Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Vitreous Humor A Review of Biochemical Constituent
Vitreous Humor A Review of Biochemical Constituent
10]
Review Article
Abstract
Postmortem changes in the biochemical constituents of the vitreous humor have been widely used to estimate the postmortem interval (PMI) over
the past several decades. However, few reviews have summarized the relationship between the postmortem vitreous biochemical constituents
and time of death. Herein, the relationship between PMI and single biochemical components, including vitreous potassium, hypoxanthine,
and amino acids, as well as comparisons of each statistical parameter in the formula, is summarized. We also discuss other compounds such
as urea and uric acid, which have no direct relationship with PMI. Utility of multiple constituent simultaneous analysis for estimating PMI
is being increasingly investigated. The promising idea of using simultaneous analysis of multiple constituents to determine PMI is proposed
as a future research direction.
Keywords: Biochemical constituents, multiple constituent analysis, postmortem changes, postmortem interval, vitreous humor
© 2018 Journal of Forensic Science and Medicine | Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow 85
[Downloaded free from http://www.jfsmonline.com on Tuesday, July 3, 2018, IP: 37.77.69.10]
Li, et al.: Vitreous humor: A review of biochemical constituents in postmortem interval estimation
Considerable progress has been made over the past several Recently, several new statistical methods have been applied for
decades in studies of VH for estimating PMI. Many PMI estimation.[12,26‑28] Many scientists demonstrated this linear
biochemicals in VH are used to estimate the PMI, and some relationship between potassium and PMI with new approaches
chemicals show a positive correlation. These compositions and established different equations for estimating the time since
can be divided into the following categories: electrolytes,[13,14] death with varying precision.[6] For instance, Rognum et al.[27]
amino acids,[15,16] hypoxanthine (Hx),[17] creatinine, urea conducted linear regression analysis to develop a formula that
nitrogen, and uric acid.[7,18] Due to these previous investigations, takes ambient temperature into consideration. The lowest
forensic examiners can accurately estimate PMI. Given this standard error for potassium values was approximately 12 mM,
background, the relationships between changes in the VH and with the 95% limits of confidence interval approximately
PMI should be further examined. at 3 h. Moreover, Lange et al.[28] reported precise results
(95% confidence limits of ± 1 h in the early PMI and 95%
Electrolytes confidence limits of ± 10 h, 110 h postmortem), which
have even exceeded optimistic expected results obtained in
Potassium previous investigations. These studies confirmed the utility
During life, intracellular potassium levels are maintained of potassium in VH as an index for estimating the time since
at high concentrations, while extracellular (VH) potassium
death. Ortmann et al.[14] studied five different equations for 600
levels are low because of the action of the Na/K‑pump.
random samples to improve the accuracy of PMI estimation
After death, postmortem vitreous potassium levels change
and obtained positive results by detecting vitreous potassium.
because of cellular hypoxia, which induces the depletion of
Although the researches described the above reported different
Adenosine Triphosphate (ATP) and loss of selective membrane
95% confidence limits of standard errors and equations for PMI
permeability for ions, after which intracellular potassium
determination, the results showed agreement in the linearly
diffuses with the passive diffusion into the vitreous body,
increased relationship between postmortem vitreous potassium
leading to an increase in vitreous potassium levels.[19,20] This
and PMI.[2,8,14,23,27,28]
mechanism, combined with cell autolysis, leads to changes
that cause postmortem levels to deviate from the antemortem In addition, numerous new analytical approaches have been
biochemistry of VH, which has been investigated in PMI used to analyze the potassium level in the VH for PMI
estimation studies.[21,22] estimation in recent years.[29-31] For example, Bortolotti et al.[30]
used capillary ion analysis to determine the vitreous potassium
Since the first study revealed the linear relationship between
levels in 164 cases to re‑evaluate the correlation with PMI for
the PMI and potassium concentration in the VH, vitreous
2–110 h. Although some breakthroughs have been made in PMI
potassium was considered as the most extensively studied
estimation during the first 24 h postmortem, the standard errors
predictor for estimating PMI.[23,24] Over the past several
of the values are less precise than those obtained using classical
decades, many studies have confirmed the linear correlation
methods. Our research team[31] recently explored a highly
between vitreous potassium levels and PMI and calculated an
sensitive fluorescence method based on silver nanocluster
equation by linear regression analysis [Table 1]. For example,
probes for determining the VH potassium levels, which
Sturner,[20] a forerunner in VH analysis, reported 54 cases to
showed improved potential for estimating the PMI in forensic
demonstrate the linear relationship between PMI and potassium
science. Compared to conventional detection approaches, our
values. Madea et al.[25] reported a formula for PMI estimation
new approach is easy, convenient, and sensitive for analyzing
by determining vitreous potassium concentrations in 170
vitreous potassium.[29,31-34]
random samples, revealing a confidence interval of up to 120 h
postmortem. Thus, vitreous potassium may be used for a larger Potassium levels may be influenced by various factors such
range of PMI estimation in real cases compared to those used as the cause of death, season of death, and refrigeration of
in previous studies. the sample.[1] The impact of both objective and human factors
Table 1: Equation for estimating postmortem interval from vitreous potassium according to different authors
Author n Intercept (mmol/L) PMI Formula
Sturner[18] 54 5.6 104‑h postmortem PMI=7.14 (K7+) − 39.1
Coe[2] 160 4.99 100‑h postmortem PMI=6.15 (K+) − 38.1
Madea et al.[25] 170 5.88 120‑h postmortem PMI=5.26 (K+) − 30.9
Munoz et al.[32] 133 5.35 40‑h postmortem PMI=3.92 (K+) − 19.04
Jashnani et al.[1] 120 2.616 50‑h postmortem PMI=1.076 (K+) − 2.815
Zilg et al.[26] 462 Unknown 409‑h postmortem
PMI =
(
ln ( M − C 0 ) / ( M − [ K + ]) )
L 0 + mAA + mTT
Rognum et al.[27] 106 4.5 118‑h postmortem PMI=5.164 (K+) + 0.174 T + (K+) × T × (−0.100) × 19.588
T: Ambient temperature, PMI: Postmortem interval
Li, et al.: Vitreous humor: A review of biochemical constituents in postmortem interval estimation
Li, et al.: Vitreous humor: A review of biochemical constituents in postmortem interval estimation
formula slopes.[18] To further develop precise equations for changes in amino acids in VH and these molecules are considered
estimating the PMI, these intra‑ or extra‑factors should be useful biomarkers for estimating the PMI [Table 2].[16,66]
considered.[35,55]
In a previous study, Erdei and Vass[67] first reported the
existence of free amino acids in the VH. Subsequently, Patrick
Nitrogenous Compounds and Logan[68] reported that the concentration of 27 amino acids
Urea nitrogen, uric acid, and creatinine are the products of protein in VH had a linear relationship with PMI at different rates.
metabolism and are considered as relatively stable compounds Girela et al.[16] determined vitreous free amino acid levels by
in postmortem serum samples.[59,60] Many researchers have HPLC and the results showed that the levels of most amino
examined nitrogenous compound levels in various biological acids in the VH increased linearly as the PMI increased.
specimens (serum, pericardium, cerebrospinal fluids, synovial Niha and Shobhana[17,66] analyzed amino acids in the VH
fluid, and VH) collected during autopsy.[61,62] Several authors using the new determination method. In the first study, they
investigated vitreous nitrogenous compounds to determine reported the application of sensing technique‑based silver
postmortem changes in nitrogenous compounds and study nanoparticle fluorescence probe for determining the PMI by
postmortem vitreous nitrogenous compound levels in relation quantifying vitreous cysteine (Cys). The equation determined
to various causes of death.[7,11,19] by using regression analysis was found to be PMI = 26.69
In the early 1959, the concentrations of urea nitrogen and + (−0.05) × (Cys).[66] In the second study, they utilized a
creatinine were studied in the VH as an exploratory study to highly sensitive method based on fluorescence spectroscopy
evaluate their postmortem changes.[63] Subsequently, Coe[22] to determine VH tryptophan levels. The results suggested
compared the levels of vitreous urea nitrogen obtained from that tryptophan has a strong positive linear relationship with
each eye at different PMIs and found very stable values. PMI and revealed a gradual increase in VH tryptophan (Trp)
However, Hanna et al.[64] found a strong correlation between the with increasing PMI up to 90 h, with a standard error of 5.2 h.
concentrations of urea and creatinine in serum and postmortem Moreover, the study reported that the regression equation was
VH in dogs over a 24‑h PMI, and the positive relationship in PMI = 0.34 (Trp) − 0.74.[17] Using amino concentrations to
previous studies may be related to limitations of the detection determine the time of death is becoming increasingly common
method or some other factors. Finally, Palmiere et al.[19] found in forensic science. Although the utility of vitreous amino acids
that these parameters showed no PMI‑related differences in the is inferior to that of vitreous potassium, studies have revealed
VH and other investigated fluids (e.g., postmortem pericardial the development potential of VH amino acid determination
fluid and serum), confirming the biochemical stability of for PMI estimation.
nitrogenous compounds. In summary, most studies showed that
the vitreous creatinine, uric acid, and urea concentrations were Conclusion
not correlated with the PMI.[24,19] These authors found that urea Much progress has been made in using the VH to estimate the
and creatinine are very stable compounds in biological fluids PMI [Table 3]. Vitreous potassium remains the best marker
and that their postmortem values remained nearly unchanged for PMI determination. Many scientists have focused on
during storage.[7,19,40] new statistical and analytical methods to accurately estimate
PMI. Utilizing Hx and amino acids for PMI determination is
Amino Acids becoming increasingly common in forensic science.
Amino acids are the basic elements of large molecular proteins As a current research hot spot, multiple constituent simultaneous
and participate in a series of biochemical reaction processes analysis may be advantageous for immediately monitoring
such as biosynthesis and catabolism. Some 300 additional postmortem changes of VH compounds. In the future, PMI
amino acids have already been discovered in cells and have a estimation studies with many biochemical constituents such as
variety of functions in humans. In their free form, amino acids ions, amino acids, glucose, and proteins may be simultaneously
are transported across the blood–vitreous barrier.[65] This is the analyzed by analyzing multiple constituents using novel
basis of the maintenance of vitreous amino acid concentrations. detection techniques such as fluorescent‑sensing analytical
Therefore, numerous studies have focused on postmortem techniques. As an analogy to the microarray technology,
Table 2: Relationships between postmortem interval determination and vitreous amino acid concentrations
Author n Selected amino acids Analytical method Findings
Erdei et al.[67] 1 13 (Cys, etc.) Chromatogram Identified the presence of free amino acids in VH
Patrick et al.[68] 120 27 (Taurine, etc.) Amino acid analyzer Linear relationship with PMI
Girela et al.[16] 58 19 (Trp, Leu, etc.) HPLC Linear relationship with PMI
Niha et al.[17] 90 1 (cystine) UV‑vis spectrophotometer PMI=26.69 + (−0.05) × (Cys)
Niha et al.[66] 76 1 (tryptophan) Fluorescence spectra PMI=0.34 × (Trp) −0.74
PMI: Postmortem interval, HPLC: High‑performance liquid chromatography, VH: Vitreous humor, UV: Ultraviolet
Li, et al.: Vitreous humor: A review of biochemical constituents in postmortem interval estimation
Table 3: The relationship between biochemical constituents in vitreous humor and postmortem interval
Analyzed marker Routine analytical method Current conditions References
Potassium Flame photometry and ion PMI up to 120 h (especially ± 1 h in the early PMI) [1,18,20,21,25]
selective electrodes
Sodium Ion selective electrode No PMI‑related difference [8,38‑42]
Magnesium Ion selective electrode No PMI‑related difference [15,45‑47]
Hypoxanthine HPLC PMI=Hx × 0.215 + T × (−0.467) + Hx × T × (−0.005) + 10.353 [16,26]
Urea and uric acid Enzymatic uricase colorimetric Stable postmortem changes [5,17,20,58‑62]
Creatinine Enzymatic uricase colorimetric Stable postmortem changes [5,17,20,60‑62]
Amino acids Many new sensitive methods Have a linear relationship with PMI [16,63‑65]
T: Ambient temperature, HPLC: High‑performance liquid chromatography, PMI: Postmortem interval, Hx: Hypoxanthine
Li, et al.: Vitreous humor: A review of biochemical constituents in postmortem interval estimation
Study of vitreous potassium correlation with time since death in the relation to the causes of death in forensic autopsy. Forensic Sci Int
postmortem range from 2 to 110 hours using capillary ion analysis. Med 2005;155:18‑23.
Sci Law 2011;51 Suppl 1:S20-S23. 51. Pérez‑Cárceles MD, del Pozo S, Sibón A, Noguera JA, Osuna E,
31. Ding Y, Li X, Guo Y, Duan W, Ling J, Zha L, et al. Estimation of Vizcaya MA, et al. Serum biochemical markers in drowning: Diagnostic
postmortem interval by vitreous potassium evaluation with a novel efficacy of strontium and other trace elements. Forensic Sci Int
fluorescence aptasensor. Sci Rep 2017;7:1868.
2012;214:159‑66.
32. Muñoz JI, Costas E, Rodríguez‑Calvo MS, Suárez‑Peñaranda JM,
52. Rognum TO, Saugstad OD, Oyasaeter S, Olaisen B. Elevated levels
López‑Rivadulla M, Concheiro L, et al. A high‑performance liquid
chromatography method for hypoxanthine determination in vitreous of hypoxanthine in vitreous humor indicate prolonged cerebral
humour: Application to estimation of post mortem interval. Hum Exp hypoxia in victims of sudden infant death syndrome. Pediatrics
Toxicol 2006;25:279‑81. 1988;82:615‑8.
33. Zhou B, Zhang L, Zhang G, Zhang X, Jiang X. The determination 53. Rognum TO, Saugstad OD. Hypoxanthine levels in vitreous humor:
of potassium concentration in vitreous humor by low pressure ion Evidence of hypoxia in most infants who died of sudden infant death
chromatography and its application in the estimation of postmortem syndrome. Pediatrics 1991;87:306‑10.
interval. J Chromatogr B Analyt Technol Biomed Life Sci 54. Madea B, Herrmann N, Henbge C. Precision of estimating the time since
2007;852:278‑81. death by vitreous potassium – Comparison of two different equations.
34. Muñoz Barús JI, Suárez‑Peñaranda J, Otero XL, Rodríguez‑Calvo MS, Forensic Sci Int 1990;46:277‑84.
Costas E, Miguéns X, et al. Improved estimation of postmortem interval 55. Yildirim A, Demirel B, Akar T, Senol E, Erdamar H. Usage of vitreous
based on differential behaviour of vitreous potassium and hypoxantine
humour hypoxanthine and potassium values for the estimation of
in death by hanging. Forensic Sci Int 2002;125:67‑74.
postmortem interval. Health Med 2011;5:1129‑36.
35. Cordeiro C, Seoane R, Camba A, Lendoiro E, Rodríguez‑Calvo MS,
Vieira DN, et al. The application of flow cytometry as a rapid and 56. Madea B, Käferstein H, Hermann N, Sticht G. Hypoxanthine in vitreous
sensitive screening method to detect contamination of vitreous humor humor and cerebrospinal fluid – A marker of postmortem interval and
samples and avoid miscalculation of the postmortem interval. J Forensic prolonged (vital) hypoxia? Remarks also on hypoxanthine in SIDS.
Sci 2015;60:1346‑9. Forensic Sci Int 1994;65:19‑31.
36. Mount DB, Sayegh MH, Singh A. Core concepts in the disorders of 57. Blana SA, Musshoff F, Hoeller T, Fimmers R, Madea B. Variations in
fluid, electrolytes and acid-base balance Springer 2013;2:147-70. vitreous humor chemical values as a result of pre‑analytical treatment.
37. Wilkie IW, Bellamy JE. Estimation of antemortem serum electrolytes Forensic Sci Int 2011;210:263‑70.
and urea concentrations from vitreous humor collected postmortem. 58. Lucy D, Aykroyd R, Pollard M. Commentary on muñoz JI,
Can J Comp Med 1982;46:146‑9. suárez‑peñaranda JM, Otero XL, rodríguez‑calvo MS, et al. A new
38. Achinger SG, Moritz ML, Ayus JC. Dysnatremias: Why are patients still
perspective in the estimation of postmortem interval (PMI) based on
dying? South Med J 2006;99:353‑62.
vitreous. J Forensic Sci 2001;46:1527‑8. Erratum in: J Forensic Sci
39. Ingham AI, Byard RW. The potential significance of elevated vitreous
sodium levels at autopsy. J Forensic Leg Med 2009;16:437‑40. 2001;46:209‑14.
40. Palmiere C, Mangin P. Postmortem chemistry update part I. Int J Legal 59. Zhu BL, Ishida K, Quan L, Taniguchi M, Oritani S, Li DR, et al.
Med 2012;126:187‑98. Postmortem serum uric acid and creatinine levels in relation to the
41. Byramji A, Cains G, Gilbert JD, Byard RW. Hyponatremia at autopsy: causes of death. Forensic Sci Int 2002;125:59‑66.
An analysis of etiologic mechanisms and their possible significance. 60. Uemura K, Shintani‑Ishida K, Saka K, Nakajima M, Ikegaya H,
Forensic Sci Med Pathol 2008;4:149‑52. Kikuchi Y, et al. Biochemical blood markers and sampling sites in
42. Zilg B, Alkass K, Berg S, Druid H. Interpretation of postmortem forensic autopsy. J Forensic Leg Med 2008;15:312‑7.
vitreous concentrations of sodium and chloride. Forensic Sci Int 61. Zhu BL, Ishikawa T, Michiue T, Tanaka S, Zhao D, Li DR, et al.
2016;263:107‑13. Differences in postmortem urea nitrogen, creatinine and uric acid levels
43. Coe JI. Use of chemical determinations on vitreous humor in forensic
between blood and pericardial fluid in acute death. Leg Med (Tokyo)
pathology. J Forensic Sci 1972;17:541‑6.
2007;9:115‑22.
44. Mulla A, Massey KL, Kalra J. Vitreous humor biochemical constituents:
Evaluation of between‑eye differences. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 62. Kawamoto O, Michiue T, Ishikawa T, Maeda H. Comprehensive
2005;26:146‑9. evaluation of pericardial biochemical markers in death investigation.
45. Whitehead FJ, Couper RT, Moore L, Bourne AJ, Byard RW. Dehydration Forensic Sci Int 2013;224:73‑9.
deaths in infants and young children. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 63. Naumann HN. Postmortem chemistry of the vitreous body in man. Arch
1996;17:73‑8. Ophthalmol 1959;62:356‑63.
46. Byard RW. Incapacitation or death of a socially isolated parent or carer 64. Hanna PE, Bellamy JE, Donald A. Postmortem eyefluid analysis in
could result in the death of dependent children. J Paediatr Child Health dogs, cats and cattle as an estimate of antemortem serum chemistry
2002;38:417‑8. profiles. Can J Vet Res 1990;54:487‑94.
47. Nowak R, Balabanova S. Determination of calcium and magnesium in 65. Reddy VN, Chakrapani B, Lim CP. Blood‑vitreous barrier to amino
postmortem human vitreous humor as a test to ascertain the cause and acids. Exp Eye Res 1977;25:543‑54.
time of death. Z Rechtsmed 1989;102:179‑83.
66. Niha A, Anand L, Shobhana KM. Smart platform for the time since
48. Farmer JG, Benomran F, Watson AA, Harland WA. Magnesium,
death determination from vitreous humor cystine. Biosens Bioelectron
potassium, sodium and calcium in post‑mortem vitreous humour from
humans. Forensic Sci Int 1985;27:1‑3. 2016;86:115‑21.
49. Gregora Z, Kratochvíl J, Vávrová J, Oplistil L. Sodium and magnesium 67. Erdei Z, Vass Z. Chromatographic investigation of free amino acids of
levels in the vitreous body. Soud Lek 1979;24:51‑4. the human vitreous body. Acta Ophthalmol (Copenh) 1967;45:22‑4.
50. Zhu BL, Ishikawa T, Quan L, Li DR, Zhao D, Michiue T, et al. 68. Patrick WJ, Logan RW. Free amino acid content of the vitreous humour
Evaluation of postmortem serum calcium and magnesium levels in in cot deaths. Arch Dis Child 1988;63:660‑2.