Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ijer v10 I6 ND
Ijer v10 I6 ND
brand loyalty is the core of marketing (Patrick & Xu, 2018).This study aims to
planning. For companies, brand loyalty is explore the antecedent factors affecting
one of the important factors to increase consumer sportswear brand loyalty in
market share, and also concerns the lifetime Thailand. The research results may have
value and brand loyalty of consumers implications for company marketing
(Chaudhuri & Holbrook, 2001). Consumers strategy.
can learn from previous experience about The rest of this paper is organized as follows.
the value that a brand delivered. Research Section 2 presents a review of the relevant
indicates that loyal customers are willing to literature and outlines the research
share experiences of the products they use hypotheses. The research methodology is
with others, and consumers will make repeat presented in section 3 while analysis and
purchases (Kotler & Keller, 2016; Sheng & results are in section 4. Finally, research
Liu, 2010). Loyal customers save marketing conclusions, limitations, and
costs because the cost of attracting a new recommendations for future research are
customer is six times that of current discussed in section 5.
customer retention (Fard, Ismaeelzadeh, &
Ramshini, 2016; Rosenberg & Czepiel, 2. Literature Review and Research
1984). Hypotheses
2.1 Brand loyalty
Customer loyalty is the strategic objective of Brand loyalty (BL) is manifested by
the business (Gamble, Tapp, Marsella, & consumers’ repurchasing behavior toward a
Stone, 2005). Research has also outlined the specific brand (Ailawadi, Neslin, & Gedenk,
factors that influence customer loyalty. 2001; Shim & Gehrt, 1996; Zeithaml, Berry,
Understanding the important factors in & Parasuraman, 1996). Aaker (1991)
customers’ purchase decisions and brand defines brand loyalty as customers
loyalty enhances brand management (Shim continuing to repurchase their original
& Gehrt, 1996). Customer satisfaction has image product even though another brand
an impact on customer loyalty (Homburg & could provide higher value, better product
Giering, 2001; Taylor & Hunter, 2003). features, or convenience (Chaudhuri &
Other factors include trust Holbrook, 2001). Loyalty represents
(Delgado‐ Ballester & Munuera‐ Alemán, consumers’ comprehensive evaluation of the
2001), quality (Huang, 2008), and brand brand (Oliver, 1999). It is also the long-term
image (Keller, 2013). However, the factors customer attitude toward the brand
that impact sportswear customer loyalty in reflecting the permanent commitment of the
emerging markets are still developing
customer (Shankar, Smith, & Rangaswamy, close relationship, they will become
2003). inseparable and brand loyalty will be stable
Brand loyalty also shows the customer and lasting. Customers will also actively
learning process and customer perceptions recommend the brand and pass on positive
of the company or brand influence customer word of mouth (Gamble et al., 2005; Singh
patronage (Kumar & Shah, 2004). Loyalty is & Pattanayak, 2014).
not only in terms of behavior but also the Previous research found that sports brand
attitude showing the preference of the names affect consumer brand loyalty (Singh
consumer (Keller, 1993). When behavior & Pattanayak, 2014; Yee & Sidek, 2008).
and attitude tend toward a certain brand, it is Research on sportswear brand loyalty of
considered true customer brand loyalty consumers in Hong Kong found that
(Nam, Ekinci, & Whyatt, 2011). Attitude perceived quality affects brand loyalty for
loyalty predicts behavioral loyalty (Oliver, hard-core loyal consumers (Lau et al., 2006).
1999). The antecedents that influence Investigating brand loyalty from a strategic
consumer loyalty include affection and marketing perspective is considered to be
cognition, such as brand association, brand the most appropriate approach (Chaudhuri,
trust, perceived quality, brand performance, 1999). This research will also discuss brand
and customer satisfaction (Krystallis & loyalty from a customer-oriented
Chrysochou, 2014; Tsao & Chen, 2005) perspective.
After consumers have experienced a brand,
they have a relationship with the brand 2.2 Brand image
through the process of perception and Brand image (BI) is the consumer’s overall
cognition. This triggers support and perception of the brand (Keller, 2013). All
recognition for the brand and generates associations that consumers link with brand
customer loyalty (Fournier, 1998). Brand nodes in memory constitute a brand image
loyalty can generate brand performance (Berry, 2000). Ha and Park (2013)
(Chaudhuri & Holbrook, 2001; Raithel, distinguish brand impressions into two
Sarstedt, Scharf, & Schwaiger, 2012), facets including cognition and emotion. The
reducing marketing and operating costs brand image deepens the customer’s
(Bowen & Chen, 2001). understanding of the brand’s attitude and
Loyalty comes from brand trust and brand feelings, enabling consumers to have brand
affect (Delgado‐ Ballester, 2004). Brand recognition and establish brand equity
trust affects brand loyalty (Chaudhuri & (Keller, 2013). Khundyz (2018) surveyed
Holbrook, 2001). Fournier (1998) argued 150 mobile phone users and found that
that when consumers and brands form a brand image had a significant impact on
2012). Perceived quality (PQ) has a positive evidence that the age of consumers who buy
impact on customer satisfaction (Akbar, such brands is under 25 years old. Their
Som, Wadood, & Alzaidiyeen, 2010) and is research also suggested that improving the
a determining factor in satisfaction (Olsen, perceived quality can enhance consumers’
2002); it also influences consumer choice trust and also improve behavioral intention.
and continuous purchase (Crane, 1993). We therefore formulated the following
Quality affects consumer preferences and hypotheses to examine the effect of
purchase intentions, and therefore positively perceived quality on brand loyalty, customer
affects brand loyalty (Su & Chang, 2018). satisfaction, and brand trust:
Perceived quality is considered to be an H4: Perceived quality has a significant
antecedent factor in customer brand loyalty positive effect on brand loyalty.
(Rasheed & Abadi, 2014). Loureiro (2013) H5: Perceived quality has a significant
conducted a study on the brand equity of positive effect on customer satisfaction.
online banking and the results indicated that H6: Perceived quality has a significant
brand loyalty and perceived quality positive effect on brand trust.
explained 53% of online banking brand
equity variability. A survey of 400 fashion 2.4 Customer satisfaction
clothing consumers in Vietnam revealed that Oliver (1999) argued that service
brand trust is a mediating factor in the satisfaction is the consumer’s satisfaction
impact of perceived quality on brand loyalty response to the service characteristics or the
(Kieu, 2019). Lau et al. (2006) suggested level of service provided. Factors that
that product quality is the most important influence customer satisfaction include
factor for sports brand loyalty. The product quality, service quality, price,
perception of quality and brand situational factors, and personal factors
communication affects trust in the brand and (Zeithaml, Bitner, & Gremler, 2017).
ultimately affects brand loyalty directly or Customer satisfaction (CS) is an overall
indirectly (Zehir, Şahin, Kitapçı, & Özşahin, feeling based on personal experience that
2011). depends on how the customer feels the
Perceived quality positively affects trust performance of the service or product is
(Corritore, Kracher, & Wiedenbeck, 2003) relative to their expectations (Fornell, 1992).
and influences consumer preferences and Therefore, the gap between the service
purchase intentions (Tsiotsou, 2006). In a obtained and the expected result makes the
study of consumers who purchased foreign consumer disappointed or happy and
sports goods, Deheshti, Firouzjah, and therefore influences customer satisfaction
Alimohammadi (2016) provided empirical (Kotler & Keller, 2016; Zeithaml et al.,
2017). Consumers have a higher level of H8a: Customer satisfaction mediates the
satisfaction when the actual experience of relationship between brand image and brand
the product exceeds their expectation. The loyalty.
higher the satisfaction, the higher the loyalty H8b: Customer satisfaction mediates the
(Anderson & Srinivasan, 2003). relationship between perceived quality and
Chen’s (2012) research on e-service reveals brand loyalty.
that customer satisfaction positively affects
customer loyalty. Another study in the 2.5 Brand trust
energy industry also finds that consumer Brand trust (BT) is the process of personal
satisfaction affects loyalty (Ibáñez, cognitive behavior and arises when
Hartmann, & Calvo, 2006). Relevant consumers feel safe about their own
research also highlights the positive consumption activities (Delgado‐ Ballester
relationship between customer satisfaction & Munuera‐ Alemán, 2001), and such
and loyalty (Kumar & Shah, 2004; Schirmer, feelings are derived from past experience
Ringle, Gudergan, & Feistel, 2018; Suh & and interaction.(Rempel, Holmes, & Zanna,
Youjae, 2006). Higher levels of customer 1985). When consumers believe that brands
satisfaction help the company differentiate can achieve commitment value and perform
from competitors to establish brand loyalty better in the future, the brands will receive
(Anderson & Sullivan, 1993; Fornell, 1992) consumer repurchase intentions and support
and the success of business (Oliver, 1997). (Aaker, 1991).
Furthermore, Gorondutse and Hilman (2014) To enhance trust, the brand builds upon the
revealed the mediating effect of customer consumer’s willingness to rely on the
satisfaction between service quality and capabilities or functions offered by the brand
customer loyalty in the food and beverages (Moorman, Zaltman, & Deshpande, 1992),
industry in Nigeria. Brand image also effects and the brand can meet customer needs and
customer satisfaction and thus customer realize its commitment to value. The
brand loyalty (Tu & Chang, 2012). consumer’s trust evaluation of the company
Therefore, customer satisfaction is important after purchasing the product will positively
for long-term customer repurchase. affect the customer’s loyalty in terms of the
After reviewing the relevant literature, this relationship with the brand and can further
study proposes the following hypotheses to guide the customer’s long-term loyalty.
examine the effect of customer satisfaction Aaker (1991) argues that in order to
on brand loyalty: maintain or improve customer loyalty,
H7: Customer satisfaction has a significant companies have to provide products that
positive effect on consumer brand loyalty. meet customers’ expectations. Brand trust is
3.3 Data collection and analysis the World’s Most Valuable Brand in 2019
To test the research hypotheses and the (Brand Finanace, 2019). The research
influence of the variables on consumers’ participants are Thai citizens aged over 18
brand loyalty, this study selected one years old. A total of 329 surveys were
sportswear brand, Brand A. This will make returned and 321 valid responses were
it possible to conduct a more in-depth obtained. A total of 38% of the sample were
exploration of the factors affecting loyalty males and 62% were females. The average
toward a sportswear brand. Brand A is age of the respondents was 36.81 years old
currently a world-renowned brand, and is (Table 2). The SPSS 24.0 program was used
also ranked the National Formerly Popular for statistical analysis, including descriptive
Brand in 2018 (Interbrand, 2018) and also and analytical statistics.
4. Analysis and Results suggested that a factor between 0.5 and 0.7
4.1 Reliability analysis is acceptable. The individual item reliability
Reliability refers to consistent test results checks the estimated factor loading, which
being obtained under the same conditions exceeded 0.5 (Hair, Black, Anderson, &
and at different times. The most commonly Tatham, 2006), indicating the scale is
used reliability test is the Cronbach’s alpha acceptable.
coefficient.
The Cronbach’s alpha of the scale is
0.564–0.760 (Table 3). Nunnally (1978)
4.3 Regression analysis and hypothesis Exploring the existence of mediating effects,
testing this study follows the recommendations of
The study used regression analysis to test Baron and Kenny (1986) that the mediation
the impact of variables on brand loyalty. effect must meet four criteria. The empirical
Brand image had a positive significant effect results of the four steps used in this study
on brand loyalty (β=0.224, p<0.001) (Table are presented in Table 4 to 7.
5). Perceived quality had a positive After the analysis, the result revealed a
significant impact on customer loyalty (β significant change coefficient. Between the
=0.294, p<0.001) (Table 4). H1 and H4 were perceived quality, customer satisfaction and
therefore supported. brand loyalty, the coefficient of perceived
In addition, brand image had a positive quality is found to have reduced from β
significant effect on customer satisfaction =0.294 (p<.001) to β =0.145 (p<.001) (Table
(β=0.301, p<0.001) (Table 5). There was 4) and the value is significant. Between the
also a significant positive impact on brand brand trust, perceived quality and brand
trust (β =0.241, p<0.001) (Table 7). H2 and loyalty, the coefficient of brand trust is also
H3 were therefore supported. The results found to reduce, and the value is significant
also indicated that perceived quality had a (from β =0.294, p<.001 to β =0.114, p<.001)
positive significant impact on customer (Table 6).
satisfaction (β =0.449, p<0.001) (Table 4). Between brand image, customer satisfaction
Therefore, H5 was supported. Perceived and brand loyalty, the coefficient of brand
quality also had a significant positive impact image is reduced from β =0.224 (p<.001) to
on brand trust (β=0.369, p<0.001) (Table 6); β =0.114 (p<.001) (Table 5). Between the
H6 was therefore supported. brand image, brand trust and brand loyalty,
Customer satisfaction was found to have a the brand image coefficient is reduced from
positive significant effect on brand loyalty β =0.224 (p<.001) to β =0.110 (p<.001)
(β =0.398, p<0.001) (Table 4). The result (Table 7).
indicated that if consumers had high From the above results, the coefficient is
satisfaction, they tended to have high brand weakened and shows a significant
loyalty. The result supported H7. Brand trust relationship. The results indicate that
had positive and significant effect on brand between the brand image, perceived quality,
loyalty (β =0.277, p<0.001) (Table 6); H9 and brand loyalty, customer satisfaction and
was therefore supported. brand trust have a partial mediation effect.
The regression models validated that H8a,
4.4 Mediation effect analysis H8b, H10a, and H10b were supported.
The research results show brand image has a their brand loyalty (Chinomona et al., 2013).
significant effect on brand loyalty. Positive Customer satisfaction toward the quality of
brand image is good for customer loyalty. In sportswear also affects brand trust, which
addition, brand image also affects consumer will positively and significantly influence
satisfaction, which is consistent with brand loyalty. This result is similar to those
Yulianti and Tung (2013). When consumers of Su and Chang (2018), and it is obvious
have an image, they with have higher levels that product quality cannot be ignored.
of satisfaction. Furthermore, brand image Furthermore, brand trust is also the
also significantly affects sportswear brand mediating factor between brand image,
trust. The finding is consistent with perceived quality, and brand loyalty.
Alhaddad (2015). If consumers have a good Positive brand image would positively
image of a sportswear brand, they tend to impact on consumer satisfaction and
have trust in the brand. Therefore, there are consequently brand loyalty. Similarly, brand
numerous ways for sportswear companies image also affects consumer trust in
build up customer brand trust. For example, sportswear brands, and then positively and
sportswear brands can seek to provide significantly affects brand loyalty. Customer
positive experiences to win consumers’ satisfaction and brand trust could be
trust. enhanced by companies launching activities
Perceived quality affects consumers’ trust to improve product quality or enhancing
and satisfaction with the brand. The results brand image and finally, to enhance
of the study indicate that a positive consumer brand loyalty.
perception of the quality of sportswear
products positively and significantly affects 5.1 Implications
consumer satisfaction and brand trust. This study provides empirical evidence for
Therefore, sportswear brands need to developing sportswear brand loyalty and
provide high quality products to consumers. provides the following recommendations for
Products that exceed consumer expectations the application of research results.
help build consumer loyalty (Zeithaml et al., First, the global sportswear market is
1996). forecast to grow continuously in the future
This study demonstrates that satisfaction and and the market in emerging countries will
brand trust are predictors of brand loyalty. increase rapidly. Existing sportswear brands
Consumer satisfaction is the mediating are highly competitive, and brands should
factor between brand trust, perceived quality, consider how to build long-term
and loyalty. Perceived quality affects relationships with consumers to win
consumer satisfaction and thus, impacts on competitive advantage. The research results
indicate one of the key tasks is to establish material, ergonomics, store decoration,
and maintain customer loyalty. Retaining and so on. Through the appeal of sports
existing customers has the advantage of product quality, strengthening
reducing business marketing costs consumers’ brand satisfaction and brand
(Rosenberg & Czepiel, 1984). trust can help to enhance brand loyalty.
Second, there are many choices for Thai
consumers regarding sportswear brands. To 5.2 Limitations and further research
build customers loyalty, this research There are some avenues of further research
suggests companies should first focus on to pursue and limitations of this study to
customer satisfaction and brand trust, which address.
have also been highlighted by previous First, this study focused on only one
research. The implications are: sportswear brand in Thailand, the research
1. Brands need to form a clear and strong results may therefore lack generalizability.
brand image to represent the value as Future research should explore more brands
well as the impression that the company in Thailand and compare the differences in
wants to deliver to the customer. For brand loyalty.
companies to have positive brand image, Second, this study focused only on
it would be helpful to strengthen sportswear brand; however, there may be
consumer satisfaction and brand trust. different factors affecting consumer loyalty
Consumers create an image from a toward sports shoes, sports clothes,
variety of factors, such as the cleanliness accessories, and so on. Future research can
of the store, store display, employees focus on specific sportswear products.
dress and behavior, and company Third, data for this study was obtained via
website. Company should focus on an online survey. Future research can be
maintaining a consistent brand image carried out in a variety of channels such as
throughout every moment of contact surveys in physical stores.
with customers. Brand image can create
recognition for customers.
2. It is necessary to emphasize product
quality when communicating with
consumers through marketing activities.
The attribute of quality includes product
design, performance, innovation, and
service. Sportswear brands can
emphasize the advantages of function,