Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Newoton Raphson 115467-278925-1-PB
Newoton Raphson 115467-278925-1-PB
Indian Journal of Science and Technology, Vol 10(33), DOI: 10.17485/ijst/2017/v10i33/115467, September 2017 ISSN (Online) : 0974-5645
Abstract
Objectives: This paper proposes a fast strategy to extract the electrical parameters of photovoltaic cell (PV) and determine
both the minoritycarrier’s lifetime and the diffusion lengths of photovoltaic cell using the double-diode model. Methods/
Statistical Analysis: The polycrystalline silicon (poly-Si) junction is chosen in this work due to the importance of its
proprieties in industrial and economic fields. The proposed method to extract the PV electrical parameters contains two
steps. The first is based on the graphical adjustments to choose the initial values of these parameters, and the second
method uses numerical approach based on the Modified Newton-Rap son’s algorithm. Findings: The values of obtained
parameters are compared to the others methods and give a considerable agreement. The statistical errors (MBE and
t-statistic) are about 10-8 and 10-10 respectively. Furthermore, the found values of both the minoritycarrier’s lifetime and the
diffusion lengths are precisely comparable with theoretical models, and give a best value. Application/Improvements:
The obtained values give very useful information on the cell intrinsic quality, and can improve the conception and realization
performances of the solar cell with high conversion efficiency.
1. Introduction
are not given by the data sheet of the manufacturer of
In recent years, the Photovoltaic Cells (PVC) based on
these PVC. Moreover, they are not directly measurable by
semiconductor junction, in particular on polycrystalline
the experimental set-ups. Several numerical techniques
silicon (poly-Si), know a great focus because they have
have been used for the identification of these parameters
several proprieties as the low cost and simplicities during
such as the least square method5, the Newton’s method6,
manufacturing stages. Many research works in the PVC
and the Levenberg Marquardt’s method7.
fields allow to ameliorate the photovoltaic conversion effi-
In this work, the used model of PVC depends on
ciencies to exceed the range between 19.8% and 23%1,2. To
seven electrical parameters
better understand of the physical mechanisms inside the
(Photocurrent Iph , diffusion saturation current Is1, ide-
solar cell, we must to precisely determine these electrical
parameters values. The real model of PVC contains both ality factor n1 of diode 1, and recombinationsaturation
the series and parallel resistances, and two ideal diodes3,4. current Is2 , ideality factor n2 of the second diode, series
A good handling of this model requires precise determi- resistance Rs and shunt resistance Rsh). The proposed
nation of its electrical parameters. The values of the latter method in this work is based on the Newton’s algorithm.
One of the problems in using this last is the choice of the of the electron doesn’t follow a direct transition from the
initial values; a poor choice of these conduction to the valence bands, but it follows an indi-
Parameters can produce a divergence of this method. rect transition via the recombination zones which his
This is why it is interesting to initialize energy level is located in forbidden band gap. Also, the
The Newton’s method with values given by other
bulk recombination lifetime of minority carriers τ SRH is
complementary methods, such as the graphical one8.
Nowadays, a better determination of the minority carrier’s highly depending on the density and the position of these
lifetime permits judging the quality of the PVC mate- traps. The τ SRH is identified by the following equation13:
rial9. A high value of lifetime indicates a good material,
while a low lifetime can inform the inadequate technical
problems of PVC construction as a dislocations or high
impurity concentrations in this material10,11.
The objective of this paper, in one hand, is to deter-
mine the seven electrical parameters of the p-n Si-poly
using the developed algorithm. In the other hand, the
exploitation of the found electrical parameters make it
possible to deduce both the minority carrier’s lifetime and
diffusion lengths using the analytical method.
2 Vol 10 (33) | September 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
El hadi Chahid, Mohammed Idali Oumhand and Abdessamad Malaoui
The best choice of initial parameters can accelerate 3.2 Diode Ideality Factors
the algorithm convergence. Contrary, poor initial values
In equation (1), the first diode (D1) represents a diffu-
increase the iterations number and can affect on the opti-
sion process of load carriers, while the second diode (D2)
mization algorithm. In literature many techniques can
represents the carrier’s recombination in the space charge
determine the initial parameters of PVC used to start the
region. Several authors use the ideality factors (n1 = 1 and
Newton Rap son’s method14,15.
n1 = 2) in ideal cell but these values become unsuitable
3.1 Resistances Values of Rs and Rsh for a real diode17,18. To initialize these factors ( n , n ) we
0
1
0
2
=
• In the high voltage values of the curve I = f (V), With, A11 exp ( ( I sc Rs ) / ( n1Vt ) ) − 1 ,
the current through the cell is given by:
=A12 [exp ( I sc Rs ) / (n2Vt ) ) − 1] ,
I ph − I 0 exp ( β (V + Rs I ) / n )
Ic =
= (7) A21 exp((Vco ) / (n1Vt ) ) − 1 ,
To determine the Rs series resistance, the voltage V is
written as independent variable in Eq. (7) to give =
the fol- A22 [exp ( (Vco ) / (n2Vt ) ) ) − 1] ,
lowing equation:
n n B1 = I ph − I sc − ( I sc Rs ) / Rsh ,
=V ln ( I pA / I 0 ) − Rs I + ln (1 − I c / I pa ) (8)
β β
B=
2 I ph − Vco / Rsh .
The (-R ) is the slope of this equation and the tan (α)
s
The system solution formed by the equation (13)&(14)
at the point (V = Voc, I = 0), can be written as:
is given as follows20:
tan (α ) = ( dI / dV )V =V = −1/ Rs 0 (9)
oc =I s01 ( B2 A12 − B1 A22 ) / det (15)
0
The initial value of photocurrent I ph can be deduced I s02
= ( B2 A11 − B1 A21 ) / det (16)
from R s0 , R sh 0 and Isc as:
Where (dot) is the matrix determinant: det = (A22A12
= 0
I ph I sc ( Rs 0 + Rsh 0 ) / Rsh 0 (10) - A12 A21)
Vol 10 (33) | September 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 3
A Fast Strategy to Determine the Physical and Electrical Parameters of Silicon Photovoltaic Cell
m m
In this study, the function variables are x1, x2 ,...xM. Where Ii , Vi are the measured current and volt-
these latter represent seven electrical parameters of PVC.
These variables are the elements of the vector X = [x1, x2
( )
age respectively? I Vim , X Is the calculated current by
,...xM] and the problem is presented by (N) equations as equation? (1), and ( X ) is electrical parameters vector
the following compacted form F1 (x1, x2 ,...xM ) = 0 with(i
= 1, 2, ..., N). The obtained system contains a equations defined in equation. (29). as it is observed in Figure 3a,
number greater than the seven parameters. In this case, & 3b, satisfactory agreement is remarkable between the
the obtained Jacobian matrix (J) is not a square matrix, so obtained results and the experimental data. To confirm
we must use the pseudo inverse of the Jacobian (J)+. Thus, this observation, the deviation between the measured and
the parameters vector (X) to be identified are updated at the calculated current is relatively small; it does not exceed
each iteration of the modified Newton-Rap son’s method 7 mA Figure 3c. By analyzing the error variation in this
(MNR)21: curve, the output voltage increases significantly with error
(E). This result obliges us to take into account the step
X i=
+1 X i − J + .[ F ]i (19) voltage (δ V ) which is variable during the measurement
i
process. Therefore, for the high voltage measurement, the
Where X i is the vector containing the resulting values of step voltage must be small.
Using developed method, the initial values of seven
parameters at iteration ( i ) , Fi is the elements of vector
electrical parameters and their optimal final values are
F and ( i= 1, …, N ) and ( N ) is the number of values listed in Table 1. In this table, some reference values are
presented to be compared with the final ones24. It’s noted
in a set of data). The row vector elements (J i ) is given by: that the initial and final values are closer but they show
Ji =[∂Fi / ∂x1 , ∂Fi / ∂x 2 ,…, ∂Fi / ∂x M ] , and the itera- significant variations. Also, the found optimal values by
the developed method are very similar to those given in
tive process will stop, when the error å
X i +1 − X i ≤ . The the reference. These results show the importance of ini-
tialization stage because they permit a fast convergence of
main steps of computational algorithm to estimate the PV
developed algorithm. To analyze the performance of the
parameters are shown in Figure 2. proposed technique, many statistical errors are calculated
4 Vol 10 (33) | September 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
El hadi Chahid, Mohammed Idali Oumhand and Abdessamad Malaoui
and interpreted. These indicators are the standard devia- Table 2. Statistical indicators results of electrical model
tion (SD), the root mean square error (RMSE), the mean Indicators statistics Our method In reference24
bias error (MBE), and the “t-statistics”. Their analytical SD(10-3) 2.79 20.32
expressions are defined as follows8,24:
RMSE (10-3) 2.73 19.92
MBE (10-3) 5.1×10-5 -14.10
1 N
( )
2
∑ t (10 ) 9.3×10 5.01
-5 -5
=SD I i − I im ,
N − 1 i =1
1 N
∑(I )
2
RMSE
= i − I im ,
N i =1
(21)
1 N
MBE
=
N
∑(I
i =1
i −I i
m
),
Vol 10 (33) | September 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 5
A Fast Strategy to Determine the Physical and Electrical Parameters of Silicon Photovoltaic Cell
studied parameters in this relationship are the minority For silicon semiconductor, the density (n1) as a func-
carrier lifetimes (τn, τp) and length diffusion (Ln, Lp) in tion of the temperature (T) can be written as27:
regions P and N respectively. In this work, a surface (S = 2
cm2) of p-n Silicon is chosen with other physical param- n i = 4.34 ×1015 × T 3/2 exp ( −6493 / T ) (29)
eters listed in Table 3.
In literature, the current densities (J01, J02) of diode 1 Table 3 can be exploited to determine the physi-
and 2 respectively are defined as25,26: cal parameters (τ n , τ p , Ln , and L p ) using equations
(22)-(29). These parameters are presented in Table 4 and
ni2 ni2 compared with those found by other research28,29.
=J 01 q Dn / τ n + q Dp / τ p
Na Nd They show a small difference between τ1 in the equa-
(22) tion (28) and their references. However, the difference
J 02 ≈ π qWni / τ nτ p of (τp) is important which approximately equal to 10%;
(23) the calculated (τp) is greater about 10 times than in refer-
Where (ni) is the intrinsic carrier density, (W) is deple- ence29. This difference due to existing of recombination
tion layer width, (Na) and (Nd) are acceptor and donor mechanism in the depletion region. Generally, these
densities, (Dn) and (Dp) are the diffusion coefficients of mechanisms are neglected in standard J02 formula30. The
minority carriers, (τn) and (τp) are lifetimes of minority analytical expression of J02 must be corrected by an effec-
carriers in P and N regions respectively. In equation (23) tive coefficient (α) as (. In this case, the values of these
the expression (W) is given as: parameters are, Lp = 12 μm, and α = 3π.
( )
2 𝜏n(s) 2.35×10-5 1.17×10-5
a τp − ( cJ 01 / J 02 ) τ p + bc / J 02 =
0 (27)
𝜏p(s) 1.36×10-8 1.18×10-7
Ln(µm) 285 201
The solution of this equation is:
=τp (( cJ 01 / J 02 ) ± )/ (28)
Lp(µm) 4 12
6 Vol 10 (33) | September 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
El hadi Chahid, Mohammed Idali Oumhand and Abdessamad Malaoui
model. The advantages of this model are the real repre- 9. Haynes JR, Shockley W. The Mobility and Life of Injected
sentation of the intrinsic material phenomena. Also it Holes and Electrons in Germanium. Physical Review. 1951
can give information about the recombination of charge Mar; 81(5):835–43. Crossref
carries due to the inevitable defects in the material. The 10. Elani Ussama AI. The effective carrier lifetime measurement
proposed method is based on the initialization values of in silicon: The conductivity modulation method.Journal of
King Saud University – Science. 2010; 22(1):9–13. Crossref
seven electrical parameters with graphical method and
11. Corbett JW, Bourgoin JC. Les défauts ponctuels dans les
the development of new algorithm. This later is based on
semiconducteurs.Journal de Physique Colloques. 1978;
the Newton Rap son’s method to determine the optimal 39(2):17–21. Crossref
values of these parameters. The obtained results com- 12. Chahid E, Oumhanad I, Feddaoui M, Malaoui A. Study of
pared with theory and some previously published work the physical parameters on the GaAs solar cell efficiency.
show a good agreement with I-V experimental data. This Journal of Ovonic Research. 2017 May- Jun; 13(3):119–28.
method is very simple to use in real times measurements, 13. Hovel HJ. Semiconductors and Semimetals. New York:
and can determine easily many physical parameters like Academic. 1975; 11:86–100.
the minority carrier lifetime, diffusion length though 14. Laudani A, Riganti-Fulginei F, Salvini A. High perfor-
recombination current densities. The determined values ming extraction procedure for the one-diode model of a
comparing with the theoretical models show an excellent photovoltaic panel from experimental I-V curves by using
agreement in level of physical and electrical parameters reduced forms. Solar Energy. 2014; 103:316–26. Crossref
15. Ghani F, Duke M, Carson J. Numerical calculation of series
extraction.
and shunt resistance of a photovoltaic cell using the Lambert
W-function: experimental evaluation. Solar Energy. 2013;
7. References 87:246–53. Crossref
16. Bouzidi K, Chegaar M, Bouhemadou A. Solar cells parame-
1. Zhao J, Wang A, Campbell P, Green MA. A 19.8% efficient
ters evaluation considering the series and shunt resistance.
honeycomb multicrystalline silicon solar cell with impro-
Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells. 2007; 91:1647–51.
ved light trapping. IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices.
Crossref
1999; 46(10):1978–83. Crossref
17. Malaoui A. New method for improving the quality of electri-
2. Green MA, Emery K, Hishikawa Y, Warta W, Dunlop
cal measurements: application to the extraction of the intrinsic
ED. Solar cell efficiency tables (version 37). Progress in
parameters of the photovoltaic cells. International Journal of
Photovoltaics: Research and Applications. 2016; 2 (1):3–11.
Crossref Innovation and Applied Studies. 2016; 15(2):375–86.
3. Chahid E, Idali MO, Feddaoui M, Erritali M and Malaoui 18. Malaoui A, El mansouri A. Deux nouvelles méthodes com-
A. Effect of measurement factors on photovoltaic cell plémentaires pour l’extraction optimale des paramètres
parameters extracting. International Journal of Electrical électriques des jonctions.Revue des Energies Renouvelables.
and Computer Engineering - IJECE. 2017 Feb; 7(1):50–7. 2010; 13(2) :199–212.
4. Revati D, Natarajan E. Enhancing the Efciency of Solar Cell 19. Appelbaum J, Peled A. Parameters extraction of solar cells-A
by Air Cooling. Indian Journal of Science and Technology. comparative examination of three methods. Solar Energy
2016 Feb; 9(5):1–6. Crossref Materials and Solar Cells. 2014; 122:164–73. Crossref
5. Press W H, Vettering WT, Teukolsky SA. Numerical 20. Adel A, Hamdi A, Montaser A. Deduction of two diode
Recipes in C: The Art of Scientific Computing. 2nd edition. model parameters for photovoltaic system. Proceedings of
UK: Cambridge University Press. 1992; 1–949. the 3rd International Conference on Energy Systems and
6. Gupta MK, Jain R. Design and Simulation of Photovoltaic Technologies, Cairo, Egypt. 2015. p. 121–35.
Cell Using Decrement Resistance Algorithm. Indian Journal 21. Ben-Isael A. A Newton-Raphson method for the solution of
of Science and Technology. 2013 May; 6(5):4537–41. systems of equations. Journal of Mathematical Analysis and
7. Marquardt D. An Algorithm for Least Squares Estimation Applications.1966; 15(2):243–52. Crossref
of Non Linear Parameters. Journal of the Society for 22. Easwarakhanthan T, Bottin J, Bouhouch I, Boutrit C.
Industrial and Applied Mathematics. 1963; 11(2):431–41. Nonlinear Minimization Algorithm for Determining the
Crossref Solar Cell Parameters with Microcomputers. International
8. Malaoui A, Barrah E, Antari J. Implementation a new Journal of Sustainable Energy. 1986; 4(1):1–12. Crossref
approach for modeling and determining the electri- 23. Green MA, Blakers AW, Shi JQ, Keller EM, Wenham SR.
cal parameters of solar cells. International Journal of High efficiency silicon solar cells.IEEE Transactions on
Innovation and Applied Studies. 2016; 15(2):329–38. Electron Devices. 1984; 31:679–83. Crossref
Vol 10 (33) | September 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 7
A Fast Strategy to Determine the Physical and Electrical Parameters of Silicon Photovoltaic Cell
24. Al Rashidi MR, El-Naggar KM, Al Hajri MF. Parameters talline silicon.Journal of Applied Physics. 2003; 93:5447–55.
Estimation of Double Diode Solar Cell Model. International Crossref
Journal of Electrical, Computer, Energetic, Electronic and 27. Varshni YP.Temperature dependence of the energy gap in
Communication Engineering. 2013; 7(2):118–21. semiconductors. Physica. 1967; 34:149–54. Crossref
25. Simoen E, Vantellmont J, Layes C. Effective generation-re- 28. Yang ES. Microelectronics Devices.New York: McGraw-
combination parameters in high-energy proton irradiated Hill. 1988.
silicon diodes. Applied Physics Letters. 1996; 69:2858–60. 29. Liou J, Wong WW. Comparison and optimization of the
Crossref performance of Si and GaAs. Solar Energy Materials and
26. Taretto K, Rau U, Werner JH. Method to extract diffusion Solar Cells. 1992; 28(1):9–28. Crossref
length from solar cell parameters-Application to polycrys- 30. Sze SM. Physics of Semiconductor Devices. 2th edition.
John Wiley & Sons. 1981; 868pp. PMCid:PMC348793
8 Vol 10 (33) | September 2017 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology