Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Learner Guide - Develop and Manage Performance BSBHRM512
Learner Guide - Develop and Manage Performance BSBHRM512
Table of Contents
Introduction ........................................................................................................................................................ 4
Chapter 1 – Develop performance management processes ............................................................ 5
What is performance management? ......................................................................................................... 5
1. Learner Activity – Analyse strategic and operational plans ................................................. 9
Develop performance objectives and metrics .................................................................................... 12
2. Learner Activity – Goals, objectives an targets ...................................................................... 13
3. Learner Activity – Design job standards .................................................................................. 14
4. Learner Activity – Develop KPIs .................................................................................................. 19
Develop effective processes ...................................................................................................................... 21
5. Learner Activity – Design methods and processes to develop KPIs .............................. 23
Develop processes for formal performance appraisal meetings ................................................. 24
6. Learner Activity – Design a performance appraisal process ............................................. 26
Consult with key stakeholders .................................................................................................................. 29
7. Learner Activity – Identify and assess stakeholders............................................................. 32
8. Learner Activity – Gain support for implementing performance processes ............... 36
Chapter 2 – Implement performance management processes .................................................... 37
Provide manager training ........................................................................................................................... 37
9. Learner Activity – Training needs analysis for managers................................................... 39
Effective training ............................................................................................................................................ 40
10. Learner Activity – Training methods and support............................................................. 41
11. Learner Activity – Plan a training session ............................................................................. 44
Support mentoring, proactive coaching and continual feedback ............................................... 45
Support intervention to manage underperformance ....................................................................... 47
12. Learner Activity – Managing underperformance ............................................................... 47
13. Learner Activity – Intervention to manage underperformance .................................... 49
14. Learner Activity – Counsel and discipline employees ...................................................... 51
15. Learner Activity – Appropriate recordkeeping for intervention ................................... 53
BSBHRM512- Develop and manage performance-management processes
Greenwich Management College
Issue Date: 25 February 2016
Page 2 of 81
ABN -31 114 584 940 RTO Provider 91153 CRICOS Code: 02672K
Level 2,396 Pitt Street, Sydney NSW 2000 Australia
Tel: +61 2 9264 2223 Email: info@greenwichcollege.com.au
Web: www.greenwichcollege.com.au
Introduction
This unit describes the skills and knowledge required to design performance objectives
and metrics and how to develop performance management processes in an
organisation.
This unit applies to individuals who are authorised to establish effective performance
management processes for an organisation and who may have staff reporting to them.
1 nd
Armstrong, M., 2000, Performance Management: Key Strategies and Practical Guidelines, 2 edition,
Kogan Page, pp. 1–2.
An ineffective system, on the other hand, tends to lead the organisation toward
inconsistent performance and poor morale.
On an individual level, the performance management cycle focuses on the time the
employee is with the organisation and is developed by the organisation to achieve their
potential and assist the organisation is meeting its goals.
Plan
Review Act
Monitor
The four stages in the performance management cycle can be described in more detail as
follows.
The performance management cycle should be applied to the whole workforce where
every stage provides a basic framework for improving people performance. Each stage is
supported by important performance management components such s processes and
documentation.
Performance management systems and processes must be integrated in order for them
to be effective in building capability. Effective performance management processes
ensure that activities at every level of the organisation are coordinated and align with
organisational goals.
The below chart demonstrates how performance management can be integrated both
vertically – linking organisational, departmental, team and individual objectives and
capabilities – and horizontally – linking other components of HR as well as other
management systems.
including the vision, mission of the organisation, its goals and strategic objectives, the
company structure and its operations at all levels.
Different organisation would have different goals and strategies to achieve those goals
hence performance management would need to be tailored to each organisation.
The performance management strategy must support both overall organisational strategy
and HR strategy.
Scenario:
You are the new HR manager of ‘GoodBuy’, a supermarket distribution warehouse,
which supplies over 70 small to medium-sized independent supermarkets and
convenience stores throughout Victoria.
Vision
To establish, within five years, the reputation of ‘GoodBuy’ as the premier supplier of
independent supermarkets in Victoria.
The strategic plans of ‘GoodBuy’ that will achieve its mission and vision through:
Engaging with customers
Maintaining superior product line
Increasing market share
Increasing profitability through growth
Growing distribution capacity
Supporting innovative thinking, management and leadership skills creating a high-
performing organisation
Task:
1. Analyse strategic and organisational plans (including vision and mission) and
identify objectives to be addressed in integrated performance management
processes to be developed.
As part of performance management, you need to set clear expectations for people
working in particular roles. This means you will have to:
These terms are often used interchangeably however goals are more general than
objectives, while targets are more narrowly defined than targets.
The bellow example illustrates an organisational goal, related objectives and targets:
Job standards
Job standards are work performance benchmarks in terms of quantity and quality
expected from each employee. These standards form the basis for performance reviews.
The most common ways to describe and measure standards of acceptable performance
include: time, accuracy, quantity and quality.
BSBHRM512- Develop and manage performance-management processes
Greenwich Management College
Issue Date: 25 February 2016
Page 13 of 81
ABN -31 114 584 940 RTO Provider 91153 CRICOS Code: 02672K
Level 2,396 Pitt Street, Sydney NSW 2000 Australia
Tel: +61 2 9264 2223 Email: info@greenwichcollege.com.au
Web: www.greenwichcollege.com.au
Examples:
Job standards
Time
Accuracy
Quantity
Quality
Further information
To have a better understanding o how to write effective job standards, you can download
a tutorial at:
http://www.google.hu/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=2&ved=0ahUKEwi5
6Zj76XLAhWoJZoKHetZBBMQFggjMAE&url=http%3A%2F%2Fhr.uky.edu%2Ftandd%2Fdo
cuments%2FWriting%2520Effective%2520Job%2520Standards%2520Tutorial.doc&usg=A
FQjCNEO3ro0qpVGBjOykgG36-K27nzI6A
A key performance indicator (KPI) can be a numbers, percentages or ratio that indicates
some important measures of performance. KPIs typically cover the following key result
areas (KRAs):
Performance indicators will vary according to the nature and goals of a business and the
nature and responsibilities of specific jobs. For example, a courier might have a
performance indicator relating to the percentage of deliveries made on time, whereas a
call centre operator might have a performance indicator concerning the percentage of
customer calls answered within a minute.
1. KPIs should promote common and clear understanding, so they must be:
Simple enough for anyone to understand
Calculated in a standard way across the organisation
Documented
st
Adapted from Student Workbook, BSBMGT517 Manage operational plan, 1 Edition 2015
KPI types
Lagging indicators These KPIs indicate past performance. They are typically
“output” oriented, easy to measure but hard to improve or
influence.
Examples:
Time taken to answer a phone call
Amount of sales generated in a months The number of
orders recorded accurately
Number of complaints resolved
Leading indicators These PKIs are future oriented, they measure the input that
should be introduced to achieve better results. They are
typically hard to measure and easy to influence.
Examples:
How much training a sales representative has completed
to improve their sales skills
How many customer has a sales representative
approached in order to promote a new product
Considering the organisational strategic goals and objectives, develop KPIs for a
customer service agent at ‘GoodBuy’. You may use performance measure listed in
‘GoodBuy’ operational plan outlined in the first learner activity.
Balanced scorecards
They are used to records individual KPIs and are provided to employees at the beginning
of the performance period, so employees are aware of what is expected from them.
They consider both financial and non-financial contributions of individual employees to
business strategic and operational goals.
A balanced scorecard would typically list the following key result areas:
Financial
Customer satisfaction
Internal business process
Professional development
Policies
Policies inform employees of the overall aims of the organisation, such as ensuring
quality, consistency, fairness or legal compliance, with regard to particular aspects of
operations and performance.
Policy content:
Purpose statement (the intent of the policy, desired standards and objectives)
Scope (whom does it apply to, a workgroup, a department)
Resources (additional document, related forms)
Roles and responsibilities (who is responsible for implementation)
Legislation (Identification of any applicable legislation)
Procedures
The new behaviour is good for them in some way. ‘Good’ may come from
remuneration, self-esteem, a sense of belonging or many other personal
motivating forces.
Their peers and friends will support them in behaving in the manner required.
People are affected by what they see as the ‘subjective norm’. If they believe that
their peers and friends whose views they value do not support them
demonstrating the required behaviour, they are unlikely to do so.
They have the capability to behave in the way required. People need to believe
that they have the necessary skills, knowledge, resources and authority to execute
the required behaviour.
Appraisals help develop individuals, improve organisational performance, and feed into
business planning. Formal performance appraisals are generally conducted annually or
biannually for all permanent staff in an organisation. Staff members are usually appraised
by their manager.
The HR department should provide guidance and support to line managers on how to
conduct a performance appraisal session. A performance appraisal planning checklist can
also assist managers in conducting the appraisal session.
BSBHRM512- Develop and manage performance-management processes
Greenwich Management College
Issue Date: 25 February 2016
Page 24 of 81
ABN -31 114 584 940 RTO Provider 91153 CRICOS Code: 02672K
Level 2,396 Pitt Street, Sydney NSW 2000 Australia
Tel: +61 2 9264 2223 Email: info@greenwichcollege.com.au
Web: www.greenwichcollege.com.au
The below checklist is used by line managers for performance appraisal session at
‘GoodBuy’, however the procedure for performance appraisal meeting has not yet
been developed.
Your task is to develop a procedure for conducting formal appraisal meetings. The
checklist below can assist you in developing the formal procedure.
Date
Task
completed
Submit paperwork to HR
When creating a performance management system, input should be sought from key
stakeholders to determine the best method for performance management or the
required features of the performance management system.
You will also need to consult with and manage key stakeholders to gain support and
agreement for performance management processes
To identify stakeholders you have to list everyone who can be affected by the
performance management process, which means:
Prioritise stakeholders
You may have a long list of stakeholders that are potentially affected by your
performance management process. The level of power, interest and influence will vary.
Some of these stakeholders have more power to help you or block your ideas, and some
have less power to do so.
Using this matrix can help you map your stakeholders based on their power and interest
in performance management process.
BSBHRM512- Develop and manage performance-management processes
Greenwich Management College
Issue Date: 25 February 2016
Page 29 of 81
ABN -31 114 584 940 RTO Provider 91153 CRICOS Code: 02672K
Level 2,396 Pitt Street, Sydney NSW 2000 Australia
Tel: +61 2 9264 2223 Email: info@greenwichcollege.com.au
Web: www.greenwichcollege.com.au
Stakeholder matrix
High power, interested people: you must fully engage with these people and
keep them satisfied
High power, less interested people: keep these people satisfied but don’t
overwhelm them with too much information, as they will get bored
Low power, interested people: Keep them informed and seek their feedback, as
it can often be very helpful
Low power, less interested people: monitor them but minimise the effort you
put in their communication
Consultation process
Stakeholders who are higher priority will require a more involved consultation method
than those classified as low priority, as outlined in the table below:
Identify an example of a stakeholder for each quadrant and detail why you have
classified this person in this category. You may use the organisational chart provided
below to identify certain stakeholders.
Management support
Any new system, including performance management process, will not work unless it
receives the full support of middle and senior management. Management must provide
all the necessary resources to ensure the success of the program.
Finance
Equipment
Opportunity
Morale, support and encouragement
Employee support
Whenever a new system or change is made in the workplace, employees always look
upon it with suspicion. The first question they will ask is: “What’s in it for me?”
There are several ways management can gain employee support including:
Obtaining approval
Depending on your organisational policies and procedures, you may not gain approval
for performance management processes. It is important that you understand this
approval process, which would determine the following:
You are about to implement the new procedure for performance appraisal at
‘GoodBuy’. Since you are aware of the employees’ resistance to change, you are
planning to hold a meeting to gain their support, as that would be essential for the
success of this new initiative.
• Setting objectives
• Defining capabilities
• Selecting and using performance measures and indicators
• Monitor and identify performance gaps
• Provide feedback, counselling and coaching
BSBHRM512- Develop and manage performance-management processes
Greenwich Management College
Issue Date: 25 February 2016
Page 37 of 81
ABN -31 114 584 940 RTO Provider 91153 CRICOS Code: 02672K
Level 2,396 Pitt Street, Sydney NSW 2000 Australia
Tel: +61 2 9264 2223 Email: info@greenwichcollege.com.au
Web: www.greenwichcollege.com.au
Managers and supervisors need to be trained in the performance gap analysis in order to
identify strong as well as weak areas of skills application in the employees job
performance.
Before you design any training for managers, you must conduct out a training needs
analysis in order to:
You are required to design a training session for line managers at ‘GoodBuy’ about
conducting performance appraisals. Before you start designing the training, you
must conduct a training needs analysis.
The first step is to determine what skills and competencies are required to
conduct appraisal meetings. List them below.
In order to identify any skills and competency gaps, you need to determine the
level of skills and competencies of line managers who are required to conduct
such meetings. How can you do so?
Effective training
Training programs need to utilise various training methods and provide ongoing support
systems, e.g. mentor, follow-up and information.
Training programs must cater for any special needs, e.g. language literacy and numeracy
problems (LLNP), or disabilities and it should comply with relevant legislation.
Training should comply with relevant legislation and is should always be monitored,
evaluated and reviewed.
Explain
Demonstrate
You are required to design a training session for line managers at ‘GoodBuy’ about
conducting performance appraisals (as per the previous learner activity).
Which training methods and support would you select for this training and why?
Session planning
Before delivering a training session, you should always do the required preparation,
which includes completing a session planner. This will ensure that you include all
information required, arrange all resources and equipment and your training is well
structured. The better the planning, the easier the delivery is for you.
Teaching or
assessment strategy
Timeframe Activity or approach to Tools/resources
achieve session
objectives
15 min Overview of a sales Presentation Projector, laptop,
technique Internet
Use the template provided to plan a training session for line managers on how to
conduct performance appraisal meetings.
You may use the information already gathered in the previous two learning activities.
Teaching or
assessment strategy
Timeframe Activity or approach to Tools/resources
achieve session
objectives
In addition to formal training and performance appraisal, you will need to provide or
encourage ongoing support to employees through informal performance management
activities.
Common ongoing activities include mentoring and coaching. You will also need to
encourage regular monitoring and feedback to ensure employees continue to perform at
their potential and in alignment with organisational needs.
Mentoring
Coaching
Coaching is the act of directing, guiding and training an individual or group to achieve
better performance. It often involves modelling what to do.
1. Goal
2. Reality
3. Options
4. Will
Further information
To gain a better understanding about coaching and mentoring, please visit the following
coaching website and read the article provided:
http://new.coachingnetwork.org.uk/information-portal/what-are-coaching-and-mentoring/
What is underperformance?
Types of interventions
Education
Sponsorship
Providing feedback
Positive and negative feedback is equally important, as positive feedback re-assures the
employee of being on the right track while negative feedback provides the opportunity
for improvement. Negative feedback should always be constructive and it is best to give
it as soon as the underperformance is identified.
The process for giving positive The process for giving negative
feedback: feedback:
The customer service team leader at ‘GoodBuy’ approaches you for your advice.
Hugh, a customer service representative is not performing to the required standards:
he has provided inaccurate information to the customer on a number of occasions,
he does not follow the ordering procedures and has taken wrong orders a few times.
Hugh’s performance appraisal is due and the team leader is unsure how to manage
his underperformance and is asking for your assistance.
What advice would you give the team leader? What type of intervention should the
team leader first use to manage underperformance in this scenario?
Counselling
The primary purpose of counselling is to help the employee to solve personal and
behavioural problems rather than a lack of on the job skills. Work based problems
involving the lack of skills can be dealt with by skills training and up skilling. Counselling,
on the other hand, can be seen as an elaboration of a joint problem-solving effort. The
aim of counselling is to guide the employee to improve their performance or correct any
inappropriate behaviour rather than to punish them.
Oral and written warning can be given in the counselling phase, while the other options are
rather used in the confronting phase.
What approach you take when dealing with an underperforming employee depends on
whether the employees are willing and are able to improve.
The appropriate intervention for employees who exhibit different ability and willingness is
demonstrated in the below matrix.
Outline the remaining intervention options to assist the team leader in this situation.
Grievance procedures
Employees may be unhappy with some aspects of performance management.
Uncooperative workers.
Negotiation
Whilst most employees will receive their appraisals quite calmly, some may not accept
them. It may be necessary to go through a negotiation or conflict resolution process to
handle this situation.
If negotiation does not work, then you should advise employees of their options under the
organisation's dispute resolution or grievance procedures.
3. If not resolved, the issue can be brought to the attention of the Human Resources
Department
5. The employee (and union representative, if applicable) can discuss the matter with
the supervisor/manager, a senior manager and a HR officer
6. Either the employee or the union can refer the issue to the Australian Industrial
Relations Commission (AIRC).
Support counselling
BSBHRM512- Develop and manage performance-management processes
Greenwich Management College
Issue Date: 25 February 2016
Page 54 of 81
ABN -31 114 584 940 RTO Provider 91153 CRICOS Code: 02672K
Level 2,396 Pitt Street, Sydney NSW 2000 Australia
Tel: +61 2 9264 2223 Email: info@greenwichcollege.com.au
Web: www.greenwichcollege.com.au
Managers may need your support as they undertake counselling processes as part of an
intervention to remedy a performance issue.
Counselling tips:
Counselling process
When all previous attempts to manage poor performance or behaviour have been
exhausted, or if the employee has committed serious misconduct, formal disciplinary
action must be taken.
What is misconduct?
If other methods have been ineffective, you may need to hold a disciplinary meeting for
the employee that may require the attendance of the following:
If, once all possible assistance has been given to the employee, the employee's
performance still does not improve, then it will be necessary to institute progressive
discipline.
You will need to provide support to managers who are undertaking termination processes.
In doing this, you will need to ensure access to procedures, provide advice, and ensure the
process adheres to organisational policies and legislative requirements. Such requirements
may include, for example, the Fair Work Act 2009 and antidiscrimination legislation.
Employers could ask themselves the following questions before deciding to terminate
employment:
Unfair dismissal
Fair Work Australia (FWA) defines unfair dismissal as harsh, unjust or unreasonable and if it
is not a case of redundancy. To determine whether a dismissal is unfair FWA considers the
following point:
Was there a valid reason for the dismissal that related to the employee’s conduct or
ability to do their work?
Was the employee notified of the reason for their dismissal and given the
opportunity to respond?
In case of unsatisfactory performance, was the employee warned before the
dismissal?
Notice of termination
3. Issue two written warnings if counselling and disciplinary action have not been
successful; first warning following the interview and second and final warning if
there is no improvement after monitoring process.
4. Notice of termination issued to employee, giving the required notice period (weekly,
fortnightly or monthly) according to the employment contract
5. Document all warning and termination notices making sure employee sign and
acknowledge receipt
6. Include copies of all the above in the employee’s personnel file as the official record.
Further information
As part of continuous improvement, you will need to regularly evaluate and improve all
aspects of the performance management processes in accordance with organisational
plans, policies and procedures.
You will also need to reflect on your own performance and seek feedback to improve your
performance as an HR professional.
Use checklists (list all skills and behaviours of effective HR professionals and tick the
ones you possess)
Use evaluation frameworks
Get feedback from peers or managers
Designing learning and development plans helps organisations to build capability, achieve
goals and improve performance management.
Before developing learning and development plans you need to conduct training needs
analysis to identify any gaps. Training needs analysis include:
Training options
Informal training
Formal training
E-learning
Workshops
Coaching and mentoring
Conference
Training packages are documents that outline the range of training options available for
an industry sector. (E.g. this unit is from the Human Resources package).
Qualifications are made up from a combination of core and elective units and if you gain
a qualification you become qualified to work in that job role.
Australian Qualifications Framework (AQF) defines the levels of nationally recognised
education and training in Australia.
Levels in Australian Quality Framework are split across three sectors:
Each level in the AQF provides a guide about the complexity of skills and knowledge that a
competent learner at that level should demonstrate. You should be familiar with the AQF
as you design personal learning and development plans and choose training, to ensure it is
a suitable level for the ability and the role the person is working in, or is aiming to work in.
Further reading
To get a better understanding about the Australian Quality Framework, visit the following
website: http://www.aqf.edu.au
Video
There is a video and an article that describes how to match competency standards to
learners needs: http://students.fortresslearning.com.au/course/des401-3/understanding-
the-structure-of-a-unit-of-competency/
A personal development plan (PDP) is no different from any other plan; it requires goals
and objectives, actionable strategies, milestones and some method of measuring
progress and results.
A PDP should be a living document that employees should take personal responsibility
for maintaining with the support and collaboration of the manger.
A HR professional cannot only help line managers to evaluate and address individual
learning and development needs, but also developing groups and organisational
development plans.
Creation of an organisational learning and development plan is a more complex task and
it involves the following generic steps:
5. Evaluate the gaps and design learning interventions and make them available to
line managers and individuals to close that skills gap
To ensure the practical delivery of training and learning and development outcomes, you
will need to:
As part of this phase, you need to plan regular training and training evaluation and
integrate training with existing operations and performance management processes.
You may often need to contract external training providers to deliver professional
development services for various reasons:
To ensure a suitable and high quality training provider organisations will need to consider
the following:
Duration How long will the training program run for? Is the
length of time adequate for the training needs?
Assessment methods Does the assessment cover all the specific outcomes of
the program?
Use your personal development plan that you had developed for the previous
learner activity.
Conduct a research to source training providers that would deliver appropriate
training to address your skills gaps.
Detail one example:
Provider name
Course name
Accreditation
Duration
Cost
Course material
Assessment
methods
Delivery mode
Location
Availability
Supply specifications will need to be created – this will provide the basis for assessment.
You will need to take action if the supplier does not comply with the agreed specification,
fails to meet quality assurance standards or there is a problem with performance.
You will need to approach negotiations in a positive and constructive manner in order to
achieve quality objectives for the training. This is perhaps even truer in cases where you
need to address poor quality provided and negotiate a joint approach to remedying the
situation.
The following steps (in this order) should be observed in the negotiation of
remedial action:
1. The organisation provides the training supplier with formal notification of non-
compliance with quality assurance standards
4. The organisation requires the training provider to identify the primary cause of
the problem
7. The organisation requires the supplier to provide a strategy for the total
elimination of the problem
Listen to the other’s position carefully. Make sure you understand it and why it
may be important to them.
Look for shared goals. Both positions may be compatible.
Explore options and trade-offs.
Be prepared to politely walk away, if you can’t achieve your required
objectives.
Regardless of the type of negotiation, you will need to develop clear objectives.
When it comes to negotiating training contracts, your objectives may be financial,
time driven or quality driven.
Give examples of such objectives.
Financial
Time driven
Quality driven
Generate reports
To support your recommendations and persuade others (such as the senior management
team), you will need to ensure you can explain how your recommendations will lead to
the required outcome.
You always have to outline the positive effects of your proposal establishing cause and
effect examples. For instance, if your recommendation is to alter performance
management processes to include an incentives program, you should provide examples
of other organisations introducing such programs and achieving success.
Report structure:
Body The main body of the report should detail the key findings of your
report and analysis. The body of your report should include:
Data collection techniques/methods used
Findings or results
Analysis, discussion and explanation of your findings.
The body should be presented in a logical sequence. It may be
divided into sections outlined by heading and subheadings.
Conclusion Summarise the key points from the main body of the report
Clearly relate to the objectives of the report
No new information should be included here.
Performance
Chapter Name Element
Criteria
employees