Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tenderness On Palpation and Occlusal Abnormalities in Temporomandibular Dysfunction
Tenderness On Palpation and Occlusal Abnormalities in Temporomandibular Dysfunction
Tenderness On Palpation and Occlusal Abnormalities in Temporomandibular Dysfunction
temporomandibular dysfunction
M. Ai, DDS, DDSc,* and S. Yamashita, DDS, DDScb
Tokyo Medical and Dental University, Faculty of Dentistry, Tokyo, Japan
P.am is a frequent complaint of patients with tem- included a case history, inspection and palpation, auscul-
poromandibular dysfunction. The pain is commonly caused tation of the TMJ sound, measurement of jaw positions and
by a dysfunctional temporomandibular joint (TMJ) and movements, radiographic assessment, a symptom provo-
muscles of the masticatory system. It is essential when cation test, and occlusal evaluations. Palpation of the TMJ
making a diagnosis to identify pain according to the sites and muscles was performed according to Krogh-Poulsen
or states of discomfort. For this reason, a systematic pal- and Olssonl and the tenderness or discomfort was re-
pation is fundamental in clinical examinations. Although corded. Occlusion was examined directly intraorally or on
some problems related to palpation, such as the examiner’s the diagnostic casts, taking into consideration the signs and
experience, the response of the patients, or the topographic symptoms, and the results were recorded in detail. A con-
impossibility of palpation have been indicated, systematic sensus diagnosis was rendered after the accumulation of
palpation’s role cannot be denied for comprehending the data, with particular attention to the contribution of
painful symptoms and rendering a diagnosis.‘, 2 Actually, occlusion as an etiologic factor. In some instances, the di-
numerous studies on temporomandibular dysfunction have agnosis was not initially recorded definitely but it was for-
confirmed that palpation is essential in assessing symp- malized during treatment to accommodate symptoms, or
toms of the dysfunction.3-10 after recovery.
TMJ and muscle tenderness on palpation and their re- In this study, tenderness was reported on palpation at
lation to occlusion were studied in this article to obtain the initial clinical examination. Although palpation was
specific clues for diagnosis. performed at 18 sites for one side, tenderness in the
following two sites was combined-lateral and dorsal sites
MATERIAL AND METHODS of TMJ, maxillary and anterior sites, middle and mandib-
Two hundred ten patients diagnosed as having temporo- ular sites of the superficial masseter muscle, and anterior
mandibular dysfunction from a population of 254 patients and mandibular sites of the medial pterygoid muscle.
complaining of various types of facial pain and mandibu- Patients with occlusion as a contributing local factor
lar disorders were invest.igated. were classified into three groups.
Forty-four men and 166 women were examined, diag- I. Abnormal intercuspal position (IP), such as decreased
nosed, and treated by one of the investigators from 1975 to vertical dimension, instability, and deviation of occlusion
1989. The mean age was 39 years and the range was from including tooth loss, attrition, or artificial crowns.
12 to 70 years. Clinical examinations were conducted and II. Abnormal tooth contact in the IP, such as premature
contact. or unbalanced tooth contacts in the IP.
aProfessor,The First Department of Prosthodontics. III. Abnormal tooth contact in eccentric positions, such
bAssistantlecturer, The First Department of Prosthodontics. as premature contact or occlusal interference in lateral jaw
10/l/35560 movements, and protrusive and retrusive movements.
20
18
16
14
12
% 10
8
6
4
2
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28
Number of involved sites
Fig. 1. Frequency of TMJ and muscle tenderness on palpation related to number of in-
volved sites (n = 210).
Table I. Distribution of patients according to The tenderness was generally unilateral. Unilateral ten-
contribution of occlusion and tenderness of TMJ and derness was most frequent in the TMJ and the deep mas-
muscles seter muscle, the ratio being 8.6, while in the lateral ptery-
Tenderness goid muscle and the anterior temporal muscle bilateral
Contribution of - tenderness was elevated but unilateral tenderness was
occlusion + Total more frequent, with the ratio being 1.1 and 1.4, respec-
tively.
+ 161 (77) 7 (3) 168 (80)
- 40 (19) 2 (1) 42 (20) Interrelationship of tenderness in each site
Total 201 (96) 9 (4) 210 (100)
The interrelationship between TMJ tenderness and
Numbers in parentheses are percentages. muscle tenderness was reviewed for all patients with tem-
poromandibular dysfunction, and it was found that TMJ
tenderness was noted in 69 (36%) of 192 patients with
RESULTS muscle tenderness, and in nine (50 % ) of 18 patients with-
Tenderness was observed in 201 of 210 patients with out muscle tenderness (Fig. 3). Thus the statistical inter-
temporomandibular dysfunction, and in 161 patients with relationship of tenderness was not positive. With 201 pa-
tenderness the contribution of occlusion was verified (Ta- tients having tenderness, the interrelationship of tender-
ble I). The patients with a contributing occlusion were se- ness in each site of palpation was calculated by the chi
lected for the occlusal group and the remaining patients square test. TMJ tenderness showed no correlation with
were classified as the nonocclusal group. tenderness of any muscles, but between various muscles
correlations were apparent (Table II). This was especially
Frequency of TMJ and muscle tenderness true of the deep masseter muscle, the anterior temporal
The frequency of TMJ and muscle tenderness on palpa- muscle, and the sternocleidomastoid muscle.
tion is illustrated by the number of involved sites in Fig. 1.
Certain patients (14 % ) had three sites of tenderness for 28 Frequency of TMJ and muscle tenderness
sites of palpation, but the average was 5.4 sites for all pa- in each occlusal group
tients, and 5.3 and 5.9 sites in occlusal and nonocclusal One hundred sixty-one patients with an occlusal contri-
group, respectively. bution were subdivided into groups I, II, or III according to
abnormal occlusal relationships, and the frequency of ten-
Frequency of tenderness according to sites derness was recorded in each group. A few differences were
of palpation observed between the three groups: the number of tender
The frequency of tenderness in each site of palpation was areas ranged from 1 to 19 in group I (with abnormal IP),
determined, with 201 patients exhibiting tenderness (Fig. while the number of tender areas ranged from 1 to 11 in
2). The most prevalent site for tenderness was the lateral group III (with abnormal tooth contact in eccentric posi-
pterygoid muscle (62%): followed by the insertion of tem- tions) (Fig. 4). There were few differences in frequency with
poral muscle and the posterior digastric muscle. limited. tender areas (1 to 10) between the three occlusal
100
90
80
70
60
% 50
40
30
20
10
0
01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14
Sites of palpation
Fig. 2. Frequency of TMJ and muscle tenderness according to each site of palpation
(n = 201). 01, TMJ; 02, deep masseter muscle; 03, superficial masseter muscle (maxillary
and anterior sites); 04, superficial masseter muscle (middle and mandibular sites); 05, an-
terior temporal muscle; 06, posterior temporal muscle; 07, insertion of temporal muscle; 08,
medial pterygoid muscle; 09, lateral pterygoid muscle; 10, posterior digastric muscle; 11,
insertion of sternocleidomastoid muscle; 12, middle of sternocleidomastoid muscle; 13,
mylohyoid muscle; 14, occipital muscle.
Unilateral or bilateral tenderness in Conversely, unilateral tenderness was lower than bilateral
occlusal group and nonocclusal group tenderness (34 % to 66%) in the nonocclusal group.
The distribution ratio of unilateral and bilateral tender-
ness was determined in each occlusal and nonocclusal DISCUSSION
group. Unilateral and bilateral tenderness displayed a Temporomandibular dysfunction is a multifactorial dis-
similar ratio of 53 % to 4’7% , and of 49 % to 51% in groups order involving physical, psychological, emotional, social,
I and II, while unilateral tenderness was higher than bilat- and local factors. Abnormalities of occlusion are included
eral tenderness (65% to 35% ) in group III (Fig. 6). in the local factor. The contribution of occlusion has long
20
18
16
14
12
%lO
0
1’1 ’ 1’3’ 1’5’ 1’7’ lb’ il ’ i3’ 2’5’ i7’
Number of involved sites
Fig. 4. Frequency of TMJ and muscle tenderness by number of involved sites according
to occlusal group (n = 161).
14 * - - - - - - t * -
13 - - * - - - - - * *
12 - * - - * - t
t - *
11 t * t t t * * t
10 - * - - * - -
09 - * * - * - t t
08 * - - - - -
07 * - - t -
06 - - - _ _
05 - * * t
04 * t
03 - t
02 -
*p < 0.05.
tp < 0.01.
01, TMJ; 02, deep masseter muscle; 03, superficial masseter muscle (maxillary and anterior sites); 04, superficial masseter muscle (middle and mandibular sites);
05, anterior temporal muscle; 06, posterior temporal muscle; 07, insertion of temporal muscle; 03, medial pterygoid muscle; 09, lateral pterygoid muscle; 10, pos-
terior digastric muscle: 11, insertion of sternocleidomastoid muscle; 12, middle of sternocleidomastoid muscle; 13, mylohyoid muscle; 14, occipital muscle.
was documented between numerous muscles. The deep 4. Muscle tenderness demonstrated various patterns in
masseter muscle, the anterior temporal muscle, and the frequency and in site depending on occlusal abnormalities,
sternocleidomastoid muscle were repeatedly identified as so an association of muscle tenderness and occlusion was
tender in various other sites. This indicated that tender- implied.
ness of these muscles seldom occurred independently, and These findings may be helpful in rendering the diagno-
was mostly associated ,with tenderness in other sites. sis of patients with temporomandibular dysfunction.
Functional relationships between the sternocleidomastoid
muscle and the superficial masseter muscle were recently REFERENCES
23. Franks AST. Masticatory muscle hyperactivity and temporomandibu- 27. Kohno S, Yoshida K, Kobayashi H. Pain in the sternocleidomastoid
lar joint dysfunction. J PROSTHET DENT 1965;15:1122-31. muscle and occlusal interferences. J Oral Rehabil 1988,15:385-92.
24. Mahan PE, Wilkinson TM, Gibbs CH, at al. Superior and inferior lat-
eral pterygoid EMG activity at basic jaw positions. J PROSTHET DENT Reprint requests to:
1983;51:710-8. DR. MINORU AI
25. Zijun L, Huiyun W, Weiya I’. A comparative electromyographic study FIRST DEPARTMENT OF PROSTHODONTICS
of the lateral pterygoid muscle and arthrography in patients with tem- FACULTY OF DENTISTRY
poromandibular joint disturbance syndrome sounds. J PROSTHET DENT TOKYO MEDICAL AND DENTAL UNIVERSITY
1989;62:229-33. l-5-45 Y’IISHIMA, BUNKYO-KIJ
26. Johnston DR, Templeton M. The feasibility of palpating the lateral TOKYO 113
pterygoid muscle. J PROSTHET DENT 1980;44:318-23. JAPAN
I
t has been reported that condylar asymmetry (the Table I. Condylar asymmetry, sex, age, and right- or
comparison of vertical condylar height between left and left-handedness in a group of patients with arthrogenous
right condyles) is greater in patients suffering from cran- origin of pain
iomandibular disorders than in asymptomatic patients.l Sex Age (yr) AI Right- or left-handed
Condylar asymmetry has been associated with the over-
loading of the articular surfaces of the joints, and it affects Male 20 14.29 Right
Female 13 33.33 Right
the soft and hard tissue component of this surface, partic-
ularly the undifferentiated mesenchymal cell layer.2 A Female 21 -18.18 Left
Female 34 -12.50 Right
schema has been suggested to account for the progression
Female 42 -3.70 Right
to osteoarthrosis in these patients.3 Hyperactivity of mas- Male 22 -18.18 Right
ticatory muscles may lead to overloading of articular sur- Male 21 -22.22 Right
faces.4 This leads to thickening of soft and hard tissues. As Female 20 25.90 Right
a result, condylar asymmetry is increased, with a concom- Female 26 -16.29 Right
itant increase in muscle hyperactivity. This process can Female 25 -23.00 Left
continue until the adaptive capacity of the surface is % Female 80 Mean 25 Mean 18.76
exhausted. This is reflected in the diminishing of the un- SD 8.124 SD 8.0689
differentiated mesenchymal cell layer. At this point, dete- AI, Asymmetry index.
rioration of the articular surface and eventual osteoarthro-
sis occur. This suggests that condylar asymmetry would
decrease in patients with an arthrogenous origin of joint the condylar asymmetry index with a radiographic exam-
problems. The objective of this study was to concentrate on ination of symptomatic patients.
METHOD
aAssistant Professor, Depart.ment of Restorative and Prosthetic
Dentistry. This study included a group of patients referred to a
10/l/35883 University clinic complaining of craniomandibular disor-