Crude Oil Price Formation

Hassan Z. Harraz
hharraz2006@yahoo.com
2015- 2016

© Hassan Harraz 2016 1

Prof. Dr. H.Z. Harraz Presentation
© Hassan Harraz 2016 2
 Lecture # 7
Crude Oil Price Formation
The Functioning of the International Oil & Gas Markets

© Hassan Harraz 2016 3

Outline of Lecture

© Hassan Harraz 2016 4

1) INTRODUCTION
 Oil is the world economy’s most important source of energy and is therefore critical to
economic growth. Its value is driven by demand for refined petroleum products,
particularly in the transportation sector.
 Petroleum products power virtually all motor vehicles, aircraft, marine vessels, and
trains around the globe. In total, products derived from oil, such as motor gasoline, jet
fuel, diesel fuel, and heating oil, supply 33% of all the energy consumed by
households, businesses, and manufacturers worldwide. By way of comparison,
natural gas and coal supply 22% and 28%, respectively, of the world’s energy needs.
 The principal activities involved in moving crude oil from its source to the ultimate
consumer are:
 Production, which involves finding, extracting, and transporting crude oil;
 Refining, the process by which crude oil is turned into products such as
gasoline; and
 Distribution and marketing, which focus on moving those products to final
consumers.
 These activities occur within a global marketplace—an extensive physical
infrastructure that connects buyers and sellers worldwide, all supported by an
international financial market. The physical infrastructure encompasses a vast array
of capital, including drilling rigs, pipelines, ports, tankers, barges, trucks, crude oil
storage facilities, refineries, product terminals—right down to retail storage tanks and
gasoline pumps.
© Hassan Harraz 2016 5
1) GLOBAL PRIMARY ENERGY SOURCES

50%

Nuclear 45%

Hydro Oil
40%
6.3%
35%
6.0%
Oil Coal
30%
36.4%
25%
Coal Gas
27.8% 20%

15%

10%
23.5% Hydro
5%
Natural gas Nuclear
0%
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005

Oil and gas remain as predominant energy sources

© Hassan Harraz 2016 6

Who's who in Global
Oil Markets.. !

© Hassan Harraz 2016 7

 Oil prices relate to many uncertain factors

OECD/IEA - 2007
No single cause of high prices…!

© Hassan Harraz 2016

Oil Prices: a increasingly complex
market constellation

© Hassan Harraz 2016 10

 Oil Barrel Politics:
3) MANY FACTORS INFLUENCE THE FORMATION OF Running on Volatility
OIL PRICES AND OTHER ENERGY PRICES

© Hassan Harraz 2016 11

© Hassan Harraz 2016 12
3.1) Supply and Demand
• Domestic demand and global demand both effect on crude oil price.
• Over the last decade, emerging markets like China and India have increased demand for crude oil
and so this led many speculators to suggest that demand would outpace supply.
• On the domestic side, the regular reports from the EIA on refining activity and crude oil supply
have direct impact on crude oil price and also crude oil futures price volatility.
• Released weekly, EIA reports and API reports are often key fundamental influences on crude oil
futures markets.

3.2) OPEC Output

 OPEC ; from its name, we all can be sure that its activities will have strong effect on oil market.
 OPEC production levels and promises for production can also add volatility to crude oil prices.
 Even a scheduled OPEC meeting and speculation about increases or cuts to oil production can
impact crude oil futures markets.

3.3) Weather
• That sounds strange that weather can affect oil price, but it will.
• Storms in the Gulf region of the United States as well as the North Sea can halt production of crude
oil both on drilling platforms as well as refineries which may be shut down anticipating the arrival
of a bad storm.
• Events like Hurricane Katrina stand as strong examples of how weather may have a direct impact
on crude oil price.
• You have just viewed some fundamentals that affect on crude oil prices. There are some more but I
can’t list out here for you because of the limited spaces. Just discover more from the resource. By
the way, keep up with the oil and other futures market prices for your investments!

© Hassan Harraz 2016 13

© Hassan Harraz 2016 14
3.4) Geopolitical and economic events have driven large
movements in world oil prices
Real (Dec 2009)
dollars per barrel

140 Global economic crisis

Iran-Iraq
War Very low spare
120 capacity
Saudi Arabia
100 abandons role as
Hurricanes Katrina
Iranian and Rita
Revolution swing producer
80
Asian Financial Crisis
60
9/11 attacks
40
OPEC cuts
20 production
Arab Oil Iraq invades Invasion of Iraq targets by 4.2
Embargo Kuwait OPEC cuts quotas 1.7 MMbbl/d MMbbl/d
0
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
Source: EIA
Figure : Oil Crisis in relation to oil price

© Hassan Harraz 2016 15

 4) CRUDE OIL PRICES UPS AND DOWNS
Crude Oil Prices: What Happened?

 Oil prices:
 Implications for supply and demand
 A dynamic equilibrium of factors
 The basic story: As long as supply far outstrips demand, oil prices will stay relatively low.
Ultimately, the supply and demand dynamic is the thing to keep an eye on. And expectations matter enormously here.
Whenever new data shows an unexpected boost in oil production or an unexpected drop in oil demand, prices tend to
go down.
Conversely, a surprise drop in supply or a surprise surge in demand will push prices back up.
As global production changed relative to demand, the world moved from a period of “Over Supply” (or peak oil) in 1998 to
one of “Under Supply” in 1999 and 2000.
Inventories are a good means of seeing the imbalance between petroleum production and demand.
For example, when production exceeds demand, inventories rise. A large over supply will put downward pressure on
prices, while under supply will cause prices to rise.
4.1) Rising Oil Prices
$139 by June 2008

 Oil prices have been steadily rising

for several years and in June 2008
stand at a record high of $139 per
barrel.

Is the rise due to a squeeze in

availability (peak oil) or are other
political or economic factors to blame?
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image: Oil_Prices_Medium_Term.png

© Hassan Harraz 2016 17

 Oil price near $100, ……. but why?
$/bbl Crude Futures
Front Month Close
100
95
90
85
80
75
70
Source: Platts
65
Aug 07 Sep 07 Oct 07 Nov 07 Dec 07
NYM EX WTI ICE B rent
Source: IEA Oil Market Report

 Tight crude and product fundamentals push oil near $100/bbl in late-November
 Resilient demand growth – driven by non-OECD regions
 Concern over inventory cover ahead of winter demand
 OPEC-10 production has fallen, despite rising oil prices

© Hassan Harraz 2016 18

4.1.1) Cost inflation dampens investment impact
‫تضخم التكاليف التي تخفف تأثير االستثمار‬
(long-term futures prices remain above $80)

Source: Resources to Reserves, IEA, 2005

 Tight service sector causes further cost inflation - $35 to $55/barrel?

 Call option for speculators/OPEC?
 Marginal cost of non-OPEC production influential when OPEC producing flat out
 When spare capacity exists, price OPEC are willing to keep spare capacity off the market is the key

© Hassan Harraz 2016 19

4.1.2) Rising Costs Hamper Projects
‫ارتفاع التكاليف التى يعيق المشاريع‬

Rising costs pressure Delays in awarding Increased order times

project timeframes contracts delay projects further

Credit squeeze adds Fixed price tenders Uncertainty reflected in

further difficulty to increase risks for bids, pushing costs up
project finance contractors further

Source: IEA Oil Market Report

© Hassan Harraz 2016 20

5) CRUDE OIL PRICES
 Brent crude oil spot prices decreased by $7/b in January to a monthly average of $31/b, the
lowest monthly average price since December 2003. Ongoing growth in global oil
inventories and uncertainty over future global demand growth continued to put downward
pressure on oil prices during January. After growing by an estimated 1.8 million b/d in 2015,
global oil inventories are forecast to grow by 1.4 million b/d in the first quarter of 2016.
Daily changes in crude oil prices were highly correlated with daily changes in global equity
indexes. The increased co-movement and higher volatility likely reflect increased
uncertainty about future global economic growth. Changes in overall demand for risk
assets, such as commodities and equities, by investors and market participants may also
be playing a larger role in price discovery across global asset markets compared with
previous months.
 With global oil inventory builds expected to continue in 2016, upward pressure on crude oil
prices will be limited. Forecast Brent prices will average $38/b in 2016, $3/b lower than
forecast in last month's STEO. The largest inventory builds occur in the first half of 2016,
helping keep Brent prices below $40/b through August.
 Brent prices are forecast to average $50/b in 2017, with upward price pressure
concentrated later in that year. At that point, the market is expected to experience small
inventory draws, with the possibility of further draws beyond the forecast period. Brent
prices are forecast to average $56/b in the fourth quarter of 2017.
 Forecast West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude oil prices average the same as Brent crude
oil prices through the forecast period, compared with $2/b lower than Brent in 2016 and $3/b
lower in 2017 in the prior STEO. The price parity of WTI with Brent in the forecast period is
based on the assumption of competition between the two crudes in the U.S.

© Hassan Harraz 2016 21

© Hassan Harraz 2016 22
 5.1) A Short History of the Rise (and Fall) of Oil Prices
 This wasn't always the case. Between 2010 and 2014, as you can see above, oil demand was soaring around the world, as
countries recovered from the financial crisis but global production was struggling to keep up. Many older oil fields were
stagnating. Conflicts in places like Libya and Iraq were restricting supply. Countries had to draw down their stockpiles, and
prices soared to around $100 per barrel.
 Those high prices, however, spurred drillers in the United States to use innovative hydraulic fracturing and horizontal
drilling techniques to unlock vast quantities of oil from shale formations in places like North Dakota and Texas. US crude
oil production has nearly doubled since 2010.
Eventually, supply caught up with demand — and then surpassed it. That's when the crash came.
 By mid-2014, global demand was starting to slow down. Europe was still reeling from the eurozone mess. China's economy
was starting to stumble. But the United States continued to produce more and more oil. Iraq and Libya were also starting to
bring more production back online. So prices began sliding, down to $70 per barrel.
 At that point, many people expected Saudi Arabia and other oil producers in OPEC to cut back on their own production to
prop up prices, as they have in the past.
 Surprisingly, that didn't happen. Saudi Arabia decided to increase production in order to maintain its market share, hoping
that the subsequent fall in oil prices would crush US frackers, who require higher prices to stay profitable.
 Ever since Saudi Arabia's decision to maintain output in late 2014, prices have kept tumbling and tumbling - to $50 per
barrel, then $40, then $30 - largely because supply has remained strong and demand has been weaker than expected.
 US drillers turned out to be far more adaptable to low oil prices than the Saudis thought, as companies cut costs and
boosted productivity in order to keep the oil flowing. Iraq has nearly doubled production since 2014 - to more than 4 million
barrels per day - as it recovers from conflict. Thanks to the nuclear deal with the US, Iran will start exporting more oil this
year as sanctions are lifted, offsetting declines elsewhere.
 In the meantime, major developing economies like China, Russia, and Brazil remain mired in a slump, putting a
damper on oil consumption. An unusually mild winter helped suppress demand for heating oil. And a stronger dollar
means that some countries now have to pay more for crude imports, which further limits consumption.
That's the basic story: As long as supply far outstrips demand, oil prices will stay relatively low

‫ فإن أسعار النفط ستظل منخفضة نسبيا‬،‫طالما العرض يفوق الطلب‬

 On the flip side, crude producers like Saudi Arabia, Russia, and Venezuela are struggling to balance their budgets and suffering
from a major revenue crunch. Oil companies in the United States and elsewhere are watching profits evaporate. Banks that financed
the US shale boom are reeling from a wave of defaults. Developing nations that previously relied on petrodollars for financing are
now hurting. It's a major disruption.

23
Figure : Present and future global oil and liquids supply cost curve

© Hassan Harraz 2016 24

 Figure : Cost of Supply Curve for Global Oil 2020
Note:
 Future Oil Prices will be determined by marginal cost of developing new oil rather than
OPEC interventions.
 North American Shale will out-complete many Oil sands and Arctic oil projects.

© Hassan Harraz 2016 25

 Sub -$20 oil

Figure : Overall cost to produce one barrel of crude oil

© Hassan Harraz 2016 26

Sub -$20 oil seller Club

© Hassan Harraz 2016 27

© Hassan Harraz 2016 28
5.2) Falling Oil Prices
Why crude oil prices keep falling and falling, in one simple chart

People are literally throwing barrels off a

plank. That's what it's come down to.
(archigraf/Shutterstock)

© Hassan Harraz 2016 29

Dropping? Why are Oil Prices
1) Increased Global Supply: Global supply of oil has surpassed the global
demand, which has resulted in the fall of prices.
2) US Oil Boom: Oil Production in the US has increased as Shale oil
production has gone up to 4 mb/d. As such, US import of oil from OPEC has
reduced by half.
3) Increased output from Libya: Because of the civil war in Libya, oil
production had decreased to 150,000 – 250,000 b/d. It now produces 1
mb/d, which may go up to 1.2 mb/d by next year.
4) OPEC Infighting: There is a rivalry among OPEC members, who are trying
to lower prices to maintain their market share
5) Negative European Economic Outlook: A slowdown is expected in
Eurozone economies in 2015. The growth forecast has been cut down by
IMF to 0.8% in 2014 and 1.3% in 2015. Then, over the last year, demand for
oil in places like Europe, Asia, and the US began tapering off, thanks to
weakening economies and new efficiency measures.
6) Tepid Asian Demand: Countries in Asia are reducing oil subsidies, as a
result of which oil demand has fallen, which in turn has resulted in
increased oil prices, thereby, reducing demand.

© Hassan Harraz 2016 30

The Oil Head-Fake

www.oftwominds.com

© Hassan Harraz 2016 31

 Effect of falling oil prices on Russia

More than half of its The Russian

Russian budget economy may go into
budget revenues
heavily relies on its
oil income
come from selling Oil Recession if oil
and Gas prices keep falling
32
Image Courtesy: http://www.kp24.fi/data/attachments/6488fd17-c93a-453c-b788-eedd292063d9_389541.jpg © Hassan Harraz 2016
 Effect of falling oil prices on Iran

High oil prices are one of the major factors affecting the Iranian economy.

Severe economic problems may result if oil prices keep falling.

Iran may decide to reach a nuclear deal with the US to ease economic sanctions.

© Hassan Harraz 2016 33

Image Courtesy - http://www.timesofisrael.com/irans-supreme-leader-undergoes-prostate-surgery//
 Effect of falling oil prices on US

Falling oil prices will cause

gas prices to go down,
which will result in
increased consumer
spending.

This will translate into

accelerated economic
growth to a forecasted
3.5% next year.

© Hassan Harraz 2016 34

Image Courtesy: http://www.ulkeajans.com/images/haberler/obama_uluslararasi_toplum_gazzede_ateskes_icin_calismali_h56636.jpg
Global Consequences of falling Oil Prices

Increase in global demand for

goods and services
Reduced OPEC’s global power

Benefit to Western and European

economies

Decline in oil and natural-gas

undertakings

Reduction in Commodity price

The devalue of Oman

© Hassan Harraz 2016 35

5.3) So when will oil prices rise again?
It's a guessing game, and there are lots of plausible guesses.
 No one knows for sure. Or, if they do, they're laying bets in the financial markets.
 Some banks project oil prices to keep plummeting down to $20 per barrel this year.
 Others expect a rebound to around $50 or $60 per barrel-by year's end as the US shale boom tapers
off and demand recovers.
 In January, the IEA pointed out that prices could easily slide lower this year… if Iran ramps up
production faster than expected
 Ultimately, the supply and demand dynamic is the thing to keep an eye on. And expectations matter
enormously here.
 Whenever new data shows an unexpected boost in oil production or an unexpected drop in oil
demand, prices tend to go down.
 Conversely, a surprise drop in supply or a surprise surge in demand will push prices back up.
 So if, say,……. the cold war between Saudi Arabia and Iran heats up and somehow leads to conflict that
crimps production, …………prices could rise. (So far, that hasn't happened.)
 If low prices are harder for the US shale industry to handle than anyone thought, that could also
cause prices to rise higher.
 If China's economy suddenly rebounds unexpectedly, that could have a similar effect.
 Or maybe Iran will do something that causes EU and US oil sanctions to snap back into place.

 Alternatively, perhaps the supply glut — and hence low prices — will persist indefinitely.

© Hassan Harraz 2016 36

 Crux ‫صلب الموضوع‬
When Oil prices Moves UP ?
1) Inflation increases
2) Government spending on subsidy increases
3) Foreign currency reserves reduce
4) Our export becomes weaker
5) GDP is affected negatively
6) Share market crumbles
7) Investment decreases

© Hassan Harraz 2016 37

© Hassan Harraz 2016 38
© Hassan Harraz 2016 39