Professional Documents
Culture Documents
9 Henry V and English Nationalism
9 Henry V and English Nationalism
9 Henry V and English Nationalism
Ryan Thomas
more
Contact Author
The 1989 film Henry V incorporates many nationalist themes, but principal among them is the
conscious change of social organization from the feudal and hierarchical society of feudalism to the
egalitarian and national based cultural organization of the nationalist nation-state. The film presents
a stark contrast between the English, who are egalitarian, united as one nation, and joined as one
people under one banner, against the French, who enjoy only the support of a clique of divided
nobles in a deeply hierarchical and unequal army and society. Through a depiction that goes on to
contrast the English society and army against their French counterparts, the arising traits of English
nationalism are portrayed and strengthened in contrast to French feudalism, highlighting emerging
characteristics of English nationalism and the imagined English community and their glaring
absence in the French cast. Throughout all of this, the key word is "portrayed" - Shakespeare's
interpretation of Henry V and Agincourt says more about his own time than about the year 1415.
When, during the pause of battle, the French routinely choose to ransom their prisoners, they do not
express the converse for the common soldiers. The nobles must be sorted from the common men,
separated from the mercenary blood. One cannot imagine such disdain for the average soldier to be
expressed by King Henry. The French Army of Lords is many things, but it is decidedly not an army
of “brothers”, as in the case of the English.
I would readily concede that not all of the elements that will one day characterize the modern
nation-state are present in Henry V of course. The entirely literate population, the universal clerisy,
has yet to emerge, as have the economic structures of the industrial society not visibly in the offing.
At this time, there still exist foreigners in English service - - although perhaps the Scots, Welsh, and
Irish can be viewed as those plainly drawn into the orbit of an emerging English dominance over
the islands, rather than against the nationalist ideal itself. Although portrayed as a nationalist
struggle by the English, the war itself was still fought over the old dynastic struggles of old. But to
worry upon these points would be to quibble to excess. In Henry V the vital components of English
nationalism as portrayed by Shakespeare are present.
Footnotes
1 Ernest Gellner, Nations and Nationalism (New York:Cornell University Press, 1983), 10.
2 Gellner, Nations and Nationalism, 10.
3 ibid. 63
Works Used
Anderson, Benedict. Imagined Communities. New York: Verso, 2006.
Gellner, Ernest, Nations and Nationalism. New York: Cornell University Press, 1983.
Henry V. Dir. Kenneth Branagh. Perfo. Kenneth Branagh, Paul Scofield, Derek Jacobi, Ian Holm,
Emma Thompson, Alec McCowen, Judi Dench, Christian Bale 1989, DVD.