Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3 PDF
3 PDF
ABSTRACT
3
Corresponding author. TEL: +39-079-229346; FAX: +39-079-229273; EMAIL: delcaro@uniss.it
INTRODUCTION
Olive oil plays a special role in the category of vegetable oils for many
important reasons. One is the balanced fatty acid composition reported by
many studies (Fedeli and Testolin 1991; Hill and Giacosa 1992; Martin-
Moreno et al. 1994; Roche et al. 2000), which rank this product as first among
dietary fats. Moreover, specific sensory characteristics and the presence of
other important components in the unsaponifiable fraction, which accounts for
the nutritive and health-giving properties, distinguish extra-virgin oil from
other edible vegetable oils (Khor et al. 1998; Visioli and Galli 1998; Owen
et al. 2000). These characteristics are mostly intrinsic to the oil, although some
result from the extraction systems used which do not involve refining pro-
cesses, and therefore leave the unsaponifiable fraction unchanged. On the
other hand, many other factors influence the quality of the oil, such as the
olive-ripening stage when picked, the olive variety, cultural and harvesting
practices, the health of the drupe, the interval between harvest and processing,
and pedoclimatic conditions (Montedoro and Servili 1992). As in other foods,
the quality of the oil decreases during storage. The reduction in shelf life is
attributable to lipid oxidation mechanisms which lead to rancidity. It is known
that these reactions are catalyzed by light and heat and are partly slowed down
by compounds belonging to the unsaponifiable fraction (phenolic compounds,
carotenoids, tocopherols) (Gutierrez Gonzales-Quijano et al. 1977; Lercker
and Capella 1997; Aparicio et al. 1999; Gutierrez et al. 2001; Servili and
Montedoro 2002; Del Carlo et al. 2004).
The antioxidant effects of extra-virgin olive oil seem to be a result
of the phenolic compounds, as the oleuropein, hydroxytyrosol, tyrosol,
4-hydroxyphenylacetic acid, caffeic acid, vanillic acid, syringic acid, etc.
(Kris-Etherton et al. 2002; Tuck and Hayball 2002), of which content depends
on the cultivar, climate and degree of ripeness of the fruit. Also, carotenoids
and a-tocopherol are important antioxidants because they protect oil from
auto- and photooxidation (Psomiadou and Tsimidou 2002a).
In the last years, the production of monovarietal extra-virgin olive
oils has increased because of their chemical and sensory characteristics
(Psomiadou et al. 2000; Aparicio and Luna 2002; Morello et al. 2004), and
Italy now has more than 30 protected designation of origin extra-virgin olive
oils. As in Sardinia most of the O. europea L. trees belong to “Bosana” cultivar
(used to produce extra-virgin olive oils) and as so far there are no studies about
storage of oils obtained from this cultivar, a work has been carried out to
determine the influence of storage period and different exposure conditions
(light and dark) on quality parameters, phenols, carotenoids, a-tocopherol,
chlorophylls, oxidative stability and antioxidant activity of this monovarietal
oil in order to assess its shelf life. Extra-virgin olive oil was analyzed until 18
STORAGE AND EXPOSURE EFFECT ON BOSANA QUALITY 141
Sampling
A homogeneous sample of 10 q of olives of the cultivar Bosana harvested
in December 2002 with no defects and at an optimal stage of ripening (70%
just turned dark-colored and the rest green), was processed in an industrial oil
mill using a three-phase centrifugation system, after defoliation and washing
of the drupes. The olives were crushed with a fixed-hammer metal crusher
(model MO 30, OMT, Grassina, Florence, Italy) and the olive paste was
kneaded for 35 min at 30C. The paste was then centrifuged (model GAMMA
1, OMT) at a flow rate of 600 kg/h, using 300 L/h of water. The oil phase was
further clarified in an automated discharge vertical centrifuge (model Elma
2500, OMT).
The oil obtained was stored in hermetically sealed 60-mL colorless trans-
parent glass bottles. Bottles were filled up leaving a headspace of 3 mL and
exposed to either direct sunlight or in the dark at room temperature 22 ± 3C for
18 months. Analyses were carried out as soon as the olive oil arrived at the lab
and after 2, 4, 6, 8, 12 and 18 months of storage.
Free Acidity
This was determined by the methods reported in EEC Regulation 2568/91
of the European Union Commission (EUC). Data obtained were expressed as
gram of oleic acid per 100 g of oil (% oleic acid).
Peroxide Index
We used the method described in EEC Regulation 2568/91 of the EUC.
Data obtained were expressed as milliequivalent of O2 per 1000 g of oil
(meq O2/kg oil).
Antioxidant Activity
Antioxidant activity was measured in the phenol extract, by the method
described by Brand-Williams et al. (1995), using a decoloration curve of the
stable radical 2,2 diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl (DPPH·). Fifty microliters of the
sample were made to react with 3 mL of a 6 ¥ 10-5 M solution of DPPH·for 1 h
at 515 nm and 25C, in order to obtain a decrease in absorbance by the radical
DPPH·. As the graph of absorbance versus time showed that the decrease
followed a fourth-order kinetic (r 2 = 0.99), it was possible to express the
antioxidant activity as -OD-3/min mg 103, i.e., with the following equation:
1 A3 − 1 A30 = −3kt
a-Tocopherol
This was extracted by the method reported by Psomiadou et al. (2000),
using a Waters 625 high-performance liquid chromatography equipped with a
spectrofluorometric detector FL3000 (Thermo Separation, Muskegon, MI) at
STORAGE AND EXPOSURE EFFECT ON BOSANA QUALITY 143
Oxidative Stability
This was measured with a Rancimat apparatus (Metrohm Co., Basilea,
Switzerland) using an oil sample of 3 g at 120C and 20 L/h airflow. Stability
was expressed as oxidation induction time (h) (Laübli and Bruttel 1986).
Statistical Analysis
All the analyses were carried out using two containers for each sample,
making two determinations for each container, for a total of four analyses.
Data were evaluated by a two-factor completely randomized factorial design
using MSTAT-C software (Russell D. Freed, MSTAT-C Director, Crops and
Soils Sciences Department, Michigan State University; Version 2.0). Storage
period and exposure conditions (light or dark) were chosen as variables.
Means, where appropriate, were separated by Duncan’s multiple range test for
P ⱕ 0.05 and P ⱕ 0.01.
TABLE 1.
INFLUENCE OF STORAGE PERIOD AND EXPOSURE ON MAIN QUALITY PARAMETERS
OF BOSANA EXTRA-VIRGIN OLIVE OIL
K232 K270
Data followed by different letters for each source of variation and column are significantly different by
Duncan’s multiple range test.
** Significant at P ⬍ 0.01.
UV, ultraviolet; ns, not significant.
Source of variation Chloropyhlls Carotenoids Phenols (mg a-tocopherol Oxidative Antioxidant activity
(mg/kg) (mg/kg) gallic acid/kg oil) (mg/kg) stability (h) (-OD-3/min mg 103)
Data followed by different letters for each source of variation and column are significantly different by Duncan’s multiple range test.
* Significant at P ⬍ 0.05.
STORAGE AND EXPOSURE EFFECT ON BOSANA QUALITY
** Significant at P ⬍ 0.01.
145
146 V. VACCA ET AL.
TABLE 3.
CORRELATION COEFFICIENTS AMONG OXIDATIVE STABILITY AND ANTIOXIDANT
ACTIVITY AND THE PARAMETERS CAROTENOIDS, PHENOLS AND a-TOCOPHEROL OF
BOSANA EXTRA-VIRGIN OLIVE OIL
* Significant at P ⬍ 0.05.
mainly linked to its fatty acid composition (especially the ratio of oleic to
linoleic acid) but are also important minor components as tocopherols, caro-
tenoids, etc. Therefore, induction period is the result of the fatty acid compo-
sition and the simultaneous activity of various prooxidant and antioxidant
factors endogenous in the oils (Psomiadou and Tsimidou 2002a). Some
researchers state that oxidative stability measured by Rancimat is not a stan-
dard quality parameter, but it is a useful tool to gain information about the shelf
life of virgin olive oils (Aparicio et al. 1999); others say that it is useful only
to evaluate differences in oils obtained with different technological processes
(Lercker et al. 1991). So we can suppose that total phenol content itself cannot
explain the variations observed in our data, especially for the last two sam-
plings. Therefore, this point needs to be studied more deeply to explain this
phenomenon.
As regards antioxidant activity, a significant decrease was observed
during storage. Samples stored in the light retained higher antioxidant activity
than those kept in the dark. Correlations between antioxidant activity and
parameters reported in Table 2 showed significance only for total phenols
(Table 3) (Del Carlo et al. 2004). Antioxidant activity, determined by the
method previously described, was not correlated to oxidative oil stability
(Pizzale et al. 1999). We can suppose that the lack of correlation in the samples
during storage is because of the fact that polyphenols undergo hydrolysis
reactions during aging, as reported in other works (Del Carlo et al. 2004).
CONCLUSIONS
In conclusion, the results of our study revealed that the extra-virgin olive
oil of Bosana olives is a shelf-stable oil. In fact, after 18 months of storage, the
oil can be still considered extra-virgin, thus conforming to the shelf life stated
in the label. This in part could be attributed to the high original content of
148 V. VACCA ET AL.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
REFERENCES