Pee URS ts Uc me Toy Ree ote eee a Se Cn ra ne ena ec oan ten) eters reno Te ec KAPA @AEL * UCKYCCTBO CKPMMUYHOUM UIP + KAPA @AELL UCKYCCTBO Oba RZ se) 70a Ml ol e TeVee oodKAPA @AELU UCKYCCTBO CKPUTNMUYHOU UTP bl XYAOXK ECTBEHHOE MCMOAHEHHE M MEAATOTMKA TEPEBOA C HEMELIKOTO. BAAAMMHPA PAGES. Msdarae Gmopoe, ucnpuérennoe u donornennoe e KAACCUKAXXI wocken 2007YIIK 786 BBKC85.815.8 ‘ent CARL FLESCH DIB KUNST DPS VIOLINSPIE KONSTLERISCHE GESTALTUNG UND UNTERRICHT ‘VERLAG RIES & ERLER GMBH BERLIN 1928 Komaenmapun Ba. Paced xeu K. 71 Mexycerno exprnmmoit uepit, Xyxoxecrpesuoe weronwenne 1: negarorna, — Ma: Manarescrssit 007. — 204 c., xonmanT HCH. ISBN 978-5-89817-141-4 Kana mugeiouteroen expunatta nexarora, ysurennT, [epunra, 2K. Hené s M. Poo- ‘rasa Kapaa @aeia no caoewy auavensio woxer Guers nocrax.teds B oxi pa ¢ casemet pennxuotn «Ilxonasis a «MeToAnkasens suoropexovoro nenoammTemeroro WeKyeeTOs 1S enewnemno#, axpecovaiiok expinanan zureparype XX sexa ovor =pya xe nee ananoron ¢ souks apesiia muporti W aecoxeaTHocTH NOANATW B xem mpotines. Kax os. evs Teaihxolt m nipennimsko euiGpare Penepryep, Kak <9axXBaTATS B HleNy ayzUTOpINO i npeoxanere serpeasoe nosnerie, — 97H fr asorie ADYFKe Bompocks, mHAMOITUNECH peANE: ‘rom noncestenno# saber: nenoauuTeta-npopeccHoNaNs, aBrop paccwarpuacer sa CTpANH ‘uax xastol paborat Ho «Hexyecroo cxpamnnoll nrpiir — ne mpocto epoq +rexntonori cxepnmHore Mae ‘reperna, Dra stra — xyAoMecrBeitoe mrrepaTypHoe NpOHIBCHeUR, CPO AAIBAIE «E. Horo We ORNOCEIEE TPYAOB. Eine Gommys weunocrs aanvoe waaaiene npexcrassser GaaronapA upnaarceMony i xnnre KonnanT-anexy © apcnauin sanncanit K, Dnewa, waers wa KoropArx mnepRNe craner zocronnest poceiiexoll ayzsropust VILE 786 BBK 85.315.3, Oxpanzemen 3axonon P «06 asmopexom npas u ewexnuix npacax>. Bocnpouseedenue ruuzu oem cn9coG0s, 6 KeAOM UAU HaCMUNHO, ‘623 paspeutenua npacoobaadamenet Gydem npecnedosamnca fe cydeOuom nopsane. © Pabeit B. 0., 2007 ISBN 978-5.89817-141-4 © Magarensexnit gow #Raaccua-XX1+, 2007 OT MEPEBOAYHKA Konueprapyromuit wouozanren ssicokoro paxra, weemupuo usnecrni ne- garor", anrop Goxtamtoro exe MeTORIWECKX TPYAOR H MANTHuOCKHX nOCOGHTE, DenancTop xnaccMveckins pousBeneRuil cxpUnUYHOM auTepeTyps (conaTE H Hap ‘suru Baxa, couatit Mouapra, Berxonena, Bpaaica, kanpucus Maranuai), Kapa @aeni, — Gecenopxo, wanGonee snaxurerbEan durypa 8 sapyOexnoR cixpanats- noi nexaroruie neppoit rozosman XX nexa. Bo uioroM coxpanaior coe auese- ue ero MCHOTHUTeALCKMe H MeToANNocKue MpHUNsIMNs, oKaaaBUILE GOBINOR BI abe Ha paaniTie expstnNsHOM NeABTOrMKH BO BOM NEE, BTON HUONE Hm HAN, erpane*™. Kemarexsmalt tpyq «Hexycorno expumno® urpaie — cxonnerrpmposas- Hoe mupaxcouse weronuveckux u xygoncecrsenntx arasgon Daca — step ony6zuxopan 2 1923 (rox 1) x 1928 (row 2) roxax. 3707 "pYK, oxpaTAIRAIOIIH ce nosMonMBe acIIeXTM TEOPHE CKPUMAHOTO UeNOAMMTeACTBA, MepeneRet 1A HecKombKO HaMIKOB, nHOTO pea Nepensnanaen. Pycckmit nepevox sepROTO TOME, KeaMKoM Mocsamesnoro npoOsemam cxpunMsdoll Texumiex, nana 2 1964 ro” ay", Bropoll 10m, xoropom paceaarpitBaioTeR BONPOCS! XYAORECTREHHOTO HC- Hommenia x oGuure pHEIUMs NeAaroruicH, 0 HacroMMero BpeMeNE me Guim 1e- penexen u octasien weusnecTESIN pyccKoMy siTaTemn. TaKiM o6pas0a, ‘ccuonuoit reoperimveckutt tpyx Drema, XAaBHO CrasmAAH AOCTORENEM IINPOKOTO pyra cnlenuannoros no neex expauax nsiconopaamttol: myssiKastsuok Kys7y- A, HameeTeH y une GhacTarVECKHE MEH eM HANONORIERY, HOCKOMBRY COREDRARNE Gonx ToMOB TecHO saauMocsssan0. Hexsam rayGoxo nowKTD MeToRNIECKHE MpManumnt Daema, ne wes npercTasenus o ero ar=.AAx NO sompocaM seTeTH Ku, NewxonoTIN, Nak THK CRDHNUHOTO MCMOARATENEETAA, O O° NOAAFOTHTES- oft cnoteme neon. IloxasaTetsu0, 470 pexaxctop pyeckoro HSAANKA DepBOTO ‘Towa cHockax u KouMeutTapsax nocTORHHO ccRineeTes Ha OPHENRAMDIESIHt BBTOP- cenit rexcr sroporo Toma. Hexycorsennoe o6ocoS.renne aByx vactek enmmoro ne oro, KaKHM sRageTea TpyA Dzema, npaKrHYeCKH CHUMAET NENUOCTS wneIOIe- roca nanan. * B acze ero yaeuuxos — I. Illopunr, 3, Honé, H. Tesnexs, P. Onsonocos, I. Te- unwea, fl. Xaewa, M. Poctass, apopeccop Xapssoscxoli xonceparopus A. A. Tou one %* Hexoropsie wzen Drena nonyunan pASBHTHE 8 TpYAAX MEAN cOVETEKI Mero: ancros K.P. Mocrpaca 1 10. H. Sizmexeaus. ‘4 daew K. Hexyootso cxparicenolt arp. 7. 1 / Tlepevon ocvonsoR waers rexers P., Bammera, Peagen «Ocnomie yupionesne (apancmente) Zam 2 Tepenone UH. B. Cagonone. Berymnrenaa cratea, peanknia nepesona, Komsettrapaat m 20n02- emma It. A. opryaarona. M.: Myaune, 1964. 3Or nepenoaxnna Tipeanarsesatit nepenon atoporo Toma uhtoaMeH a oomoRe GepmusCKOrO H3- anus 1928 roga*. Tlepesonim« nomsonacs xcepoxonuel oKSeMMIApa, npHt- anreamero Banapexofi rocyaapcraennokt GaGnnorene (Moowxen); wa TATy.1€ CO urraxmom 6uSauorexa JleaunrpageKol xoucepnaropun umeeTox coGcrBeHOpys- Mas xaperaennad uagnuce K. neue ta newentkom xansxe: «Kowcepsaropan [e- ‘Tporpara x ee ynaxaenomy Aupextopy Anexcanapy T'naayxony. Baxex-Baxen, 15/IX 28», ‘Baroxox0x wToporo TOMA AocOBKO HepeRORUTER KAK «apTucTHeCKOe BO:LTO- mOKHes, 7. &. ROCCOSRARe MYSLIKANDINAX OOPEIOR, MYAKIKRMHO-DCTETHTTECHIN newuoctel, wo 10 cymiectsy paBkoaHAYHo Houarino xygomcecTueNYOrO HOON Tlepesox mpexyomarpunaer neaHauirensHBte CORPAMCENA OpsrHHARbHOTO ‘rexcra, Tlocuesii sasepaiaior KOMMeNTapHM, DasTsACHALOMHE Te HUI HARRIE 1O- stoxenia paGora u amoniue mx oueHKy ¢ HoSHI eonpemenHOl Teopuit x IpAI- "THREE eKPHMITGHOTO ReNOEITeNCTBA, Bourpas xaxa Mupy Mioxteomno TANANTANRBIX expaMAUeR; B HX wMHOe — BB utouytecs uenonmures, negaroru u MyauKasuute Xentexu: Posed Béx, Hose) Hosxv, Sleonomsa Aysp, Ené XyGam, Kose (Home) Carers, Kapr zen, Cecpanaaun nasamani eno MySHKAmTEEyIO KapLepy Mpoctaaenme AMpHe- put Apryp Honan a Onan Opmanau. Tlepeweaouine aprucrat » cnet 6oms- MIMHCTHe Ke mpmEas ena K KopeRoil HaIyONAmSHOCTH, yAy'H MpencTaBHTe- su repwastossiunol quacnopis (Kame noero eDpelicKoro MpoucxoxAeKHs); 1 TOMY ae Hx TROPUECKAM AeRTEADEOCTS, KAX MPABICIO, PASBEPTABATACS KAXEKO ‘38 mpemenana poms. Onaxco paawierHo Hx pHpOAHCTO apOMaNE 30 MHOTOM enocoGersonau myaickanbilie BnevaTseMMs nereTaa 1 :0HOCTH, Pannen O68- 30m matTarICkHe Opxecrpsi — yuMKastsHag OCOGenHOCTe BeHTpMM, MAMATHAR KA omy, 170 xoTs pas oOusan B oT0H erpane. Tor axe Deut » soo aproGxorpa- Qua"* scnomuuser, xax a gereTme ero YaWIM UrpaTs MapoRENe BemrepcKHE aenoxu, Bo nropom tome «Hexyecraa cxpunwenoll nrpste, B MPHIOMeNT, 38° BepulatIeN OpmrHmansHoe MSAANNe, saxMOTHTEABAIH pagKeN osarnasxeH «Rubato » ysuike nenrepexux wapoqutix cxpunavelie®**. ‘Boe 970, oxHaKO, He nen ocHosanutit arrectosaTs Dxeuia eneHrepeRin KPH awoms, Kax 970 AezaeTCR AO cHx TOP uo sacrapeaoll upumIHKe, BMsBANEOH Benoe pews KOMBIORETyPHLIME coOOpaxeHHSM. ¢CrpaHa POUNEHHA® — EONS- Zosaxxcsbil, Ho Boe ace me PeMAaLOME axeTOp, KOTAA Devs saxORAT O MpHUANTEA- ocrs x Tol wun uno uamuous.xsHol Kyauype. OGyxanuulien 2 xoncepsaTopH- x Bem x Tapioca, npenoxananumi » yteOmisx aasexomiax mecrs orpan****, ‘rem, kax nOMTAEKO (Hanus: Gxux 1037 rox}. Cast SunoascxH 1 nonpocax untTepaperancuit UpsAepmuBAce COBCEM NIX BarAMAOR (CM. €70 CTATLID +O meroxe paGorsi¢ yaenstkaseae, 1955). ‘#8 Bpewn nosazano yaannscocn. xpumieexoll noon Dzems: P. Oaxonocos, suicrynaanii e xonnepraam » CCCP (1965), npoxesoucrpnposan nesnoaenyno Tex: fnmny ... konoe oreyrevae «sentiment intimee, T. ©. sMeHHO ve Ka¥ectaa, KOTOpHE ‘ryote waxonses y conereRsx expHNAER. ‘S44 O. 18 yrasauuoro pyecxoro mazanma, 6 Or nepenonunna Astunilexas cxpunauxa Hiqa Tenner, scnomuuas ypoxs @aema, pacctassinacr: {Ha max nocroauuo npueyremonaia HeGoaLitian aygHTOPHK, cOcTosBINAs 9 21 MenHTHIX MyoEKAHTOD, YYeHEMKOR I-mpoCTO rote; 110 mateuuI Dacura, 970 o6neT- ‘sano TepexoR OT YueOHOrO Kenecea Ke KoRRepTHOH ¢ zrpaxe*. On acerza tpesiocr Inna YueWUy noaMONOoTS NPONTpATD aRNANTEAR MaTepRAN OT RANA Ho KONA, fe mpepuinaz ero. Tlo oxolwastiat Hrpit YuLTENL MeRENO ROTARALT CO CYA i “BE ‘aa Onyx daMevamns, aapakeHposaHENe uM wa nomex HOTHANX crpamsn. Crepsa (Ommevasiice HOLOMIETENDHKC MOMCRTH, & 3ATEM YWENTITK NORBepTases GesxasI0CT- nowy pasnocy 98 xonymyeusise omuGi. YueHAKH CBexMBAAKCH OT CTPAXR, HO HE ombiriinand wynerne o6nass. Jsrio xoxo Drew erpaxa He nuytaM, OTHOCHNACE RHEMY ¢ yBaaKeHHEN w sN0UOHSI0, roROBONOFHGKY, KAK OB CAN HX HASKINALT, MPIC [BHMAINes MEOH TaIEKe OxOTHO, Kak HOxBaIe*, ‘Xapaxrepuctuxa O.xeuta xax teoperuxa — 8 AaHKOw KorTeKcTe HanGoutee cy- meoTmeHHaR — Ke cxyuaiino oTReceKA ke KOM MpeyMe7OBIA. “Hausen ¢ ror, ut0 pedi coppemeRnix emy cxputaaelt aout — onwu us ca: enix o6paaonanisx m epyaMponainihix — losag NporHwONOTO-RHOCTs ericxiit- nbn, repnooAasiinan TaxanTex Tana Bazacaua u Cepacare, ne oraroujenmscx Gpe- Menest oGpasonaauix m anicoxore HuTenIeRTe, Dmemy, Geccopuo, spueyye ‘eopemueckoe MAIMIeHNe, UpeuNyMeCTBEHHO anazHTATVeCKOTO cx.taAR. Tt smith tpyq ero senonn — «Moxycormo expumirino urpate — 10 cpoemy sraverito ose GhTE ocTaREH B ORE psLl co «IlIKozOy Jeonomyga Mouapra a «Mezo- oli» Pore-Kpefinepa-Baiio. B enonuamuol, axpecosanrod cxpunavas aztTepa. ‘ype XX nexa s107 Tpya Re MMEeT ARATOTOB € TOK Bpeua INMDOTA H BCEOXBAT HocTat RoeTaReNUAIX B HEM HPO6EM, ‘Bo Bropow rome TaaBwor BuMauNe YZexeHO DompocAM NyaNIKANSHOR 2¢- ‘rere H NeHXONOTHDA MOTOAHHTEACKOTO, NACTHNMO LeAATOrUyECKOrO TSOPYECT na**, Ho EX paceMorpenmo nocToRHHO conyreTayioT UpeKTHYeCKHe DeKO- Mennann, aarparsaaioinue Gyknatewo nee (Gea Hpeynennuexaa!) cTopoRst MpodbecoHouanbiol AeRTexbHOCTH CRDITIEWA, BIMIOTS LO TAKUX ACTA, KAK LY- opis na Gangax KoumepTuoro dypaica — sieTHNHO HeMeTIKAA CKPYnYesuOCTE meronmanocrs! Tloaaxeze gayxrommmea «Hoxyoorso cKpymHuol urpsir mpuperersonax nazpuapx semexol cxpamrano# moms 0. [lewsax. B ancswe K asTopy ou or evan: «Bu BIOORHAH B PYRH cKDATANEH Oubun0... Beck UPUNTO B PRcver Bee, ‘ero candawo co expnioll i ¢ uEpoli ua nel, wrwTo ne yrymjeHo. Ha kaxesutt no poe Bur namin yGenseressscait orner...e #1 Tlowra oxnonpeweso co BrOpkIt TONOM Guam anepue onyOxNKoDARSt 2 CIITA mupoxo wanecrane paGori: JI. Ayopa «Mog mkoxa nrpst a cxprEnKee 4 eHrepaperansen nporvenennit cxpimmauuoll xaxecukte, HiscKOnSKO me ys ‘nas ux nenocTa Kax merom4eckiEx HOCOSutl, Hazo BCE 2e NPHSHATH, 470 HEM: Gexcno noanmnaiomtee eparnenne rpyaon Ayapa a Pxeua suo oCopavusaeres He B rlonbay epabix, HpexeRe Neere HO YPORRIO TeopeTitiecKoH muream, ocoGerHO Auanoram e xaaccoxe Ayopa » Casner-TerepSyprekoR xomcepesropait. + ler, no xe.: M.Compbell. The great violinists. London: Granada publishers, 1980. P. 108 ‘St Gonenr aponsaaa Goxsmoh warepee x npobremane nexxanaruit, o6uIa.eH 60 ene: ranaaenaotn » anit aac (na Gecemus nepenoarata cP. OxHonocowit, KPNERKAS- nine Mockay n kavecrbe ‘vieua oops womrypca miren “aihonex070). ‘wets Hur. no ex.s M. Campbell. The great violinists, P. 106. ‘sek Ayap Jl. Mom mxona urpis na expuenxe; Virrepuperaitia mponaneenttt cKDH- renofi enaceme / OSmax pexaxan, npoxuexooue n xouwertrapyy TH. M. SiaozzcKo- 0. Mu: Myaua, 1965. C. 100.Or mepenoatmna 1» vompocax sorerink nenoanuremscrea. Paceysenensit Aygpe Tuna «Babyasre ‘Tpaganmo... He zymaiire o cranes **** gpyuar cellvac 10 MeuBINe! Mepe HAU- x20. Ho cers ut Gonee enyGoxwe paanuena — 06a anTOpa OURRIOTER HA xYRONECT- ‘enuati onBIr pasmMx NoxoneNHA mysuixanTop. Ayop RexoauT us ombira XIX ne- xa, reapunne O6pas0m ero HocMeRMNX BeXRKRX MpexcrannTeeli — Bewsuckoro, oaxiwa % Capecate. Cuctewa merommieckux H xyxoxceTBeRRSIX RST7AAOS zea — orpeoxenne nonoro ora b pasnuram expunwunoro MexyccTsa, oTaIIA, enxsamnoro ¢ uenamn Vaan, Kpelienepa, Tx6o, Xeiipena, Curers,, Ty6epana 1 xpyrux msaammpixes expmnavell XX pera. Hors am nagoOnoots & KOMMeHTapHsX KO mropoMy Tomy +HcxyceTme cxpH- ‘nuauo urpure (npu cro aNCoKoli ero omeHKel), a TeM Goslee B COKDAIERIAK opuramansnoro Texcra? Besyesoano, ecrs. B cyxinennax zeta npoasnserca mpotecexonantiam, OOTaTAR RNTYRNMK, OCTDRR m UPORMAATe/ILIEIT Yat, BMECTE (© TeM oul He no ncom nocnexoneTexLuHL, a nopol x mporiBopewmBKK — O6 sToM, B MACTHOCTH, MO%HO CYRETS 0 NpMBeREMEAIN BALE SAMENAHHAM 0 KOBKYDCE um. Hsam. Toumsie, merine neGaoxenma apropa me neerga sapepmiawrea yOoaH- ‘TexDURINEH aLiBOAANCH; MOCMEAMMe HHOFRA Wepectyp MpAMOAMNEHAEL HK MEXAIIC- ‘TWH, HOTA HOMpOCTY HegocTaToNHO OGocHORAREN. 70 RACRETE CORPAIE- ‘Buti, 10 onM HeoOxosHaUM BONAY CKAOHHOCTH aBTOpA I MUOTOCTOMINO, & HOAAC 4x Amuresuok buxcaryen nunaanns wa necyniectoeHHoM. Hi uaxonet, (aKTop ‘ppenten: nepnex nyGmmHKAnH BTOpOTO TOMA ONECHA OT EAC HPOMENYTROM CR ‘me 70 ner. Dro neraa o10xa, 3 TeveNue Ko7OpoH Ne MOr-IM ue YeTApeTs O7HeAsIEM noxoscewa paGora ‘zemna, panuo xax 4 ee Ocuonuas uayasan Gaza. MyssKo- ‘bexTeCKIE TPYAKI, Ha KOTOPISE OM cosiNAETER, B CBOeH SHATATETEHO ZACTH MER ctanamor ceroans cxopee HeTopHueckyi, YeM Hay4HO-TIpaKTHWeCKY HexNOCTS. ‘Beam xommertapast Ko BrOpoMY TOMY HOKAMYTER KOMY-T0 “epectyP NPRANPR- [BBINGH, TO 970 TOBODET 0 BAAKHOCTH NOABATHX BOMpOCOS H B HeOM — 0 HAUMOC- ‘7H caMoro "pyaa; 20 ncaicow enyzae, KouMoHTaTOP crpeMILteR K MaKeHMATEEOH nay:moit oGxexrasnocra. Kepx Dzein — Ges commenua, pexmxnil TeoperHk CEDH- naHoro ueKyeeTBa; TAXHe IORH He HyacAAIOTEA B CHMCXORHTENAHOM OTHOMIONI. 1 coGe, om oeraionca momuiuH Nam n enoxX OMIEEKAX. Ba, Paset MIPEXHCJIOBHE Korna » yexa6pe 1923 rona sume neppiiit rom «Hexycersa cxpemnd- noi Mrpulr, te NpeaTionaran, To BLIXO) BTOpOTO TOMA BaTAHETeR TOUTH ua nave ner. Hpwunmer o7of saqepku Paamwhs: B TepBy0 ovepeae 270 copmenienue MHOM AByx BuyOB NeATeNBHOCTH — KONKepTAO-KeMOIHNTERL. cKO m neqarormueckoil, HenexCrHHe wero st Mor NOCBAIHATS jlAHHOMY TDY- AY JH CTOMBKO BpeMeNH, CKOMKO OCTARNANH Mie MOH OCHOBHBE 3A ‘Ta. Tak, maNpHMep, OTAeADHNe (bparMenTA 9TOTO TOMA cosnARAIICh MACTBIO BO BPeMA MOeSZOK MO ANEPHKAHCKEM pePHAM, ZACTHIO B Mana. uu no AtaanmieckoMy oxeany; 3 Epporie neck watepwax npocmarpipat- A, MpuBosuren n nopasoK H upHOOperaT aanepmeNHyio opMy. Banepa ka OGwacHaeTca TaKKe NOBMSHOM caMoro MaTepuara, TpeGonanInero AamrenbHOTO BpeMeHH juts OcHORATeNRHO! ero PaZpaGOTKE. Kax npu nozrorosxe nepsoro Toma, Tax Ha 9TOT pas AelicTBeRAY!O N0- Mots oxezat we Maxe Tleccyap. Conerst ororo amewareabHoro HeToneKA ‘MR ocoBentocTH ero MopaNBHAN HosMepzKa RaAIM MMe CHT mpoliTH Kemer satiny», npumeunth x sanepureniio Moero tpyza. K remy 3 nepByio o1€- ent o6pantena Moa raryGoxan, ueKpeHtasa GnarotapHocrs. Al Gaaronapro Taxx«e: zoxropa BepHepa Boatdpxaiiia 3a ero ieHte 3a- MeaHna, oTHOCAMUecH K NHCTO TeopeTITIeCKHM AcrIeK TAM PaGOTHI; POCO. anna Xyro Bemmura, wonsmero Ha ce6a TpyAHY!O aatexy HORTOTOBKGH WI aocrparumuoro MatepHama; Moero MagaTeis joKTopa Pobepra Puca, HoNoranmero MHe B WreHuE KoppeKTYP H, HaKoueH, wor 704» Xawtin Pret, n KaxecTBe MoeTO ceKpeTapH MOATOTOBMBIIY!O Beck PyKonitcHt ‘exer pa6orut.BBEXEHHE TIpeanaraemuili pya HH B KaKoit mepe He mperenayeT 1a TO, sToOn! npencrasur unraremo oOutyio TeopHIO MeTOAMATeNLCKOrO, a Tem Goxee KowmosuTopeKoro Taopuecraa!. Bayjmomyneca Tpyys! 110 norzpocam obtmelt HM MySEIRamIbHO OCTETHKE, KOTOPMINE Mii PacKOwlaraeM, ZenaioT HaNMUTeH BeAKYo HOBY!O HONEITKY EpoHMkHOBEHHT B oT OOsiacTs*. B HACTOAUIEM 7O- Me YAY? PACCMOTPeH AHI Te XyOxKecTEeHHBIe NPUNNAER, KOTOPHC ‘recto caasanu ¢ HpAKTHECKO AeRTeNIBMOCTHIO MYSbIKALTA-CKPHAN, ‘H oramio ce6e oT¥eT B TOM, ¥TO MoGuIe UsBICKAHHA O SarpoEyTOH MHOli Teme MOTyT BeTpeTHTE HenpHAIHeHHOe OTHOUIeHHE Co CTOPOHB KOH- ileprapyiomero cKpHriaya RMICOKOrO Paxra, ocoGeHHoCTH, eom1H eFO ABPO- ammo npacyuy cruxminuil, mepposaammui xapaktep. Taxoit ckpsmiat (OGsINHO He cKOHeH MHOO PASMBIIIAATS Ha MpodeccuoHANLILIe TEMB, TAK Kak emy # Geo Toro yaaeTeA YerelNIHO OcyMecTBAATS CnOM XyAO*KeCTBCH- Hue Hamepeaus, B TOM OTHOWeHHM On HanOMMHACT Hex e7oBa Tere 19 muesaa Tlesrepy: +51 caaury wH0ro pasronopos o MyshiKe, 970 — AypHOe ppemsnperponoknenner. CoequneHMe MYSEIKi € OTBCHEHMBINM HORATE ‘AMM — BOT TO BHYUIGeT MYSMIRANITY-NpaKTAKY HeoZONNMLIl eTpAX Neper ‘reopuelt. Bwecte ¢ rem ects Hemaxo cxpHnavell, Koropsre He yxonxeTnopaires uatepnperantteli, wenvixom ommparomelica ua cepy woRcosMarerbsoro, i OMlyilaIoT HOTpeOHOCTH B slcHOM HOMMMANIEM saKOHOMepHOCTe! CBOETO Hexyecrna, Zlammtuil tpyX aapecyerce mpexye Bcero AByM KaTeropHsM expunaeil-npodeccuonatos: mpeoGnaqaromelt macce Tex, se CTAHORNE- Hite MponexomuT 8 nocTomOl Gops6e, HII HOcTeneHHo npHOmIAI0- ile 1x K menaemoMy conepuIencTay, H TeM, KOMY BRepeHo BocTHTAHHe Tonpactaionyero HoKoxenHa cKpUNAWel, To ecTs negaroram. TIpenBHAy, ‘uTO H 9TH ARE KATeTOPHH MpUMYTCA 3a HoYueHNE HACTOAMeTO TOMA ¢ HSBC ermen neronepvtem, Eoutt 8 mepnoM Tome paspaGarsina.tach ob ACT, yoke HeoAHOKpaTHo Guininiasl NpeAMeTOM HaYYeHHA, A H pelt ITA B OCHOBHOM © Belilax KONKpeTHLIX M 9pHMEIX, To aAec GoslsMelt YACTHIO HecsERYIOTCH ‘meHMa Hamero BHYTpeHHeTO MixpA, C TPYAOM MloTeIOUIHECH CIOECHOMY serpaxxenuto, Coananad onacHocTs Gur B WeM-1HG0 MenOHATEM, ABTOp Hameper B CBOHX HAKICKAKMAX TPEPAO CTOATS Ha NOwBe PeabHOCTH 1 9a- HUMATBCH B TepBy!o TOAORY TAKMMM MpoOaeMaMHL, KoTOPEIe MpesICrABIA- for wos miTepec Aue CKPHTIAYR-MpopeccHOHANA M ARAMOTCA, B ONpERE- newHoii crerien, mpegMeTom ero MoBcestHeBHOMt 3a607HI. ‘Mur pasznituaes 1p THNa OTHOUICHHE YeONeKa K NYaBIKe: mpodyrmus- hoe, suipaxaontecca 8 cOsRaNHM NYSKIKAMLHLIX MponsBeneHMit, peyen- uence, mixpaxaioulcecs B HX ROCTPKATH, H penpodyrmuenoe (wocmpo- ngnonsiiyee), KoTopoe aakmOuAeTcA B OHCceHEH MYBIKH Ao COOMARME caymarenei. «Bocnpovanogmunite MyakikanT — He Mpocto mocperHi 10 Mexuy KOMTOSHTOPOM H EHYMATENEM; OH Kak Gut coemHHET B ceGe TOFO i ApYroro, Korga CHO cHoeTO HeKYCCTBA Mpeupamaer MepTBHe HOTHNE SHAKH B AKHBYIO MYSLIKY, BOCCORAARAR MPH 9TOM aBTOpexufi TeKcT TAKHM, ‘KAKI OH caMt eFO COIBIIINT, Tipennaraemas paota crapur cpoeit 1exsi0 HoyueHMe SAKOHOB, KOTO- PEM HORHEH HMEHHO AHEEI BMA MYaKIKATSIO! RemTeNbHOCTIE — HC- kycoTao pocmpousnenenua. ‘Yrobar AowectH Ao cmyiNATens KPAcoTY H cMLICN NpoMaBEAeHI, CKPH- naw omen mpenke Beero 0619187» onpenerennEINH My3KIKAM-HO-HCTON- RuTemcxuMn Kaecteawn. On JomKeH TAKIKe B COBepINIeHCTBC BARTS TexHHKOE Mrpet Ha CBOeM HMICTPYMeHTe HK, KPOMe TOTO, MPeACTABAATE CO- Gok murepectiyio AUWHOCTE, CHOCOBHYHO «JaXBaTHTD B ILLeH* ayAHTOpHIO. Bo nceopy2kumt 9THX KAYECTR OM CTOHT Nepex sanaveH — TOCTABNTE cBoe eKyccTRO Ha cay2x6y KOMMOIMTOPY, OsHAKOMME cayiaTeeli c ero TROPE- eM. A Kora mpowaneneHie BsHOCHTCA HA KOHIePTHY!O DCTPAAY, APTHC- ‘ra-ckpmiaua MoxcTeperalor peckMa WeNpHATHEIe «mOGouHLe sABIeHHSte B Bue PABTHUHLIX NOMeX SMIHECKOTO MAH TICHXMECKOTO cHOHCTBA, KO- ‘ropbie ey HpexoToHT ocoaHaTs H npeoxomeTs. TToMHMO 9TOrO OH AONKEH, B Tenax cHoeTO MpodbeccHoHATSHOTO POCTa, HOCTOAHHO HByYATD KOHMEDT- yw JINTepATYDY NpHOOpetarl HANA, HeOOXoAMMALe AIH TOTO, NTOGK nepeqazats caoit onkIT NuAqINUEM cobparEsiM M10 HeKYcoTBy*. B cootsereranu ¢ o1ua HAI TpyA CKAAgLIBAeTCA Hs CeAYIOMNX OCHOR- subix pasgexon: 1. O6mue anemenrst myauikaxsHoro HenomHeHHA. Tl, Texnwecxue onemeaTa Kenoauenns. TIT, Yenoneseckas m apriicrHueckam auuHOCTS. IV. Tlowexa » nyGauuHom nenommenmt. YV. Cxpununaa azteperypa KonMeprite mporpauMt, Vi. Iipenonapanne. TIpexne wea MpHcrymurh K paccMoTpeHMO 9THX OCHOBHSIX nYRKTOR, HeoGKOTHMO YAOCTOREPHTECR, RIPABE AH MBI CYAHTE O MeMMOCTH TOM am oil uTepriperalwa TmaRHMM O6pAsoM N10 TOMY, KAK OHA BOCHPHHHA- cerca ny6amxoit, Mix zomxami raxoKe MOnTaTEca B O6ULIX wepTax O60c- Mopars cymHocTh MyaMKambHO-DCTeTHMeCKOTO cY2KReHNA, 7. €. KPHTH- xx. Cxenyer mu oleHHpaTs apricTHueckyi uHTepnpeTanmo KaK HeGABHCHMY;0 «nenyE B ceGer HIM COobpasyach ¢ OTHOMCHHEM x Hei cay arena? Slanseren 2 upucyTcraMe cnymrarena HeOOXOAHMEIM YoTOBH- en xyLomecrBeHHoro cRepILeHHA, KHIM 18 aTOrO JocTATOEHO HeTIOHNTe- Am wcaymatena, oSreruHeHHoro B oAHOM nue? Hl HaKoHe: mMeeTost 1H paummagoaoe paszane mencay myn x enerrySnmenate He- TIpeacze ncero yeraoRHM, 470 MYSKKANSHOe MpousneqeHHe, COomaR- Hoe KOMMOsHTOpOM B CHLLY CTOHTAHHOTO BHYTPeHHeTO TOOYARNEHIA, BCe aa mperHssnaeno ana nySaMaHoro HenomHenuA. KoumosiTop crpeMuT- em o6NApORORATS CBOE TROPEHMe, CHEAT eTO ROCTOAHHEM BOSMODKHO * Cuenwamemt pare paGorit roeasutex sonpocex neaaroruk, paccmarpusae Moh 1 ce recnolt canax o apracriueckOR ZemremHocTi (n Tol wepe, 2 xaKoM ZOCTIOKENA Stiqatoumrxca apracros moryr crars necoBminne Aocroste:t). Mem 0 nsaHMoneiCTsuit prax OyX enepaLienticx amas — nenoxaTenscrse H neqarorux — MpomsunaeT coGott new paGory. atBuenene Sonburero wea mysiKanton 4 mOGurexeh wysuKH. Tonpobyem ceGe Mpencrapurh, wro MysbiKa.tbHoe MpOMIREEHHe BLINOANNIO Ges CBOE MPEN- HagHavenne, CyRY4M MCHOAMeHO KAMKAKM B OTAEMBHOCTH H TOEIO ATA CO 6a, 70 corn TaK, Kax sraeTca Kura. OnTAMHCTS YTBEpKRAOT, 470 CO ppeNesem wyatrkarisHoe O6pasopaHHe HOAMUMETCA Ha TAKYIO BAICOTY, KO- ‘TOpaa nosnomHr panonomy caymiatemo ray6oKo NocTHI: H MpoUyBCrno- Bath moGoe couMHeRHe MyTeM OHOTO AMIN BHBaTEHOTO MPOYTEHHA TEK- cra (qo eHx nop taKo% croco6 Gu qocTyneH TomLKO Ha6panmut). Ho ceftuac 06 oom ne Mosxer Osi H pew, culenoRaTeNEHO, Ipoeccro- HAAbHBIH MySKIKANT-NCTOMHUTeMT He HMeeT HpaBA +DOCTPORBOAMTS® pa aM coBcrnemoro yAopomberpna; ero nepselimias obsaanHocT» — jonecT#t mponasegenue uckyccrsa 40 miMpoKoi aygmropiin. B omonienun oroi suceuH neaKET eMbiex ero cymectBosanus. Eos 2e On MpexNOUMTAeT MY- BHNMPORATS +414 CGAP, TO TeM CAMBIN HORTREp2LaeT CHOI MpHHAsLTER HocTs K TOMY paspaay Mystixant7oB, KoTOpEni ¢)paunyas NeNKATHO HME. Hywor eamateurss (m0GurenH), a HeMI,ét OSoaHauaiOT YHITRLKMTeTHEEIN HTambaHexHM cAoEOM «quAeTanT+. PaaniiNe MexRY APTHCTOM H AILTE- TAHTOM aaKOAETeR He B YoBHe MACTepeTRA, KOTOpIAi ¥ AUMCTAHTOR 3a ‘acry1o pattme, Ye ¥ npopeccHonasios; cyTb BOM, slnseTEA mH MCKYCeT- Bo JU AAHHOTO TUNA PAABHLIM HTH NOGONMLIM gallaTHeN H Tye IpoTeKaeT ero Myiikanbuad JemTeABHOCTS — Ha KoHUepTHOM acrpaze HAM B NOMALI- weit ofcraonke. Hamexy «paGoroqaremos — Komnoszropy — shi oxa- 2keM Peambity!O YouyTY AMUIb Tora, KOTAA BHICTYNMM R POH Mponaranze- Tom cro MyaHIKH, CTpeMacs K ToMy, UT06HI OHA Gaia BOCTDMHATA BosMorksto Goxee LIMpOKUM KpyroM cYMATeNeH, T. e. B YCMOBUAX KOH- ueprsoro saa, Verano, wro suctyneHue nepen aymmropuelt apAseTes comanbHoit OSnsaNHOCTsIO MySEIKAHTA-MCHOMHHTOAS, Mx ROMA BaaATS ceGE BOTPOC: corp mH cymecteHHoe pasiuune u TpeOORAHHAX TexuMYecKOrO NOAA, HpeMBADAFeMEIX x HeTOAHeIHO B KOHKEPTHOM saute HB KAGHHeTE? OTBeT ‘ua oT0r Bompoc Moker OxITb TOALKO yrRepAMTeMeHBAM. Hsyzas Wits MENON sist KaKoe-1N60 mponsneseHMe B ROManTHelt OGoTaHOBKe, MEI OOKIYHO pO Hukaewcs puaTabntd, paxocTasin omymennamn, Hac oxparisnaer 61a ToctHoe uyBctno yROBeTBOPeHHA — Re HATpARA sa HAM TPYA sAKTOTeHA BHeM caNoM, a ero OHeHKa, He OGyeRORAGHNAA TpeGOBARRAMN SICIETO ap- ‘THoTHYecKoro copepileKcTsa, BeeHeTO mpexocrammena Haul UyperBo Of BeTCTHeHHOCTH HaNHYecTBYeT 3jecb UII, B ReckMa orparutenno crene- EX — TOCTONBKY, MOCKOMMKY HAM eule NpexCToHT OBRAKETS TAMTUM Mpowabenenuext » TexauveckoM M xyfomeorBeHHOM emteate, Hac we cree Naot oxpyaaioujan o6cTaHOBKA; OLLYIIAH HpMATHOe ORMHOLECTEO, Mut a 2ke TO9BOTAEM ceGe OcpoBoANTLCK OT CTECHsOMHX Hae Npe{METOR OMENTE, 4 HMT¥TO He MetaeT HaMt MOBTOpUTS HeyAABIMlics HACCA HECKOTEKO Dad, loka ero uenoaHeume Hac He yiloaxeTnopiT. Tloxoxenne meuserca np HaauunM Xora 61 ORWOrO-enMECTBEHHOTO caymatess. Cpaay ake nosnuKaer acenmiomee GecnoKoiicTso ¥yBcTs0 OT- Betersennoctu. Beam x0 9roro, 6yayau HaemitHe ¢ coOoll, MEE He TAK yok 3a- Sornance o TOM, Bisitzer mH Tor Hat HHOH nacca2k c epsoro pasa WIM Her, To Terlepb TpeGosanne nosMosxHo GombIero conepuIeHersa 3 MenO/MeHI crano nempemensoit neo6xomstocTsi0. B o6craHlonKe KoMUepTHOrO 28.18, px Berpeve c Maccoit ueanakostisx HaM soged: (KoTOpan i TOMY xe Mmpen cTapiaerca HAM BpaxkneSHo HacrpoeHHioll), acto B HeGtaronpMATHEIX 12 Baenenne DHeMINHX yenoRusK TaxKeCTs OTBeTCTREHHOCTH RospactaeT B orpoMttoit crenenm, nonaBnan co6oit ucuoaumrens. Onur yaNT Hac, ¥T0 pasmMHe MOXAY ABYMA PoRAMM MysHIYEpODAHHs (4A COGA> H +AIH nydaMKA>) HACTOMKO BEAHKO, WTO 06 YPOBHE HeHOAHEHUA MOxKHO OKORYATEIIEHO CY ANT TOMBKO IPH TOM YeROBHH, eCAH OHO COCTOATOCE B KOMILEPTHOM 3ALNe. Keseausil aprncr, naaxe cami miqaouutiica, noanan ory Heriity noporoH uenolt Heya m pasovaponannii. IIpucytersue caymarenel — oto cna, cnocoSuad, xax n nerenqe 06 uckymeHu cRatoro ANTOHMA, HAKONAOMATE BO BCOX YFOMKAX NAULeTO COSHAHHA MANEHBKHX YPORTHBAX wepTAKOD, exHAHO cKarsuMx syGul M He YnYCKAIONUX oayIaM BRYIIMTS apTMCTY ca. Mite 4YAOBMIAELIE UPeACTaBAeHHA, CRORM HA Her PesyaALTATH ero TPYLOB yerpemaienmi. Orciona Tare exenyer, wro nenaror, sanMMaLoUNMieR KoNNepTHOtt JeA- ‘TexsHOCTHIO, Meer GonbinMe npeHMyniecTva Nleper cBOHM KoETOM, My3M- uspyiounm ¥ ceGm noma B cpoGoaHoe or negaroruni Epema. Kar 6oxeT yunrtenb mpexocrepes enoero yuettitica oF onlacitoctell, KoTOpBe aNeeT HEL exy He o coScrBeHHoMy onuiTy, a mo uyseum paccxanauel Ero MomHO ymO- OobHT» XEpypry, sHeuOUIeMy Oprastul eNOReYeCKOTO TExTA TOMHKO HO 1906. DazeHHAM, BMEeCTO Toro, TOG! HSYHHTE HX HA KKBOM WIM MePTBOM Op) nuame. ‘Beat mut xorum werko onpeneruts, a sates i noGoport BoesosMonGHHe ‘Sarpyaiensia H NONexH, MpenstreTayiome OcymtecrDsICHH}O HAI Xy/1O>Ke- crpehinx namepenuii, To yaxe no ofKoH oToHk pare Mi AO-UHI HOO PATS emecrom xelicrsiAa» KonleprHyio acrpary, Tax Kax GOMBIIKHCTHO TOMEX yonOBuax onmHONHOTO MysHRUPORAKIER HoNpocTy we BogHMKAeT. CyMt! Ya Bee exasano9, sf NoxpasyMeBalo 10K XYAO2KeCTREHNKIM HeTOMHeHHEM, Kotopoe cocranmsier mpeqMer MOHX HOCAeAYIONNX HaLLCKANHi, TOEKO IyG- airuHoe BBIeTymLTeHKe B KORRepTe. ‘Teneps saqenHM Bonpoc: KAKUM YoIORHAM AOMMHA OTBEYATb CoBep- ienHad mtvepuperanim MysMKaaBHOrO HpoaReeHMA? (TlosHTHBHAs NO. cranonxa nonpoca.) Him 2xe: KakHe O6CTORTENLOTBA MOTYT MIOMEILIATS Mie cuirpars nansioe npomspeneHne Hany auIHx o6pasoM? (HeraTMBHas HocTa- Honka.) Tloswrapiias nocraHopka zonpoca npewcramastercs MHe zitmennott ‘caieza; smH60 A paccmarpinaio ceOs, cRom HIAUBURYAmLIEIe crlocobHOCTH, BKYCM H CKIORHOCTH B KAYeCTHE HOPNATHRA, MOTYULETO CYTE MEDMION. Xyaomecraetuoro cnonueHus, uGo mpiEMEMAto 8a O6pacel KaKyIO-LN- Syab mumxatomyioca, Ana Meus OcobeHHO MpHMeKATeRLAyl aprHeTHe. Yio awtnocrb. To # Apyroe Hacer MIN. MpexonAtyw TeAHOCTD. Ons Bokasuimaet, 970 pase MoTpeOnOCTS B caNoBMIpaxenHH OHBACT ryGOKO Peaamana y karenOTO HOBOTO MOKONEHA BPTHCTOB, He TOBOPA ake 0 Cped- Cmeax supaxensa, Botou oTuomennu yGennTenbitnIM HPHMepOM CY HT Nponcmenmee aa nocneyune 30-40 net namenenue aunautyas KoneGa- Bui p ckpumraxom suOpato. Bes comuexua, BuGparo coupeMennnax KOI. Heprupyiomux ckpnaveit nomcromeris naaay GuLI0 Gr PacKeHeHo RAK EPeynenirtennoe H GeaBxyctoe; B TO 2Ke BpeMs RUGpAT TorTAMMAx Gorn HINX auprycgon noxasavtock Ost celiac XONOARAM 4 HEBMIpASHTENbHDIM. 'a uepputit narnan oro yrneprxqenue KaDKETCR BAATLIM € NOTOAKA H HEAO- Kasyemim, B xelicranremtocr 2Ke cpeni Hac eme Hemano cxpamavelt, ABAROUNXCH 2CMBLIMH CHHeTeNAMM UPOMCIIEMMAX MepeMen, a HeKOTO. Pe ig HX MOFYT CAY>KHTE HArsAAHEIM OOpaamoM crapolk Ha1H MORO He RonmurenscKo# Mauepst. 13Monaro npeanoaoxuits, 470 AHYHEI NosKenAMHA H MpeRTHCAHNE KOM nosTopa nomorazor HeTONHHTeM0 IPARMIBHO HotTepApeTEPOBATE MPOHS- pexenue. He rozopa yoke 0 TOM, “TO TAKOTO Poa YKAAHHA MoxeT ATH ‘Toubko coppeMeHHEti aBTOp, — COMHHTEBHO, BCeTAA 1H KOMMOSHTOP OCO- suaet nanaysisti cnoco6 Hcnomuexxa cpoux Taopennit. Ilo omsiTy Mit BiaeM, 70 emo SauacTyI0 O6CTOHT KAK pas HaoGopor. Herarusxas nocTa- HoBxa nonpoca ropaaxo Gonee mogoTBopHa Xora Okt Yrke HOTOMY, WTO On Hanpassider Hale BHHMAHWe Ha MHOPOWACTeHHIe TOMEXH, CTOANIMC Ha hyrn ocyillecrsienua xygowecTenHHix Hamepenuil. HenpeweninM yoxo- PHeM BoAKOTO OBYUCHH H BOCTIMTANUM HBETCR YCTPRHEHHe OTPHIATED~ hie Kaviecrs, TOBKO HenpanteHe OUIMGOK H HeXOCTATKOB COgIReT OCHO- by aaa copepmencrsa, Jlocrmxenue xpenkol, ycroiiumnoh Texan HepoaMoxHo Ges MpeoToreHUA RCHUECKHX HOMeX u RecbexTon B HeMOMTe- hum. IIpapeqe mpuMep: npHauna Hadmonaenoli y Gombummuctaa CkpHTa- edi HeynoBrersopmrensiolt HHTOHAIMM SAKMOUAeTCH B Tox, ITO SHAT. embuad MaCTs MeqaroroB YAOBNeTROpseTcs OANOM TMM KoncraTaTHelt (paNDUIMBEIX HOT, BMeCTO TOTO WTOGM YHUNTOSKUTS +KOpeH> aa» — HORO- Crarounyio CIYXOBy10 BOCHDHHMTHEOCTE HATH oTeyTeTBHe (B ZoKHO! Me pe) ROppexrupyommx asirxenuit uamsuen'. To xe cneayeT cKAaaT io Wenmefimux Kayectnax, 6¢3 KOTODEIX HICTIONMeHHe He MOXET MOAHATI- (en 0 BBICOTH THOPTECKOTO ARTA, — TAKHX KAX HYBCTBO CTIUNA, PHTMA, CO- coGHOCTE K aMOKHOHAREHOMY BuspaxeHMO. B wapecTHo! cremenit OM MO- Tyr Gur MaHadamuminut epoficrRaMs TaaNTa, Ho K CBOeMy TOMHOMY [PASBHTHO NPHXOAST su TOrAa, KOFAA sAbOTAMH BOCTTATEN ONIROT- ta or neaveckOro pona nUIAKOB. HMCHHO TOTOMY MBI BHIHM CBO} T1AB- HyWO sagauy He w TOM, WTOOH HACTARAATS MySLIKAHTA B AOHPONeTENAX, KO- TOpuIMa OM OAH OFAAAATk, A B TOM, aTOGsI ykasATL eMy NYT lpeonozenun scenoaMoakusIx 1OMeX x HenOCTaTKOD. ‘OGparusuivich K HegOCTATKAM, Mui TeM caMLIM SATpORYNH mpoOAeMy kputaxn, Kpxttkonark — aHaviT cymits 0 Yen-1u60. BuickaaaRnoe KDs- ‘musieckoe cyaciexte MoxkeT GIT MOLINA CTUMY.ION AATEUeHMNeTO PAID ‘Tua apruermseckolt munoctx. Mexkay Tew ueHHOCTs moboro cysAenHA OKAanIBAeTCA BeCEMa pABAHUHOH B GAPHCHMOCTH OT TOTO, KTO HC KAKHX 10- ‘unui xpHtunyer. Hrpa ckpHnaa ouensaerca OGnIsHO ¢ TPex TOWCK 9pe- Bua: UMCTO MygEIKANbuOK, CKPHTOYHO-Texmuweckoll W HNMIpeCcHOMCTH- neckol. CysKnenue Mepnoro Poga MMeeT Meco Torma, KorAa yHCTO CkDHIMUHAA Cropota HCHOAHEHIA, PABHO KAK THNHOCTE CAMOTO HCTIONH- ena OTxonAaT na Bropolk NAH, A KPHTePHAMM OUEHKM CTAHOBATCA TPAK- ‘ToBKA, crumb, pur % 7.0. Ipyrokt pox KpuTHXOB — sHaTOKM CKDHIICH, HaMpeNiaionive cpoe BHUMAINe MABHBIM O6pAasoM Ka MHCTPYMeHTASHBE xawectaa urparoutero. Haxoxen, Tpe7bs kaveropra nenreselt pearmpyeT B epsyw oveperb ua CHAY RHYIIOHHA, CEOHCTReHHY!O AANHOMY MemOsiH- Testo; HX cysReH Me ONPEHEAAETCR TEM, HACKOABKO OHM OMIYTHLAM Boarelt- Cone HoAYWAeMBAX HM TARHCTRENHMIX BOE, OGBIUHO MMeHYENEIX ¢OMINA- bent. Taxoro Poza cyuewe cKARAMBACTCA scetlenO MOR BAMAHHOM MSHOCTH HCLONMMTeNA, H 9ecb OTCTYNAIOT wa sazHuit TMAH KaX Mpoipec- cuonaxsito-ckpHOHALIC, TAK M MySEIKambHBIe MoMeNTAI. MBI Hag0BeN 970 cykqeune HmmpecchonneruueckKHM. Tlpormmopeusimue MueHits,. KOTOpHIe, Kak HM CTpAHO, 3AGACTYTO HC- XOAAT Of MYSuIKANTOR BEICOKOTO para, Ha Moll BArAAR, OCHORAHE HALeH- Ho Ha pasmuann KpHrepHen. Buidecenve oueHKm aanucuT KAK OT CHAM “4 Buenenwe ‘MecKoro M @MONMOHANEHOTO HACTPON, TAK H OT CmOUBUTXCA Y axHOrO anna nloxatnit % noaapenui (z OOmeMysiIKaaLHOM M mpocpecciowaTbHO- unerpymentamou cumene). Een Guth Ao KouuA OGzeKTHBHDIM, ‘70 eneayer OTAATS MpeaTOWTeHe OLCHKE, BuINeceHHOM ¢ YCTO MYIBI- RamHolt TOWKH OpeHHA; AHLIG MPH YCAOBAH YAOBNETROPeHUA HATIAX wy> SuIKAMBHO-aCTETHYECKHX BATPOCOB YMECTHO FOBOPUTE 0 MMIHOCTH HCTON= nureaa # ero MpoeccHomambHHX KaMecrsax. Tlono6Ham nomurKa sycraHOBJeHMA PAHTOR CE 2e BEChMA OTHOCHTeAIBHA, TAK KaX 4YBCTRO crmaa, ne HoAKpenMeHHoe AocTATOUO! TexHUYecKolt ynepenHOCTHIO, MORHO CpaRHiTe ¢ HaobparkeHeM Topca, AMIMTeHMOTO PYK wm TOIOBKS MomHaN HEAUBUAYAAbHOCTD TAKIKe OcTaeTeR yulepSHoH, ECM OHA BAI ABARET TOUIBKO cROH, cyryGo AUUHBIE MOGY-KAEHUA, a He HEH, 38,102KOH- te » my3nikabHOM npoHanegeHHM. O7cIOAa BLIBOA: BCeCTOPOHHEe, OF eKTHBHO NpARHaMEHe cywAeHMe AOMKHO B Panto mepe yuNTHBATS Myssikaxbiie, npobeccHouAmLHo-TexHHYeCKMe K ANYHOCTHHIC KANCCT- a apricra. (Or Koro HeXORUT KPUTHKA? B7eck MowHO YeranOBUTE emexyIou\He kareropun: ertommurens, onenunaiomnti cam cobs (camoxpurixa); Tegaror, xpntuxyiomndk yuennka (neqarormueckan KpiTHKa); Konnera-wyauixalizis, paa6upaoulue uenoaHenve «10 KocTouKaM+ (ronapumeckas xpTuxa); Crymarens, KpHTHKYIOMINi apriicra, UToGt TeM CAMLIM OcMBICIETb caou anevarnenna (eaymiarenscKad xpuTiTKa); H, waxonen, oinuansietit xPHTHK, BEICKASEIBAIOUINTl cBoe cy IRENE a npecce (npodeccuomam.uas KpuTiKa) CamoxpuTika npeguonaraet cAMAKe B onNOM nme sobnextay i teyGuenrar KPHTHKI, APYTHME COBANM, HeXoe «pasjBocHHe mHUHOC- tH» MenomuMrend, OHOBpemenno jelicrByIoMero H HAb.mOAAFOMErO 3a nelictenem, Henoauto2kHo peqcrasirs cobe, 1ToGi1 TBOpHecKoe cBepIe- lle, oTORH KoTOporo KOWTEs B e*pepe LoqcosHaTeMEHOTO, OPraHHaHTO CO- neTanocs ¢ OOLERTEREBIM, PACCYAONEMIM anaitaoM. CaMOKDITHKA Cry- DHT TeHHBIM MORCHOPLEM B Mpontecce saHATHH, OCOSeHHO B OTHONTeNIH rexnuueckux xetaeli. OxRaKO HeMBICAHMO Ha ee OcHOne cyAHTb 06 HeMIO.- HeHMH B HeIOM, TeM Gore, eosIK pews HAeT o nyGTHIHOM BBICTyHeHsNT. Kancaasit xouneprapyronnl apruer neoasoxpario yOoxqa.tes 8 TOM, 1 cKomExo O6maHuHRLIM OuIBReT BlleYaTaeHHe OF cobcTREHNOTO HeTOMHeHEs na serpane. ByZy¥n B cocTosHMM cyauTS 0 KoppelcrHocTit TexXHHTeCKOMt cropolia HenomHerua, OH Ban AX cHOCOGeH NATS ceGe OTHeT B TOM, AeitcT- burenbHo s1H eMy Yaasiock HaikTH YTS K cepauy enymarens. Menosimmreat Boera CkOHeH paccMaTpURATL TEXIHVECKYIO MagKOCT B KaUeCTBE TAH oro onpexessomero (bakTOpA, H ecaM 97a cTopoHA ero YAOBAeTROpsET, To om mopaxkaeten HeGraronpHATHOMY cy:eHMIO 0 cBOEM HeHOHEHHH, buieKaganHOMy GecHpHCTPACTHAIM H TlOHMMaIOMMM crymtaTenem. “acto MoxcHo naGmionaTb, Kak RouKepTHpylouRAk apTHCT, He MMeBUIHit KOHTAK- ‘tac ayauropueil B revenue azutTensHOrO BpeMenut H BCeCTAME 9TOTO 1O- Bepaloinrd cBoe HCKYCOTBO TAnHMM O6pasow caMOKPHTMKe, nepectaeT PASBUBATLON H RCTYNAeT Ha sO;eHEIe HYTH. Wirax, eamoouenka B MckYcoTBe, Kak iB 2KvSHH, — He yuu er10co6 nosnanwta nerut. Kax Man0 MOxHO ZOBepATe CyOBeKTHEHOMY BedATAe- Hino — 3 ot0m yOorkaeeres KaxkAMIa CKPHIIAY, KorAa Om B Meppbtit pas e7Bi- 15Bronenxe mn? ceGa B MexaHnecko# samHeu; K cRoeMy yoRacy OH O6HApy>KHBAeT He- octane, 0 KOTOPKIK 0 CHX HlOp He Noospesar™. Y6enmauucs 8 TOM, s70 caMOKPHTHKA TocTpoeHa Ha mATKOM YHAa- Merte, HcnomEUTeAL, Bonel-enomel AOMKEH HeKATh cebe HemnnenpHAT- oro cynsio. B nepayto ovepeat o o6pamaeres x coGcrnentoMy 1enarory, Rak K YexOueKy, OGAaRAIOMeMy COMAHKIME MpoHeccROMATHHbINM SHAN: IMM HB TO 2ke BDEMA AUUHO BAMHTepECORAHHOMY B CROEM yueIHKe. Ost ‘Ko cy:kAeHMe neaarora sauacTyto GutRaer B vem-To OrpaHHeHHRIM. TTocTO- smHoe, JuIMTebHOE OOUIeHHe C YYEHHKOM, 2uBOe YuacTHe B ero cymEGe, OTAMUHOe aHaRMe ero CHAIBHKIX H cnABKIX CTOPOH, KopoWe, cua MpHBL KM — nce 970 MpunomNT K TOMY, "TO eapeHHes moxarora npuTynaaerca**, ‘obanm x oromy, “ro neRaror He Boerza o6nagaeT NPHPOAHKIM ABPORAIH ‘eM u OzaronpuoSperenMLiMn sHaNHAKH B Taxol crenet#, KoTOPAR Mora Gur cayscurs rapanTaelt npansiioro, GeaoumBoutore eyaknenua. Hacto Haj HUM JoBAeeT ero coBeTaCHHAA MAHepA HenloxEeHHA, paccMaTpHaae- Maal m KavecrBe o6pasua, HM OH HAXOAUTCA «TOR TENHOGOM® KAKOH-7160 TegarorMueckoi cucTeMe — Tak HIM Hia‘le Om OKAgUIBAETEA He B COCTO- AHMM No JocToRHCTBY OHeHUTS cHocos xyAOKecTReHHOTO BIPAKeHH, vayuuit spaspes c ero nonnmaxney. Ee ox K Tomy 2ke Kenpasarvet XK acrpaste, TO eMy HapepHAKA NOKAXKYTCA Hy RALIMI Te NPUXOTK ADTHCTE- ecKoro BAOxHOBeHHA, KOTOpKIE poxAarOTCH caMoll armocdepolt KOHNEDT- Horo sana. irax, menaroraveckas KpHTHKA, 28 PeAKHMH HeKUOYeHHAMH, 8 He om UpesMepHO SABHCHT OF JIMUHAX NOTHROR, NpHTyANeHA CHAO! ZpH- BHIUKGH OrpaHHaena cyOneKTHBAKIM OAHOCTOPONHUM XapakTepow Te Aarorwueckix Bosspensi. Besoropopouro Aomeparucn TakoH KpuTHKE ue cneayer. Kputuxa, uexogamas or coSparsen no npohecoum, saanetea kent um JocTommuem aprucra. BuaroxenaremHo HACTpOCHITGIC KOEN HO: poit exHHEIM cx1OBOM, CKaSaIIMIM B HyAKHEIL MOMeHT, MoryT ¥yAONeliCT- ReHHO NOBAMATS HA TOTO, KTO NCKpeHHE MPHCAyHNBAeTeS K HX CORETAM. Yacro Gxisaer, To noce TaKOrO poaa KDMTURE Y cKpHnava cuanaer crea nexena, 1 on c yorpamauomell orueTaMBoeTiio BEAHT CoO MAYA no xoxmomy nyu! B peayabrare HaYHHaIOT OTMAXaTS hipenatcrsHa, Mpe- TpakqaninMe nyTs, HAMOBO CTpoaTCs YenOBeHeCKHe CyALOKI, HOpoi nante MpuxoauT cnacenue oT ruGemH — H nce To Onaronapa cnoRy, BoMpeNA ckaganomy wenosexom decruimm H mpaMonHuelinin’, K comaneniHio, oT0 caysaetes pexXo, 1 BMHOH Tomy Wane Bcero rayoe camomoGue, RocIIpH- Humaromjee jexonyio GecnpucTpacTHyi0 KPHTHKY Kak JET! OONAY. K orxpsiro Bbtckasannomy Mueniio exenyer OTHECTHCE Kak K AparoneH- omy qapy! C apyroii cropomu, xpuruyloniutk Koxzera me nena OnIBaeT RocTATOWHO GecKOpHICTHEIM, CHOCOGHAIM M3 HHCTO HeTOREECKHX HOBY2K- * BaaenH, S70 omen coGersenore NOHOANENH ¢ NoMORN GeeupHeTpaCTHO _pancxosporoit aaacrami noka tro wenozsayeres xpaline waro, Henazexo Bpesem, HOT Za nant expuna Gye? HNeTs »cnoek paGorentxABueTe xora Ou IpocTeMtn 39y- + HaoGopor, mmewanaese, mponoseenioe YuenMKoM A nenazora mpi nepnof expeue, uamte neero oxaauinaeroa ObzekriaH0 DepUlM, TAX KaX aaech One CHARAN eorea Geo nansuua nopewenenmicx sitize o6croaTeaEcT®. 16 Buexenne neuuit Mopaznsito onepaeark cnoero ronapuna. Text caxtkist xpHTHKa 3 Yer KozserH BMECTO ACHLIX, KOMKPETHHX OueHOK GonbUTelt YACTO BEIpA- seneres B MeompexeeHNNsX, OGrekaemHIx GopMysEpoKAX M cxoDectIX BMIBOPTAX, OTMENCHHSNK KaHHOOM HlevaTso HeHcKpennoctH. TIpH 9TO%M. HepenKo ROSHMKAeT eHTYAKHA, KOTAA MIpABLI ropiT aenaiNeM Yenss- {ATD HeAHKenpAATHOe H OGOCHORAHHOe MHeHHe 0 ce6e, a KPHTEEY:OWeTO ‘Tak W HORMMIBAET CKASATH MPABAY, HO... OTKPOBEHHOTO PasrosopA He - ay TaeTeA, 06a CHHUIKOM r1yGOKO YeAMTH B THEE yosIOBHOCTeit H MpeADAC- cyako3. Toxmannoe Mee oOnapyxunaeTcs oOkI'HO Mose — 98 Cr Hof netiomnurena. (Cyskaenie Ko.t1er-neckpnmavel, » meppyio ovepean masacron (ro ect xaTeropHit MCIONHHTeNeH, CTOAMMK Ha CAMO RMCOKOH cTyneHH Myab- RATBHOTO PAIBHTHA), MOET OHITh B HOBCCTHOM CMBICE HOHCe, WEN MELe- ne exputiava. He 2areuxesioe npodeccnonaxxsinimn MexOHaMit, OHO ‘rr0coOt0 nepHee oTpaaHT MYIHRATHHYIO cyMNOoTH MTOMHORHA™. Kpirika co eroponi ak HasmipaeNoro «epenstero exymiarena+ nmcer Goxpittoe sHAYONKO Yoke TOTOMY, NTO HMEHHO ero BocMpHsITIHO B NEpByO ‘oweper® axpeconano MyaniKansHoe KenosHeNue. Tipecrosyran «arpa Ha nyBaMkys oak GiITs nOpHNAeMa ZN B TOM cMy‘Ee, ecm HCAOAHH- ‘esis 8 HeTAX BoanelieTHHA ombayeTcs MenospOmenTaMH (c TONKI spent BSICOKOrO apTHCTHMA) cpencTRaMm. Caxo uO ceBe crpemnenHe apracra K MaKCHMAHHON JOXOMUAROCTH HCTORIEHIEH Ie MONET CHHTATHCH HpeRO- cynmreasbim. Hano taxake mposects rpans Me:xAY YoTHEIM BbICKAgHIBA- eM enMAAHOTO ezytATens (¢ KOTOPHIN MBI AEHO BHtaKOMDS) H BLIPAKE- Hem YaOBNeTBOpeHHA aH HeygosOmsCTBUA co cTOpoHK NHOTOMKOM acces, uMeHyeMor ny6muKoik, Oniymenna ongeTbHBIX HEAMBHAOB, CAHTHIX B Mace, HaMeKMOTEH pb roll ce mepe, a Kakolk yrpaunaered caMocTOsTembHOCT KAZKAOTO MINH: ‘Ie, a ero OMOMIEH CTAHORATCH TeM HTeHCHBHEe, HEM Goble OKPYDKAI0- ix inogeli wx paagenser. Yenoneveckoe coobujectHo Hepexko oxasninter- cm ex1ocoGuim K conepmienmo Aliens, KOTOPHe AAA OFAesTBHOTO ZHI Gsiam Gur a6comorio HemBIenMMss. Koniteprmpyiouite aprHeTsi a1axoT 0 omsrry, To B TlotyyeToM aaste MoxeT MpoFiTH HesaMeeHHEIN caMOe BBIa- ouleeca HeHomMeHHe, B TO BpeMA KAK MpHCTaEHOe oHMMANHe GONEIIOME AyAWTOPHH oKAaHINGeT cHLMoneltiee RosAeficTENe Ha NCNONEHTEAA, HORLI- uaa ero aMomponanomuii Tonyc**, Ream mi sexor# npocneanrs mprmist or0i yAHBMTeTKHOM 28KORO- MepxocTH, To Mar AOZDRHE MpeKAe BeeTO YaICHHT Cebe, TO 2Ke sBNIsICTCH haa Hac MepHnoM — mMeHme OTgeIKUEIX mE, O6paayioMUx Macey, ‘Han soremie Mace 8 HenOM. PaceMoTpMMs CoCrARHe u1eMeHTHI, Ma KOTO. DEX ckuuaaBIBAeTeH «cpeAHAA aYANTOPHAY KOHEPTOD CKPHTIMIEOH MYIE Xen, Hantepento ncxsosis 13 Hee nposbeccnowar7bHBIX KDHTHKOM, Mat Hale Hest » weit enoxytoutte Kareropmu: 1) npodeccHonamnite ciepumatt, 2) apyrue mysisxanrus-npodeccionanss, 3) expimaun-so6xteam, 4) 1po- “me moSurens mystic, 5) mpoamts, Mano cunenmmne B MyauIKe, Ka2- * Oomenavectno, xax ware Mower gave expuravy nuanncr —mapriep no rrpe ma: Nepnow aneau6se. seght Hey. Boexep coracr noawonean ronopirh atte o nexoon soyacria® ayG 7aot us orix rpynm mpucymt ocobsrit xapaxrep KpuTuuecKolt oeHKH, KOTO Putik moaker Onirs oSoaHavex mpHGHsHTeMHO CHeRYIOUITM O6paAsOM: 1) mpoeccnonamsHo-Mysbikabii (To CTE ¢ yOPOM Ha CKPHIMYHO- ‘Texnuveckite MoMeHTH); 2) MyauikambHo-MMmpeccnonMeriMeck nit; 3) mampeccnonnernueckitt ¢co expumiHsia yR0HOM; 4) wampeccuonueraectcit 5) mpumurussasit, ncxoaauiuti us wAcT0 sayKonoro BocnpanTia". Hraxt, mit Bnaxat, ero AMI onpeseneHHaN Kareropua cxymaTereit, coeguumojad npoecchonansHo-cxPHNMYAYIO H OFIEMysuKANDAyIO _kyabtypy H ba06an0k oGaaaaioNaN HapeCTHBINM 9THMECKHMH KaTeCTBANH (Gnaroxenavensocth, oTCyTCTAHe 3ABNCTH, IUMPOTA BIPAAROB), — TOTBKO Ta KaTeropua cHocoGHa BBICKAsATb HpABHMBHOe, KOMIETeHTHOe cysHe- ame. Oguaxo, ecam nepure Becany x’9HqM, auias Kareropus cocranna- er, Kak MpARitno, He Sonee ABYX npolteHTOB ayAMTOpIN KoNMepTHOTO gata. Cyncqeits octastsHoit uRcTH NYGIMKH AODKHB Guns npuanants Gonee Hit _MeHee OLHOCTOOHEMMM, TAK KAK OHH Wamle Bcero OTpaxazor KaxyI0-1160 ormemsnyio, ocoGeHHo ApKo saneuarnenmysca vepry uenoxKeHHA. Hoa BHM K 9TOMY, NTO MYSMKAHTM M HOOHTeNH, He Hrpaiomiue Ha CKPHNKE, ‘ouenunaior urpy expHMANA, GeccosHaTeMLHO HOANMILAACE TOMY BoszelicT- MIO, KOTOPOe HA HX OKAIMBAOT HHCTO MYSKIKANDHBIe ZOCTOHHCTBA HC- nomisemoro npouaperexns. penoqueceumsit na cpenzem yposHe KOH- uept Berxosesa gocrasager un Gosmbinyo panocTh, vem «TInacka nexbM> Tlarasmnts a nanGonce conepurentom KenonnenHa’. ‘AuawusTuueckoe enpomynsinanies nyG.kH packpMBaer Hepen nami nectpylo KapTHRy RCeROOMORHBX KPHTHMECKHX Cy RACHMIL, BGosLInMNCT- Be cnoem ogHocTOpouHEX # HeKOMNETeHTHEIX, ITH OTAEMBEMIe BLICKASHIBA- nts B cpoelt copokynHocTs obpasyior «oGulee MHeHue®, B KOTOPOM TOC axoll ia BuimenepewHoneHEEZX KaTeropuit eNMIMINTCH TeM ABCTHEHHCE, wen Goasunuit nponent ny6auKH ona cocrasaser. Hanpumep, ayzuTopHA xouypcos Tlapwxckoll KoHcepsaropHm cyauT yuacTHuKOR npeMMytect- BeHHO ¢ MYSKIKATHHO-mporbeccHOMANBHO! TOW speHHA, TAK KAK OHA CO- crour 8 CombimuHeTpe cBoe ua OGpasonannetx cxpunavell. B ouenke ve~ MoaHeHns HapeCTHMX KAMCDHBIX ancaNGueit pemaroMuMH OKesBIBAIOTCA ‘Mero MysLuKabHELe KPHTepHH, HOCKOALKY axeck Mepenec B nyOAMKe Np HasieaknT «ua6paHHolle REpXYIIKe MYAHIKANEHO PAIBUTEIX sOOHTENTH. Bomumioe, Ho ofsiocToporiee cKpHIMTYHOe AapowanHe HAXOAMT OTKAMK raanieim o6paa0M y mpo*peccoua.ton (B Menbinied cTenenst y MySBIKAHTOS nooSiie), & TAX HAghIRAeMBIH «TexHAph» MPH coxeiicTEuu yMexo opraHHs0- nannoii pexnamus goOunaeres yertexa y AonepaMBOH, yao! MoAAMAHOMY wexyecrsy Tons. 'B nporimonec YerHOMY BICKASKIRAHICIO OTACNBUBIX JH, Macca BEIpa- akaer cnoe ono6penve antioqucmentanu. Dror BappapcKnil oOuraait xcxm10- Maer TOHKyIO AMdepenTANINO KDUTHIECKHX cyaKAeEMH; My mmETE HaD- annenus oMorail, paanW4aeMble page TO M0 CH.e H MpoAOARHTeTEHOCTH, Rarpamaaior Gea pas6opa HeTHHHRi TALAHT M OeazapHocTs. CyaMTs Ha 9TOM OcHORaHMH 0 TORMMAHO HeMHOCTH McHOAMeHMA — Kak oTO wHOrAA croifcrnenno HeonuiTKo# Moaonext — ConbIAA OMIHOKa, crocoOHAs 10- pOoKAATE BpeAMBIE HULOSHH. ‘Orcioga calexyer BLIBoR: MHeHHe +Gombmoit ToATMs, UpomBnmOMecc bo BHeLIHNX npHHAKAX OAOGPEHKA, He OGranAeT HH MavieHimelt OFBeKTIE- Baegene Holl NeHHOCTEIO H MODKeT CAYAIITE AHI eOOUIHM SHAMCHATENEN®, YPAB- HOBEIIIBAIONIEM pASTMMHEIe, HOAYAC TPOTHBOMOOAABIE MCHA, HAN KE ORagaTenem rocnoxcTRYIONIero B ake SMORNOHATEHOTO HACTpOs. APTHC- "Ty BKICOKOTO PaHra, HO BCHKOM caywae, He MPHCTAIO NpHAABATD PeuTALONICe SHAYOHHE TOMY, ¢ Kaxoli MHTeNCHBHOCTHIO TYOTHKA PAGOTATA ARAOHANH. Cymecrsyer, onaxo, pox xpHTHxu, 4pesBstuaiiHo Baxkusti 1K MeTON- mutema, no Kpaiisiet mepe, ¢ TOU apeHHA ero BieMHerO yerlexa; pets user, pasyMeercs,, 0 mpodbeccHonansHolt kpuruxe. B ro Bpema KaK PALO- noit ¢nyiarexs xpanur cnow BHevaraenns npu ceGe uGo ZenuTcA wMM {YeTHO co CRONM OmKoKAlMIHM OKPY>KeNMEM, KPUTHK BMHOCHT CBOE Cy Ae- ‘nue Ha raaerute oxoee, Hocae Yero oH0 crantonTea AocronNHeM OOMID- oro Kpyra wurarenel, Ke GusuMX cBNZeTeNAAH OnMCARHOTO TBOPEC- Koro axra. O cocroaBiliemes HCnomMenHH yanaeT wuex0 mORelI, KOTOPOe BTNCAYY, @ TO HB JeCHTe THEA pas Mpestimaer ayqMTOPHNO, MpucyTCT- noBapily%o Ha KoMnepre. KpurHk ne ToaEKo nubopwupyer oOulecTBeH- oct, HO « Hanpannser ee muenne. Ero noxrasia, Tox KOTOpO! Mpocrst- paeren B mpenenax oF cRepmannow GxarocKaoHHOcTH 20 HeyeMHoro BoeTopra, crocobxa npo6yanT y UMTATeNs 2KesIaHHE CAMOMY MCIMTATE dereravecKoe HacaaneHve, Crom upHBuIeKATeNbHO onMcaMHOe. fl1H ap- ‘Hera 2e ToxBambinIe THPARE OSHAYAIOT, WTO eFO HeKyecTHO MpHsHaHO 4 omenexo No AocToHHeTBY; aTO HoMOTaeT exy O6pecTH yBepeHHOCTh B ce- 6e w B upasaastocTs uabpaxuoro um nym. BcRow ovepeds, KPUTIUECKOe nopauanne (8 TpaHMuax OT ocTopoxHOTO HaMeKA 10 S06HO!t HacmeIiH) elle peuironbee, eM MOxBANa, onpexenser coboll MHeHUe uHTATEIE 4M MO2eT OCHOBATeABHO MOKONeGaTS Bepy XYAOMNMKA B cHoH TATART i enoe Byaymiee. Haeanbueiit kparHx Zos>Ken oOnaqeT® emexyiouyHMn scHO BLIpEKeH- [HLIMHE KAWECTRAMH: IIMpOKOe OBIE, MYIKIKAEHO-TeopeTmMeCIoe H MYaEI- Kasmbtlo-HCTOpHTIecKoe OOPAIORAHHE, IHAKOMCTHO C TeXHAecKHMH OcOGeH- HoctaMH HaH6onee PACHPOCTPAHeHHKX MYSKKAMDHMIX MeTPyMeHTOR, PARHO RAK H NemOReUeCKONO TONIOCR; TOHKAK BOCTPHMMYABOCT K sHNCHI- AN HeKYCCTRA, OCTPOe AHATHTHYeCKOe MBIUITOHKC, yMeHHe OGeKATE CBO atenH He mpocto B KOppeKTHYIO, HO H BO BNlewaTsatOInyso sHTepaTyPHYIO Qopmy. K ostomy meaty npuGawxaiotes, KoMewno, oveHb nemHorde. Tipexene ncero, pexkitil u3 conpeMeHHNX MySBIKAALHBIX KPUTIEKOB OTBeSA- er asym mmxecaeayionun Tpeosannan: 1) cnoco6uocth cyAuTh 0 ROCTOMHCTBAX HOBOTO MYSEIKAABHOTO COMME ua c nepsoro npocaymmpaRna; 2) xopomice SHANE TEXHHVeCKNX MpeMUOCKITOK HHeTpyMeHTaABHOTO i nokambHoro HenionHeHHs. Tlepsoe tpeGopanne s paccmarpunaio Kak MpaicruYeckit HeBKITOTHH- Moe. Toasko nocperctsenHoe m caaGoe MoxKeT GxiT® O0aHAHO c HepROTO sarzana. Hoxmuuno snawiremsnoe mponspexenie, ocoBeHHo ecxH OO 5 AsevCR HOBATOPCKAM, AOIDKHO GhIT RAHMATENBHO M3YWCHO B IONHOM Ye annenun., B KoHHepTHOM anne BHHMAHHE KPHTHKA OTBNCKACTCS He TOMEKO caysaiinocramz neaxoro pora, Ho H RenenCTAMe rReTymIel HeOGXomUMOCTH: * Hanecranait eaoeltexzonoerao « iomopy Hlooed) XemnwecGeprep noexe mepsoro we- ‘osuenstn oxn0r0 a Knaprevod BpaMcn 02RRI0CTMO HOCMOTpeN Ha WEKOETO NDECTEDEIO- oxpirrna m mienatya sTOpoMy expuaNy? «JHo6omTGO, exon Gut OH 3a 28 0, TO Gu amare, nak eMy 970 roHDABHIOCSY. 191 xparvaiimmil cpox nozosm. cnom nnowansenst ia 6ysare. Tae nitpaba: Tumaerca npodeccwonamsias upaniuka — cpaay ake OfseKATD eaoe eye. Jetiie » eneprasouuil oonpoysatem eaonecntil napaa, ROmeeNeTnyONHE Topeaurs aouepsuiporo MTavesA; MDM 9TOM, KoReUHO, He MosKer CMT 1 peut o rayGoxom npoumaonema b eymmoer® rponabexextan. Mt ya He ronopun 0 rex cayame, Horaa coxeDaceTesINOC RDHTRUCCROTO Cy Jest puiiocirex m atepray epaemBok pave isk woauioxey KaNeMOYDY. CkaOHHOCTE HEKOTOPEIX KPHTHKOR CTABHTh AMTEpATYPAY! POPMY Hast CO- Aep2kaHHeM (7eitleBoe BAO B AParoneHHom cocyze!) — MPHIMHAa TOrO, 4TO Cnivriie aprucrim euoew Gostiunutcrae e wenovepuext oruocaren ie ne- enamels xpurae. Crporo ronopa, Kaxrouy eepseanomy mporpeccnonsmiosy sepstriney enegonaxo Gia eiye 20 npocayiibaiiix Hovoro coulteNsin oxNaxoNTLoR ero naprurypoll wan keamupow. Dro anatirr, ro OM AONsKeN HocARIAT noe npoeceu ne ToxLKo nevepA, HO H AuenHoe Bpesn, GeapeaRenbi orqanasce noastoxcenofl tia Hero RiicoKoOrBeTorHeNHOM MiteeH. OAUBKO to Goaniuelt wacrn nonocrarovtioe mavepnaxbioe noaHarpanexesite aa pit. uvecky0 aeareasuoers naMyetaer KpHTIEA HekaTh ee6e IpHMeMeH » Kaxoil-au60 apyroll coepe Myaickausuol paNHu em 2avaCryIo He Xoaraer apeweuit a 70, wro6i npuilaa 9 KONepriull aa NoaroToReN- tm, [ToGanuat aTomy orpauinvenia weskoro pons, KoropIM Mpobeccno- Hasan xpierane muyacnen NonuiarTLeN NO MOTHBAM pEATHeCICOrO xepaxtepa. Tasera mperocranaser emy Muvrowo Nasoe pocrpalierio now Hosoe, Tax kaxe Ronananionee Gombnicrvo ee aurarenel SespAs- Jinan coburn myanikanniiod sxnanin, Hane ncero re mai Hue apr crimeoine zooruaeuns orvemaores # evar Wecxoabiani Qpasanct. Troport m cam epienaie ne » cocrosmu aianeeri itexesoro xyonKecTaeHHo- ro Bnevaraenia, Tax axe ragera ia WneuoORDX cooSpasken noeulaeT ro nA neckomico Koulepron 2 fevestte ojworo Beuepay u eMy HpHXogeITCR Ha ocuonanin wacrureoro npocayuntnanits cyaiino nporpatete ien0M. ‘Taxcnonnamoren cuemencnevenntae (ha cnexyratee ¥zpo! sum, AOSOPON, sanogaaae (cnycta veTupe Hegemn!) penexsHM, dbuKeupyiomme BreyaT- Zeus, Koropwe eute ne yenenw enepenapirscas m NpOMETKe Sexy Konmeprisin oenom m eaaKuuiell auGo Yate toryekteam OT BpeMeN. Hemsn we mpuonars, uro raaezuas uayerpia Oombii3x opoz08, Py!0D0- AMAA SHCTO KOMMEPYECKHMH HHTepecaMM H 10 CBoeii cyTH BpaxkqeOHaa Noxyeorny, naryéuo nalser Ha npodecchouasbnyio xpTiny, coo a ler ce pom» no6yaurrens poova m coapenaiti myaninaitron-xyROMOD", io kacaeton «puriki, lomelteewol wa crpaxitax CmeNuarbHX Mya ‘easite seypHauon, 70 ofa OGpaltiaereH K MeNMOFOWMNeNHOMY KPYTY Zarenell, npHDIAkunx evar’ Ha octonasoe eoderBeumux pnevanaes. Hac, ckpunaweri, upereae neero wnrepecyer, AocTaTOUMO i KpATHK snaer rexunrtecigyio eropouy snorpysenraaiioro MeaosneHna 8 aomeT 5M OH MDaBHLAAHO cyAWTS 0 NOCAeAMEN He TOKO ¢ WteTO My NDAOR (noo ipinpecenounerivecnoi), wo u ¢ eyry60 npobectitouariouol 7o¥t pens. Hapecrio, ero comsto-Kouneprsyio jesteabNOCtD bexy™ MAMSNe O6pasoM MMAHHCTEL, MeRIKE H HCNOAMMTeAM Ha CMBIYKOBEIX MECTpyMeH- ax: coorsererseuso, purine zona GsLM GH XOPOLIO paabuparbon » nonpocex Goprenuenniof, aokaroioK w ckpnniinol rexsten. Ozunio ‘uuua, oGnaagioue eros pagwocropomknNit CHeMMaNLALIM suaMNaHet, ctpewanorea patine pepo. Barow ewe xe Noero PHXORNTE CDE 20 Buegenne nawaM, Tak Kak OUTH KaxKMBt KpHTHR Gone HAH MeHee cHocHO BIaqeET Goptenmaxo; suanue ToMKocTeH BOKAIBHOTO HeKYeeTBA HEOGXOAMMO AAA ‘Toro, wroGu o6yuaTt meNHIO, HO HeoGmaaTeNLHO, xorgA TpeSyeren Beero smu ormanTs xopoutero neue or naoxore”. Have oGeToHT eno co crpyHuuKanm: sect nempementnin yoaoRHeM KoMHeTeHTHOTO cysRneERAA SBAMETCH sHANMe TexuMecKHX OCOGeHHOCTeit UHCTpyMeHTa. TlooTOMy DpHTHK, He urpaiountt na cKDUIIKe, peaxo OkIBAeT R cocTOAIINH AATs cepE- esnyio npodbeccroramsayio oneuKY MrpBI CKPHTIAUA; eaty Gomel YACTEIO ne ocTaeTeA Hitero ADYTOTO, Kak CYHTE O Heli c MYARIKAMLHO-MMNIpECCHO- nucrHueckoli roux spenua. EonM OH Ipouitnarezen x TazaitTam, TO ey, MeCOMHeHHO, OTKPOIOTCH MYIMIKADHBIE AWIHOCTHMIE KAYCCTBA HCIOTHH ‘Tena, HO Ox 6yxeT ObxOAUTs CTOPOHO! NHCTO cKPHNMHEIC MOMCHTHS, OFpa- HuMMEIEHCS AByMA-TpeMa CCUM, MeO SHANAMNME pasar. MMexno MooToMy Mur Tak YacTO HAGmMoAeM peaKoo pasmicIe MexAY cymmAeNHEM KOMAETH-CKPHHAGA M TAK HagIBAeMOTO UPOPECCHOHATHOTO KPUTHKA. Koxu nepnurit ygenser omxHoe BHMMANMe TeXHHYECKOMY YMeHHIO He- Noanutena x cooTseTCTBeHHO MoxeT OMpeseTUTE creneHs ero TPKpOAKOH ogapentocrs, To nocnestatit (r. e. KPHTHK-HeeKpuTiay) ame BOETO 40- Bonserayetea nepeaavel oOiero BeyATAcHUA, MPMKPMBAR KpACoTAMH cxora barctureckyi0 GeccoxepxatensnocTs cnoell KpHTHKH*. Tompobyiire ali7i w perjeusuarx XapakTepHCTHKY TaKaX KaveCT® CKHMAa, KAK Tat [HeDaM HAH CMUUKOBAS TeXHMKa, JOCTOMNCTBA HIM HeAOCTATH BBY KOFI evens, cmenia NOsMiW, RUBPATO, ToMLOCTE TexHNNeCKOTO BunOAMCHUs wr, nt Obsrano nesoctaer H sHanHA cKPHIMYHO! mHTepaTypM (KpOMe ca- MBIX TIORYAAPHLIX COMUBeHHH), NOOTOMY CXONET ¢ PYK TAKE CHyAMiMLE HAM MPOMSDOABHBE KCKAAKEHS TeKeTA. Yxasanmue ofctoarersorea orpuljarenbuo BAMALOT Ha PASBHTHe CKDH- MMHOTO HCKYCCTHA, TAK KAK ALOT BOAY HA MeNIBENNY HaRECTHOTO Poa cxpunaveit — caMoysepeHtsIx, HOepXHOCTHEIX H COMHHTENLILIX B pO- eccnonamuom orHouleRun. ToqoGi0 Tomy, Kak Puxapg Barep neni CKPUNKY TomGKO BO MHOoECTHE, TadeTHAA KPHTHKA AHUb Tora HpHOOpe- TaeT cytecrBenHoe sHaveKMe AnH apTucTa, KOTAA HORARTAIOMIee GON MUKCTRO BUICKasHIBANHit cKoAATCA MexAY Cobol Braap MoMeHTAX. Tor chaxcr, ¥To HecKONBKO KOMMETeHTHIIX AMI, HEIABHCHMO APYT OF ADYTA MMULAH OAMHAKOBOMY MHeHIO, TOBOPHT 0 TOM, 70 9TO MHeHHe cHpa- peamuno. Hak, naxHo He euHHoe MHeHHE, A CyMMADHOG, BEIRORHMOE a emoTo paya KPHTHOCKHX cyaieqeHHtt, Xora raserHan KpHTHKa davacTyIO OkAaMRAeTeH eRMNCTREHIIAM BH- AOM KPHTHKH, BLICKASEIBACMOM OTKPORCHHO, Gea OBUNAKOR HM OT-ARAOK, anayenue, npuaanaenoe elf apructont (ocoBeltHO R HaaTe ero KapLepst) Sompmeii wactbio mpeypeanvexo. Tocaeauuii uepeako Oninaet NORHOCTEIO AesopMeHTupOBAH NPOTHBOPEIMBLIMH MHCHHAMT, Ha KOTOPLIX HepOSMODI- Ho cnesars Kaxne-nn60 cymMapHote sEiBomis. UpeamepHoe RHUMANHE K ra ‘SeTHOMt KpHTHKe orlacHo He TOMBKO Tem, YTO OHO MO>KOT HOBEPIUYTH EPTHC- ‘Ta B cocTomEme ayntenHolt nenpeccun; oH0 TaKsKe erlocoGHo O6parHT» ero a noxkanti nyte, B TOM CAYuae, ecm KPHTHKA OcHOBLBACTeR Ha HeBep- mux npegnociimcax. ApTact B Mlopy cBOeTO CraHORNEHHs ero 2a6KInACT * Hpoo6pas menpecenomncraveckoro, Gxecramero » extiexe xaTepaTypHOR @opaes, Mo aBcomoruo wenpodpeccnonanssoro c¥acteNust MOxHO yeMoTpers OREN FENIX 'eline e@aopewrniicxwe wou», comepacamtelt osueanue urpit arane. arBuenenne ry Merny, 70 6narocknonHule OTIMBM cant no coGe He CenaIoT sHAMe- HTN TOFO, TO HX He BACNY>KWA, M HAOGOPOT, raseTHAR KDTIKA He 110- MeiligeT sanATE NoROBaIOMIee MeCTO TOMY, KTO ero RocToHH. HocmeaHee MO- 2keT GLITE YACIOM KOMIOIHTOPA, CCH, CKARKEM, Y HETO Her BosMORKHOCTH. YenLIMATe HcnomesTHte CROCCO NPOMIBEACHHLA HAM ECMH eFO TEOPEHHA Oe O{KAIOT BKYCKI COBPEMCHHUKOB HACTOKEO, WTO eMY He NpuxomsTCA Dal cumurars Ha npuananne npH xsaMH. Ho MCNONNHTeT, ba CTaBa BCTUIES- baer Ha NOAHe CeroAHAMHeTO AKA, BeerAA uaiiqeT MyTH 1 OGuIEHMIO co caymarensn. Eom Bce ae HeKoTOpBie KORMepTHpyOUUIe APTHCTHI, KAK 970 MoaKeT NoAaaTECA, He SaHMMaIOT NPHAKYeCTByIOMeTO HM HoxO-KeNHst, To HA 90, 10-RAAMMOMY, ECT FuIyOOKMe, HESAMCTHBLe JUL TOBEPXHOCTHO- ro narasaa IpHIMEM, B TepDy%0 ONepem’ HEAOCTATOK ocoboro KavecTBa — THEMOTHUecKOM CHUM BEYIIEHAR. Ospuconanmoit awit Kareropiit McKlomEHTeNei, He TomKO 6xarorope- roux neper 060i nexaTHoR KPMTUKO!, HO M CKHOMHEIX HOAMARATS HOR ee namanue, savacryio naryOHoe 428 Hx PASBHTHLA, NPOTMBOCTONT cpaBiH- ‘TenuUO MaAOUMCMEHHAS TPYMILA TEX, KTO CUHTAeT raseTHY} KPHTHKY BOO6- me Heaocroinoit anmmanna. rH onH MpeOspaior B onackoM sa6ay2KRe- uumt, MorkHo zonycra7s, To TROpYeCKMlt reHMT, AaTeKo omepeaHBUTHA cnow aMtoxy, anpave He CuNTATHCA C MHENHeM COBPEMeHEHKOB, HOCKOALKY oH, nooSHo Berxonexy mocmequux xnapreros, oOpaiaercs x eye He PO- AubunMea noxosienuam. Ho McKyceTno uuTepmperaTopa — scetje10 110 pookenne cpoero Bpemens. Kaxoit Gur suaunremuolt xuuHocTEIO OH HI Guus, rexHveckas cropoua ero mactepcrsa TpeGyer HocTomHHoTO KOHTpO- 3a, CCAM OHA CnY2KHT BEICIIIM XyRoxKecTReHEUIM HenaM. CANOKPHTHKA — 270 expax, Koroporo nerko nonkynuTs. Tloamoro Aonepa sacayznsaeT JIM OCHA CO CTOPOHB, BuIsINZICHHAA CAMEM apTICTOM Ha OCHOBANM MHOroaNcIOHERIX cyKAeHHL, YeTHRIX H NeVATHRIX. Ora «cpennAs» onenKA He ROmKHA, KOHEYHO, ROBACTH HAs APTHCTOM HACTOALKO, UTOG OTANEKATE, ero of uaGpaHHoro HM MyTH B yrogy rocnoneTayiomHK BKycaM. Ho B oxy- ‘uae, Korga BosHKaeT HeoGxomAMOCTS MepecTpofiKH TexHMYeCKOTO ann para, — 8 K OTOMY ¢ TeTeRHEM BpeMeHH MpHXOAMT KaxkAMIH CKPHNAL TomBKO MHeRHe NYGANKH, BLIPAXCHHOe P OTIMBAX KPHTHKOD, MOMCT KE RTD HAM, ONPARLATHCE 1M OKMARHUA, CRABAHHBIe C TAKOM nepectpalKoit, HAXOAUNOH AH Moi Ha NYTH X 2eTAHHO! NeAM HUH 9AGpeAH B TYNUK, OTKY- Ja wer uMoro BBIXOMa, KAK BOSBpaMleHve Haga. BaarockaonHaa KpMTAKa, KaK IpABNAO, He OKAsMIBAeT CyLECTBEROTO RAHATINA Ha NaTbHeMimtee TBOPTECKO® PAIBHTHE, B TO BPEMs KaK C1080 1O- PHMAINIH, cAZAHHOe B HY2KHBIA MOMEHT, MODKET CAT NOBOPOTHEIM HYHK- ‘TOM, — CoH TOMbKO Y ADTHCTA XBATHT MY2ECTBA BHUMATENEHO MPHCMY- marca x wewy. Ho yr06nr anaeub peambHYI0 HOMbY M3 KDHTUKH, APTHCT ‘RosuxeH cyMeTs Mepenectu oerenHeckoe cyAyeNHe Ha AIEIK CROETO PeMeC- ‘na. Boas, Hanpumep, xpurwxa oGpamiaer BHMManMe Ha *eCTKOCTD SBywa- HUA, TO eMy CAORyeT daaTL ceGe BOMpOC: Boe IM B NOpAKe B OTHOLIEHH TOWN KACAHMS CMMUKA H CTPYHKI, He MPeyBeAMYEH AM HAKHM CMBUKA n 1.11, Butgnantoe ue6naronpaatuoit xpuraxoit wyncrno NORABNeRHOCTH HIM BpeMesHoe cuuoKenue apTHcTHMecKOH DenyTANMM He ABIAETCH UpeS- -MepHO BMICOKOM naaToH, ecaM B KOHEUNOM HTOTe MOTy? OMIT AOCTHEAYTAL ‘BaMeTHEIe YeIexXH B ORNARCHNH MACTEpCTROM. ‘Mul 20 cHx Hop He KacaaHck RaxkHoro McHKomorMuecKOrO MOMCHTA, CO anaroujero Hopolt Reonoammuaie HPenATCTRNA AIK MKECeHHS CHpAReATH 22 Baonen oli, oGxerrmpnoli onemen. Pews yqer 0 HWHofk cxemanii Hout antraIR- ‘THM, BOsHKALOMIe# To oTHoMIeNMO K cAMOMY HENONUITENIO HH X saHte- pe ero MIP — 0 cBoerO Poa HpeAyGerkKeNINM, OF KoTOpOTO Me BAcTpAXo- BANM NM Uenerord, MH XPUTHKM, Hit ROARETH, HH AerKe psoDble rhocerirens KoHepton. BenoxniM 0 CKOpOCMeNAX anleioweHAX, KOTO- pie Aenavoroa cpaay 26 10 nesxoxe apmucra ua 9orpany («s109epr HN.) x GeccosnarenbHo pacnpocrpaumores Ha ucnosmene. Hpopeccuonaste- sii RDHTIME oOuIWHO sapaniee HaCTpoeH 3 OTHOMICHAH AaxtHOTO NEMO ‘Ten B TOM CHYWRE, CCA OF MIEN ROIMONHOCTL NpeRApHTENLHO NOAA. KOMMTDCH CHEM H ONPEAEIUT, HBINLETEH IM OM eNPYTOM HUH eBparoMtr, GusoeTbI0 zyxoDuO GxuSKOH wAM uysKAOH. BooMO2RHO mM, HANDHMCP, ‘wro6i anTHCedrTT x0TA Ger Ha KOPOTKOE BPeNA OTEpOCHLI CRO MpemTYGE>K- euitA H mposDsLx noAMy!O OO LoKTHMBKOCT» n ONOHKE AprHCTA, Welt aH IC- exit H AYXoBMUG OGM HOcHT spKO BAIpAACEHHBLE enpelice LepTM?” Jlaace: enocoGen am xpurmx — sio6itTem, «usiramugrste — mpwusts xy- ROxeCTHEHHYIO MHAMBHAYANEHOCTS MpockeTAeKHO-AnoAOHHYECKOTO exnaga, na HeoGopor, erporHil Knaccuier — onOOpuTD MaTeHYIO CTPA erioers menommenns? Ke aromy exeayer 1o6asWr®, WO Kaxksbal KpHTMKY- ro1lut (no oGaganoer wa AoSposoastio) cKAOHEH NpHEHCAATE aprueTa, IAKONOTO eMy 110 PERN AOCHIOKeNL, K ONPEACACHHOMY PASPSAY, ‘To ects MaxtenbaTs Ha Hero apsisK; Yeranontrameecs TaxKMM OODAsOM Mite. ve dpesmurvafino tpyqHo moKomeGaTs, Aa>ke ecat B urpe aprucra mpowso- ‘uuaw eymecrnemmue wonenemus, Cnoso pageuTHe xyAoHKENKA me COnDA- meno Toq¥ac € CAMMINH YaMDuTeNDEEIMH mpespaiemaaet! Topadzo orveraupee Bocmpmnmwaiores: HANK MOMCHEMLA, DOOHAKUINE B MpoKecce Dduomomun xounossTopeKoro THOpecTBA, TAK Kak OHM SATevATTeND BnloTHOM Texte. Ho H THOpMeCTAO MYQKIKANTA-HCTOMIHHTEAA TOMB.TACTHO ‘Tea ako aKOHEM TOCTORHHOTO OBHORIERUA (KOTH H MeHtee 9AMETHOTO BHIII- xe). Hooromy gor xpurnke Kex Bnipasntesia oOmlecTBeHKOTO. MHeHHA 3 nonpocax Hexyccrsa — apema or speMent nepecMarpusar> ycromBuIne- a, wa nepsuti sarang KeatiGnexsre cyacnenmn, mposepam 1x cooTBETCTBNE opts aicrant rBopYecKoro pocra m pasnuTan xyROMuNHKA-Tep- nperaropa.Trasal OBIE 9TEMEHTEI MYSEIKAJIbHOTO HCHOSHEHHA Taannas npobxewa, neraroutas reper xy ROskHTHKCOM-suTepuperaropom, cocronr 8 Tom, "roGs1 co¥erar» cxoGory mpoaBesta aprncTHYecKolt MH RUBHAYAGHOCTH © YBRDKONHEM Ie TeKOTY HpOHIwEReHAA M BUIpADKOHLIM em amepensa KounosmTopa. Kaxnit o6pasom aMaHOCTS xyqonKcHMKA Monker OcROGOAUTHCR OF NYT, HATATAEMBIX HE Hee OXDYAIOIAUM. MiEDOM coGcrseHHoli nenxnKolt, — Gyxer noxasano 8 aatbuefinie. Toxamect orpamiuunen moyenne Tex sitcTo MysuiKeabHLIX TpeGonanMl, KoTOpEIE npouaseaesne cranur mepen mcnommsrreeM. Vevepoxnenme, Gyro ne cymtecrayer winkarcx o6teaaMMMEX Hop xyonkecrmerHoro enosmeHHst, — He Gostee “eM BbIpAeHMe PACTepsEO- ‘erm mepea aniom xnorouncxexsanx npobex. Hecommenno, nowarHe xy. ROMeCTHENHO-IIPEKPACHOFO CsIHITKOM MHOTOOHPSAHO, WTOU ero MOHHO Guino prucnyr » pasexs nempenonetrx, oecTsrsunix SopMya. CaMise Cm Ale ACTETHMECKHE RICYATNEH ROSHHTKALOT HMEHHO KAK PEaY.IATAT CHiO- MMHYTINN BpOXHODCHM, MOTH eHoMeNs BEICUeTO NOpAAKA TAX %e pesawsnnst no noel npHpORe, Kak H x aeuDKIE HoCHTEAE. TOsKO 9aK0- DeHesOMy meAaHTy Tor HAM MHOK CHOCOB MepeRavH EPELCTABAAETCR EAH. ‘crnenno RoamonHis. BMecte ¢ 7eM HIRO He MonkeT OTPHHATD, TO CYNE cryor unrepuperaitzm, KoTopHe © HomisiM OcHopamMeM joz2KaHS: Gurr ‘oxapaxcrepudonanas xaxe wenepanie. Taxtice uirepnperanimt, OLeDNAHO, mpe- ne6peraiot mpanitxaum m saxonann, OGyenanmBaIOMyNH iembHOe, TAPKO- usioe nnovarnenne oF Myauikaoro wenoauenss, Aprucr wooKoT 663 onacensi oraaricn postylonlM eFO 2MOMMAM JIt> pH TOM YCHOBHN, ec- ‘IH mpeamieerayrouee pocmiTaxie paaBH1o B HEM KavceTBa, ofoanavAese coGuparesbuiaN HONSTHEM eMysblKaTLHAN RYRKTYpAY; HoCMeRNAA, Cram eorhewaenot aero. ANSKOOTH wYOGIRAT, NPOHOXPAIIT 00 OF NOPY- Tlox emyanikansuoit Kysstypoiie mht MonpaayMepaen aHAHMe 38KOKO- epnocrell myatkansioll PopMii, PapNOHiOH, MeTpopHTNE, OPHAMEHTHKK, ApTaKyAAMN, auMAMMKM, aroruKit, d)pasMpOBKL, Hapany © passiTEIM uyner#om eri. B aow sanavy mettee RoeTo BKOAMT ucvepmimBaroUtee PAC eMorpeuve yxasammerx xntcuunand, Tem Gosee, “To MMeeTCA MHOA.eCTHO TPYAOB, culenwam.io mpesmasHaTeENX 9 KeveCTBe PyKOBONCTBA ILIA HSY- arom mysnixy*. “ro ac mpexae wcero unrTepecyer 8 oTHx AMcHHIAI- * Tpyan no rapmouucr w rexamnxe xonmmosuae Peyorwane, Mapxea, Bexrepa, Pat a, UlénGepra; H. Riemann. System der musikalischen Rhythmik und Metrik. Leipzig, 1903; Th. Wiehmayer. Musikalische Rhythmik und Metrik. Magdeburg, 1917; pean sue tpyauto purrane P. Beenbauia (cu. H. Riemann. Musiklexikon); 8. Dannreuther 24 O6mne oaemouTit MyounaaLHoro enomMenK ax — Bompoc o Tom, mpuMexunt 14 GesoroROpOUHO HX dAKoitB K'HAMEMy auerpymenty. Ha 9T0 IpHXOAHTCH OTBeTHTh OTpHnATeTbHO. ABTOPAI HO- AABNAOMETO NHCTA PYKOBOACTE MexOAAT Ha cueMMMbHNECKIEX yonoRt (Poprenmanno# urpk, He YuHTHIBE OcOGeHHOCTeR PHTMUKE X @paatpoR- RH, MPHCYOWX HeMOXHeHHWO HA CMRIGKORKIX HHCTPYMeHTAX; Hocmenuee NOAWMHCHO COBCOM HEBIM SaKOHOMEPHOCTAM, XOTA Gs Ye B cHAy TaKO HUAN, Kak HeOOXOAMMOCTE NOCTOAHHO MeHSITS eMEIUOX. B xamuolk eM Oyaer enenana nonsTka paceMoTpeTs OGmIKe IAKOHB HAZBAAHEIX BB ie AvenunmuE eKBosb MpHsMy named uRCTpyMeNTanEHO! crreusKsTt HalM HepecMoTpeTs TaKOBKIe, ECTH OHH OKAMKYTCH HECOBMECTHMBIMH ¢ Heli. Caeayer nommurs, 470 aoGoe Hactamenue z zanuoit oGnacTH HOCKT yMoapumembitnil xapakrep H npexctanaer coboli, Zo uaxectHoli cremenn, YUpAXGeNHe MEIC, KOTOpoC MoXeT coueTATECH 00 cROGORO!t XyRoweCT- eHHOTO BMIPADKEMHA AMINE B TOM CAYUAC, CCAM MeNKAY OTHMM {BYMA CTOPO- HaMHt He BooHEKKET HeMpHAEEpHMOTO MpoTHBOpeTEA. to HAO NOHHMATE ‘enetyionyie O6pasom: MB NOCTHPaeM PARMA MYIMIKAIEHOTO HCTOMHeH ES pasy€om, KoTOpHIIL KOHTPOAMPYeT HX MPAIcTHYECKOe MPUMeHeHHe BINOTE 20 TOTO MOMeHTA, KOPAR OHO CTAHOBHTCH Js HAC IPMBKITHBIM, eCTeCTHEH- iim x Goccoauarenbutnin. Bent 6st Mit OROATHCb BEIBYIRNEHHLIME B TpO- yecce MCNOJHeHMs NOCTOMHHO RAONMRATS B NAMATH Ree AURAMIENeCKHE 1 arorH¥eckHe OSoaKAYCHHA, BCIO CHMBOANKY HoTHOrO TexcTa — TaKOe cromHoneHHe Mepraok Gyknit ¢ 2MBO! waTepHell smHLIOcE Gxt npHUETHO cepneanolinmux nomex. [evarisie oGoanavenua cnoco6os ncnomuenua NO2KHO YHOAOOHTS ocaM, HEOOXOAMMNIM MPH BOIETCHN SARNIA; KOTAR cxpofixa saxonvewa, 1x yaasaor ¢ dbacaga u BiiGpactiBalor Ha cBANKY. Merp « pum O6meaiaunmoe onpenenenue nonsTHit emerps m epuTM> mpeqcranns- loves @ABA J BOAMORKHBIM, TAK KAK HX OHANEHME PASKITTHO B AARHOHMOCTHL OF Toro, PACCMATPHBAIOTCH JH OH B KAuECTRE OBREKTHRHAIX AaMKOCTe!, YMpABAReMBIx eCTECTECHHLIMM SEXONAMM, WIM KAK PacxomMe TepMUNEL aunefi toncegtesnok pewn. Ormeri raxase mepemensmnocrs cy7enennit, DEICKASAHELIX 8 pasHoe BpeMa npexcraBiTeaaMH MysuKabHOH HayxM. Tak, wo Becnhamo, Mystikasuas Merpuka exer cBoe Hayao or uooTH¥e- ckoii: «Mit momen emexo mpHuATS rHTOTesy 0 TOM, UFO HEWAO TOdaIH 6ix- 0 oxMoBpemenHo Hayao Mystsix. [oosia euoem HepmonATAAbHON Bi He Gnima menue, Mystixa Guia menonueli x ctuxorsopHomy Texcry. Jims 8 Goxee nosaHee speMa KaxKnuit Pox MOyIHs caMocToATembHOe pasoH- THe — moosHis Kak HcKYCCTBO AeKAAMAKHH, MYSBIKA KAK OOMIACTS +4HCTOTO unerpysentanusma». Tlepsax no apeMex MHCTPyMeHTamuuaa MysuKa Suna enecneit Ges cxone*. Cornacno «Mysuikamsuomy cxonapior Prncania, TepMnuE! «MOTD» H «PHT» WACTO NPHMEHAOTeH KAK OGooMAMEHHE TOA nectsemuix nonarmit. CaM 2ce Paaan onpeseaaer pasanune B UINTesBHO- Musical ornamentation. London, 1808-1895; H. Riemann. Musikalische Dynamik und Agogik. Hamburg, 1884; M. Lusty. Tratéde expression musicale. Paris, 1873: G, Adler. Der Stil in der Must. Leipzig, 1911; E. Kurth, Grundlagen der linearen Kontrepunkt. Berlin, 1922 — pabore, mucroues ocoGoe anavenne 2x8 expmnevel, BENAY comepAINe- oem n nell anasia oxnorasoence eacrelh xa cona7 Baxa Ans cxpuateH con9. * R Westphal. Elemente des musikaliachen Rhythmus, Jena,1872. 25Panna 1 TH ARYKOR KAK ¢pHTMHUecKoe KAYECTRO®, a paBTITUNE CHBHEIX H CAGE novell Takra KaK eMerpHueckoe Kaecteos. [as A. Xoficnepa monsTHe PHTMA OXRATMIRAET RCE MBICHUMBIe WIEHEHUA BRYKOBOH TKAHM HO BPEMeHH; oGtilee HousTHe HoapaanenseTcH uA eynopanoNeNNMit TAKTOBEIH PATHE 1 enoqummenmatit aHeraxronuti: putas. Merp — nonarue Goze ysKoe, oT- Mocamleecat ucKMOWHTemEHO K TAKTOBOMY puTuy. B coorsercrsii c oTHM Moppete 4actH conaT Baxa ja CKPHMKH COO comb MUNOP M JI MHHOP He aaxsnoualon B ceGe «meTpHMecKOTO PHTMAy, B OTAMNHE OT MepsEIX YACTe! cOHATEI AO MADKOP K MapTHTH MH Ma2kop'. Merp Monker OGosnawars TaIOKe OAMHHUHBSI BAN eMeTPHYECKOTO PHTMAS: TAK, HRTPUMEP, MALTEMANZA, 2H- PAH TABOT CYT TPH PABAINHENIX THMA MoTpA. PuTMAKA— UMEpOKOe Hows ‘rue yuenua 0 pHtMe, MerpHka — yakoe NOHsTHE YUEHHS O MeTPHUECKOM pare. ‘Mut Ges uaqoOHocrst yenoncuusu 6x1 cnow paory, ecnm Gut cram pac- cemaTpubarh KaaKayio 19 oTHx KaTeropwii » oraeaLuocTH. Kare nM pasaH4HO x TeoperHuecKoe HCTONKOBAHHe, B AKKROH MySHIKAMBHO MpARTHKE ON we ory? Gurr HeKyecrbenHo pacnenenis. A npeseraewan paGora cranuT mpascruueckste npoGmemur no Tany yra. Buenwe namero ceprua H sbixanine exyskan 1OKaaTeECTBOM TOrO, ¥TO PHIM HeHAUANLEO HpHCyIy venoneeckoMy opranueuy. Bonk orn’ xRe ymin ocymecTamorea B Napyurenue pHTMa, To MpHxomHTCH ZYMaTb 0 Gonesum aM AyuIeBHOM paccTpolicrBe. Xonb6a x Ger TarixKe noAMANeHLE BaKOHAM PUTMA, K3NCCh APHTMHA MOaKET ORITS CHMTTOMOM Gomtesmt — HH onsauenma. B ayauiice pur apseTes HepsopoAMnM oneMeHTOM, HaxoAs- TOWN OTHE B KAKO skGHBOM cyMecTAe. MesIOnHO ¢ XapaKTePHBIM, OCT- PbIM puTMoM Mo%HO yoHATL, AaDKe ecw ee DOCTPOKABECTHT ORMINM zu sorerykapanwen >. Tlogvepkuyras purmwHocrs cpoiiersena napoguoit mysuiKe, Mur ROCHPHHUMAeM PHAM KALIMMM HYBCTRAMH, MBL Mo2KeM ero CHMIUIAT, Rit Fore, OMMATS MycKynAMM Texa, OqNOOOpAgHEIH, HoHOMeHTTEN Ha jE TeNbHOM IpoTsKeHNGE PHTM AelicTaYer YeRINAIRON|e, TOITOMY PHTHTIeC- Koe pasHooGpasie ZOMKHO YAHTEIBATECK MPH CocTaBAeRMM KONLepTHO mporpasant. He cenyer cmemmmsars puma c maxmon. Taxrosaa vepra wate Bcero cay:kuT NOMexoit 4A BuiaBNERHA PHTMHUECKOrO HaTANA (BHOCHeRCTRMA Mar 3 oToM yBeaumen). Car naraaziuim o6pasom (s mpamom cutsieste copa) pasmuuie Merk Ay TAKTOM H puTMOM mposBaaeTcs y AMpu>Xepos. Hexoropsle Ha HUX 1O- Bombersyiorea Tem, 470 oTuersuBO DoCMpOUSBOAAT ABEKeHLA, COOTBETCT- syloule mpeanucaxuomy taxrosomy pasmepy. [[pyrae ucnomssywor ‘TARTHPOBAHMe JIMLNG KAK cpeneTs0 YupaDseuHA OpKecTpoM, crpemace pele neero neperars (e MOMOITsIO AMPHOKepCKOrO 2ecTa 1 NCIMIEICH) MponHaannoe 2KHBEIM PHTMON TeHEHHe MYDKIKATEHOM MBICTI. This puaBneHa Merpa (Tak 2ke KAK M puTMa) peLIMOMjee SHAYEHHE umeeT noRwepKupanie aByKa (axuest). O6a 9TH NONATHA ZO HaBeCTHO! creneHH mAeHTHTIHEL, XOTA B OOMXOAHOM PeUH MYDKIKA:ITOD TOR AKMeHTOM HonpayMepaeren ycuzennoe nonvepKunanne. MysbixasHam HayKa pas- Jurvaet MATE amgOB aKKeHTa: MerpHuecKsi, PHTMMNECKHA, AMHAMETEC- kuti, arormuecknit m narerHaeckitit. Merpuveckstit aknieHT ooHaNaeT BEIZETeHMe CILIBHOTO BpeMOHH TaxKTa 10 epaBiteniio co cxaGsiM, CKOpee MBIC-ICHHOC, HEM peaTBHO BLITONAseMOe. 26 OGmne oxemenrat wyauKaaeHoro Nenoamenus B actHocTH, HM pM KaKHx OGcTosTeMeTBAX He ZomKeH OxiTe caLmuIEH eTpHeckail akneHT, NpHXORAMMics Ha CHTLMyIO OMI TAKTA B CHEKO- ne’. Ho MB ApyrHx OTHOMIOHMAX MeTpHYecKUit aKHeHT, OMyTHMMI HA CAYX, MPHHAAIOKUT K HHCAY AYPHBIX MPHBEIEK, HcKMOTAIOMINX caoGORy erTepNPeTALI, CKOBBIBAIOLINX ¢pAITASINO H e¢ CHMBOA — tempo rubato*. B WeKoTopMIx csyUARX 97a NPUBKUKA NposIMLAETEA AaDKe apuTETEHO, Ha "IpHMep Y AUpIDHepOR, OTMeIAIONINX BCC CHLUTbIKIC NOAH TaITOB ABH>KeR- Purmuvecksi axnenr oanavaer nepHoawieckH nosTopeHHoe, CHO OmyTHMOe Ha CAYX MOAYEDKEBANHE sByKa, HEOGXOAMMOE JIA OTHeTIINBOTO OCHDKATHS PHTMHYeCKHX PPYNMMpOBOK: 2 Seam Berzonn, Konaepe I ‘Yeunenunik prrmnaeckuik axnent (aanpHMep, pH BMIACAEHEH HepBO; erBepnit B BasIKCOBOM puTMe) npousHORUT Go.tee GuaronpMaTHoe BTewAT- neHMe, NeM CTapaTeabHO BINOMHeHEEI MeTpHYeCKHMIt AKIeHT, Boerza OT- avout mosperBoM. Tbmannveckwit aknent osuadaer namepentoe yonaeuue aByKa, ne oBycnonmentioe purMHecKoi mu Merpuveckoll crpyKTYpO: Arormueckui axyertr, uacto oSosuadaenstit 4, sacayscsaer Gostee 110- ApoBioro paccuorpensia. Camniit TepMHM earorsikay 40 HocneaHerO Bpe- MeHit Guia HanecTeH TOKO MYSKIKAHTam, sHaxoMBIM c TpyaMMt PHMAHA. Tlocaeauudt nox arormkoi nonMMAeT MORMDMKaNMO Tewna, OcyulecTBLIA- emyio raaBHEIM o6pagom MyTeM HeGONBMIOTO YAAMHEHH SBYKOB BO BpeMe- x (2 OnAHUHe oF AHHAMIEKH, osHAvAFOMIe HIMeHeHHA rpomKocTH). ATO- Paka caMiIM HAPIZANLIM OOpasoM BMABIAETeA MPH McrOmHeHMH tempo rubato, Dro necbMa YAawHo HaiizenHoe oGosHAveHMe, KOTOPOFO HaM JO cHX Nop wexocrapaxo B MYaLIKaxLUo# Tepunonoram. Arorsueckuit axctieHT, CoorRetermeHHO, OSHAUAET RLIAENEHHE 3BYKA NYTEM YRETHNEHHE ero pO ‘TaxKenxocr#: “2KET Conyrcrsosars eqHHHNHOMY OBYKY HA HECKOALEIM ABykAM, CzIeAYIOUINN AYE 3a xpyrom. Ou MooKer MpuiiTAce Kax Ha CHLTBHOE, TAK H Ha cnAGOe Bpe- Ma TaKra, Ha TepBy.o WIM ocaeAMIOI HOTY B pUTMMYECKOM durype. Ero XapaKTep oupeseaseTcs HeupeBUReHHOCTEIO, HCKIOUHTENBHOCTHIO, RAS XOROM 3a npenestst OGuIUOTO® **. Sto Mevepmnimatouiee onpeseneume cneayeT ROMOMHICTS OAHOI AMIE ‘oronopKoii: xora nareTHYeckHit AKICHT M He NOAUMHEH MPARETAM, BOE *Ke ero npuMenexue ne Jono BeTyNATs B UpoTHBOpeIKe ¢ REINNeARNOH AH ‘TembHoctbi0 Hor. Tlastee msi paccmorpam re oGosHaeHHs HOTHOTO TexeTa, KoTOpLIe rpa- wieckn oroSpaxaiot wieneKus, npHcyue MyamkarsHoit dopme. K Hus OTHocaTes mperkye ucero Taxrouad Yepta (B TOM uHoTe ABofuAd), mHTa uM nesypa. ‘Hasuavenue raxronoit veprst — neat myaukamummail reKcT Ha pas- HomepHste, o6ycroaqenHBie TAKTOBIM PASMePOM eAUMMNM BpeMeHK M BbinBAATL cHEHEe oMH, KOTOPKIM OHA MpeamecTayer. Ke Mo2tO (CPABHHTS C HAYANOM CTPOKH B CTHXOTHOPCHMH, HO KAK B ODUM, TAK Hp wyshike ona ne ucera cosnasaer ¢ HavanoM MpeAAO2eHHA HH hPa abi, Tonooureauuas posts raxTORON YepTMK MPOABAAETOR PAABHEIM O6Pa- 20m B Havambnom o6yxeHHH, Bes HOMOUIM TaXTOBOH veprit HauNHaIoULL Mysbikax? spaq aM Buysusics Gut cueTy. Ho KOrAa TPYAKOCTH TAKTOROTO ReaenHA npeonomeNM, KOTAA YWEHHK HAWEHAeT HORUMATS, YTO FPA MenocrHoh MysukaAKHON hpaski He YRAAALMAIOTeR B :KeCTKME PANIIT Taxta, — c oTOTO BpeMeHM TaxTOBAR YepTa OGpaayer nenHuaiimIee npe- RaTcTBHe OpMUPOBAHMI HABLIKOR oCMMICMeNHOrO MNTORMpOBAREA. * Mono G20 Gu rare oGosumsurs a7or aKiLeHT Kax enommnveciens, ¢xpancarae- catle mam exyzerauremitulls, » cooTaerersu © epenaell peamMMhix SMOLNOEA *¥ M, Lusay. Trait de Vexpression musicale. Paris, 1873. 28 Ouue aaementss mysuKaaLworo Menoauenss OcoSenHo mesopHenTHpyer HAraaAHO BoCHPHRHMAEMOE PadrenciIMe 9a- ‘zaKra H OnOpHOl Aon: PeGenox AoxxKoH HayHNTE dyHKKHH TAXTOROH “epTEI, aprHeTy NpeA- cron ee mpeononers. Hexoropite coppemenmne KomsiosHTopat minnyT +GecTakTORyIO® My2uI- ky, MALTe ncero 1a comepyioujero HHcTpy esra Gea componorsnenus". Kos ake MpousBeneNHe HaMcaHO Ast ABYX H Ooxlee HHCTPYMeHTOR, TO TAKTORAA ‘uepra neoGxoqume ax cpereTBo naauMonoHHMaHiis. Keaprerizize x 76M 60- sie opxectponire peneruiytn «Gecrarcropoil» MYabIKH OAUTH Git 10M 2:9 HO ilonnureneli, Mower Guim, n GyayuleM Taxtonad epra 6yner samexetta APY- ruin, Goztee orpewasoUIHM MYSEIKAIEHOMY CMBLCTY OFoaHAYEHHEM? ‘Tam nepeqaax prrmaieckoit erpykTypst H NpaRMABHOMk axHeNTyaNIT ropaago Gonee cyutecrnenMyio pox» Mrpaor dau maxima, Pasnuwaior cumanie caa6ste nom. B rare na 2/, 1 9/g » Gxierpom ABMDKEMUN CHET «pas» NPHXOMNTCH HA CHITBHYIO ONO, CHET «BAY — HA ccnaby0. B npexgomunom naire (8/g wnt 9/,) nepnax fora cunsiad, sropad uxperss — caabie. Taxr, yoxopHo noxpasfenseusti a qua NoMyTAKTA, AgeT HAM RONOR- Unrensmne cutbune m cnaGire gom. B racre na 4/4 wn 2/, (4/.) » Mex- Acton ABIOKeHHM MepBA M TPeTKA AOI — CHIRHMe, BrOpAR ¥ YeTBEp- as — cnabsre, 0 py 1. nau Berxonn. Kasprer op 59 861.1Taanal _ Sana Berson, Kaaprer op. $9 1.115, Bnevetamouutit npuMep sapHcHMocTH axneHTHpoBKK OT pHTMHKH (e npunenenmi « memmune AuuTemHocTAM) MpencTaBaser coboH dburypa nun coxmpyiomell expan n Larghetto 6erxonexcxoro konuepra: Yepecuyp pasoMepnoe u mponomkuTeMKHOe HORYepKMBANHe, Janke ecat OKO BILOAKe COrmacyeTca ¢ NPABHAAMH MYSKIKAHHON AexTaMAN, ACPO BEIKIBRET OMIYINCHHe MOMOTOMHOCTH, HOmBepraomee BANMANHE cayniareneit cepheaHOMy HemMTaHIN0. Baupumepe 13 nocroaHuoe axientaposanue nepsoli, Tperselt w natoit RocLMOl YTOMARET CIIYX, MEXKAY TEM KEK BLIeMEHMe CAMOTO BBICOKOTO SRYKAB KEKAOM RICXORALEM H BOCKOANLeM MOTsTBe coobuLaeT BoeMY ST R0RY EPOMAHYTO CHAY SMONMOHALTS:OTO MOABEMA — CTOBHO rHrABTH Mepe- Spactieaiores oGaomamx cKa: 1, Byabe. Kowuepe x B ~ Boo6tre xevsMennas, nonropaexan wepes paniiste MpoMoncyTk:H BpeNe- HM AKUeRTUOBKA CrAHOBHTER TeM HeBKINOCHMee, JEM MeMBUNe HeAKEHTH- POBAHHBIX aBYKOB PacHlomaratorea meaedy aKieHTApOBARHEINH. 30 Om ameMenTH MyaMIKAIsHOTO MenOAMeNIH Tosropmomueca sBysu onMnAaKopoll BuIcoTs same Acero TPeByior He- oToporo HloqvepKHBaHHs, HesABHICHMO OT PACHOMONKCEHHS! CHALULX H ea- Gusx Zonelt B Taxre. Jlannam saKOHOMepHOCTs OCOGEHHO HArTAINHO BLABILA- eres B MYSHIKe, ocHoDaitioii 1a pure uemanexoit xaGanepss: “ ‘9. lago, Henanexas exon 1. Brawre na 6/g nceraa nazuvecrsyer aByaoabHol purn: ', Tharamons, Kanpne 20 ‘Tpexaoxbuomy purmy coorsercrayer raxr 1a 3/4. 16 BeALMonapr Komepr 41 B xanepxoit mystixe coveranue qpyx- muGo erstpexjoasHoro parma c rpexaombHKIN IPHBOAMT K KapepsHEIM (1.1m ueTOMEITTeTe!) KOMOHHALAM: 1. Bpame. Contra 09.78.16. 1 Pesos satTaanal (Crona ornocutea nax:ke nempetaiomeees Horna ConMeLIeHKe TATA HA 3/g.¢ tpexaombtinim pHTMOM, YaIOnCeHMEIN B jIBa TaNCTA: ‘A. Dopaat. Komepr I 1" Qmeck KoMnositop ACHO BLIpAGHA CROM HAMEpeHNS ¢ HOMOLTSO Mr 1 coornerctaesHoli rpyniupomxst Hor (10 YeTBipe Ha oAHO! BABKC). OGosuaxenus au? RonyeKaI07 PasauuHoe ueTORKOBARMe. Jura MoxeT Guus nousTa KaK bpasupoBowiad, 70 ecrs ompenenMOMaR rpaHHUb MYSLI- kambnok past, nance, Kax aprnkyasusonnad, Coonavaouan Wienenve BRYTPH pasts, aan Berzonen.Kaapre op. $9 382.1V, aoe n OGmue oxemeonrat myauxaasuoro nenoameunn B npexsiqymux mpumepax mrpuxoniie 1urH lo Heo6xonMMocrH UpH- uO? eneayIouNAit Bux: w upHmepe 20 — no Ba TaxcTa (npHOAMsHTeTS- Ho) Ha OAHO ADIDKEHHE caITKA; B MpHMepe 21 — porte => — no naGeakanne Hempeauamepentoro axienra, BosHMKAaIoMero MPH HeMO7s- Donaitit HeNOTO CMILUKA Ha aByKe, PeAMeCTRyIONIeM citHKoMe (¢f); BMD mepe 22 — nOcKOABKY aBTOPCKMe MITpHXH stece KpaliHe ¢neckpHMHIES. 'B ponpocax npowrenuis THT TouKu apeHMa cxpultAvell M MHasECTOR Cy- mectReHHBIM OGpasom pacxonstes. Han Hac Baxxelityi mpoGmeny co- (crannaior Emeril CMLIHA. Pacomanpitbark UIApOKOOXBATHBIe pasi1poH0" Hire KPH B 060M cny'uae Kak OGoaHayeNMS ITpHXOR OsisI0 Out, Ha Moi BaPaAA, MPOABAEHMEM -OaKIOTO aprueTUYecKOrO caMomoOua. BracKwna- ie MitoxectRa yMTesIsHOCTeH B OHO ABHUKeHNe CMBIUKA HeMa6ENHO BNe- ‘er aa coboli novepwo cwim sByka, BexencTBue ero BeLYIAN cKpHTNTEAA Hapriia oTTecaseTes Ha 2aj1HUtL TIAN 110 OTHOUIEHIHO K COMPORONK AION ‘ee HILCTPYMeHTAM; OTHM CTaDHTCS MOA yrposy NpaBMsIBHLAT aByKonOH: Ba- ‘Aue H, eneROBATENLHO, sHeHOCTE (pasMpoBKH. TlooTOMy HOTHEIE MARANA, pocnpOHSROAAIMMe OPHIMMALILIA TeKCT u YoHAMeHHEIe CREpXATMHHLIMIT aniraNi, a Takske PeTARIGH, KoTOpHE Ha 6YMATe RAINIAAAT BeCEMA «MYSBI- KANBHEIMH®, HO, TAK cKagaTb, GoxTeA cBeTa paMIIB,— KOKHBI 61TH pH SHAIEMT HETOAHMIMM ALIA MpakTHMECKOrO HeHOMLSORAMUA. Tpauaruii » 3. rome cxpumtnoit ukomst Moaxwa ~ Mosepa coco6 oGosauenua, coxpanmouait >pRSKPOROWHME M APTHKYAANHONEBIE AATH opirinaza, ¢ AoSanneHHeM K HMN IITPHXODMIX ykasamuti (Mu V), ABET 4 ee, EP EE wt F v KAK YRAagaHMe UITpHXA, NpeaMMctnasoMee daxTHYECKHA cmoco6 HeTON- 2 eaun Berson. Kaaprer op. 74.1%. & = Saerae Ca Lo ch 32 cH Hanaysianm peuieniem mpoGeMal H BasT muoi sa oGpasel, BO MHOTEX Peaaxauiax, oneTAHHEIX B DaaHOe BpeMs. DrOT coco ocTaBAKeT B_HenpH- KocuonenocTH oGosiauenins, HenlocpercTmenno orparkaroulte xy orKec Dene RaMepeHHA KoMMOSHTOpA, H OAHOBPEMeHHO oTsCUACT TpeOoBANH- 3M, BRITeRAIONIME HE NpAKTHYECKHX youOBIEH nyGrNHOTO KenOANEHHA. * Tlonsansanaeen wa nponaatenna cronerita pexaKigit OxHHX H Tex Je MPOHDBEAe- Deni, nex mpenHito, OckOSLIBATHCL Ho Ha OPMrHNANLMON TeKETe, a ma panier HaARIHAX. Spaorxax. B peayctsrare Mao #70 COxpAMILIOS MS ABTOPCKNE YRABAIIE. 33Tanna Teaypa cayxut yqo6ueim cpeacTsom Aza menpHMeTHOrO pasrpaniie- nua Myanikaxninix pas. Baecte c Tem Ona Hepeno TPHMEHAeTER Kalk oGosHauenme noAMepKHyTO! Aoprnaysst (ocoGeHHO y Perepa), 4ro AaeT nO- os JL48 npeEpArHA TORKOBAHNA. ‘Tax nassimaemad «sarenaqkar — npenaoosennoe I. Purmaxion ofoaHe- enHe b Be MANeHBKOH NEpTHKATRNOR uA, KOTOPLIM OM HOLIyeTCA aa wnenexa pas (8 TOM Hose H eHympu dpaaxponoMoH sur), — ADA eres nechwa npaKriTuiki HenoMoraTenbitNe epexeraoM. HO wate Heaypa, ‘Tak M 3aKnagKa conepyat B cebe HeraTHBHEI MomeHT (HMeR B BHZY HX ‘uavtene aid MenomMTenA-npaseriika, a He AAA TeopeTHIeA HAM YuAneTO- ca). OnM B ManectHOi Mepe Heperpy2KalOT SPHTCAAY!O NAMAT H IPH ETpe auiayetb cBOUM ¢ckpLITHIM NPHCYTCTBHeM» B KaAgOBLIX HalLeTo COURARNA OGypKnsOT K HpeyReMHMeHHOMY, MIKOAApeKOMY wieweHH pan. Mx er- Me aayHTb, Wem eOTyauTseH» OF HIEE, 70 CCTH HO BAADAAT HX B HBOS anyuannn. Jhrano mpegnowrraio neaypy B aRAe eaBORHOH aaKaRKit> (//) ans obootavenx nepepsiae » aByvasn (mogmaayass), a upocTy%0 3 Kaaqky (/) — Kak SHAK CKOpee MEICMEHHOTO, 4M PeANEHO BEITIOTHAeMOTO pasrpamiienna. ‘Tleaypa npescranaser coGoit uaxGoxee pembedimuit enoco6 wrexenns ¢ppasti na cocrasuiie vactu. Jhodpriaysa He ABAReTCA HeTIpeMeHHHIM cren- eruwem eaypu; BkYunnre nna AMNANACUeCKE odpexr, THIIA BHeaarHO- ro forte unm piano, mm60 neomugannan MORYAAUMA TAKE MOCYT CAYRETS epeqerwoM paarpanutiensi orgenumux sneruen NENOIeCKOH MMI: “ ean Bersonen. Kanprer op. 18861 I B npmpogumom suxe orpsinke Heomuqanntsit mepexon 3 MH MHOpA B cH-GoMoms Maxkop Byer HaHtGonee neTATATIONEA OOPAZOM NOREPREYT MocpeqcrBom ewextst erpyx H BuesanHoro piano. 1. . Bax, Cour e-mail. It. Buavenne ueayp Ana noxMManua MysuKer Tem cymecTBeHHee, WeM Me~ Hee HacKIIIeHA wHOrorosocHad (baxTypa NpoUsBeReHHA, B OcOGEHHOCTH 28 a4 Oomue sr0Menrat myaukaaiuore Menoamenns 11 onworonocHNx conmnesnit, mcnomaemsIx Gea conponoaxnenita. Bene- AylONeM NPHNepe MPABHADHOe NOHUNAR:Ze TAPMOHHCIeCKOR CTPYkTYpH, 2 YemOBMAX OANOTOIOCHOTO MaAOAeHHs TOstHOCTHIO COBMAMAIOMIE C MeO: JUMeCKOH, HacTonTemuo Tpedyer prBHeceHHA Heayp. Ho ONN He BeerAa Zonta Ostzb BocrpHAM Maem xaK Tlepepere aBywanN (//), wTO HeMDOem no HpHex0 Os x ApoOKONMO H HOMOABNOHMIO HenOTO. Bo MHOTHX Cny¥astx OcTATOWHO Guinaer PaSrpAHMWEHNA, BEVEpeHHe OcOaKANHOTO HENO.IITE- ZneM, Ho HesaMernoro ans earymareneit(/). 1. C. Bax Ansenan i Bropot nape (Pen Kuen) = teas, ‘ K snemy nzoxax mpusuivex, cpolicrsemmix Wenommure ss a cxBre- OBEIX HHCTPYMeHTAX, OTHOCATCA epstaLIBaIOUIe portamenti Ha wecre pas- ensIOHx Kesyp: a» ‘Mu nacronreasuo mpeqocreperaem or saoynorpeGnenua nesypanst, BHITOAHSIeMEINE B BHJe Jogyriays. Jro TaKen0e opyaue pasuponosnoH TOXHHKH MOKET MPHMCHATECA C NOAHMIM OCHOBANHEM AML TOFAA, Kora Aunaoreckie KIM ATOrHIeCKHe cpenerBAY OKAgHIBRIOTCR HeAOCTATOUEL- Mit na mepeqain rapMoumecxuit, MoRYAANOHHOM, PUTMUYeCKO! Wt Meonuseckoit erpyxtypst upousnenenua. Tak, Ha MOM BITNAA, MpHAKI a nexoropurx cKpanaselt npeasapars modrnaysoll BcTyIIEHMe MsIH BOS Bpaujenue Temtr MpormpopesuT ecrecrBeHHOMy TeveHMIO MySKIKAALHOR Muremn. » 1. Gamoncent. Kou. Teopus yaur, wo Hayao MoTuBA B onpeneseHHO!t Mepe TpeGyer crie- Uxaxpuoro muapeenua. Lux cxpanuynok urper stor npHAIN B MSBeCT- 3sPaazal ‘oll crentenst coxpaniner cpoe swavent, xoTs OH expee Hero HexORI Hs Mpupomst enanimax macrpysenron (awed B Muay nocTeneNmoe yracestte snyxa, surainaomee neo6xommmocTs yeuenof ero araxn). Bee ae rma ‘cxpamxe wavaxo worsina Aos>KHO Garr DocMpoHaseneHo c nocTaTOMNOH OF ‘Netannoctsio; a nepenone Ha cxpmniamssth sank 9T0 OanaUAeT anacTHIHOE, eecboxt0e or myosirx mpuapykon npmnowenue canraxa x erpyute. Bnpo- sen, eipamasi ne acersa oraaioT ceGe oTver B Tost, WT HNeMo cnenyeT cantar navaox motisa, Tax nampwep, ¥ expanavell, uayasomix 3 07- enunocrH Kawmyi0 sapuasuino GaxoscKoR HaxoE, pH opTopeHAX 10- ‘crommso easamaren: Dra camriocrh MyaukamhiKx HoctpoenHit euje HarnagHee mutpaxera 8 Cmuauane no 1-H conaret: % oe “Hrro sgect narxuee — nepxnmit uM HHDKHMI Fone, OKORYaHHe npeAI- Ayurelt wan savao onoit pasts? Orver Ha stor nonpoc Moaker Ghith pea SAWHEIM, B SanHeHMOCTH OT BKYca MenoAMMTeNs. JIHIHO # HEpAIO jet = ‘eMorpa 0 Tomy, uo # cunTaro Goce BaZkKHEIM — Haviano mam Komen pasts. Tpaicrsuan axyentyanss Bo MHOTOM OnpenenseTes TAK HAIKIBAEMIA- NaH MYZKCKHDEEE HU KENCKHMH OKORWANMAMN (pas. MyDxcKEM HagbRaeTes OkoNdaHMe Ha CHAGHOH, aKOHCKM — Ha cxaOolk Aone TaKTA. eMONTSI MYDKIRAASWOrO MeHonMeRRA 36 A. nan Berson, Konzept SSS —— pret a ©. Measemcon Komepe Ila, SFr" Aannoe passarme ocoGento BarkHo AAA ckpunawa, NOCKONBKY OHO CBs saH0 ¢ HeOGxoAMMOCTHIO yeueHHA HAM OcnaGueNNA aByeHocTH. B9TOM OT- MoLIeNHH samevaetea HeMao norpemtuocteil. Bo BeAKOM Cayuae HeHCKIN = jowKen nocrosHHo conyreraonaTs mane decrescendo. Tlopoit max nerpeaeNca c yKasanMaMat HapowuTO «HenpABHTBHO‘i® Ax- Neurmpouiu Ha cxaGuix Ronax TaxTa, YoumHRAIOUIelk PHTMATYECKyIO OCTPO- ‘Ty. Takwe ofosuaienua ocobento waeTat B npoamenennax Bueraita. A. Bedran. Keung Ne $ Dror mpeuamepennisit casnr, cpepmaemmsit Manepexop npansiaaEiN MerpopurmmuecKHM cxeMaM, TpeOyeT O7 HCHOAHMTENA BACOKOH crerienH BiateHiA TexHMKoH cmatuxa H ruGKOR PuTMAECKOM MpHeTOCOOsILeMOCTHL (nocaennee ormocutes Take K axxonmanuaTopy). B negarorueckon Uxaxe qannusi npem npexcransser cobalt emul w peceMa TpyzHeti a ‘Tepuas aaa ynpaxnenti. AxueHTH B MPHHIMME BLINOANAOTEA ADEKOHHEM CMAINKA BHD, TAX ax Onaroqapa yseuvenm0 cobcTBeNHOTO RecA CMBIYKA BODEUKAET NOON Murenbmait peseps cum. Jammu mpuniyam umeer Gosbmoe ataxenne pH miaGope mmrpHxoR. 37” ES ev v on —— . & a Hexmouenne npencrasxsiot co6ok Koporkue urypit Gzecrauiero snoserioros xapaxrepa, aakmouaemmte naysoi, HIM MpOTsDKOHHLIe BBYEH B BLICOKOM PerHeTpe, {UIA KOTOPEIX ATAKA B KOH- ne cMsIaKa npencraaaetca Gonee nanexHoil. 3. Babs sBaun-ewe, 83 e Typxoit maxepoh xansercs axuentaponanne saraxra (na cxaGolt 10- ze), aK oro ocoBeHHO YACTO CAYUAeTCA IPH HcHOAMEHHM epBLIX TAKTOR ouepta Mengemscona (aeuay OGosnavenus alla breve savaxr oGpasyerca yoke Ha sropoii nomosuxe TaKra). 38 OGuue saemenrst myauKasrxore emoxmenKa ©, Mennemcon Kom. a eee =f BaraKT MomeT conponON AATEC AMUN HeSHATUTEBHGIM YeuAeHHEM BYKA, BUIABIAOMINM HAYA MOTHBA, HO OHO HO BCAKOM Cx1YIAE HOMO 6s17s copaaMepeno ¢ moquepKUnatiuem cHsTLHOK AONM, OGocHORASEAIM ¢ Me- ‘Tpuveckol x pHTMHveckoit towkH apenua. Cuexyer, KOneYHO, yaTEIDATS, ‘ufo MpH CMeNe KOPOTKUX H NpOTaeMELX LITPHXOB, BSINONNAEMEEK NE MH CNBIKaMG, UpesBetvaiino TPyAHO uSGE2ATE AKMIEHTA B TOM CmyURE, eC- {NH KopoTEMi HrTpux NpHXoRHTEH Ha cxAByIO ROO TAKTA, BLIXOR Hs 1OsO- ken YkasniBaer uiDKecneayIoMNEH NpAMep. “6 2 Szece cHamsHas noxa HA TpeTbeit veTReprH TaKTa BepeTo noRtepKityTo rpoMKo, BexeneTaMe ero HenpaBoMepHIsi aKHeHT Ha BrOpoit veTREpTH, B uspectHott Mepe cxpautsaerca. BooGuie, UpHYKHA HeMpaBIBHIX ax- ueHTOB y cKpHNaveH, KAK MpABHsIO, KpoeTeH He CTOABKO B HEROCTATKE MY- SKKAIBHOCTH, CKOTSKO B HepaIMOMANLHOM pachpereneHti CMEITIA, Pasaenbitiie MIrpiXx HA Tpex KOPOTKHX 3ByKAX, MCTOMHAEMBIX B KOH: Le cMAIYKA, HognostsOF HaBosKATL HeMpemHaMepentforo Yuen DY THO- emi, noomMRatomtere pH HenomAoBantMH HenoTo cunTeKa. B pursariecxos rpymne JJ) mpaviaeiian akctenryanun Guisact napy- lena 19-28 Toro, wo BOcbMAN 6 TOUKolt wrpacten BoeM cieBI"ICO3; B OTOM cayyae expunay aunysex0H «npoxeprupaTbs cMBTYOK ra mecrianmaroit 10 Kpaiineit mepe 0 ero cepenuini, robs! xsaTitn0 cabIeKa 21m Tperbelt Bocswolt, Taking o6paox nosuatiaer nowenuil axten? ta wecruaanaroi. Cnoco6 itcupannesus: 3/, emmuxa (pw eiDKeHNN BiH) Ha DOCEAEyIO CroaKof, 1/4 exam (B oGparHoN HaxipaBstent) Ha meeTHAAtaTyio, OCFA- Jomeca TOMCMATIRA — Ha HoeseAMOW BOCHMYIO.. B monime, cocronujet Ha AByx eauroBaMREIx seyKos ommuaKonott AAH- Tennwocrit, nepabill anyke Gepere yr} rpoxtwe, a BTOpOH — yrs THIIe "xopoue. 1c PHO, homme necKomEI TAKE MOTHEOR, COBEN uAcTO BerpeLatoTeH xpumraare upenopenenions Monapre 39Tana L Obmne otomentst myaukansHoro Menoamenna as BA Mouayr Korey ‘Mar, cxpumastt crapuiero NoxoNeHHA, PACCMATpHBAEM 9TO MpABHLTO xkax Metro camo coGol paoymesonteccs, m O7-AH'Me OF HALNHX MAARIIIX CO- Gparuen. Ouo nocupuntnro Ham or yunreneit — Moaxna, Tprona, Mac- capa, Jleoapa, Mapenka, Koropsie » e010 ovepems pour Koy BhI- gatomuxen cxpunavel Kowa XVII — navara XIX nexa — Pore, Kpelineps, Baio, Béwe, Bsérana, Gxmsiimx conpemenumxann veuKnx reraccHtRos m weMocpenoTmeHHo NepenaBADINKX HCTONIETeRLeKHe TPALH- uur Toit onoxis. ‘Bropoii canronauntl apyk nce ae ne posskeH ykKopasinaruen 2 naxoft crenenm, kare eon Goi Wax Hw GxL1a nocrannena Towa. Baecte ¢ Tes ne- OGxoauMO NocpedeTHOM exe aaMeTHO! NAYSH OTAEMETE oMEO NBIDKEMHE ewnnutea ov xpyroror eToMy ytMe BeeTO cooTRErcTByeT OGosHAWeHHe = *. Waxecr koppexive Henoaenue aancnr or Toxworo pacnpexexesEa cowsraice, Onopuomy anyy exeayer yaeaun. npuOraurensit0 8/4, Heomop- nowy —1/, noel wenoxnayeol mma Caria; Rese cMBITRA ta PaB- tiie wactm ue coagacr ecrecrBeHunrx yononnil AA BLIOMHEHNs TpedyeMo- ro diminuendo. Jaapuefinime npateput: Moxy ckpinaasy waaguiero nokoneHHs H HX npemuIecrseHHiKaMH, HaGmonaeres paste muenui 8 Bonpoce o6 oTZeeNHH sarasTa oT OnOp- Hore aya, «Crapmes neeraa Oyay? rpart exenyIOMEM O6PRIOM: * B or0m oTLOMeHHH oBpaaiom MomeT NOoAY:KIRTS MEMOMHERH ANAAOTHSIIX MOTH on wa bopremirano. JLen ruaxiicra eciierHes proporo emsrovaxoro oxyka oOasaTeA- tno, Eezut pm 970M nropoit auy coBnalaer nO nescoTe © HOCAAYOINM, 0 MEXARMSM C2- Moro merpyitenta nexaowner Best wo enoco6 MenOTNeNEA. ‘Boo6ime, ec sosmintaer coMHeHTe mo HOBORY CNOAHENNA KaKol-nEGo pas, 10- acon gate. curpars ee xopomeny nianiery wa cpoest MHCTpyMeHTe". 40 » 10 BDEMA KAK MonOReHED, He OSpemeKentiaa rpyson tpaamuutt, mpexmo- “iret, 1706 aaraxkr 669 acmKorO Kepepiiea nzMMAAICH B cxeRy OMI By. ‘Tpuoau sauacrywo urpaioren Repirracriio, TOM oMbteRe, TO KeDREA sayk Yaniuaetea, a apa nocseAyIontux ykopasaMnaIores (3 BNECTO ‘Tax, 20 nerynntrentaow nocrpoetm | sacra +Henancxok criudponns He: no mo%o KacTemsKo yemaimare: Cunnona obpasyetea nytem oSteaunenua mperurecrayiomed enaGoit OmH TaKTa ¢ pasHok eZ no qamremsHocTH cHaBHOH Zonet: ‘Eoxu oe cumuuas gona mpeauecrayer cna6oil, 70 TaKoe coeaHHeHMe He oGpasyer cuKomss. Cunxona n nonectiolt Mepe BuOCHT osleMenT paoao2KeNHa B pHTMaHEC- kyl ctpyxtypy, uapyuias npumsramie saxonomepuocrH. Oua miacrHo Mexay rem aknenTHponanie csursHbIx oxelt B cHHKOTI (Fe. B cepe- une, a ne p Havane ee) — BeebMa pacttpoctpaneHiias OMIKOKA. 530 vemaaanno SSS peo? HPOMCKOMUET OFTOFO, TO B HaAMTBHOM MepHOR OBy'eHH Henaror Tpeatchinaer YueNMKy akKexTHpORATE CHLAGHyTO ROO TAXTA B CHUKOTE, Nemo yxpendenua parma. aL‘Sra nenoMoreTembian MepA BILOCHeACTANM erKO epepacTaeT B pH BUIMKY; NpeXYHPERHTE ee MorKeT TOBKO CBOeBpeMeNHOe BMeMATENLCTEO neqarora, HO, K coxkaeHIO, ITO MOMeHT WACTO ynycKaeres. Tlowepxmnanue cnaGo% gomi B cuuKone MOmNO CuHTATE MpHSHAKOM purwieckoit kymtypu myaumanra*. J nn Bron. Kaare op. 741 treme, : v v fom sy Kanon » exuxonuponantiom pitrwe npeneranaser cool ros1opoa0NHyIO aanany. a s1m2.1¥« 1H. Bpane. Koaprer oot = eessetei Tlomows aneck Moxer miicnensatit (Ho He peammayemtill) axqenT Ha snepecrantenyloy (13-3a cHiKonE!) 0710 TaRTA, Sha ES Eon wasuo mioxkectao CHKKONMpoBAHHEIX HoT OAMHAKORO! jUNIt- ‘TemsHocT#, cReAyIOULNX APYT 3a APYTOM, HO He CBASAHHEIX JUTAMH, 70 OHH Om GLITE YeTKo PagneNeHbl (BITOTS No exe sAMETHLIX TAY’ Me%AY HHt- bi), Tax, KaK ecu Gor 9TO He GeLsM CHEKONB. B yexanonolt myauixe cHKONMpOBAHHMe PHTMGI PASBUAMCE 0 CAMIIX yenonknenmerx dopa. Tayaa oamaiaer nepepiie B apyaAHHH; ee gHaveHHe pacxpuipactes ‘TombKO B KOHTpacre K nocitesHemy. LpeBapmomue nayast, T. €, TAKHC, + Ha molt sara, omsrHoMy aNpuepy ne caezonaxo 6x pxnuMars 2 cool opxectp expunaia, xoropuil na nonbrasiisx axaieuTHpYer CHLISHYIO AONO 8 CHEKONE, TO CRIA: ‘Tennorayer o meyRonzevnopHTensHOM piTMNUeCHOM BOCEITAIa. 42 Oomue oxemeurat myonuansnoro nenoanenna oropsle mpezmecrayior nepnomy sayy sum axkopay, mMeior xuteto Mpax- quveckoe SHANeHHE; OF cHocOBCrByIOT TONOH! coMMecTHOM aTake BBVA, cneAyioWel 3a paMaXOM AApUNKepCKOH MAOH HAI 98 IHAKOM, AAHAIM pykonoanreem aucanGaa. [pyroe nexo — naysa m0 oKonamMa erIOmHe- Ira; OA Kae Ox Mpomtenaer ene a HecKonEico MrHOBEHIT SOPMALTEIO 98- pepumntsiiniter orexer spemenu, «Ilox06H0 ToNy, KaK nox Boazeliersnem [RDKIX CROTOBKIX MCTONHMKOR HAINM T1898, CCAM WX BHEDRIIHO BRKDHITS, JaanmuBaIOT KaK Ohi HerATHEBMBIH OTMEYATOK cnera, — npexpaTiAutiice Sayx Gombuoro AUHAMHYeCKOrO HeMOAHeHHA BLIDHIBAET HHTeMCHBHOS OMTY- Tieke THEME, eHesBy ann», apyrie caoBAMH — oMyITeRMe BBIpasH- reabuo# maysniv®, Eon Yaxony Baxa meperours aan opxecrpa, yo 9ToM cay¥ae AUpHeDY NPUILITOCS Ger MOKAMATS YeaoDHyIO Nayay Ha hepaoit werpeprn texra. ss eat Ho W Ana coaMcra nloseaHo orcwHTaTs B YMe NepRY}O YerREpTs ¢ TEM, ‘urobur acHo OcosHATS PHTMiMeCKYIO CTPYKTYBY TeMBI. Ha molt sarang, crenens MySbiKAmBHOCTH BO MHOrOM onpexeamereH yMenMeM OTcuMTEIBATS H BEIqepACIBATE Haysel. Korga, HANpHMeD, BAIA ze netynenua x «Tpucraity naystr ykopayunalores Ha Ape WAIN TPH BOCK- nix (Kak 970 crao OOMNMBIM B AMpHepCKOH MpaKTHKe NOCTeAHHX et), — sl socmpunnwawo 970 Kak mperpexiicHize NpoTHB pirrMa; MOAHOCTIIO NpOWAAAET BCH HApAKeHHOCTE 9TOTO MCTONMeHHOrO TocKK MoTHRA*. TLioxan mpusraxa, cocroamas a upeneOpexenuy K maysaM, ocoGeHHO JerKO H OXOTHO YCHANBACTEA YUCHIKAMH, He SATPYARATONIANH CEOs BAI (camTLinaNHeM nays po apes joMammux sanatuit. Tipit naysenwn cxpummuneix KonWepToS pexoMenayerca 8 nepepsinax comHolk naprim HaneBaTs Beayiauil TO.10¢ opKecTposoro tutti; oGuensBe- cTHo, 470 Ha DaHMelt cralHM PAGOTH YWEHHK sAYACTYIO SHAeT JUIITb CBOIO Maprino H He HMeeT NpencTaBeHUA 0 pousBeReHHH B etm. 99 Omen 1. Byawe. Komepu 1 sTleponepxanunies maysst apTOMATHeCKM Mepepacraior a dbepMarEs, OkaaMinaA TeM caMLIM paspyulAloUlee BosRelicTBMe Ha pHTWITECKyIO * H. Riemann. Lehrbuch des musikalische Phrasierung. Hamburg, 1884. ‘** B genmuocrisx rogex Jlamypé, wepuanuma cnoe auaxue Barsepa nenocpescrsento "9 Gaiipeirexax nero4MMKOR, oTewiTatnaN azect RoeLMUe ¢ ABCORTTHOR TONNOCTHID. 43Paane 1 cxpykrypy mponanegena. Oco6olt pasHoRMAHOCTHO MAYIM SBAeTCH TAK vagbIngeMan «ayaa YonexAs, 7. €. HCKYCCTREHHO BTMCHYTAA B MYSKICATE- yl THAN nlayas, HagHaueHNe KoTOpOl — mpenocranure cayimarenam Bpems ina annoaxtcmenton. C 9Toik Heablo mpouanombHo paccekaiores sac ‘TH wakzoR, nanpunep, I II wacru KonNepra Menaenscona, II x III wacrat xoayepta Yaiixosckoro — n yroay ayyiiuM yenexa BHpryonaM. Tiponomeurensuocrs GepMame: aeBMCHT B NepBy!o ovepene OT OCHOR- oro Temna npowanexeHits, BO BTOpytO — OF BLIpAIKeHHOTO B MYIMKKe HACT- poeuma. HenoaMorkito, KOHeYHO, © MaTeMATIMeCKOIt ToNHOCTEIO ompene- sure rpanunst depuari. B xavectse o6ujero mpasnata MmoxHo PeKoMensonaTh yqMOeKHe OGoaHATEHHOM ATMTEABHOCTH BBYEA, A AAA OIC- "Tphix Teo — Aaxxe yrpoente. 6 oq, “EN Beramnen. Conran. 96.1 B orom mpnmepe epmara ckpunaya m0 tpaquuun aniqepsxunaeres TORBKO 10 HAvAIA ABHACHNA TPHALATSBTOpHIMH B NaprHA Hopremano. ‘Yepecuyp mpogonxuTembHas epMATA BHIKIBAGT PACXONAAKIABAIOMee CHy- marens OMLyieHMe mpenHaMepeHHocTH, HapouMTOCTH, & NOpolt Aazwe Npo- anomie 1omopucritueckui sdypexr*. ean Berson, Coma p-47- 11 Baeck dbepmary wame Boero mepexepyuBAIOT, BaGnIBAR O6 OCHOBHOM rene neeit act — Presto! B kagennuax, rae w OTHOIeHHM Kak OcHOBHOTO TeMMA, TAK M AmMTeTE- OCTH OTAeMBHBIX sByKOB AonycTuMa GbmbuIaM cBoGona, Maysi m epMarEt TaKoke MOryT GHTE HCTONKOBAITM PaaaHHHIM O6PAIOM. ‘A. Budvan,Konuepr Ne 4. Seca eee * Ga noeueaNee wpeMn craxo OFAN SDeROM MPH NEpexgRAHAN KamaraNDEr mpowaweesth ckpumnenod xwreparypH! (KaripuNep, Kouueptos pence, Bpyxa xp.) IMpowanomtxo oGoanavars 9 aorex Qepuark 8 Tex cayeaax, Kone TpeGyeren HeaHAtN- ‘rexsuoe yszmmuese a9yxa. Sra wasepa rosa Gurr, BsyeAdnL, OTReprHy?A, XOTA OAL [Ya NOvONY, #70 owe YkaskiDAeT ROpory AADuUeHiMMN MEKAAKEMNAM TEKCTE, “4 O6mue onewenrst wysmKaapnoro Nenoauonns 4s Bysemmveckow nenonnennn orm hepwars, KAK nano, nenonepama- vores. Ho wens maanavenne ranent ¢ Ranaut nop 870M w cocron, rob PEpater le bourgeois oman exonav-— micrasaaT» Hanonaa textaree xe pYaWoorH m npeokonenats nx ay seemTo NyOAMKH (7 eors No CNG Cany noaByncuare nirepee Resresnoeriso nnsteno aopaseay. HoH aye ssetores oom, epi yeranonsettnte npania, Tpertae aeer01eoGx0RNM0 nocte yassnoro ienoamenun kaxcoro-anoo ronovonomoro aaectena Pen, cranirrexymiaveno aoerarowo ppewett 28 Tor, «TOO ot Mor Hepes tynctpo yantzesnen; Seenpepuinno saopachisan nyGaty mupeyoaHan Ne {kavecau,slesommurrent picxyer shisnersy nee upecaatenic, Bunaor, oak, enyuam, KOraa naysy Olpesencuuo ne enenyer Di separ faint 7 S22 Beam expumay cvasier xo6poconeerno orewmrupars maysy, npena KoTo- poit ncweaaetca KaKoli-unGyA ecnTo; noxelt ceKyHAL, OH Byer NoCTO- ‘HHO ONROAMBATS, OpnamentaKa B xazseit pabore opnamenraxe orneqeno Gonbure MecTa, vem 970 MoxeT RokasaTbom HeoGXOAUMBIM, YUHTHIBES C0 HO CTOME Yok SHAUHTEALHYIO Porte D apeenaxe mupasutenbusIx cpercra MyaMich. Ipmunna Kpoeres B TOM, ‘ro ora wnrepectelimas, 8 BLicuIeit cTeneHM Moy"HTembiA PnanA MYaLI- KanbHoii TeopHmH coneputeHHo HesenoMa OosbUIHCTAY cKpHnadelt. Mei Tem umeeren Kanuramunit rpya A. Beltustara «OpiamenTaka B MY3bI- Kes**, B KOTOPOM HaraAAHO H OOCTOATENBHO MOKASAHA HCTOPEA PRAMiETHA heex Bugon yKpamtennil. Suaxomcrno ¢ oTo¥ pAGOTO! HeOBKORUMO KA KO- My oBpasopanniomy MysuiKanTy, OcOGeHHO ecxIH yueCT® To OBeTosTENTsCTEO, ‘STO B HamIe BpeMa AIA YeOHLIX Nene MPHMCHAMOTeH HCKMOUETENbHO O6- PaGoTKu HAM 3aHOBO OTPeAAICTHPORAHHKIC HIAAHH CTAPHHALIX cOvUHE- ii; a orax MazaHMax H O6paGoTKax yeuORHEIC OboaHaTeHHA MeHEMOB, BcrpeualomMect B OpUrHHaTEHOM TeKcTe, AAMeHeIAE HOTANH, NOERCTBNE ‘ero mocrenteno saGimaerca neppoHauaztbitatli cabicn 9THx OGosuaeH ni. Eoam expmmauy sozei cxywas noMARaeT ® PYM Mepnoe HaAHHe HAM 2Ke PYKONNcE CTApHHHOTO MpoMSRENeHHA, TO OHO OKAIMBACTCA A: Hero KH Toil sa ceunio nevaramu. Hpmmoquanie HiDke HAGmIOReHHA H HpaKntec- ie coobpaxkenus HampasmeNst TAnHKIM OGPAI0N Ha TO, WTOOHE O6y2K- * Suaruposars 6ypaya (pany.). * A. Beyschlag. Die Ornamentik der Musik. Lelpzig, 1908 (pycexsit nepenox — Pats ipzig, 1908 (pyc enon 45Taanal ATE moGosHATENbHOCTH YWAINMXCH, CrUMYAMPOBATS Wx METEpeC K AHHO!t mpacan MysnikanbHofl KAYKH; pH 9TOM MBI OrpaRNUMMca HayweHHeN Tex HOTOpHYeCKHX MepHonOB, HA NPOTs-KeHHM KOTOPKIX THOPHAM BEMKUE MA cvepa, whe HacnemMe B ocOGeHHOCTH NpMBKeXaeT BHAMANHe cKpHNATelt. Tlo choemy aatexino nee YEpAILeHHA MoryT GuITs pasneneHst Ha TPH ua ‘1) Ykpamera B caNOM HpAMOM CMEIee cnOBa, «pactineYMBaHHe> Me- soaw; 2) uparxenne enous, adybexra; a ©. bern: Knaprer d-mol. I, 3) crpyxrypmuii onement menoguueckoit mam. 4H. nan Berzone, Cora op 47.11 Xora opHamenritka p Hes10M OcHOBLIBaeTeA Ha yerommuMEXxcs npHeMax 1M TPRANNMAX, ee MpAKTHECKOe IPHMeHEHHE He ROLKHO CBOAHTECA K Ges AyMuoMy caeonanio maGz0HaN. (Crus Ht conepokaniite mpowaneneHHst — BOT NeM B nepsyi oNepeAs on Peleamiores KouKpeTHble coCoSKl BLITONHeHHA opHaMexTTamLanx OGOSHE- wounit*, Opxamentuxa suoxit Gapoxxo (10 Baxa pkmosurenbuo) no mnorax oT- MoMIeHHSX conepuleHHO OFAKUHA OF TOM, KOTOPast Guia MpMALTA BO BpeMe- a nencKmx xzaccuxos — Talia, Mouapra u Berxonena. [ooromy nis- HONHCHHe OpHAMCHTHKH B KAKOM-NHOO NpowapenenMM mpexne Beero ‘BARHCHT OF ero HPHHAAERHOCTH TOH MaIK MHOH oMOxe, Axexammans « Tapritnnt nepesiMH cpeny ckpumavel sansiauce o6ero- ATOTDHMIM MsywenMew opHamenTuKu. PesysbTatht OTHX MSbicKANHit 3a- quxcuponams 2 «Ta6muye yxpameniite, conepaamelicn cKpumaTHO! uikoxe J>xemunuaun (1740)*, « w tpyne Tapruns «Trattato delle ap- pogiatures («Tpairar 06 yxpamennaxs), oreyna Jleonoxsa Monapr n038- MMeTRoBA MHOrMe IpHMepsI, MpHneeHHBLe B ero CKMTNYHOM urKoTe 1756 rona. * Boonen, apscepy, Baxs, xoropiit n oGxacrs opmaMenrikit, KaK HBO BEX APY ux, menee neero Sux noxrpmmepon. Marreaon Raaisbaer €70 «bexwhiiM SPAKTHKOM, ‘eymgine pemrecrony TeopeTnetponaiiior; MAI¥eTpAT Topoxe JTefamnura nocxe KOSH: ‘ust Baxa nktnee o neM Kparioe H Geaoronopacoe cysegenue: «Ox G5 BEAHKHN MYDL- ‘eaneTom, Ho me yanrenen “+ B padorex no neTopmn cxpmmrumoro wenyeeras, onyGnuxonannstx 9 1950- 1 1960-x rogax, yeaoana Goace ncamuaa gave suixoan 0 cner mom J[xexmRnamH — 1751, Cae: Punséyped. Tonysenne Tapritnn, M. Mysiska, 1969. C. 30. — Hpum. ped. 46 OGmue aaements Mysueassuoro xenomKenKA Pykonuen [oka o6napysxupaiot sipyio nebpexnocts B crodobax 3a- nue ykpaiuennit. C nosmaenuem Paiiqua awuHaetes HoBAR sT10xa TAKE srB o6niacTH opHamenruxu. Boo xo u ox He Oxi GeayKopHaHeHKo TOUEEIM, ocoGeHHO B OTHOMIeHHM PAIMHINS KOPOTKHX H ALTHKHLIX PopULTATOD, Ko ‘ropsie y Hero Muorga oSosHayers onMHAKOBEIM cnocoGOM (?). Mouapr # Berxose, waoGopor, pkinichinaior yxpamienita ¢ nemuuaii- melt TulaTenbHocrino. C ot0r0 BpeMeHit OpHaMeHTuKa nocTeneHHO mepe- craet Gut mpoGaeMo#, Ho Mepe TOTO, KAK KoMHOsATOpIA ckAoHAiOTCA x ofoaHaeHHIO B HOTaX *axrHeckolt AnHTebHoCTH yKpamIeni. ‘Yueune o hopuizare (3442) npuonaso orserH7s sta Ra nonpoca: 1) Kor- na cxenyer nenognar sunt KOrRA — KopoTEHit hopuLAar? 2) nosi- 2keH 1M KoporKait hopuLIar HCHOAHATECA 3a CHET AMITEMHHOCTHE OcHOBHO- ro aH mpenmtecrsyiomero sByKa? oe can faa gepscar Boasumucreo myssikaxtos curaer THepqo yeraHoRmeHiinm, uro 2 oSosavaer anmumuh, * — xoporkuii @opuier, Ito uerepHo. Hawes croro, 470 eme nesanomro ao Baxa i Tenigena norantus opiinaros Bo06- ule orcytoTsopania; ¥X BocHpousBexenHe BCeIeI0 MpeRoCTABAAIOce BONE Henoznrens. OGosHaveHHeM CnY 2TH KPIOURE H YeprouKH. B AaTsHel- nem JH Sctanu uMTatuca KaK KoporKHe dopuuarK, 0 Kpalitieli Mepe, HA nepsiix nopax. Ousnnn Swanyam Bax vepes Tpu roa Hocse eMepTHt CRO- ero omma ony6anxonat cooit «Oust 0 mpasumEHoM cmocobe MFPs KA Ka BHpes, B KOTOPOM OH BHCTPONN TeAANTeCKH TOUHYIO Teopisio YEpAMTE- nuit. Toone Berxosena u BeGepa woranma jamHHIx opuixaron Gea OGosavenus ux hakTAvecKoH AuMTenbHOeTE NoxHoeTHI0 McwesAeT 19 mpaxruear. Jaa Taprian pasmiane Mexay Anunmbnen x KoporKaMM (bopuviaranct ‘sax odeno raapusin O6pas0M B HX BLspaaHTemLtOM aHANeHun. «Boozelicr- ‘Bue suucmux opuLTaroB cOCTOHT Bo BHeceRHH aaeMetTa NenyHeer#t, 1O- bromy oun Gone Bcero ymecTAbr 8 YACTAX CepLesHOrO WIM 'pyCTHOTO xA- Daxrepa*. Een 4Mu MOARQORATECH B OKUBICHHMIX H BECEMTKIX TbeCcAX, ‘To yrparnaca 6x1 6aeck, Hocrpasiaso Gx mpoNsHeneHHe B HeOM>. DTH C0 43a onloro He HAIIEEX CTAPLIX MacTePOB COXPAAIOT cDOe BHAYeHHE H HOHE He; pexb ocHonHOt xapakrep NpoHSBETeHMA, CCOGCHHO B CHOPHRIX Cry4a- ax, ocraetea nocaenuel, peutaouelt axctaNHelt Mpst BEIGOPe ATMHAEK aH xoporkux opuuiaros. B csoem Tpakrare TapraHH s1aer, B UCAe HPO HX, cnemyIonIie ykagaHHs cHoco6oR HenOMKeNHA: « 4 ern Tro epee * Vivesorea » axay uacru mmenoe (Koweptoa, conn). — IIpun. ped. a7Jleonomx Mouapr » croei axamenwroi ckpunuanoi mKore, KaK yoxe OrMedamock, HoReK MHOIKECTRO HOTHEIX IPMMepoR Ha TapTmnTHencKorO ‘paxrara, Coracho ero YueHito, .AMHMEIe M yjUIMMeHuBIe *PopULTATH aa Guparor or ocktoeHoro anya !/2, 2/ nam 3/4 ero anuremsnocTH, a uHoraa i TOaHyI ANMrenbuoeTS. ome Goran A 41. Mouapr Cepuneuns eons nme dopant Tac pers mec sac Koaraccndbmcanua gnunmirx popuriaron sce ake npencranasteTes Ham 3a- nyrannoii. TpyAHo 1lOHsT», HOveMy OTH ¢YKDAIeNHAs, KOTODHIE MOUTH BO ex npumepax Buiqepakusaorea Xoxblle OcHOBHOTO SBYKA, He BLINUCANEI B cootnerersuH co cpoeli xelicranrensHow mumTemsnocTsi0. Ects, npaBTa, eayaan, KOrRa MooKHO GesouIMGowNO YeTAHODHTE, KAKUM ROE OsITS Qopitnar — pment um KoporKHN. Huceres o BMAY HasorKeHHe TeMBI 1B MYX TONOCAX, BYHMCOH MUI OKTABY, NPHYeM OPIITAT YRAIRE TONBKO 1B onHOM 13 rosocoB. 43 Oomue saementat myauKaanuoro Menoamenss Dao. «Opes x Sapir Taiiqn ne oranuasies ocoSoll tmtaremmnocriio » ofosuasensy (bopmita- ron W Apyrux ykpantennii. B uaqanuet knaprera op. 76, ocHoBRHHOM Ha an- ropeKo# pykonsien, p HanectHOlt TeMe ancrpuitcioro THMHA ReTpeyACTeA ceayomaa samc) A, Fakon. Keaprer op. 76863. 1. meen ct Tlootomy, urpas Taiiqua, ne eneayer Hopectyp cKpyny.1eaH0 mpHAep- aatnarscA «OyKBhIe TeXCTA. ‘Mouapr 8 csoux oGoanavenuax ropasso Gone ToueH M HeRBYCMBICHEH. Ou yrasninaer HacToRILy¥o JamTenbHOcTs opuLAAros. Mersepra = J Boosie = lecruagnamsse = ? (nonepewua wep7a snoe ykopawimaner noes) MaLATBB TOPE B.A. Mouape. Camara e-moll KV 304 1. 49Taaza Osmo saemeurss My2uinastuoro KenonMeRNa Koporkuit hopmizar ot oGosnayaer wenepeseprayroit nocaMofl. nan Berxoven, ©. pmo 0p. 2.14. Tipa ucnoanenua wouaproscnsx dbopmizaros nmxorga He Hao ynyc- Kar 43 BAY, ¥TO MoTepesHaA WepTa sum, MoCTe cMepTH KoMMOsHTOpA ctaa oGosnaexuem Koporxoro (bopmuiera, y Monapra xe oua yRasbinaeT ‘TombKo Ha NposonHTeABHOCTS opuLAra, PABHY}0 ecTHAAUATOR*. Cuavanom XIX cronetua s o6nacta opuamentuxu nactynaer LyTaHH- tau nepaabepHxa, OTHOUIeHMe K Hell craHOBMTCA NpeHeOperKUTEABEBIM, eC pasa nocterterHo npenaiorca aaGnenmio. B KOR npomtoro BeKA, KOr- Za Hawanock cucremaTituecKoe Hay¥enve crapunHol KaaccuKM, 9TH Mpa- BHLa MpHtIocs dbaxTH4ecKH OTKPHBAT® SAHOBO. Y Berxonena yxpameuna tepaor gymxumo so6urpupanuae; ero rpynnerto » ocoGennoctu mpexcrannuor coGoit weorsemzieMyi0 YacT> me- aogueckoit suman. B cpoux panunx mponsnexenuax Berxonen eure Koe- Te nomsayerea oGosuavenuem samunoro (opuutara, nosKe OF YRASKIBAeT ‘Tombko KopoTitHe, 9a HeRMOUeHEM HuKeeNeRyIOULeH XapaxTepHolt TpyN- upon wor: n 1. aaa Berconen, Kaapror op. 18 66.1, SSeS ean > B weKoropHx HOKE KAAAMAKX n9-deoKopworO KonsepTa Monapen RerpewAeTeH yea: sarute, ommoeamecca i exerynomemy amaory IT wae. pst See acassea sed ivan In Sipu eeoeees Bes remap raceme peer ppt aor Per ce ee cence meer irene D¥xonses Kountepra yrepama): Ho Mpewute acer neoSxoHMo, TOOK MYSMIAET Mea eoSerBentioe auehine HO RAXGIONY BORPOCY. 50 Sees Ian Berson -n. p10 0p. 701 8 = C revenzem mpemenu nce vamie scrpevaorca oGosnayenua Am A. Borux u apyrux mpumepax Henoaenue KopoTux (hopmaaron pexersl JNCTCA EAWHCTBCHHO BOOMOKEBI, PABYMHBIM PeleHHeM, XOTH OHM BBI- ‘ucaitss 6ea nonepexnolt wepres. V:ke oAHOrO 9TOFO ocTATONEO, TOBE OT POKHHYTS MpMBLIHOe, yROGHOe UpescTasmeNMe, cormacHo’ KOTOPOMY koporeue opmuiaru ofosuaiaiores hepevepkHyto!t, a AmENIEIe — Heme- pevepkayroii nocemoii. B cnoux pykonnesx Berxonen noobie ne He110mIh- ayer nonepernof wepris. Hoan rekonan nezpevaerest (npeKMymecTseHH DB eppsix HSAAHHAX), TO 9TO CLeACTRME HEPAMLIHBOCTH IIH MpoHsHONE Ne- pemrewmicon. aan Bernonn. Kaagres op. 127.1% IMly6epr amu usperxa o6oanavaer jaunmse hopmLtarM, nomoCTHIO summesipan ix AuuTemuocTs. Koporkue aie Bcero oGoauauerst ¥ Hero Bunge nenepevepxuytolt mectHaanaToi. n ee pte terete ©, My6ept Kaper d-mol. I, cont 7 Horanua dopuuzaros » commennax Ilnopa nose sacaysxumnaer 10- Depa (Koporkne — Quam J, ATMMMBIE BUITCAHEL B MOAEyIO Mepy AAH- Tenor). 51cdesane Mlnop Komuepr Ne Boxaaax cura) elite enter Mexnerscon ji Koporxunx dopuuiaros menomeayer MepeeprnyTy!o ocemy30. ©, Mewnemeon. Koraye IL, as alectaee E Tlyman npumenser somo Koporkue (bopmitarit, Ho mpi arom momsay- ere paamuunsinn enocoGanH o6osHasenH: Bonpoe aummynanui nam eySrpakiunt, To ecrp o6 ucrionennn dop- uinara sa exer quMTemsuocTH mpeaMecrRyIoMIeTo WMH NOcHenyIOMLerO aBy- ka, 0 cero Bpemeuit OcraeTes HeACHLIN H BMSHIBAeT HOCTOmHHEIe CTOpHI". C romoi onpenenentoctsio MoxHo ToBOpHTk JHE 06 ucHOAHeRNM dop- nunarop 3 yicoRHEX HapTux (cx. puaepst 70, 71). TpuwenuresHo ke mygurke Baxa cySrpakitia MHOTHMH PACCMATPHDACTCH KAK IPABHLTO, 10- nyckawoniee nekoropiie Hexmouenits. J[pyrHe, aaosopor, cuuralor 10KA- AaHHLIM, 470 8 HpoHaBeReNHaX nocHeAHeTO Mepuoza satan Baxa uCo Me- SuSMEt, ‘sa HEMMOTHM HOKMOUCHIEM, AOILKHB axTHNMNUpOBATECA, UO focobentio naxkHo B OTHOIMeHMH TAK HasHIBAeMorO mNelicepa*. Ha mpakruie poms nocxeanell, pemaiomelt ucrannyin urpaer axanEttt bkye menommuren. ‘Bencrate Knaccit, tax npanHo, TpeGyior anraryananst Popuniaros. Emre 70 mx Jleononbx Mokapr KaveropuveckM HactaMsax wa TOM, YTOOLE ApH Koporkom dopuiiare yaapenue TPHXoAMTOcE Ha cHOBHOM SYK, a empoxogainives ykpaiienns aanuMarn OM BDeMs, OTBeReHHOe mpeauect- ayloutemy ockoskomy anyxy. [top, coraaco mperammo, Tare npHMe- aa anTEnammponaHnbil cn0c06 McnonHeHMA MenHamon. Lyman crapas- cn oGosuayars aTor coco6 HenocpereTeHHo B HoTHOM samucu; Kapa Ilyman neykocuumentio cxeqopara JanMoMy EPHENMMY, pomBAsA KeKO- Topyto oaHocroponmocTs. * Roporenl Qopmaar ns nDYX-Tpex suyikon, NepeXORANOE B OCHOREO! SBYK B NOCTY- areaamom xmixennn, nanpuep @e= .— [pum ped. 52 OGune stemeuris myauKaxLKoro enoxueniea Y Beiimara cyOrpaxuuia 5 npmmenenHa k crapuEHo# MySkIKe H anTH- AAU — B HpHMeHeHH K HOBO H HOReituell MyaiaKe yrRepacaaeTer fp KatlecrBe screTHYecKoro Hopmarina. Ho uinaloT K HeK MOEN Ha Ta: pila, KOrAa aBTOpcKam HOTHAG JamHCk HeABYCMBICNEHKO YRAsLInACT HA cySrpaxiyino, Hampumep: 87 A. nas Berson Keaprer op. 127.1 Bqece opunatar na cHutsHoe BpeMa TaKTa, cera BhiAeNeRD; 72 ‘rembnoeT® — pocnmast. TLim cospemennoro xonyeprupyiomero MyaMKAHTa anTAnunanss penctapsaetea HanGomee ecrecTBeHHbIM M TOTHMHTSIN CHOCOGOM HOMOMHe- Hust moGnix yKpamentti, sa ucsmosennem Tpesel. K Tomy me cyOrpaK nus aguaCTyi0 OcHOBAHA Ha caMooOMaNe — HCOAMHTENW KaxeTes, ¥T0 OH Be- per (bopiiaar Ha cHaBHyi0 AOmO TaKTa, B AelicTRHTemLHOCT OX Geper ero ha caaGy.0; nem Ana cxyMaTeaR HAYAKO HIM MPoROMReNHe TaKTA ReerAA ‘camteato ¢ Menoguvecxoit onopoit, ¢ axneNTOM. «Mopdenmow nassinactos ykpanienue, mpexcrasatomee coGoik onito- patiioe 4epezonanme OcHOBHOTO 2BYKA CO RCHOMOTATEAEILIM, OTCTOSILM Ma wiTepsan Masoli cekyHAbl; 1O CapMAHOMY npanouHeaNito on OGosHa- aero *. Eeau perloMoratenbHas Hora AomKHa Osi MOBMWEHA HTH NO: MiDKena Ha TonTOHA, TO K shaky OGaBAseTeH Aes, GeMOrs Hum GeKED. Bes cnenuamsuoro oGosavenua Berga GepeTes HiDKHAK M@LIAs CeKYEAA® (Pawan). Dro onpenesenne moxer Gurs mpHHsTO MMIITe ¢ HaHeCTHAINEH OFO- Popa, TaK Kax y Baxa Mopen? ausuierca AHATOHUMECKHM (CHOMOTa- rexbuuii suyk orcToM” Ha HEB ToH OT OCHORHOTO), I TONSKO B HOCAeAY- ‘omyio onoxy mpeguowrenem cata NoAbIORATECA MATAR ceKYHAA. Bueaom, waunnas c weckinx Kaaccukon, oTOT BINA MopAeHTa HOUT NOHO. roto mutiTen us ynOTpeGaenH; ero aaMetH TAK HasbiBaeMbtit UIHem1ep — open ¢ sepxHu BCLOMOrATeALHEIM GByKOM. B mysurke xnaccusecxoro PoMaNTHMecKOrO crits InHesJep aHTHUH- unpyerea*, * Boiimaar saqevaer no oromy nosoay: «Berxonen ene wenee, wer Bax, Git aor Tnkox, y mero Taioxte Borpevaioren ovezynuieuua OF MpwBNaME aHTILNHALUIN. KOPAR anpurwep, » NeaeHHO sacra Yeepriopit eTleonopas kaapmerHerk WAImHX OPNeCTpOS ‘rpewor popmitar aa ever xrmzeRtHocTH exeayiomero 9BYKa, TO MMH PYKOBORHT REPRO oninkerstoe wyserso. Bax» Berxonen » qaimedimese Bimmncaz 970 MECTO eaeAyOUtM paaou (n wensspexxpartfow ynezirdeny): aac ero Yer eg M3 53‘nan Beronen, Cora 0p. 96.1V. ‘man Berxonee, Cour oh. 47118. OGmue oremenrst mysuxazhuoro Menoanenna Tpynnemmo (se) npexcranaser coGoit coonunterne wopzenra it unex- xepa. 950 S55 — csumnar dopa, oguaxo UMeeTes MHOMeCTEO APYTIX RAPHAHTOB, B SABHCEMOCTH OT TOTO, mocTaBsleHo am obosuavene Han HOTOH WI Memay CoCeRHHMM HOTAMIC, HaWHHeeTea x rpynmerto ¢ rnaBHOrO HAH Ke ¢ BEpxtterO (HHDTEHeTO) BCMO- MoraTeTbHOro BBYKa, COCTOMT JH OHO Ha Tpex WK YeTEIPeX SBYKOB HT. ft. =e Jam wae mperkye ncero BaxHo sHaTb, 470 BLINHCAHHOe Tak rpymterTo 950 = BRRAACCHeCKOli MysuIKe HenOAAeTeA Ges HCKMOTEHTA coeryIONYAN O6PAsOM: 956 = Hoasnnas c 1800 roga suax © sasactyio exenmpactoa co sHaKoMt ©, HacTosIbKo pASAMUNe MeoKAY HHMH CTepOCK B CONANT NOCAEAYIONAX 1O- konewnit. K aromy npx6asnaoce crom 2xe YacToe HCTONKORAHHe % B Hla- Nett wy , a TaKUKe cMeMeHHe wy 1% (tr). Bor HecKOMILKo MpHMepOB 13 s- ‘Teparypatt B.A. Mouape Korver KV 318.1 croc enamine 55Fassel A. Monap: Coura KV 484.19, OGmue oacmenrr mysuKasnore KenommeNHs I. na Bernowe. Koaprer op. 18 Ni 4 1, & Geb ox. “* Ooo, waxy pame urpaer n ork noupocax zat axye nenoamuTeaR, cBuAeTeAh- cernyer ror ax, avo = MHNOFAN Ne MOP CLEFpATs oeTaKTODOE TpYINETTO MRE KAN m oe = ro spens ax rpyitnerto na cmEHOe BpoMM TwETR CKTARBINAAOCE HAM MENA HS TPEX ‘25yicon (ax w Mpumepe 100). 36 Jag mac, ckpunavelt, rpynnerro uMeeT 3HaNeHKe TABHAIM OOpRI0M Beaagn ¢ Tex, U70 ero 1acTo MpxMeuaer [Inop. B ero pykommesx aHaK s° YYkasiiuaer He TOBKO Ha rpyierTo, 10 MHOTAA M HA ero OOpaMeHHe, a TAK ake Ha ykpamIoNMe THNa KOpoTHol TpenH: wr Tpnaunn nenoxmens rpynnerro y Lnopa — anmanunanua. Tpase- eM MPHMePH HCTOUIKOBAHHA IHAKA c® B COOTRETETRUH ¢ FPAAKUME, aRRE- ‘kasutoit JJapxtom, Moaxnmon 1 T'pioHoM. ie _B. Mn. Komp 28 87Ha ochonanus npumepa 113 moxHo saxsowurs, wro Bpame nonnmat rpytinerto Kax ZeveHHe OcHOBHOTO SBYKa Ha MATS PABHEIX One, salt0- HALIOUINX BCIO ero juUATeABHOCT. Hut oaum kownosutop He nospeauuns rpynnerto Tax, Kak Puxapa Bar- ep; Ges atoro ykpamtents He oOxogaTCA Tony aRpHeliune TeMAl B ETO PAH Hux onopax («Tanretiaeps, ¢Puennts)*. Heosmoxeto nposectH weTkoe pasrpanuvenue Mexzy rpynmerzo u mneliepom, Ws z ‘ax Kax ix oOostavenna » noTax sacro comazaior. JLxa Hac rpere Bcero sexu wars, uz0 y Berxonena mneiidep nocrommo awmmmnupyercn. 11S 2. nan Berzone, Kaaprer op 184 ef ** Marousnecren, no sacnynusaer smwana Tor axe, W70 2 TeveHIte OnPeAeTEROTO ‘pewenu Baruep micrax oco6oe ipienpacrite & «nepenepeyroMy> Fpymmes70: B Gonee nosqnie roni on, no ensizereaicrny Tentca Prctepa, ovomien of oro napus. 58 Hackoauxo pasawune B criocoGax ucuoamenus ykpamennit nauaer Ha obit xapasctep sByaHHa — oKassIBaer MpHMep, BaaTatit He ROTyTTC- ua x IV sacra expyxuoro xnaprera Berxonena op. 18 Ni 6. ‘Tax Kak MoTHB nOBTopseTes aaTeM BO BEX YeTMIpEK TAPIA (B YEH Conkiom waoxenmu) u recHeMimHM O6pR20M CRAIAH C MYSLIRAMLHLIM COED- %axneN enor, enOCOH eTO HetONHeHUA HPEACTABNAETCs HCKIMOUHTENTEHO Borman. ST omlymaio ero, ponpexd npaninam, Kax cy6rparmponammuti, Bumonnsescutit Ha «pase. AnanoriaHo: mee ©, Meazemcon. Kouuept 118, 59FaanaT Uro kacacros mpeau, To agece Hae HHTEpecyer mente Beero HAuATO 1 saxmosenve. dpamysexas mxoaa (a AoGaxonckwit mepwon) HaTHIAA ‘Tpenb ¢ muoxHero BcHOMOraTeEHOrO sayka (TAK HAIKIBAeMA NpeABApA- wouiaa Tpems), Tengen nawsmaer ee, Kak MPABKIO, ¢ OCHORHOTO aRyKE, a5 nckmounreabmerx caysanx oGoanatacT HCXOAHMI ABYK B ane hop” utara. Hoysaonui pyxonnen WAM OpHrHHATbHHIe HOARHEA GRXORCKEX commnennit ueo6xoqaMo slab, wro Bax ofoanatian pe ¢ HMAKHeTO 3By- ka (ws, € BePXHErO — Gm, A TPedIb ¢ 3aKMONEHHEM — sy, OAHAKO, HOCKONL- Ky 8 Hamme Pacnopaxxene NOUTM HMKOTRA He MonAAaHOT HORANUA, He TOR Beprinmeca oSpaGoTKe, — copeTyeM MPHACPAKHBATHCA HMKEOTOAYIONNEX papa: 1) Ecau snyx, mpemtecrnyromuri rpenu, connagser no auicore ¢ ocuon- HbiM 3ByKoM caMOit TPenH H 06a aBYKA CAATOBAHE!, TO TPE NO HEOGXO MocTH AoDKHA HAIHATbeA ¢ BepxHerO SBykKa (RAXKe ECM HP OTOM MeL erea Hanpasienne curuxa). H.C Bay. Conan pmo 1 m 2) Ecam mpeqmecrnyiommi cauroneniatit aByx oterouT na coKyEAy BAIME BBYKa TPeNH, TO OHA MO>ET HALMHATKCS TOIKKO C OCHORHOTO (HH Huprnero) asyka, H.C. ge. Couaa gm ns 3) Ecau npequiectaysoumtil suyx orerour Ha coKyHay Hite, TO HoApa- SyMenactes Haviano TpemH ¢ OCHOBHOTO HAIK REpXHErO BBYKA. __H. Bax. Conara amo B nanniom noupoce wenkaa nonocTaio RowepaTeea Tapriiit, TAK RAK BcnoeM HanectHom mMcbMe K cixABopuxe JlouGapAMHM OH DeKONeHAYET Ha Nuwar Tpen ¢ nuKHero aByEA, aR eTpaKtares — c nepxnero. Jleonom.a Mouapr tauimaer ¢ nepxnero, Talia — c nusxnero aayka (npxt HCRmONe- Max suinncuIDaetca {MHEG PopuLaar). B. A. Mouapr Kax 6yato exexy- er npaswian orna. Berxonen npaslepaHBaeTeH MIEN, TO TPeNb AON Ha HaumtHartoa c ocHoBHoro sByxa, Ho qonyckaer HeKmOveHMA, Hoa pero Mpowanexennax nerpewaetca oGosHasenme KoporKoro chopminara uepen ‘penbio, To 970 YKASKIEACT HA HAYEIO TPeAH CBOPXY WAM cHIHay; TEIN gopunar sjeck ucxmoven. Dpannyackue ckpunsut — Poge x Kpelinep B cponx stionax, Ballo » caoel expumsinoit mone — pekomenjonasi Ha- ‘MuHaTe rpests ¢ Repxnero anya OGmue axemeurst MyaMKasLuOrO MenoamenHs 12s P.Rpehuep 42-70. Ne 1. Page. Komuepe Ne 7.1 ue Ilnop navuuaer ¢ nepxuero suyka (ecnm ner apyrix oGosnavenit) Buame npexs Tpems McnomnseTca HaYHIaA ¢ OCHODHOTO SBYKA, 38 HEX: newex caysaen, Korga KoporKmit cbopuINar mepex TpexrbIo yasuipaeT na nporinonozoxnisik erocoS ucnostMeNnss. Bonpoc 0 npumenema WK nenpHMeneMH naxu.taza (saxmo¥eHKA) TpeaM YaCTO sBuAeTeA TPeTMeTOM orKeCTOUeRTELX cTIOPoB, OCOGEHHO B cAA- ai € MeOAHeHHEM KxnaccHYecKHX conaT. PaceMaTpHBAA HOT BONPOC C HCTO- HYeCKOH TOuKH apeHMA, MoO ykAsaTE Ha TO, wT0 KopesaM MpenyeMarpH- an HcHONHeHMe Tpestell ¢ HaXxnIarAMM, Cys To HaRAHINO ero coHAT (OP. 5), suutemmemy 2 1710 rogy. [presmuuani a cpoetk cxpunsunoit uncome 000: svawae? Tpemb © Haxuuaarom B auiZe *, a Tpemt Ges NAxtIIArA — OOBTUITSIM enocoGon. Penes, wamye scero Biinvcsmaer HAXITNAr B Tex CxyWASX, KOTA 3a Tpemsi0 cneayer Goaiee muicoxuit suyx. Y Baxa wa weoOxomuMocts wax- nuara ykasumaer monepewiaa uepra, ZobaaTennad K O6OsHAYeHIO Tpet (o»), KoTopyl0, onHaKo, He cnenyer cNemunaTs ¢ OGosMaeHHEM MopiIeHTa (0s). Bo nonkom nyuae anak HM + mpegtomaraior erlonuene Gea axuLiara, ecm Ke HamHo oGosHavenne fr, 70 aXULAr HeoOssaTenen. ITo- uno ororo Bax oayactyso nomuocrsio muinMcHinaer Haxularn. Kax yore ro- Bopwiioes, GaXOBCKHe HAXIITArH OcHORAHM Ha HHTepRAsIE GOsIKLION COKYHAIAL (uo ormomemmo K aByxy TpesH); npeTpactie K NoayTOHOROMY HaxUlary OGuapyaxuacres n Gosiee noagMoW anoxy. Tent Gea Haxuutara y Baxa, Ka Mpasio, fomwHa saKAHYEBATECR HecKOADKO PaRBUe caMoro sByKa, Ora ‘pawn, 10-BHAMMOMY, BocxomuT x KopenaH, y KoToporo Tpeat TacTO BuI- cai enexyiomess o6pa20M: ta GES Ho moemy mnenmo, xaparrepmisit ana Baxa nocxonamit menonuec- Sorit oGopor, savepmarouyuit omy m3 dacrelt yuna, 128 ace Fareed ‘Taprini puinidebipaer HAXtUIar TOmBKO B TOM Cayuae, ecaH cuMTReT ero Heobxomumsim (rak 2ke Jeonoaya Monapt). ¥ Taiiqna u B.A. Monapra Borom ornoMleHum HaGAOqAeTCA HeACHOCTS, ECM TOAEKO HAXMMIAT He DL 61Paap Ss iy snnorn 9 nn, Buns romp Bent, B pc kak To yrsepaxcqaer Ano PyOunmrelin Hexoropuie pyre. Jase eos seer eros ore cn tn neon etre on See Ze ctonpsnerrmnen tenon, tone ne ret me Sesh ows pment pu nngnonmg nanan pein {ptbtaoyny, auratnyoypan afspnontoy en not pu ort murs cnt te Sma 1 oer vo apyka. IIpeqnoromenne Py6unmreiina 0 Tom, wo Berxonen mocToAHHO roan etromanns enna re ornament tpean y Berxosena rpe6yior waxmaara, Jase ec1H OH He YKA3AK B HOTAX, B megnennoit vactu Kpeityeponoii conatst a fang wrane st: Hereneny ey Sane nota Te less mera na tl np promo neen,ranian ac Sear semen ron ween, eras Maa Brora np Govee YaCTEIX CNOPOB, BOSHHKAUIHX B CBABH C NpObzeMoi HHTepmpere ceo ecesnptmian cms ape arnrar enna poy equa re crac tn a sms tren traf gsm ui Zein Ny oes tap apo seeder caret nee anovvap, roy vans tems pers ceca cues Seton a ox ocr gui ebm frets na an Seren ook mtn cement ann unr sroerce one ne ‘Tpeam ¢ naxmiarom (Conara op. 1276 3.111. 190 Conran. 1206 1.14. ‘ Conan op. 12. 3.1114, Comara o. 23.11 62 O6mne seMenrat mysuxasyuoro MenomHeRHs x_n 0a. “¢ v eer: oman 30983. a PRRs wg oe EB 63cris Myon Paane 1 (Conara op. 47.14 Cons op. 30 Ne 3.111 x cee owaraop.<7- IIIS. xD ‘Tpexx Gea naxmzara a eas 3 wn " Goma 0,308 1.1, ae Comer 0.96.1 oma ep 30783. Tipoowaxputnax miienpimenennnie npyMepb Mbt anexaent: 9 op. 12 SSS = up op. 23m 24 Berxonen sesne oSosnavaer waxumaarn B op. 30.Ni 1 wax: ‘unatiewe yiasanas, a Kexowennen onson enpotey sprrmepa 130 (VD top. 30 Ne 2 nee npema aaneptmaone uaxstizaro 3 op. 30 Ne 3 ofa eno Ha Coon Meuoamentn naxoparen, Tak ck, 2 ipnOaMenrexsHOM Daawose- vy Cote. 30963 : deat cant; Bop. AT npeam Geo naxuinara sawerusin obpasoM mpeodseA07, @eeeee= pohtRh ‘nop, 96 ont ceraioren exmniernenian enocoom wetomena. = = aaa HHonoe oreyrenaue axsznaron 2 10 couare (op. 96) nacroxsio 6p0- cacrem wasn, sro 2n0 nuk nennon cantane NeSpenuOCTao Heh, Te Gonee y Takoro AO6pocoRecTHOTO H TOUHOTO B CBOKX YKAasAHMAX aBTOpa, x eeeeet trator Kax Berxosex. MomHo Tpeqn010%XuTs, 4TO B BTOT MepHOA cBHOeTO TROPYE- = _—- craa, nce Gozee ormannBieroca oT TpaquMMii XVIII Beka, Berxoner o7ma~ sun ipesnownense spenu Ges nanczaare: Rem ss Bosaten 130 epansoss Crgyamail saprer op. 95 (IL sacra), x0 norperie abe Senge MATE eine mpmieDis = (rye naxmurar Gesyenonno meoGxomnm). 64 65B nporsonec stomy: H cnosa: ‘BepHyaumes exe ua weckomsxo wer Haga, stot naiixem boprenuas- HOM TpHO mi-GeMous marxop (op. 70 Ne 2) muorecrBO Tpextelt, Hee Ges Eni oro Haxmiaara, Hom ke repeeMoTperk TlocsieKMe KBApTeTEl, TO MUI YBH- num a Luaers op. 127: me Roe ens= Dro se Meeto a penpuse: To wceit ovesuauoctu, Berxosen » gannom enyuae cwnTaer naxusmar OGAsaTenbHBIM, Ho ero NOBTOpHOe OGosHANENMe B MOTAX — MaMuIINUM. B apyrnx xnapterax nocaequero nepnona Hexmiard numucamss wauGomee ‘TOUR, B RHE Hor TloMHOk AmTENMHOCTHL. ao qe zam Bernoven:Kaaprer op. 131 66 O6mxe oxenonTM MyaNRamsnoro KeMomKeNNA Demin DOMORTEE MYORINAABHONO MOMOAMCMM® SL KIOWA K BEIBOAY, WTO B NepBoM HepHoge THopyeciBA BerxoneH, pepitt 8 HeOSXOAUMOCTS HAXILIAra, BO BropoM — He cuHTa: ero OGRaaTeNb- suist, BTpeTBEM — cHOMA Repuyaica x Hey. B cRaau cOTHM M1 HoMaTasO, 470 nomoe HeKMOWeHHe HaxIer0D B op. 96 apameTca UperHaMepeHiHIM™. B ocTaNBHOM, eoxK Out RAKE YATOCE MOAHOCTHIO PaspelmHTs NpoGTeMy saxuuiarop y Berxonena, aMSnusii exye McnommTens uceraa coxpaHMT ‘cooHt mpane. Tily6epr x Ilyas we nceraa 6xizrH mpenesuo aopoconecrisnmn B no- npoce HOTALUM HAXINARNA; OHK BEINMCHIBANLE CTO TONHOCTSWO JIKIIIb B TOM. cayine, econ IpHAABANH eMy TeMaTKMeCKoe SHaYeHHe, HanpHMeD: ©. lybepe. Kanerer «Popes. Bap. 1 1 fe fe fe ke Konneprupyiomne cxpumayn npouinsx spemen, 10-BuzuMOMy, 06 ‘nau 2 9TOM eMBIE-Te GolTee PASEUTEIM HyBCTHOM CTHLIA TIO Cpanntenitio ¢ Ha- x. Tloatomy xonmosirropsr ictaccueckol au0xit Mors MOsEoaUTE ceGe Gurrs eOpexaminor, Bpanc Guin yore menee ONTHNHCTHUREIM, OH B-TOMHOC: 11H )uKeHponazt Ha Oyare Bee cou nomeanus™*, TIpx nenonensit couar ¢ (boprennano npuxoawres urpars Gea Hax- mara Tpext, o6oaaNeHHEIe OMOUPeMCHHO B OGeux MaprHax, Ho coopa- 2keHHEEM CHEXPOHHOCTH, OCOGEHHO eC.1M Ha TpenM yKasaHA epaara, Breck nomoraer sm60 copmecriitit (sapanice yenonaemuli) cuer, 3160 apne init KoHTAKT, HosRONsHOINIH TOAKO ONpeTeAMTS MOMENT OKOHYAHHE TPe- ‘a 4 Hawama caemytoMero aByKA. I. nan Berxann. Conaa op. 7.115, ry Tloaius uenoanuresis B ponpoce mpuMcHenus HaxuITaroB MODKET OF- “dneTHt IARHCETh H OF TEXHMMECKHX, TO eCTE B ONpeneeHHOH Mepe orOMCTH- ecKax coo6pankenni. Tax, Con tpemt YAO6HO HCTOATE BTOPLIM Tat + Buano Gara muciefl crenenit untepecwhi paccmorpers nox 97H TOM apeRI APY: re nportanexenna QUI Goprensano, xawepHoro axcaMGs, opkecTpe), ¢ Tex "TOC putt, HaKOKeR, ¥ TBepmu YEow:RONIAN LO NOVOAY MPAMILTDOTO NpHMCHORI Hax- ‘* Bupowen, om, ovesn gio, ne 6izn GomsurHn moGieTereM cKpHMAOM spe: w-rpex. ero comatax aan expaink M Goprennano Mid HAXOAHM BoerO HIND ORY EXHMCTHENTYIO ‘peas (a rome IT sacri op. 108)". 67eM, TO MAXILAAr OKASKIBAeTCH HEKCTATENBHKM BRAY HeOBXOAHMOCTH cKOMBSHTE MepBLIM NamYem Ha TomTona BHNa. B nonObUBIX cAyZARK, a ellie Gontee — B yeTlo¥KAX Tperlel MPM BOCKOASIIEM METORMHECKOM ARH. 2KeNHM CKPHTIAGH CKTOMmOTCA K TOMY, 1TOOS COBCEM OTKASATECH OT HaX- uiara, ecaiM om He mpegeranasercs cOnepileRHO HeOGXOAMMMIM © MYIII- AbHOM TOKE apen B neqarorueckoii mpaxtuxe pexomenayerest cexoRaT® CTapoMy mpa- buy, coraacko KoTOpOMY Tpeme, saxaHUAACKAR He GoNee BKICOKOM aRy- ke, Wenoansetes ¢ MAXUITATOM, B TO BPENA KAX WIA TPeNit ¢ OKONMANHEM Ha Gozee nusxom snyxe on neoOsaarenen. Henaror, coSoqiutit or upeny- Gexnenuit, « secs npegocranH CROKM YeHHKAM WanecTHYIO CTeTeH» CRO- Goan, yurTeipan CIAIONHOCTE K HApYILIEHHIO TPAAMNNONHAX (opM, THT Hylo Ayia conpemennoro myalkanbHoro HeKyecTaa. Koporkas rpem acerja uconasercs 6ea HAXtinara: a Tape — ©. Kpedeaep.Bapwnao na rexy Kopenne 0 Tipu stom wntcao Tpexessix yaapon y MMaKMcTOa M ckpunaveit paamza- no, Hocennue oGxoaarea anymat ADHoKeHUAMH (TOKEN H OTYCKANHE 09- oro nasisila), 8 TO BPEMS Kak MMAEHCTAM NIPHXOAMTCK BLOMHATS TETLIPC abwxcnna (noxLen 1 onycKaHMe deyx nanbuee). OTHOCHTEIEHO BombUIAR ‘TpYAHOCTS HcHomMeNHs TpenM Ha KABHIIHOM HNOTpyMertTe aBARETCH, 1O- BHAHMOMY, UpHNMHO! TOrO, “TO IHMARMCTHY, B OTHOM coraacHs ¢ TeopKel, ROcMpoUsBORAT KOPOTKY TpeuTh R BIE MOpAeHTa, a cKPHTAN YzapAIOT asistiem 10 CTPYHe CTOMBKO PAI, CKOADKO NOAROAAET NpOTAKEHHOCTE BA- ‘oro sByKa v, KOMeHO, yponoHL TexEMuecKoro-MactepCTaa. AKIEHT CMB Kom, oOsraxo conyrersyiommik Koporkokt Tpem cxpanauell, etuMy.tupyer sorperioes MiTeHCHRHOe ABILKeHMe TATEUA, LITOANAOMeTO TPE; 2TO cnocobcrayer yexopenttomy wepesoRaHiio Tpeentrx YAapoR H, cooTReTCT- BeHHO, BospacTaio Hx Yea Ha eAUHHNY Bpestens, Bo noXeMy pH ne- noaHeHust conar-ayovon ¢ Poprenuaxo KOpOTKad Tpem cKpHLAYA ate Beero oKastipaercs Gostee axebexTHoi. Ec s enouxe rpeselt pocxonamero zzavouNuecKoro Haim xpoMaTz- Neckoro apu>kenua Maxuaars He OGostayeHEI co RceM oMpexeeHHOCTEIO, Bonpoc 06 Hx MpBHeceHHM peliaeTea B SaBICHMOCTH OT AHIHOTO BKYCA HM MysnixamsHoit mTyHaHH HrparoTero*. * Samernm, To Barnep 6x11 ctopommiow upmMeneHs HAXIAN 21M ROCxORAIIX nenovex peel 13060r0 pone. ‘Hegemon hyo 68 OSmme suemenTa: mysuxaanuoro xenoanenns Buncxonanyrx nenouKax, sMaroMMecKX Ham xpowarsiaecKinx, HaX- maar GesyenosHo ormanaer. ‘Mat afaem, ro cxpunasi XVII « XVII cronernié @uxexponans sa 6y- ave TOabKO soCTORY MenOMeCKOR MONI MeqNeNHBIX wactei, a Mp HC- TonHeHHH YCHAMAMN €© BCOBOOMOOKEKIMM. YKPANICHESN, BILTOTL HO Ca- orx samicaonarsix uryp. Xapaxrepes s Tom cmBicne mpsMeD, wSsTEIH a ancTepaamexoro maaan cover Kopeai op. 6 (oGosuatemia yxpante- runt noniannete): 69Taanal Hanee 10-a conara Taprunu (op. 1), ¢ rimaimninn 48 ToH sox YRpAMIeHMAMH (nanevarans: Meaxun mIptroM): Iupoxo uanectua uoaxumoscxan penaxuua Adagio 22-ro xonyepra Buormy, ¢ npHMeHeHHeM MHorowtcneRHBIx eagréments+*, nomemtentian » 3-m rome cxpunmunoit mons Mloaxnma~Moaepa. C npaxruueckoit row a ApeHNa OTA TONBITER ROIMKHA BRITE NPHAHAKA HeYARHOM, TAK KAK OHA He BLIBEIBaeT y HCHOAHMTENA xeTAHHA cAeLOBATS AAMDUTE 0 STOMY NTH; cxopee neero y Hero nomBHTea crpewaenHe BoccTaHosHT® crporse, Guaro- POREBIe KONTYPH MeONITH B UX NepBOHAYAAEHOM EAC. ‘Betpewaerea rake ocobas pastosuaiocrs yxpanienuil kaqenuonHO- To THING, KOTOPLIe MPHSHICRAIOTCR K TAKODMM JHIN NO MPHOHAKY MecTA, BaHHMAeMOrO HM B MeTPOpHTMMIeCKOH CTPYRTYE MEOAHH, B jeliCTRH- TembHOCTH 2Ke ABAAIOTeR MeOGXOAAMLIM TEMATHYCCKHM I7eMeHTOM. a tan Bernonen. Kowwept 1%, ‘Teun, » xoropom HenomHmOTeH YEPANIOHNA 9TOTO THN, AOMKEH 10- ‘croaHHo corsacoBLinaTbcat ¢ OCHORHHIM TeMTIOM Bcel actu. B npuBegeH- Hom IPHMEpe BOCEMBe, COOTBOTETBEHHO TeMMY K XAPAKTEPY, BAIPADKEHTHO- my o6osnavenvem Larghetto, He 102KHKi GLiTs Yepecuyp HocHeLLHEIMH. Apraxyasmast Tlog aprukynanseh Mai nOHMMAeN CRAaHOE HAM PAgxeNbHOe HeHOAHE- Hue sByKOB, o6pasyioux MysiIKasbHEI MOTHB HAH pasy. Apruxysin- uso wacto cMeuupaior ¢ (bpaseposKoll. B padore T. Bumaiiepa «Myaui- asistiad DHTMHKa K MeTpHKa®** caenyiomTEM o6pagoM RCKPHITO page orux Byx tlonaTuit: «TIpannabuan rpyamuposka ouyrpx ¢ppasui (1a 470 ZomKHO Gurr oSpameno BHuManHe) OGosHaYaeTca CTOBOM ¢apTHKY.In- vias. 5 xopouto apruxyaupyi0, ecan # coGupaio noezMHO sByIt, cBASAE- * Vecpameunit (@pana.). ** Th, Wiehmayer, Musikalische Rhythmik und Metrik. Magdeburg, 1917. 10 OGume saewenrss wyomRaannoro nenoam uate smroH, a nocaenuMit Ho WX yKOpAsHMBAIO*; XopoMIO GpABHYIO, ecm ysbixamsisti OTpAIBOK, PACHIeReHHBIH ApPHKYNAUWOH Ha OTZEsbHLLE NO- Cspoetitn, MpexCTaeT n MoeM HeMOMHORHM RAK eNNHaR, HeNOCTHAA M 3aBep- entas MyacamBsIas MsICsI Tlop06HO TOMY, RAK DH WPeHIE CTEXOB XO- poulam, supaguTensian mHTepmperamua TexeTa We ncerga coveraeToR ¢ AOCTATONMO ACHEIN H NeTHHM TO MPONIHECeHIEM, TAKAO MOET METH [MecTO Xopottias ¢bpasHpoRKA M ORLORDEMEHHO HNOXGH APTHKY.AIIA KAKO To-mNGo MysuixamsHoro orpustaia (Ht Hao6OpOT)>". Oraerme mpevene ncero Kopenioe paamrmne Menxy apruxynannelt sexpunusnow i 3 GoprenuanHoM HcHommTensoree. ILEalHer & COCrOAHHH obvenutmrs 10600 akemiaeNoe KomIeCTHO ayxoB NOcPeACTBOM legato, cy" ‘ectaanemoro Kak wneTO MestiteDsINN npweMaxs, Tak H € NOMOMIH10 NORA sit, Ckpinayy B stow mpensrcrayer neoBxoAHMOeTS CMe CMBINKE, TAK dee KAK MORLY Wan AYXOBHRY — KeOBxORENOTE Spars LIxaNHe. Bexenet nue atoro BhiniomHenne expittitssiore legato ensiaaito Co MHO2eCTHON KON. "ApoMtHccoB, B gapuouMocrH or yponut TexuiKieH cixpHmiawa. Heaawerias (10 pOsMOMGHOCTH) cmeHa EMBTEKE HEOBXOMHIMA He TOKO 189 UCTO 3BYKOBMX cooSpaxkeHni, Ho eute Goce — m nesmx mpaBHaLHOR MyauIKEATBHOH aprHi- xynanun, Hapaay ¢ 7TH Hemban raioKe oGolinics Gea yMeHist HanTekaTe nogNouarO Gombitee YMeA0 SByKOB He OANO ADHEKENTHE CMI. B nonpoce panjeanol apruxyasngan (non legato) wenomurrenn a eMBINKODBIX HLCTPYMORTAX CTAMDROTER ¢ ABLNEMMOH, HeaHAKOMOH HHA ucTam, AyXORMAM H HEDMAN. ¥ Beex Hx NpOTsOREHEE (x. €. HEHONATEMEIC oMMyto Mepy AaIKTeMBHOCTH) anys, Obpaayromte GHICTPHIE NACCArKHL, Be aa OGxeaunlenss, 7. e. urpanorea legato. ¥ erpymmuxon aaske » Texte prestissimo moryr rier» ecto pasaebuise mporsiaemue BBY, HeNON- itsemre urmpirxo détaché. “ro Kacaeres anyxop yRopouveHusts (7. 0. De- aabHO say'aMNHx He B MOMMY! Kepy OFOIHANCHHO! B HOTAX sUUATe-THHOCTH), ‘70 OBN m OiteTpoM ARLENE HeOMaOzeR wirpHxaLEH staccato, martele, A Take MpMIrMOULEME H OFeKeKuDAONGHNEH mTpHXaMN. B détaché pas AemsNAG apruxyannun ocymecrbsseTCs B peoyauTAre exe aaMeTHOTO, he nogaaiobleroen Hamepelitio Repepiina a 2RYWaltit, BLIGBALIHOTO cxteHON eonavka; B OTpuImeTInE UITpHXAX OMIyIeHUIe paaestEHOCTR YeHLAINBAeTEA Saarogaps nome waepsnbiN Hayaan, HOONAKAIOUUIM Me AY OF/eNbs- Mit apioxcennanan canraica. Cxpunnunoe détaché He weer choero axiaora 3 oprenuaxnolt urpe, noaTomy n muokecueayiolleM npuMepe miecrHajtta- ‘Tule B napri hoprenkaxo rosDKHM HeNOAHATHCA legato; pH aToM OTHA- eer paasnrane easanolt u pasyenssof apritkyasiin (HauHNN ¢ nperselt erseprn mepporo zaxra): Moa ay Berson, Coma op. 3081.19 =Taapal ‘Taxus oGpaaom, mpHx détaché — npomexyroanoe snewo mexcry lega- tom staccato — pykax crpynuNkca annsierea BkipaoMTeTbHBIM epencTBOM, nooGmoro KOTOPOMY HET y OCTANLHBIX LCTPYMeHTOR. "YeopoweHbie anyii B CKDUNNIHOR urpe — sto ocoGaa oGnacts, TpeGy- routast sunarenbioro paccMorpedia. OHM XapaictepHaylozem He CTOEKO ‘reat, 470 HX PeabHas MMTeABHOCTS MeNBIe HOMMHAITEHO!l, CKOEEO HAZ item nayaia, exioaylouielt nocite Kaxkzoro suyKa*, Brevarmenme KpaTKocTst, orpuinncToctH auyWaHHiA saBNCHT OT COOTHOIIEHE Mexuy NpOOMKHTENS- HocTEw0 OTAeHLitOTO aBYEEA Ht NIAyaH. Breck BOSMORHO MHO:KeCTRO OTTeI- Kon, KoTopuie He MoqmOTeA MpocTomy mepewnCaeHH0; GecenopHo zAnKS To, 70 XapaKTep MPOUSBEREHUEA B KesIOM OMpeseraeT CoGOH cHOcObMt 1tC- HONHeNKs YKOPOUERIEIX SBYKOB, UMeIOLTAXCH 8 HOTHOM TexeTe. Pages joulsie mayan MoryT GuIT} vocmPoUsBegerE ABOAKHM CHOCOGOM: 1) nytem suesamnoft octawosx ABMKeHHa CMBIUKA, 2) nyrem cuanita cMsrka co cTPYHDI. Tlepnatit cnoco6 sieakwt R ocHoRe "pyri LITPHXOR, B KOTOPY!O RxORAT! a) OGunnosennait upux martele, uenommsemai y Konya eMEtuKa, B ymepenuon aBurxenun. us ‘A Beéran. Konopr Ne 41 nae 6) Tuoproe staccato-martelé » Onterpom xawaKenH. rHax 7 >>, aR expumansix —> han FF. KC rpynne urrpixos, ocronasmesx Ha propom enlocobe, npunasuteAKaT: a) Sautillé (npstraromyait mrpix). °* 06 avo yace Fonopnaoch 8 Neproxt rowe «Hexyeeraa cxpimaraol ure. 2 Osmue oxewenTst MyaNKAZEMOFO KemoNeNNs 6) Spiccato («Opockonniis urrpux) B cepemite CATIA ILM ¥ KbAOMEH. W. Boa. Komepe I 8) Jleryuee staccato. (gene suet) 1) ¢Henoasmxnoes (sossparnoe) staccato (y Konomia, B cepentite iy KONIG eMBI4KA). ©. Mearercou. Koanepe IL, ‘cvesmenee Haeso) a) Ricochet (saltando), 154 7Taanal ‘is neero toro cmeayer, "To B pompocax cKpHNHYHO apraxynan eb eT ne TOmEKO O eRAGHOM HIE PasneNRHOM crocoGe MenOAMEH HA. Bi Gop KomKpernoro mrpuxosoro upHeMa, conyrerpyiomlero pEaxeNbiOMy 341M oTpuisueToMy enocoOy, tpeGyer oF Hae YMCKMS PACTIOSHARAT TORRE pasaHuHa B xapakrepe MYSMKAAbHOTO MATePHAA, ‘Jhaums » nocaeaHee apeust KOMMOSHTOPH CTANH NOAKIORATKCA LepTOy- Kit (,u1a o6osHaveNis paaqebHbIx 3BYKOB) BMECTO TOMKE, COOTSETCTBY!O- jet ykopovexromy anyny. [lake Taxoll, orkocHTeMHO coBpeMeHtl aB- Top, Kak Maxc Bpyx, eine BinvenRas TOWKH BMeCTO WepTOveR: M. Bpyx. Komepr 1. IIs Presto o> & Perec eees oy oeeen Pepa eee SS ee aaa a YY Kownoswropos crapmiux noKoseHiit BBIGop MexRY MpOTSDRENIAINEL H yKopoweHHEIMH sByKAMH B PaIMeTbHLIX HITPHXAX, KA BPABEO, MpeTO- cranaieres uenoaNuTem. Zan mpanuaenoro pemenna onpesesstonni 8 hepayio oxepere BIA- ere Xapaictep npouspereuua B HeTOM, MIpeoOnanaiouui nareramecksti xapakrep MHOTHx CTapHURHX npoMaReeRMit HAcToATeNLUO TpeGyer NpH- menenita tumpoxoro détaché. H.C Bex, Coma emo 18 ‘een © Jee Buuexoropaix cay'aax ToHKMe aByKosHe rpariallsa RocrHraiores 1epe- AOpANHeM MpOTaDKeHMEIX H KOPOTKHX IITPHXOR. A. nan Bepnonee-n. p40 0p. 97-1119, 14 OGmue axementat MyanxathHoro Nenoanenna Togwac KoporRie mTpHXH cxyKAT TAKIKe CpenCTROM pedrpadtuueHiA orembitnix locrpoenuit': H.C. Bax, Conara Ne 1 exp cone 10 (een Sum) SIT Beet 2 secret = Say H.C Bax. Maxoma ys Taps 822 : ‘on Knees) fe B xamepxoii mysuixe ¢ yaactuem hoprenuaxo npuraomait uTpHx He Mower OMIT IPHMeHeH, ec B OBeITK MApTHAX Co¥eTaIoTeH BLIeTpHIe Paa acnbunie Oarypst (non legato). Peamwaxe wexxay dboprennanunm legato i expunuausim détaché ene tepnumo (110 neobxommMocTa!), HO npsiraio ual urrpux nuanncraaeckoe legato BaaHMOMCK.mOGeHSI: 18 A. nan Barzan, Coma op 47.1 z Berpynxom keaprere, np HenomHeNHM pasenbHEIX NaccarKell OnHO- BpeMeHHO HECKOMDKHMH HHCTPYMEHTAMI, TAKIKE CEAYET OTAAT PERTO- ‘wrenue détaché reper MpLIraOIRHMH IITPHXAMH, COaAAIONUIMN HeMATELe SaTpYAHeHNA B OTHOWEHNH YeTKOCTH H PHTMHYHOCTH aHCAMGueBO ur- Pur. Dro mpanio cOxpaHtAer cBoe gHaNeHHe H B OpKecTponO# mpaxTinKe. Sine sioxy ocHosanuit am sanpera npsraioulHx mTpHXxoR mpH MCTON- HonMMt GaxoscKix coummensii, ocoGeHHO ecaM coorseTeTRYIOMUNi MYIBI- Kanban MatepHan HocHT ApKo BuIpaxeuHEi «nrpoRols xapaxrep. Tlpeanozomenute 0 Tom, 470 TeXHHKA NPMTAOUIAX LuTPHXOB Guia HeMaBE- erua crapoii Kore, Jake ec cUNTATh ero AGCOMOTHO AOKASRHHKIM, He monker caysuT NPHNHHO! /LIA OTKABA OT HeHOARAORAHHS RoCTHOReHHL cospemennoit cxpunuuno% rexHukH, ecx1m OHO crocoGerayeT OGorailexHio DuIpasHTeMSURIX cpeaCTB HHTepHpeTaILIH". Pas yor Mut NPHEMHMMALTSHO BLICKASAIMCE 9a HCTOMBBOBAHHe OTPHIBHC- ‘Tux UITpHXoR, TO HOsHMKAeT BoNpoc (HMes B BAY HCTOMHEHME B MeRTEH- * Bpeme cnoell xawepnoli mysunse upeamwualino peaxo mpunexa mpurmomye enpexe. 15Tasnal HOM WaIK ymepentHo cKopom Teo): martelé wma spiccato? H sgecb B nep- bylo ovepenm peutaer obitiee HACTPOeMHe, IPMCymlee AaHHOMY UpoHswene- mmo. Hsp martelé sByxT MomHoBecHo, oneprHaxo, auymMTeMO, Intpaxy spiceato B Taxol xe crerleH cpolictueHHA PHTMKUeCKAs oMpene- eHHocTs, 10 OH Gone THGOK M BosAyeH. IIzpux martelé y Kona cMBI¥KA yMecTeH HUIb B cyepaKAHHOM ABI ‘A Beran, Komen 285.1 164 Jaro, Omran npegsowresate sation enoco6y enykonennesena, enone team nenomono cetonsenen te aneseexo Texts cme M.Bpn Keen 1.202.1¥6 TS a ee tee aaa ae = SS See From none xerrenna) Byeck npumeneue mrpuxa martelé y KOHNS CMLIUKA MpHager anyua- iio HasIMMne erkoRecHAIH xapaxrep. Martelé » azoiimarx norax o6s1uo He urpaetes y Kuna cmnIuKA, TAK aK OHO Tpey{bADsseT HOBSILTeNUEIe TPeGOUANM K MMIIEGHRIM YOHIIAM urparomero (naxuauerit axuent m ELxeTpoe HpoBeNeHHe CMBIMKA OAKO- Bpentenuo na abyx crpyuaxl). Oru yeusus moryr Guirs oOnerweHBt po- creiimum o6pasom — gamenoi martelé taxes, xpynanin spiccato y Koxoaru. J[axoro mpanusia He MOryT MOKONeGATE OTAEABHBIe HCKTO- NeHHA, caMoe HArAAqKOe HB KOTOPSIX NPHBOMUTCH B HNDKECMeAYIOMEN. upumepe: Baece verko ykasaminil KOMMOsHTOPOM UITPHX y KOHTA eMBIUKA OGyC- ‘OBAeH, LO-BNAHMOMY, OcOBeHHOCTANH HEAHANAVARLUOH CMAIUKOOH 7ex- Tipumenenme staccato-martelé nponsnoxnt weKarowrTenbuEiit advent aaoke B mpoMameneHuax cyryGo KAMepHOTO CTHLI: 76 OGmne snemenrat mysuiKaasuoro MenoaMenss pean. Koaprer op. 4. 1V.~ Martelé y koxoaku, r. e. orpisucrisi mrpHx Sea HonEEMANHs CMMI coctpytts, pH zt0Gsix OGcronTemECTBAX HeAONYCTHM, TAK KAX SHAHTE:L- no yaenuarsummiics Bec cxnItica enocoGeTayer obpasonamiTIo TEyMOBHIX npranyxon. Tlogo6xsiii cuoco6 urpi IpHHUMAeTeR B PACKET TOALKO B Tpe- HMponowmErx esx. Coremanustit urpux oGpasyer coveranue martelé y Kouta esruKa u spiccato y Koaonsa, pasjenenNBIx mexkay Cobol npoTsaDeNHMIMH BByIa- on, menosascemsiun détaché. TIpuateitene aroro MITpHEXA 3a4aCTYIO TOMO- rae OB1aqeTS HaBIKOM TOWHOrO pacupeeneHHA oMAtHKA, Ossao sBy4a- uve ero THIKeHO exuHCTBA, BCNeACTOMe PasTHnA B cAMOM MeXANHaMe anyxonanzeseuna. Jamastii cuoco6 c MysuikamsHoil TOXRM apes KeyAOR- aevaopiTenen, TeM He MeHee OH JOBONEHO 4ACTO NpHMeHsIETeA 110 coO6pa- oeumaM yno6erma. 1 yros me pore Seon gg = = Spiccato y rononkM worker npunensTsca TosIbko B MioaHice forte, » pHT- AuNveck#t XaDAKTepHBIX OMHIOxAX He eXHMIKOM GiteTporo TeMTTa. 10 Qn, xauprer op. 25.1V Pasamaue mexzy spiccato u sautillé ommHo waltz coe orpaxenne B noTHoit sanucn. Bsuto Gxt 2kenaTenbunin pas HARCEAR YaaKOHUT! 060- ‘anauenme spiccato 8 ue npamoil, saccrpenHok KuMay aansToli, a sautil \é— w nue npocroii rowen". m an Bersoven. D190 op. 1082 1¥ Sis = Hackonsxo pasamunnim mosker Oxith HcToaKoRaHHe Tou — pitettTe- To cumsoza yxoposennioro anya nero raaBHol axyerieckoll npMMeTEs Mayan, BMAHO Ha muKecsTeRYIOULUX MPHMepoR. Teopaa, noxogmman 13 tpazunii (boprenuanHoro MenomuTeNKcTRA, Yat wae, v0 emu yKOpOveHIEIH anyK HAN ake NepBstit B pany Ta 7Paanat Romnix npebyer npedwecmeyouel ayant. Kax oGerour ¢ orHM xoxo Bcxpamanol mrpe? Tipemae ncero TexHika eMaIuKa B CMemaNMLIx nrrpHxax o6yenanaHa- er qazexo ujyulee pasaHuMe B cpABHeHMH c MMANMCTHMeCKO npAKTHKO! 7. e, OM MocrapaeTes NocpenCTBOM «cHaTHA> 2-H x 6-i BochMolt mpenna- PHTL mocrerylouuei yxopovoHHMth any nayao#. Ha cxpunke nono6xuti ipwem noxasaca Gu HeecTeCTBeHHKIM, K TOMY 2ke OH CTARET NOR YrpOLY PuTwuiHocT Henoauenus. Tooroy HrpaontMih ¢ MOAEKIM npABoat Ho- ombayer snech cMeny CMBIKA KAK cDenCTRO pagnenenus mrpuxor legato 1 spiceato. MnanuerHeckoe mpasHsio, Tacatnee 0 TOM, ¥T0 YKopOweHHO- MY SByKy omen MpenmecTBoBATe XOTA Gh MUEMATEAT Mepepiie B SBy- ‘uanHH — j34 Hac, cxpunavell, xeficraNTeNEHO AMINE B TOM cAyAC, ecm ocnonuoi, npeoGuazaouyaih rei HpoxaReAeHUS OKAIMEACTCH AOCTATOUHO MeATeHITSIM, YTOGKI MODKHO Oxislo ceGe NOIROMHTE ary «aByaamyio Naysye Gea ymepba 118 pwTma. ‘Tax, a nceraa cknosnce k MEeHIO, “To B CKPHTITUHOM KoMLEpTe, Ha- MucanHom nuanuemom Bpamcom, Towxa ua 2-i mecrHagnatolt HHKecre- ayiomteli purmiuecko dburyper m3 gate He nosokHa 6u1Tt HousTa GyxDaLHO, 7. €. PaIxeMbHHOCTh ZOCTHTACTOR 9KeCE Me «cHaTHeM> aByKa, a nonpocTy cmeHofi cuntuka. IIpH Gotee HoRYepRAY- ‘TOM pasqenensH He TOAGKO ABTOMATHECKH 2AMEAIACTCA TOMI, HO TAKIKE, BeAeACTBMe CTepeoTHIHOTO YKOPAYMBAHAA, HAHOCHTER saMeTHTutl ymteps ‘epoGone zatepmperanin. Ecau nocneauuit onyk cxMronaHHolt rpynitit HOMEIEH TOUKO!, 70 OH Moxer OirT» aHOo ormesteH OT npeNBIAYEINX sByKOB, NGO TOTBKO YKOpO- ‘We, T. e, e7O MOIKHO BAST ABOAIKHM cTlocoBoM: Ognaxo wamepexua KommosHTopa, Kak MpABHLA0, OTBCUAET MHEIL BTO- poit crioco6"*. Tax, xampumep, BeTxowed 8 OAOOHEIX CHYUARX YALE ReeTO Mpeqnownracr sameHHT® TONKY BLITHCAHNO! Nayaoit, HaGeram TeM caMuin mpenparintx Tomkonaxcaii: I. Berxone,Kaaprer op 130.1¥ Obmue saemenrit Myoumaasmoro Kenoamenna B mpormponec aromy: Creayer aanee yueers 10 oGctoatemscrno, TO yKopauHRanHe aRyKa, HOMeweHHoro TOUKOI, LOKHO HAXOMUTECH B ONPERETEHHOM COOTHOLICHHH ceromoMMnanbHoit AuMTeEHOCTEIO. ITO MOXCT OMIT MATEMATHUECKH BLI- paxkento npocreiiuiM o6pasom: n xkepray npuNocHTCs NoxOBMHA AIHTENE- Eure Gosiee waxes, ocoGenno 8 KamepHoit myabike, cxMTaI RoNpOC Ke HIO- ancupoakoit. Menoannrent k KoHnY 9Toil YacTs OMyIIaeT HOAHOE HSHEMO- akene, HO We MOsKeT flaake MPHOAMIMTECK K AOCTHLKeNHIO TpeOYeMOrO BBy- xonoro peayitsrara. Becnaoquste yeuuusA CKpHTAWa YXORAT Ha TO, TOO ALUOANNT UpeAMMcARUM WOAHC, MOXbIYACe MepanNOHATBHBIM Mps- MOM, KAKHM SBISETCS AMIDKEIHIE CMBUKOM BANS B BOCKOAAIEM Taccaze crescendo m cwsIKOM BBepx Ha sf B uucxonaMemt naccaxce diminuendo. * TIpmnexennoe moe, orvennino oGoanawertioe Berxonenoxe conocrannenme dim. (/p) serese, ame noaro mutegaer 9 HONK apeNtia wenonsueTexei: 2 emTaanal Oomne xemontus myauixansnoro weno. “TlepenepuyTHer iuTpHxi, NlocneAOBATeAIBHO NPHMeHSeMELe HA npOTADe- ust ncelt Y8CTH, NPORBORAT ageck MoMeTHHe TyAeCa: Sanne a eee 2ata spot ee 7 v Beraer Sompoc: KaKHMM cooGpaxKeHHAMM PyKosO_CTBYeTCR KoMHOSH- ‘rop, BHOCA Te HAM Eble ZuHAMUUecKMe yKasaHUA? Orser HesarpyqnuTe- sien: crescendo osnawaet mpuGauaKenue K HeKoeli KysMmHALOHHO! TOI ‘ke, socruraemoli up mioauce f. Dra Kybmunaiyes (p upuMepe MoMeveHa epecr#koM) 10 Gomtsinea aacr cosmagaer c Bepuimnoli (7. e. caNaIM BBICO- kui 38yKOM) MeTOAMECKOH ¢bpagst HIM MOTHBA: 1H. Byane. © r9H0 0p. 8.1%. Beam @ a ee hd pe f —" ee Hucxoqauiemy AsiKenm0 MenonMH, osHataOMIeMy ocaaGseHKe Ha- parxeniis, Walle Bcere conyrerByer saTyxauue cums sByaHOCTH: I. an Berxonen, Kaaprer op 9283, 1 t en Hrex, aasoxeuue auepx — crescendo, nuns — diminuendo. Dro «n0- Mauunee Npasutor, Kaxnot Ger ynPOUIeMHEIM OHO HH KagasTOCs, MoRKeT pac (cManpHEATSCA KAK OCTOB, Ha KOTOPOM HosRORUTeM Boe SAAIe AMHANHIC. 90 Boe ake us stor0 mpasiina ects unomecrao uck moves. Tpextite neero 910 BHesamHoe piano, exexylouiee HenocpemoTBeHHO va Hapactastnem. Ha- syiavenue Toro moalica — NpuaNed, BENMaHMe cyUIaTesta Ke KaKOMY-mH- 60 HeommpaxHoMy rapMoHMecKomy HAH MeOAHYeCKOMY OSOPOTY: I. nan Berson. Kaaprer op. 5903.11. oy legetetttl ee Space eee E Bee nHesannioe u wenpegungennoe, BosHuKaiouyee B mpoecce rapMons- Meckoro MAM MeOMMUeCKOTO PASBUTA, HAXORWT CROC A/lEKBATHO BOTLTO- uexne B aayxono% aunamuxe. Buesanioe piano uckmOuHTeBHO IIEPOKO pena Berxonen. Osureynorpesurexsunii npiem monayas nepen plano, KoTopomy Mpeqiecrayer auuamuyeckoe Hapactaitie, oOtstcuAeTeA B MepRyIo o4e- eas coobpaxkensamnt akyeraecxoro nopaitka. ITpH mueaanoll, He pasxe- JieHnoit naysoit emene rponxoit m THXOH sByaHOCTH penepbepallisl SBy:O- BEX BOK, MMeIOIHX GOsBIIYIO ANANTYAY KOneGANH, Moker NpHBeCTH Knormomeno THXOH 3ByUHOCTH, BILIOTE AO «HLYeDOTO® HTH. Ke KpaiiHe He- oruermuporo ee BocrpHATHS. B otom cayuae moprnaysa wenarenbua xors Obi B KeAAx coBmoneHttA axyermueckoit uucroru. Pasymeeres, ona He AOAKHE OkITh tepectyp Am1- Teabxofi. Hcroanenue, CHOI HaILIMMTOBAHHOE HORUEPKHYTRIMH zLiOdyT- aysaMu, slerxo npHobperaer orreHok NelaHTH1ecKoro LEXOAApeTaA. ‘Tnuaserseckoe narneranne B ero HanGonee ecrecTReHHoM H HocnenoRa- ‘TenbitoM mqe OGpasyereA coomuHeHHem crescendo u accelerando, aaTyxa. Hue — cauaunem diminuendo u ritardando. Paaymeeres, aunanieckit orrenor ne oGasarensHo omKeH coveraThca ¢ arormueckum. Hicxyecreo (‘bpasuposkn cocTouT 8 YMeHHE Kak OGEeAMEATS, TAK M pASAeNATE OTH AKA onemenra. Hago yers yeuiupar> Gea Toro, "To6i4 omHORpeMeHHO 61TH BAI Hynqensam yeKopsrs, a decrescendo mnomMATE 6o3 SaMeqeHHs TEMTIA. Crescendo u accelerando: 228 pocostngetoQaana 1 Diminuendo » ritardando: Crescendo allargando: H, Bpawe, 1, x90 0.8 20 t er pe pcd we Diminuendo u stringendo (animato): Hpac. © anaprer op 25, Coda 231 Saimato 4sD¢yperrow oxo+ HasiiBaeted RHecanoe YMeKDINeHMe CHB SByKa UDR: GyknassHOM MopTopeHHM KaKOTO-nNGO MysbiKamSHOrO MocTpoenHa HH! Motpa, 9ro moaHc ocobexHo xapaxrepex aia myssixut XVIII croaerua. m B.A. Monaps: Koamepe Ne 4.1% 4, Onuaxo HeenarensHo, 170K Ha ocHORe sToro MpMeMa BosHMKaNas Ipianiuka crepeorismoro ¢MaroHH4A KarKqoro NoBTopAloMyerocs MOTHBA. ‘Uso nonyanaock 6st HPH TOM, HaNpHMep, Hs ynepropst [Hymaxa «Mand peu, rxe MONTH Kasai MOTH KpoBoAHTCA ABA pasa nonpan! Kpoxe TO- 10, Hawukad ¢ Berxonena, B oTHX CnYYARX IPOABARETCH TeHREHUMA K ycu aero. 92 OGmue oxemeurar xyauRaannoro xenoamenns Tlaccaser ua enpoxonamnxs sByKoR B MyaHiKe RoGerxosentcKoft Mops npespantaioren y Berxosena # ero nocneaonatencl 8 sonymennenusier épurypst. B cxpanmusx Konneprax Mouapra uaccackan dpairypa savac- yl ene He maxozuTca 8 OpranHyeckolt cnaai ¢ rnanbiM TeMaTIT¥eCK MM MaTepHaTOM; ce MpslMoe HaSHANeHMe — cay2ItTs OCHOROIK ALE ZeMOHeTpA- vx MctoMmTeTEM eBoero MacTepCTBA: B.A. Mousgr.Konuepr Ne 4.1 2 7 Ho yoke » GerxosencKom Konuepre maccmkH O6pasyior HeoGxonmcoe AOnOmMeHHe MeNoUNecKoil AMENH; OHM TECKO CBsLaaEHI © Melk Ht OBpAMA Jor ee mogo6Ho Tomy, Kax MaI0L OBRMRAeT AyGomtAl cTBOR: 25 Co om, JI. aan Berson. Komtepr. 1. B Mocw npegcranienuu sagxpexr oxo» cumnonuanpyer smoxy, Korma Myauumponanue paccMarpunan0ce ckopee Kak MpMsTHOe zoGanmeHMe K enetexoit Gecese, Yew Kax cltocoO BAIPAMeHH GOIN XyROMeCTBCH- uuix H duocodexux ugeit. Umenio nootomy nami mpuex, Ha Moi Bara, B MYsbiKe MlOcmeGerxXoBeHCKOrO HepuoAa BCTyTIAeT n MpoTHBOpEYME cocranem. 93.Tana I Plano kax. cpencrao paarpaHMeHHA MeTORHYeCKOTO azIeMeHTA, C ORHOR cropount, H puTMHMecKOrO HIM rapMOHMecKorO — c ADyrOM, HMeeT Kap- aunambiioe suavease. Boabmem x ipymepy penko wenomnaemoe Andante ua 2-1 conaras Baxa am cxpunkut como: 2388 Breck mexonns poo | Hogaepyasa BTopsIM FOOCOM, OGpesyIOuyEM PHTMHYECKYIO I TOHAMBRYIO ‘onopy: eam curpar c oaunaxonoit cuioit nepsite Tp BocMBe B IDEM rO- oce, To MeOAHs MpHMEr esenyIOITUA BHA: rob naGerxart noxoGHoro HeKaxKeMHA, KeOOXORHMO [aT NOYYBCTBO- baz» nay9y Ha Tpetsel BocMoit aepxttero ToN0ca; ANA BTOrO TpeTHtt SBYK 0 nomex OuiTh CHIPAH HA HecKOBKO cTynenell THIIe! Tipmeezem nepasiit nepon Andante c oGosayenuaMH mioancHpoaKit coraacuo ykasaMHomy mpHAmny: 4 OGmue snementh MyaMRAKINOr RenoReRKA nyo Sa = ca eee Barnep saxaeiinus upogowkurenkHyi0 Wrpy B HiORHICe piano muxparxKe- eM ¢MannTIecKas MONOTOHHOCTES . Mery TEM pontag B AUMANHTIEC- KOM OTHOMeHMH SBYYHOCTE Ha CYPYHUKIX HHCTPYMeHTAX IpeACTARIET CO- Golt TPYAHO AOCTHMEEI Hea. Mul He TOBOPHM ameck O HeOOXOREMOM CHOKOHCTSHN H YnepeHHOCTH m BEECH CMAIUKA, 0 %KENAEMOM POBKOCTIE SeyUAHHA MPH HTpe B paamuaEx ero uactax. IIpeaMononKHN, 470 KeHO-- murens oGnagaet jocrarouNo# exoGooll H MaBKocTsIO B coeAMHeRNi cMBITKOB, CTPYH It HOAMUE, OGecHemAsIONIelt NeXpepMIBHOCTL H TaCTH HocTS aByuanns Ho aame a oToM caywae ocraerca ele mpeoaoner® raapEnit, mpenay- ulecrsenuo mcuxozorsaecknit Sapsep. IIponomxurenioe THx0e sBy'A- He, Kak MpABHAO, CBASAHO ¢ BHIPADKEHHEM CAEPKAKHOTO YRCTRA, Hpo- ‘cpeTHEHHOTO M YMyAPOHHOTO MupocorepHaNHs, OBLIMH cnolicrmeHHOTO avium apenomy Bospacty. 1Onocr# 2Ke Goxsunel uactbi0 mpHcynI crpact- HOCTS 1 HeT1O¢peACTROHKOCTH BUIPAIKCHME, NpoMOTeKAIONIHe OT HAGLITIA utsnuecknx m ayLIesHEtx cuut. He notomy aM y MomOAIX MysbiKaNTOD pen- Ko MONGHO YemSIIUATS J.IMTesTEHOe, BELIepIANHOe HB TO Ie BPE DOT owamsuo HanomHeHHoe piano? Bo II uacra expymisuoro xoumepra Berxo- Beit Ha MporarKeHuM NOWTH BCero Nepsoro MepHORA OGosHaLAeT MIOAHC PP, 8 Bo BTOPOM Pagnene MpHOaRnaeT K 9TOMY YxazaEHe sempre perdendosi, 1. @, He NPOCTO THXO, a KAK Oui NOCTENeHHO HCveaaM, PACTROPALCH, OTPEUTA. ses oF Oxpy>xalomIeTo Mupa MOF camcoro ceOs. OmHaKo ¥ Gonmuncrea CkpHnavelt ota BEICOKAK, MHCTHTUecKam RXOXNOREHHOCTS UHABOANTCH 10 yporna opauuapxoll ckpunuunoi karrHxenut; HoTHEEEIit xapakrep MY2sI- in — mpomsaenue rayGouaitmero, wo cxpurroro, cnepaxanuoro yBerBa — EDM 9TOM MomHOCTHIO yrpaumBaeTeA. OxeDMANO, cocOGHOCTE BDIpASH ‘TexpHomy piano na Goasmiom npoTaxemu npeqmonaraer BBICOKMit yO- bent ckpuiitunoit, Mysuikam.noit x 2yxomHoit KymuTYpEI, KoTOpETit neTpe- ‘aerea Kpaiine peaxo. ‘Auuioruumise npumepir 13 GeTKoneHcKoTO KoUNepT a. mw eee feat é ere £ ‘Conon PB) cy Ue a Tipu menoavenuu conar aaa ckpumem 1 oprenuarto THx0e sayuanne Taur B ceGe onacnocts norepx ssyKouoro Gaxauica OSoux MuCTpyMeHTOB, NockomBky MHAHeT BEInY>KeH COOGPAIOBATE CHTY HATLUEDOTO yaaa He CTomsKo ¢ MpeAMMcaHHMIMH AHHAMUYECKHMM OTTEHKAMKL, CKOMBKO C AAM- TomuoetHio orgeLInsx sByKoR. Tax, HampaMep, n I wactH @oprennaiio- 95Taana 1 O6mue a0m Th MyAMKaanHoro Menomwenns ro tpMo Berxosenta (op. 70 Ni 2) HcnomunTembeKas TpaxTonKa Aact Ham caexyiomylo KapTHHy COOTHOMEINS OTACIBHBIX MapTuil c TOUKM speHHA usta B ro npesa kax erpynubie, B cooTBeTeraiH co cMuICzIOM ¢ppashi, O6zIerY ‘uquor any'iocTh Ha NonORAHHOM HOTe ¢ TOAKOH — MHaRCT BEIRYACIEH, Ha ‘oGopor, YoHLIHTL ce ¢ TeM, YTOOM RIATHIT GBYK K TpeTLeit YerBepTH He y:1e~ ‘rywiulest Ghi CORCEM, — OAHA Ha TUINBHBIX UpHAHE, nO KoTOPOME Tom canaune spysnoctH ‘boprenuaHo H CTpyHMLIX OKAsuIBAeTCA Bee-TAKH HETO- cerwskcunsnia i Tbtmamuueckas MoHOTONHOCTs MO2KeT NposBRATLCH MB NOCTOAHHON| arueraxnu rpomKocTi. Takas MaHepa Mctlonuenua 8 TexHMMeCKOM OTHO MIeHNHt HecpanHeMHo MpONTe, ona He TpoOyer cxoaLKo-mNOyA» sHAMHTET Horo HAKPAIKEHHA AYXORHEIX CH, HO HA CHYX AYAHTOPHH OHA feitCTBY ‘TAK 2ke, Kak “epectyp apKutil cpeT Ha ceruaTKY raasa, OGBIuHO 97a MAH a uger pyka 06 pyKy c MsnecTHolt Ayitestiolt npaomunemnocts¥, cBOH Craeoit HenomEMTeN!0, KoTOPAS B MOMIOAMe TORM HPOABATETCH B BUA erpeMseniis HocTosEHO eHATH HanpomoMs, Ges comHeHMii M AOMTHX pai ayant «Bacrummmes, Hatonro pactanyrute f u mf, navxe ecaim OHM dpopream wo npenmmcanst KoMMOaHTOPOM, KOKI GiuT» oTaeprayral. BoTInX cay'A4 AX HeobxOMuMA AUyhepeHIUALLNA 9BYNHOCTH, MpoRoAMMAR B cOOTBETCT- RHKC€ HONeMANM # chageMM mexomHYeCKOfi JUHI: 35, ‘A Duyn Koey hm ae c—— SE B xamepuoit myanke Monapra n Taiiqua wacto pcrpeuaetcn noeex0B8-| une piano u pueaasoro forte 6ea coonnuuremsnore crescendo. ¥ Hac A0| cux Hop Her TouHEIx MpABHA Ans NonOOMBIXx emy'aen. Ecau paccmarpuBars| TOT NONPOC # MCTOPHECKON MAKE, TO HIBeCTHO, YTO OCOBATEM TAK HE aumaemoli maxreiimckoi ukomsi S14 Cramsn (1671-1757) snepsse BBex, crescendi u diminuendi » opkecrpony. upakTuxy « 5 ocoGenHocTH — B UDAKTHKY erpysHo-cxnvKonoro uenoAMMTeNseTBA. Xora TBOpYECT Taiiqua a Monapta onupaecs ia gocrunkenis Maxredimnen, o6a 97H macs repa Kpaiisie ckyno uenlomsayior cresc. u dim. Bosunkaet ponpoc: wmesoT: aM mipaBo coapeNtentibie Knaprerstite HeNOAHMTERH 0 cpoeMY YeMoTpeHEO | 06 snofHTE JONOAMUTEMEMLE HOACH, HeXOAN H9 MPHENEIOB NanrlimcKofi iwkomu? B yenom, «nenogrorommentioes forte amum B peakux cayyasx oatocTbIo cormacyerca ¢ HAMM MYSHKAABHLIMH MpeACTAnEMHAMH: B.A, Monapr.Konuepr Ni 4 24 gqenb cei Brece adppexr snesenioro forte, yeustewm peak sayvannen yKo- poventuisx nochMisx ua crpyne Cons, xefiorayer noxo6uo YARPY KyAaKON. Tost coxpasexs sMpMeckoro xapakrepa TeMM HeoGXOAMMO CoeAMH ‘rensttoe crescendo u emarsenuas, sMloayKoporkass apruiyasuns ZBYX AIKeNSHBIX ROCKMBIX. Eom B MOROGHHIX cxty"UAAX MerkAY YURCTHILCAMH suicanGna BOsHNKHYT pasHioraacH, 70 cxeayeT urpars ettopHoe MecTo pas- $HHBINHC er1oCOGAMM 0 TEx Op, OKA He GAT THepTO YeraHORIEHO, KA- xoit us napuantos oGnaaaer Geayeaonnsin upennyuyecrsox. Kak 681 TO HH Guino, anTopekwe AUMAMHUECKHe YKAIAHNS B npONaReNeHHAX ROGETXOBEH- cxoro nepHona HHKOHM OGpasom He NOAH PACCMaTPHBATSCA B KavecTBe Hempepekaemoro «cxona Gonsero>. Hhoanc /p, 7. e. wemeaennoe ocaaGaeune sey wnocrH, TaKoKe ne Bcerza caeayer nonuMars GyxBambHo. Sto ke OTHoCHTER H K aKiLeHTY, oTMeveN- omy 8 HoTax snakom sf. Takoll axiient ocoGenno YacTo ocymlectBAReTCH rnocpegetsom rpy6oro npitnoxenna CHT (B BITE PHIBKa, TOTKA, yAapa), bie coorsercrans ero oOilemy AmiaMmYecKoMy yPopilo AaxHoro smIMsORa ie xapaicrepy npontaseenna B iyexom. Sforzando morker HMerh APHICC ini apamariteckiti OTTeHOK, m sasienstocTHN OF npeoBAaAOIeTO B My- suike Hacrpoeia. B nepsom cayuae sf exopee Bcero wo2Ker OuiTt NeToAKO- BaHO KaK mfp, BO BTOPON cilywae ONO NpexnonaraeT Goce peaKnh asykovolt Kourpacr™. Dro pasaH“ne caMLIKOM Maso MpHEMMAeTER BO BA manne, ocoGexHo mips wenoaHeNM Monapra. Breck, HA Molt nana, HaOGoper, Tpebyercs HeoBnerdenHoe sf: B.A. Mousyr Knaprerd-moll KV 421. + lee. 97Boobate mae xancerem, sro sf y Monapra conavaer Gomyo crenemy rpomxocri, ve mpocto suesamuoe /. Heo6xonuMo Takake KocHYTLes HeKOTOpHIX OrpHuarenBINIx MomexToR | ‘uueto rexuuveckoro nopsinka. IIpeakqe Bcero a0 pagAYBAHMe H aaTyXestHe pH cBasiiBANHM ABYX cOCeMMMX 3BYKOB; 3ATeM eRoIOUIeer portamento, © KoTopou, KaK 0 TeXHHWeCKOM HexocTATKe, MOAPOCHO TOBOPHLTOc® B ep BOM TOME; jee Sf HA AAKNOUNTETBHOM GBYHe NACCARA, BOGHIKAIOUIee eeACTEHE TOTO, "70 CMEINOK peaKO ¢epHIBAeTEAS CO CTPYTE. A. nan Berson, Konner a 4 UH, naxonen, youenue ssyanocrH naxuinara 10 cpapnenino ¢ upemuie- crayoulelt Tpex1s10, 470 OGLIKO coueTaeTeH ¢ npeyBeTHIEHHLIM pacuIMpe- MMeM ero BO Bpemennt. Tem cawaiN HaxmLaary KPHAReTON aHauEHHe,, Ha KoTopoe OM AMKax He Mo>KeT mpuTasaTs. Kax B AHHAMUUeCKOM, TAR MB AFOTuNCCKOM CMBICHE HAXIMTAr He FOMKEH SEMETHO BRIRCAIATHCA HO KoHTeKcTa H OcoGeHHO — 6hITs rpome rem. rect iat Paspeman co6e Monmukaiuno AMMaMuveckix upeamucannii, Hcnon- rem noquac BepHo yrajtinaer cxpkITMit aaMttcen anropa. Tax, HanpH- Mep, Berxosen 8 raasioit tee II] vaca cxpunusnoro Kouuepra o603Ha~ ‘daet moaNe p; 9707 HloaHc ocTaeTea B cue Aats OSouX, cmeAYIONHX APYT 3a ApyroM upobexeniit rextat (a crpysiax Comb x Mn). Paammune tem6pa or1x {ABYX CTPYH camo no ceGe OGyesaBMBAeT KONTpACT B XapaxTepe SByYANIEA. ‘Momo npemnososxurs, To conocraRneHHe My:kecTReHIoi CHIH Tpa- ui BxoqHAO B HaNepeHua KoMToaHTopa. He npuganan nepromy 1poBeHe- ino temst rpyGoro, Hamopucroro xapaKrepa (KAK 9TO WACTO MOKHO YerKI- IaTb), MBI Bee 2Ke He CHHTAEM DOGMOXKHKIM TPAKTOBATH TEMY CXEpIKAHHO HW cyX0, Yemy ckmouser Hac asTopcKHi HIORHe p. B ABKHOM CHYuBe MODK- Ho emexo aamenute p ua mf, —— 250 af necro? * Cnt @aeu K. Mexyecrao ceprmanod arpis. 7. 1. M.: Mysuxa, 1964. C. 43. — Mpux. ped. 98 Oomue sxemenrat wyauKabHoro HenoaNenna Crom 2xe onpasaaxo npustecenie akuenra, ecru om okaduIRaeTCs He- oGXOAMMEIM AA BOAUMOMORUMALHS YuRCTHHKOR asteau6an, B uHKeceny- foUleN MpUMepe YAUCOHHOe ABILKEHHE, BRITOTHAEMOe YeTEIPRMA HHCTPY- MOHTAMH, HPOSBYWHT CHHXPOUNO AMUIL IPH TOM YexOBHH, ComM NepBAS cHsIbHaa Jona GyaeT «npunevaTanA® aKieHTOM, YTO 1OSBOITET C cANOTO HA- aula YOTaMOBTS ERI, UpaBHALAL Tem. asy—P.lyaan, O-a, comer Ih Tlowuso store Moauduxanua qMHaMuecKux yRasanuit moxKer GxiTh noaesHoli B uegaroruxe. Mu umeem 8 Buay cayuail, Korga yueumK c Ha KAOHHOCTHIO x cbNerMaTiHCIecKoMy TeMnepaMeHTy UpUBLIUHO cROmuT f HP nelitpambHomy®, Geciwperomy m/ mH mp. B noxo6tom enyuae nenaro- ry cleaver NOOMIpATS AMMaMudecKMe upeysenMueNNa. OnacHOCTS cucTe- MATHYeCKOrO BOCHUTAHHA CKNOHHOCTH K MPeYBeNAEHUAM He TpoaHT 10 ‘rex Hop, Toxa quierMaTHKy, y2Ke AOCTHTHIEMY OFrseKTHBHO ¥AOBNETHODH- ‘TeuIBHBIX SBYKOBKIX PesyABTATOR, IpomowWKaeT KasATECA, TO OM MpeyBE- amuwmaet cBepx MEP. Baxuefiumit Bonpoc, Kacwompiiien mpakruveckoro MpHMeHeris Ha- RHO AMHAMMKe, MBI MpUGeperaH AZIM OKOHYAHUA BACTOAMIerO PasqezA, Poun waer o npiasannt orgocutesbioro xapaxvepa ncex newaTiTlIx 060- suaveHMi Auwamurkn, ocoGeHHo Toraa, Koraa MYsbIKy perlpoayumpyioT He DOAMHOWKY, a B compymectBe c ADyrumu mucTpyMenTaNH. CHsIa oBykKa, Oe- sycaoBKo gocraToMHad Ais TOTO, uTOGM AOOUTECK BTevATEHNs NlOsIHO- asyanoro forte 8 comuoi conare Baxa, wo2ker oKasaTsca pastocutbKoH piano, ecau 8 urpe yaacrayer apyroit, Gonee Mout uUCTpyMoHT. B pe- samopnok conare Iymana nuaxucry caeayer BRINOANST» HIOAHCHPOBKY c nemwuaiimelt ocropoxuocrsio, TAK KAK NAprHa CKPHNKU NOVTH HOBCEME- ero yRepacMmaeTer B cpesHeM PerucTpe, Hero 3ars1yWIAeMOM BBYYHOCTHIO ‘oprenuano. B 10 >ke Bpems TOMHO pacesHTaNHOe H BLIBEpeHHoe piano pH YaACTMM APyroro MUCTPYMeHTa, HrpanMero eine AeAMKATHEE, MO2KeT CLIT bocpimato Kax m/f. Tlootomy b aHcamOs1eB0i HTpe, MOMHMO BLINOAKEHMS newarHaix yRasaHuli, Heo6XOAHMO WeTkoe Hpexctamlenue o Gonbitiell HAIK Mensutoll sHaYHMOCTH TOTO HJIK MHOTO MOTHBA KaK MOPHLIO Au YeraHOR.TE- mua TpeGyenofi cu ssyka*. Couposoxyaioiue durypst, HOAOGuBIe TEM, KoTopAie HPUBOAATCA HHDKe, BAYIAT HAROHLANEO, CAM CTeMleHD HX TPOMKO- TM He cuuaena 40 BosMonHOro upegea: * Honewan npoGnews, soamneasomaa » Gocunexenmx mapuanrex m uponecce Kaa: ‘ermisx penevHIil, HAXOAIET Choe BLIDANEHAC B CREAYIOMIEM XAPSHTEPHOM EIOTE. Tlepsuri cxpunas, o6pemascs. Ko aropoy (1a naoGopor): «Tloxanyiiera, urpaiite Pano, rea on aac. Bropocrpans— nepeouy (nx manfopoy «fle, oy me 99Taazal Bo rropom raxve npuMepa 258 ckpHniaX He OsDKeH NOHMMATE GykcnaLtk Ho ykaaanne cresc., TAK KAK 9TOT MioAHe He MOsKeT Ost NOMMEPAKAH Bopxs| uM roocom dbopreriatio!” ass (empee) Ina Berxonen, Conara op, 24.1, one) Bxecs nepsoit expumxe nocze fp cpaay »xe npegctoxt norpysuTbea B cy MpaK pp, wro6st yerynuT> rmanenerno Bropoit cxpunKe. B TpeTLeM TaIcTe| nepssiii ckpunay goasKex ucromssonars crpyny Pe, umaye om axe mpH cae MOM JOTKOM aayKONIBIeYEHHM, Ma-3a CRETIO OKpACKM erpyHEt Js, HEA Mpeseauo sarayumr stoporo cxpumava. Buppasiipane sayunocra versipex Hcrpymenton knapreva, auiqene~ ue TemaTHeckHX TOXOCOB H SaFYIIeBKIBAHHe BTOPOCTeNeKHBIX, KOpOWe TO- ops — acuocrs pce‘ KoETpanyRKTHNecKo!l TANH CTaxioRATCs Tol HEAT. Holt KouewHoit nemmio, KoTOpAS Moxker Oki AOCTINHYTA TOmTKKO TpyAHOH PeneramZoHnoi paSorol. B ocoGennocrH nepaomy cxpHHaYy HaNeRKHTy orga cx10n0 Geper Bropad cxpINIikA, Ohith TeM Oonee CkepaKANTBIM, TEN 28: ernce npenocronerao oro snyowtis nanecrs (nit mateeTs ero imterpy” Bee nummieckasanxoe nonrsepauaeT, TO BAAneHMe AMHAMUYECKHMH rpaqarManae BXOAMT B APCEHAT TEXHAUCCKHX CpeNCTA CKPHITAYA KAK BADK- nefimas cocrannas wacts, OawaKo Ro Reel Haulell or:oRuo! mTepaType MBI PACHOMAPAeM, HACKOABKO MHE MABECTHO, JIMIh ORKHN-CAMHCTREHAIM nocoSwext To AAHNOMY PaateAy: # HMeIO B BURY ANHAMHIeCKHe OTIORA P. Ioana (uaaanme Bpelirxoma x Teprens). a.tbueiimee takonnenne coormererayiomlero HHCTPYKTHEHOTO MATepuaA GutnO Ohi RECKMA ZENA Tenuusim. OnyGauKonaHHan B Kavectse Mpusoxenus K mepooMy TOMY «Vexycerna ckpanmunoit urpats «Cucrema rams raicke Moxer Lith HC- onbdonaun Aan veenoowonaecx yzpaxaenn, MAmpanenmMsx Wa OnzARe- sue quamsnxoll. 100 Oomue oxemenrit MyauIKaanHoro MemomHoHNs ‘Tem « ero MameHeHns (arormna) Tew oakauaer Mepy RpeNEHM, onpexeAsONTyIO akrHYeCKyIO AUETE NK ocTh aByKO B MYBHIRANDHOM MpovtancnennM. ATOrMKA — MOHSTHe, HDE- snenioe 8 MYKIKAABIEYTO TeOpInI PaMAHOM H OKPRAYMeRAIOITIC® HaMeHERNS ‘TeMMa, O6YCTOBAEHHEIE KHBLIM, THOPYECKHM XAPAKTEPOM BCETO HCHOAHM- ‘reuexoro mponecca. TeMtt mponaneyeHia, TAK 2° KAK M OeOeRKOCTH et JHIHANDIKH, YoranaDzuBaeTeR c HOMONIBIO YonOBHBIX SHAKOB Hutt rreMMATS- {nx Tepation. BuuMaTenbioe OTHOMICHHE K HHM Hit R KAKOR Mepe Re Oma ect TpeGonaniia wateavirieckoi rowocr.. Henoxmenie, oTMeeHHoe Hever apmteririeckolt auDuayamnocT#, Oo.tee Beero wapyer HACeHHO ‘Tet, 470 OHO NOcTORHO OTCTYTAeT OF CTPOFHX MIKOABHBIX MpABILT. Merpo- HOMMCCKIE TOUHAS HPA MOET GMT HAIBAHG KOPPERTHOM, HO B HOTON offa HoKeeTes cayiazesno GeanyuO#, MeprHOf, MexaHMecKol. Outy- Ilene senoro, nuiparrrenLioro HenomeH#eA nOaKMLKAeT MaBHEIN O6pA- 50M KAK CXERCTAHE FHORIX, NOAGAC ee AAMETHRIX TEMMOBKIE CABHTOR. kana O6menpunarunk WTambAHCKHX OG0aHAYEHMIt TeKORA: Largo, ‘Adagio, Larghetto, Andante, Andantino, Allegretto, Allegro, Presto, Prestissimo. Tonaras, 70 aiaveHHe oTHx TepNHHOR OOMLeHIRECTHO, Mit orpaniiuitMen BeixcHenHeM OFAeHKAHIX KexOpaayMeMti, OOHMKAOMIX pH RO6pocopecTHOM npowTeltNst TeKeTa, a Tale YCrpAHeHHEM. HeKOTO- Dunk, YROPenUBILHIXeM ¢ TeNeNHIeM Bpewel, HenepHx NOuATH. “Andante — Ten cxopee onuinaetnsat, ext pacranyriil (andare — ma: 1, neroporimno Gpecti). B XVIII neke Andante, no-BigurNowy, st7paoce Guicrpee, eM celivac. B orsomiesix tema Andantino cymecrayer wesc xocrs, Muorie nonaraor, u70 970 OGoakaveKite — He 170 WHO, KA YMesD immeassian dopa cxona «Andante» i orwocitreA Aith x OOweMy’ Tposave enun (im ero wactH), a He x TeuMy. OAuako Ha mpaxruie Andantino Conmmuneren or Andante Gance Texy'iM K oRHOBpeMeNIHO Goslee rastanTasN xapaictepom. Larghetto — 20 wesioro yexopenoe Largo, Allegretto — “‘ayTb samegtenHoe Allegro. Monapr 1 Berxonex 8 ObICTpBIx 4aCTHX OBONECT- nonasiich ykaaanmen Allegro, Nacto AoGannag K HeMy NoacutomAll Tep- wank — aperto, molto, assai, moderato, maestoso, con spirito, grazioso, vivace, con brio, risoluto, energico, appassionato, cantabile, piacevole, scherzando, commodo* 1 r. 1. He cneayer peerga NoMMMaTh 9TH OGosHAeHHA GyxeanpHo**, BI uactn 2-A boprenmannol conarsr [ymana nomeyeno «Tai Srrenpo, KaK TomSKO BoSMOMHOr, GmuKe x KOKNy — «OuteTpee> m enyera 16 ‘raxron — «ete Gicrpees. B III wacrit ero ake cxpumNHOH coMaTSt op. 105 Mx axonuM Ha porsaKentin neeli wacri yieaaannn: eTuxo, rpocro>, «HTeMHoro owcntenneee, «Hlemnoro nogssxnees, «ITpemmiecrayionii Tesi, — K Ka ROMY no Nepotsx Tpex yieaaalttit erHociTes enobo etrpentecrRyiOUtiits? * Honocrua aaSanuaz omu6xa oxnoro no nepenewnkon npoussestenuit Berxosens, peaparunazero «Allegro commodo» Berpyasiom Kpsprere op. 127 (IV secrs) «Allegro con motor ‘%* Toxrop Meppar a «Ciuryorax crepol x wosod Beusc+ upmsonir exeayroutit pant: ‘+B sax-Semot-mexcopaoxe kaaprere op. 127 Berxosen oGosuaun rie-ro noceperiie Tenn Andante, Ho paccraaeae, cxpima BEM, NononKsn eaaprer B UpUCYTCTENH as: Top, coxpanun » stom wecre NpermeereyiontWllTeNt, NoAares HOSTED STHNE COMBIETO nesarnenua. Hloene wenoanenna Berxonen Bova co cTy.e, Wsaek Wa KapAcAHA Kapau ‘am, aarepreny no neex NerHIpeX HAprAK cxom0 «Andantes, seveH HOBEDH.ACA K Me omen i supasiia um exon Gnaroxapnocry. 101Paaeat Ososnavenne Poco Andante Taxske nopoit caysKuT HeTONHHKOM HenO~ pasymennit. Ilepenenentioe OyKRanLHO, OHO ooHaaeT eHeMuOTO WATOMe; nescHo, uMeerTca sm B MAY Gonee NejLeHHAS HH Goslee GuIcTpaR XOTKGa, B xenonumremucxoit mpaxrinse Poco Andanto, tax 2«e kax Pill Andante, urpaeres "yt GxieTpee, vem mpocro Andante. 1. Bpave. Cora op. 78. 255" Aiagiow st Pi Andante essa) Bo It wacra expnnussoro Konnepen Bpanea, a aayxraicronom tutti op xeecnpa tlepex navasiom arioaa b araues Mattope sero oGodmaten0 rit, C nocrenyrouius pid largemente. Bomtaramerao expunaeltm farpmceDo howeay-ro npespamaior ovo viagasnne n stringendo mn Zambmeliiest coor enetnedo yexopaior reM. 256 90% Paannuine Temopnix o60aHaYeHH Ro II YaCTH nA-MEKOHOIL conATSL Bpanca Taxace Gomsurelt wacTbi0 He IpHAUMaeTCA BO BRUMANIE: 1. Byun. Comara op 100.115. faoiaaee Bs SS 102, Oomne oxemonrst myanKazuoro Menoamonus Wexona wa temnosuix obosnavenuit, Zarinix KosmosuTopoM, weno ‘rest YeTAHABMMBAET TenepasbHLAlt Team cero MpoMaKesIeHAL WK ero WaCTH. Fea ror Test Hepepen, TO MYSLIKATLMLIe HCH, saOrKenHEZe B NpOHaBETE: HN, He nomyaior eBoero nonMoMteHUst, cami xapaKTep ero HCKaxaeTCsH. Beat Amxe Heanaurvesiiuie OrkNOHeHHA B CTOpOHY YoKOpeHIIA HH BaMeR- neHAM TeMIIA OPO TAIOT PASTE MYSKIKAIBHO-ICTETHMECKHUX BIIEWATIIE- nuit. [lootomy a aprucra uckamrounTenbHo parka ciIocOGHOCTS c caMore HAWAIA «yXRATHTES Tex, HaGoxee cooTBETCTBYIOIMH XapakTepy HCION- neMOro, yaepaaTs e7O lO KOMMA, HesABHCHMO OT BCEBOSMONCHEIX AFOTHVC- CRUX HOMeHeHIL, ROIHIEMONIHX To XoAY ucnoMMeMA. Ecau ayia onpesene- "niiz ocHonHIOTO Teva HaxtHtO Gosice WIM Mestee OOLEKTUBUEIE AANHEIE B BILE yoxosuix oSoanavennil, ykagaNua alla breve, a raxoke xapakTepucrHk, CO- TepokANEXCR B CANOM HAQHAHHM MPOMABEAeHEA, TO NpefcTaRtaeTca 503- ‘MontHOCTE paaymaio RanecHTD Ace eas M enpoTHBe. OzuaKo czeayeT ocrepe- PATKOS Nepectyp AWKTATOPCKEX NpeAMHCANK; B BONpOCE ycTaHORAeNAA emia 3aKOHLI MySLIKaTLHOH mUTepnpeTaltH G2ee HEM THe Okt TO MH GLO cooBpaaylores c.auuHocTHIO iHTepHpeTATOpA.. Haxoaiexue npanuaiuioro Tewa B anawTeNLAOH Mepe o6ycxonaeHO TeM, KAKOBA YKASAHEAA KOMNOSHTOPOM OCHOBHAS eAMHMTIA HSMepeHAA raxra. Kean olta nokaakeres caumikoM Os1erpoi No oTHOMeHHIO x tIpeANA- caHHOMY TeMy, TO ee JenaT HA Ke, A y HeHomHTENeH, TaroTeORMX MORNCHHBIM TeMMAM, — AaxKe Ha YeTEIpe AoaIM. OTH eNeHHA ocHOBHO! eaHHMUBI TAKTOROTO HEMepeHUA cyIeCTREHHBIM OOpAIOM BKENOT Ha onpe- exteHMe TeMnA: eM Goubine Aone, Tex MesuTeHHee, HEM MeITBINC, TEM 6x- cempee, Hmenio novtomy Andante — ecau ToasKo oxo He pactanyto cnepx epat — cnenyer 1aGerars GeccosuatemsHoro zereHua ocHonMoit exMMHnES, 1. €, HaNpuMep B TpexieTBepTHOM TakTe HY2KHO OTCUMTRIBATE YeTDepTHt, fa Hin Koem cayune He pocbabte; » Adagio pexomenayerca nocTynaTb Kak aa nao6opor: 25 Andante cantbie A. Monagr Konept Ne 4. I B.A. Monspe Konnepr NS. 119. 289 Mago deste O6osnavtenue ¢ (alla breve) rpeSyer ocoGoro BHUMAHHA UpH EIpe B MeA- JeHHOM TeMne, TAK KAK B 970M CHYaae OHO MpemMOAraeT COxPalteHste YKA- anol enuHMn HaMepeHia M MeIuOAeT aemIeHMe TaxkTa HazBOC”. To 2 OGosuaxerne m Gonee OxieTpHX TeMNaX, KAK MpaBHA0, peRyeMarpuaseT Comanne xayx ens B OEY. 1, pave. Contra op 100.1114 Alegrtt gris (quasi Aan)