Professional Documents
Culture Documents
How Website Usability Affects: Consumers Product Choice
How Website Usability Affects: Consumers Product Choice
How Website Usability Affects: Consumers Product Choice
1 amazon.com
Case Study
Contents
1. Introduction…………………………………………………………..3
2. Literature review………………………………..………………….10
3. Research Methodology………………………………………….12
4. Research Findings………………………………………………….16
5. Conclusion…………………..………………………………………..17
6. References…………………………………………………………….20
7. Bibliography………………………………………………………….21
8. Appendix……………………………………………………………….23
Introduction
2 amazon.com
Case Study
Website Usability has everything to do with how well visitors can interact and get around
the site. The nature and complexity of websites and the ever dynamic users with no time to
waste have urged on designers, interaction designers and UX specialists to narrowly study
this subject with the view to creating a usable and intuitive interface for users.
WHY AMAZON.COM..
Amazon.com have become a trusted site for unique shopping experience and a point of call
for online shoppers. According to Jakob Nielsen, amazon.com uses associative links to create
a fun and rewarding experience for users (Overbeeke et al, 2003). As a result, you can easily
spend much more time shopping on Amazon than is dictated by the simple metrics of
buying the book you came for as quickly as possible says Nielsen. This justifies the choice of
amazon.com as the subject of this study.
The concerns of modern designers and companies using websites to sell themselves is that
of usability. But usability goes beyond just being easy to use and functional and tends to
user-experience, user empowerment and engagement that drives fun and enjoyment.
The aim of this research therefore is to understand web usability using amazom.com as a
case study with the hope that the findings will inform a better decision making and serve as
a heuristics for designers/design researchers and students working on website usability
projects.
The research questions to be considered are; How usability enhances user- experience, The
relationship between design and usability and How amazon.com uses usability tactics and
functional advantages to enhance consumers choice.
The report will start with chapter 1, on introduction to usability and web usability. The
literature review will explore theories on usability and how Amazon is structured for
usability in Chapter 2. Chapter 3 will look at the research methodology used. Chapter 4,
findings of the primary research and an analysis of the findings. Chapter 5 will draw
conclusions from the secondary and primary research findings and how the two findings
answers the research question or create the great ontological divide.
3 amazon.com
Case Study
What is Usability?
The International Organisation defined usability, ‘’as the extent to which a product can be
used by specified users to achieve specified goals with effectiveness, efficiency and
satisfaction in a specified context of use".-(ISO [9241-11]),
There may be no agreeable definition of usability due to the ontological debate of what
constitutes usability but (Nielsen, 2010) states that usability is a part of usefulness and
composed of the following framework;
1) Learnability: How easy is it for users to accomplish basic tasks the first time they
encounter the design?
2) Efficiency: Once users have learned the design, how quickly can they perform tasks
3) Memorability: When users return to the design after a period of not using it, how
easily can they re-establish proficiency?
4) Errors: How many errors do users make, how severe are these errors and how easily
can they recover from the errors?
5) Satisfaction: How pleasant is it to use the design?
This five attributes will serve as guide to Amazon’s usability due to its wide citation and use
by Usability Professionals’ Association (UPA).
4 amazon.com
Case Study
Learnability
Satisfaction Efficiency
Usability
Errors Memorability
The prevalent definition of usability has been on improving ease of use, but there is more to
usability than ease of use (overbeeke et al, 2003). Stating that user may choose to use a
product that is difficult to use because it is challenging, seductive, playful, surprising,
memorable resulting in the enjoyment of experience .This new school of thought have
called on designers and computer scientists to not only focus on the ease of use and task fit
but to understand users more and in their whole context and determine ways to better
design for experience.
This has inspired the discipline we know as Human-Computer Interaction (HCI). HCI began as
a partnership between computer scientists and cognitive psychologists (Bannon, 1997). One
of the attractions of cognitive psychology is the metaphor of ‘’Human as an information
processor’’. Bannon notes that this reduces the translation problem at least in principle,
since both the user and the system are modelled in the same framework of concepts.
Finally, users are not interested in products; they are in search of challenging experiences
notes (Djajadininrat et al, 2003).
5 amazon.com
Case Study
Functional
Emotional
Aspirational
*Functional: Means the product should work well and be easy to use
*Emotional: The emotions associated with a product should be appropriate in the context
of the associated tasks E.g; for a website like Amazon.com, people should have feelings of
trust and security since most people will store their bank details and other valuable
information.
*Aspirational: Relates to what does owning the product say about the user. E.g; If you shop
groceries over the internet, then you are up to date and would be seen as a really smart
person.
These approaches see the person as a ‘user’ and the product as a ‘tool’. Furthermore, the
concept of usability can be interpreted in terms of User-Centered design (overbeeke et al,
2002) states that people’s skills are used when interacting with products and may be
considered on three levels; Cognitive skills, perpetual motor skills and emotional skills.
Furtherance to this is that knowing, doing and feeling play a whole part in our interactions.
The works of Jordan and Overbeeke will help us to evaluate and categorise the user
according to their skills and knowledge of interacting with (Amazon.com).
6 amazon.com
Case Study
“We work to earn repeat purchases by providing easy-to-use functionality, fast and reliable
fulfillment, timely customer service, feature rich content, and a trusted transaction
environment’’.
Round (2004) notes that Amazon focuses on customer satisfaction metrics. Each site is
closely monitored with standard service availability monitoring; site availability and
download speed. Interestingly it also monitors per minute site revenue upper/lower bounds
– Round describes an alarm system like a power plant where if revenue on a site falls below
$10,000 per minute, alarms go off!
Amazon.com’s focus on customer service, satisfaction and experience may have been term
to describe their success. But lying in-between those terms are usability, user-experience
and satisfaction.
With the business of putting customer experience first and ensuring their satisfaction. They
have features that boasts on simplicity and ease of use amongst many attributes embedded
on the site.
7 amazon.com
Case Study
Courtesy: Amazon.com
Technology is a huge enabler for an internet business like Amazon.com. Key features of the
website especially on the homepage as with the other pages according to (Chaffey, 2012)
can be noted below as shown;
8 amazon.com
Case Study
Customized webpages
Editorial/Customer EG;Recommendations&
Product Information
review
Notifications
1-Click
Online
technology/Secure Wish list,Buying guides
recommendation list
payments
Amazon augments its product descriptions with information and recommendations from
both Amazon staff and customer reviews (Nielsen & Tahir, 2002).
Since Usability has attributes as (Nielsen, 1993) quoted, Amazon.com applies these
attributes especially with its features optimized for personalisation (Nielsen & Tahir, 2002).
They also note that Amazon uses color sparingly and effectively for emphasis and here,
attesting to the attribute according to Nielsen.
As an e-commerce site, simplicity and usability is crucial without making it any difficult for
users. Let us look at Amazon’s homepage and analyse the extent of its conforming to the
usability attributes.
9 amazon.com
Case Study
Os and Browser
welcome&site
Content controls
Self-promotion
Navigation
Advertising
of Interest
Identity
Filler-1%, Unused-12%
19%
26%
5%
35%
0%
2%
Fig.4: Screen Real Estate for Amazon.com (Nielsen & Tahir, 2002), Homepage usability
10 amazon.com
Case Study
Research Methodology
In trying to evaluate a site like amazon.com to determine the impact of usability on visitors
and shoppers, this research considered the fact that Amazon has been in existence for over
17 years with many changes ever since.
The approach to determining a methodology for the evaluation of the site would be to take
a reverse engineering approach since the site has already been designed.
This methodology will involve a detailed qualitative study known as ”Usability Testing”.
What is a Usability Test?
Usability test involves a systematic observation under controlled conditions to determine
how people can use the product (Jerz, 2011), also, (Sharp et al, 2007) is an approach that
emphasizes the property of being usable.ie it is the product that is being tested rather than
the user.
In this case, the researcher is trying to establish a relationship between the usability of
Amazon.com interface on the product choice of consumers.
In a usability test, the goal of the test has to be determined and it generally involves
measuring how well test subjects respond in four areas; efficiency, accuracy, recall and
emotional response.
According to (ISO, 2010) usability test has to be defined beforehand, so if the results of the
test meets the usability goals, then the system can be considered usable.
Why Usability Test?
Usability test will allow the efficiency in conducting a test on Amazon.com by merely
observing users use the website. Using a defined set of task and then assessing the user-
satisfaction during the test.
The procedure will be to sub-divide the amazon.com interface into functional genres and
then create tasks to test the attributes of each of the sub-divisions
With little time and budget, usability testing will be the most efficient qualitative approach
in this study
What to Test
Initially the users will be defined. By rephrasing the user category using the works of
(Jordan, 2003), that users associate with a product based on 3-levels; Functional, Emotional
and Aspirational;
11 amazon.com
Case Study
This categorization will enable us to understand the intentions and motivations off each
visitor as it enter the site during the test.
Next will be to start with a plan. The plan will define a set of objectives according to specific
sub-divisions of amazon.com using; Information Architecture, Interaction Design and
Identity design.
Then task will be created the users will participate in the test using random selection.
As with qualitative study, the problems of this usability test is selecting the right audience
and framing the right questions that will answer the questions.
(NB: time and number are the two main measures used in terms of time it takes typical
users to complete a task (Sharp et al, 2007).
Research Findings
At the first stage of the usability test, a total of 15 users where studied. Each user was given
a task to perform. Each user had to perform the same set of tasks. Their answer, actions was
closely monitored and recorded.
The scenario was for each user to perform (shop) on Amazon.com under normal conditions
while the objective was to record certain features of the interface. The task list would
include the following;
12 amazon.com
Case Study
7 1.7 Add yourself unto the RSS and email alert list for special offers
*If you experience any difficulty or concerns, pls notify the facilitator
*optionally click on interesting pop-ups and advertising messages
According to the overall goal of the usability test, the test will attempt to create a task that
will take the user through the various objectives as would be derived from the parameters;
Overall Goal
Specific Objectives
2 LINKS/HYPERLINKS
2.1 Are the links leading to the expected outcomes
2.2 How many clicks away to the shopping cart
2.3 How long does it take you to find an item
3 PRODUCT LISTING
Are the products listed in tune with the consumer’s mental model
How helpful were the recommendations and product suggestions
13 amazon.com
Case Study
2 WORDING
2.1 The wording are supposed to provide a guided direction to the cursor
2.2 Framing icons with words and actions, fonts (visibility)
2.3 Wordings display,(on-mouse click, on-touch)
3 ADVERTISING
3.1 How do users react to advertising, openings
3.2 Is advertising actually good and how do they help users
3.3 Target advertising msgs and understanding of the users shopping behaviour
3 COLOUR-
CODING/SCHEME
How memorable is the logo
Color-matching on pages, color-variation and inclusive design for dyslexia
users and other users with issues such as; color-blindness
4 REGISTRATION
Having an account on amazon.com
How comfortable were users while shopping and time expended
The objectives will represent the basis for creating a task list and emphasis will be built
around the needs for each of the parameters.
Analysis
Each of the 15 users performed the task successfully and the transcript of the result would
be recorded as shown below;
14 amazon.com
Case Study
Follows links Links links Links Links Links Links With difficulty
From the Table a graph would be adapted to indicate the disparity between the different
users and various approaches that the users bring to the task.
15 amazon.com
Case Study
`````
6
5
4
3
2
shoppers
1 Surfers
0 Window shoppers
Fig.8.Graph Showing the results of usability test task against the user type
• According to the graph; 80% of shoppers are used to the Amazon interface and were
able to perform the task under 3mins. Compared to 40% for surfers and 60% for
window shoppers.
• The Shoppers, made use of the links more than the surfers and Window Shoppers.
• The shoppers were composed of existing Amazon users that already know how the
site operates and can predict the outcome of clicks.
• The window shoppers, attempt to do more clicks than the rest of them
This test measured time and the effectiveness of links and the existence of error.
Conclusion
16 amazon.com
Case Study
Good design is problem-solving. The web have since shifted from “pixel-based” design to
“rule-based” design (Veen, 2001).Designers cannot just pass off a photoshop sketch to
assistants and ask them to make the page writes veen.
The audience sample which can be thought of as amazon’s hypothetical audience were able
to engage with the site on three levels; functional, emotional and aspirational at various
stages individually. The users are an attestation to usability tactics of Amazon in appealing
to their audience in the affective states and allowing the user to interact with the site and
create his or her own experiences with usability attributes such as memorability, learnability
as originally noted by (Nielsen, 2010) being inherent in shaping the users interactions.
Nowadays, everybody claims to take man not technology as the starting point in designing
product interactions but they seldom practice it.
This study restates the values and benefits of usability. It is thus a call for designers to
rethink product design from the ground up. Design is not about beauty but a smile in the
user’s heart which has been the focus of Amazon in winning the user’s heart and directing
them towards meaningful interactions, highly functional interface, with less time and can
then sell and resale to the users using personalisation and customisation.
Finally, the notion behind usability is that if an object is designed with the users psychology
in mind, it will be more efficient to use, easier to learn and more satisfying. This study have
enabled us to assess the metrics driving such in Amazon.com and being aware of the
motivations that various types of users bring to the experience.
References
17 amazon.com
Case Study
*Bannon,L.J.1997.Dwelling in the great divide: The case of HCI and CSCW. In G.C.Bowker,
star,S.L.,Turner,W. and Gasser,L(Ed),Social science, technical systems and cooperative work:
lawrence Earlbaum Associates
*Blythe,A.M.,Overbeeke,K.,Monk,F.A.,Wright,C.P.2003.Funology:from Usability to
Enjoyment ,Kluwer academic Partners, Amsterdam
*Chaffey,D.2012.amazon.com;case study.http://www.smartinsights.com/digital-marketing-
strategy/online-business-revenue-models/amazon-case-study/.jan 16,2012
*Chaffey,D.2012.Amazon.com;case study.http://www.smartinsights.com/digital-marketing-
strategy/online-business-revenue-models/amazon-case-study/.jan 16,2012
18 amazon.com
Case Study
*Norman, D. 2004.Emotional Design: Why we love (or hate) Everyday Things. Basic Books,
New York.
*Overbeeke,K,Blythe,A.M.,Monk,F.A.,Wright,C.P.2003.Funology:from Usability to
Enjoyment, Kluwer academic Partners.
*Overbeeke,K,Blythe,A.M.,Monk,F.A.,Wright,C.P.2003.Funology:from Usability to
Enjoyment, Question and Answers with Jakob Nielsen. Kluwer Academic Partners.p.103-105.
*Usability. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usability#cite_note-3
19 amazon.com
Case Study
*Veen, J. 2001.The art and science of web design. New Riders Publishing.P.104-133
*Wilson,C.2005.Usability and user experience design: the next decade. intercom jan,6-
9.www.stc.org/intercom/pdfs/2005/200501_6.pdf
Bibliography
*Arup, J. What is usability. http://blog.userdesign.com/usability.html
*Bannon,L.J.1997.Dwelling in the great divide: The case of HCI and CSCW. In G.C. Bowker,
star,S.L.,Turner, W. and Gasser, L(Ed),Social science, technical systems and cooperative
work: lawrence Earlbaum Associates
*Chaffey,D.2012.amazon.com;case study.http://www.smartinsights.com/digital-marketing-
strategy/online-business-revenue-models/amazon-case-study/.jan 16,2012
20 amazon.com
Case Study
*Norman, D. 2004.Emotional Design: Why we love (or hate) Everyday Things. Basic Books,
New York.
*Overbeeke,K,Blythe,A.M.,Monk,F.A.,Wright,C.P.2003.Funology:from Usability to
Enjoyment, Kluwer academic Partners.
*Usability. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usability#cite_note-3
*Veen, J. 2001.The art and science of web design. New Riders Publishing.
*Wilson,C.2005.Usability and user experience design: the next decade. intercom jan,6-
9.www.stc.org/intercom/pdfs/2005/200501_6.pdf
21 amazon.com
Case Study
Appendix
Courtesy:www.smartinsights.com
User Profile
22 amazon.com
Case Study
Methodology
Item Details
Testing Procedure Formal Usability testing on the Amazon.com webpage
Location Office home/kenrick library
Moderator Charles Ikem
# of Participants 15
Required Equipment Computer with acess to testing environment.
It should have the screen recorder software installed.
Observation/watching using camera and jotters/diary
Session Date(s) March 7,10,11:
Description Users will be observed while performing a list of tasks, for each of the
audience types identified.
23 amazon.com
Case Study
24 amazon.com