MAY 06 2020
Time Recorsted
[Cour ce
IN THE COURT OF INDIAN OFFENSES
FOR THE WESTERN REGION
WINNEMUCCA INDIAN COLONY
WINNEMUCCA INDIANCOLONY
Petitioner, )
} — €aseNo.;CIV-19-WRIS
vs ) C1v-19-WRI6
) CIV-19-WRI7
MYRL AYER, JAMES JAY AYER, ) CIV-19-WRI8
STORMY AYER, LINDAAYER, and) CIV-19-WRI9
any other persons known and unknown) CIV-19-WR20
)
)
)
nly,
residing with the Ayer
and
KEVIN DICK and BRIAN DICK,
and all other persons residing with or on
the premises of the Dick occupation
and any other persons known or unknown.
and
ELENA LOYA, and all persons residing
at 1149 Cinnabar St,
and
LESLIE SMART, JR., and all persons
residing with or on the premises of the
‘Smart occupation and all other persons
known or unknown,
and
DWIGHT BROWN, DOREEN BROWN,
LOUELLA BROWN, aka LOUELLA
GEORGE, aka LOUELLA STANTON,
ELDON BROWN. GILBERT GEORGE,
and all persons residing with or on the
premises of the Brown occupation and any
other persons, known or unknown, residing )
with the Brown family, except and )excluding ALVA BROWN. )
)
and )
ALL PERSONS RESIDING AT 232 )
SOUTH STREET, excepting COLEEN
MISSOURI, Lessee )
Respondents, )
ORDER AND WRIT OF MANDAMUS
NOW on this Sth day of May, 2020, this matter comes before the Court upon
Respondents’ Emergency Motion for Order of Contempt. The Petitioners have filed a response to
Respondents’ Motion and the Court is advised in the premises and therefore FINDS and
ORDERS as follows
PROCEDURALAND FACTUAL HISTORY
The cases at present were initiated in June, 2019 by the Winnemucca In
in Colony in an
attempt to evict Respondents from property in which they resided or claimed as residence. On
June 10, 2019 specific Petitioners sought injunctive relief to prohibit Respondent Winnemucca
Indian Colony Council, and any agents acting on their behalf, from forcibly removing
Petitioners. The Court granted the request for temporary injunction and has not since vacated that
order, On June 14, 2019, the Court issued a Notice and Order for specifically named
Respondents to vacate the residences pending further proceedings on October 24, 2019.
Prior to the October 24, 2019 hearing, the Respondents filed numerous affirmative
defenses which included but are not limited to, lack of authority of the Winnemucca Indian
Colony to exercise jurisdiction over the Colony; due process under which individuals who have
purchased their property are entitled to compensation; and the need to determine what agency
has authority to exercise regulatory control of the property. On October 10, 2019, this Court
issued an Order of Stay pending a trial on the merits of the case.
On December 31, 2019, this Court denied Winnemucca Indian Colony Council’s request!
demand to transfer the proceedings to what they referred to as their own tribal court
On April 2, 2020, this Court issued a second injunction against the Winnemucca Indian
Colony Tribal Council, Robert McNichols, and any other agents or representatives acting inconcert with the Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council and/or Robert McNichols from
entering the properties specifically located at 1149 Cinnabar Street; 1141 Cinnabar Street; 1137
Cinnabar Street, 1136 Cinnabar Street, and 1136 1/2 Cinnabar Street; all located within the
exterior boundaries of the Winnemucca Indian Colony. The order specifically prohibited the
Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council, Robert McNichols, and any agents acting on their
behalf from interfering with the residents’ use and and enjoyment of their properties and
dwellings, including but not limited to: restrained from removing, taking, destroying, damaging,
or otherwise touching any personal or real property or fixtures at said properties; and are
restrained from releasing any animals or pets at said properties, and are restrained from harassing
the residents or otherwise disturbing the peace. The Order further demanded the J-Rails be
removed from West Bell Street and West South Street until further order of the Court.
Additionally, the Order prohibited the Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council, or its agents
or representatives, from destroying or otherwise disposing of property which has been moved,
retrieved or otherwise relocated. This Order was initially set to expire on April 23, 2020;
however, the Court extended the injunction until June 25, 2020. This Order remains in full force
and effect
The Respondents have now filed an Emergency Motion for Order of Contempt alleging
the Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council, by and through its Chair, Judy Rojo, and its
agents have violated the injunction,
The Petitioner, Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council, has responded to the
Emergency Motion and denies evicting anyone but does not deny removing abandoned property
or other property. Further, the Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council states it will be
removing “abandoned trailers, an old shed with an open and untreated sewage pit beneath it and
other abandoned vehicles with no license and no claimants.”
DECISION
Having reviewed the pleadings in this matter and being fully advised in the premises, the
Court FINDS and ORDERS:The Court has been nothing less than abundantly clear about its injunctive orders. On
April 2, 2020, the order specifically prohibited the Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council,
Robert McNichols, and any agents acting on their behalf from interfering with the residents’ use
and and enjoyment of their properties and dwellings, including but not limited to: restrained from
removing, taking, destroying, damaging, or otherwise touching any personal or real property or
fixtures at said properties; restrained from releasing any animals or pets at said properties, and
restrained from harassing the residents or otherwise disturbing the peace. The Order farther
demanded the J-Rails be removed from West Bell Street and West South Street until further order
of the Court, Additionally, the Order prohibited the Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council,
or its agents or representatives, from destroying or otherwise disposing of property which had
been moved, retrieved or otherwise relocated
The Court has been advised by the Bureau of Indian Affairs Law Enforcement that the
Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council and their agent or representative, Robert McNichols,
have not removed the J-Rail blockades from West Bell Street and West South Street as was
ordered on April 2, 2020. Further, in their responsive pleading and declaration filed this date,
legal counsel for the Tribal Council admits to having “demolished” the property of Dwight
Brown on May 4, 2020. Regardless of whether the demolition was done in concert with, or by
consent of the resident, the action is a violation of this Court’s April 2, 2020 injunction which
specifically prohibited destruction of any property. Additionally, the Tribal Council’s responsive
pleading also provides an admission of destroying property that had previously been removed in
spite of this Court's injunction prohibiting same.
To be clear, the Court is aware of, and certainly understands the desire of the
Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council to make the Colony property environmentally safe
The Court is also aware of the fact that the Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council applied
for, and received funding from the Environmental Protection Agency prior to their efforts to evict
residents, and that the parameters of the funding require it to be spent timely. However, prior to
the national pandemic of COVID-19, this Court set this matter for trial to determine the
ownership status of the Colony lands, the rights of the residents occupying assignments on the
Colony, and the rights of the Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council to regulate the landbase. Each of these issues remain outstanding as no trial has been held due to the ongoing
national pandemic. This Court understands the desires of the Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal
Council to move expeditiously; however, to be clear, this Court will not be tolerant of any
individuals or entities, including the Tribal Council, ignoring its orders
Based upon the foregoing, this Court makes the following specific FINDINGS.
1. That is in the interest of the health and welfare of the Colony residents that the
Winnemucca Tribal Council is acting to clean-up hazardous waste.
2. That the Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council has admitted to destroying
property since the issuance of this Court’s injunction of April 2, 2020.
3. That the Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council was awarded funding to assist in
the clean-up of hazardous waste and that said funds must be spent timely.
4. That the Colony residents are entitled to due process protections under the U.S.
Constitution and/or the Indian Civil Rights Act of 1968 to be secure in their property.
5. That the Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council and its agent or representative,
Robert McNichols, have failed to adhere to the Court’s order to remove the J-Rail blockades.
As a result of the Winnemucca Indian Colony Tribal Council’s actions since the issuance
of this Court’s injunction on April 2, 2020, this Court ORDERS as follows:
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that the Winnemucca
Indian Colony Tribal Council and their representative, Robert McNichols, are to remove the J-
Rail blockades by 12:00 (PST) on May 6, 2020 or both the Tribal Council and Robert McNichols
will be civilly fined in the amount of $500.00 per day each
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that the Winnemucca
Indian Colony Tribal Council and their representatives and agents are hereby ORDERED to
cease and desist ALL operations pertaining to the environmental clean-up, including removal,
relocation, and/or destruction of property on the Winnemucca Indian Colony until further order
of this Court
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that the Winnemucca
Indian Colony Tribal Council wall not be allowed to proceed with their operations to clean-up the
Winnemucca Indian Colony until such time as they submit a written plan of action to include allProperties and planned activities for the clean-up to this Court for approval. This Court will
entertain such plan on a weekly basis. The plan should detail the property, the concems of the
Council, the plan for remediation and a specific time-table. The Court will then determine
whether the Tribal Council and its representatives will be permitted to move forward on a plan
by plan basis. This Court expects to have the first plan of action no later than close of business
on Wednesday, May 6, 2020 and at the same time each week until such time as the
environmental clean-up is completed.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that should the
Winnemucca Indian Colony ‘Tribal Council fail to adhere to this Order, this Court will entertain a
‘motion/request to consider whether the members of the Tribal Council are exceeding their scope
of authority at times when they fail to adhere to a properly issued and continuous Court order,
and may find each member as well as Robert MeNichols personally liable for any damages
incurred as a result of the defiance of this Cour’s order.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
ws
MARSHA HAI
N, CHIEF MAGISTRA’