Hydroxychloroquine: Trump's Covid-19 'cure' increases deaths, global study finds | Science | The Guardian 2020-05-25, 12:31 PM

Hydroxychloroquine: Trump's Covid819 'cure'

increases deaths, global study finds
Malaria drug should not be used to treat coronavirus, scientists say, after study shows
high death rate

Coronavirus : latest updates

See all our coronavirus coverage

A Utah pharmacist counts out hydroxychloroquine pills. One in six patients taking the drug, or its sister drug, chloroquine, died,
compared with one in 11 patients not taking the drugs. Photograph: George Frey/AFP/Getty

Sarah Boseley Health editor

Fri 22 May 2020 17.32 BST

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2020/may/22/hydroxychloroquine-trumps-covid-19-cure-increases-deaths-global-study-finds Page 1 of 7
Hydroxychloroquine: Trump's Covid-19 'cure' increases deaths, global study finds | Science | The Guardian 2020-05-25, 12:31 PM

Hydroxychloroquine, the anti-malarial drug Donald Trump is taking to prevent Covid-19, has
increased deaths in patients treated with it in hospitals around the world, a study has shown.

A major study of the way hydroxychloroquine and its older version, chloroquine, have been
used on six continents – without clinical trials – reveals a sobering picture. Scientists said the
results meant the drug should no longer be given to Covid-19 patients except in proper research
settings.

While the paper, published online in the Lancet medical journal, is not a trial designed to
assess the drug, it shows that the rush to use it around the world may be ill-advised. Significant
numbers of doctors have been prescribing it without evidence. It is known that the drug can
cause heart irregularities, but many have claimed it is safe because of its long use treating
malaria.

There was a rush to use the drug in Covid-19 cases after the French doctor Didier Raoult said he
was curing his patients at La Timone hospital, in Marseille. The US president then claimed
hydroxychloroquine – less toxic than the original chloroquine – was a cure, and later said he
was taking it himself against coronavirus.

The drugs are fairly safe for patients being treated for malaria, but Covid-19 is a very different
disease. The authors of the paper pulled together results for more than 96,000 patients in 671
hospitals, taking one of the drugs, with or without an antibiotic such as azithromycin, between
20 December and 14 April.

The death rate among all groups taking the drugs was higher than among people who were not
given them. One in six of those taking one of the drugs died, while one in five died if they were
taking chloroquine with an antibiotic, and one in four if they were on hydroxychloroquine and
an antibiotic. The death rate among patients not taking the drugs was one in 11.

The statistics are not exactly comparable because, as this was not a trial, there were differences
in the age, gender, general health and stage of illness of the patients. But the US authors of the
study say, allowing for these differences, there was still higher mortality among those taking
the drugs.

The team also found that serious cardiac arrhythmias, which cause the lower chamber of the
heart to beat rapidly and irregularly, were more common in all the groups receiving one of the
four treatment regimens. The biggest increase was in the group treated with
hydroxychloroquine in combination with an antibiotic, where 8% of patients developed a heart
arrhythmia compared with 0.3% of patients not given the drugs.

“This is the first large-scale study to find statistically robust evidence that treatment with
chloroquine or hydroxychloroquine does not benefit patients with Covid-19,” said Prof
Mandeep R Mehra, lead author of the study and executive director of the Brigham and
Women’s hospital advanced heart disease center in Boston, US.

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2020/may/22/hydroxychloroquine-trumps-covid-19-cure-increases-deaths-global-study-finds Page 2 of 7
Hydroxychloroquine: Trump's Covid-19 'cure' increases deaths, global study finds | Science | The Guardian 2020-05-25, 12:31 PM

“Instead, our findings suggest it may be associated with an increased risk of serious heart
problems and increased risk of death. Randomised clinical trials are essential to confirm any
harms or benefits associated with these agents. In the meantime, we suggest these drugs
should not be used as treatments for Covid-19 outside of clinical trials.”

Others scientists suggested the drugs should no longer be used in Covid-19 treatments, except
for carefully controlled clinical trials.

Dr Stephen Griffin, associate professor in the school of medicine, University of Leeds, said the
paper was “potentially a landmark study for Covid-19 therapy. While not a placebo-controlled
trial, an observational study on this scale undertaken with stringent and meticulous analysis is
powerful indeed,” he said.

“Whilst controlled trials will be required for confident affirmation, the indications are that
these drugs certainly ought not to be used outside of a trial setting where patients can be
monitored for complications. One might also question whether the resources necessary for
large studies might be better diverted to other causes, at the same time allowing the drugs
themselves to be used for their original purpose.

“Furthermore, it is clear that high-profile endorsements of taking these drugs without clinical
oversight are both misguided and irresponsible.”

Stephen Evans, professor of pharmacoepidemiology at the London School of Hygiene and

Tropical Medicine, said it was unlikely that trials would now find any substantial benefit from
the drugs. “A definitive answer still awaits the results of the randomised trials, but it is clear
that the drugs should not be given for treatment of Covid-19 other than in the context of a
randomised trial.

“It might even be said that to go on giving them, other than in a trial, is unethical, given this
evidence that is not yet contradicted by other available evidence.”

News is under threat ...

… just when we need it the most. Millions of readers around the world are flocking to the
Guardian in search of honest, authoritative, fact-based reporting that can help them
understand the biggest challenge we have faced in our lifetime. But at this crucial moment,
news organisations are facing an unprecedented existential challenge. As businesses
everywhere feel the pinch, the advertising revenue that has long helped sustain our journalism
continues to plummet. We need your help to fill the gap.

You’ve read 13 articles in the last six months. We believe every one of us deserves equal access
to quality news and measured explanation. So, unlike many others, we made a different
choice: to keep Guardian journalism open for all, regardless of where they live or what they can
afford to pay. This would not be possible without financial contributions from our readers, who
now support our work from 180 countries around the world.

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2020/may/22/hydroxychloroquine-trumps-covid-19-cure-increases-deaths-global-study-finds Page 3 of 7
Hydroxychloroquine: Trump's Covid-19 'cure' increases deaths, global study finds | Science | The Guardian 2020-05-25, 12:31 PM

We have upheld our editorial independence in the face of the disintegration of traditional
media – with social platforms giving rise to misinformation, the seemingly unstoppable rise of
big tech and independent voices being squashed by commercial ownership. The Guardian’s
independence means we can set our own agenda and voice our own opinions. Our journalism
is free from commercial and political bias – never influenced by billionaire owners or
shareholders. This makes us different. It means we can challenge the powerful without fear
and give a voice to those less heard.

Reader financial support has meant we can keep investigating, disentangling and interrogating.
It has protected our independence, which has never been so critical. We are so grateful.

We need your support so we can keep delivering quality journalism that’s open and
independent. And that is here for the long term. Every reader contribution, however big or
small, is so valuable. Support the Guardian from as little as CA$1 – and it only takes a minute.
Thank you.

Support the Guardian

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2020/may/22/hydroxychloroquine-trumps-covid-19-cure-increases-deaths-global-study-finds Page 4 of 7
Hydroxychloroquine: Trump's Covid-19 'cure' increases deaths, global study finds | Science | The Guardian 2020-05-25, 12:31 PM

Remind me in July

Remind me in July
Email address

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2020/may/22/hydroxychloroquine-trumps-covid-19-cure-increases-deaths-global-study-finds Page 5 of 7
Hydroxychloroquine: Trump's Covid-19 'cure' increases deaths, global study finds | Science | The Guardian 2020-05-25, 12:31 PM

Set my reminder

We will use this to send you a single email in July 2020. To find out what personal data we
collect and how we use it, please visit our Privacy Policy

We will be in touch to invite you to contribute. Look out for a message in your inbox in July
2020. If you have any questions about contributing, please contact us here.
Have you got a minute?
Please answer four short questions to help us improve how we remind our readers to
contribute.
Share your thoughts

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2020/may/22/hydroxychloroquine-trumps-covid-19-cure-increases-deaths-global-study-finds Page 6 of 7
Hydroxychloroquine: Trump's Covid-19 'cure' increases deaths, global study finds | Science | The Guardian 2020-05-25, 12:31 PM

Topics
Medical research
Drugs
Health
Coronavirus outbreak
Donald Trump
Infectious diseases
news

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2020/may/22/hydroxychloroquine-trumps-covid-19-cure-increases-deaths-global-study-finds Page 7 of 7