Marking Rubrics for Part A: Short Review

Rating Score
0 1 2 3
Overall content Information is Information is Information is Information is gathered
gathered from gathered from gathered from from multiple, research-
single source. multiple sources but multiple, research- based sources. (Updated
mainly are from based sources. with articles that published
webpage/Wikipedia/ (Updated with after year 2010)
blogspot sources. articles published
before year 2010)

Properties of No discussion is Discuss the chemical Briefly discuss the Provide details discussion
the selected given on the structures & unique chemical structures on the chemical structures
nanoparticle chemical structures properties of the & unique properties & unique properties of the
and unique selected nanoparticle of the selected selected nanoparticle
properties of the but with major nanoparticle. accurately.
selected scientific mistake
nanoparticle. found.
Detail on the No discussion is Contains ONLY 1 or Adequately discuss Provide in-depth discussion
selected given on the 2 of the following: ALL of the on ALL of the following:
application selected application. - The working following: - The working
principle/mechanism of - The working principle/mechanism of the
the nanoparticle in the principle/mechanism nanoparticle in the selected
selected application. of the nanoparticle in application.
- Accurately correlate the selected - Accurately correlate the
the selected application. selected application to the
application to the - Accurately correlate unique properties of the
unique properties of the selected nanoparticle.
the nanoparticle. application to the - Accurately show how the
- Accurately show how unique properties of application being improved
the application being the nanoparticle. upon the usage of
improved upon the - Accurately show nanoparticles.
usage of nanoparticles how the application
being improved upon
the usage of
nanoparticles
Nano(toxicity) No related Major scientific Briefly state the Provide detail on the
& information is mistake is found in toxicity of this toxicity of this
Sustainability given. the given nanoparticle and its nanoparticle, its impact to
information. impact to human/environment, and
human/environment nicely correlated to at least
. one of the SDG.

Future No related Major scientific Briefly state he Provide scientifically-

prospect information is mistake is found in future prospect of sound opinion on the future
given. the given opinion. the selected prospect of the selected
nanoparticle @ the nanoparticle @ the selected
(e.g. the given future selected application. application.
prospect is non-logic
or too ideal/cannot be
done in reality)
Total = (?/15)*10%
(by Dr. Yeap Swee Pin)
 Marking Rubrics for Part B: Oral presentation

Rating Score
0 1 2 3
Audience cannot Audience has Student presents Student presents
Organization understand difficulty following information in information in logical,
presentation presentation because logical sequence interesting sequence which
because there is no student jumps which audience can audience can follow and
sequence of around. follow. understanding easily.
information.
Content of the The content of the The content of the The content of the The content of the slide is
presentation slide is not accurate slide is too brief with slide is accurate, accurate, contain all the
slide and contain major missing of many contain some of the necessary scientific
faults in the scientific necessary scientific information & easily
scientific information. information, part of understood.
information. the content is hardly
understood.

Subject Student does not Student is Student is at ease Student demonstrates full
Knowledge have grasp of uncomfortable with with expected knowledge by answering
information; student information and is answers to all all panel questions with
cannot answer able to answer only questions, without explanations and
questions about rudimentary elaboration. elaboration
subject. questions

Total = (?/9)*4%
(by Dr. Yeap Swee Pin)