Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sustainability Studies: Assignment-2
Sustainability Studies: Assignment-2
ASSIGNMENT-2
SUBMITTED BY – NIKITA
BFT/17/143
1. INTRODUCTION……….………………………………………………………….3
2. INDEXES OF DJSI………………………………………………………………..3
3. CHARACTERSTICS AND METHODOLOGY…………………………………..5
4. COMPANY SELECTION PROCESS……………….…………………………...7
5. ASSESSMENT……………………………………………………………………..8
6. VALUE OF DJSI INCLUSION……………………………………………………10
7. CONSTRUCTION………………………………………………………………….10
8. REASONS TO PARTICIPATE IN DJSI………..………………………………..11
9. RESULTS…………………………………………………………………………..11
10. CRITICISM…………….…………………………………………………………...12
11. CASE STUDIES……………………………………………………………………15
12. CONCLUSION…………………………...………………………………………...20
The family of the Dow Jones sustainable indices was created in September 1999
with the purpose of reflecting the top, large company performers in terms of
economics, social and environmental aspects. This family, which consists of several
indices that are based on global, regional and national benchmarks, has grown and
become diversified through the years with the creation of specific indices at the
regional and industry level.
It arrived in Europe in 2001 with the creation of several regional indices (DJSI
Europe and DJSI Eurozone). The last ones that were created were the DJSI
Emerging Markets and the DJSI Australia. Today, this set of indices constitutes a
clear and sound benchmark for large investors.
The Dow Jones Sustainability World Index (DJSI World) tracks the performance of
the top 10% of the 2500 largest companies in the Dow Jones Global Total Stock
Market Index℠ that lead the field in terms of sustainability. These 2500 companies
represent the eligible universe for the DJSI World and are assessed using the CSA
(Corporate Sustainability Assessment) on an annual basis.1
Composite Index
Dow Jones Sustainability World Index (DJSI World)
Subset Index
Dow Jones Sustainability World Index ex Alcohol, Gambling, Tobacco,
Armaments & Firearms (DJSI World ex. All)
Dow Jones Sustainability World Index ex Alcohol, Gambling, Tobacco,
Armaments & Firearms and Adult Entertainment (DJSI World ex. All/AE)
1
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/djones-sustainability-world.asp
Customized index
The DJSI methodology facilitates the design, development and delivery of
customized sustainability indexes. For example, indexes covering different regions,
indexes covering different segments of the leading sustainability companies, indexes
covering additional exclusion criteria and indexes denominated in different
currencies.2
2
https://www.resolve.ngo/docs/djsi-world-guidebook_tcm1071-337244.pdf
DJSI World, in March 2018, reported 318 constituents and five-year annualized net
total returns of 9.5%. About a third of the benchmark's weight by market
capitalization was concentrated in companies based in the United States, of which
there were nearly 50. In terms of environment, social and governance disclosures,
the index reported a carbon footprint (measured in metric tons of CO2 emissions per
$1 million invested) about 25% better than the broader S&P Global BMI, the index
from which DJSI World draws its constituents. Fossil fuel reserve emissions
averaged nearly half of those reported for the S&P Global BMI, and DJSI World also
fared better in terms of carbon efficiency.
The index is weighted based on free-float market capitalization, and changes are
made once each year in September based on updated sustainability scores. Each
company represented in the index has its corporate sustainability assessed through
an intricate weighting system that looks at economic, environmental, and social
metrics. Candidate firms are further assessed based on media and stakeholder
commentary and industry-specific criteria. Companies are reevaluated each year;
those that fail to show consistent progress may be removed from the index.3
3
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/djones-sustainability-world.asp
Invited universe
Consists of the companies by float adjusted market capitalization
from the S&P Global BMI that have been invited to participate in CSA
(Approximately 4,500 companies)
Assessed universe
Consists of the companies in the invited universe that have been
analysed based on CSA
DJSI
Rule - based selection of top 10% most sustainable market caps
per industry, based on their sustainability scores.
ASSESSMENT
A defined set of criteria is used to assess the economic, social, and environmental
opportunities of the companies that the DJSI has listed, which are chosen based on
the Corporate Sustainability Assessment by RobecoSAM. Information comes from
the annual RobecoSAM questionnaire (the Corporate Sustainability Assessment),
company documentation, the Media and Stakeholder Analysis (an examination of
media coverage, stakeholder commentaries and other publicly available sources
provided by RepRisk ESG Business Intelligence), and personal contact with the
companies. Industry leaders from RobecoSAM Research's Corporate Sustainability
Assessment are chosen to be listed on the DJSI.
Once a company is listed on the DJSI, it is monitored daily for any critical arising
issues, which can lead to the exclusion of the company if deemed critical enough.
Examples of events that would lead to exclusion include: commercial practices,
human rights abuses, layoffs or worker disputes, or catastrophic disasters. This
monitoring is supported by RepRisk, a global research firm and provider of
environmental, social and governance (ESG) risk data. RepRisk screens media
outlets, stakeholder groups and other publicly available sources to identify risks
related to these issues. The information gathered is then systematically analyzed
and quantified. If a critical event happens, the situation is analyzed by RobecoSAM
for the scope in which it reaches. If large enough, the event will be analyzed further
4
https://blog.ferrovial.com/en/2015/09/best-in-class-what-is-it-and-what-criteria-are-required-to-join-
the-dow-jones-sustainability-index-djsi/
CRITERIA WEIGHTINGS
Economic Dimension 33%
Environmental Dimension 33%
Social Dimension 33%
Industry Criteria 57%
General Criteria 43%
ECONOMIC DIMENSION WEIGHTINGS (in %)
Corporate Governance 6.0
Risk and crisis management 6.0
Codes of conduct/compliance/anti- 6.0
corruption and bribery
Industry-specific criteria Depends on industry
ENVIRONMENTAL DIMENSION WEIGHTINGS (in %)
Environmental reporting 3.0
Industry-specific criteria Depends on industry
SOCIAL DIMENSION WEIGHTINGS (in %)
Human-capital development 5.5
Talent attraction and retention 5.5
Labour practice indicators 5.0
Corporate citizenship/Philanthropy 3.0
Social Reporting 3.0
Industry-specific criteria Depends on industry
5
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dow_Jones_Sustainability_Indices#DJSI_World_Index
Investment
Members gain exposure to investors who value DJSI.
Members also gain exposure to investment products and tools that use DJSI data,
such as the S&P ESG index series and Bloomberg terminals, both newly
announced in 2016
Recognition
DJSI members can trumpet the achievement and utilize the DJSI logo in
communication.
Inclusion can also strengthen employee commitment to values and support
recruitment efforts of candidates. 6
The results lead to companies entering and leaving the index, as each sector is
represented by market capitalization volume.
As a result, companies leaving the index give way to new companies entering it
and the number of companies making up each sector is different and fixed,
although this may vary from year to year depending on the companies comprising
the sector.
In the case of the World Index (DJSI World), approximately about 10% of
candidate companies are selected to be part of this exclusive group, that is, those
that have obtained the highest score in the ranking within their sector and which
therefore represent the best sustainability performance.
To many companies the presence or continuity in this index has become a
fundamental and strategic objective given the influence it has on the so-called
‘socially responsible’ investors or ‘SRI’.
6
https://www.slideshare.net/FrameworkLLC/what-is-the-dow-jones-sustainability-index-djsi
CRITICISM
7
https://blog.ferrovial.com/en/2015/09/best-in-class-what-is-it-and-what-criteria-are-required-to-join-
the-dow-jones-sustainability-index-djsi/
8
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dow_Jones_Sustainability_Indices#DJSI_World_Index
Using self-reported data as proxies for the social or environmental effects the DJSI
intends to reflect leaves the index exposed to corporate biases and additional
credibility risks. It rewards companies with greatest capacity to respond to SAM's
questionnaires and information requests rather than those with the best socially
responsible practices. Secondly, relying on self-reported data carries substantial
risks since information from companies may not be completely credible. An index
based on biased information often underestimates real risk factors in the listed
companies' operation, even in those instances when submitted information if verified
by an auditing firm such as PricewaterhouseCoopers, KPMG, etc. Ultimately,
companies with challenging corporate environmental and social issues are more
likely to devote public relations resources to minimize the perception of risk within
their operations. In order to address some of this feedback, RobecoSAM added a
Media and Stakeholder Analysis component to the annual Corporate Sustainability
Assessment, in order to complement and help corroborate the questionnaire and
documentation provided by the participating companies. For the MSA, RobecoSAM
works with RepRisk, a global research firm specialized in risk analytics and metrics
related to environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues. RepRisk screens
media outlets, stakeholder groups and other publicly available sources to identify
risks, which are then systematically analyzed and quantified.
It has been also found that in the DJSI the three dimensions of sustainability are not
considered in a balanced way, being biased towards economic criteria to the
disadvantage of social and environmental ones. A further bias of the DJSI is that it
Adidas
Adidas has been included in the Dow Jones Sustainability Indices (DJSI) for the
twentieth time in the year 2019. This year also marks the twentieth edition of the
globally recognized indices, which evaluate the sustainability performance of the
largest 2,500 companies listed in the Dow Jones Global Total Stock Market Index.
The comprehensive assessment considers factors such as corporate governance,
risk management, climate change mitigation, labor and environmental standards
both within the company and with its suppliers, as well as innovation management.
In addition to being again included in the indices, Adidas was ranked best in its
industry in the criteria of Brand Management, Information Security/Cyber Security &
System Availability, Environmental Policy & Management Systems, Operational Eco-
Efficiency, Social Reporting and Talent Attraction & Retention.
Adidas continues to become ever more sustainable. In the current period of its
sustainability strategy, the sporting goods manufacturer is pursuing tangible and
measurable targets up to 2020. Key priorities include the use of more sustainable
materials for products, tackling water scarcity in manufacturing countries and further
improving working conditions in the supply chain. Adidas has not used plastic bags
in its own stores since 2016; sources only sustainably produced cotton since 2018
and presented the world's first fully recyclable running shoe this year. From 2024
onwards, only recycled polyester will be used in every product and on every
application where a solution exists.
The results of the annual DJSI review were announced by RobecoSAM, a global
investment group focused exclusively on sustainability investing, in collaboration with
S&P Dow Jones Indices. The DJSI are the longest-running global sustainability
benchmarks, a key reference point in sustainability investing for investors and an
Burberry
Burberry has been included in the 2019 Dow Jones Sustainability Index (DJSI) for
the fifth consecutive year, ranked third place in the ‘Textiles, Apparel & Luxury
Goods’ sector and achieving its highest score ever score in the Index. The leading
global sustainability metric, the DJSI evaluates a company’s economic,
environmental and social impact and is a trusted benchmark for investors who
integrate sustainability considerations into their decision-making and investments.
Burberry has a longstanding commitment to sustainability, with social and
environmental programmes in place for more than 15 years and its latest five-year
Responsibility Agenda covering its products, global operations and the communities
that sustain the luxury industry.
During 2018/19, Burberry reduced its market-based emissions by 43% and procured
58% of its total energy (including 68% of its electricity) from renewable sources.
Burberry is now carbon neutral across the Americas region, its EMEIA retail stores
and UK operations, and aims to be 100% carbon neutral by 2022. Building on this,
Burberry recently set two new, ambitious climate goals approved by the Science
Based Target initiative (SBTi) for its own operations and extended supply chain.
Burberry’s Spring/Summer 2020 show during London Fashion Week was certified as
carbon neutral. Burberry offset its impacts, such as the flights of guests travelling to
London specifically for the show and the build and production of the event, through
VSC-certified REDD+ projects which prevent deforestation and conserve tropical
rainforest in the Brazilian Amazon.
Driving a more circular economy for fashion is central to Burberry’s sustainability
agenda and as part of this Burberry continues to expand ways to reuse, repair,
donate and recycle products and materials. A founding member of the New Plastics
Economy Global Commitment which aims to eradicate plastic waste and pollution by
2025, Burberry is working to eliminate problematic or unnecessary plastic packaging.
This includes ensuring plastic in packaging can be easily reused, recycled or
Moncler
Moncler has for the first time in 2019 entered the Dow Jones Sustainability Indices
World and Europe, recognized as the Industry Leader in the textiles, apparel and
luxury goods’ sector.
The Dow Jones Sustainability Index globally ranks the leading sustainability-driven
companies based on economic, environmental and social responsibility criteria,
which are analyzed by RobecoSAM’s trusted sustainability investment specialist.
Moncler reports every year on its sustainability performances and targets and will
present its new strategic sustainability plan for the 2020-2025 period in the coming
months.
Inditex
Inditex, the most sustainable retailer according to the Dow Jones Sustainability Index
For the third year in a row i.e in 2018, the Dow Jones Sustainability Index has
singled out Inditex as the retailer with the best practices along the environmental,
social and economic dimensions
The report, underpinned by reinforced methodology this year, flags Inditex's
leadership in Environmental Management Policy and Contribution to Society and
Philanthropy
The company keeps avant-garde in Supply Chain Management, Human Rights, and
Strategy for Emerging Markets, Operational Eco-efficiency and Tax Policy, among
others
Inditex scored 45 points above the sector average. Inditex has been ranked the most
sustainable company in the global retailing industry by the Dow Jones Sustainability
Dow Jones Sustainability Indices (DJSI) rating are increasingly being used in
innovative new products for investors, such as the S&P 500 ESG, S&P Europe 350
ESG, S&P Topix 150 ESG, S&P Global 1200 ESG and S&P Long-Term Value
Creation Index. Selected results of the DJSI are also shared on the Bloomberg
Professional platform, making them accessible to a growing number of investors.
The DJSI gives us the unique opportunity to provide a more in-depth and complete
picture of company's corporate sustainability efforts. This opportunity sets the DJSI
apart from most other sustainability rating frameworks. This is the world's most
credible international sustainability rating and done globally, free of cost.