Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Epoxidation of Soybean Oil in Toluene With
Epoxidation of Soybean Oil in Toluene With
Research Paper
highest conversion rate but not necessarily at the highest side reactions. In this work, we compared the kinetics of
conversion. The kinetics for each individual set of condi- the epoxidation of soybean oil in toluene with peroxo-
tions differ. In our study, we selected the synthesis in so- acetic and peroxoformic acid generated “in situ” in the
lution in order to minimize side reactions and to obtain a presence of an ion exchange resin as catalyst. The mea-
high epoxy yield. sured kinetic parameters were the rate constants at 40,
60 and 80 °C and the activation energies. The extent of
The objective of this work was to find the conditions for a side reactions that may have taken place was determined
maximum epoxy yield and to compare the kinetics of the by titration, Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy
epoxidation with peroxoformic and peroxoacetic acids (FTIR), gel permeation chromatography (GPC) and vis-
formed “in situ”, as well as to analyze the type and extent cosity measurements.
of side reactions. We were particularly concerned with the
polymerization reaction as a result of the ring opening,
2 Materials and methods
since it contributes considerably to the increase of viscos-
ity. It is known that epoxidation in solution is preferable if 2.1 Materials
the minimization of side reactions is desired [1]. The ring
opening caused by formic acid in the presence of isobu- Soybean oil of RBD grade (refined, bleached, deodor-
tanol was found to be a thousand times faster than that ized) and of an iodine number of 125 (Hanus) was ob-
tained from Archer Daniels Midland Company (Decatur,
USA). Glacial acetic acid (certified A.C.S. Plus) from
Correspondence: Zoran Petrović, Pittsburg State University,
Kansas Polymer Research Center, 1501 S. Joplin Street, Pitts-
Fisher Scientific (Pittsburgh, PA, USA), formic acid
burg, KS 66762, USA. Phone: 316-235-4928, Fax: 316-235-4919; (95–97%) from Aldrich (Milwaukee, WI, USA) and a 30%
e-mail: zpetrovi@pittstate.edu (w/w) solution of hydrogen peroxide from Sigma (St.
Louis, MO, USA) were used. Amberlite IR–120 in acid spread on a NaCl plate were analyzed using FTIR to
form was purchased from Supelco (Bellefonte, PA, USA), check the disappearance of the double bonds at
toluene (HPLC grade), ethyl acetate (HPLC grade), and 3009 cm–1 and the formation of the epoxy groups (dou-
sodium sulfate anhydrous from Fisher Scientific. blet at 822 cm–1 and 833 cm–1). The iodine value, as the
measure of concentration of double bonds, was deter-
2.2 Methods mined using the Hanus method [13], and the epoxy oxy-
gen content was measured according to a standard pro-
A FTIR Perkin-Elmer spectrophotometer, model Spec-
cedure for oils and fats [14].
trum-1000 (Perkin-Elmer, Norwalk, CT, USA), was used
to follow the formation of epoxy groups, the disappear-
ance of double bonds and the formation of hydroxyl 3 Results and discussion
groups (side reactions). GPC is a technique used to sep-
arate the molecules according to their sizes, and was “In situ” epoxidations were carried out in the molar ratio of
found to be well suited to follow the formation of dimers 1:0.5:1.5 – double bonds : organic acid : hydrogen perox-
or trimers from the side reactions during synthesis. Wa- ide. The detailed mechanism of the peracid formation dur-
ters GPC model 510, equipped with three Styragel HR ing epoxidation with in situ formed peroxoacetic acid is
Waters columns (covering molecular weights range given in a previous paper of us [3]. While organic acid is
102–106) and differential refractometer model 410 (Waters, converted to peroxoacid and then regenerated, hydrogen
Milford, MA, USA), with tetrahydrofuran as the eluent was peroxide is consumed in the process and the excess of
used to follow the molecular weight increase (polymeriza- 50 mol-% relative to double bonds was considered rea-
tion side reactions). The flow rate of tetrahydrofuran was sonable. The amount of toluene used was 43.9 wt-%
1 ml/min at room temperature. Viscosity was measured at relative to the weight of soybean oil. Ion exchange resin
30 °C with a Rheometric Dynamic Stress Rheometer, was added in an amount of 25 wt-% relative to the sum
model SR–500 (Rheometric Scientific, Inc., Piscataway, of the weights of organic acid and 30% H2O2 solution.
NJ, USA), with parallel plates of 25 mm in diameter, Two series of epoxidations were carried out at three
having a gap of 0.200 mm. different temperatures (40, 60 and 80 °C), one with per-
oxoacetic acid and the other one with peroxoformic acid.
The samples of the first series are designated as SB-
2.2.1 Synthesis
PAA40, SBPAA60 and SBPAA80, where SB stands for
Each synthesis was carried out in a 500-ml three-necked soybean, PAA for peroxoacetic acid and the number for
round-bottom flask equipped with a thermometer sensor, the temperature. Corresponding samples with peroxo-
a mechanical stirrer, and a septum, pierced with an injec- formic acid were designated as SBPFA40, SBPFA60 and
tion needle to equalize pressure. The whole apparatus SBPFA80.
was kept in a water bath to maintain the respective tem-
perature of 40, 60 and 80 ± 0.5 °C. Thus, the temperature The variations of the iodine values and the epoxy oxygen
was measured inside the reaction vessel and in the water contents with reaction time for epoxidations with perox-
bath. 100 g (0.49 mol) of soybean oil, 50 ml of toluene, oacetic acid and peroxoformic acid at the three applied
25.00 g of Amberlite, and either 15.00 g (0.25 mol) of temperatures are presented in Figs. 1 and 2. The iodine
glacial acetic acid or 11.80 g (0.25 mol) of formic acid value is a measure of the concentration of double bonds
were added into the round-bottom flask. With agitation,
83.70 g (0.74 mol) of 30% H2O2 were added slowly
through a separatory funnel during half an hour. This pre-
caution was taken to prevent overheating of the system
due to the exothermic nature of epoxidation reactions. An
ice water bath was prepared to cool off the reaction if
needed. Samples were taken out of the reaction vessel
every hour.
To purify the samples, the solution was first dissolved in
ethyl acetate. The Amberlite was filtered off, and the fil-
trate was poured into a separatory funnel. The washing
with warm water was repeated until the pH was neutral.
The oil phase was further dried above anhydrous sodium
sulfate and then filtered. The solvent was removed using Fig. 1. Comparison of iodine values vs. time for the epox-
a rotary evaporator, first with the help of a water vacuum idation of soybean oil with peroxoacetic and peroxoformic
pump and then under high vacuum. The purified samples acid at 40, 60 and 80 °C.
Eur. J. Lipid Sci. Technol. 104 (2002) 293–299 Epoxidation of soybean oil in toluene 295
k1
AA + H2O2 i PAA + H2O (1)
k2
k1
DB + PAA i EO + AA (2)
Tab. 1. Analysis of the GPC results of epoxidized soybean oils with peroxoacetic and peroxoformic acids.
Sample Temperature [°C] Time [h] area of ESBO [%] area of dimer [%]
SBPAA40 4 99.5 0.5
40 8 99.5 0.5
12 99.2 0.8
SBPAA60 4 99.4 0.6
60 8 99.0 1.0
12 98.8 1.2
SBPAA80 3 98.7 1.3
80 6 98.4 1.6
9 98.2 1.8
12 97.3 2.7
SBPFA40 4 99.4 0.6
40 8 99.3 0.7
12 98.8 1.2
SBPFA60 2 99.3 0.7
60 5 99.1 0.9
9 98.9 1.1
12 98.5 1.5
SBPFA80 2 99.0 1.0
80 5 98.5 1.5
9 97.8 2.2
12 97.9 2.1
increase is significantly higher [15] (the viscosity of the that there was no considerable difference in side reac-
polyol, depending on the number of hydroxyl groups and tions.
substituents on the adjacent carbon atom, is typically
above 2000 mPa s for 3 OH groups per molecule). 3.1 Kinetics of epoxidation
The presence of dimers and trimers in the polyol drives The above-mentioned results were used to determine the
viscosity to about 4000 mPa s. Acetic and formic acids reaction order of the epoxidations carried out with perox-
achieved almost complete conversion in about 3 h at oacetic and peroxoformic acids formed “in situ”, and also
80 °C judging by the time when the final viscosity was to determine the activation energies for the applied ex-
reached. When viscosity is plotted against conversion, all perimental conditions. The general form of the rate equa-
values for the different reaction temperatures and the dif- tion for the conversion of double bonds by peroxoacetic
ferent peroxoacids fell on the same line (Fig. 7) indicating acid (epoxidation reaction 2) may be written as:
References
[1] L. H. Gan, S. H. Goh, K. S. Ooi: Kinetic studies of epoxida-
tion and oxirane cleavage of palm olein methyl esters. J.
Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 69 (1992) 347–351.