 41. Retrieved 13 December 2016 – via
National Library of Australia.
Foster, Robert; Hosking, Rick; Nettelbeck, Amanda (2001). Fatal Collisions: The South
Australian Frontier and the Violence of Memory. Kent Town, South Australia: Wakefield
Press. ISBN 978-1-86254-533-5.
Foster, Robert; Nettelbeck, Amanda (2012). Out of the Silence: The History and
Memory of South Australia's Frontier Wars. Kent Town, South Australia: Wakefield
Press. ISBN 978-1-74305-039-2.
Gage, Nicola (19 May 2017). "Waterloo Bay massacre commemorated 170 years later
with memorial". ABC News Online. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 29
May 2017.
Gage, Nicola (21 July 2017). "Waterloo Bay 'massacre' debate rages as Aboriginal
community looks for 'closure'". ABC News Online. Australian Broadcasting Corporation.
Retrieved 6 October 2017.
Liston, Ellen (17 June 1882). "The Story-Teller". Adelaide Observer. XXXIX (2124).
South Australia. p. 44. Retrieved 14 December 2016 – via National Library of Australia.
"Memorial Wording Has Been Approved". West Coast Sentinel. 17 October 2017.
Retrieved 21 October 2017.
Parish, E. W (1906). The Real West Coast : A New Picture of a Rumour-Damaged
Country. Adelaide, South Australia: W.K. Thomas & Co. Retrieved 15 December 2016.
Somerville, J. D. (13 November 1936). "Early Days of Eyre Peninsula". Port Lincoln
Times. IX (483). South Australia. p. 3. Retrieved 18 December 2016 – via National Library
of Australia.
Somerville, J. D. (27 November 1936). "Early Days of Eyre Peninsula". Port Lincoln
Times. IX (485). South Australia. p. 3. Retrieved 18 December 2016 – via National Library
of Australia.
Thompson, Neil (1969). The Elliston Incident. London: Robert Hale. ISBN 978-0-7091-
0844-3.
"Was There Ever A Massacre?". The Chronicle. LXXX (4, 219). South Australia. 23
September 1937. p. 58. Retrieved 17 December 2016 – via National Library of Australia.
Further reading[edit]
Hastwell, Annie (28 May 2019). "Waterloo Bay cliffside deaths still haunt South
Australian town 170 years later". ABC News. The History Listen. For RN. Australian
Broadcasting Corporation.
show
show
Coordinates: 33°39′S 134°53′E
Categories:
Eyre Peninsula
1849 in Australia
May 1849 events
Settlers of South Australia
Aborigines in South Australia
Massacres of Indigenous Australians
Navigation menu
Not logged in
Talk
Contributions
Create account
Log in
Article
Talk
Read
Edit
View history
Search
Search Go
Main page
Contents
Featured content
Current events
Random article
Donate to Wikipedia
Wikipedia store
Interaction
Help
About Wikipedia
Community portal
Recent changes
Contact page
Tools
What links here
Related changes
Upload file
Special pages
Permanent link
Page information
Wikidata item
Cite this page
Print/export
Download as PDF
Printable version
Languages
Add links
About Wikipedia
Disclaimers
Contact Wikipedia
Developers
Statistics
Cookie statement
Mobile view