Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Liquidos Barrera EB
Liquidos Barrera EB
Barrier/buffer
media for
mechanical seals
1
On the following pages, basics, terms, and Purposes and function Barrier/buffer media are also used if process media
the purposes of barrier/buffer media are explained. with a high solid content have to be sealed.
This leads to the properties of the ideal If mechanical seals are used in pumps or other Particles may enter the sealing gap which can lead
barrier/buffer medium. Finally, standard barrier/ machines like mixers or dryers, often a barrier/ to a destruction of the seal faces. Beyond this,
buffer media are discussed and selected buffer system with a suitable medium is necessary solids may deposit inside the seal chamber thus
problematic cases are described. to cool and/or lubricate the seal or to avoid blocking the o-ring’s and the spring’s movability.
deposits. The external medium is named with the
Generally, it is not possible to make a global umbrella term ‘barrier/buffer medium’ and performs Deposits at the atmospheric side of the seal occur if
statement on the basis of this brochure as to diverse tasks dependent on the application. the process medium for example tends to crystallize
whether or not a barrier/buffer medium is suitable or due to crack residues from oils.
for a mechanical seal. But the consequences and Barrier/buffer systems may be used in combination
effects may be more easily evaluated, and an with single and multiple seals. In a lot of applications the process medium has to
increase of the seal‘s life time may be achieved in be completely separated from the environment.
specific applications. The barrier/buffer system takes over the heat Possible reasons are, environmental hazards caused
removal or cooling in cases of high process by the process medium, threat to safety in the
temperatures, or high temperatures at the seal due workplace, or the process medium may not come
to the dynamic friction of the seal faces. into contact with oxygen.
If the process medium itself is not suitable for Also heating of the seal by a barrier/buffer medium
lubrication of the seal because of bad lubrication may be necessary if the process medium has a high
properties, or other reasons, for example high solid melting point. Otherwise the process medium would
contents, then the barrier/buffer medium takes over harden at the atmospheric side and therefore lead
the lubrication. to damages at the seal.
2
Selection of the correct sealing
system requires the choice of
a suitable barrier/buffer medium. The
question of which barrier/buffer
medium is the right one is therefore
important, but not always easy to
answer. The fact is that unsuitable
barrier/buffer media may significantly
reduce the life time of seals and have
a negative effect on the process
stream.
3
Modes of operation and barrier/buffer systems
Depending on the design and the arrangement of the Quench Buffer and barrier medium
mechanical seal, and the required functions of the
barrier/buffer system for the specific application, A quench according to API plan 51 or 62 means If an external medium is introduced between two
different modes of operation are possible or that mostly water or a gaseous medium like steam mechanical seals two different pressure conditions
necessary. The plans for the auxiliary systems are or nitrogen is used as external medium at are possible:
based on the API 682. atmospheric pressure.
p3 < p1: If the pressure of the external medium (p3)
is lower than the pressure to be sealed (p1), then it
Flush is named a buffer medium (equivalent to API plan
52) or a buffer gas (equivalent to API plan 72).
Flushing serves either to lower the temperature or
to prevent deposits in the area of the seal faces. p3 = p0: If the pressure of the buffer medium is
The flushing medium may be the process medium atmospheric pressure then this is called an
itself or an external medium. The most common unpressurized operation.
API plans are 11, 21, 31 and 41. If an external
medium is used then it is called API plan 32. p3 > p1: In case of a pressurized operation
according to API plan 53 or 54 the external medium
The flushing pressure has to be always higher than is called barrier medium or barrier gas with
the pressure to be sealed. To restrict the flow of the API plan 74.
flush into the process medium the flushing medium
should be sealed against the impeller. This can be In most cases it is recommended that the barrier
achieved by using a flow rate restrictor (throttle). pressure should be 2-3 bar (29-44 PSI) higher than
The flow speed in the throttle gap should be the highest pressure to be sealed. In cases with
between 1.0 and 2.5 m/s. Thus it is avoided that operating pressures p1 >20 bar (290 PSI) the
soiled product comes between the seal faces. barrier pressure should be 10 % higher than the
pressure to be sealed.
Plan 32 Plan 74
Detailed information on API is available in our brochure „API 682 4th edition Application guide“ Please ask for a copy.
4
Different values should be seriously challenged and Barrier/buffer systems ••The arrangement of the piping should be as short
matched with the relevant experts, if necessary. In and streamlined as possible. To avoid air pockets
case of vacuum operation higher differential Barrier/buffer systems can be divided into the pipes should be installed steadily rising.
pressures may be required after consulting pressureless and pressurized systems. Examples for To change the direction, only pipe bends and for
EagleBurgmann. such systems are displayed on this page. shut-offs, ball valves with full bore should be used.
••In principle the outlet pipe of the mechanical seal
If a quench or a buffer medium is used due to the has to be connected with the lateral connection of
pressure conditions, the quench medium is enriched During the installation some general things have to the barrier/buffer system tank. Please carry out
with the process medium in the course of time. In be considered: the following instructions for the connection:
case of a flush according to API plan 32, or ••Assembly and operating manual of the barrier/ ••Mechanical seal OUT has to be connected with
a pressurized operation according to API plan 53 or buffer system. barrier/buffer system IN,
54, the pressure of the barrier medium is always ••The installation of the barrier/buffer system should ••Barrier/buffer system OUT has to be connected
higher than the operation pressure of the process provide an easy operation, monitoring and with mechanical seal IN.
medium to be sealed. The result is that the barrier maintenance.
medium is introduced into the process medium in ••The tank should be positioned above the
a certain amount. mechanical seal (approximately 1 … 2 m) to allow
a natural circulation of the barrier/buffer medium.
In a lot of cases a circulation of the barrier/buffer The distance may be shorter if the circulation is
medium is required. This can be provided by supported by a pumping device inside the seal or
a natural circulation by the thermosiphon effect, or a circulation pump.
by forced circulation using an integrated pumping ••The piping of the barrier/buffer system loop should
device inside the seal, or a circulation pump. The be made of stainless steel and the dimensions
circulating volume is dependent on different should be according to the assembly and operating
parameters like the type of circulation, the rotational manual. The pipe sections are normally connected
speed, or the viscosity of the used barrier/buffer by screwed joints.
medium.
SPS SPS
N 2 (Option) Orifice
Flare stack
SPI SPI
SPN SPN
(Option) (Option)
IN IN
OUT OUT
1…2m
1…2m
OUT IN OUT IN
Mechanical seal Mechanical seal
EagleBurgmann TS2000 seal barrier/buffer system, displayed Pressurized thermosiphon system for natural or forced circulation. Pressureless thermosiphon system for natural or forced circulation.
with circulation pump SPU 5000. Equipped with all necessary
connections for additional measuring units.
5
The ideal barrier/buffer medium
The demands on the “ideal” barrier/buffer medium ••High lubrication capacity General demands
are sophisticated and it is difficult to always fulfill ••High heat capacity
all criteria. Therefore each decision is characterized ••Free of solids One of the primary tasks of a barrier/buffer medium
by setting priorities and making compromises. ••No tendency to deposit is the lubrication of the seal faces. Consequently the
Mainly the following criteria are important to select ••High resistance of the used materials barrier/buffer medium should have a high lubrication
a suitable barrier/buffer medium: ••High ageing resistance capacity. In most cases the lubricity of water is
••Suitable viscosity sufficient. Also, a high heat capacity has advantages
••Good compatibility with the process medium if the barrier/buffer medium is used for cooling the
••No classification as hazardous substance seal, because the heat capacity is proportional to
••High ignition temperature and high flash point the heat removal. The heat capacity of the barrier/
••Sufficient distance between the boiling point and buffer medium has to be considered during the
the process temperature dimensioning of the barrier/buffer system to
••No tendency to foam calculate the required circulation rate for example.
••Good availability and low costs
The barrier/buffer medium may neither contain
solids nor tend to build up deposits. Deposits or
smears may occur, for example, due to crack
residues of oils, or due to residue building additives
Cartex-DN double mechanical seal with in oils, particularly zinc or phosphor additives or
connections and integrated pumping silicates. For this reason also media which tend to
device. The viscosity of the barrier/
buffer medium is recommended to be crystallize should not be used.
max. ISO VG 5.
The materials of the barrier/buffer system have to
Heat capacity be resistant against the barrier/buffer medium.
spec. heat capacity at Thermal conductivity at
20 °C (68 °F) [kJ/(kg·K)] 20 °C (68 °F)[W/(m·K)] For example if EPDM elastomers are used, no oil
“normal” water 4.3 0.6 may be used as barrier/buffer medium.
30 % propylene glycol/70 % water 3.95 0.47
oil ~2 ~0.1 Important is also the high ageing resistance which
silicone oils 1.45 ~0.15
means the barrier/buffer medium should not change
glycerine 2.4 0.3
ethanol 2.4 0.17 its properties even after time. This may happen by
air 1 0.026 the influence of temperature or shear stress,
nitrogen 1 0.026 by contact with air (oxidation reactions, cracking,
Oil and other hydrocarbons have about half of the heat capacity of water. formation of acids, polymerisation) or humidity
Specific heat capacities and thermal conductivities of typical media (hydrolysis, formation of acids).
6
Viscosity • Natural circulation: 0.5 to 5 mm²/s; Viscosity
• Forced circulation by a pumping device inside the The viscosity describes the “thickness” of liquids and melts,
Low viscosity fluids are generally more suitable to mechanical seal: 0.5 … 12 mm²/s; but also of suspensions. It is a measure of the fluid’s internal
resistance to flow and is defined by the frictional resistance
be used as barrier/buffer medium than fluids with • Forced circulation by an external circulation pump: with which a fluid responds to deformation by compressive or
a high viscosity. The higher the operational demands 0.5 … 15 mm²/s. shear stress. The higher the viscosity the “thicker” the fluid and
on the seal regarding rotating speed and heat the lower the capability of flow. There are two related
generation the lower the viscosity has to be. A pumping device inside a mechanical seal may be measures of fluid viscosity – known as dynamic and kinematic
viscosity. The dynamic viscosity is the ratio of shear stress and
In exceptional cases higher viscosities may be a pumping screw or a pump ring. Here the the velocity gradient vertical to the flow direction. It can be
required. This has to be checked on an individual performance curve has to be considered because it defined by the force F to move 2 parallel planes with the
basis. is dependent on the viscosity. Seals with different velocity v against each other. In most cases it is measured with
pump devices like the EagleBurgmann Cartex have rotation viscometers.
The viscosity is dependent on temperature and to be examined separately.
decreases with increasing temperature and vice V F
versa. Therefore the viscosity index of the barrier/ If an external pump is used for the circulation its
buffer medium should be as high as possible, which design data has to be observed. For example, if an d
A
means the temperature dependence of the viscosity EagleBurgmann SPU500 is used the maximum
should be as low as possible. Depending on allowable viscosity is 15 mm²/s.
Graphical illustration of the dynamic viscosity.
operation mode of the mechanical seal, the Source: Römpp Lexikon
following recommendations regarding the optimal If a gear pump is used in an EagleBurgmann SPA,
The current unit of dynamic viscosity η is mPa•s. In earlier
viscosity of the barrier/buffer medium can be given. a pressurized barrier fluid system, the viscosity times the unit P (Poise) or cP (Centi poise) was used.
Preferably it should be observed within the whole within the whole operating temperature range has to 1 cP = 1 mPa•s. Water has a viscosity of 1 mPa•s at 20 °C (68 °F).
operating temperature range. be 12 mm²/s minimum.
The kinematic viscosity ν is a measure of the internal friction in
a fluid. It is measured for example with a capillary or falling
In exceptional cases, for example, with compressors sphere viscometer, or it is calculated by dividing the dynamic
or agitators, higher viscosities (up to 68 mm²/s) viscosity by the density of the liquid: ν = η / ρ
may be used. But this always has to be checked
Today the common unit of the kinematic viscosity ν is mm²/s.
with the relevant experts.
In earlier times the unit St (Stokes) or cSt (centi Stokes) was
used. 1 cSt = 1 mm²/s.
500
water-mixtures, starch-water-mixtures, lubricants, polymer melts,
280 Chocolate sauce
200
Non-Newtonian fluids should not be used as barrier/buffer
50 Fruit juice
32 Sour cream
100
when shear forces are applied. This may have negative effects
1 Water
2 Milk
7
Compatibility with the process medium On the strength of past experience barrier/buffer Security aspects
media which are certified according to USDA-H1
The compatibility of the barrier/buffer medium with or NSF/H1 (USDA = United States Department of In principle the evaluation of the barrier/buffer
the process medium has to be checked together Agriculture, NSF = National Sanitary Foundation) medium regarding environmental hazard, health
with the end user in each case. The barrier/buffer can be used. Probably media which are approved hazard and security aspects (safety in the work
medium should be inert against the process according to CFR 172: “Food additives permitted for place) has to be done by the operator of the seal.
medium, which means no reaction can take place direct addition to food for human consumption” The used barrier/buffer medium should not be
between the barrier/buffer medium and the process or CFR 178: “Indirect food additives: adjuvants, classified as a hazardous substance, thus it should
medium at the corresponding operating conditions. production aids, and sanitizers” may also be used. neither be harmful to health nor to the environment.
The ignition temperature of the barrier/buffer
Also the quality of the process medium must not be Documents to evaluate the barrier/buffer medium should be significantly higher than the
negatively influenced by the barrier/buffer medium. medium with regard to environmental hazard, maximum operating temperature. Low flammability
This is of particular importance with end products health hazard and security aspects is a further criterion: the flash point should be
(safety in workplace):
such as, food, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals. significantly higher than the maximum operating
• Material safety data sheet temperature. The formation of explosive or ignitable
If necessary specific regulations like the German • Technical instructions on air quality control – “TA-Luft” mixtures with air has to be avoided in all cases.
• GESTIS database on hazardous substances (Information
“Regulation about the use of extraction solvents and system on hazardous substances of the German Social The maximum operating temperature should be at
other auxiliary materials in the production of food”, Accident Insurance) least 40 °C (104 °F) lower than the boiling point of
the German food and feed code „Lebensmittel- und • Appendix VI of the regulation (EC) no. 1272/2008, tables 3.1 the barrier/buffer medium. If the seal is only low
Futtermittelgesetz (LFGB)“ and specific “Codes of and 3.2 (list of harmonized classification and labelling of stressed, which means low pressure, low sliding
hazardous substances).
federal regulations” (CFR) of the food & drug • European chemical Substances Information System (ESIS) velocity and low temperature, a lower temperature
administration (FDA) have to be considered. The difference of e.g. 20 °C (68 °F) may be sufficient.
evaluation whether a medium can be used as This has to be clarified on an individual basis.
barrier/buffer medium in the food and
pharmaceutical industry has to be done by the Ignition temperature and flash point
operator of the seal. The ignition temperature is the lowest temperature of a hot
surface at which substances self ignite. According to this, the
ignition temperature is the lowest temperature which
flammable gases, vapours, dusts or finely dispersed solids
must have in the most ignitable mixture with air to initiate the
combustion or the explosion. It is not a material constant but
dependent on the test conditions.
The flash point is the lowest temperature, corrected to a
pressure of 101,3 kPa (760 Torr), at which the vapours can be
ignited by an ignition source under specified test conditions.
Source: Römpp Online Lexikon
8
Gas solubility, foaming 0,35
0,06
0,01
Henry‘s law
0,00
ci = αij · pi 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Temperature [°C]
ci = concentration of gas in liquid
pi = partial pressure of the gas above the liquid
αij = temperature dependent solubility coefficient of the gas i The solubility of nitrogen in water dependent on pressure
Source: The solubility of nitrogen and air in liquids, J. Phys. Ref. Data, Vol. 13, No. 2, 1984
in liquid j
(= Bunsen absorption coefficient or Bunsen coefficient)
8
The amount of gas which is dissolved in a liquid is proportional
to its partial pressure at the liquid surface (at equilibrium).
At equilibrium means the liquid is saturated. Only at high ■ Methanol 50 °C (122 °F)
pressures there will be a difference in proportionality. ■ Methanol -25 °C (-13 °F)
6 ■ Mineral oil* 100 °C (212 °F)
■ Mineral oil* 20 °C (68 °F)
■ Water 0 °C (32 °F)
■ Water 90 °C (194 °F)
Standard cm³ gas/g solvent
0
0 20 40 60
Pressure [bar]
*viscosity at 38 °C: 34,9 mm2/s
9
Standard barrier/buffer media
In this chapter detailed information about standard Water The decision tree below can be used to evaluate the
barrier/buffer media is provided and existing quality parameters of water which should be used as
problems are described. In a lot of cases water is a suitable barrier/buffer barrier/buffer medium. The surrounding conditions,
medium. In most of the cases demineralized water mainly the temperature play a decisive role.
Barrier/buffer media which are often used: or distilled water can be used. Because the
• Water lubrication characteristics of these water qualities Some of the parameters interact in their effects
• Mixtures of water-glycol are quite bad the suitability has to be checked with thus if only one parameter is given the evaluation of
• Alcohols an expert from EagleBurgmann in case of hard/hard the water quality is not possible. Therefore the
• Different oils like mineral oils, synthetic oils, seal face combinations and high operational saturation index (also Langelier saturation index,
white oils or vegetable oils demands on the seal. LSI) was established which describes the tendency
• Gaseous media like nitrogen or steam of water regarding calcium carbonate deposition.
Make sure that the temperature at the seal outlet
does not exceed 60 °C (140 °F). On the one hand
Water with the following properties is a sufficient distance to the boiling point has to be
suitable as barrier/buffer medium.
ensured and on the other hand the deposition of
• 6.5 ≤ pH-value ≤ 7.5 calcium carbonate should be kept on a low level.
• 25 µS/cm ≤ conductivity ≤ 250µS/cm
• Total dissolved solids (TDS) ≤ 500mg/l
The water should not contain any solids as they tend
• Hardness of water ≤ 100 ppm CaCO3 (≈ 5.6 °dH) to deposit (calcium carbonate). The deposition of
• 60 mg/l CaCO3 ≤ Alkalinity ≤ 150 mg/l CaCO3 calcium carbonate is mainly problematic at the
(ideal is between 80 and 120 mg/l CaCO3) atmospheric side of the seal due to the vaporisation
• no solids
• Turbidity < 5 NTU
of the leakage. This may lead to clogging of the
• Chloride content < 250 ppm dynamic O-ring.
• 0 ≤ LSI (Langelier saturation index) ≤ +0.5
• Free of gas, which means ≤ 0.2 Ncm³ dissolved gas Usable in most cases. Pay attention with high loaded seals and
Demineralized water or distilled water available?
per cm³ of water yes had-hard seal face combinations!
↓ no
In general distilled or demineralized water fulfill these criteria. Organize parameters of the water
↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓
pH-Value Conductivity Total dissolved solids Hardness of water Solid content Turbidity Dissolved gas Chloride
(TDS) content
↓ ↓ ↓ ↓
LSI (Langelier saturation index)
Evaluation of tendency to calcium carbonate deposition
↓
O < LSI < +0.5 no < 5 NTU < 0.2 Ncm3 gas/cm3 < 250 ppm
Restrictions on seal life time can occur, but water can still be used.
If the parameters of the water are above the limits, a significant reduction of the seal life time will occur.
Barrier/buffer medium
11
■ Wasser-Ethylenglykol ■ Wasser-Propylenglykol ■ Wasser-Glyzerin
Wasser-Ethylenglykol-Gemischen [mPa*s]
are not suitable. ■ Wasser-Ethylenglykol ■ Wasser-Propylenglykol ■ Wasser-Glyzerin
20
Source: Internet, Pekasol L Data sheet, pro Kühlsole GmbH Source: Internet, Glykosol N Data sheet, pro Kühlsole GmbH
the considerably lower freezing point.
109
■ water-ethylene glycol ■ water-propylene glycol ■ water-glycerol
108
107 100
■ water
■ 30 % propylene glycol
106 50
■ 50 % propylene glycol
Boiling point [°C]
20
Dynamic viscosity [mPa•s]
105 10
104 5
103 2
1
102
0,5
101
100 0,1
0 10 20 30 40 50 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Temperature [°C]
Content of ethylene glycol, propylene glycol or glycerol [mass%]
Boiling points of water-ethylene glycol, water-propylene glycol and water-glycerol mixtures Dynamic viscosity of water-glycerol mixtures
Source: Internet, pro Kühlsole GmbH Source: Ullmann‘s Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry, paper Glycerol
-40 4,3
■ water-ethylene glycol ■ water-propylene glycol ■ water-glycerol
■ water-ethylene glycol ■ water-propylene glycol ■ water-glycerol 4,2
-35
4,1
-30 4,0
Spec. heat capacity [kJ/kg•K]
3,9
-25
Freezing point [°C]
3,8
3,7
-20
3,6
-15 3,5
3,4
-10 3,3
3,2
-5
3,1
0 3,0
0 10 20 30 40 50 0 10 20 30 40 50
Content of ethylene glycol, propylene glycol or glycerol [mass%] Content of ethylene glycol, propylene glycol or glycerol [mass%]
Freezing points of water-ethylene glycol, water-propylene glycol and water-glycerol mixtures Specific heat capacity of water-ethylene glycol, water-propylene glycol and water-glycerol mixtures
Source: Internet, pro Kühlsole GmbH Source: Internet, pro Kühlsole GmbH
12
Alcohols Oils Mineral oils often contain additives, e.g. to improve
the corrosion protection or the ageing stability.
Preferred barrier/buffer media, including for food If oils are used as barrier/buffer medium the These additives may thermally decompose and form
and pharmaceutical applications, are the alcohols following things have to be considered: If they are deposits on the seal faces, which may lead to
ethanol or propanol. Also mixtures with water are exposed to higher temperatures for any length of a destruction of the seal faces.
possible. Most of the alcohols, mainly the alcohols time their properties may negatively change. A lot of
with lower molecular mass are volatile substances, oils, mainly mineral oils, build up residues similar to This problem is known for example with the additive
which means that they evaporate fast at lacquer or glue up to tar, at higher thermal stress. ZnDTP (Zinc dithiophosphate) because ZnDTP
atmospheric conditions. This will cause a number of This happens due to a partial decomposition of the decomposes at about 120 °C (248 °F).
disadvantages. On the one hand the barrier/buffer base oil which is not very thermostable. A maximum
medium often has to be refilled, mainly if used as temperature of 60 °C (140 °F) at the outlet of the Please also make sure that no ash is used as
unpressurized buffer medium and on the other hand seal is recommended. additive. The dependance of the viscosity on the
ignitable mixtures with air may form more easily. temperature should be as low as possible, which
In general oils may only be used within the specified means the viscosity index (VI) should be as high as
An advantage of most alcohols is the low melting service temperature range for oxygen atmosphere possible. In general, synthetic oils have a higher
point of significantly below 0 °C (+32 °F). according to the manufacturer. If oils are used as viscosity index than mineral oils.
Therefore alcohols are preferred in low temperature barrier/buffer medium their hygroscopicity may be
applications. Ethanol has a melting point of a problem. The water content may be up to
-114.5 °C (238.1 °F) and a boiling point of 78.3 °C 1,500 ppm whereas the lubrication capacity
(172.9 °F). The melting point of propanol is -126 °C drastically decreases at water contents ≥ 750 ppm.
(-195 °F) and the boiling point 97 °C (207 °F). Due
to their high vapour pressure, in Germany the
TA-Luft has to be considered. Possible alternative 200
alcohols may be 1-butanol or 2-methyl-1-propanol,
but they are classified as harmful. 100
80
60
Glycerol (=propanetriol) is another alcohol which is 50
used in mixtures with water as barrier/buffer 40
2
Type 40 C° 100 C° VI
n Klueber Summit DSL 32 32 5.8 125
n Klueber Paraliq P 12 17 3.7 103
n Klueber Summit HySyn FG 15 15 3.6 125
n Klueber Summit PGS 10 A 10 2.5 61
n Molyduval Syntolube A5 1LM 7.8 2.1 –
n Molyduval Biolube 5 7.5 2.3 –
n OMV Sealfluid SH2 5 2.0 277
n Shell Morlina S2BL5 5 1.6 –
n Klueberfluid NH 14-005 5 1.7 –
1
-20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120
Temperature [°C]
13
Mineral oils Compressor oils are an additional group of mineral White oils
oils which are often used as barrier/buffer medium.
Often so called lubricating oils are used as barrier/ They are highly raffinated mineral oils and therefore are a group of oils which are often used as barrier/
buffer media. They are composed of the high boiling of higher thermal stability than “standard” mineral buffer medium. They are high-value lubricants which
fractions of the raw oil and are separated by oils. They are used to lubricate fast running bearings are synthesized out of paraffinic oils. They may be
vacuum distillation, de-paraffinized and and gears installed in turbo compressors and steam classified in technical and extra high-quality medical
de-aromatized. At the end high quality products are turbines. Oils for this use are specified in the DIN white oils.
treated with hydrogen under pressure to eliminate 51515. However, compressor oils are not suitable for
impurities. Thus the base oils are produced. The high sliding velocities (>100 m/s), because they Technical white oils are very stable regarding
properties of the end product (motor oil, gear oil, form deposits or smears on the sliding faces. environmental influences and gum formation and
electrical insulating oil, metal working oil, hydraulic they do not get rancid. Medical white oils are used
oil etc.) are adjusted by blending oils with different Good experiences exist with the oils „Shell Morlina in pharmaceutical, food and cosmetic applications
properties and by selecting suitable additives. S2BL5 and S2BL10“ and “Aral Vitam AC”, which and have to fulfil high quality standards regarding
have proven themselves as barrier fluids used on purity and compatibility. Therefore these medical
Lubricating oils are classified in viscosity classes several test rigs. white oils are colourless, odourless and tasteless
according to the ISO-VG (International organisation and they are aromatic and sulphur free.
for standardization – Viscosity Grade). The labelling A further recommendation is “Klüber Paraliq P 12”,
shows the viscosity at 40 °C (104 °F). a paraffin type mineral oil: Due to their limited temperature stability the
Example: ISO VG 5 -> ~5 mm²/s at 40 °C (104 °F). ••Certified according to NSF-H1, which means that it maximum outlet temperature of the barrier/buffer
may be used in food and pharmaceutical medium is recommended not to exceed 60 °C
In many cases also hydraulic oils are used as applications (140 °F). Good experiences exist for example with
barrier/buffer medium. These are operating liquids ••Operating temperature range: -10 °C … +60 °C Biolube 5 from Molyduval.
used for hydrostatic and hydrodynamic transmission (14 °F ... 140 °F)
of power. The labelling shows which additives were ••Kinematic viscosity: 20 mm²/s at 40 °C (104 °F)
added. and 3.7 mm²/s at 100 °C (212 °F) Vegetable oils
••Neutral towards numerous HNBR- and
FKM elastomers The advantage of vegetable oils as barrier/buffer
medium is their good biodegradability. Beyond this
they are easy available and may be used in the food
industry. However vegetable oils have a relatively
low resistance against hydrolysis and a low oxidation
resistance caused by the polyunsaturated fatty
acids. Therefore vegetable oils should only be used
for process temperatures up to 60 °C (140 °F).
14
Synthetic oils Properties Mineral Synthetic oils
oils
There are different types of base oils produced by Synthetic Polyglycols Carboxylic acid Phosphoric
hydrocarbons esters acid ester
chemical synthesis. The most important group are
the synthetic hydrocarbons with the polyalpha- PAO Alkylated Diesters Polyol
aromatics esters
olefines (PAO) and the alkylated aromatics. They are
mainly used for the lubrication of refrigerating Rheological behaviour at low temp. 0 ++++ ++ +++ ++++ ++++ 0
machines. Polyalphaolefines are saturated aliphatic Viscosity at high temp. + +++ + ++++ ++++ ++++ 0
hydrocarbons. They have a high oxidation resistance Oxidation resistance + ++++ ++ +++ ++ ++++ +
(with additives)
which is comparable with that of mineral oils and
they have a very good chemical stability. Resistance to hydrolysis ++++ ++++ ++++ +++ + + 0
Biodegradability 0 0 0 – ++ +++ 0
The polyglycols are an additional group of synthetic Toxicity low low low low low low increased
oils with their most important representatives ++++ excellent, +++ very good, ++ good, + acceptable, 0 moderate, – poor
polyethylene glycols and polypropylene glycols. They Comparison between the properties of mineral and synthetic oils
Source: Industrie Report – Synthetische Schmierstoffe, Mobil Schmierstoff GmbH, 1999
have a high viscosity index, limited oxidation
resistance and very good lubrication properties.
PAO PAO & Esters Diesters Polyglycols
Carboxylic acid esters were originally developed for Klüberfluid Klüber Summit Klüberoil 4 Klüber Summit Klüber Summit
NH1 4-005* HySyn FG 15 UH1-15 AF DSL 32 PGS 10 A
aircraft engines. Polyol esters and diesters belong
to this group. Polyol esters are mainly used for the General information Without additives Mineral oil free Lube oil without Synthetic Synthetic
compressor oil additives compressoroil; high compressor‑ oil;
lubrication of refrigerating machines. Both the oxidation resistance low solubility of gas
polyol esters and the diesters have very good and thermalstability;
thermal and oxidation resistance and a high easily biodegradable
viscosity index, usually between 160 and 180. But Approval regarding food / NSFH1 USDA-H1 and USDA-H1 and – –
both groups are susceptible to hydrolysis if they get pharmaceutical FDA CFR 178 FDA CFR 178
applications
in contact with water.
Operating temperature -40 °C … +150 °C -45 °C … +135 °C -45 °C … +110 °C -30 °C … +140 °C … +140 °C
range [°C] (-40 °F … +302 °F) (-49 °F … +275 °F) (-49 °F … +230 °F) (-22 °F …+284 °F) (+284 °F)
The phosphoric acid esters or phosphate esters are
Kinematic viscosity at 5 / 1.7 mm²/s 15 / 3.6 mm²/s 18 / 4.0 mm²/s 32 / 5.8 mm²/s 8 / 2.5 mm²/s
tertiary esters of phosphoric acid. They have a low 40 °C / 100 °C
viscosity index, a good oxidation resistance but only (104 °F / 212 °F)
in neutral environment, a limited thermal stability Compatibility Neutral towards numerous HNBR and FKM elastomers Neutral towards Neutral towards
and they are susceptible to hydrolysis if they get in with elastomers numerous FKM numerous HNBR
contact with water. Fluorinated elastomers should elastomers and FKM
elastomers
be preferred as secondary sealing elements.
Synthetic oils which are suitable as barrier/buffer medium
(Recommendations by Klüber Lubrication)
If the oils should be fast and completely *Testet on a test rig of EagleBugmann
biodegradable, then either polyethylene glycols or
carboxylic acid esters (diester or polyol esters)
should be considered. Good experiences exist for Perfluorinated polyethers (PFPE)
example with Syntolube A5LM from Molyduval and Klüberalfa YM 3-30 Klüberalfa DH 3-100
with OMV Sealfluid SH2. General information Fully synthetic, non-flammable High temperature oil
lubricants with good low temperature
behaviour
Perfluorinated polyethers are a further group of
synthetic oils. They are special lubricants which are Operating temperature range -60 °C ... +100 °C (-76 °F ... +212 °F) -25 °C ... +180 °C (-13 °F ... +356 °F)
(at ≤21 Vol-% oxygen content)
very stable and as a consequence they are
essentially inert against chemical and corrosive -60 up to +60
(at ≤21 Vol-% oxygen content)
attacks. Beyond this they are non-flammable, non-
combustible and harmless for health and Kinematic viscosity at 25 / 5 mm²/s 100 / 12 mm²/s
40 °C / 100 °C (104 °F / 212 °F)
environment.
Perfluorinated polyethers which are suitable as barrier/buffer medium
(Recommendations by Klüber Lubrication)
Typical applications are in processes with strong
oxidants like oxygen (O2), ozone (O3), nitrogen
oxides (NO x), sulfur oxides (SO x), halogens (e.g.
F2,Cl2), hydrogen halides (e.g. HF, HCl, HBr) and
uranium hexafluoride (UF6).
15
Gaseous barrier/buffer media Purity requirements on gaseous barrier/buffer media like air
and nitrogen according to ISO 8573-1
When using gaseous barrier/buffer medium it has to EagleBurgmann GSS4016 gas supply system
be considered that the lower the dew point the dryer for gas lubricated mechanical seals.
The main functions of the GSS are:
the gas and the worse the lubrication capacity • Filtering of the barrier or the flushing gas
becomes. In case of dew point is < -70 °C (158 °F) • Pressure monitoring and control
the wear of the carbon seal faces will be increased. • Flow monitoring
Another common gaseous barrier/buffer medium is • Leakage control and discharge
steam. It is mainly used as steam quench to heat the
atmospheric side of the mechanical seal in case of
process media with a high melting point. Thus
solidification of the leakage is avoided. A steam
quench may also be used to avoid the contact of
leakage with the atmosphere if an undesired
reaction occurs between the medium and the air.
Steam is also used in food applications.
16
Not recommended barrier/buffer media
In this chapter some examples for non Diesel
recommended barrier/buffer media are described.
Nevertheless they are often used. These are: Low flammable fuel mixtures for diesel engines
which mainly consist of paraffines with different
contents of olefines, cycloalkanes and aromatic
Antifreeze agents for cars hydrocarbons. Their composition may differ and is
(cooler protection) mainly dependent on the production process.
Normally they have a boiling point between +170 °C
Indeed these media are often based on ethylene … +360 °C (+338 °F ... +680 °F) and a flash point
glycol but contain corrosion inhibitors or other between +70 °C … +100 °C (+158 °F ... +212 °F).
additives like e.g. silicates which may lead to a high
wear of the seal faces. Common trade names are Diesel should not be used as barrier/buffer medium
e.g. Glysantin. because it is subject to the classification according
to the EC-regulation of hazardous substances
(H351: Suspected of causing cancer).
Lubricants for automatic transmissions
17
Barrier/buffer media for critical process media
Critical process media and the usage of barrier/ Service notes Installation and start-up notes
buffer media are for example highly concentrated
acids and bases. If in this case water is used as the The barrier/buffer medium should be changed If the machine is installed outside then the risk of
buffer medium (the sealed process pressure is regularly. It is recommended to change the barrier/ freezing has to be considered. The barrier/buffer
lower than the pressure of the buffer medium) the buffer medium after each repair, each shut down or medium must not be frozen and also the change in
supply system is enriched very fast with the acid or if the concentration of the process medium in the viscosity has to be taken into account (viscosity
base process medium which may lead to an barrier/buffer system is too high, but at least every increases with decreasing temperature). During
increased corrosion. Therefore the flow-through 12 months. The most economic change interval has start-up it has to be ensured that the viscosity is
operation mode or a flush with an external medium to be determined by the operator of the production sufficiently low. If necessary the area of the seal
should be used in this case. plant himself dependent on his experience. can be warmed-up by using a low driving speed of
the machine during start-up. In critical cases
If pressurized operation (pressure of the barrier In case of acid or alkaline process media the heating for the area of the seal and if necessary the
medium is higher than the sealed process pressure) pH-value in the barrier/buffer system may be taken feed and return pipe should be provided. An
in combination with water as barrier medium is as indicator when to change the barrier/buffer insulation of the piping shall be considered as well.
used, it may produce a spontaneous and large heat medium. When the pH-value differs more than
development. Beyond this a chemical potential 2 units from the original value then the barrier/
equalization occurs despite the higher barrier buffer medium should be changed. Beyond this
pressure and therefore an equalization of the a chloride concentration of 250 ppm should not be
pH-value between the process and the barrier exceeded in a closed loop thermosiphon system
medium takes place quite fast. because an increasing corrosion rate can be the
consequence.
A concrete example is the sealing of concentrated
sulfuric acid. For this application positive
experiences are available with isododecane as
barrier/buffer medium at operating temperatures up
to 50 °C (122 °F) and the barrier/buffer medium
Galden® (perfluorinated polyether). Generally
speaking perfluorinated polyethers seem to be
suitable for the application with concentrated
sulfuric acid because of their high chemical
inertness. Paraffin and silicon oils have been found
unsuitable several times because they were
decomposed by the sulfuric acid.
18
A straightforward approach
to a suited barrier/buffer medium
N
The OEM/operator specifies the medium
Y
N N
Is the medium water? Is the medium an oil? Is the medium known to be a suitable barrier / buffer medium?
Y Y Y N
Obtain the following data from the OEM/ Is the oil known to be a suitable Obtain the following data
operator or have a water sample tested: barrier / buffer medium? from the OEM/operator:
••pH ••Melting point
••Conductivity ••Boiling point Material
N
••Total dissolved solids (TDS) LSI ••Flash point safety
••Water hardness ••Ignition temperature data
••Solids content Obtain the following data from the OEM/ ••Viscosity sheet
••Turbidity operator or request from the manufacturer: ••Hazard statements
••Proportion of dissolved gases ••Solids content
••Chloride content •• M aterial safety data sheet / ••Heat capacity (see page 6)
production information ••Gas solubility (see page 9)
•• V iscosity at 40 °C (104 °F) and 100 °C (212 °F) ••Material compatibility
•• O perating temperature range ••Lubrication capacity (see page 6)
•• A dditivation ••Tendency to form deposits (see page 6)
•• M aterial compatibility ••Resistance to ageing (see page 6)
Y
Are the water parameters below the Y Oil parameters OK? N Oil not
recommended limits? (see page 11) (see page 15) suitable
N
Y
N N Parameters OK?
Is medium suitable for entire Is there any action that can be taken so that the medium can
operating temperature range? still be used? E.g. heating the seal area, adapting materials.
N
N
Water quality not OK –
consult with
Consultation with OEM/operator N Has the OEM/operator confirmed
OEM/operator compatibility with his process?
Possible questions:
Which barrier / buffer medium is used in other machines in this
process? Y Y Y Y
Which media do not affect the process, e.g. water, oil, glycol,
alcohols, etc.?
Is there any action that
Determine a suitable barrier / buffer medium from the type of
N can be taken so that the
process medium or solvent.
medium can still be used?
Determine a suitable barrier / buffer medium from the operating
E.g. heating the seal area,
conditions, e.g. low temperatures.
adapting materials.
Parameters OK?
Y
Is it possible to select a suitable barrier / buffer medium? Check corresponding parameters
Y Y N
19
Argentina · Australia · Austria · Belarus · Belgium · Bulgaria · Brazil · Canada · Chile · China · Colombia · Cyprus · Czech Republic · Denmark · Ecuador · Egypt · Estonia
Finland · France · Germany · Great Britain · Greece · Hungary · India · Indonesia · Iraq · Israel · Italy · Japan · Jordan · Kazakhstan · Korea · Kuwait · Latvia · Libya · Lithuania
Malaysia · Mauritius · Mexico · Morocco · Myanmar · Netherlands · New Zealand · Nigeria · Norway · Oman · Pakistan · Paraguay · Peru · Philippines · Poland · Qatar
Romania · Russia · Saudi Arabia · Singapore · Slovenia · Slovak Republic · South Africa · Spain · Sweden · Switzerland · Syria · Taiwan · Thailand · Trinidad and Tobago · Tunisia
Turkey · Turkmenistan · Ukraine · United Arab Emirates · Uruguay · USA · Uzbekistan · Venezuela · Vietnam · www.eagleburgmann.com/world
EagleBurgmann is one of the internationally leading companies for industrial sealing technology. Our EagleBurgmann Germany GmbH & Co. KG
products are used everywhere where safety and reliability are important: in the oil and gas industry, Aeussere Sauerlacher Strasse 6–10
refining technology, the petrochemical, chemical and pharmaceutical industries, food processing, power, 82515 Wolfratshausen, Germany
water, mining, pulp & paper, aerospace and many other spheres. Every day, more than 6,000 employees Tel.: +49 (0)8171 23 0
contribute their ideas, solutions and commitment towards ensuring that customers all over the world can Fax: +49 (0)8171 23 12 14
rely on our seals. Our modular TotalSealCare service underlines our strong customer orientation and info@de.eagleburgmann.com
offers tailor-made services for every application. eagleburgmann.com