Professional Documents
Culture Documents
5 1@10.1163 - 157007483X00014 (HockenP1983 Jesus Christ and The Gifts of The Spirit)
5 1@10.1163 - 157007483X00014 (HockenP1983 Jesus Christ and The Gifts of The Spirit)
5 1@10.1163 - 157007483X00014 (HockenP1983 Jesus Christ and The Gifts of The Spirit)
by Peter Hocken
1 Apartial exception is found in the case of healing.Many early Pentecostals, e.g. those
who were previously in the Christian and Missionary Alliance, believed in divine healing
prior to being baptized in the Spirit. However, the evidence is that healing became more
prominent in their awareness after baptism in the Spirit, and it then took its place more
clearly among the full range of charismata pneumatika.
Peter Hocken (S.T.L., Accademia Alfonsiana , Rome), is on the staff of the Mother of God
Community, Washington, D.C. He is a prolific writer, doing research from within the
Catholic charismatic tradition. Father Hocken serves as Catholic Book Editor for
PNEUMA.
in the declaration of faith of the Assemblies of God (USA) stating: "With
it (the Baptism) comes the enduement of power for life and service, the
'
bestowment of the gifts and their uses in the work of the ministry"
(para. 7).
It is appropriate then in a conference on the theme of charisms to
look more closely at this link between the spiritual gifts and baptism in
the Spirit. In particular, I want to examine how these spiritual realities,
the gifts and the baptism, were understood in relation to the three
Divine Persons, especially the Son and the Spirit.
1The A/G definition does speak of "life and service" but the dominant interpretation
is power for ministry. There is no significant difference here between those holding a
two-stage and those holding a three-stage view of conversion, sanctification and baptism
in the Spirit. The Apostolic Faith of Azusa Street which taught a three-stage doctrine
stated in a profession of faith "The Baptism with the Holy Ghost is a gift of power for the
sanctified life." Issues of September 1906, p. 2; November 1906, p. 2; September,
1907, p. 2; May 1908, p. 2.
2 Ase.g. in the Declaration of Faith of the Elim Pentecostal Churches of Great Britain
and Ireland, quoted in W.J. Hollenweger The Pentecostals, p. 519.
- 2-
Accounts of baptism in the Spirit which focus on power without
specifying any relationship with the person of Jesus lead readily to
presentations of the spiritual gifts simply in terms of power and without
specific reference to Jesus Christ. Many inadequate views of the
charisms stem from failing to see their relationship to Jesus. Separated
from Jesus, spiritual power is no longer power of the Holy Spirit of God.
We can recall the words of Jesus, "many will say to me 'Lord, Lord, did
we not prophesy in your name, and cast out demons in your name, and
do many mighty works in your name?' And then will I declare to them `I
never knew you; depart from me, you evildoers'" (Mt. 7:22-23).
Separated from Jesus the holiness of the gifts is obscured.
These remarks concern Pentecostal definitions of baptism in the
Spirit, that is to say the teaching that has found its way into formal
professions of faith of Pentecostal denominations. However, these
formal declarations of faith represent a third level which followed upon
two preceding levels (1) the reality experienced which was described
in Pentecostal withnesses and testimonies and (2) the ordinary teaching
being given by Pentecostal preachers prior to the formulation of any
declarations of faith. This process is not unusual in Christian history. I
want now to show that the early Pentecostal witnesses and teaching
present a richer understanding of baptism in the Spirit than found
expression in formal professions of faith.
- 3-
teaches, though not in the account of Pentecost in Acts 2, that the Holy
Spirit reveals the person and work of Jesus Christ.1 More of the Spirit
means more of Jesus Christ. Besides witnessing to this "more," several
of these accounts testify to a deeper understanding of the Cross (e.g. A.
Moomau, C.H. Schoonmaker) or of the Blood (e.g. Mrs. Mead) or to
some vision of Jesus on the Cross (e.g. J. Jeter, Mrs. Price). Many other
similar examples can be found.2
1 CEin particular John 16, vv 13-15; Eph. 1, 17, Rev. 19:10. The one verse in Acts 2
that refers to the co-working of the Son and the Spirit is verse 33: "Being therefore
exalted at the right hand God and having received from the Father the promise of the
Holy Spirit, he has poured out this which you see and hear."
3 Victory,April 1909, p. 1.
- 4-
the God of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of glory, may give you a
spirit of wisdom and of revelation in the knowledge of him, having the
eyes of your hearts enlightened, that you may know
First, the hope, secondly the riches and thirdly the power. The power
depends on the knowledge, a point that will be important when we come
to examine the gifts.
In fact, there are countless references in early Pentecostal teaching
to show that baptism in the Spirit brings a fuller knowledge of God and
of his Son. The Apostolic Faith of Azusa Street teaches, for example:
When a man or woman gets the baptism with the Holy Ghost,
they are filled with continual light. It is a great light than
when you were sanctified. It is the full blessing of Christ.
When you were converted, you got rid of sin; when you were
sanctified, you were cleansed of carnality; but the baptism is
the third Person of the Trinity upon your soul, that reveals
Christ and takes the things of the Father and shows them
unto you.1
- 5-
Many other references could be given.1 In the first issue of The
Apostolic Faith produced in Portland, Oregon, it is taught: "When the
Holy Ghost comes in He reveals Christ in you."2
A fascinating document in this respect is the "London Declaration"
concerning "The Baptism in the Holy Ghost" of November, 1909. The
London Declaration was signed by virtually all the leaders of
Pentecostal meetings in Britain at that time. Under the heading "What
we teach concerning the Evidence and the Results" it states:
-6-
3. - The Judgment of the Devil (Heb. ii., 14, 15).
[The Prince of the World is already condemned.]
'Confidence, December 1909, p. 287. The whole declaration plus list of signatories
takes up pp. 287-8.
4"Jesus is the minister who officiates at this baptism in the Holy Spirit. We present
our whole being to Him. Body, soul, and spirit must be yielded." (Ralph M. Riggs, The
Spirit Himself,p. 67). Yielding to Jesus means fuller measure of Jesus through His Spirit.
- 7-
Towards a fuller definition of baptism in the Spirit
1A.A. Boddy, the Pentecostal pioneer in England, who always remained within the
Church of England, described "seven hall-marks of heaven upon the Pentecostal baptism
with the Sign of Tongues," namely 1., Jesus is Glorified. 2. Calvary is ever honoured.
3. The Bible is Loved. 4. Souls are Saved. 5. Missions to Heathen. 6. Love for Prayer
Gatherings. 7. Readiness for His coming. (Confidence, August 1909, pp. 180-183).
-8-
the Spirit one receives the Spirit in an obvious way? It is not because the
Spirit was not received in conversion, nor is it that Jesus was not
received in being baptized in the Spirit. The important theological point
is that the word "receive" does not mean the same in these two
instances. At conversion, one is responding to the preached word and
accepting the gospel message. This is the beginning of faith, the opening
of the door to Jesus Christ. At baptism in the Spirit, there is a fuller
yielding to Jesus, the surrender of one's faculties of speech, thought and
decision to the same Lord. This fuller yielding, itself a fruit of the Spirit,
opens the human spirit to God, revealing the majesty of Jesus Christ
and making evident the reality and activity of the Holy Spirit. In
conversion, the Spirit is present but the person isn't aware of the Spirit;
in the baptism, the Spirit and Jesus are more fully present in a way that
the distinctive person of the Spirit is known and recognized. It is easy to
see how this has been described as "receiving the Spirit."
We are dealing with successive openings of the human mind and
heart to the Triune God, not with dealings with separate persons of the
Trinity.1 It is then impossible for there to be a change in our capacities
with regard to other people without there being a change in our relation-
ship to God. The new power is function of a changed relationship - the
power of the Spirit reflecting a changed relationship to Jesus Christ.
The second half of the paper examines the consequences of the position
adopted for our understanding of the spiritual gifts.
'
Consequences for the Spiritual Gifts
This inconceivably close relationship between the Son and the Spirit
in baptism in the Spirit also applies to the spiritual gifts to which the
believer is opened at Spirit-baptism. If the Spirit glorifies Jesus, and
makes Jesus known, then the spiritual gifts as works of the Spirit are
equally closely linked to the person of Jesus Christ. The gifts are not, so
to speak, just external tools, however powerful, that the Spirit works to
demonstrate the power of God. They are works of the Divine Spirit, yes,
but the Spirit never acts separately from the Father and the Son, and
1 Itis for this reason that the accounts by some Pentecostals of the sovereign action of
the Spirit are theologicallyunsatisfactory, e.g. Ralph Riggs, when he writes: "As the Holy
Spirit is the agent of God and of Christ, and also operates in His own right, so prophecy is
an agent for other gifts and is also a gift itself' (The Spirit Himself, p. 115). It is the first
"also" and the "His own right" which must be disputed.
-9-
never acts without revealing something of Jesus Christ. This is
classically expressed in John 16:15 "All that the Father has is mine;
therefore I said that he (the Spirit) will take what is mine and declare it
to you." The Holy Spirit is not independent!
The Spirit's relationship to Jesus Christ cannot be separated from
the Spirit's role in the Body of Christ. All the spiritual gifts are for the
building up of the Church, the Body of Christ (cf. 1 Cor. 12: 11-12). The
Spirit and the body go together (the conjunctions in Eph. 4:4-5 are
particularly significant).
The spiritual gifts as distinctive works of the Spirit of God manifest
the saving purpose of the Father as realized in the Son through the
Spirit. Each of the gifts tells us something about the wonderful purpose
of God in forming the Body of Christ. Since the restoration of these gifts
to God's people characterizes the Pentecostal movement, the spiritual
gifts individually and corporately tell us something about the significance
and distinctiveness of the Pentecostal movement in God's purpose.
It will be easiest to explain this further by taking a closer look at
particular gifts. In each case, we should notice the link between seeing
the particular gift in relation to Jesus Christ and seeing how it tells us
something about God's restoring purpose in the Pentecostal movement.
For God's purpose is in no way separable from Jesus Christ, "by whom
and for whom all things have been created" (cf. Col. 1:16).
Prophecy
This same principle applies to tongues and healing. For example not every Spirit-
baptized believer receives a specific ministry of healing, but all are called to pray for the
sick in times of need.
-10-
As I see this distinction working out in the life of a large charismatic
community, the people being given a specific call to be prophets are
those God is training to speak to the whole body to provide its vision and
direction. In such people God looks for a maturity in holiness of life. God
seeks men whom He can trust, as He could trust Jeremiah and John the
Baptist, to speak His word in all situations, come what may. It is in this
fulness of the gift of prophecy that we see most clearly its essential
nature, namely revelation. It reveals the full counsel of God, and it is
given for God's People as a whole.
The kind of prophecy that God gives to each Spirit-baptized believer
is parallel to the love He gives each for other members of the body. It will
be operative in day-to-day living and worship, in situations of mutual
encouragement and consolation. Its horizon will generally be narrower
than that of the recognized prophet, being concerned more with this
day, this group of people, whereas the full prophet will be trained by
God to have horizons as wide as the heart of Christ.
The revelation-gift of prophecy typifies an essential element of the
Christian life being restored to the life of God's People through the
Pentecostal movement. Revelation to the human spirit is being given
back to God's People through this move of the Spirit.
However, God's revelation to the Christian is not restricted to
prophecy. The revelations and illuminations of the Divine Spirit in the
human spirit are not all intended to lead to public utterance. Indeed, at
the heart of them is God's revelation of Himself to the believer, so that
God is more deeply known and more fully worshipped and adored. So
the restoration of prophecy accompanies a restoration of wider aspects
of God's revelation to the Christian.1
This brings us to the role of Jesus in prophecy. God's revelation is
Jesus Christ. As Paul tells the Ephesians:
'
For he (the Father) has made known to us in all wisdom and
insight the mystery of his will, according to his purpose which
he set forth in Christ as a plan for the fulness of time, to unite
all things in him, things in heaven and things on earth (Eph.
1:9-10).
1 Insome ways,we can say the restoration of prophecy has followedthe restoration of
revelation of the things of God to the believer taught within the Keswickand other "higher
life" movements. Cf. section below on "The Significanceof the Pentecostal Movement."
- 11-
God's revelation is not Jesus plus other thing. It is Jesus and how
He brings all things into subjection to Himself in the Body of Christ.
Prophecy then is not just any message from God. It is always in some
way a declaration of God's purpose in His Son. Jesus is not just the
speaker in prophecy. He is also the message.2 He is the truth as well as
the way (cf. John 14:6). This is why the fulness of the gift of prophecy is
found in those commissioned Christians, to whom the Lord has given a
deeper vision of Himself and His Plan so that they can speak God's
Word to the nations and to the whole People of God.
The importance of seeing revelation as characteristic of the Pente-
costal movement and as wider than prophecy is that God's word is not
solely for ministry. It is first to establish the believer in his relationship
to God in Christ, and on that foundation to be a spokesman for God to
others. If Spirit-baptized Christians are not receiving revelation regular-
ly from God in their prayer-times concerning who Jesus is and the place
of Jesus in God's plan, then the chances are that messages received and
uttered as from the Holy Spirit are slight indeed. The person who is not
hearing from the Lord about the Lord himself is not going to be hearing
from him about anything else.
'
Tongues
The renowned Catholic theologian, Karl Rahner, says: "that this (Jesus') word as
God's final word can be understood to be definitive not because God now ceases arbitrarily
to say anything further, although he could have said more, and not just wanted to. It is
the final word of God that is present in Jesus because there is nothing to say beyond it,
because God has really and in a strict sense offered himself in Jesus" (Foundations of
Christian Faith, p. 280).
2The Norwegian leader, Thomas Ball Barratt, quotes with approval a M. Godet who
says: "Assuredly it is not for nothing that the Apostle has begun this whole discussion
on the spiritual gifts by indicating the precise character which distinguishes true and
false inspirations, by recalling that the one have as their common character and essence
this cry of adoration - Jesus, Lord! whilst the others tend to the humiliation and rejection
of Jesus. It was sufficient then to place every prophecy in relation with this centre of
the entire Christian revelation, the Person of Christ, and to see what result the prophecy
which had been heard tended to make little of Him or to glorifyHim" (The Giftof Prophecy,
Peniel Press edn. London 1974, p. 20) Barratt's booklet on prophecy was also included
as a chapter in In the Days of the Latter Rain.
- 12-
by-passing the ordinary human process of mental conception and
linguistic formulation.
Here again, the gift of tongues tells us more about God's restoring
purpose in the Pentecostal movement. Tongues is a prayer of praise.
The gift manifests the natural incapacity of man to praise God. It shows
that praise is first a gift, an activity of the Holy Spirit in the Christian.
In tongues, the Christian makes a quantum leap beyond the
stammering limping character of ordinary human language to declare
what is beyond declaration and to express the inexpressible. In this way,
tongues helps to restore awareness of supernatural mystery to Christian
worship. This gift reminds us of the gift-character, the empowered
character of all Christian worship, not just the exercise of tongues.
Praise of God is both the center and high-point of all Christian worship
and the greatest activity to which the Holy Spirit raises the Christian.
Praise is essentially the declaration of who God is and what He has
done for His people. At Pentecost the disciples who received the Spirit
speak "the mighty works of God" (Acts 2:11). But for the Christian, who
God is revealed in and by Jesus, and what God has done is supremely
the incarnation of His Son. Tongues as an expression of praise is a
declaration of the glory of Jesus Christ. This is why we were created and
yet nothing more transcends our natural capacity.
It is the conscious awareness of the relationship of tongues to Jesus
Christ that safeguards this gift from degenerating into something sub-
Christian. When Jesus is not the center of a person's life, it is still
possible to utter glossolalic sounds, but it will no longer be an
expression of praise. It may well become an instrument for evil spirits, a
point made early in the Pentecostal movement by T.B. Barratt.1 This
symbolic character of tongues as showing what God is restoring through
the Pentecostal movement, namely praise, follows on from what is
indicated by prophecy, namely the restoration of revelation. The two go
together: revelation to the human spirit leads to praise from the human
spirit. As revelation received goes deeper, so the praise and tongues
become richer.
- 13-
Healing
The gifts of healing being restored to God's People make plain God's
total opposition to all evil, and the victory won by Jesus Christ over all
the works of the enemy. Physical disease and affliction, mental illness
and disturbance, are equally consequences of the fall and are a
manifestation of man's alienation from God. While there is not a direct
equation between human disease and a person's sin (cf. Jn. 9:2-3),
disease nonetheless manifests man's fallen state and would not have
been without the fall. Each healing by Jesus is not simply a kind action
done out of love for a suffering individual, but is a declaration of God's
saving purpose for all mankind. The restoration of healing to God's
People particularly through the Pentecostal movement signifies God's
purpose to restore man fully to the image and likeness of God, and
shows that this restoration is an unmerited supernatural action of God.
The full range of God's healing scope, physical, mental and spiritual,
shows clearly that God's saving work extends to the whole man, body,
soul and spirit.
However, here too the spiritual gift is directly concerned with the
person of Jesus Christ. Jesus is not just the healer, but he is the
prototype of whole, human life in union with God. God does not heal sick
man just to relieve pain and discomfort. He heals man so that man can
be what God created him to be, to be incorporated as a living member of
the Body of Christ glorifying Jesus the Head.
This perspective reminds us that sin is the major obstacle to man's
calling, and that Jesus saw all other forms of healing in relation to
repentance and forgiveness of sin (cf. Mark 2:9-10). In other words,
seeing healing in relation to Jesus Christ is an important safeguard
against the tendency to become so engrossed in more visibly sensational
forms of physical and mental healing that the less visibly dramatic
conquering of sin through the Blood and the Cross recedes into the
background. We have all had experience of healing ministries where
Jesus is seen simply as the one who does it, and not at all in terms of the
result produced. This is a distortion which can begin with a separation of
Son and Spirit. Spiritual power can be glorified rather than Jesus
Christ, faith in healing more than faith in Jesus Christ, and one can find
healing ministries where the name of Jesus is rarely used.
Prophecy, tongues and healing have been selected because each
manifest a particular aspect of God's restoring purpose in the
Pentecostal movement. The other charisms listed in 1 Cor. 12:8-10 have
a close affinity with one of the three examined. Words of wisdom and of
- 14-
knowledge, and interpretation of tongues are revelation-gifts, like
prophecy. Working miracles is a power-gift, like healing. Both revelation
and power flow from and point to Jesus Christ.
11 have not treated here two other characteristics of the Pentecostal movement,
namely effective evangelismand awakened expectation of the Second Coming.These are
less new and were more in evidence prior to the Pentecostal outpouring. Both represent
aspects of Christian life not so much restored as heightened in this movement of the Spirit.
ZIt is interesting to note various "down-and-up" couplets in the Scriptures, e.g.
"Faithfulness will spring up from the ground, and righteousness will look down from the
sky" (Ps. 85:11).
30ne of the marvelous records of revelation to a Catholic saint is The Dialogue of
Catherine of Siena. It is interesting that a life of Catherine was written in 1898 by Arthur T.
Pierson, a prominent support of the Keswick "higher life" teaching.
- 15-
and corporate life of the Church. Since the Enlightenment, belief in the
very possibility of divine revelation has been seriously eroded.
With the Holiness movement came an increased awareness of the
power of the Holy Spirit in the life of the believer. It was only among a
minority within the Keswick movement that a clear teaching was
developed as to the revealing work of the Holy Spirit. This can be seen
most clearly in Andrew Murray's classic The Spirit of Christ, first
published in 1888.2 The idea of the Spirit revealing the glory of Jesus is
far from new with the Pentecostal movement.
However, the Pentecostal movement did add something decisively
new to what had been taught and lived for many centuries. The
restoration of prophecy brought the fact of revelation through the Spirit
into the public and corporate life of Christians. This itself reduced its
elitist connotations and caused prophecy and revelation to be seen as
accessible to every Christian.
The individual Christians who already knew divine revelation of the
mystery of Christ were however limited in their response, as long as
there was not accessible to them a form of praise as immediate and
direct as the revelation they had received. This need was met in the gift
of tongues.3
This presentation is anchored on the essential relationship between
Jesus and the Holy Spirit. Jesus Christ is central to the meaning of
baptism in the Spirit and He is central to the meaning of the spiritual
gifts. These convictions make the Pentecostal movement more
important and basic for Christianity today even than many accounts of
Pentecostals themselves. The Pentecostal movement where it is being
wholly faithful to its origins is not adding anything to Jesus and
knowledge of Him. In God's purpose, it is restoring a fuller knowledge of
Jesus, of His purpose and of His power.
IThe main emphasis was on what man has to do to receive holiness from God. The
Holy Spirit was primarily presented as he who empowers man to act.
2See in particular the chapters entitled "The Spirit Glorifying Christ" (Ch. 11) and
"The Revelation of the Spirit" (Ch. 22).
3This position throws an interesting light on the question of tongues as initial evidence
of the baptism in the Spirit.
- 16-