Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Elsevier Science Publishers B.V.. Amsterdam - Printed in The Netherlands
Elsevier Science Publishers B.V.. Amsterdam - Printed in The Netherlands
29(1986)145-160 145
Elsevier Science Publishers B.V.. Amsterdam - Printed in The Netherlands
Lehrstuhl fiirPhysikalischeChemie II
Ruhr-UniversitatBochum
D-4630 Bochum 1, Federal Republic of Germany
ABSTRACT
The experimental investigationof high pressure phase equilibria, especially
the measurement of properties of coexisting phases, is not only of fundamental
scientific interest, but is also an intriguing and fascinating technical prob-
lem. This work reviews some recently developed experimental methods and clas-
sifies them with respect to the observed thermodynamicproperties. Several de-
vices and experimental procedures for the determinationof phase equilibria are
briefly explained. The advantages and limitations of these different methods
are discussed.
INTRODUCTION
Among the many thermodynamic properties of fluid mixtures the phase equili-
brium properties are especially important for several reasons: Many separation
processes in the chemical industry utilize phase equilibria so that understand-
ing the phase behaviour of mixtures is of considerable economic interest. On
the other hand, many theoretical studies of the thermodynamicsof mixtures have
shown that the phase behaviour of mixtures is quite sensitive to intermolecular
forces. In particular the calculation of phase equilibria at high pressures is
a very severe test for the theoretical concepts involved (equations of state,
pair potentials, mixing rules, etc.). Therefore experimental methods for the
determination of phase equilibria are not only immediately valuable to the
chemical engineer (by providing him with data on which his designs may be
based), but they are also very important to the theoretician.
EXPERIMENTAL METHODS
In mixture thermodynamics it is often practical to distinguish between SO-
called density and field variables (Griffiths and Wheeler, 1970). "Fields" are
variables which have'the same values in coexisting phases (e.g., temperature,
pressure), whereas "densities" are usually different (e.g., mole fractions,
molar volumes). The experimental determination of the field variables, although
an art in itself, is usually rather straightforward. The central problem of a
phase equilibrium experiment is the determination of the density variables. It
is more the exception than the rule that in a given experiment more than one
pair of 'idensities"is observed directly. Therefore it seems permissible to
classify the different experimental methods according to the "densities" which
are primarily observed.
The following descriptions of experimental methods do not constitute a com-
plete catalogue of modern techniques, but are meant to explain the underlying
principles. For older reviews see Schneider (1975) or Young (1978).
- x Methanol
148
1986) in figure 2. The experimental isobars have a very broad, flat top. Here,
even slight disturbanceswould lead to large fluctuations of the phase composi-
tions, and so the application of the analytic method (see below) is not recom-
mended, whereas the synthetic method encounters no problems. On the other hand,
the synthetic method is less accurate on the steep parts of the isobars because
here a slight error in the overall compositionwould lead to a large deviation
of the temperature.
If the motions of the pressure-transferringelement (piston or bellows) can
be recorded with sufficient precision, it is also possible to obtain PVT data
and even orthobaric densities from a synthetic experiment, An example of such
an application has been published by Meskel-Lesavre, Richon, and Renon (1981).
Because of the high resolution of the volume measurements, the formation of a
new phase is detected not visually, but from the appearance of discontinuities
in pressure vs. volume curves.
Synthetic experiments with visual observation of the phase separation have
also been carried out at high temperatures,e.g. with mixtures containing long-
chain alkanes (de Loos, Poot, Perbal, and Lichtenthaler,1985) or mixtures con-
taining water in the vicinity of its critical point (Japas and Franck, 1985;
de Loos, Wijen, and Diepen, 1980).
Fig. 3. Analytic/syntheticapparatus
(Wisotzki, 1984).
a) pressure cell
This view shows the Bridgman piston with
the bellows attached to it, the magnetic
stirrer, a sapphire window, and the two
sampling capillaries;
max. pressure 3000 bar, temperature range
80 - 373 K.
I
~____________-____
bellows position.
51
._
-I BZ
d
PS
FV
He
---_____ C-V
GC
I
150
ratus can be used according to the synthetic method as described above; for
mole fractions far away from the critical point it is operated in the analyti-
cal mode: Samples of the liquid or the vapour phase are transferred into sample
loops connected to six-way valves. From there the samples are flushed into a
gas chromatographby flowing helium gas.
This apparatus has been designed for cryogenic applications. The pressure
cell is cooled with liquid nitrogen or with methanol from a cryostat. As long
as all components of the mixture under investigationhave high vapour pressures
at ambient temperature, no components of the samples are lost through condensa-
tion in the sampling capillaries, and so the compositions of the phases within
the pressure cell agree - at least after thorough flushing - with the input
compositionsto the gas chromatograph.
A typical result from this apparatus is shown in figure 4, which contains an
isothermal phase diagram of the nitrogen/ethanesystem. At the lowest tempera-
ture shown, a liquid-liquid immiscibility and the melting phase transition
"overlap" so that a solid-liquid-liquidthree-phase state occurs at about 1600
bar. At the higher temperatures the liquid-liquid immiscibilityregion remains
undisturbed (Wisotzkiand Schneider, 1985).
p/MPa
150
100
sl
2 phases
.
0.2 Ok 0.6 OB
X
b) sample preparation
l-2 sampling valves, 14:
separator funnel, 15: orga-
nic solvent reservoir, 16:
calibration volume, 17:
manometer, 20: vacuum pump,
21: helium reservoir, 22:
carbon dioxide reservoir.
For further details see the
original literature.
153
also the tie lines have been obtained, and so it is possible to study enhance-
ment factors or K-values with this apparatus.
Determinationof concentrations
Spectroscopyor photometry usually belong to this class of methods, because
they make use of Beer's law (proportionalitybetween concentration (amount of
substance per volume) and absorbance). The difficulty with these methods is
that the extinction coefficientshave to be determined by extensive calibration
procedures. In some recent publicationsnear infrared (NIR) (Swaid, Nickel, and
Schneider, 1985) or ultraviolet (RiiBlingand Franck, 1983; Ebeling and Franck,
155
1984) spectra have been utilized. The application of ultraviolet and visual
light spectroscopy is more or less restricted to aromatic or coloured com-
pounds. With infrared spectroscopy it is easier to find strong absorption
bands; unfortunately,the probability is quite high that absorption bands of
different compounds are overlapping. The use of larger wavelengths (fundamental
range) cannot be recommended for high pressure applications, because the ex-
tinction coefficients of fundamental bands are so large that rather small op-
tical pathlengths are required; these are difficult to keep constant when the
pressure is varied.
Instead of infrared absorption, Raman scattering can be used for the deter-
mination of compositions (e.g. Diller and Chang, 1980). Except for the fact
that Raman spectroscopycalls for a different pressure cell design from infra-
red spectroscopy,applicabilityand experimentalprocedure remain similar.
Figure 7 shows a schematic diagram of a phase equilibrium apparatus with
near-infraredspectroscopicdeterminationof phase concentrations.The pressure
vessel is equipped with two pairs of windows. It can be moved with respect to
the spectrometer so that the infrared sample beam may pass either through the
lower or through the upper phase. A piston is used to build up the pressure and
to control the volume of the pressure cell. The position of the piston, to
which a magnetic wire is attached, can be sensed by means of a high frequency
differential transformer. Further details of the high pressure cell have been
described elsewhere (Swaid, 1984). The infrared light intensitiesare digitized
and passed to a microcomputer, which records the data and performs baseline
corrections,smoothing, integrations,and other services required to obtain the
desired concentrationdata.
In analogy to the synthetic method described above, at the beginning of an
experimentalrun known amounts of the components of the mixture are transferred
into the pressure cell and brought to a homogeneous state. Since the volume of
the cell is known from previous calibrations, it is possible to calculate the
overall concentrationand to determine the extinction coefficients. Then the
pressure or the temperature is changed to bring about a phase separation. The
previously determined extinction coefficients are then used to calculate the
concentrationsof the coexisting phases.
With infrared spectra of hydrocarbons dissolved in supercritical gases, it
has been observed that the shapes and positions of the absorption bands depend
on pressure, temperature,and the solvent gas used; fortunately,the integrated
extinction coefficients show little dependence on pressure, temperature, or
compositionso that they can be used to calculate the concentrations.
The spectroscopic method is also applicable to high-pressure equilibria
involvingsolid phases. As a typical example for such a system, figure 8 shows
156
b) general assembly
SG: stirrer driver, SPl, SP2:
stirrer coils, TE: thermocouple,
TM: thermostat iacket.MMS:micro-
meter screw, INF,TFM:-high fre-
quency bridge for determining
position of piston, SP: screw
press, A/O: sample and reference
beam analog/digital converters;
spectrometer: Cary 17H.
For further details see the ori-
ginal literature.
Reproduced with permission from
Konrad et al. (1983); copyright
1983, Elsevier, Amsterdam.
157
the phase behaviour of the carbon dioxide/adamantane system (Swaid, Nickel, and
Schneider, 1985). The solubility of adamantane, which is solid at the tempera-
ture shown, in supercritical carbon dioxide is almost negligible at pressures
below some 100 bar, but increases very much in the pressure range 100 - 200
bar. Beyond 500 bar the solubility declines slightly. It is interesting to see
that the differences between two proposed calculation methods (based on the
Redlich-Kwong equation (1949) and our own equation of state (Deiters and Swaid,
1984)) become evident at high pressures only. This stresses the importance of
high pressure experiments for the development and testing of better computa-
tional methods.
Determination of volumes
A very interesting method, which avoids the complications of withdrawing
samples from a high pressure vessel, is based on in situ determinations of
fluid volumes. The idea is that at fixed pressure and temperature the composi-
tions and densities of coexisting phases of a binary system are also fixed; the
amounts of the coexisting phases, however, are not fixed, but depend on the
overall composition within the pressure vessel. If the same equilibrium state
(phase separation at the same temperature and pressure) can be reached with
different overall compositions, and if the volumes of the coexistingphases can
be measured, it is possible to calculate the orthobaric densities as well as
the mole fractions from a set of linear balance equations.
There are different technical realizationsof this experimentalprinciple.
Specovius, Leiva, Scott, and Knobler (1981) have used a glass apparatus and ob-
P/MPa
' 80
70
60
50
40
0 343.15 K
30 0 383.15 K
20 4 363.15 K
10 v 403.15 K
I
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 C 6
ci/mol*dm-'
served the position of the meniscus with a cathetometer. Fontalba, Richon, and
Renon (1984) have used a steel cell, where the position of the meniscus is
sensed by a movable thermistor.
It must be noted that this experimental principle requires an excellent re-
producibility of pressure and temperature in the autoclave. Furthermore, the
set of balance equations, which has to be solved for the phase compositions and
densities, is not always well-conditioned. It is necessary to observe the phase
volumes quite precisely.
The connection between total composition, total volume, phase compositions,
and phase densities can also be used to obtain the orthobaric densities from
mole fractions (by means of the analytic method described above; HUbner, 1983).
DISCUSSION
The rather large number of experimental methods and devices for the determi-
nation of phase equilibria in fluid mixtures under high pressure indicates that
there is no "perfect" method yet. Each method has its drawbacks and advantages,
and it is quite important to be aware of them.
The synthetic method does not require complicated analytical devices and so
it is relatively inexpensive. Furthermore, since there is no need to wait for
equilibration of phase compositions, the synthetic method is able to give much
information in a short time.
It is important to realize that the synthetic method does not observe the
phase boundary itself, but the formation of a new phase. Since a certain amount
of this new phase is necessary in order to be visible, the recorded pressure-
temperature state is never on, but always within, the phase envelope. As long
as the slopes of the phase boundary lines (e.g., dew point lines) vs. composi-
tion are small, the deviations will be negligible, but for mole fractions far
away from the critical this may not be so. Furthermore, if during a dew point
experiment the liquid phase does not condense as a mist, but as a thin film
on a wall of the pressure cell, the dew point may easily be overlooked. In
addition, the synthetic method cannot be applied when the coexisting phases
have similar refractive indices. On the other hand, the synthetic method does
not disturb the equilibrium very much so that it is reliable and especially
useful in the vicinity of critical points.
If the synthetic method is applied to multicomponent mixtures, it yields the
P-T-x envelopes only, but not the tie lines, so that its usefulness is much re-
duced in this case.
Analytic methods are generally slower and more expensive to use than syn-
thetic devices, but they are not restricted to binary systems. Furthermore,the
analytic method works well far away from critical points. It cannot be applied,
159
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Financial support by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft,the Minister filr
Wissenschaftund Forschung NRW, and the Fonds der Chemischen Industriee.V. for
the experimentalwork performed at Bochum is gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES
Deiters, U.K., and I. Swaid, 1984. Calculation of fluid-fluid and solid-fluid
phase equilibria in binary mixtures at high pressures, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys.
Chem., 88: 791 - 796.
Diller, D.E., and R.F. Chang, 1980. Compositionof mixtures of natural gas com-
ponents determined by Raman spectrometry,Appl. Spectroscopy,34: 411 - 414.
Dorau, W., H. Kremer, and H. Knapp, 1983. An apparatus for the investigationof
low-temperature,high-pressure,vapor-liquidand vapor-liquid-liquidequili-
bria, Fluid Phase Equil., 11: 83 - 89.
Ebeling, H., and E.U. Franck, 1984. Spectroscopic determination of caffeine
solubility in supercriticalcarbon dioxide, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 88:
862 - 865.
Figui&e, P., J.F. Horn,S. Laugier, H. Renon, D. Richon, and H. Szwarc, 1980.
Vapor-liquid equilibria up to 40000 kPa and 4OO'C: a new static method,
AIChE J., 26: 872 - 875.
Fontalba, F., D. Richon, and H. Renon, 1984. Simultaneous determination of
vapor-liquidequilibria and saturated densities up to 45 MPa and 433 K, Rev.
Sci. Instrum., 55: 944 - 951.
Japas, M.L., and E.U. Franck, 1985. High pressure phase equilibria and PVT data
of the water-nitrogen system to 673 K and 250 MPa, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys.
Chem., 89: 793 - 800.
Griffiths, R.B., and J.C. Wheeler, 1970. Critical points in multicomponentsys-
tems, Phys. Rev., A2: 1047 - 1064.
Heintz, A., and W.B. Streett, 1983. Phase equilibria in the hydrogenlethene
system at temperaturesfrom 114.1 to 247.1 K and pressures to 600 MPa, Ber.
Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 87: 298 - 303.
Holscher, I.F., G.M. Schneider, and J-6. Ott, 1986. Liquid-liquidphase equili-
bria of binary mixtures of methanol with hexane, nonane, and decane at pres-
sures up to 150 MPa, Fluid Phase Equil., in press.
Hiibner,H., 1983. Neue MeBwerte fijr das PhasengleichgewichtflUssig/gasfotmig
bei Helium/Stickstoff-Gemischen, Chem.-Ing.-Tech.,55: 382 - 385.
Konrad, R., 1982. Doctoral Dissertation: Thermodynamik und Phasenverhalten
fluider Dreistoffgemischebei hohen DriIcken,Ruhr-UniversitatBochum.
Konrad, R., I. Swaid, and G.M. Schneider, 1983. Hiqh-pressurephase studies on
fluid mixtures of low-volatile organic substances with supercriticalcarbon
carbon dioxide, Fluid Phase Eauil.. 10: 307 - 314.
Legret, Il., D. Richon, and H. R&on,- 1981. Vapor-liquid equilibria up to 100
MPa: a new apparatus, AIChE J., 27: 203 - 207.
160
de Loos, Th. W., A.J.M. Wijen, and G.A.M. Diepen, 1980. Phase equilibria and
critical phenomena in fluid (propane t water) at high pressures and tempera-
tures, J. Chem. Thermodyn., 12: 193 - 204.
de Loos, Th. W., W. Poot, R. Perbal, and R.N. Lichtenthaler,1985. Fluid phase
equilibria in quasi-binary systems of ethylene t n-eicosane t n-tetracontane
Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 89: 846 - 850.
Maier, M., and K. Stephan, 1984. Eine neue Apparatur zur Messung der Loslich-
keit von organischen Stoffen in hochverdichteten Gasen, Chem.-Ing.-Techn.,
56: 222 - 223.
Matzik, I., and G.M. Schneider, 1985. Fluid phase equilibria of binary mixtures
of SF, with octane, nonane, hendecane, and decahydronaphthalene,cisat tem-
temperatures between 280 K and 440 K and pressures up to 140 MPa in compari-
son to mixtures of hydrocarbons with CO*, CF, , and CHF,, Ber. Bunsenges.
Phys. Chem., 89:, 551 - 555.
Meskel-Lesavre,M., D. Richon, and H. Renon, 1981. New variable volume cell for
determining vapor-liquid equilibria and saturated liquid molar volumes by
the static method, Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundam., 20: 284 - 289.
Ott, J.B., I.F. Holscher, and G-M. Schneider, 1986. Liquid t liquid phase equi-
libria in methanol t heptane and t octane at pressures from 1 to 150 MPa,
J. Chem. Thermodyn., in press.
Radosz, M., 1984. Variable-volume circulation apparatus for measuring high-
pressure fluid-phase equilibria, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 88: 859 - 862.
Redlich, O., and J.N.S. Kwong, 1949. On the thermodynamicsof solutions, V.: An
equation of state - fugacities of gaseous solutions, Chem. Reviews, 44:
233 - 244.
RBRling, G.L., and E.U. Franck, 1983. Solubility of anthracene in dense gases
and liquids to 200°C and 2000 bar, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 87: 882 -
890.
Schneider, G.M., 1975. Phase equilibria of liquid and gaseous mixtures at high
pressures. In: B. Le Neindre and B. Vodar (Editors), Experimental Thermody-
namics, Vol. II, Chapter 16, Part 2, Butterworths,London, pp. 787 - 801.
Specovius, J., M.A. Leiva, R.L. Scott, and C.M. Knobler, 1981. Tricritical phe-
nomena in "quasi-binary"mixtures of hydrocarbons: 2. binary ethane systems,
J. Phys. Chem., 85: 2313 - 2316.
Streett, W.B., and J.C.G. Calado, 1978. Liquid-vapourequilibrium for hydrogen/
nitrogen at temperatures from 63 to 110 K and pressures to 57 MPa, J. Chem.
Thermodynamics,10: 1089 - 1100.
Swaid, I., 1984. Doctoral Dissertation:NIR-spektroskopischeUntersuchungenzum
Phasenverhaltenvon Decan t CO?, Adamantan t CO, sowie Octacosan t CO, im
Temperaturbereich300 - 450 K und bei Driickenbis 1 kbar, Ruhr-Universitat
Bochum.
Swaid, I., D. Nickel, and G.M. Schneider, 1985. NIR-spectroscopicinvestigation
on phase behaviour of low-volatile organic substances in supercritical car-
bon dioxide, Fluid Phase Equil., 21: 95 - 112.
Weber, W., S. Zeck, and H. Knapp, 1984. Gas solubilities in liquid solvents at
high pressures: apparatus and results for binary and ternary systems of N2,
CO2 and CHoOH, Fluid Phase Equil., 18: 253 - 278.
Wisotzki, K.-D., 1984. Doctoral Dissertation: Fluid-Phasengleichgewichteund
kritische Erscheinungen in den binaren Systemen N, t Ethan, N, t Pentan und
CF, + 2-Methylpropan zwischen 88 K und 313 K und bei DrDcken bis 200 MPa,
Ruhr-UniversitatBochum.
Wisotzki, K.-D., and G.M. Schneider, 1985. Fluid Phase Equilibria of the binary
systems N, t ethane and N, t pentane between 88 K and 313 K and at pressures
up to 200 MPa, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem., 89: 21 - 25.
Yonker, C.R., B.W. Wright, H.R. Udseth, and R.D. Smith, 1984. New methods for
characterization of supercritical fluid solutions, Ber. Bunsenges. Phys.
Chem., 88: 908 - 911.
Young, C.L., 1978. Experimentalmethods for studying phase behaviour of mixtu-
res at high temperatures and pressures, In: M.L. McGlashan, ed., Specialist
Periodical Reports, Chemical Thermodynamics, Vol. 2, The Chemical Society,
London, pp. 71 - 146.