Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Libro Feminismo
Libro Feminismo
Libro Feminismo
Designing a a
Feminist Alexa
Feminist Alexa
An experiment in
feminist conversation design
Contents
Introduction 4
Approaches to
Diversity & Inclusion 6
Fellowship Overview 7
Workshop Design 8
Day one 10
Context
Purpose
Persona Creation
Day two 12
Refining Ideas
Storyboarding
Conversation Design
Idea generation
Day three 14
Prototyping
Presenting
Reflecting
Protoypes 16
Conversation Design
Without Coding 20
Feedback 22
Conclusion 24
Introduction
“…we had talk
enough but no
The UAL Creative Computing
conversation; Institute fellowships represent a
there was nothing substantial part of the Institute’s
annual public programme which
discussed.” exists to connect students,
practitioners and researchers at
- Samuel Johnson the
University of the Arts London
with an international community
of creative computational
professionals, artists and
activists.
When facing the task of how to Creative Computing Institutewas an The broad context for the project is
design a workshop that would allow opportunity to ponder these difficult the gendering of personal intelligent
participants to imagine and prototype questions through practice, and to assistants(PIAs) which are so often
feminist conversational interfaces, challenge ourselves as designers of characterised as female. As Jaqueline
one question kept nagging at the education and technology to come up Feldman says,
Feminist Internet team: WTF is a with some answers.
feminist conversation?What kind of “By creating interactions that
exchange between a human and a encourage consumers to understand
piece of technology would qualify as the objects that serve them as
‘feminist’? How could the feminist women, technologists abet the
nature of the exchange be measured prejudice by which women are
by the designers of the technology? considered objects.” 1
Could there ever be a feminist
response to ‘Hey Alexa, what’s the As well as this female
weather like today?’ Being awarded characterisation, the way PIAs are
the inaugural fellowship at UAL’s new programmed to respond to abuse
1
Feldman, J. (2016) T he Bot Politic, The
New Yorker: bit.ly/AlexaReport01
- and yes, people actually verbally Another context is t he rise of voice driven by what they ‘say’ - which is,
abuse these devices as though they technology, which is predicted to of course, shaped by the data they
are real women 2 - is problematic. shift the landscape of search and have collected about us. As the voice
Responses that are coy, or even e-commerce in the coming years.3 ‘revolution’ unfolds, we see a fantastic
flirtatious, or which simply ‘don’t Google and Amazon voice assistants opportunity to build conversational
compute’ abusive remarks are are colonizing the world of electronic interfaces that have drivers beyond
woefully inadequate. At Feminist devices like Google Home, Amazon commerce - drivers around positive
Internet we expect better than this, Echo, smart speakers, smart displays, social change and wellbeing. In
and believe that PIAs should educate phones, headphones TVs, cars, other words, wewant to imagine
as well as simply comply. We want laptops and wearables, conditioning technologies that can empower their
to see PIAs that reflect interesting, people to use voice in a way that users rather than just help them
nuanced understandings of gender, becomes more and more natural. So, search and shop.
that respond adequately when they it is going to become more and more
receive verbal harassment, and which common to talk to and be listened So, with the help of our learning
support the advancement of internet to by the devices that surround partners, we gathered 40 UAL
equalities. us, and have consumer behaviour students and several Alexas
together for two intensive 3-day
workshops, with a mission to
imagine and prototype personal
2
Fessler, L. (2017) We tested bots like Siri 3
McCue, TJ. (2018) Okay Google: Voice
intelligent assistants that would
and Alexa to see who would stand up to Search Technology And The Rise Of Voice
meet a meaningful human need, and
sexual harassment, Quartz: Commerce, Forbes
embody feminist values. Here’s how it
bit.ly/AlexaReport02 bit.ly/AlexaReport03
happened...
In line with the UAL Creative application formwas simple, jargon- intersectional nature of feminism,
Computing Institute’s commitment free and friendly. We welcomed explaining that gender oppression
to diversity in technology and digital students to approach us if they felt often intersects with other forms of
inclusion, we took several steps to unsure they would fit in: oppression, such as capitalism, or
ensure the programme celebrated colonialism.4 Aspects of the workshop
diversity and was inclusive. The “We believe it’s very important that focused on Human Centred
workshop facilitators, learning to have a diverse group of people Design placed emphasis on being
partners, speakers and panellists taking part. Everybody’s welcome! If respectful of people from different
represented different ages, you’re thinking: “That sounds great, cultures and backgrounds, and the
ethnicities, nationalities, genders, but it’s not for me because x or y”, recognising the danger of falling into a
gender identities and values, which we our email is open”. ‘sympathetic’ rather then empathetic
felt was important so that students role, when trying to solve social
could recognise themselves in the By nature, the workshops explored problems. Chimamanda Ngozi Adichi’s
programme, and explore the topic issues of diversity, tackling gender Ted Talk, The Dangers of the Single
from different perspectives. We bias both in the technology industry Story was invaluable in this regard.5
required no prior technical experience, and in algorithms, and encouraged
and made sure that the language students to look for ways to mitigate
of the call for applicationsand the against this. We emphasised the
4
We gave Patricia Hill Collins’ ‘Matrix of 5
Ngozi Adichie, C. (2009) The Danger
Domination’ as a reference here. See Collins, of a Single Story, TED:
P. H. (1990), ‘Black Feminist Thought in the bit.ly/AlexaReport05
Matrix of Domination’ in Black Feminist Thought:
Knowledge, Consciousness, and the Politics of
Empowerment, pp.221–238.
Applicant data
• 2 three-day workshops • 42 participants
• 2 key learning partners →→12 first generation
entrants to University
• +200 UAL students and staff →→12 EU students
→→18 International students
• +100 industry people
→→12 Home (UK) students
• 8 feminist Alexa prototypes
The tricky question of ‘WTF is a their users? We felt that having ensuring it doesn’t knowingly
feminist conversation’ challenged a framework to measure their or unknowingly perpetuate
us to consider how we would work against was necessary, gender inequality.” We took
measure the success of the and discovered that the perfect Josie’s framework, simplifying and
workshop. How could we ensure thing was already out there. modifying for our purposes, and
that we participants were able Feminist AI researcher Josie Feminist Internet Visual Designer
to evidence the use of feminist Young has developed a Feminist Conor Rigby treated it graphically,
values in the design of their Chatbot Design Process6, so there were visual ‘tags’
PIAs, and the conversations which aims to help designers representing each standard:
they imagined them to have with “make your chatbot better by
Design &
User Representation Purpose
Rather than design a PIA for How are you planning to depict Considering the needs of your
a ‘universal’ user – can you or represent your chatbot to identified user, what is the
identify a user that can be your users? purpose of the feminist PIA?
empowered through a feminist
PIA?
Conversational
Design Team Bias
The conversation is the We all come from places and We then mapped the standards
primary interface between experiences that have shaped to each stage of the workshop, so
the human and the PIA. It’s our thinking and perspectives, that participants had something
how the user will decide and we tend to unconsciously
to guide their thinking. For
whether the PIA is effective, embed these perspectives in
their final presentations, we
so the design needs to be the things that we make. The
carefully crafted. What types risk of not reflecting on these encouraged the students to
of responses would embody questions is that your PIA may articulate how they had used the
feminist values? How can you reinforce negative stereotypes standards in the development of
get the PIA to speak with a about particular groups of the ideas →
feminist voice? people, which could be harmful
to your users. How might we
embed bias in the design?
6
Young, J. (2017) Designing Feminist Chatbots
- Research Summary, PDF:
bit.ly/AlexaReport06
Purpose
Day 2
Conversational
Purpose User Design
Day 3
Conversational Conversational
Design Design
Design &
Representation
1 2
3 4
Francis Agnes
Age: Age:
22 75
Location: Location:
from Asia London
1 2
Storyboards
User Purpose
7
The Pop Up Agency:
https://thepopupagency.co/
1 2
Pitching
After a furious final scramble to
get things finished, each group
presented a pitch deck and did a
live demo of their conversation.
This went 100% smoothly for
every group. Honest.
Reflecting
Pany
Team Bias Team Bias Representation
Has your team reflected on how your How will your PIA remind the user it’s
values and position might lead you to not human?
choose one option over another?
bit.ly/panyprototype
Conversational
Bud
Design
bit.ly/budprototype
Page
Conversational
Design
bit.ly/pageprototype
Will you assign a gender to your PIA? How will your PIA remind the user it’s
Why? not human?
bit.ly/essyprototype
Pillow
Design & Conversational
Representation Design
How will your PIA remind the user it’s If it receives abuse, how will the PIA
not human? respond?
bit.ly/pillowprototype
B(o)(o)
Design &
Representation Purpose
How will your PIA remind the user it’s How will your PIA remind the user it’s
not human? not human?
bit.ly/booprototype
Egami
Design & Design &
Representation Representation
What’s the tone of voice (physically Will you assign a gender to your PIA? Why?
and metaphorically)? In what waysmight this reinforce or chal-
lenge gender stereotypes?
bit.ly/egamiprototype
Anything else :)
Marina Dragzilla’s check out
Thank you to the creative For many people gender and technology are things that are
organizers of this workshop. So completely separate. Many people don’t understand how
badass. So bomb gender can impact technology, so changing this is one of my
quests, and I think I found the best group ever to be friends
Thank you for being so generous,
with because they have this quest also… and you’re now
caring, and patient. I can
only embrace all the values taking it to your practice as students and professionals, so
represented by Feminist Internet I just want to say thank you so much. It’s very heartwarming
and Comuzi. I loved working with to see that people are interested in this and it was very rich
you all and hope to do it again in to watch the whole process and to see these outcomes. For
the future! me it could not have been more of a success, and I hope that
in the queer future we’re building together there will be way
I am very grateful for this more discussion of gender and technology and you can take
experience and hope for the
this to other places you go
workshop to be developed in other
UAL colleges and beyond UAL in
the future, as it is necessary to
get students to think about the
ethics of the web to ensure a
good future for the Internet for all
Exploring the question of “WTF is nuanced sex education, or develop the technologies we were inventing.
a feminist conversation?” through self-knowledge. We realised that We knew that, in an ideal world we
creative practice, with a group of there may not be a feminist response would have had more conversations
extraordinary young artists and to the question “Hey Alexa, what’s with the people we were designing
designers was, in itself, like having the weather”. What this reveals is for - conversations that would help
a fascinating, challenging but not that feminism is ‘lost for words’, us understand their challenges and
ultimately rewarding conversation. but that Alexa isn’t designed to elicit aspirations. In the end, what happened
Over two 3-day periods, we talked to feminist conversations. In fact it is over this fellowship was part of a
imaginary users, Alexa, researchers, not designed to elicit conversations bigger ‘feminist conversation’, but by
educators and each other. We at all. creating a discursive, transformative
brought our diverse perspectives environment, and producing real world
about feminism(s) to bear on the As temporary conversation prototypes, we took as step towards
design of technologies that could designers, we tried to bring a clearly making the conversation more than
engage their users in conversations articulated set of feminist values just talk. ♥
that might improve wellbeing, reduce to the design process so that we
loneliness, boost body-image, deliver could weave them into the fabric of
www.feministinternet.com www.arts.ac.uk/
enquiries@feministinternet.com creative-computing-institute
Twitter: @feministintrnet Twitter: @UAL_CCI
Instagram: @feministinternet Instagram: @ual_cci