Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Advanced Combined Cycle PDF
Advanced Combined Cycle PDF
GER-3936A
GE Power Systems
Advanced
Technology
Combined Cycles
R.W. Smith
P. Polukort
C.E. Maslak
C.M. Jones
B.D. Gardiner
GE Power Systems
Schenectady, NY
Advanced Technology Combined Cycles
Contents
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
System Integration Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
Performance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
Steam Turbine . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
Shaft Train Configuration. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
Features . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
Steam-Cooling System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
Integrated Control System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
Plant Arrangement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
Repowering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
List of Figures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
List of Tables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
Fuel
Heat Recovery
Fuel Steam Generator
Heating
System
To
Stack
Cooling Air
Cooling
System Attemp
Filter
Feedwater
HP IP LP LP Generator Pump
LEGEND
Cooling Deaerating
Steam Water Condenser
Air Treatment
Water
Exhaust Filter
Air A
Fuel Gland Seal
Air Filter Condenser
B
Condensate Pump
Condensate Filter
heater to pre-heat the fuel gas supplied to the ture effect on performance for the STAG 107H
combustion system. The water leaving the fuel as well as the part load performance. The
heater is returned to the cycle through the con- graphs in Figure 4 show the ambient tempera-
densate receiver to the condenser. ture effect on performance for the STAG 109H
as well as the part load performance.
Performance The low NOx emissions are achieved by a Dry
The rating point thermal and environmental Low NOx (DLN) combustion system. The
performance is summarized in Table 1 for the closed circuit steam-cooling system also con-
advanced technology single-shaft combined- tributes to the low NOx emissions because a
cycle units burning natural gas fuel. The minimum of air bypasses the combustors for
graphs in Figure 3 show the ambient tempera- cooling the gas turbine hot gas path parts.
NOx
Thermal Emissions Thermal Discharge
Combined-Cycle Net Net Heat Rate (LHV) Efficiency ppmvd at to Cooling Water
Unit Power, MW BTU/kWh kJ/kWh (LHV), % 15% O2 BTU/kWh kJ/kWh
Notes:
1. Ambient Air Conditions = 15°C (59°F), 1.0133 barA (14.7 psia), 60% RH
2. Steam Turbine Exhaust Pressure = 0.04064 barA, (1.2 In HgA)
3. Performance is net plant with allowances for equipment and plant auxiliaries with a once-through
cooling water system
4. Three-Pressure, Reheat, Heat Recovery Feedwater Heating Steam Cycle
110%
95% Power 99.5%
Basis: 100%
90% 15°C (59°F) ambient temperature, 99.0%
1.013 BarA (14.7 psia) ambient pressure, 90%
60% relative humidity,
85% 98.5%
0.0508 BarA (1.5" HgA) ST exhaust pressure,
2 x 851mm (33.5") LSB 80%
80% 98.0% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% 50.0% 60.0% 70.0% 80.0% 90.0% 100.0%
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 Power Output (Percent of Rated)
Ambient Temperature (°F)
Figure 3. S107H ambient temperature effect on performance and part load performance
Basis:
90% 99.0% 100%
15°C (59°F) ambient temperature,
1.013 BarA (14.7 psia) ambient pressure,
60% relative humidity, 90%
85% 98.5%
0.0508 BarA (1.5" HgA) ST exhaust pressure,
2 x 851mm (33.5") LSB
80% 98.0% 80%
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% 50.0% 60.0% 70.0% 80.0% 90.0% 100.0%
Figure 4. S109H ambient temperature effect on performance and part load performance
HP Throttle
Pressure (psig/Barg) 2400/165
Temperature (°F/°C) 1050/565
Hot Reheat
Pressure (psig/Barg) 345/23.8
Temperature (°F/°C) 1050/565
LP Admission
Pressure (psig/Barg) 31/2.2
Temperature (°F/°C) 530/277
Exhaust Pressure
Pressure (in. HgA/barA) 1.2/0.04064
The low thermal discharge to cooling water specific back pressure conditions expected
results from the high efficiency and the general requires low-pressure section designs with a
characteristic of combined-cycle systems in broad range of exhaust annulus areas. This is
which approximately 30% of the unit power achieved by selection of the last stage bucket
output is produced by the steam cycle. length and the use of both single-flow and dou-
Bottoming cycle steam conditions are tabulated ble-flow exhausts. Table 3 summarizes the last-
in Table 2 for systems that produce the perform- stage buckets that are applicable for the
ance shown in Table 1. The combined-cycle sys- advanced technology combined cycle units.
tems are also available with 124 barA / (1800 Applications with low condenser pressure
Psig) throttle pressure which may more opti- require a steam turbine with a double-flow
mally suit systems with lower cost fuel or a mid- exhaust. This two-casing design is similar in con-
range duty cycle. figuration and construction to that applied by
GE in single-shaft combined-cycle applications
Steam Turbine with F technology gas turbines. The high and
intermediate pressure sections are combined in
A wide range of steam turbines are available to
one casing connected by a single crossover to
suit specific site, duty and economic require-
the center of the double-flow low-pressure sec-
ments for both 50 Hz and 60 Hz applications
tion.
while satisfying all of the combined-cycle inte-
gration requirements. Since there are no Operation is with sliding pressure with the con-
extractions for feedwater heating and since trol valves wide open. A control stage at the
steam is generated and admitted to the turbine inlet is therefore not required.
at three pressures, the flow at the exhaust is
approximately 30% greater than the throttle Shaft Train Configuration
flow. The last stage generates up to 15% of the The single-shaft power train is configured with
steam turbine output, so the efficiency of the the gas turbine on one end, the steam turbine
turbine's last stage and the sizing of the exhaust in the middle and the generator on the other
annulus area are particularly important for all end, as shown in Figure 5. This close coupling of
combined-cycle applications. The range of site- the steam and gas turbines permits full mechan-
COL.
COL.
T C HP LP IP GEN.
SINGLEFLOW,
SINGLE-FLOW,
DOWN
DOWN EXHAUST
EXHAUST
COL.
COL.
T C HP IP LP GEN.
TWO
TWO FLOW,
FLOW,
DOWNEXHAUST
DOWN EXHAUST
THRUST
THRUST BEARING
BEARING TIETIE
RODSRODS
KEY
KEY FOR
FOR SHAFT
SHAFT POSITION
POSITION SOLID
SOLID COUPLING
COUPLING BEARING
BEARING
Total 86 17,967
line. The gas turbine cooling steam return and extraction after the first superheater pass is
any HP steam turbine exhaust steam not used used to cool the LP steam turbine from ~70%
for gas turbine cooling are reheated in the speed until steam turbine loading is underway.
HRSG and admitted to the IP steam turbine. Figure 2 includes a diagram of the three-pres-
During unit acceleration to rated speed and sure, reheat HRSG. While the system can be
operation at low load, the gas turbine is cooled configured with either forced or natural circu-
by air extracted from the compressor discharge. lation evaporators, Figure 2 shows a system with
The air is filtered prior to supply to the cooling natural circulation evaporators. The HRSG is a
system. The cooling air from the gas turbine typical three-pressure, reheat HRSG that is com-
cooling circuit is discharged to the gas turbine monly applied in combined cycles. It includes
exhaust. During air-cooled gas turbine opera- the following features to accommodate the
tion steam flow is established through the steam steam cooling system:
supply system to warm the steam lines and sta-
■ The reheater size is reduced since part
bilize the steam supply conditions prior to
of the reheating is performed by the
admission of steam to the gas turbine cooling
gas turbine cooling steam system.
system. This steam is discharged via the
reheater to the condenser through the IP ■ The reheater is located in the gas path
bypass valve, which is modulated to maintain downstream of the high temperature
the pressure of the cooling steam above the gas section of the HP superheater. The
turbine compressor discharge pressure to pre- reheater receives steam during all
clude gas leakage into the steam cycle. operating modes except at very low
Appropriate shutoff valves isolate the gas tur- loads during startup, prior to
bine cooling circuit from the steam cycle while availability of IP steam.
it is operating with air cooling. These cooling ■ HP steam is extracted after the first
steam shutoff valves are included in the trip cir- pass of the HP superheater during low
cuit such that the system is transferred to air load operation to establish gas turbine
cooling immediately upon an emergency shut- steam cooled operation before the
down to purge steam from the cooling system. steam turbine is loaded and provide
Initial cooling steam supply and line warming cooling steam to the LP steam turbine
steam is supplied from the HRSG. Steam is above ~70% speed.
extracted from the HP superheater after the ■ Control of the HP steam temperature
first pass and mixed with steam from the HP is accomplished by a steam
superheater discharge to supply steam to the attemperation system which bypasses a
cooling steam system at the required tempera- section of the HP superheater. This
ture. The cooling steam temperature control system eliminates the potential for
will match gas turbine cooling steam supply to dissolved contaminants to enter the
the gas turbine compressor discharge tempera- steam as can occur with attemperation
ture during transfer from gas turbine air cool- with feedwater. Attemperation steam
ing to gas turbine steam cooling, which occurs is extracted after it passes through one
prior to steam turbine loading. In addition to pass in the superheater to assure that
providing start-up cooling steam supply to the it will be dry after the small pressure
gas turbine cooling steam circuit, the HP steam drop across the steam control valve.
Supply of high purity steam to the gas turbine steam supply to the gas turbine. This device will
cooling system is an essential requirement of operate at least 24,000 hours without mainte-
the system for efficient long-term plant opera- nance when provided with steam meeting the
tion with high availability. Features included in system purity requirements. The upstream sys-
the system to accomplish this requirement are: tem design features and associated protective
■ Reliable condenser leakage detection strategies provide a means of assuring the
system with redundant condensate design life of the steam filter.
conductivity sensors and automated Figure 6 presents the location of the steam and
protection logic. water sampling points within the S107H and
■ Full flow feedwater filtration. S109H combined-cycle systems. All sampling
■ All cooling steam is purified by probes and instrumentation (including a sam-
evaporation in a steam drum with pling panel) are of high sensitivity and reliable
continuous monitoring of drum water design. Steam and water conductivity, pH, and
purity. sodium measurements are continuously sam-
pled and monitored. Other measurements not
■ HP steam temperature control by
required for plant protection are monitored
steam attemperation.
intermittently.
■ Full flow steam filtration.
■ Application of non-corrosive materials Integrated Control System
in piping, filters and equipment
The single-shaft combined-cycle unit is con-
downstream of the cooling steam shut-
trolled by an integrated, computer control sys-
off valves.
tem that coordinates the gas turbine, steam tur-
The steam filter is the final line of defense bine, generator, HRSG and unit auxiliaries to
against particulate contaminants in the cooling start, stop and operate the unit to meet system
Na Na
Si
CC CC 1
CC
SC
HP Steam to IP Steam
Steam Turbine, pH LP Steam to
to Gas
Gas Turbine Steam Turbine
Turbine
HP LP
IP Drum
Drum Drum
2 1 1
SC SC SC
Si pH pH
pH
LP Steam
Turbine
1
Exhaust
CC
Filter
B
Legend: All samples are taken on
SC - Specific Conductivity continuous basis
CC - Cation Conductivity Note: All HRSG sampling requires
Na - Sodium Analyzer cooling and temperature
D.Ox - Dissolved Oxygen compensation, minimize time for
Si - Silica Analyzer sampling process
pH
power requirements with input from a control load and daily start service. The high degree of
room operator or from a remote dispatch area. control integration maximizes automation of
The architecture for the single-shaft integrated startup, shutdown and normal operations,
control system (ICS) for a single unit is shown which reduces plant operating costs.
on Figure 7. Figure 8 shows the architecture for Easy to configure color graphic displays provide
a multiple-unit plant. a common look and feel to both the unit and
Generator
Static
Steam
Turbine
Gas
Turbine & HRSG & Unit HMI/ • Time Synchronized Unit Controls
Excitation Steam Cycle Auxiliary Server
Starter & Cooling
& Mechanical Control
Bypass Steam
Protection Auxiliaries
Control Control Alarm
Printer
• Time Coherent System Data
HRSG/MA
BOP
Gas Turbine
Generator Equipment
Steam Turbine
A redundant data highway connects all control plant level control. Windowed displays enable
components with the central control room con- the operator to constantly monitor the desired
soles. Historical archival and retrieval of plant process and simultaneously view detailed pop-
data assists performance optimization and up windows to trend equipment operating data
equipment maintenance. Time synchronization or diagnose process problems. An engineering
of all control components provides time coher- workstation enables the operator to configure
ent, time tagged data for process monitoring, and tune control loops, perform detailed con-
historical archival, sequence of events logging, trol and process diagnostics, maintain software,
real time trending and comprehensive alarm manage the system configuration and generate
management. High speed communication operation reports.
interfaces link the plant control to external dis- The ICS is designed with dedicated I/O
patch and control systems. (inputs/outputs) to control the engineered
The control and protection strategies are inte- equipment packages. In addition, it has the flex-
grated between all components of the system. ibility and expandability needed to address
High levels of fault tolerance maximize unit additional I/O requirements to satisfy individ-
starting and running reliability for both base ual owner requirements. This includes both
Remote Dispatch
Control Room
Gateway
HRSG/MA
BOP
Gas Turbine Equipment
Generator
Steam Turbine
HRSG/MA
BOP
Gas Turbine Equipment
Generator
Steam Turbine
Redundant Unit Data Highway #3
Operator
Station
Generator Steam Turbine Gas Turbine HRSG & Operator
Static Balance
Excitation & & Cooling Steam Cycle Station
Of
& Starter Bypass Control Steam Mechanical Plant
Protection Control Auxiliaries Alarm
Printer
HRSG/MA
BOP
Gas Turbine Equipment
Generator
Steam Turbine
redundant and non-redundant I/O which is close at 105% rated speed and reaching the
integrated with serial remote I/O (e.g. fully closed position at 107% of rated speed.
GENIUS, Fieldbus) and connections to pro- This normal governing characteristic is overrid-
grammable logic control systems. All I/O points den by a power/load unbalance-sensing feature
are available to the controls database for the upon the sudden loss of significant electrical
integrated system. load. Pressure in a steam turbine stage, repre-
The speed and load control for the unit oper- sentative of steam turbine output, is summed
ates through control of the gas turbine fuel with a gas turbine fuel flow signal and continu-
valves. The steam turbine control valves are ously compared with the generator electrical
closely coordinated, being closed at startup output. When a significant imbalance of power
until steam at sufficient pressure and tempera- generated over electrical output is detected the
ture for admission is available from the HRSG. control and intercept valves are closed as rapid-
They are then ramped open and held in fixed ly as possible, limiting the speed rise to less than
position as load is changed with sliding pres- the 110% setting of the emergency overspeed
sure. The steam turbine control valves do not trip. Ultimate protection against excessive over-
participate in normal frequency control. The speed is provided by the emergency governor
HP and LP control valves begin to close when that trips the unit by simultaneously closing all
speed rises to 103% of rated speed and are fully gas turbine fuel and steam turbine control and
closed at 105%. stop valves.
The intercept valves operate in a pressure con- The sequencing system automatically starts the
trol mode at low load to maintain proper steam unit from a ready-to-start condition and loads it
pressure in the gas turbine steam cooling sys- to gas turbine base load or a preset load. Table
tem. With increasing speed the intercept valves 5 shows starting time from initiation to full load.
lag the control valves by 2% speed, beginning to Figure 9 presents an overview of the starting and
loading sequence for a hot start. Figure 10 is a steam turbine has a single-casing and single-
similar presentation of the cold start sequence flow exhaust as would be applied at a site with
of a single unit. Note the speed hold shown for steam turbine condenser cooling that accom-
developing steam for steam turbine cooling, modates the higher range of exhaust pressures.
which is not required in multi-unit installations Plants using steam turbines with double-flow
where running units can be used to support exhausts are approximately 10 feet (3m) longer.
steam turbine cooling needs of the starting The plan area for the 60 Hz advanced technol-
unit. ogy combined cycle is approximately 10% larg-
er than that for current technology combined
Start Standby Time to cycles, while the power is increased approxi-
Designation Period (hrs) Full Load (min) mately 60% so that the plot space per unit of
Hot 0-12 60 installed capacity is reduced approximately
Warm 12-48 120 45%.
Cold >48 180 Plant related considerations that influence the
selection of the single-shaft configuration for
Table 5. Starting time from initiation to full load
the advanced technology combined cycle are
tabulated in Table 6. The gas turbine cannot
Plant Arrangement operate independently of the steam cycle so
The high power density of the advanced tech- there is no operating flexibility advantage for
nology combined-cycle systems enables a com- the multi-shaft system. The single-shaft system is
pact plant arrangement. Typical plan and eleva- lower in installation cost because of the single
tion arrangements are shown in Figure 11 with generator, main electrical connections, trans-
overall dimensions for outdoor STAG 107H and former and switchgear as compared to two for
STAG 109H plants. In this arrangement, the the multi-shaft system.
110
100
90
..% Speed, % Net Plant Output..
80
Normal loading
70
60
OUTPUT
50 Bring steam
turbine on
40 line.
30 Transfer
from air to
SPEED
20 steam.
10
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75
TimeTime
fromfrom
Synchronization (minutes)
Roll Off (minutes)
110
Speed hold to generate
100 steam turbine cooling
steam.
90 (Not required for multi-
..% Speed, % Net Plant Output..
50
SPEED
40
Transfer
from air to
30 steam
cooling. Basis:
20 Single unit with auxiliary
OUTPUT boiler sized for steam seals
10 and condenser purge only.
0
0 15 30 45 60 75 90 105 120 135 150 165 180 195 210 225 240
TimeTime
fromfrom
Synchronization (minutes)
Roll Off (minutes)
Figure 10. Typical S107H/S109H cold start loading profile, single unit
Multi-Shaft
STAG 107H STAG 107H
Single Shaft (One GT/ST)
Equipment (Quantity)
– Gas Turbine 1 1
– Steam Turbine 1 1
– Condenser 1 1
– Cooling Water Trains 1 1
– Generators 1 2
– Main Electrical Connections 1 2
– Generator Transformers 1 2
Steam Valves (Quantity)
– Main Steam Non-Return 0 0
– Reheat Isolation 0 1
– Reheat Relief 2 2
– Reheat Stop/Control 1 1
– Low Pressure Non-Return 0 0
Foundations High High/Low
Installed Cost Low High
Operation
– Combined-Cycle Simple Simple
– Start/Stop Simple Simple
– Load Following Good Good
– Contingency Management Simple Complex
– Islanding Good —
– Simple Cycle No Yes
Staged Construction No Yes
A
C
Nitrogen
Air
Gas
Cleanup
Heat Recovery
Steam
Generator
Cold Reheat
Hot Reheat
Main
Air
Exh. Gas
Nitrogen
I.P. Coal
Coal Gas
Steam
Water
L.P.
Oxygen
integration of the steam cycle with the gas tur- water permits can minimize site
bine cooling system requires appropriate con- permitting work.
sideration, but several methods for matching A wide range of steam turbine ratings can be
the cooling requirements to the existing steam matched to the MS7001H and MS9001H gas
cycle are available and include the following: turbines by retaining existing feedwater heaters
■ The cooling steam temperature and as may be necessary to meet exhaust flow limi-
pressure for the MS7001H and tations.
MS9001H gas turbines are in the same
range as those of the cold reheat Conclusion
steam in many conventional steam
The GE advanced technology combined cycles
units with 2400 psig (165 bar) throttle
promise improved economics of electric power
pressure.
generation with outstanding environmental
■ Apply cooling water and existing performance in natural gas and coal-fired appli-
support facilities and replace the cations. These characteristics are enhanced by
existing steam turbine with a modern, the evolutionary development from a technolo-
high efficiency steam turbine that is gy base with extensive experience, which
specifically matched to the combined- assures low maintenance and reliable, conven-
cycle requirements. This option is ient operation.
attractive when the use of existing
List of Figures
Figure 1. Advanced technology combined-cycle unit
Figure 2. STAG 107H/109H cycle diagram
Figure 3. S107H ambient temperature effect on performance and part load performance
Figure 4. S109H ambient temperature effect on performance and part load performance
Figure 5. S107H and 109H single-shaft STAG equipment configuration
Figure 6. Steam and water sampling schematic
Figure 7. Single-shaft combined-cycle unit integrated control architecture
Figure 8. Multiple-unit station control architecture
Figure 9. Typical S107H/S109H hot start loading profile
Figure 10. Typical S107H/S109H cold start loading profile, single unit
Figure 11. Single-shaft unit plan and elevation
Figure 12. Unitized advanced technology IGCC system
List of Tables
Table 1. Advanced technology combined-cycle – thermal and environmental performance
Table 2. Advanced technology combined-cycle steam conditions
Table 3. Last-stage buckets for advanced technology combined-cycle applications
Table 4. Single-shaft combined-cycle experience
Table 5. Starting time from initiation to full load
Table 6. Combined-cycle configuration comparison summary
Table 7. Ratings for advanced technology IGCC plants