Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Times: Pirate Wreck Puzzle
Times: Pirate Wreck Puzzle
MARITIMES
2018 • VOL 31 • NO 1
WWW
NMB
dotBM
Board of Trustees
Philip Akeroyd, Robert Blee, Jennifer 14 Whipping up a 17th-century
shipboard feast
Davidson, Timothy Davidson, Jazmin
By Grace Tsai
DaPonte, Dr. Douglas De Couto, Andrew
Dias, Dr. Janet Ferguson, Pamela Ferreira, 16 News: Education strategy;
Michael Grayston, Michael Maguire, new Curatorial offices
Dr. Clarence Maxwell, Edwin Mortimer,
17 Publications: Bermuda Maps,
Isabelle Ramsay-Brackstone, Robert
Steinhoff, Neil Stempel, Charles Thresh,
14 Heritage Matters 6, Defenses
of Bermuda 1612–1995
Col. Sumner Waters
Executive Director
Elena Strong
Curator Deborah Atwood, PHD
MARITIMES MAGAZINE OF THE NATIONAL MUSEUM OF BERMUDA
2018 VOLUME 31 NO. 1
Registrar Jane Downing
Conservator Zoe Brady Editor: Elena Strong Assistant Editor: Deborah Atwood
Facilities Manager Andrew Harris MARITimes (ISSN 1015-6127) is published by National Museum of Bermuda Press
PO Box MA 133, Mangrove Bay MA BX, Bermuda
Admin Assistant Paula Pitman Tel (441) 234–1333 Fax (441) 234–1735 E-mail: curator@nmb.bm
Ticket Office Corene Smith Website: www.nmb.bm
Percival Ratteray Publication history: Under the name Bermuda Maritime Museum Quarterly, publication began in 1988
(2 issues: Volume 1, no. 1 and no. 2) and continued each year with four issues until 1995, when only two
issues were produced, being Volume 8, no. 1 and no. 2. In 1996, the name of the magazine was changed
to MARITimes, and four issues (Volume 9, nos. 1–4) were produced. From Volumes 10–14, MARITimes
was produced three times a year, and two issues a year for Volumes 15, 16, 17, 23, 24, 27 and 30.
Only one issue was published for Volumes 13, 22, 25, 26, 27, 28 and 29.
The National Museum of Bermuda is located within 15.73 acres of fortifications at the Royal Naval Dockyard, including buildings of
outstanding historical value. The Museum is a non-government, non-profit Bermuda Registered Charity (No. 136), established in
1974, and its general operations are funded by donations and gate receipts from over 70,000 visitors annually. Its staff is supported by
local and visiting volunteers. NMB is overseen by the Board of Trustees of the National Museum of Bermuda. The Museum opens 9
am–5 pm weekdays, 9:30 am–5 pm weekends (last admission 4 pm) every day except Christmas Day. Winter hours 10 am–5 pm (last
entry 4 pm).
2 MARITIMES
l News
2 0 1 8 V O L . 3 1 N O. 1 3
l News
MB had a strong presence management, and how to National Museum of American tional institutions and
N at three conferences this
year. Executive Director
digitise archaeological records
and collections. Grace Tsai’s
History, Mystic Seaport, Los
Angeles Maritime Museum
exchange their experiences
and knowledge.
Emeritus Dr. Edward Harris research (see p. 14 ) was also and Vancouver Maritime The Museum has been a
attended a MIT Conference, presented at the conference. Museum, discussed issues and member of CAMM for
entitled “Rebuilding a Dr. Atwood also visited East challenges facing maritime nearly three decades.
Resilient Caribbean,” in Carolina University to speak museums. Dealing with Although not part of America
Boston, MA. The two-day about Bermuda’s shipwreck natural and man-made and no longer called the
workshop brought together and salvage history to disasters, learning from Bermuda Maritime
island leaders and researchers students of the Maritime failure, experiential learning, Museum—NMB officially
to discuss strategies for Studies Program. marine archaeology, building changed its name and
rebuilding and improving In April the National audiences, connecting with broadened its scope in 2013—
island infrastructure in the Museum welcomed more communities and staying it is impossible to divorce
wake of storm-related disasters. than 65 delegates at the 2018 relevant were some of the Bermuda’s 500 years of
Dr. Harris spoke on the Annual Conference of the topics explored. history from its maritime
Museum’s recent hurricane Council of American There was a strong local heritage and its relationship
damage and methods of Maritime Museums representation with the with its North American
recovery. (CAMM). Founded in Museum presenting on neighbours.
Curator Dr. Deborah 1974, CAMM brings disaster management NMB Executive Director
Atwood attended the Society together institutions working planning for hurricanes and Elena Strong highlighted the
of Historical Archaeology’s towards the preservation and dealing with disaster after- importance of researching and
51st Annual Conference on interpretation of North math. The Bermuda National understanding Bermuda’s
Historical and Underwater America’s maritime heritage, Gallery spoke about using maritime heritage. “There is a
Archaeology in New orleans, promoting research, exhibition, local artists to reinterpret a strong and deep community
LA, entitled “Landscapes, publication and collaboration collection and better connect interest in our maritime
Entrepots, and Global Currents.” among maritime heritage to the local community. heritage but the key is to
Presentations discussed a professionals. Endeavour and the Bermuda make this history relevant,
ranged of topics including While the Museum Sloop Foundation presented accessible and to explore the
how to develop community- was the official host, the on their successful experiential stories which have traditionally
based archaeology projects, conference was held at the learning and STEAM been marginalised,” she said.
the role of archaeology in Bermuda College, where programming. The conference Special thanks to the
climate change science, place- representatives from small provided local institutions an Bermuda College, which
making within the Diaspora, and large maritime institu- opportunity to establish new provided the venue for the
underwater cultural heritage tions, such as the Smithsonian relationships with interna- conference.
4 MARITIMES
l News
Artists Mike Walsh (above), Abi Box (below) and Calix Smith
(right) with their work
2 0 1 8 V O L . 3 1 N O. 1 5
l News
ROCHELLE SMITH
emphasis on defences
from Newfoundland to
Puerto Rico constructed to
combat German surface
Fat Tire cyclists race on the Ramparts, while Triple Challenge competitors lug telephone poles (below) warships and U-boats (see
Publications, p. 17).
at Tire Massive and the
F Bermuda Triple Challenge
returned to the Museum for
another year of racing. The
second race of the Furniture
Walk Mountain Bike Race
Series was held at the
Museum, completing a loop
around the Commissioner’s
House, past the new solar
panel installation and through The second lecture was
Casemates. given by archaeologist and
The Triple Challenge, now friend of the Museum Dr.
in its eighth year, is a three- James Delgado (pictured)
day obstacle race with events whose presentation “The
in St. George’s, Warwick and Final Frontier: Space-Age
Dockyard. The Dockyard Technology, Deep-Sea
event, now known as the Exploration and Ship-
CHUBB Royal Challenge, wrecks,” outlined the
takes place on the last day of role technology plays in
the weekend and requires advancing how archae–
competitors to plunge ologists and scientists
through water obstacles and
BERMUDA TRIPLE CHALLENGE
6 MARITIMES
l News
2 0 1 8 V O L . 3 1 N O. 1 7
l New Acquisitions
Harry Fox (back row, second from right) with other internees
at a camp in France during the Second World War
8 MARITIMES
The family of Private James
Archibald O’Connor, 1st
Battalion Lincolnshire
Regiment, has donated the
prayer book he was carrying
at the time of his death in
action in 1918, which was
pierced by an enemy bayonet.
O’Connor, son of Thaddeus
and Helen O’Connor of St.
David’s, joined the Bermuda
Laurie and Barry Keefe have donated a photo Bermuda en route to the European front Volunteer Rifle Corps in
album made by her grandfather John Alexander in 1915–16. The album documents the March 1913 aged 17, and
Clark “Jack” Macpherson, Major commanding Battalion’s halcyon days in Bermuda, training headed to the front with the
“B” Company of the 38th Battalion, Canadian for deployment, swimming, sailing, and playing 1st Bermuda Contingent in
Expeditionary Force, which was stationed in football and tug-of-war. 1915. He saw almost
continuous active service,
was wounded in September
1915, and was killed on April
26, 1918. He was buried in
a small cemetery in the
village of Fricourt on the
way to Cambrai and is
memorialised at the Tyne Cot
Memorial Zonnebeke, West
Vlaanderen, Belgium.
2 0 1 8 V O L . 3 1 N O. 1 9
l Heritage
10 MARITIMES
A well-defined fish pond just below the span of Somerset Bridge. Below, a pond at Daniel’s Island, Somerset
seasonal practice of fishing which would The skill with which Bermudians
allow the fish to have regenerative periods worked the cedar and palmetto plants
each year, reducing the risk of overfishing. endemic to the island was praised world-
As interest in Bermuda as a tourist wide. Unfortunately, the old skills of
destination grew, fish ponds became working with the natural resources
another feature adding to the unique provided by the archipelago are fading
beauty of the island, showcasing both the away as their practitioners die out
traditional practices of the islanders and without being able to pass on their skills
its natural wonders. Although groupers and knowledge.
were the primary occupants of many of Bermuda still holds a wealth of
the island’s ponds, they also stocked knowledge waiting to be tapped.
parrotfish, angel fish, turtles, and other Although community involvement in
colourful varieties. The aesthetic value of the propagation of culture seems to be
these ponds is obvious, as they present fading away, that is not to say that
colourful aquariums showcasing the Bermudians are not interested in that
varied marine life Bermuda has to offer. culture. Invigorated protection of
In 1831, Devil’s Hole became one of Bermuda’s culture can be easily achieved
Bermuda’s first genuine tourist attractions if we provide the community with a
when it opened for tours. It was a voice, and show that ideas and knowledge
pleasing spot where visitors could relax have a pivotal part to play in conservation
while looking at the variety of fish and efforts. Using this knowledge when
turtles encased within. managing the conservation of fish ponds
The environment held a sense of will enable their sustainable and efficient
agency over Bermuda’s history, affecting management. Advancing these goals will
the island’s settlement and use. In turn hopefully provide the framework for the
Bermudians shaped the landscape, continued conservation of the other
somehow enabling a small archipelago to emblems of Bermuda’s culture that are
sustain a population that rapidly began on a global scale. Bermuda onions, beginning to disappear, serving to
to outgrow it. Against the odds, islanders arrowroot, and lilies were known around begin a revitalisation that will allow
found ways not only to sustain them- the world, to the point that Bermudians the unique and intriguing heritage of
selves but to make a name for Bermuda today are still referred to as “onions.” the island to thrive.
2 0 1 8 V O L . 3 1 N O. 1 11
l Cover
Morgan’s Island
wreck may be
1619 pirate ship
Colonial Bermudians stripped stricken ship
beyond reach of nosy Customs officials
By Dr. Bradley Rodgers
Program Director Maritime Studies, East Carolina University
ast Carolina University archaeologists are one step
12 MARITIMES
EAST CAROLINA UNIVERSITY
The stricken ship’s disarticulated timbers can clearly be seen close to shore. Inset, an ECU diver surveys the wreck remains
“Salvage marks are plentiful on the disarticulated wreck, and Further investigation should shed more light on life in 17th
though many of the fasteners and planks have been removed, century Bermuda and its settlement, especially pertaining to
many of the timber remains are in great condition.” the salvage of ships in distress.
There is much work to do to complete the analysis of the “The economics and impact of salvage in the early settlement
wreck, according to Rodgers, as it takes “extensive archival of Bermuda has not yet fully been explored by academics and
research, archaeological analysis and funding to fully verify the can provide a fascinating window into how the first Bermudians
find, and it is one of the more confusing wreck sites we have survived on an isolated island,” said NMB Executive Director
ever studied—it has been completely taken apart down to the Elena Strong. “Bermuda’s rich underwater cultural heritage,
fastenings.” However, the team has documented enough of the which is protected by law, is not only a valuable cultural
site to identify ship construction techniques matching those tourism asset, but also comprises a tangible archive of the inter-
described in 17th-century Dutch treatises. In addition, the action of African, American and European cultures over five
wood has been identified as greenheart (Ocotea rodiei), a New centuries. over the past 40 years, research on these wrecks has
World timber historically harvested in Dutch trading territory yielded considerable data informing historical narratives about
in South America, and the few artifacts seen reflect Dutch the lives of the people who depended on these vessels to ferry
northern European heritage from the early 17th century. goods and people to various ports along the Atlantic Littoral.”
2 0 1 8 V O L . 3 1 N O. 1 13
l Research
14 MARITIMES
the meat was desalted in shipboard fresh impacts of the study because key
water, and then boiled. The food items mechanisms of the human body
were subjected to laboratory tests including are controlled by the microbes
microbiological, nutritional, and flavour that live in the gut. Studies show
profile analysis. a relationship between the gastro-
As of March, 2018, the analyses are intestinal microbiome and diseases
still underway but preliminary results are including obesity, diabetes,
available. It was hypothesised that the autoimmune diseases, gastro-
salted and dried items would grow few, intestinal diseases, and certain
if any, microbes because of their high salt types of cancer. In particular, it
content or intense drying and heating. appears that traditional foods
Further, it was thought that the ship- harbour more diverse microbio-
board water (originally sourced from a logical populations, and that people
natural aquifer) would grow pathogenic who have more diverse taxa in
bacteria, and that the beer and wine their gut have a smaller chance of
would primarily grow the yeasts that Meat being dry cured in the salted beef barrel in getting common Western diseases.
helped in their fermentation. Most of the August, 2017 C. Clemente et al. measured
results were unexpected. Not only did the differences in diversity within the
salted beef grow several different taxa, However, the pyrazine, ketone, and furan gut microbiome of the average individual
including three entirely new species, but functional groups were present in signifi- living in the US in a sanitised Western
the salt itself grew at least eight different cantly fewer amounts at the end of the environment, with that of the indigenous
taxa. It is unclear how long cooks on sample collection, but ethanol had a Yanomami in Venezuela, who practice a
ships normally boiled meat, but it was marked increase. It is possible some of foraging lifestyle, and noted that that
discovered that it took 30 minutes of full the ketones were reduced to alcohol, Yanomami had 50 percent more micro-
boiling for the salted beef to become which would explain the increase in bial taxa compared to US residents in the
sterile, so anything less than 30 minutes ethanol. Although running each sample study. Martínez et al. ran a similar study
of boiling meant ingestion of more takes about 30 minutes, the analysis of comparing fecal samples from non-
microbes, both good and bad. While the the results takes significantly more time. industrialised regions in Papua New
beer and wine grew several microbes, they Nutritional analysis is underway, but the Guinea (PNG) with those from the US
did not grow on the MacConkey Plain results are not yet available as these are and found the PNG samples had greater
agar, a substance used to scientifically test pricier and take longer to process. bacterial diversity, lower inter-individual
culture growth in a controlled setting and Within the past year, the SBSB team variation, different abundance profiles,
that is used to test for common has teamed up with a local brewery, and bacterial lineages undetectable in US
pathogens such as E. coli. This suggests the Karbach Brewing Company, on a residents. Likewise, comparisons between
the bacteria growing in these beverages joint collaboration to recreate a modern the gut microbiome of European children
have no effect, or possibly beneficial replica of the experimental shipboard and children in Burkina Faso, Malawi
effects, on humans. The water samples beer for a beer tasting fundraiser in peoples and Amazonian Amerindians,
taken from the barrels grew easily on the which proceeds will go towards the cost and Hadza hunter-gatherers in Tanzania,
MacConkey Plain agar, which confirmed of nutritional analysis. The beer, named collectively imply that there is greater
our hypothesis for water. Nautic Ale, will also be available in select diversity within the gut microbiome of
Flavour profiling was done by PhD locations in Texas aside from the less modernised countries, much like the
student Kayley Wall at Texas A&M fundraiser. Thanks to Karbach Brewing microbiological results seen in food from
University in Dr. Chris Kerth’s laboratory the nutritional results have been the SBSB project.
via Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectro- expedited significantly and should be Further studies made the connection
metry, a technique that captures the available very soon. that communities practicing pre-industrial
volatile compounds in foods, which The SBSB team is most intrigued by foodways have a lower frequency of
translates to their aromas. Interesting the microbiological results found thus far. obesity, diabetes, gastrointestinal diseases
results have come back so far. For example, Currently the evidence suggests that the and many other chronic non-infectious
in the case of the beer, there was the sailors consumed a large variety of both diseases. Although the SBSB project
presence of pyrazine, ketone, and furan good and bad microbes, much more so results are still preliminary, it is possible
functional groups (along with esters, than modern humans living in Western that studying past preservation methods
benzene, aldehydes, alcohols, and acids) society are exposed to in their diet. This and foods will help understand modern
when it was first put on the ship. may be significant looking at the broader health and diseases.
Evidence suggests 17th-century sailors consumed a large variety of both good and bad
microbes, much more so than modern humans living in Western society are exposed to
2 0 1 8 V O L . 3 1 N O. 1 15
l News
16 MARITIMES
l Publications
COMING SOON The Museum Press is working with the from 1775–82; and by the Humanitarian Insurgency, he refers to
Department of Community & Cultural Affairs to publish NMB the battle of civil rights and abolitionism that led to the Emancipa-
Trustee Dr. Clarence Maxwell’s latest book. Set us Free explores tion Act of 1833 and the Abolition Acts I and II of Bermuda the
the Bermudian response to the Age of Revolution: not only to the following year. Maxwell uses these two moments to show the
British American Revolution, but what he calls the Humanitarian character of that Bermudian involvement and the consequences it
Revolution or Insurgency. By the British American Revolution, he had on the historical trajectory of this mid-Atlantic archipelago.
refers to the political crisis that enveloped British North America Set Us Free will be published in May 2019.
2 0 1 8 V OL . 3 1 N O. 1 17
l Events
Heritage
Matters
celebrated
The publication of Dr. Edward
Harris’s Heritage Matters
Volume 6 was celebrated at
Gallery oneSeventeen on
Front Street in Hamilton.
As the title suggests, this is
the sixth volume in the series
showcasing Dr. Harris’s news-
paper columns about Bermuda.
Fans of the Harris canon will
be pleased to know that
Heritage Matters Volume 7
Executive Director Elena Strong with Birgitta Nygren, Rees Fletcher and Bengt Nygren will be released in 2019.
Jean Gardner, Alexia Cooper and Sue LeStrange Author Dr. Edward Harris with Terrill and Michel Drew
Pat Lang with Paul Shapiro and Rosemary Jones Chinni Mahadevan, Sandra Outerbridge and Philip Akeroyd
18 MARITIMES
Putting
history on
the map
The Museum Press honoured
the publication of Jonathan
Evans’s monumental new
book Bermuda Maps at a
well-attended launch
at the CHUBB Gallery in
Woodbourne Avenue,
Hamilton. The event, which
was accompanied by a
temporary exhibit featuring
original maps highlighted in
the book, was generously
hosted by CHUBB. Wayne Carey, Jonathan Evans, Zane DeSilva and James Hallett
Sue Bendell, Peter Adwick, Jean and Peter Oliver David and Jill Lamneck and Paul Leseur
Sam Buxton, George Thomas, Michael Darling Jr, and Dr. Edward Harris Tony Pettit and Doug Patterson
2 0 1 8 V O L . 3 1 N O. 1 19
l Conservation
20 MARITIMES
Street bollard cannons rescued
E ast Carolina University
graduate students led
by Dr. Bradley Rodgers
have been helping with the
conservation of a number of
historic cannon. Five guns
were recovered by Crisson
Construction in 2017
during work at Hunter’s
Wharf, St. George’s, and
are on permanent loan to
the Museum from the
Corporation of St. George’s.
Four had been used as
bollards, partially embedded
in concrete and painted
green, and one cannon was
used as wharf fill. Crisson
told NMB of the discovery
and transported the
artifacts to the Conservation
Laboratory in Dockyard. All
five guns were in unstable
condition and heavily
damaged and without treat-
ment would have had an Cannon being lowered into a con-
extremely short life. Four servation tank. Below: preparing
other cannon from the cannon for electrolysis treatment
Museum’s permanent
collection were included in the project. moved into large tanks
As part of the conservation process, to go through a four-to-
students created highly detailed 3D five-year electrolysis
models of the cannon. This fast, cost- treatment, which uses
effective and accurate method of an electric current to
documentation captures a higher level of further clean the
detail than photography, description or cannon, remove
drawing. These techniques, when used chlorides, and reduce
in tandem, result in a very complete data the corrosion product.
set and can be used as a point of The process was
comparison throughout treatment and carried out using
referred to by future researchers. forklifts and trained
The cannon were mechanically operators, as placement
cleaned, removing as much concrete is vital to the success of the project. completed by ECU has been instrumental
and debris from the exterior and interior After treatments are complete, the in ensuring these artifacts are preserved,
as possible. Cleaning involved chiselling cannon will be stable and available for said NMB Conservator Zoe Brady, who
away concrete, power washing paint and display and study for years to come. added: “The progress made on these
debris, and emptying the barrels, which East Carolina University has been huge artifacts in just a few days is out-
were packed with fill and unexpected working with the National Museum on standing. It would be impossible to make
artifacts, including flint, coal and pottery. maritime archaeology projects since such headway without the assistance of
Once cleaned, the barrels were the 1980s. The conservation work the East Carolina team.”
The barrels were packed with unexpected artifacts, including flint, coal and pottery
2 0 1 8 V O L . 3 1 N O. 1 21
l Volunteers
Corporate
friends
help out
Thanks again to our Corporate volunteers
who returned this year. Volunteers from
Deloitte assisted NMB Facilities Manager
Andrew Harris with painting projects and the
crew from Fat Tire Massive (below) donated
their time to clear the High Cave of the
invasive plants growing on its perimeter.
Kitson volunteers (bottom) helped clean up
flowerbeds around the main entrance.
22 MARITIMES
l People
2 0 1 8 V O L . 3 1 N O. 1 23
MUSEUM CORPORATE MEMBERS
Corporate membership helps support MARITimes magazine and many other NMB education and publication projects
CO M M O D O RE ($500 – $999)
Australia Japan Cable Group Frog & Onion Pub
of Companies Great Things Ltd.
BAS Serco Ironshore
Bermuda International Gas Transportation Jardine Matheson International Services
Co. Ltd. Ltd.
Botelho Wood Architects Meyer Group of Companies
Dolphin Quest (Bermuda) Ltd. Nissan Global Reinsurance
Fast Forward Freight Ltd. Pro-Tone Cleaning Services Ltd.
Fram Shipping Ltd. Vallis & Hayward Limited
D O N ATI O N S I N KI N D
Bermuda Project Managers One Communications MobileTech Ltd.
Limited ColourLab Greg Peters
Bermuda Pest Control Crisson Construction Tops Ltd.
Bermuda Scaffolding Island Press Ltd.
BCM McAlpine Mazars