Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Worsley, Péter - Cargo Cults
Worsley, Péter - Cargo Cults
Worsley, Péter - Cargo Cults
ü. I
ARTICLE 39
Cargo Cults
By Peter M. Worsley
Reprinted with permission. Copyright @ 1959 by Scientific American, Inc. All rights reserved.
230
tlrfEf-f
Cargo Cttlts 231
work Prepilring aírfields, roads and covered rvith sores. Manarnakeri was history of "blackbirding"-the seizure of
doclis for the rnagic ships and planes extremely fond of palrn winc, ancl used istanders for rvork on t.úe p|antations of
tlt;tt tlrer, beIieved ll'ere crlmíng ft.trm to clímb a huge tree every day to tap Australia and Fiji-hacl built .,p n .es-
"Rusefel" (Roosevelt), the friendly king the |iquicl from the Í|olvers. He soon ervoír of hostílitv to Europeans. In other
of America. . Íound that sorneone was getting there areas, however, ihe a..ilri of the Wlrites
The Japtese also encountered mil- before him and removíng the liquid. was accepted, even rvelcomed, for it
lenarian visionaries during their south- Eventually he trapped the thíef, vlho meant access to brrlly becf and ciga-
ward march to Gua<.lalcanat. Indeed, one turned out to be none other than the rette-s, shirts and paraffin Iamps. rvhiskv
of the strangcst mirror military actíons of \,lorninq Star. In rcturn for his free- ancl bicvcles. It also mearrt access to thc
World War Il occurrecl in Dutch New rlom, the Star gave the old man a rva.nd knowlcclge behínd these matería| goocls.
Guinea, when Japanese forces had to that would procltrce as much fish as he for the Errropeans brorrght missions nnd
be- turned against the local papuan in- liked, a magic tree and a rnagic staff. schools as well as cargo.
habitants of the Gee|vink Bay regíon' If he drerv in tbe sand and stamped his
The Japanese had at ffrst been'rece]ved foot, the drawing would become real.
with great iov, not because their. .,Great- practícallr. the on|v teaching the na.
er East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere" prop-
Manamakeri, aged as he was, now mag- r tives rt'<.eived nlx)ut ErrroDean life
ically impregnated a yorrng rnai<lcn; the
aganda had made any great impact up- catnc front tht, rnissiorrs' wIlíclr em1llr:r-
child of this union was a nriracle-child
on the Papuans, but because the na- lvho spoke as sooÍl as he was born' But sized the central signíficance of re|igion
tives regarded them as harbingers of the the rnaíden's parents were horrified, and
in Etrropean socíety. The \{elanesians
new u'orld that was dawning, the Í|ight alreadv bclievcd that man's activities-
banishec'l her, thechild and the old man.
of the Dutch having already given the The trio sailed off in a carnoe createcl by whcther gardening, sniling canoes or
first sign. Mansren, creator of the islands \Íansren (..Thc l-ord''), as the o|d lnan bearirrg clrilclrcn_necdecl mIrgícal as.
and their peoples, would norv rcturn, trotv bccarne knorvn. On this iournev sistance. Ritual rvithottt httmlrn eíIorl
was not cnough. Btrt neíther rvas httmlln
bringing rvith him the ancestral dead. r^ \íansrctt rejtrvenated lrimse|Í lly ste[-
All this had been known, the cult leaders effort on its orvn. This outlook \vas re-
ping into a fire and flakíng off his sca|y
declared, to the crafty Dutch, who had inforcc<l bv mission tcaching.
skin, whiclr changed into valuables. He
torn out the first page of the Bible tlren sailed around Geelvink Bay, creat-
Tlre irritial crrtlrrrsiasm for Errropean
where these truths rvere inscribed. When ing islands rvherr: he stopped, and pco- rule, horvevcr, \\,as spcedily dispelled.
Mansren returned, the exísting rvorld p|íng them rvíth thc anccstors of t|re The rapid srorvth of the pl,rntation
order rvould be entirelv ove;turned. economy remove<l the bulk of the able-
pre)-ent-dav Papuans.
White men rvould trrrn black like papu- bot|ied lnen from the ví|lages. leaving
The l\{ansren nryth is plainly a crea-
irns, Papuans would become Whites; women, childrcn :rnrl okl men to carrv
tion mvth full of svmbolic ideas relating
root crops would grow in trees, and to fertilitv antl rebirthl on lts liest tlrev corrl<l. The splendiá
Comparative
coconuts and fluits would grow like evidence-especially the shedding of his vision of the erluality of all Christians
tubers. Some of t|re is|anders nó.v began begnn to secrn a piorrs deception in face
scalv skin-confirms the suspicion that
to drarv togetlrel into lirrge "torvns"; of the rcalitics of thc color bar, the rnulti-
tlre old man is, in fa<.t, thc Snake in an-
others took Biblical names such as other guise. Itsvclroarralvtic u'rite rs argrrc
plicitv of livll Christinn nrissions and
"Jericho" and "Galilee" for their villages. tlrc' operr irrcli{:ion of nrany \Vhites.
that thc snukc occrrpies such a prornirrent
Soon they ldopted nrilitary uniforrns and I.'or a long tirnc the natives accepted
part ín mythology the world over be.
began drillirrg. The Japanese, by now thc Errropcan mission as the means by
cause it st:rnds for the penis, another
highIv unpop*ut"', t,í"d. to disarm arrd uhiclr thc "curgo" w'ould eventually be
fertilitv syrnbol. This mav be so, but its
disperse the Papuans; resistancc.inc,vi- made available to tlrern. But they found
tablv develope<l. The climax of this
svrnbolic sigrrific:ince is srrrerly more that lcccptancc of (lhristianitv did not
cornplcx than this. It is the "rebirth" of
tragerlv cirme u'hen several canoe-loads lrring the cilr!{o irnv nearer. Thev grerv
the hero, rvht,tlrrr Mansren or the Snake,
of íalratic's saiIed out to attack clisillrrsiorretl. Tlre storv now bcgarr to be
Japanese that exercises such ttniversa| fascinatíon
rvarships, believing themselves to be in- 1-rut ulrorrt that it rr,:rs not tlre Whites who
over rnen's minds.
vulnerable bv virtue of the holy water rnade thc c;rlgo. lrtrt the clerrd arrcestors.
The I 9th-century missionaries thought
rvith which thev had sprink|eá them. To pcopk,cornplcteh ignolant of factorv
that the l\íirnsretl story would make the
selves. But the bullets of the prodrrction. this rnrrde good sense. White
Japanese irrtr<rdrrction of Christianitv easier. since
did not turn to water, and the atiackers rncn dirl rrot rvork; tht:y nrerely rvrote
the colr<t'pt of "rcsurrection," not to
were mrrrved dow.n by machine.gurr Íire. sccret siqrrs on scraps of pnller. for rvhich
rnt'rrtiorr that of tlrc "virgin birth" an<l
tlrev w'crc given shiploads of goods. On
the "seconrl coming," was alrearlv therc.
the other hantl. the Melanesians labored
By lÍt67' ltolr'ever, thc first cult organ. rveck aftcr rveek for pitiful wages. Plain-
pehind this incídent |av a long historv' izert arorrrrd tlre \lansren leqen<j s,ai re-
h the goods nrust l)e made for N{ela-
u A, long ago as l85i missionaries in portt'<1.
nesiilrrs somervhere, perhaps in the Land
theCeelvink Bav region had made note Though such myths rvere rvidespread of thc Dcad.'l'he Whites, who possessed
of the storv of Mansren. It is tvpical of in l\,Ít.lanesia, and mav have sparked oc. tlre seclet of the cargo, rvere intercepting
manv \íeIanesian myths that ilec.irrne casional ntovements even in the ore- ít ant| kceping it from the hanrls of the
conforrrrrlcrl rvith Christian tloctrine to White cra, tlrr:v took on a new sig;ifi- islarril<'r's. to rvhom it rvas reallv con-
íorm the ir|eolosical basis of the m<tve. cance in the late l9th cr.:nturv, once thc sirlrrcrl. lrr tlrt, \llclirng district .if N",u
ments. The lt'gend tclls horv lonq ago European powers had ffnished parceling Crrinc;r, after some 40 1,ears' r,xpcrience
there liverl an olcl mirn namcd I{irnama- out the Melanesian region anlong them- oI thc rrrissions. the rrativcs werrt irr i.r
leri ("he rvho itches"), rvhose body wirs selves. In manv coastal areas the long bodv one day *,ith a petition demtndinq
rr :Y
-tH*l
2s2 CI J L'I'I ] RA I, AN'I'I I ROI'O I'O(
130
.{r
i .,' GILBERI
'';rt/L
.:\
k*r . ..
':
"r
o[, de-
A1;ot'alvpsc, rvith its prophecies
(ilr[o secret slrotrlcl no$ llc re' oI l)itt)('r' rrntl <'llrirlistic rvritirrg' l\tanv.of
thrrt thc tlrlir lrrr<'ks on tlte .t1,,.'t',i,i,,,t,l,.,tttrtcttiott' llitrticttlrtrlv
11',1,','.1,'1i1,,'r,,tclv trtrlt
verrlt'tl to tlrern. [or tht'r'lrltl Itt'ett verv oblects' ....\Íi:;,i.,''l;
irttril('tl\'('.
rr.tst lrr' <lt'strovirrg st:ctt't ritrtrtl
p,ltl('ltt of rrnirri- tltat sIt.e ss the itnminence' of
' " ttt tllt't'xistcrrce
$0 sltotrq ls tllls l)('ll('r l,r tlrt'rn ttr tht: gaz-t:
(lonrinq' lil:e those of the
"*1,,,rittg irrrd \\'om('r), fo' *'hom for- thc Sct rrrltl
o[ rt "scctel" tllat tlte cargtl cults gerter-
ii.,r",i
',,,,,itt,a glimpst oI tllt' s:rcrecl ob- Scvcnth l)irv Atlverltists, itrc ttftrltt 'tc'
allv corrlain some ritilal in imitirtion of ,rr,'r'lt
"."n ltitv| mt'rtttl tlr(' s('verest .',..'.l .,I stirnrrllrtirrq Itrillctrlrríltti t'rrlts
thi' nrvsteriorrs Ettropc'ttr customs rvltich
rIt ts r|otllrl islentlt'rs lrr rt'alit1 ' lttttrt'l t'r'
luurottq tltt'
i,,','.,lti,'r. t'vt'tt tL':ttlr''i'lrt' lrt'lit'f
tlrrrt
ijt,' li.'l,,,t"ri,rtrs tltcrnst'lvts reuork
tirc
to lrt'tlte c'irrc to tlre rvhitt'tnatr's
"r.'lr,'i,l ll''.'.' ,r"r" thc chost'rt llcolllc is ftrrtltcr lt
ertr;tortlittarl' Po\\'er ovcr grlrlds and
tltt'ttr'
ol tlrt Bible' rlrrt'trittt's tltc rtrissiotrarics tertt
'l-ltt'lreiie.,'tt sil arottttd trlrles rvith ,,'i',1,,r,',,1 1,., 1lrrrr lt"rtliitg lllt l]ilrL' rvlrrrt tlllv tltcnl-
rnt'rt. ()l tll('PcoPlc sclc< titru Il ortt
frtr tlrl lives irlttl cttst<ttn';
ctrtrgcrri'rl irt il'
btlttlt,s rrí Í]tlrr.crs in front tlf tlrtlm, Olcl'f estarttcnt rt'scrnble their
o'*'n íi,'.l 1l'rr.tit'rrl;rrlv
irt the '.,l..,* itt ;tt'tlirs
<llt'sst'rl in Iitlrolleltn clotlrt's, rvaiting fo,r of thc Etrropeans' Sttclt lrt,lr'.'tttt'llts hirvc rlccttrrctl
livcs rather tliatt those
tlrc cargo slrip tlr air'1.llanc to rnltt'rial- rr,ltet.t' ttrissiorts trt rlrrite dií{t:r'crtt tr'1lcs
soUTH PAClFlC, scene oÍ lhe religious ed ovelnight. Then came tbe Japa-
dist urbances krtorLtn ns carlo cltlts, is shown nese. onlv to be ousted in turn largelv
in this nnp. MLtst cargo cults haue been in bv the previouslv unknown Americans.
Mclattcsia, sltozLnt ltcre as Íour re1ions Anrl arnong these Americans the lrtela-
cttck)sad irt brokot rectanglcs. Each of these rresians sarv Negroes like themselves, liv-
rr',qirrrrs is slunur itt a detnilcd map in thc inÍI livcs rrí lttxttrr,otr et1tt:rl terms rr'itlr
rvhitc C.l. s.ifhc sight ol tlrese \cgrocs
folltturittg pn1es. Also shotur on this nrap
art' thrcc outlyins cargo cults, ttLto of them seclne<l likÍ a ftrifi|lmclrt rlÍ lhe o|c|
pr'o1lhecies t() Ínitn\' cargo ctllt |e:rders.
Polytrcsian ard the third Micronesinn.
Ntlr. tttttst rl't' ltlrÍ:t't tlrt' slrct'r sc:lle <lI
Nrrlrlrt'rs rur l/rrsr nralts indicatc irrdiztidual
culls.l,cllrs rcfcr lo trypicnl t't'nlurrsof culls
tltis ittv:tsirrtl. Árrtttrtrl;l rrriIlirlrr Ll. S.
(sec ntrmbcr arrd letter keys troops 1.r;rssr'<l tlrlouglr tlrc A<lrniralty
accompanying each map). Islarrds, conrpletelv srvampirrg the in-
habitants. It u'as a rvorld of meaning-
less and chaotic changes, in which any-
thing rvns possible. New ideas were im-
ported and given local twists. Thus in
the Lovaltv lslands pcople expected thc
French Communist Partv to bring the
mi||ennium. There ís no rea| evidence,
horvever, of anv Commrrnist influence in
I MAMAIA MOVEMENT TAHITI I930.I944
7 HAU.H4J MOVEMENT NEW ZFALAND these movements, despite tlre rather hvs-
l 8ó0.I B7l terical belief nmorrg Solomon lsland
3 oNoToA TROUBTES GttBERT r5rANDS932
plrrnters that the ntme of the local
"l\tasinga Rule" movement rvas derived
from the lvord..i\í.rrxian''! In reaIity the
a MYTH OF THE RETURN OF THE DEAD llaIrle comes from a So'lomon Island
b REVIVAL OR MODITICATION OF tongue, irnd meatrs "brotherhood."
PAGANISM
Eulope:rns rvho have rvitnessed otrt'
INTROOUCTION OF CHRISTIAN
bretrks inspirecl bv the cargo ctrlts ,trc
ELEMENTS
tusuallv at a loss to understand rvhrrt ther'
rI CARGO MYTH
c BELIEF THAT NEGROES WITT
beholi. Thc islandels throw arvry their
BECOME WHITE MEN AI.ID money, break their most sacred taboos,
VICE VERSA abandon their gardens and destroy their
Í BETIEF IN A COMING MESSIAH precious livestock; they indttlge in sex-
t ATTEMPTS TO RESTORE NATIVE ual license or, alternativelv, rigidly sepa-
rate men from rvomen in huge com-
POLITICAT AND ECONOMIC
CONTROL munal establishments. Sometimes they
THREATS AND VIOLENCE AGAINST spencl days sitting gazing at the horizon
WHITE MEN for a glímpse of the |ong-arvaited ship or
i uNroN oF TRADTT|oNALTY airplane; sometimes they dance, pray
SEPARATE ANO UNTRIENDLY arrd sing in mass congÍegations' be-
GROUPS coming possessed and "speaking with
tongues.'i
ob,"í",, have not hesitated to use
such words as "madness," "mania," and
"irrationality" to characterize the cults.
But the cults reflect quite logical and
h,rve lret'rr <lominant, from Roman Cath- fetches 30 porrnds sterling per ton one rational attempts to make sense out oí
olic to Scvcnth Dav Adventist. The rea- month arrd btrt 5 porrntls ir fcs' ntontlts a social order that aPPears senseless
stlns Íor the emergence oí tlrt'se cults, of later. Witlr no notion of the rvorkings <lÍ and chaotÍc. Given the ignorance of the
corrrse, lie far deeper in the life-expe- s'orlrl-commoditv markets, the natives Melanesians about the wider Eulopeatr
rience of tlre people. see onlv the srrdden closing of planta- society, its economíc organízation and
tions, icdrrcecl wages irnd unemplov- its highlv developed technologv. their'
rf -ht, ccrrnomv of most of the islands is reactions form a consistent and un-
nrcrrt. artd are inclint:cl to attribute their
I vcrv llack.vard. \ative agliculture insccuritr' to the whirn or evil ín the na- derstandable pattern. 'fhey rvrap u1l all
pro<1,,c:e.- littlc for the rvorlc.l ma-rket, ,rnd ture of irrdividual planters. tht'ir 1'earning and hopc in an amalgam
cvcn tlre Europeirn plantations and Such shocks have not been confined that ómbinei thc be'si counsel they can
rnirtes export onlv a ferv primarv plod- to the economic order. Governments, find in Christianity and their native be-
rrcts nnrl r'nrv nratcriirls: c()prar rubber, too, have come and gone, especiallv dur' lief. If the rvorld is soon to end, garden-
qrll<l' \telanesilns :tre r1uíte unab|e to ing the trvo rvorld wars: Cerman, Dutch, ing or Íishing is unnecessarv; cverything
tun<lerstancl rvhv copra, [ol example, British and French administrations melt- wil| be provided. If the lríelanesians are
234 CULTURAL ANTHROPOLOGY
NEW GLi /Nt A l:r.s ltccrt n prolific brt't'dcr to be part of a rnrrtlt s'itlt'r ortlt'r. tltc
of cargtr cults, rcsultitr,r front tltc irnpact ttf taboos tlrat prescribe thcir social contlttct
Dutch, Cannnn, Britislt nnd Iafarrcsc rult must no\\. be lifted or broken in a ltesl-r'
on its Stottc Ápc ctt/ltlrcs. At prcscnt t|tc prescritrd rvat'.
rucstem Ttttrtittrr is lrclr/ lrv thc Nethcrlnrrds O cqlrsl tbccgo Ercr cÜr*- Tb
but claimctl lty Indonesia. TItc southcnst <ü- '.re"*p|..** trp .nrn. F tr mrm.n-
't,il
(Paltua) and northt'nst (U.N. 7'rrtst Ü["'
Ttrriton1 1rf Ntrt' Gttin'n) nrt'tot'r'nlcrí l'v Ptryr ts .I. &5! Úl ]!b
Australin. lrg!*]- lim.Fim in qF ínhdl \i'i
tn g: -5 '" ar '"{:
.FtTt Ü.üh .üild rürl- Íbd rrrt|
a MYTH oF THE REÍURN of TH5 Dt^] Í r!.|Íf, rD. A co-tB E!9'rf{ d*{tt- < q- '' ..! r< '1 " srirl ""'-
ó ntvtvlL oP l.too|llc^lioA. c$ E r--auP:s 70 a:l-l*E '. -- ri
1i9rt rri -:, br.' -' ;t l:' \'rrr( P' '\-
PAGANISM P:'. . :r'l ::cÉ.:,J:
^"\]
c |NÍPoDuc'|oil of cHl|snx{ cc..-; :r-
t ! E}.|t NÍs l THr€Ars AND vlottNcE At this p()irrt it shorrltl lre olrscrvetl tlral
d cePcc '-'"rx v.!|ÍE MEN ^GAtNsÍ f\ .u11. oí tlris r:t'rrr.r.rI kirrrl .lt'(. tI()l
? Btt'tr r- NtGeO{S wrtl
-- i L.' ].J ot TRAo|Í|oNA|.tY peculial to \tclrrrit'sil. \tt'rr rr'lro [t't'l
BtcoiA,€ wx|ÍE MeN Al\ro STPARATI ANO UNTRIENOTY
vtcE vfes^ GROUPS
t45
...WTW
-
:,
i'.j':.iiÉl , .*. t
N"
1': ::.
, ..,:.., .i... ^
NlNlGo lsLÁNDs
ADMIRALTY ISLANDS
;{.;
:\
|úANUS$ffjP1 .;rdr i;,!
q
t'hi o
5b
<\. *
BISMARCK ARCHIPELA
:r,',-Q)
ERrralN
)
'éi
'tai-',I.: \ dr
Í.i..'>)*
/.,á;t:
::','. /' .i.,
\il,alt?.',,i\i, lt
!
'i !
l
tl"r: 'i''"':,I,ir'.,l
)-*'t+.1; ?;t;' ', 11
:i:L::.:.'
"
$ -É'x *)
PORI MORE
.;,',.ilil
! Qcq;
srcj.y\y1 ', , ,"'j
: .f -:\
ot) YT. \l
A , tr
,Lr f.r
,ifllc 11.""''
:"',,i"
.:.t
:,,.1,,.
'
-..i; :
i..l
,,i5;',: '' , .;;rjr;
',, ii{'.'., ;, ...
236 CULTURAL ANTHROPOLOGY
-,{F
NEWHEBRIDES ÁND NEW CALED)NIAare, respectiqely, Anglo-French and French FUI ISLANDS are a British colony.
possessions. otrc Nau Caledonian cult placed Messíanic hopes in the Comrnuníst Partv.
Although generally Christianized, they
haoe spawtred seueral senti-Christian cargo
cults.