Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Transportation Case Digest: Calvo V. UCPB Gen Insurance Co. (2002)
Transportation Case Digest: Calvo V. UCPB Gen Insurance Co. (2002)
FACTS:
At the time material to this case, Transorient Container Terminal
Services, Inc. (TCTSI) owned by Virgines Calvo entered into a contract with
San Miguel Corporation (SMC) for the transfer of 114 reels of semi-chemical
fluting paper and 124 reels of kraft liner board from the Port Area in Manila
to SMC's warehouse at the Tabacalera Compound, Romualdez St., Ermita,
Manila.
The cargo was insured by respondent UCPB General Insurance
Co., Inc.
July 14, 1990: arrived in Manila on board "M/V Hayakawa Maru"
and later on unloaded from the vessel to the custody of the
arrastre operator, Manila Port Services, Inc
July 23 to July 25, 1990: Calvo withdrew the cargo from the
arrastre operator and delivered it to SMC's warehouse in Ermita,
Manila
July 25, 1990: goods were inspected by Marine Cargo
Surveyors, who found that 15 reels of the semi-chemical fluting
paper were "wet/stained/torn" and 3 reels of kraft liner board were
likewise torn
SMC collected payment from UCPB the total damage
of P93,112 under its insurance contract
UCPB brought suit against Calvo as subrogee of SMC
Calvo: Art. 1734(4) The character of the goods or defects
in the packing or in the containers
spoilage or wettage" took place while the goods
were in the custody of either the carrying vessel "M/V Hayakawa
Maru," which transported the cargo to Manila, or the arrastre
operator, to whom the goods were unloaded and who allegedly
kept them in open air for 9 days notwithstanding the fact that
some of the containers were deformed, cracked, or otherwise
damaged
Trial Court: Calvo liable
CA: affirmed
ISSUE: W/N Calvo can be exempted from liability under Art. 1734(4)