Consolidation (By DR Manal) PDF

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 67

Soil Consolidation

Theoretical Soil Mechanics

Fall 2010

1
Introduction
‡ Settlement components:
δT = δ i + δc + δs
where:
δT = total settlement
δi = immediate settlement
δc = consolidation settlement
δs = secondary consolidation settlement (creep)

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

2
Introduction
P
‡ Loading Diagram

Construction period Time


Time
‡ Cohesionless soil
δi
δT ~ δi

S
Time
‡ Cohesive soil δi
δT = δi + δc + δs δc

S
?
δs
Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

3
Fundamentals of Consolidation
‡ Spring-cylinder analogy
Stress = p
Stress = p
Stress = p

Δu = 0 Δu = p Δu < p Δu =0

„ Added stress (p) = Total stress (σ)


„ Spring load = Effective stress (σ’)
„ Water pressure = excess pore-water pressure (Δu)
„ Valve opening = hydraulic conductivity (k)

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

4
Application on Soil
‰ Stress distribution before application of load

GWT GS

Sand

Clay

Gravel

σt u σ'

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

5
Application on Soil
‰ Immediately after application of q (t = 0)

q
GWT GS

Sand
q

Clay q

Gravel q
q
σt u σ'

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

6
Application on Soil
‰ Long time after application of q (t = h)

q
GWT GS

Sand
q

Clay

Gravel q
q
σt u σ'

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

7
Application on Soil
‰ Total stress: σ t = Σγh + q
‰ Pore water pressure:
ƒt=0 Î u = γ wh w + q (clay)
Î u = γ wh w (sand)

ƒt=h Î u = γ wh w (clay)
Î u = γ wh w (sand)
At time t ???
‰ Effective stress:
ƒt=0 Î σ'= Σγ'h (clay)
Î σ' = Σγ'h + q (sand)

ƒt=h Î σ' = Σγ'h + q (clay)


Î σ' = Σγ'h + q (sand)

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

8
Rate of Consolidation

q
GWT GS

Sand
q

Clay q

Gravel q
q
σt u σ'

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

9
Rate of Consolidation
u σ'

t=0 t=0
t = t1 t = t1

Clay t = t2 t = t2

t = t3 t = t3

t=∞ t=∞

q q

Degree of Consolidation (U):


Δσ '
U=
q

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

10
Compressibility Parameters
Coefficient of compressibility (av):
is the rate of change of void ratio (Δe) with respect to the applied
effective pressure (Δσ’) during compression.

From consolidation test,


get e-σ’ curve e e-σ’ curve

Δe eo
av = e1 Δe
Δσ ' Δσ '

σ’o σ’1
σ’

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

11
Compressibility Parameters
Coefficient of volume compressibility (mv):
is the volume decrease of a unit volume of soil per unit increase
of effective pressure during compression.

ΔV ΔeVs
V (1 + e o )Vs 1 Δe av
mv = o = = =
Δσ ' Δσ ' (1 + e o ) Δσ ' (1 + e o )

eoVs

Initial Condition Final Condition

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

12
Preconsolidation Pressure
Preconsolidation pressure (pc):

is the largest effective pressure that has been applied on the soil
in its geological history.

From consolidation test, get e-log(σ’) curve

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

13
Determination of Preconsolidation Pressure
e-log(σ’) curve
5
a b
3
1
4
2

pc
σ’ (kg/cm2)

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

14
Determination of Preconsolidation Pressure
1. Determine point of maximum curvature (a).

2. At (a), draw tangent to e-log(σ’) curve.

3. At (a), draw horizontal line.

4. Draw a bisector to the angle enclosed between the


tangent and horizontal lines.

5. Extend the linear portion of the curve until it intersects


the bisector at point (b).

6. The preconsolidation pressure (pc) is the x-coordinate


of the point (b).

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

15
Types of clays w.r.t. preconsolidation
1. Normally consolidated clay:
Clay that has never been loaded in the past by more than the
existing effective overburden pressure (σo’) pc ~ σo’
2. Overconsolidated (preconsolidated) clay:
Clay that has been loaded in the past by more than the existing
effective overburden pressure (σo’) pc > σo’
Causes: pre-existing structures, erosion of overburden

3. Underconsolidated clay:
Clay that has been loaded partially by the existing effective
overburden pressure (σo’) pc < σo’

Define: Overconsolidation Ratio (OCR):


pc
OCR =
σo'
Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

16
Compressibility Parameters
e-log(σ’) curve
Recompression curve
Cr

Virgin compression
curve

Cc

Swelling curve

Preconsolidation pressure
pc

σ’ (kg/cm2)

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

17
Compressibility Parameters
‡ Compression Index: Cc
Δe
Cc = Slope of virgin compression curve
Δ log(σ ' )
Cc
Ccε =
(1 + eo )

‡ Recompression Index: Cr
Δe
Cr = Slope of recompression curve
Δ log(σ ' )
Cr
Crε =
(1 + eo )

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

18
Compressibility Parameters
‡ Coefficient of consolidation: cv

Tv H d2
cv =
t
where:

Tv = time factor = f(U)

t = time at degree of consolidation U

Hd = drainage path

‡ Coefficient of permeability: k

k = cv mvγ w

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

19
Consolidation Settlement (δc)
‡ Calculate settlement (δc) of clay layer of thickness (H) due to
added stress (Δσ’):
Δe
δc = H
1 + eo
‡ For normally consolidated clay:

Δσ’
Cc
'
σ eo
δc = f
H log( )
1 + eo oσ
'

e Cc
e1

p c ~ σo ’ σ f’
σ’ (kg/cm2)

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

20
Consolidation Settlement (δc)
‡ For overconsolidated clay, (σo’ and σf’) < pc:

eo Cr
e1

e
Δσ’

C σ '

δ c = r H log( f' )
1 + eo σo
σo ’ σ f’ pc
σ’ (kg/cm2)

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

21
Consolidation Settlement (δc)
‡ For overconsolidated clay, σo’ < pc and and σf’ > pc

eo Cr

Cc

e
e1

Δσ’

σo ’ pc σ f’
σ’(kg/cm2)
Cr p C σ 'f
δc = H log( c' ) + c H log( )
1 + eo σ o 1 + eo pc

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

22
Consolidation Settlement (δc)
‡ In settlement calculations, we calculate Δσ’ at
centerline of clay layer of thickness (H), and assume
they represent the average stress within the layer. This
is OK for thin layers.
q

∆σ’
H Clay

‡ For thick layers, divide the clay layer into sub-layers,


each of thickness (Hi). Then: δc = Σ δci

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

23
Secondary Consolidation Settlement (δs)
t100

U = 100%
Δh
Δlog(t)

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

24
Secondary Consolidation Settlement (δs)
‡ Secondary compression index (Cα):
Δe
Cα =
Δ log(t )
where:
Δh
Δe = (1 + eo )
H
‡ Secondary consolidation settlement (δs):
Cα t
δs = H100 log( )
1 + e100 t100
where:
e100 = void ratio at U = 100%
H100 = thickness of clay layer at U = 100%
t100 = time to U=100%
t > t100

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

25
Secondary Consolidation
‡ Lumps all compression that follows completion of primary
consolidation

‡ Decrease in void ratio with time at constant effective stress


(creep)

‡ Slow drainage of water

‡ Typical Cα/Cc ratios:


„ Granular soil 0.02 + 0.01
„ Inorganic clays and silts 0.04 + 0.01
„ Organic clays and silts 0.05 + 0.01

‡ Since primary consolidation is completed first in parts of soil


near drainage boundaries, therefore, secondary consolidation
will start before primary consolidation is completed everywhere
in soil layer/sample
Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

26
Secondary Consolidation
‡ Secondary consolidation results from different mechanisms
among which:

1. Soils may have voids of widely different sizes. In some soils,


water/excess pore-water pressure drain from larger voids during
primary consolidation, and slowly squeezes out of smaller voids with
time secondary consolidation

2. In organic soils, water may drain out of voids in accordance with


primary consolidation, then water drains slowly out of organic
matter secondary consolidation

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

27
Secondary Consolidation
‡ Secondary consolidation results from different mechanisms
among which:

3. Clays of high plasticity are surrounded with more adsorbed water on


clay particles’ surfaces by local electrical effects (electric double
layer). As particles are pressed more closely during primary
consolidation, viscous resistance to volume change increases, which
slows down the drainage of pore-water secondary consolidation

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

28
Terzaghi’s 1-D theory of consolidation
‡ Assumptions:
1. Soil is saturated
2. Solids and water are incompressible
3. Soil compression and water flow are 1-D
4. e-σ’ relationship is linear (av = Δe/Δσ’ = constant)
5. Darcy’s law is valid (v=ki=kΔh/l)
6. Soil is homogeneous and isotropic
7. Soil properties are constant with time
8. Soil is loaded instantaneously (at t = 0), and load
doesn’t vary with time

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

29
Differential equation of consolidation
‡ Equation governing rate of consolidation

‡ Consider a differential element of soil

Qin Area = dA
Volume = dV Surcharge load
dy
x ground surface
y dx
z dz

Qout

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

30
Differential equation of consolidation
− ∂ (dV ) ∂Q
= Qout − Qin = ( )dz assumption 3, compression and flow 1-D
∂t ∂z
Q = −kidA assumption 5, Darcy’s law is valid

∂h
= −k dA
∂z
∂ u u = excess p.w.p Qin Area = dA
= −k ( )dA
∂z γ w Volume = dV
dy
k ∂u
=− dA dx x
γ w ∂z dz y

− ∂ (dV ) ∂ k ∂u z
= (− dA)dz
∂t ∂z γ w ∂z Qout

∂ (dV ) k ∂ 2u
= dV Equation (1) assumption 6, soil is homogeneous
∂t γ w ∂z 2

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

31
Differential equation of consolidation
dVv e e
= dVv = dV
dV 1 + e 1+ e dVv e
dV ∂ (dV ) ∂ (dVv )
=
dVs 1 1 ∂t ∂t
= dVs = dV
dV 1 + e 1+ e dVs 1

e
∂( dV )
∂ (dV ) ∂ (dVv ) 1+ e ∂ (edVs ) ∂e ∂e dV
= = = = dVs =
∂t ∂t ∂t ∂t ∂t ∂t 1 + e
∂ (dV ) ∂e dV Equation (2)
=
∂t ∂t 1 + e

From equations (1) and (2),

k ∂ 2u ∂e dV
dV =
γ w ∂z 2 ∂t 1 + e

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

32
Differential equation of consolidation
k (1 + e) ∂ 2u ∂e
=
γ w ∂z 2 ∂t
∂e ∂e ∂σ '
= (chain rule)
∂t ∂σ ' ∂t
∂e ∂σ ' ∂e
= − av : av =
∂t ∂t ∂σ '
∂e ∂σ ∂u ∂u ∂σ
= − av ( − ) = av : = 0 (assumption 8, load doesn’t vary
∂t ∂t ∂t ∂t ∂t with time)
k (1 + e) ∂ 2u ∂u
= av
γ w ∂z 2
∂t

∂u k (1 + e) ∂ 2u
=
∂t avγ w ∂z 2
∂u ∂ 2u k (1 + e) k
= cv 2 : cv = =
∂t ∂z av γ w mvγ w

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

33
Differential equation of consolidation
‡ For constant z: (1 2)
∂u t = t0
u2 = u1 + dt
∂t as time increases, u decreases
t = t100
‡ For constant t: (1 3) z
∂u
u3 = u1 + dz u
∂z
‡ At any t and z: (1 4) t = t2 t = t1
1 2 z = z2
u
∂u
∂ (u1 + dt )
∂u ∂t z = z1
u4 = u1 + dt + dz 3 4
∂t ∂z
or ∂u
∂ (u1 + dz )
∂u ∂z
u4 = u1 + dz + dt
∂z ∂t
This is the differential equation governing time rate of consolidation. Solve for
any boundary conditions (get isochrones: curves relating u to z at any time t).

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

34
Solution of differential equation of consolidation
‡ Boundary conditions:
Example: a clay layer, of thickness 2H, with top and bottom
boundaries freely draining Sand

t = t1
„ u(z=0,t) = 0 as time increases, u decreases
„ u(z=2H,t) = 0 2H
t = t2 Clay
z
u Sand
‡ Initial condition:
For wide fill, applied instantly to saturated soil, the initial excess
pore-water pressure u(z,t=0) is independent of depth and equals
the applied stress

„ u(z,t=0) = ui

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

35
Solution of differential equation of consolidation
‡ Solve the differential equation with the above boundary and
initial conditions and get u=f(z,t)


2ui nπz − n 2π 2 cvt
u ( z, t ) = ∑ (1 − cos nπ )(sin ) exp( )
n =0 nπ 2 H 4 H 2

‡ (1-cosnπ) = 2 if n odd,
= 0 if n even
Therefore, let n = 2m+1, therefore, n always odd

nπ π
‡ If M= = (2m + 1) : n=2m+1
2 2
cv t
Tv = , where H corresponds to the longest drainage path within the clay layer
H2
z
Z=
H
Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

36
Solution of differential equation of consolidation

2ui
u ( z, t ) = ∑ (sin MZ ) exp(− M 2Tv )
m =0 M

‡ Solution in terms of degree of consolidation (U):

u −u u ui
U ( z, t ) = i = 1− u
ui ui z u ui-u

2
U ( z, t ) = 1 − ∑ (sin MZ ) exp(− M 2Tv ) 2H
m =0 M
t=t
‡ Average degree of consolidation for entire layer:
U = area / area
z
By integration:
2H

∫ udz
Ut = 1− 0
ui

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

37
Solution of differential equation of consolidation

2
‡ Ut = 1− ∑ 2
exp(− M 2Tv ) ……… Equation (3)
m =0 M

Equation (3) was solved Table and chart:


U (%) 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 95 99 100

Tv 0.0 0.008 0.031 0.071 0.126 0.197 0.287 0.403 0.567 0.848 1.129 1.781 ∞

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

38
Solution of differential equation of consolidation
‡ Fox (1948):

Tv = π/4 Ut2 for Ut<60%

error less than 1% compared to Equation 3

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

39
Solution of differential equation of consolidation
‡ The differential equation was solved for double-drained layer
isochrones are symmetrical around mid depth hydraulic
gradient is zero at mid depth no water flows across this
plane an impervious membrane could be inserted at this
depth without influencing progress of consolidation.

‡ Therefore, solution of differential equation for double-drained


layer of thickness 2H can be extended to single-drained layer of
thickness H.

‡ Remember:
Ut = St/Sultimate

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

40
Practical Applications
‡ Soil Improvement using:

1. Preloading

2. Vertical drains

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

41
Preloading
Δps = γshs Δps = γshs

Sand
or Soft Clay

Soft Clay

‡ Soil deposit with compressible layers of soft clay, loose silts,


organic soils, …… , mostly underconsolidated or normally
consolidated.

‡ Place designed fill on area to be treated, leave it for certain


period of time to reach target reduction in its compressibility.

‡ Need to know: pc, Cc, Cr for natural deposit.

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

42
Preloading
‡ Case 1: e
Preload (1 to 2), remove
surcharge (2 to 3), build.
Reduce ultimate settlements 1
caused due to construction. 3
2
‡ Case 2:
Preload (1 to 2), leave surcharge,
build on top.
pc Log p’
More for embankments and
highway construction.
Most of ultimate settlements
occurred before paving

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

43
Preloading
If Δpb’ < Δps’ e

eo=e1 1

e3
3
2
Δp’b 4
Δp’s

pc=po’ Log p’
‡ Add surcharge: (1 to 2) [Cc]
‡ Remove surcharge: (2 to 3) [Cs~Cr]
‡ Reload with building: (3 to 4) [Cr]
‡ Settlement due to building: (3 to 4)
Cr po' + Δpb'
S= H log( )
1 + e3 po'

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

44
Preloading
If Δpb’ > Δps’ e

eo=e1 1

e3
3
2
Δp’s
Δp’b 4

pc=po’ Log p’
‡ Add surcharge: (1 to 2) [Cc]
‡ Remove surcharge: (2 to 3) [Cs~Cr]
‡ Reload with building: (3 to 4) [Cr]
‡ Settlement due to building: (3 to 4)
Cr po' + Δps' Cc po' + Δpb'
S= H log( )+ H log( ' )
1 + e3 po' 1 + e3 po + Δps'
Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

45
Preloading
Notes:

‡ H in settlement calculations corresponds to void ratio e3


less than original Ho (corresponding to eo). Ho – H could
be significant.

‡ po’ + Δps’ new preconsolidation pressure.

‡ Calculated settlements are ultimate settlements.

‡ When shall we remove the surcharge to reach target


reduction in compressibility???

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

46
Preloading
‡ Determine tsr (time for
surcharge removal) such p’
that Stsr,s = Su,b
Δp’s

‡ Stsr,s = Su,s x Utsr Δp’b


tsr Time
‡ Therefore:
Su,s x Utsr = Su,b tsr Time
Utsr = Su,b/Su,s
Su,b
where: Building
Su,s
U = average degree of
consolidation Surcharge
Su,b = ultimate settlement
due to construction of
building
S
Su,s = ultimate settlement
due to surcharge load

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

47
Preloading
e

Cc po' + Δpb'
S u ,b = H o log( ) (1 to 2)
1 + eo po' eo 1

2
Cc p + Δp
' '
(1 to 3) Δp’b
3
Su ,s = H o log( o
) s
1 + eo po'
Δp’s

For design Δps’:


po’ Log p’
•get Utsr
•get Ttsr

•calculate:
Ttsr H d2
t sr =
cv
Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

48
Preloading
Notes:
‡ Preloading should compress (consolidate) soft soils without
causing shear strength/bearing capacity failure. The magnitude
and rate of preloading are designed to provide an adequate
factor of safety against undrained failure during operation.

‡ If estimated rate of primary consolidation is too slow,


supplement natural drainage layers with vertical drains
Radial Flow (not 1-D).

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

49
Vertical drains
‡ Purpose:
Reduce drainage path, thus, accelerate rate of consolidation.

‡ Define:
Vertical highly permeable elements inserted in soil. Water drain
laterally to one of the vertical drains, and then vertically to escape
from the soil through the drain.

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

50
Vertical drains
‡ Construction:
Years ago: form holes in soil filled with permeable material (sand
or gravel). Holes are formed either by:
„ Driving pipes 12 to 24” in diameter displacement drains
(smeared/remolded/disturbed zone)
„ Drilling holes non-displacement drains (no smear zone)

Currently: Wick Drains


Preformed plastic drainage elements: 4” wide, 0.5” thick
Rectangular in shape, but assumed circular in analysis with same
surface area.
rw b
t

rw = (b+t)/π
Equal Perimeter
2πrw = 2(b+t)

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

51
Wick drains
‡ Artificial drainage paths
‡ Central plastic core: free-draining water channel,
surrounded by thin geotextile filter jacket

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

52
Driving wick drains

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

53
Driving wick drains

Ground plate

•Wick drain is bent at its end and stapled around a ground plate or ground rebar.
•The driving machine drive the ground plate (hooked to wick drain) into the ground
until reach target depth.
•The wick drain is cut at the ground surface.

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

54
Analysis of Vertical drains
‡ Negligible lateral deformation (assumed 1-D deformation)

‡ Radial flow dominates

‡ Terzaghi’s 1-D theory of consolidation assumptions are


valid except Assumption # 3 (1-D water flow radial)

‡ Differential equation for 1-D deformation with radial flow:


same concepts applied in derivation of 1-D theory of
consolidation

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

55
Differential equation for 1-D deformation with
radial drainage
− ∂ (dV ) ∂Q
= Qout − Qin = ( )dr Radial flow
∂t ∂r
Q = − k r idA assumption 5, Darcy’s law is valid

k r ∂u u = excess p.w.p
=− rdθdz
γ w ∂r Qin

− ∂ (dV ) ∂ k ∂u
= (− r rdθdz )dr
∂t ∂r γ w ∂r Qout dz

− ∂ (dV ) k r 1 ∂u ∂ 2u dr
=− [ + ]rdθdrdz r
∂t γ w r ∂r ∂r 2
dV
∂ (dV ) ∂e dV
= 1-D consolidation derivation
∂t ∂t 1 + e
∂e dV k r 1 ∂u ∂ 2u
− =− [ + ]dV
∂t 1 + e γ w r ∂r ∂r 2

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

56
Differential equation for 1-D deformation with
radial drainage
∂e ∂u 1-D consolidation derivation
= av
∂t ∂t
av ∂u k r 1 ∂u ∂ 2u Qin
= [ + ] dθ
1 + e ∂t γ w r ∂r ∂r 2

∂u k r (1 + e) 1 ∂u ∂ 2u Qout dz
= [ + ]
∂t avγ w r ∂r ∂r 2
dr
r
Define:

k (1 + e)
cv = Coefficient of consolidation
av γ w
k r (1 + e)
cv ,r = Radial coefficient of consolidation
av γ w

∂u 1 ∂u ∂ 2u Differential equation for 1-D deformation with radial flow


= cv ,r [ + ]
∂t r ∂r ∂r 2

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

57
Solution of differential equation for 1-D
deformation with radial drainage
‡ Model:
„ Cylindrical freely draining well, rw
„ Surrounded by cylindrical shell of undisturbed homogeneous
soil, Re Re
rw

‡ Boundary Conditions: rw
„ u(rw,t)=0
Re

∂Lu (0, t )
„ =0
∂r

‡ Initial Condition:
„ u(r,0)=ui=Δp

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

58
Solution of differential equation for 1-D
deformation with radial drainage
‡ Apply boundary and initial conditions and solve the differential
equation to get average degree of consolidation:
2T
U r = 1 − exp(− r )
m
where: rw
c t Tr = Radial Time Factor
Tr = v ,r2
Re
n2 n 3 s2 kr n 2 − s 2
m = 2 2 ln( ) − + 2 + ( ) ln(s )
n −s s 4 4n kr ,s n2
Re n = drain spacing factor Rs
n=
rw As n increases, # drains decreases Re

Rs Rs = radius of cylindrical shell of incompressible disturbed


s= soil (smear zone)
rw
Kr = radial/horizontal soil hydraulic conductivity
Kr,s = radial/horizontal soil hydraulic conductivity of smear zone

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

59
Solution of differential equation for 1-D
deformation with radial drainage
‡ The solution for the average degree of consolidation is presented
in the following chart (no smear zone):

Numbers on curves are


for drain spacing factor
(n)

get get
‡ Calculate Ur Tr t

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

60
Combined vertical and radial flow
∂u ∂ 2u 1 ∂u ∂ 2u
= cv 2 + cv ,r [ + 2] u = excess p.w.p
∂t ∂z r ∂r ∂r

‡ (1-U) = (1-Uv)(1-Ur) U = average degree of consolidation

‡ U = 1- (1-Uv)(1-Ur)

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

61
Vertical Drains
‡ Filter: surrounds vertical drain
„ kfilter: high enough to allow flow of water
„ kfilter: low enough to prevent washout of soil

‡ Re depends on spacing between vertical drains

„ Square Pattern: s
πRe2 = s2 Re
Re = s/(π0.5) = 0.564 s

„ Triangular Pattern: Re
Re ~ 0.5 s

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

62
Smear Zone
‡ For non-displacement drains, no smear zone:
„ Rs = rw, s=1
„ kr = kr,s

‡ For sand drains: 1 < s < 4 (typically)

‡ For wick drains: s can be larger than 4

‡ For example:
rm = 80 mm (mandrel radius to insert wick)
rw = 32 mm
If Rs/rm = 2 (smear zone ~ 2 mandrel radius)
Therefore, Rs = 2 x 80 = 160 mm
s = Rs/rw = 160/32 = 5

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

63
Example
Vertical Drains
q

Re
Clay Triangular
20’ pattern
s
Impervious rock

„ rw = 0.5’
„ Thickness of clay layer = 20’
„ s = 20’
„ cv = cv,r = 10 ft2/year
„ Find U at t = 1 year

‡ Note: combined vertical and radial flow

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

64
Example
‡ Vertical flow:
cv t 10 × 1
Tv = = = 0.025
H2 20 2

2 π
Ut = 1− ∑ 2
exp(− M 2Tv ) where M= (2m + 1)
m =0 M 2
m M 2/M2 exp(-M2Tv) 2/M2 exp(-M2Tv) Uv
0 1.57 0.81057 0.9401789707 0.7620803692 0.23792
1 4.71 0.09006 0.5739774050 0.0516942845 0.186225
2 7.85 0.03242 0.2139258782 0.0069360714 0.179289
3 11.00 0.01654 0.0486761380 0.0008052121 0.178484
4 14.14 0.01001 0.0067616575 0.0000676641 0.178416
5 17.28 0.00670 0.0005734222 0.0000038413 0.178413
6 20.42 0.00480 0.0000296879 0.0000001424 0.178412
7 23.56 0.00360 0.0000009384 0.0000000034 0.178412
8 26.70 0.00280 0.0000000181 0.0000000001 0.178412
9 29.85 0.00225 0.0000000002 0.0000000000 0.178412

„ Therefore, Uv = 17.8%
„ If use chart, Uv = 17.4%

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

65
Example
‡ Radial flow:
cv ,r t 10 ×1
Tr = 2
= = 0.1 where Re ~ 0.5 s = 10’
R e 10 2
2Tr
U r = 1 − exp(− )
m
n2 n 3 s2 kr n 2 − s 2
m = 2 2 ln( ) − + 2 + ( ) ln(s )
n −s s 4 4n kr ,s n2

R e 10
n= = = 20
rw 0.5
Rs
s=
rw

Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

66
Example
‡ If no smear zone:
„ Rs = rw, s = 1
„ kr = kr,s
n2 n 3 s2 kr n 2 − s 2
„ m=2.25, where m= ln( ) − + + ( ) ln( s )
n2 − s2 s 4 4n 2 k r , s n2

2T
„ Ur = 8.5%, where U r = 1 − exp(− r )
m
„ If use chart, Ur = 8.5%
„ U = 1- (1-Uv)(1-Ur)
= 1-(1-0.174)(1-0.085) = 0.248 = 24.8%

‡ If smear zone with s = 2 and kr,s = 0.1 kr:


„ m=8.44
„ Ur = 2.3%
„ U = 1- (1-Uv)(1-Ur)
= 1-(1-0.174)(1-0.023) = 0.198 = 19.8%
‡ Note: smear zone reduced rate of consolidation
Dr. Manal A. Salem – Theoretical Soil Mechanics - Consolidation

67

You might also like