Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Improved Three-Phase, Five-Level Pulse-Width Modulation Switched Vsi
Improved Three-Phase, Five-Level Pulse-Width Modulation Switched Vsi
Research Article
ISSN 1755-4535
Improved three-phase, five-level pulse-width Received on 6th December 2013
Accepted on 5th October 2014
modulation switched voltage source inverter doi: 10.1049/iet-pel.2014.0133
www.ietdl.org
Charles I. Odeh ✉
Department of Electrical Engineering, University of Nigeria, Nsukka, Nigeria
✉ E-mail: charles.odeh@unn.edu.ng
Abstract: This study presents an improved three-phase, five-level pulse-width modulation (PWM) switched voltage source
inverter. The single-carrier, multilevel PWM scheme is employed to generate the gating signals for the power switches.
Operational principles with switching functions are given. By controlling the amplitude modulation index, three- and
five-level output phase voltage waveforms can be achieved. For modulation indices of 0.45, and 0.9, the proposed
inverter topology was subjected to an R–L load and the respective number of output voltage level were synthesised.
For a step change in the modulation index, the response of the proposed multilevel inverter circuit topology is
demonstrated. Fast Fourier transform analyses of the output line voltage waveforms, at the indicated depth of
modulation, were carried out and the corresponding total harmonic distortion values were obtained. Comparison of the
proposed inverter configuration and the classical 3-f topologies is given based on the power circuit component count.
Moreover, analysis of the conduction power losses in the power semiconductor switches of the proposed inverter
topology is given. To verify the performance of the proposed inverter architecture, simulations and experiments are
carried out on a 3.46 kW rated prototype of the proposed inverter for an R–L load; and adequate results are presented.
1 Introduction inverters [17–30]. In all, the driving objective is to obtain a high level
of stepped output voltage waveforms, which result in low total
High power demanding industries are usually connected to medium harmonic distortion (THD), with fewer power circuit components
voltage grids. For connecting power electronic converters to medium and/or minimum number of input DC sources, for medium and
voltage grids two trends are observed, one using classic power high power applications.
converter topologies with high-voltage power semiconductor With this pivot objective, works done in [31, 32] achieved the
switches and other using new multilevel converter (MLC) enhancement of the basic H-bridge inverter configuration for
topologies with medium voltage semiconductor switches. Out of single- and three-phase applications. In [31], an auxiliary steering
these two trends, MLCs have become popular for medium voltage circuit is inserted between the midpoint of two DC sources and the
high power applications because of reduced rating of power H-bridge configuration. This 1-ɸ power circuit arrangement is
semiconductor devices, improved quality of output voltage, near capable of synthesising five-level output voltage. Also, proposed
sinusoidal input currents, lower common-mode voltages, less dv/dt in [32] is a 3-ɸ, three-level pulse-width modulation (PWM)
stress, smaller input and output filters, increased efficiency because switched voltage source (SVS) inverter, which has the inherent
of possibility of low switching operation, reduced output torque capability of employing one common DC-supply to synthesise
ripple, reduced electromagnetic interference problems and possible five-level output line voltages.
fault-tolerant operation [1–6]. In furtherance of the aforementioned concept of fewer power
The popular multilevel topologies are neutral-point converter circuit components and/or minimum number of input DC sources
(NPC) or diode-clamped converter [7], flying-capacitor (FC) for an appreciable output voltage levels, this paper presents an
converters [8] and cascaded H-bridge (CHB) converter [9]. In improved 3-ɸ, five-level, PWM SVS inverter; wherein two equal
addition, generalised multilevel inverter topology with self-voltage DC sources and auxiliary steering circuits are introduced in the
balancing [10], mixed-level hybrid multilevel cells [11], SVS inverter configuration in [32]. With appropriate single-carrier
asymmetric hybrid multilevel cells [12] and soft switched PWM switching scheme, the proposed inverter topology is capable
multilevel inverters [13–15] have been proposed. The topology of of generating nine-level output line voltages. The increased output
NPC inverter is limited to three-level operation because of voltage level leads to a considerable reduction in the output
capacitor voltage balancing issues as well as excessive clamping voltage THD.
diodes required for high level inverters [4]. The topology of The aforementioned effect is of prime importance in
capacitor-clamped inverters is limited to three-level or four-level transformerless power conditioning systems and makes the
because of several limitations like a capacitor voltage balance proposed inverter configuration well suited for these systems.
requirement, pre-charge of the capacitors at the start and need of Moreover, in drive systems conventional multilevel PWM inverters
larger number of capacitors. In addition, this topology is not generate common-mode voltage or a ‘neutral shift effect’ within
suitable for low and medium switching frequencies because of the the motor windings. This common mode voltage may build up the
high cost of FCs [16]. For higher-level operation, cascaded motor shaft voltage through electrostatic couplings between the
inverters are preferred as they require the least number of rotor and the stator windings and between the rotor and the frame
components compared to other topologies as well as modularised [33]. Moreover, since the conventional inverters have a DC offset
circuit layout; and packaging is possible, because each level has voltage between the ground and the motor neutral point, the
the similar structure [16]. Although the modular structure solves common mode voltage becomes higher and the motor
the voltage imbalance problem, this approach requires many line-to-ground voltage may be much higher than its rated
isolated DC sources and link voltage controllers. line-to-neutral (phase) voltage. Therefore the transformerless
In recent years, several topologies with various control techniques design of the drive with the conventional PWM inverters may
have been presented for single- and three-phase cascaded multilevel cause a much larger common-mode leakage current to flow into
the ground [33] and cause a high-voltage stress on motor insulation have the same ground with the input DC source, and the motor
life. However, in the case of the proposed multilevel inverter line-to-ground voltage is identical to its phase voltage. Therefore,
configuration, the neutral point of the motor stator windings can the ‘neutral shift effect’ disappears, and as long as the motor phase
g1a g2a g3a g4a g5a Inverter type Proposed Diode-clamped FCs CHB
inverter
0 on on off off off
VS off off on off on main 15 24 24 24
2VS on off on off off switching
0 off off on on off device
−VS off on off off on main diodes 15 18 0 0
−2VS off on off on off DC bus 2 1 (split into four by 1 6
(non-isolated) DC-link capacitors) (isolated)
clamping 3 0 18 0
capacitor
Fig. 3 Switching pattern, for phase ‘a’, of the 3-ɸ, five-level pulse-width modulated SVS inverter and switching angles
where Ac is the peak-to-peak value of the triangular carrier signal, Am For Ma equal to or less than 0.5, only the upper reference wave, R1
is the peak value of the rectified sinusoidal reference signals and k is is compared with the triangular carrier signal, T. The inverter’s
the number of voltage levels synthesised, per half-cycle; in this case, behaviour matches exactly to that of the SVS inverter proposed in
k = 3. Table 3 shows the ranges of modulation index and the [32], synthesising three-level output voltage waveform per phase
corresponding values of the phase angle displacement. Also, the for a period. On the other hand, Ma is set to be greater than 0.5
frequency modulation index expression is for five-level output phase voltage to be produced in this work. In
this case, the two reference signals, R1 and R2 have to be
compared with the triangular carrier signal to produce switching
fc signals for the power switches.
Mf = (2)
fm Considering phase ‘a’, and referring to Fig. 2, the gating signals
are then given by the use of basic logical AND, OR and NOT gates
where fc and fm are the frequencies corresponding to the carrier and
modulating signals, respectively. g1a = (T . R1 ) + (R2 . T ) · A (3)
4 Analysis of the SVS inverter module Also, the conduction loss expression, PD, for the diodes in the power
circuit can be written as
Analytical expressions for the average conduction power losses in
the main power semiconductor switches can be obtained in terms
of the voltage and current amplitudes, depth of modulation and VDO Im p K I 2 p 2
PD = 1 − Ma cos f + D m − Ma cos f (10)
power factor for typical conditions prevailing in pulse-width 2p 4 2p 4 3
modulated inverters, [37]. For each of the active switches
(insulated gate bipolar transistors – IGBT) used herein, a good
approximation for the average on-state loss, PT, is where VDO and KD are the constant on-state voltage across a diode
and on-state resistance, respectively. Similarly, (10) can be
VTO Im p K I 2 p 2 rewritten as
PT = 1 + Ma cos f + T m + Ma cos f (8)
2p 4 2p 4 3
PD = PDC + PDV (11)
where VTO, KT, Im, Ma and f are the constant on-state voltage across
a switch, on-state resistance, peak load current through a device, Equations (8) and (10) can be normalised to have the
applied modulation index and power factor angle, respectively. three-dimensional plots of
Fig. 7 Phase ‘a’ capacitor and switches’ voltages and currents waveforms for Ma = 0.9
5 Simulation and experimental results
vo 2
=M =
(16)
2Vs 5.1 Simulation results
8t
1+ 1 + 2L
D The operational principles and the switching scheme of the improved
SVS inverter shown in Fig. 3 and Table 1 have been investigated by
MATLAB SIMULINK simulation. A balanced three-phase star
where tL = L/RTs ; Ts is the switching period; and R is the load connected R–L load with 40 Ω resistance and 60 mH inductance
resistance. per phase were used for input voltages of 100 V each.
Fig. 5 shows the simulated waveforms of the output voltages and 26.20 and 12.28% for Ma = 0.45 and 0.9, respectively, are
load current at switching frequency of 3 kHz for the indicated obtained in the line voltage waveforms.
loading condition, when modulation indices are 0.45 and 0.9. The
phase voltage waveforms in Fig. 5 exhibit three-levels: VS, 0 and
−VS; while the corresponding line-to-line voltage waveforms show 5.2 Experimental results
five-levels: 2VS, VS, 0, −VS and −2VS. Furthermore, increasing Ma
to 0.9 results in the synthesised phase voltage waveforms to have Based on the simulation results, a laboratory prototype of the
a five-levels: 2VS, VS, 0, −VS and −2VS, whereas the improved 3-f, five-level PWM SVS inverter was set up and tested
corresponding line voltages have a nine-levels: 4VS, 3VS, 2VS, VS, to verify its validity. Table 4 gives the prototype specifications and
0, −VS, −2VS, −3VS and −4VS as earlier predicted. For a step parameters. The aforementioned modulation scheme is
change in the modulation index, the response of the proposed implemented by using basic CMOS logic gates and TL 084 IC
multilevel inverter circuit topology is demonstrated in Fig. 7. and hence, the 15 gating pulses were generated.
Considering phase ‘a’ module of the SVS inverter, the switches’ Fig. 9 shows the inverter prototype and experimentally obtained
and capacitor voltages and current waveforms are shown in Fig. 6. gating signals of phase ‘a’ leg. Fig. 10 shows the experimental
This figure shows that the output phase voltage levels of the SVS waveforms of the inverter output voltages for the specified loading
inverter are principally determined by the blocking voltages of the condition in Table 4, where the depth of modulation is 0.45.
power switches and the capacitor voltage as demonstrated in Furthermore, increasing the amplitude modulation index to 0.9
Figs. 7 and 11b. results in the synthesis of higher level of inverter output voltages,
Spectral analysis of the inverter line voltage waveforms in Fig. 5 is as experimentally depicted in Fig. 11. In Fig. 12, the
carried out for the varied amplitude modulation index values. The corresponding line currents and one of the capacitor voltage were
spectral results are displayed in Fig. 8; wherein THD values of shown.
Fig. 12 Experimental output line currents and capacitor voltage for Ma = 0.9
a Line currents
b Capacitor voltage